Printer Friendly
The Free Library
14,757,244 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

Reviewing Environmental Health Education in the United Kingdom: A Month-Long Sabbatical.


Abstract

Between May 11 and June 8,1998, the author examined seven undergraduate environmental health programs in England, Ireland, Northern Ireland, Northern, division of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland (1989 est. pop. 1,583,500), 5,462 sq mi (14,147 sq km), NE Ireland. Made up of six of the nine counties of the historic province of Ulster in NE Ireland, it is frequently called  Ireland, and Scotland. This opportunity was provided by the NEHA/Chartered Institute of Environmental Health Sabbatical Exchange Program, funded by NSF International NSF International, formerly National Sanitation Foundation, is a not-for-profit, non-governmental organization that develops standards and provides product certification and education in the field of public health and safety. . The author visited programs at both large and small universities, two health departments, and the seat of city government in Belfast. The focus was the academic programs that educate environmental health officers in the United Kingdom and the Republic of Ireland, the U.K. approach to preparing students for environmental health practice, and their general educational preparation. A philosophy and system have been developed that lead students from the classroom to the workplace. Although the programs are housed in institutions that vary from small regional universities to a world-renowned research university, all graduates of the U.K. system possess a common body of knowledge. The author's interactions with faculty a nd environmental health professionals in the United Kingdom have prompted the realization that changes in the U.S. system are imperative if we are to advance as a profession.

The Tour

My experiences as an environmental health professional and educator have spanned 21 years in the Commissioned Corps of the U.S. Public Health Service and eight years teaching in undergraduate environmental health science programs. Because of these experiences, it has long been my desire to learn about academic environmental health programs in other countries. The NEHA/Chartered Institute of Environmental Health (CIEH CIEH Chartered Institute of Environmental Health (UK) ) Sabbatical Exchange Program, funded by NSF International, Inc., gave me the opportunity to fulfill that desire by spending four weeks in the United Kingdom, visiting with and learning from environmental health faculty in England, Ireland, Northern Ireland, and Scotland.

King's College King's College, former name of Columbia Univ.  and Oxford

When my wife and I arrived at Gatwick Airport, we were greeted by one of our primary hosts and contacts, Norman Parkinson Norman Parkinson, CBE (born London April 21 1913, died 1990) was a celebrated English portrait and fashion photographer. Biography
He was schooled at Westminster School. He began his career in 1931 as an apprentice to the court photographers Speaight and Sons Ltd.
, director of the Environmental Health Program at King's College, London. We spent our first week in Blackheath, a suburban area of London, talking to Noun 1. talking to - a lengthy rebuke; "a good lecture was my father's idea of discipline"; "the teacher gave him a talking to"
lecture, speech

rebuke, reprehension, reprimand, reproof, reproval - an act or expression of criticism and censure; "he had to
 our host about the program and facilities at King's College. As Norman guided us through the main King's College campus in downtown London, I observed a marble plaque commemorating a famous former faculty member, Sir Joseph Lister. Lister was a pioneer in aseptic aseptic /asep·tic/ (-tik) free from infection or septic material.

a·sep·tic
adj.
Of, relating to, or characterized by asepsis.
 surgical technique, noted for introducing misting carbolic acid carbolic acid: see phenol.
carbolic acid
 or phenol

Organic compound, simplest member of the class of phenols. A colourless liquid with a bland, sweetish odour, it is toxic and caustic.
 into the operating theater. That innovation reduced the potential for infections and ultimately increased the probability that patients would survive surgery.

We also had the opportunity to visit with staff members of the Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea The Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea (often abbreviated to RBKC) is a London borough in the west side of central London.

It is an urban area and was named in the 2001 census as the most densely populated local authority in the United Kingdom, with a population
 Environmental Health Services health services Managed care The benefits covered under a health contract . We took a walking tour of the borough and met with Guy Dennington, special projects team manager for Kensington and Chelsea Kensington and Chelsea, inner borough (1991 pop. 127,600) of Greater London, SE England. Kensington is largely residential with fashionable shopping streets and several luxurious hotels. Portobello Road is a well-known street market. .

In London we traveled by subway, better known as "the Tube." Travel in and out of London was best accomplished with the local train service, which runs frequently to suburban areas.

From London, we headed north for Oxford, where our hosts were Mike and Ann Dooley. Ann is an environmental health officer (EHO EHO Environmental Health Officer
EHO Equal Housing Opportunity
EHO Eclectic Homeschool Online
EHO Estimated Hourly Output
EHO Engage Harpoon Order
) with the Oxford Health Authority and a previous winner of the NEHA/CIEH Sabbatical Award. Because she received her environmental health education in her homeland, the Republic of Ireland, our discussion provided me with yet another perspective on the practice of environmental health,

During a luncheon in Oxford, I learned that EHOs are responsible in many jurisdictions for investigating noise complaints with the police. The EHO is on call for this duty and may be required to confiscate To expropriate private property for public use without compensating the owner under the authority of the Police Power of the government. To seize property.

When property is confiscated it is transferred from private to public use, usually for reasons such as
 noise-making devices such as stereo equipment. That is a duty I hope does not become routine in the United States United States, officially United States of America, republic (2005 est. pop. 295,734,000), 3,539,227 sq mi (9,166,598 sq km), North America. The United States is the world's third largest country in population and the fourth largest country in area. !

Next, we traveled to Manchester, where we were met by another primary contact, Eric Foskett Eric was an excellent host and took responsibility for arranging most of our visits with the various university environmental health programs in the United Kingdom.

Northern Ireland Northern Ireland: see Ireland, Northern.
Northern Ireland

Part of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland occupying the northeastern portion of the island of Ireland. Area: 5,461 sq mi (14,144 sq km). Population (2001): 1,685,267.
 and the Republic of Ireland

Our tour of the various university environmental health programs began with a train trip to Holyhead, Wales Wales, Welsh Cymru, western peninsula and political division (principality) of Great Britain (1991 pop. 2,798,200), 8,016 sq mi (20,761 sq km), west of England; politically united with England since 1536. The capital is Cardiff. . We had Britrail passes, which allow unlimited travel over a specified number of days to anywhere in the United Kingdom. From Holyhead, we traveled to Dublin, Ireland, on a large ferry boat. While in Dublin, we met with the environmental health faculty at the Dublin Institute of Technology The institution is currently planning a single campus, the Grangegorman Campus, thus moving from its many city centre locations which has often been a source of criticism.  (DIT), and a wonderful luncheo was given in our honor by Dr. Marlene Proctor (head of school), Mr. Shamus Kiely (lecturer), and other members of the faculty. In addition we had an opportunity to meet the director of environmental health for the Republic of Ireland. After the luncheon I gave a presentation about environmental health programs, university operations, and environmental management in the United States.

The Republic of Ireland is not part of the United Kingdom, nor is the DIT program accredited accredited

recognition by an appropriate authority that the performance of a particular institution has satisfied a prestated set of criteria.


accredited herds
cattle herds which have achieved a low level of reactors to, e.g.
 by CIEH. My visit to the program arose from a desire to obtain a broader view of European environmental health programs.

The next day we took a train from Dublin to Belfast, Northern Ireland. The train was late, and there were rumors of a bomb explosion or threat to the railway ahead, but we experienced no trouble. Upon arrival, we checked into a local bed and breakfast in Whiteabbey, just outside Belfast. Mr. Harold Harvey, director of the Environmental Health Program at the University of Ulster The University of Ulster (UU; Irish: Ollscoil Uladh[2] [3]) is a multi-centre university located in Northern Ireland and is the largest single university on the island of Ireland, discounting the federal , was our host.

A very scenic spot, Whiteabbey is on the bay, or lough Lough (lŏkh, lŏk). For names of Irish lakes and inlets beginning with "Lough," see second part of element; e.g., for Lough Corrib, see Corrib, Lough. See lake. , where the Titanic was constructed. My review of the environmental health program with Harold and Oliver Hetherington, another faculty member, coincided with final exams. From my visits to this and two other universities (Oxford and King's College), I concluded that U.K. universities focus more on academics than do American universities. The paraphernalia of school pride, athletic events and other extracurricular activities are not nearly as apparent as in the United States.

The next day, we met with City of Belfast officials, including Brian Hanna, a former EHO and chief executive of the City of Belfast. We also met with William Francy, director of health and environmental services The various combinations of scientific, technical, and advisory activities (including modification processes, i.e., the influence of manmade and natural factors) required to acquire, produce, and supply information on the past, present, and future states of space, atmospheric, , and Damien Martin Damien Martin (born 1947) is a former Irish sportsperson. He played hurling with his local club St. Rynagh's and with the Offaly senior inter-county team from the 1960s until the 1980s.

Damien Martin was born in Banagher, County Offaly in 1947.
, environmental strategy manager. In Belfast, program planning based upon risk assessment is on the forefront of the agenda, and it was apparent that these efforts are based on solid strategic planning Strategic planning is an organization's process of defining its strategy, or direction, and making decisions on allocating its resources to pursue this strategy, including its capital and people. .

By coincidence, we were in Belfast when the referendum concerning Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland was voted on. There was much activity in the city, with loudspeakers on cars advocating various stances on the issue.

The next day we took a sea ferry to Strenraer, Scotland, where we began the long, scenic train trip back to Manchester.

Manchester

I visited Manchester Metropolitan University History
During the last third of the 20th century MMU grew through the combination of several colleges, some of which were founded in the 19th century. The mergers began on 1st January 1970, when Manchester Polytechnic was formed from Manchester College of Art and Design, the
 (MMU (Memory Management Unit) The part of the computer that governs memory access. Either part of the CPU chip or housed on separate chips, the MMU controls memory partitions and virtual memory. See memory and virtual memory.

MMU - Memory Management Unit
) with Ann Clayton, program director of MMU's environmental health program. It was becoming evident that entry into U.K. programs is much more competitive than entry into U.S. programs. Students initiate the effort while in high school: They take tests to earn their "marks," and they score points in the proper subject matter (math, sciences, etc.) so that they can compete for slots in accredited programs. The scores required for entry vary by program, but my impression was that students enter these programs with the goal of working as EHOs. They do not seem to wander into the programs, or, even worse, drift into the profession--as seems so prevalent in the United States.

Scotland

Our next trip was to Glasgow Scotland, and the University of Strathclyde The University of Strathclyde (Scottish Gaelic: Oilthigh Srath Chluaidh) is a university in Glasgow, Scotland. History
The university originated as Anderson's Institution in 1796.
. The Strathclyde program is not CIEH accredited, but it is accredited by the Royal Environmental Health Institute of Scotland. According to according to
prep.
1. As stated or indicated by; on the authority of: according to historians.

2. In keeping with: according to instructions.

3.
 Dr. Michael Jackson Noun 1. Michael Jackson - United States singer who began singing with his four brothers and later became a highly successful star during the 1980s (born in 1958)
Michael Joe Jackson, Jackson
, program director, the Strathclyde program is going to attempt dual accreditation Dual accreditation is the practice in diplomacy of a country granting two separate responsibilities to a single diplomat. One prominent form of dual accreditation is for a diplomat to serve as the ambassador to two countries concurrently. . The program offers a B.Sc. degree in environmental health, and its structure resembles that of programs in U.S. universities. Dr. Jackson's program is located in the Department of Civil Engineering; as in the United States, environmental health programs in U.K. universities are housed within different departments or schools.

While in Glasgow I met with David Spires, from the local health authority Because Glasgow has a small inland port The term inland port is used in two different but related ways to mean either a port on an inland waterway or an inland site carrying out some functions of a seaport. As a port on an inland waterway
An inland port
, EHOs must do port environmental health work, which mainly consists of deratting and galley inspections.

Leeds and Salford

At Leeds Metropolitan University Coordinates:

Leeds Metropolitan University is a university with campuses in Leeds and Harrogate, Yorkshire, England.
 about an hour by train from Manchester, I met with Dr. Jeff Cram, senior lecturer senior lecturer
n. Chiefly British
A university teacher, especially one ranking next below a reader.
 in environmental health, and Terry Moran Terry Moran (born December 9, 1960 in Chicago, Illinois) is the co-anchor of Nightline. He had been ABC News' chief White House correspondent from September 1999 to November 2005. He often anchors World News, Nightline, and other ABC News broadcasts. , lecturer, and received a copy of a student's research paper. Students in U.K. environmental health programs are required to write "honors papers" that involve considerable research. The quality of these efforts is at least equal to that of graduate-level thesis work in the United States.

After my return from Leeds, Eric Foskett and I traveled by car to the University of Salford The University of Salford is a university situated in the city of Salford in Greater Manchester, England, United Kingdom. It was founded in 1896 as the Royal Salford Technical Institute, and gained its Royal Charter and full university status in 1967. , which is very close to Manchester. Dr. Denise Rennie, head of department, and Norma Ford, lecturer, were our hosts. Like many other environmental health programs, Salford has students who do not pursue the EHO-accredited track, but who follow programs in areas such as occupational health. Some of these graduates work in the private sector, where the accredited curriculum is not required. Graduates who do not receive EHO accreditation also may work for the health authority in a technician-level position. This arrangement restricts them to working in a particular area, such as air pollution or occupational health. They cannot serve the health authority in multiple areas of environmental health, even if they have advanced degrees in their fields. Thus, the track to working for the local borough as an EHO involves training in a broad range of subjects, but can take only one path: an honors degree in environmental health from a CIEH-accredited curriculum.

Back to London

Later, when we returned to London, we visited the John Snow Pub on Broadwick Street Broadwick Street (formerly Broad Street) is a street in Soho, City of Westminster London. It runs for 0.18 mile (0.3km) approximately west-east between Marshall Street and Wardour Street, crossing Berwick Street. . As you probably know, Snow is considered the "father of modern epidemiology" and is credited with explaining the transmission of cholera long before the germ theory germ theory

Theory that certain diseases are caused by invasion of the body by microorganisms. Louis Pasteur, Joseph Lister, and Robert Koch are given much of the credit for its acceptance in the later 19th century.
 was developed. The Broadstreet Pump no longer exists, and the street has been renamed, but the pub does bear Snow's name and holds some interesting memorabilia.

A Comparison of Curricula and Professional Practices

The Schools and Curricula

According to CIEH, 12 universities in the United Kingdom “British Universities” redirects here. For the cricket team of this name, see British Universities cricket team.
Most United Kingdom universities can be classified into 5 main categories,
  • Ancient universities
 offer a four-year, accredited bachelor of science Noun 1. Bachelor of Science - a bachelor's degree in science
BS, SB

bachelor's degree, baccalaureate - an academic degree conferred on someone who has successfully completed undergraduate studies
 (B.Sc.) degree in environmental health/science [1]. Two universities offer an accredited postgraduate qualification in environmental health, consisting of a two-year master of science (M.Sc.) degree. As in the United States, each university has its own admission requirements, which are based on final grades attained by students in the U.K. equivalent of high school. The student must obtain "A" levels in a certain number of courses, most of which are in the sciences. Accommodations may be made for "mature" students and others holding certain national diplomas or certificates. The national application process works somewhat like a clearinghouse. Students apply to various environmental health programs using the national application. Since they must compete for slots in the program, they have an investment in the process. They are focusing on and committing to careers as EHOs from the time they enter the university.

Our own recruitment of environmental health students contrasts sadly with this system. We harvest our students from among the "undeclared" or from other majors. Rarely does a freshman or transfer student start out declaring an environmental health science major. Also, entering an environmental health program requires minimal investment on the part of students since enrollment is little more than an exercise in paperwork. The propensity of U.S. academia to focus on the number of students enrolled does not allow the luxury of requiring students to compete for openings in most programs.

We need to begin educating students in the early grades about environmental health science and steering them into accredited programs. Maybe we will eventually reach the point of competition for what should be highly coveted cov·et  
v. cov·et·ed, cov·et·ing, cov·ets

v.tr.
1. To feel blameworthy desire for (that which is another's). See Synonyms at envy.

2. To wish for longingly. See Synonyms at desire.
 openings.

General Education and Supporting Work

The U.K. student entering a program jumps directly into the environmental health curriculum. The U.K. programs essentially do not require general-education courses, unlike accredited universities in the United States, which require students to take 50 to 60 semester hours of general education. This requirement includes courses in English, history psychology, basic sciences, and other subjects. The U.K. programs consider this work to have been adequately covered by the U.K. National Curriculum students follow in junior high and high school. The U.K. faculty I visited considered the last year of "high schoo1" in the United Kingdom as roughly equivalent to the first year of college in the Unite States. This arrangement entails perhaps one shortcoming short·com·ing  
n.
A deficiency; a flaw.


shortcoming
Noun

a fault or weakness

Noun 1.
 of the U.K. system: Most U.S. students appear, at least on paper, to be more broadly educated than their U.K. counterparts. The U.S. accreditation body, the National Environmental Health Science and Protection Accreditation Council Accreditation Council may refer to:
  • Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education, the body responsible for the accreditation of medical doctors in the United States
 (NEHSPAC), requires that students complete courses in basic biology microbiology, chemistry and organic chemistry, physics, communications, and mathematics to the precalculus pre·cal·cu·lus  
n.
A course of study taken as a prerequisite for the study of calculus.



pre·calcu·lus adj.
 level [2]. The U.K. system assumes that ente4ng students have adequate "underpinning" knowledge in Level 1 subjects such as biology, physical science, basic ecology and algebra/trigonometry. This assumption allows the program to spend much-needed time in the technical areas of environmental health. Level 2 subjects such as advanced biology and ecology microbiology calculus, math modeling, wave mathematics, and computing are addressed within the curriculum.

In he United States, the general-education curriculum is an important and necessary component of higher education higher education

Study beyond the level of secondary education. Institutions of higher education include not only colleges and universities but also professional schools in such fields as law, theology, medicine, business, music, and art.
. It may be time, however, to examine why universities require e students to revisit so many courses they have taken year after year in junior high and high school. I find that many seniors cannot remember who was President after FDR, let alone any issues related to the Louisiana Purchase Louisiana Purchase, 1803, American acquisition from France of the formerly Spanish region of Louisiana. Reasons for the Purchase


The revelation in 1801 of the secret agreement of 1800, whereby Spain retroceded Louisiana to France, aroused
. Yet, much valuable college time has been spent revisiting these subjects Perhaps, instead of encountering another "resurfacing" during higher education, students should be made more accountable for bringing "liberal arts liberal arts, term originally used to designate the arts or studies suited to freemen. It was applied in the Middle Ages to seven branches of learning, the trivium of grammar, logic, and rhetoric, and the quadrivium of arithmetic, geometry, astronomy, and music. " knowledge with them.

Environmental Health Curricula

The U.K Curriculum

In the United Kingdom, the core curriculum, as required by CIEH, is arranged into three knowledge groups. Group 1, Holistic Areas, addresses strategic planning and policy development in environmental health. The courses also provide a holistic framework for understanding concepts and recent developments in public health and sustainability and for applying priorities.

Group 2 covers knowledge and skills applicable to all environmental health specialties Health specialties include topics such as mental health, public health, and sexual health. . These courses consider legal issues, administration, inspection techniques, investigative techniques, compliance strategies, interpersonal skills "Interpersonal skills" refers to mental and communicative algorithms applied during social communications and interactions in order to reach certain effects or results. The term "interpersonal skills" is used often in business contexts to refer to the measure of a person's ability , professional conduct, organizational management, pest and vector control Vector control is any method to limit or eradicate the vectors of vector born diseases, for which the pathogen (e.g. virusor parasite) is transmitted by a vector which can be mammals, birds or arthropods, especially insects, and more specifically mosquitoes. , human health impacts, epidemiology the built environment (housing and institutions), risk assessment and risk management, problem solving problem solving

Process involved in finding a solution to a problem. Many animals routinely solve problems of locomotion, food finding, and shelter through trial and error.
 and decision making, health promotion, and business and commercial awareness.

Group 3 supplies technical knowledge applicable in specialist areas. These areas include environmental protection, food safety and standards, port health, housing, occupational health and safety and public health.

A detailed knowledge of the three curriculum groups enables EHOs to undertake their duties competently within individual specialties. In addition, each student must complete a 240-day professional placement (internship), either between the second and fourth year of school or after completion of the degree requirements. During this internship the student must work toward a series of specified professional competencies and must complete a detailed 300-page Professional Training Logbook with a supporting portfolio of evidence. This material is assessed by CIEH at a charge to the student of approximately $100.

The U.S. Curriculum

Like the U.K. system, NEHSPAC divides its requirements into three groups. Group 1 comprises separate courses in epidemiology, statistical methods, and toxicology Group 2 provides a basic understanding of environmental economics, environmental health management, law and public policy development, and risk assessment and risk communication. Group 3 involves an in-depth study of four technical areas with exposure to a majority of the others. These course areas are given in the sidebar above.

NEHSPAC requires the student to complete an internship that lasts a minimum of 180 clock hours (22.5 days). This requirement normally is fulfilled in the summer, between semesters, but internships can be completed during any semester.

Entry into the Profession

The United Kingdom

A U.K. student who aspires to become an EHO first must be accepted into a CIEH-accredited course of study at a university or college. Upon completion of this curriculum, the student receives a B.Sc. in environmental health/science. To qualify as an EHO, the student, must complete the degree with honors (Hons.), which indicates a certain ranking within the class. In addition, a structured practical training experience of at least 48 weeks is required. The graduate then must acquire a Certificate of Registration by the Environmental Health Officers Registration Board (EHORB) by completing the training logbook, which CIEH reviews. A formal assessment with a written examination, a risk audit paper, and a formal interview follow. The process costs about $200.

After two years in a first job, the EHO is qualified to undergo an "assessment of professional competence" (APC (1) (American Power Conversion Corporation, West Kingston, RI, www.apcc.com) The leading manufacturer of UPS systems and surge suppressors, founded in 1981 by Rodger Dowdell, Neil Rasmussen and Emanual Landsman, three electronic power engineers who had worked at MIT. ). This assessment follows the typical model for a United Kingdom chartered profession. Professional competence is defined by CIEH as "the completion of tasks to the satisfaction of the employer, client and/or professional peers, within the recognized field of expertise of the profession, using all due care and without serious fault or error."

The purpose of the assessment is to evaluate the EHO's ability to apply professionally the knowledge and skills developed during qualification. Investigative, analytical, interpretive, communicative, educative ed·u·ca·tive  
adj.
Educational.

Adj. 1. educative - resulting in education; "an educative experience"
instructive, informative - serving to instruct or enlighten or inform
, organizational, and attitudinal abilities are assessed in three ways:

1. a case study,

2. a log of professional practice, and

3. a professional interview.

Once EHOs have passed the APC, they are entitled to "corporate membership" in CIEH. This credential is critical; job advertisements often specify "Corporate Membership of CIEH" or "passing of the APC."

After being entered on the Environmental Health Officers Registration Board ("the Register"), EHOs have an ongoing responsibility to continue professional development throughout their careers. CIEH members must complete 20 hours of suitable continuing-professional-development (CPD CPD citrate phosphate dextrose; see anticoagulant citrate phosphate dextrose solution, under solution.
Cephalopelvic disproportion (CPD) 
) activity each year, with 10 hours occurring in the "core activities." Core activities relate directly to professional environmental health functions. "Supplementary activities" are organized endeavors linked to personal development with indirect relevance to professional functions. Examples include computer courses, management courses, language skills, and social sciences. Each year, a random sample of 10 percent of the CIEH membership is checked for compliance with the CPD requirement. Failure to comply can result in removal from membership.

Thus, corporate membership denotes that an individual has both achieved and maintained professional competence in the field. There is a common body of knowledge that each individual must possess before being employed and "registered." This requirement is important to employers, the courts, the public, and other government departments.

The United States

The complexity of the U.S. system amounts to a nonsystem in which local, state, and federal agencies have differing employment and registration requirements. The following overview is representative of the profession in the United States. Enormous variations make it impossible, however, to cover requirements for every state and situation.

Graduates of NEHSPAC-accredited programs compete with all other graduates, regardless of their academic majors, for government positions in environmental health. The 50 states and the federal government take different approaches to filling these positions. There are basically five approaches to filling entry level positions:

1. Selection is based solely on academic qualification--a degree in environmental health/science from a NEHSPAC-accredited school. The Commissioned Corps of the U.S. Public Health Service takes this approach, requiring that any applicant who holds only a B.S. degree must have majored in environmental health/science at a NEHSPAC-accredited school. No professional test or merit exam is required.

2. The minimum requirement is a B.S. degree with an applicable science major such as chemistry biology geology or environmental health science. This system is used by the state of Florida.

3. A B.S. degree in any field is accepted, but a minimum number of science hours are required. The state of Kentucky takes this approach.

4. Applicants may be required to have the qualifications listed under approaches 2 and 3, but they also must take a "merit" exam that helps rank them. The merit exam may or may not be relevant to the field of environmental health.

5. Some college hours in science are required, but no minimum academic degree is required.

Registration as a sanitarian sanitarian /san·i·tar·i·an/ (san?i-tar´e-an) one skilled in sanitation and public health science.

san·i·tar·i·an
n.
A public health or sanitation expert.
 or environmental specialist also differs from state to state. A few states have no registration requirement. Others require sanitarians to take and pass a registration test within a year or two. The focus varies from testing knowledge of a wide range of environmental health subjects to testing knowledge of state regulations. Some states also accept the national registration examination associated with NEHA NEHA National Environmental Health Association
NEHA National Executive Housekeepers Association
NEHA Northern Estates Homeowners Association (Indianapolis, Indiana) 
.

Similarly, states that require registration may or may not mandate "continuing professional development CPD is the means by which members of professional associations maintain, improve and broaden their knowledge and skills and develop the personal qualities required in their professional lives. " or "continuing education continuing education: see adult education.
continuing education
 or adult education

Any form of learning provided for adults. In the U.S. the University of Wisconsin was the first academic institution to offer such programs (1904).
," and in those that do, the number of course hours varies, as does acceptable content.

Discussion and Conclusions

My sabbatical experience in the United Kingdom, while enjoyable and informative, also caused me shock--and often embarrassment--when I compared the typical education and qualifications of U.S. practitioners with those of our U.K. counterparts. We lag sadly and our system needs some major overhauling. We cannot be a photocopy of the U.K. system, nor should we be. We should, however, emulate those aspects of the system that will improve environmental health in this country.

I do not mean to reflect negatively on any member of our profession. The future is before us, and the changes I suggest below are meant only to strengthen and advance the profession. I will start with some shortcomings A shortcoming is a character flaw.

Shortcomings may also be:
  • Shortcomings (SATC episode), an episode of the television series Sex and the City
 in my own segment of the profession--education--but many of the important issues are interconnected.

Issue 1: Student Recruitment

We must begin to recruit students well before they enter college--and we must inform them that the profession exists. Many students are unaware of what we are about, even after they graduate from college. The ranks of our accredited schools are filled with individuals who have drifted in from other majors. Sometimes they come out of real interest, but all too often they are just looking for Looking for

In the context of general equities, this describing a buy interest in which a dealer is asked to offer stock, often involving a capital commitment. Antithesis of in touch with.
 a major that will accept the hours they have already completed for some other major with which they are dissatisfied or, sadly some preprofessional pre·pro·fes·sion·al  
adj.
Preparatory to the practice of a profession or to its specialized field of study.
 program in which they have failed to make the cut.

Entry into the curriculum should be an honor, not an escape hatch Noun 1. escape hatch - hatchway that provides a means of escape in an emergency
aeroplane, airplane, plane - an aircraft that has a fixed wing and is powered by propellers or jets; "the flight was delayed due to trouble with the airplane"
. It is a well-known principle that human nature treasures a goal achieved through hard work far more than one reached easily. Most university administrators, however, are so saturated with the idea of maintaining class numbers, that it will be a difficult transition to focusing on student quality. To our credit, once students enter the curriculum, most become committed to the profession and wish they had been in the program from the beginning.

A recent initiative to develop environmental education in school-aged children should help. Such projects must, however, emphasize our role in protecting public health, not focus on the fashionable birds-and-whales efforts with which we are often confused. To educate the next generation about what we do, we must define ourselves. Also, we must work toward a system in which students compete for slots in our programs.

Issue 2: NEHSPAC Improvements

Our counterparts in CIEH, while not perfect, have clearly defined the generic knowledge and skills needed by an EHO. They have also established the technical knowledge required and then used a holistic approach holistic approach A term used in alternative health for a philosophical approach to health care, in which the entire Pt is evaluated and treated. See Alternative medicine, Holistic medicine.  to putting it all together. Unlike the NEHSPAC system, theirs is not a "buffet" approach to a curriculum. If we are ever to become a profession like nursing or medicine, we must establish a common body of knowledge.

Th graduates of the U.K. programs mentioned above basically have identical training and capabilities. They share a core of knowledge. The NEHSPAC system is upside down. It requires courses in non-environmental health areas (i.e., epidemiology, statistics, toxicology) and dictates "understanding" of others (i.e., economics, management, law and policy, risk assessment and risk communication). These bodies of knowledge are important and should be addressed, but, in the words of one of my favorite My Favorite is an independent synthpop band from Long Island, New York. They released two CDs: Love at Absolute Zero and Happiest Days of Our Lives. My Favorite broke up on September 14, 2005, when singer Andrea Vaughn left the band.  Baptist preachers, we are "minoring in the majors and majoring in the minors." With respect to our core of knowledge, NEHSPAC requires only that students complete four technical areas "in depth" and be "exposed to a majority of others." This means that a curriculum could be accredited by offering specific courses in environmental chemistry, environmental epidemiology environmental microbiology Environmental microbiology is the study of the composition and physiology of microbial communities in the environment. The environment in this case means the soil, water, air and sediments covering the planet and can also include the animals and plants that inhabit these areas. , and hydrogeology hy·dro·ge·ol·o·gy  
n.
The branch of geology that deals with the occurrence, distribution, and effect of ground water.



hy
 and merely "exposing" students to all of the other subjects.

We need more specificity in our requirements, particularly with respect to food, air, water, wastewater, solid waste, and vector control. All of the other subjects listed are valuable and could be addressed after the environmental health core requirements have been met--not instead of them. The curriculum should not be designed around what faculty members can or want to teach, but around the core of knowledge required by the profession.

Issue 3: Who Is Hired

When I received my initial education (B.S. in Environmental Health, East Tennessee State University East Tennessee State University (ETSU) is an accredited American university, founded October 21911 and located in Johnson City, Tennessee. It is part of the Tennessee Board of Regents system of colleges and universities. , 1970), I studied with two esteemed environmental health professionals, Dr. Monroe T. Morgan and Dr. Trenton Davis. Neither had received undergraduate education undergraduate education Medtalk In the US, a 4+ yr college or university education leading to a baccalaureate degree, the minimum education level required for medical school admission; undergraduate medical education refers to the 4 yrs of medical school. Cf CME.  in the field of environmental health. They entered the field with science or health degrees. At the time there was no other alternative. Unfortunately, we have progressed little since then.

In the United Kingdom, one must graduate from an accredited program to be employed as an EHO, and our goal in this country should be to have the same requirement for government positions in environmental health. The following three hiring issues also should be pondered.

First, we often employ the individuals with minimal or lesser qualifications. The best preparation for a profession is an education tailored for that profession. Some states require only 18 hours of sciences for environmental health professionals. In addition, the quality of the academic work is questionable. Courses may be listed as sciences yet have little value in preparing one for environmental health work. Biology, chemistry, and physics courses provide valuable supporting knowledge, but do courses such as "Game Birds game birds, a term used variously for all birds of the order Galliformes (gallinaceous, or chickenlike, birds), for certain quarry species within this order, and for a variety of quarry birds of several other orders.  of the State," "Geography of Bolivia The geography of Bolivia is unique among the nations of South America. Bolivia is one of two landlocked countries on the continent, and also has the highest average altitude. ," or "Taxonomy of Flowering Plants plants which have stamens and pistils, and produce true seeds; phenogamous plants; - distinguished from flowerless plants.

See also: Flowering
" contribute to an understanding of environmental health principles? I am convinced they do not! Yet courses like these often are applied toward qualifying hours. Individuals with such credits may be employed over environmental health graduates because of local politics or because supervisors fear that the new graduates will know more than they do.

Second, even a biology or chemistry degree does not prepare the student for environmental health work. I have encountered health department employees with these degrees who, after three to five years of employment, admit that they do not fully understand what they are doing and why. In my opinion, it takes the non-environmental health graduate a minimum of five years of work experience to acquire the knowledge base of an environmental health graduate. So why are non-environmental health graduates often employed rather than the environmental health graduate? One reason is that "birds of a feather Birds Of a Feather - (BOF) (From the saying "Birds of a feather flock together") An informal discussion group, scheduled on a conference program or formed ad hoc, to consider a specific issue or subject.  flock together." Supervisors who have biology or chemistry backgrounds themselves may look for those graduates who resemble them. The thinking is that "I am doing a great job with a biology degree, so therefore this person can too."

The third issue concerns the "merit" examinations. A merit examination should address the field in which the individual is to be employed. An examination for an environmental health position should cover the common body of knowledge in environmental health. If the examination measures knowledge of chemistry, biology, and physics, then the process will favor people holding degrees in those fields although they have little knowledge of environmental health science. NEHA and the state organizations must make a unified effort to establish the environmental health science degree as the minimum requirement for entry into government environmental health positions. Initially, preferential hiring of environmental health graduates, when available, may help.

Issue 4: Continuing Education

U.K. environmental health professionals are on average better qualified than their American counterparts. CPD requirements equal and exceed our continuing-education requirements. Fortunately many American practitioners continually try to upgrade their skills in the field. Unfortunately, just as many refuse to do any more than necessary to stay abreast. Many will not attend a night professional meeting or take a local university course. These are, as one of my colleagues puts it, "minimum Johns and Janes." This attitude, if it prevails, will drag down the profession.

The quality of the continuing education also must be assessed. Continuing-education units (CEUs) should be evaluated strictly. During my tenure at Eastern Kentucky University Student Life
The Eastern Kentucky University Office of Student Life works closely with Registered Student Organizations (RSO's), Greek Life, and Thursday Alternative Getaway (TAG).
 the environmental health faculty, in an agreement with the Kentucky Sanitarian Registration Board, evaluated all continuing-education work and assigned the amount of credit. This was done gratis GRATIS. Without reward or consideration.
     2. When a bailee undertakes to perform some act or work gratis, he is answerable for his gross negligence, if any loss should be sustained in consequence of it; but a distinction exists between non-feasance and
, as a service to the profession.

Issue 5: The Reality of the Profession

In the United Kingdom, an EHO belongs to a chartered profession that requires two years of professional experience followed by an "assessment of professional competence." Statutory, minimum qualifications for "inspectors" in food safety and occupational health and safety have been set and can be obtained from CIEH or the Institute of Food Science and Technology (IFST IFST Institute of Food Science and Technology ). The Certificate of Registration of the Environmental Health Officers Registration Board also is a specified qualification.

Central to the other issues I have addressed are the following questions: What is a professional? What is a profession? According to the 1992 American Heritage American Heritage can refer to:
  • American Heritage (magazine)
  • American Heritage (band)
  • The American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language
  • American Heritage Rivers
  • American Heritage School, a small private school in Broward County, Florida
 Dictionary, the first definition for the noun "professional" is "a person following a profession, especially a learned profession." The first definition for the adjective "professional" is "of, relating to relating to relate prepconcernant

relating to relate prepbezüglich +gen, mit Bezug auf +acc 
, engaged, or suitable for a profession: a professional field such as law; professional training." It is in defining the second term, "profession," that we gain insight into what we are. The first definition for that noun is as follows: "an occupation requiring considerable training and specialized study; the professions of law medicine, and engineering." The problem is that we want to be "professionals" in the sense of these first definitions but that we are still professionals only in the sense of the second definition--that is, "engaging in a given activity as a source of livelihood or as a career."

Some readers may be insulted by the implication. It is meant to refer to the field as a whole, not personally to individuals. The reality however, is that the words we want to use to define ourselves and our work will not wash when the dictionary meaning is applied. Why? Entry into a profession requires specialized study. One cannot become a lawyer without graduating from law school, a physician without graduating from medical school, or an engineer without graduating from engineering school, where one learns a common body of knowledge. There is one common door into a profession. For us, that door would be an accredited undergraduate degree “First degree” redirects here. For the BBC television series, see First Degree.

An undergraduate degree (sometimes called a first degree or simply a degree
 in environmental health. We often boast that our profession requires abundant knowledge of science, mathematics, and environmental health. Yet many practitioners are employed with inappropriate degrees; some have completed no science courses, minimal science courses, or unrelated science courses. They learn the duties of the profession solely from on-the-job training.

Many people still argue that one can learn the field just by being employed in it. Consider an analogy Would you seek medical advice from a physician who has majored in history with a biology minor and then has worked as an apprentice in another physician's office for a certain number of years? Doubtful. Yet we assert publicly that our professional decisions affect the health of hundreds of people every day Should we be any less appropriately trained and qualified than the professions we often envy for their status?

I am not inveighing against those who currently work without degrees in environmental health/science. The point is that the environmental health profession will not be elevated, advanced, or respected outside of its membership until at least two things occur. First, everyone entering the profession must possess a common body of knowledge. This knowledge must be obtained through undergraduate or graduate training in environmental or public health. Second, the field as a whole must grasp the concept that requiring entrants to have an undergraduate degree in environmental health will strengthen the profession, thus elevating both those currently in it and those yet to enter.

Acknowledgements: Much appreciation is owed to Norman Parkinson, of King's College, University of King's College, University of: see Dalhousie Univ.  London, and Eric Foskett, vice president of the International Federation of Environmental Health, for documentation and personal guidance.

Corresponding Author: Dr. Darryl B. Barnett, R.S., D.A.A.S., Kerr Chair and Department Chair P&ES Building.

REFERENCES

(1.) "Core Curriculum for Qualifying Courses with Integrated Practical Training" (1997), London: Chartered Institute of Environmental Health Founded in 1883, the Chartered Institute of Environmental Health (CIEH) is a professional and educational body, dedicated to the promotion of environmental health and to encouraging the highest possible standards in the training and the work of environmental health professionals. .

(2.) "Guidelines for Accreditation of Environmental Health Science and Protection Baccalaureate Programs" (1992), National Environmental Health Science and Protection Accreditation Council.

U.S. Environmental Health Curriculum,

Course Group 3

Air Quality Control

Environmental Chemistry

Hydrogeology

Environmental Health Planning

Environmental Epidemiology

Housing

Hazardous Materials

Environmental Microbiology

Global Environmental Health

Food Protection

Injury Prevention

Noise

Industrial Hygiene

Institutional Health

Soils

Water Quality

Water Supply

Solid Waste

Radiation Health

Recreational Environmental Health

Wastewater

Vector Control

Occupational Health/Safety

Did you know...

"Asthma is the number one reason for school absenteeism in America. Among children, it causes 10 million missed school days and 200,000 hospitalizations each year."

Source: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), agency of the U.S. Public Health Service since 1973, with headquarters in Atlanta; it was established in 1946 as the Communicable Disease Center.  
COPYRIGHT 2000 National Environmental Health Association
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2000, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Barnett, Darryl B.
Publication:Journal of Environmental Health
Geographic Code:4EUUK
Date:Jan 1, 2000
Words:5556
Previous Article:Exploratory Analysis of Respiratory Illness Among Persons Living Near a landfill.(Statistical Data Included)
Next Article:Practical Stuff!(Brief Article)
Topics:



Related Articles
1992-93 sabbatical exchange visit to the United Kingdom. (UK's environmental health program)(part 2)
NEHA/CIEH sabbatical exchange program 1994. (part 1)(National Environmental Health Association, Chartered Institute of of Environmental Health)
Learning about local environmental health authorities in the United Kingdom: a month-long sabbatical experience.(International Perspectives)
NEHA deals a winning hand: 1998 AEC and Exhibition, Las, Vegas, Nevada. (National Environmental Health Association; annual educational...
The cutting edge.(President's Message)(National Environmental Health Association)(Column)
Important Dates for Opportunity.
Primary-and Secondary-School Environmental Health Science Education and the Education Crisis: A Survey of Science Teachers in Ohio.
NEHA News.(National Environmental Health Association)(Brief Article)
NEHA's 2001 Annual Educational Conference and Exhibition Atlanta Georgia.
Apply for learning opportunities on the international level--deadline March 3. (NEHA News).(Brief Article)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles