Printer Friendly
The Free Library
14,503,364 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

Reporters follow the Enron money in high-stakes whodunit.


THE following is an excerpt ex·cerpt  
n.
A passage or segment taken from a longer work, such as a literary or musical composition, a document, or a film.

tr.v. ex·cerpt·ed, ex·cerpt·ing, ex·cerpts
1.
 from the book "24 Days: How Two Wall Street Journal Reporters Uncovered the Lies that Destroyed Faith in Corporate America," by Rebecca Smith Rebecca Smith is a reporter in the Los Angeles, California, bureau of the Wall Street Journal. In 1996 she shared a Gerald Loeb Award for distinguished financial and economics reporting.  and John R. Emshwiller John R. Emshwiller is a senior national correspondent for the Wall Street Journal, the pre-eminent newspaper of the financial community in the United States.

In 2002, he shared the Gerald Loeb Award for his coverage of the unfolding Enron scandal with Rebecca Smith.
 (HarperBusiness, $25.95).

The reporters, after coming across vague references to off-the-balance-sheet partnerships at Enron being run by the company's chief financial officer, mentioned those partnerships in a "Heard on the Street" piece that ran in the Journal in late August 2001. That mention resulted in a phone call from an inside source who provided critical information and documents concerning those partnerships. In this passage, the first contacts are made with the key source.

The person who phoned Smith sounded eager to talk, if somewhat nervous. It was one thing for someone to read a story and, over a morning cup of coffee, grouse grouse, common name for a game bird of the colder parts of the Northern Hemisphere. There are about 18 species. Grouse are henlike terrestrial birds, protectively plumaged in shades of red, brown, and gray.  about its incompleteness. It was something else for a reader to pick up the phone and actually offer to fill in the holes for the reporter.

The message left on Smith's office voice mail was vague and intriguing: "Hello, this is -- in --. You had a good story about Enron. I've got some additional information that might interest you. You're just scratching the surface. If you'd like to chat, give me a call at --."

Smith called back immediately. The voice that answered was friendly but also a trifle tri·fle  
n.
1. Something of little importance or value.

2. A small amount; a jot.

3. A dessert typically consisting of plain or sponge cake soaked in sherry, rum, or brandy and topped with layers of jam or jelly,
 wary. The person worried that top Enron executives, especially (CFO See Chief Financial Officer.  Andrew) Fastow, might find and punish anyone who criticized them. Smith gave the reassurance that reporters usually give in such circumstances. She'd protect the caller's identity except insofar in·so·far  
adv.
To such an extent.

Adv. 1. insofar - to the degree or extent that; "insofar as it can be ascertained, the horse lung is comparable to that of man"; "so far as it is reasonably practical he should practice
 as it had to be known to others at the newspaper. She said she understood how hard it was to step forward and told the caller not to worry.

Smith wanted to hear the full story, but she feared that if she pushed for too much information too soon, the person would bolt. So she let the conversation flow, interrupting only to get a few details in key places. Mostly she wanted to start establishing trust. On both sides.

Many people believe newspapers are so all-powerful that they can "make things happen." The caller seemed to share this view. But Smith had long ago learned that the truth was something less cataclysmic cat·a·clysm  
n.
1. A violent upheaval that causes great destruction or brings about a fundamental change.

2. A violent and sudden change in the earth's crust.

3. A devastating flood.
. Newspapers could instigate To incite, stimulate, or induce into action; goad into an unlawful or bad action, such as a crime.

The term instigate is used synonymously with abet, which is the intentional encouragement or aid of another individual in committing a crime.
 change not by being agents of change, but by supporting agents of change. It was an important distinction, and it made a reporter focus on working with sources that were in possession of better information than any outsider, including a reporter, could acquire.

As the source talked, Smith felt as if she'd found someone with a long-range scope. The caller knew a lot about Enron and came across as balanced, intelligent and genuinely offended by Fastow's conduct. The person mentioned "internal documents," the most beautiful phrase in a reporter's lexicon.

According to according to
prep.
1. As stated or indicated by; on the authority of: according to historians.

2. In keeping with: according to instructions.

3.
 this person, Fastow had been running what amounted to an internal investment fund at Enron that probably earned him more money than his paycheck as chief financial officer. Lots of people knew about the setup and hated it--some simply because they were jealous, others because they thought it was outrageous and unethical for Fastow to have such a glaring conflict of interest.

Enron was awash in poorly performing assets for which it often had overpaid o·ver·pay  
v. o·ver·paid , o·ver·pay·ing, o·ver·pays

v.tr.
1. To pay (a party) too much.

2. To pay an amount in excess of (a sum due).

v.intr.
To pay too much.
. Fastow's entities enabled Enron to sell off some of the assets for cash for the partnerships while also removing from its balance sheet large amounts of debt originally used to buy those assets. This process of raising cash and reducing debt allowed Euron to create the appearance of growth that Wall Street wanted to see. But, given Fastow's hugely conflicted role, were these real transactions or just shams to buff up Enron's financial face?

As a reporter, Smith had learned the value of staying cool, ever skeptical. It was a guard against "needling a story," as journalists call reporting that hypes an angle, distorting reality. But there was no denying that the source had rekindled her desire to dig down to undermine and cause to fall by digging; as, to dig down a wall.

See also: Dig
 to bedrock.

It was thrilling when the pieces began to come together and when sources came forward expecting no more reward than the satisfaction of seeing that, as Chaucer wrote in a favorite phrase of hers, "murder will out," or the truth be told. After a second conversation with Smith a day or so later, the source--whom Smith dubbed "Our Mutual Friend"--sent the first set of documents related to one of the Fastow partnerships.

The story had an unmistakable whiff of a scandal. Yet there were many questions that needed to be answered, among them why (Jeff) Skilling, (Kenneth) Lay and the board had cooperated in an arrangement that appeared to amount to featherbedding featherbedding

Labour union practices that require the employer to pay for the performance of unnecessary work or to employ workers who are not needed. Featherbedding provisions in labour contracts may result from the continuation of work rules that were once efficient but
 for Fastow. It looked as though Enron was saying one thing in public about its earnings prospects and then taking steps, privately, to shore up a weak structure that was little understood by investors.

The document from the source indicated that the partnership looked to raise at least $200 million from outside investors. While it was often written in short, incomplete sentences, the messages it contained were clear enough. These guys are working both sides of the street, Smith thought with rising indignation. Fastow was bragging about how he had access to special inside information that could be used to make money for partnership investors--not Enron shareholders.

Emshwiller thought he'd gotten pretty cynical covering stock swindlers. But in some ways, Fastow's partnerships were starting to look every bit as sleazy slea·zy  
adj. slea·zi·er, slea·zi·est
1.
a. Shabby, dirty, and vulgar; tawdry: "sleazy storefronts with torn industrial carpeting and dirt on the walls" 
 as the average stock scam.

Smith arranged for a three-way phone conversation that included Emshwiller, who was eager to hear what the person had to say. The three ended up talking for than an hour. While clearly not privy to everything, this person knew enough to convince the reporters that they had barely scratched the surface.
COPYRIGHT 2003 CBJ, L.P.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2003, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:"24 Days: How Two Wall Street Journal Reporters Uncovered the Lies that Destroyed Faith in Corporate America"; Will Justice Be Served?--Banking & Finance Special Report
Comment:Reporters follow the Enron money in high-stakes whodunit.(Will Justice Be Served?--Banking & Finance Special Report)("24 Days: How Two Wall Street Journal Reporters Uncovered the Lies that Destroyed Faith in Corporate America")
Author:Emshwiller, John R.
Publication:Los Angeles Business Journal
Geographic Code:1USA
Date:Aug 25, 2003
Words:964
Previous Article:Duped once, media resolves to increase scrutiny of companies.(Will Justice Be Served?--Banking & Finance Special Report)(financial scandals surprise...
Next Article:Comment: mixed signals a year after Sarbanes-Oxley.(Will Justice Be Served?--Banking & Finance Special Report)(Sarbanes-Oxley was a solution for...
Topics:



Related Articles
History in a Hurry. (Comment).(Enron Corp. case history)(Brief Article)(Column)
Differing failures. (Comment).(Global Crossing, Enron)(Brief Article)
Tilting at windmills: outed farmers * plane too far * careless cooks Philby of the FBI * NBC's shame * bribes for admission.(brief notes)
New scandals, old lessons financial ethics after Enron. (Ethics).
BRIEFCASE ONSTAFF LINKS DEAL WITH AUTOMAKER.(Business)
Lies, corruption, and document destruction: never before in the history of American business has a global corporation been destroyed by acts directly...
If you can make it there.(Tearing Down the Walls by Monica Langley )(Book Review)
Duped once, media resolves to increase scrutiny of companies.(Will Justice Be Served?--Banking & Finance Special Report)(financial scandals surprise...
Sarbanes-Oxley compliance subject of NY discussion.(domestic News)(Panel Discussion)
Embed cred: how close is too close for embedded reporters?(On Political Books)(Book Review)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles