Printer Friendly
The Free Library
14,380,430 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

Prince Caspian and Child Christopher and Goldilind the Fair.


EVEN a casual glance at C. S. Lewis's personal writings--his diaries, his autobiography, and his private correspondence, particularly that to his lifelong friend Arthur Greeves (1)--reveals Lewis's deep love for the writings of William Morris Noun 1. William Morris - English poet and craftsman (1834-1896)
Morris
, the late Victorian poet, co-inventor of the genre of fantasy, artist, designer, and political activist. Lewis was especially attracted to the eight prose romances (or proto-fantasy novels) Morris wrote from the late 1880s through the mid 1890s. Their lives, however, were in some ways reverse images of each other's. As an undergraduate at Exeter College Exeter College may refer to:
  • Exeter College, Oxford a college of Oxford University
  • Exeter College, Exeter a college in Exeter, Devon
, Oxford in the 1850s, Morris had intended a career as an Anglican priest, yet he abandoned his faith, avoiding organized religion for the rest of his life. (2) On the other hand, Lewis went through his studies at University College, Oxford more interested in philosophy than religion, converting to Christianity only in his early thirties. How such a writer with a growing Christian faith reacted to one whose faith had been a diminishing one is a topic of great interest. After his conversion Lewis could have reacted to Morris differently than he did--denying Morris's influence, say, or criticizing his apostasy apostasy, in religion: see heresy.
Apostasy
See also Sacrilege.

Aholah and Aholibah

symbolize Samaria’s and Jerusalem’s abandonment to idols. [O.T.
. Instead Lewis finds ways to graft aspects of his own spirituality of longing onto Morris, thus imaginatively redeeming Morris, if only partially. This complex process is best seen in Lewis's appropriation of Morris's late work, Child Christopher and Goldilind the Fair Child Christopher and Goldilind the Fair is a fantasy novel by William Morris, perhaps the first modern fantasy writer to unite an imaginary world with the element of the supernatural, and thus the precursor of much of present-day fantasy literature. .

Lewis often patterned his own imaginative fiction after the work of others--Milton's Paradise Lost Paradise Lost

Milton’s epic poem of man’s first disobedience. [Br. Lit.: Paradise Lost]

See : Epic
 for his Perelandra, Bunyan's Pilgrim's Progress Pilgrim’s Progress

Bunyan’s allegory of life. [Br. Lit.: Eagle, 458]

See : Journey
 for Pilgrim's Regress REGRESS. Returning; going back opposed to ingress. (q.v.) , H. G. Wells's First Men in the Moon for Out of the Silent Planet, George MacDonald's The Princess and the Goblin goblin or hobgoblin, in French folklore, small household spirit, similar to the Celtic brownie. Goblins perform household tasks but also can make mischief, such as pulling the covers off sleepers. They like wine and pretty children.  for The Silver Chair, and Charles Williams's novels for That Hideous Strength (Boenig). (3) William Morris should be added to that list, (4) for Child Christopher, the least well-known of Morris's prose romances, is a major source for Prince Caspian, the second of Lewis's Chronicles of Narnia. What Lewis really did with it reveals not only how Lewis treated source material, but also indicates something of Lewis's tolerance towards an author he termed "pagan" yet to whom he owed a significant spiritual debt.

Lewis bought May Morris's Collected Works Collected Works is a Big Finish original anthology edited by Nick Wallace, featuring Bernice Summerfield, a character from the spin-off media based on the long-running British science fiction television series Doctor Who.  of William Morris in 1930 (Stand 365); Child Christopher and Goldilind the Fair is included in its seventeenth volume. It is a loose adaptation of the late-thirteenth-century English poetical po·et·i·cal  
adj.
1. Poetic.

2. Fancifully depicted or embellished; idealized.



po·eti·cal·ly adv.
 romance, Havelok the Dane Havelok the Dane, English 13th-century metrical romance. It concerns a prince brought up as a scullion, who, after discovering his true identity, wins the kingdoms of Denmark and England. . All three works in this concatenation of influence deal with young orphaned princes who are silently and gradually deposed by regents. The rightful heirs "Rightful Heir" is the 149th episode of the science fiction television series and the 22nd episode of the show's sixth season. It was first broadcast on May 17, 1993.  are disregarded and tacitly demoted, but they overcome obstacles until they gain the kingdom that is rightfully theirs.

As Lewis was a medievalist me·di·e·val·ist also me·di·ae·val·ist  
n.
1. A specialist in the study of the Middle Ages.

2. A connoisseur of medieval culture.


medievalist
1.
 who had read Havelok the Dane and thought it "great stuff" (Road 184), it is worthwhile to summarize it briefly before turning to Morris's Child Christopher. Available to Lewis both in the medieval manuscript, which is housed in Oxford's Bodleian Library Bodleian Library (bŏd`lēən, bŏdlē`ən), at Oxford Univ. The original library, destroyed in the reign of Edward VI, was replaced in 1602, chiefly through the efforts of Sir Thomas Bodley, who gave it valuable collections of  (MS Laud Misc. 108), and in the edition of 1868 edited by W. W. Skeat for the Early English Text Society The Early English Text Society is an organization to reprint early English texts, especially those only available in manuscript. Most of its volumes are in Middle English and Old English.  (Skeat), (5) the romance reveals little if any interest in religion. It tells the story of both Havelok, a young Danish prince, and Goldborough, an English princess whose misfortunes resemble those of Havelok. Goldborough's dying father, king of an English realm whose capital is Lincoln, chooses Earl Godrich to be regent, making him promise to marry her off some day to the best, strongest, and fairest man in the kingdom. The earl grows accustomed to the power the regency bestows on him, so he imprisons Goldborough in Dover Castle Dover Castle is situated at Dover, Kent and has been described as the "Key to England" due to its defensive significance throughout history. History
Roman
 and neglects her interests entirely. Meanwhile Havelok's dying father entrusts his young son and his two sisters to Earl Godard, who soon murders the sisters before Havelok's eyes. The evil regent gives him over to a fisherman named Grim, who promises to drown the boy at sea. But a miraculous light attends Havelok while he sleeps, convincing all in the poem who witness it that he is the rightful King of Denmark.

So Grim, converted from evil to good, escapes with his family and Havelok, emigrating to England. There they all live by fishing and manual labor. When a famine hits, the now-grown Havelok travels to Lincoln to find work. There he so impresses people by his good looks and strength that he becomes first a porter and then a kitchen scullion scul·lion  
n.
A servant employed to do menial tasks in a kitchen.



[Middle English sculyon, probably from Old French escouvillon, dishcloth, diminutive of escouve,
 at the castle. Earl Godrich perversely decides to live up to the letter if not spirit of his earlier promise and marries this handsome, good, and strong worker to Goldborough, by this demeaning de·mean 1  
tr.v. de·meaned, de·mean·ing, de·means
To conduct or behave (oneself) in a particular manner: demeaned themselves well in class.
 marriage disqualifying dis·qual·i·fy  
tr.v. dis·qual·i·fied, dis·qual·i·fy·ing, dis·qual·i·fies
1.
a. To render unqualified or unfit.

b. To declare unqualified or ineligible.

2.
 her, as he supposes, from inheriting the throne that is rightfully hers. Through the help of Grim's sons and a loyal nobleman back in Denmark, Havelok gradually gains an army and wins numerous battles, eventually winning both Denmark and England for him and Goldborough to rule in a joint kingdom. The focus of Havelok is less on the love of its hero and heroine than on battles and heroics.

Morris's story follows the same general outline, but it is much more complex in characterization than is Havelok the Dane (Talbot; Hodgson 157, 80-82). As his daughter May recalled while introducing Child Christopher and Goldilind the Fair in 1913 for his Collected Works:
  A friend was reminding me lately of what we had both heard my father
  say about the right way of retelling an old romance: "Read it
  through," he said, "then shut the book and write it out again as a new
  story for yourself." A man might take what he liked from another, he
  said, provided that he made it his own. And this he certainly did with
  Child Christopher, which is the Lay of Havelok the Dane, for the
  modern story is altogether different in sentiment and atmosphere.
  (Morris xxxix) (6)


In Morris's retelling re·tell·ing  
n.
A new account or an adaptation of a story: a retelling of a Roman myth. 
, Havelok becomes Child Christopher and Goldborough Goldilind the Fair. Like their antitypes, they are both orphaned and deposed by evil regents, marry under the same circumstances as in Havelok, and go through danger and warfare before they are happily restored to their inheritances. But the differences between the two--what May Morris means by making a story one's own--are far more notable than these similarities.

Morris pays much more attention, for instance, to Goldilind's part of the story than the anonymous poet does to Goldborough's. He carefully crafts her into an object of physical desire and emotional longing. When the medieval poet deposits her in prison in Dover Castle, the narrative drops her until her forced marriage to Havelok. But Morris follows her into her prison, allowing the reader to witness first hand her unfair treatment there. When she finally escapes, we follow her part of the story until she encounters Christopher. Then Morris, making his most important addition to the plot, shows us how they fall in love. Here is a passage excerpted from the chapter where a chance encounter brings them together, just when Goldilind is preparing to bathe in a stream:
  From time to time she looked on him, and then she dropped her eyes
  again. In those glances she saw that he was grey-eyed, and smooth-
  cheeked, and round-chinned, and his hair curly and golden; and she
  must needs think that she had never seen any face half so fair. He was
  clad but in a green coat that came not down to his knees, and brogues
  were tied to his feet, and not more raiment he had; and for a hat he
  had made him a garland of white may blossom, and well it sat there:
  and again she looked on him, and thought him no worse than the running
  angel that goes before the throne of God in the picture of the choir
  of Meadhamstead; and she looked on him and marveled. (Morris 177) (7)


For her the religious becomes the earthly. There is also an attention to the visual that the medieval romance lacks, and the reader is very much inside the heroine's thoughts. Christopher's feelings for Goldilind more than match hers for him, and he also likens her to an object of religious awe. He says to her:
  "Maiden, when I first saw thee from amidst of the bush by the river
  yonder, I deemed thou wert a wood-wight, or some one of the she-Gods
  of the Gentiles come back hither. [...] and when I saw thee, that thou
  wouldst do off thy raiment to bathe thee, though soothly I longed to
  lie hidden there, I feared thee, lest thou shouldst be angry with me
  if I were to see thee unclad; so I came away; yet I went not far, for
  I was above all things yearning to see thee; and sooth it is, that
  hadst thou not crossed the water, I should presently have crossed it
  myself to seek thee, wert thou Goddess, or wood-wife, or whatever
  might have come of it. But now thou art come to us, and [...] I see
  that thou art a woman of the kindred of Adam." (177-78)


Morris imports this type of sensuality, lacking in Havelok, into his story. The love between Christopher and Goldilind supplants Havelok's martial concerns as the romances's central interest--though these comprise an important secondary interest. So intense is the longing between Christopher and Goldilind, in fact, that it becomes a kind of surrogate religion. Christopher, after all, mistakes Goldilind for a goddess of the gentiles. The main characters, not only in the scene just analyzed but throughout the book, long for each other as a mystic longs for God. The word "yearning" bespeaks the intensity of this longing.

We can find in Child Christopher much to confirm Lewis's assessment of the persistent sensuality he found in Morris. In Surprised by Joy he writes with uneasiness about the erotic desire he experienced while reading Morris's prose romances (169-70). In his essay, "William Morris," Lewis writes:
  [I]t is no use invoking modern psychology to reveal the concealed
  eroticism in [Morris's] imagination, because the eroticism is not
  concealed: it is patent, ubiquitous, and unabashed. [...] Morris, in
  fact, describes the sort of love that is a function of health; it
  quickens a man's pace. (222)


While I agree with Lewis that modern psychology is an unnecessary hermeneutic her·me·neu·tic   also her·me·neu·ti·cal
adj.
Interpretive; explanatory.



[Greek herm
 for explicating Morris, I would still argue that the love interest Morris imparts into the story that he appropriated from Havelok the Dane has interesting psychological implications. Unlike Havelok, Christopher is unaware of his real identity, and he is thus psychologically torn between the longing he feels for Goldilind and his sense of propriety, which precludes marriage between a queen and a commoner. And Goldilind's feelings intensely mirror Christopher's, for she is angry over her forced marriage to a seeming commoner yet still deeply desires him (Talbot 35-38). They both are in what a modern psychologist would label an approach/avoidance conflict. How they resolve their conflicting feelings comprises both a good portion of the story and also a good deal of the reader's interest in it.

There are many differences in the plot that could unduly lengthen length·en  
tr. & intr.v. length·ened, length·en·ing, length·ens
To make or become longer.



lengthen·er n.
 this article. I wish to mention only one more--Morris's inclusion of a single-combat duel as a means of avoiding war and resolving the conflict over Christopher's disputed succession. After the forced marriage and some adventures, Christopher and Goldilind are helped by a character named Jack of the Tofts, Morris's version of the Havelok-poet's Grim. Jack reveals to Christopher his true identity and gathers an army to regain his throne. Earl Rolf sends an army under a character named Lord Gandolf of Brimside (8) to meet the threat to his usurped kingdom. The Lord of Brimside, a fierce warrior, challenges Jack of the Tofts, himself a formidable combatant, to single combat, but Christopher claims the battle as rightfully his own. The fight joined, Christopher defeats his opponent with relative ease:
  And therewith [Gandolf] leapt forward and swept his huge sword around;
  but Christopher swerved speedily and enough, so that the blade touched
  him not, and the huge man had over-reached himself, and ere he had his
  sword well under sway again, Christopher had smitten him so sharply on
  the shoulders that the mails were sundered & the blood ran; and withal
  the Baron staggered with the mere weight of the stroke. (Morris 237)


By this and other feats of strength Feats of Strength are acts strongmen exhibit to showcase their great strength. They often require immense hand and finger strength, as well as core musculature. Modern feats of strength are usually performed strongman competitions, fitness exhibitions, evangelical presentations, , Morris augments the figure of Havelok that he had found in the medieval poem. Morris's Christopher is an invincible champion, one, as such, worthy of Goldilind's love.

Lewis, familiar with both Havelok and Child Christopher, does precisely what May Morris described as her father doing: he closed the book and wrote a new story, making it his own. But as a professional literary critic Noun 1. literary critic - a critic of literature
critic - a person who is professionally engaged in the analysis and interpretation of works of art
, he was aware of certain theoretical implications in such an appropriation, ones that are neither stated nor implied in May Morris's anecdote anecdote (ăn`ĭkdōt'), brief narrative of a particular incident. An anecdote differs from a short story in that it is unified in time and space, is uncomplicated, and deals with a single episode. .

In 1932, Lewis published an article in the journal Essays and Studies entitled "What Chaucer Really Did to Il Filostrato Il Filostrato is a poem by the Italian writer Giovanni Boccaccio, and the inspiration for Geoffrey Chaucer's Troilus and Criseyde and, through Chaucer, the Shakespeare play Troilus and Cressida. ," an analysis of Boccaccio's work of that name as a source for Chaucer's Troilus and Criseyde For the Shakespeare play, see .
Troilus and Criseyde is Geoffrey Chaucer's poem in rhyme royal (rime royale) re-telling the tragic love story of Troilus, a Trojan prince, and Criseyde.
. It became for decades the most cited study of Chaucer's great poem, not only because of the insightful analyses of specific passages it offered but more importantly because of the powerful theory that drove it. Lewis contended that Boccaccio's version of the story was a product of the emerging Italian Renaissance, while Chaucer systematically re-medievalized it, emphasizing a medieval interest in didactic di·dac·tic
adj.
Of or relating to medical teaching by lectures or textbooks as distinguished from clinical demonstration with patients.
 rhetoric and Courtly Love courtly love, philosophy of love and code of lovemaking that flourished in France and England during the Middle Ages. Although its origins are obscure, it probably derived from the works of Ovid, various Middle Eastern ideas popular at the time, and the songs of the . The theory involves authorial intentionality In literary theory and aesthetics, authorial intentionality is a concept referring to an author's intent as it is encoded in his or her work. Literary theory
In literary studies, the question of the validity of the methods of determining authorial intent has been debated
, a topic that rose to full prominence only in the 1980s as part of the post-modern rejection of formalist for·mal·ism  
n.
1. Rigorous or excessive adherence to recognized forms, as in religion or art.

2. An instance of rigorous or excessive adherence to recognized forms.

3.
 literary analysis. (9) If it is problematic for a critic to claim knowledge of an author's intentions, knowledge of a direct source, Lewis maintains, can give some limited access to them. If we list alterations made by an author to a direct source and notice a consistent pattern among them, then we can discern to a certain extent what drove the author's intentions in making those alterations. If Lewis used Morris as the source for Prince Caspian as Morris himself had done with the anonymous medieval poem, then it is appropriate to ask what he really did to Child Christopher and Goldilind the Fair.

First, however, we must establish a close enough connection to make the many differences between the books significant. Like Christopher, Caspian is an orphaned heir to the throne which has been usurped by an evil regent, his uncle King Miraz. And, like Christopher (but unlike Havelok), he is unaware of his true identity. The usurper USURPER, government. One who assumes the right of government by force, contrary to and in violation of the constitution of the country. Toull. Dr. Civ. n. 32. Vide Tyranny,  in both stories, moreover, initially acts in accordance with his role as regent. As Morris writes about Lord Rolf:
  [T]he Marshall summoned all them that were due thereto to come and
  give homage to the new king, and even so did they, though he were but
  a babe, yea, and who had but just now been a king lying in his
  mother's womb. (Morris 134)


But gradually this loyal allegiance erodes:
  As for the King's son, to whom the folk had of late done homage as
  king, he was first seen about a corner of the High House with his
  nurses; and then in a while it was said, and the tale noted, but not
  much, that he must needs go for his health's sake [...] to some stead
  amongst the fields, and folk heard say that he was gone to the strong
  house of a knight [...] who was called Lord Richard the Lean. [...] As
  for the King's little son, if any remembered that he was in the hands
  of the said Lord Richard, none said aught about it; for if any thought
  of the little babe at all, they said to themselves, Never will he come
  to be king. (135-36)


Lewis similarly depicts a gradual dethronement de·throne  
tr.v. de·throned, de·thron·ing, de·thrones
1. To remove from the throne; depose.

2. To remove from a prominent or powerful position.
 of the rightful heir. As Caspian's teacher, Doctor Cornelius, explains to him:
  "Everyone except your Majesty knows that Miraz is a usurper. When he
  first began to rule he did not even pretend to be the King: he called
  himself Lord Protector. But then your royal mother died [...]. And
  then, one by one, all the great lords, who had known your father, died
  or disappeared. Not by accident, either. [...] And when there was no
  one left who could speak a word for you, then his flatterers (as he
  had instructed them) begged him to become King. And of course he did."
  (Prince Caspian 55-56)


Lord Rolf is less sinister, perhaps, than Miraz, but the similarity is nevertheless clear.

After their escape from the control of the evil regent, both Christopher and Caspian find refuge among those who will befriend be·friend  
tr.v. be·friend·ed, be·friend·ing, be·friends
To behave as a friend to.


befriend
Verb

to become a friend to

Verb 1.
 them and soon press for their restitution. For Christopher, this happens when he arrives at the household of Jack of the Tofts. He has just been wounded by the evil Squire Simon, whom Lord Rolf had commanded to accompany Christopher on a mysterious errand er·rand  
n.
1.
a. A short trip taken to perform a specified task, usually for another.

b. The purpose or object of such a trip: Your errand was to mail the letter.

2.
 in the woods. Jack's sons rescue him from the attempted assassination Assassination
See also Murder.

assassins

Fanatical Moslem sect that smoked hashish and murdered Crusaders (11th—12th centuries). [Islamic Hist.: Brewer Note-Book, 52]

Brutus

conspirator and assassin of Julius Caesar. [Br.
 and bring him to their homestead, the Tofts, where Christopher will be healed. For Caspian, his rescue comes after he is injured while riding in the woods through the darkness by hitting his head against a tree limb. He joins a small band of dwarfs and Talking Animals The talking animal or speaking animal term, in general, refers to any form of animal which can speak human languages. This can by itself be interpreted in several manners, as listed in the below sections. , true Narnians. Like Jack and his household, they are living in exile in the wilderness, waiting for the eventual return of rightful order. Both groups, moreover, hold folk-moots to decide the best course of action to restore the rightful heir to the throne.

These large-scale similarities are supported by some minor but specific details that Lewis appropriates from Morris's story. For instance, the squirrel squirrel, name for small or medium-sized rodents of the family Sciuridae, found throughout the world except in Australia, Madagascar, and the polar regions; it is applied especially to the tree-living species.  Pattertwig, who is about to go on a mission to summon true Narnians to the moot An issue presenting no real controversy.

Moot refers to a subject for academic argument. It is an abstract question that does not arise from existing facts or rights.
, comments on the abilities that recommend him for the errand: "I can go nearly everywhere without setting foot to ground" (Caspian 70). Here is the first sentence of Child Christopher and Goldilind the Fair:
  Of old there was a land which was so much a woodland, that a minstrel
  therof said it that a squirrel might go from end to end, and all
  about, from tree to tree, and never touch the earth: therefore was
  that land called Oakenrealm. (Morris 133)


In addition, the nurses mentioned in the passage from Morris quoted above have their analogue in Caspian's faithful nurse who delights in telling him stories of Old Narnia and then suffers for it:
  [T]he person whom Caspian loved best was his nurse, and though (being
  a prince) he had wonderful toys which would do almost anything but
  talk, he liked best the last hour of the day when the toys had all
  been put back in their cupboards and Nurse would tell him
  stories. (37)


When Caspian reveals to King Miraz that his nurse has been telling him stories of Talking Beasts and Old Narnia, she suddenly disappears (40-41), though Aslan effects a reunion between her and Caspian near the story's end (196-98). There is a strikingly similar reunion between Christopher and one of his nurses:
  [T]here came thrusting through the throng of the hall a tall woman,
  old, yet comely as for her age; she went right up on to the dais, and
  came to where sat Christopher, and without more ado cast her arms
  about him and kissed him, and then she held him by the shoulders and
  cried out: "O, have I found thee at last, my loveling, and my dear,
  and my nurse chick?" (Morris 217)


Lewis even includes this maternal embrace: "And the first thing that happened was that the old woman slipped off Aslan's back and ran across to Caspian and they embraced one another; for she was his old nurse" (198).

The most interesting of these specific connections, though, is the hand-to-hand combat
:See also Hand to hand combat.


Hand-to-Hand Combat is the twentieth episode[1] of Mobile Suit Gundam. Plot summary
Tempers flare as Ryu and Fraw stand in Amuro's cell.
 that functions as the turning point in the efforts to bring the wronged heir back to his throne. We have already noted Morris's treatment of Christopher's duel with Lord Gandolf, particularly the hero's invincible strength. There was no such duel in Havelok the Dane, where the usurper Godard is defeated in battle, bound, and led to Havelok to receive judgment (Skeat 68-69). The decisive moment in Caspian's rise to power comes when King Miraz fights a single combat not with Caspian but with Peter, one in which Peter is anything but invincible:
  But indeed there was no need to egg the usurper on. He was on top of
  Peter already. [...] It looked as if [King Miraz's sword] would slash
  off his head. (188)


The single combat is enough to establish a connection with Child Christopher, but the differences here should strike the reader as even more significant than the similarities--indication of the first major alteration Lewis makes to the story. Not only is there real doubt about who will win the fight, there is also an even more telling change: Christopher claims the right of combat from Jack of the Tofts and then fights for his own kingdom while Caspian gives way to Peter, who fights for him. The effect of this is, for lack of a better word, to de-heroicize Caspian. Central to Morris's version is the young heir who cannot be beaten, who is the strongest and best, capable of winning his own kingdom. Caspian needs help badly, necessitating the arrival of Peter, Susan, Edmund, and Lucy back into Narnia from England in the very nick of time. But even Peter is depicted as vulnerable. This underscores for the reader that the power to resolve the conflict for the good resides not in a heroic prince or king but in Aslan, Lewis's manifestation of Christ.

The second major change I wish to mention is Lewis's erasure ERASURE, contracts, evidence. The obliteration of a writing; it will render it void or not under the same circumstances as an interlineation. (q.v.) Vide 5 Pet. S. C. R. 560; 11 Co. 88; 4 Cruise, Dig. 368; 13 Vin. Ab. 41; Fitzg. 207; 5 Bing. R. 183; 3 C. & P. 65; 2 Wend. R. 555; 11 Conn.  of Goldilind. We have already noted the erotic content of Morris's story and Lewis's discomfort with Morris's sensuality. Caspian has no female equivalent with whom to fall in love and whom he must help to regain her own throne. The effect is to simplify the story, doubtless a wise decision in a book intended for children, not, as Morris's was, for adults. But even more important than this simplification, there are no long passages in which Caspian looks with longing on his beloved, as Christopher does upon Goldilind, and there is no scene, as there is in Morris's book, where the lovers consummate their marriage.

There is plenty of longing and desire in Prince Caspian, however, but it is directed towards Aslan rather than an earthly lover. The eros, in other words Adv. 1. in other words - otherwise stated; "in other words, we are broke"
put differently
, Christopher feels for Goldilind becomes the agape agape

In the New Testament, the fatherly love of God for humans and their reciprocal love for God. The term extends to the love of one's fellow humans. The Church Fathers used the Greek term to designate both a rite using bread and wine and a meal of fellowship that included
 Caspian feels towards Aslan--to appropriate the terms of two of the loves Lewis describes in his book The Four Loves. (10) And the desire is not associated with one individual, as it is in Morris's version of the story, but with many. Doctor Cornelius and Caspian's nurse share a longing for Aslan's return, as do the good Talking Beasts. Peter, Susan, Edmund, and especially Lucy, having returned to Narnia, share in that longing. Desire in Prince Caspian is communal, not individual. As the de-heroicizing serves to honor Aslan, this de-libidinizing helps to center Aslan as the object of longing.

Longing, of course, plays an important role in Lewis's theology, where he argues that feelings of longing for earthly things that ultimately disappoint us serve to redirect our desire to God, who is eternal. This idea is most forcefully put in Lewis's autobiography, Surprised by Joy (see for instance 221-22), but it was also a dominant theme in the letters he wrote to Arthur Greeves. In one such letter, Lewis describes how Morris helped him to understand the significance of this longing. In a letter dated 31 June 1930, Lewis describes how he purchased the 24-volume Collected Works of William Morris at Blackwells in Oxford and encountered in it a work, Love is Enough, that he had never read before. Like other works of Morris, especially his late prose romances, it occasions in Lewis an intense feeling of longing. But it is only now, on the eve On the Eve (Накануне in Russian) is the third novel by famous Russian writer Ivan Turgenev, best known for his short stories and the novel Fathers and Sons.  of his conversion to Christianity Conversion to Christianity is the religious conversion of a previously non-Christian person to some form of Christianity. The exact understanding of what it means to attain salvation varies somewhat among denominations. , that Lewis understands what that longing is really for. He writes to Greeves:
  You know I always thought Morris the most essentially pagan of all
  poets. The beauty of the actual world, the vague longings wh[ich] it
  excites, the inevitable failure to satisfy these longings, and over
  all the haunting sense of time & change making the world heart
  breakingly beautiful just because it slips away [...] all this, I
  thought, he gave to perfection: but of what this longing really
  pointed to, of the reason why beauty made us homesick, of the reality
  behind, I thought he had no inkling. (They Stand Together 366)


Now, however, Lewis realizes that Morris did have an inkling in·kling  
n.
1. A slight hint or indication.

2. A slight understanding or vague idea or notion.



[Probably alteration of Middle English (a) ningkiling,
. Lewis meditates on this and, seemingly for the first time, understands it. As he explains to Greeves:
  In this light I shall come back to Morris and all that world. I have
  the key now and perhaps can stand the sweetness safely. For this too
  is a feature of life that becomes gradually clearer: namely that the
  road is always turning round and going back to places we seemed to
  have left--but they are different (yet in a way the same) when you
  come to them the second time. (ibid.)


This insight is profoundly influential, a major step towards his conversion. Lewis realized that longing in Morris was mostly sexual in nature, but he allows Morris in Love Is Enough a taste of this more cosmic longing.

This work is a verse drama in which a powerful king named Pharamond forsakes his kingdom because he has had visions of a lover whom he has not yet met. He endures tremendous suffering to find her and renounces all his power and wealth in the process, realizing that if one has gained true love, it is enough. The god of Love himself appears before each scene, commenting on the significance of the action. The language of these speeches forces the reader to conflate con·flate  
tr.v. con·flat·ed, con·flat·ing, con·flates
1. To bring together; meld or fuse: "The problems [with the biopic] include . .
 the god of Love with the God who has created all. Lewis responds to the inherent Platonism of this work, assuming that the earthly love King Pharamond seeks leads one to the heavenly love that calls us all into being. As Lewis writes of longing in Surprised by Joy:
  And that is why we experience Joy: we yearn, rightly, for that unity
  which we can never reach except by ceasing to be the separate
  phenomenal beings called "we." (221-22)


It is perhaps no surprise that in Prince Caspian, so closely aligned with Morris's Child Christopher, Lewis carefully redirects the longing he perceives in the earlier book to what he would have maintained was its true source.

The third major change I wish to list has a similar function. Havelok the Dane could admit the supernatural, as it does with the marvelous light which attends Havelok while sleeping, thus affirming his rightful claim to the throne. Morris, however, admits none of the marvelous into Child Christopher and Goldilind the Fair. It is a romance in which nothing happens that is not plausible. In this it stands apart from the other late romances of Morris, like The Well at the World's End and The Wood Beyond the World (which phrase suggested the concept of the Wood between the Worlds to Lewis for his The Magician's Nephew (11)). What Lewis does to the story is to reinvigorate re·in·vig·o·rate  
tr.v. re·in·vig·o·rat·ed, re·in·vig·o·rat·ing, re·in·vig·o·rates
To give new life or energy to.



re
 it with the marvelous. This is not only evident in the book's opening, where Peter, Susan, Edmund, and Lucy are magically transported from an English train station into the realm of Narnia, but also in the chapter "How All Were Very Busy," where Aslan goes about healing Old Narnia. I would like to term this change "re-mythologizing."

In analyzing Chaucer's adaptations of Boccaccio, Lewis theorizes that a common motivation for one author's changes in the work of another implies intentionality intentionality

Property of being directed toward an object. Intentionality is exhibited in various mental phenomena. Thus, if a person experiences an emotion toward an object, he has an intentional attitude toward it.
, enabling the critic to discern what the second author "really did" to the work of the first. One common motivation among the changes I have termed de-heroicizing, de-libidinizing, and re-mythologizing is the insertion of a new character into this old story--Aslan. Each of the changes focuses the reader's attention away from the earthly and onto God. In other words, Lewis Platonizes Child Christopher by supplying the true object to the longing he finds in Morris's work. What Lewis really does Warren Trotter, better known as Really Doe, is an American rapper from Chicago, Illinois. He is affiliated with Kanye West and his G.O.O.D. Music family and label. Discography
Songs
  • "Day By Day"
  • "Plastic"
  • "The Love"
 to Morris is, in other words, baptize bap·tize  
v. bap·tized, bap·tiz·ing, bap·tiz·es

v.tr.
1. To admit into Christianity by means of baptism.

2.
a. To cleanse or purify.

b. To initiate.

3.
 him. This is not only a significant thing for him to do, given his desire in The Chronicles of Narnia to present a Christian message in the medium of the children's story but also, I suggest, an inclusive gesture towards an author whose stories were a lifelong delight but whose "paganism" perplexed per·plexed  
adj.
1. Filled with confusion or bewilderment; puzzled.

2. Full of complications or difficulty; involved.



[Middle English, from perplex, confused
 him. He could see the divine shining through a story bequeathed to him by the favorite author of his own pre-Christian, pagan days. Lewis seeks to make clear what he thinks Morris saw only dimly, and he uses the old story of his old master to do so, thus honoring it. One thinks of Emeth, the servant of the false god Tash TASH The Association for Persons with Severe Handicaps  who worshipped nevertheless in "truth" (the meaning of "emeth" in Hebrew). Near the end of The Last Battle Aslan welcomes him as one of his own (161-66).

WORKS CITED

Boenig, Robert. "Critical and Fictional Pairing in C.S. Lewis." The Taste of the Pineapple: Essays on C.S. Lewis as Reader, Critic, and Imaginative Writer. Ed. Bruce L. Edwards Bruce L. Edwards is Professor of English and Associate Dean for Distance Education and International Programs at Bowling Green State University in Bowling Green, Ohio, where has he been a faculty member and administrator since 1981. . Bowling Green Bowling Green.

1 City (1990 pop. 40,641), seat of Warren co., S Ky., on the Barren River; inc. 1812. It is a shipping and marketing center for an area producing tobacco, corn, livestock, and dairy items.
, OH: Bowling Green State U Popular P, 1988.138-48.

Carnell, Corbin Scott. "C.S. Lewis on Eros as a Means of Grace The Means of Grace in Christian theology are those things (the means) through which God gives grace. Just what this grace entails is interpreted in various ways: generally speaking, some see it as God blessing humankind so as to sustain and empower the Christian life; ." Imagination and the Spirit: Essays in Literature and the Christian Faith Presented to Clyde S. Kilby. Ed. Charles A. Huttar. Grand Rapids Grand Rapids, city (1990 pop. 189,126), seat of Kent co., SW central Mich., on the Grand River; inc. 1850. The second largest city in the state, it is a distribution, wholesale, and industrial center for an area that yields fruit, dairy products, farm produce, : Eerdmans, 1971. 341-51.

Edwards, Bruce L. "Toward a Rhetoric of Fantasy Criticism: C.S. Lewis's Readings of MacDonald and Morris." Literature and Belief 3 (1983): 63-73.

Hodgson, Amanda. The Romances of William Morris. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press Cambridge University Press (known colloquially as CUP) is a publisher given a Royal Charter by Henry VIII in 1534, and one of the two privileged presses (the other being Oxford University Press). , 1987.

Kotzin, Michael C. "C.S. Lewis and George MacDonald George MacDonald (December 10, 1824 – September 18, 1905) was a Scottish author, poet, and Christian minister.

Though no longer well known, his works (particularly his fairy tales and fantasy novels) have inspired admiration in such notables as W. H. Auden, J. R. R.
: The Silver Chair and the Princess Books." Mythlore 8.1 (1981): 5-15.

Lewis, C.S. All My Road Before Me: The Diary of C.S. Lewis, 1922-1927. Ed. Walter Hooper Walter McGehee Hooper (born 1931) is a trustee and literary advisor of the estate of C.S. Lewis. Born in Reidsville, North Carolina, he earned an M.A. in education and was an instructor in English at the University of Kentucky in the early 1960s. . New York New York, state, United States
New York, Middle Atlantic state of the United States. It is bordered by Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and the Atlantic Ocean (E), New Jersey and Pennsylvania (S), Lakes Erie and Ontario and the Canadian province of
: Harcourt, 1991.

__. The Four Loves. New York: Harcourt, 1960.

__. The Last Battle. The Chronicles of Narnia. New York: Collier, 1970.

__. Prince Caspian. The Chronicles of Narnia. New York: Collier, 1970.

__. Surprised by Joy: The Shape of My Early Life. New York: Harcourt Brace, 1955.

__. They Stand Together: The Letters of C.S. Lewis to Arthur Greeves, 1914-1963. Ed. Walter Hooper. New York: Macmillan, 1979.

__. "What Chaucer Really Did to Il Filostrato." Essays and Studies 19 (1932): 56-75.

__. "William Morris." Selected Literary Essays by C.S. Lewis. Ed. Walter Hooper. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1969 [1939]. 219-31.

Mackail, J.W. The Life of William Morris. New York: Dover, 1899.

Madden mad·den  
v. mad·dened, mad·den·ing, mad·dens

v.tr.
1. To make angry; irritate.

2. To drive insane.

v.intr.
To become infuriated.
, Frederick. The Ancient English Romance of Havelock have·lock  
n.
A cloth covering for a cap, having a flap to cover and protect the back of the neck.



[After Sir Henry Havelock (1795-1857), British soldier.]

Noun 1.
 the Dane, Accompanied by the French Text. London: Roxburghe Club The Roxburghe Club was formed on the 17th of June, 1812 by leading bibliophiles at the time the library of the Duke of Roxburghe was auctioned. It took 45 days to sell the entire collection. , 1828.

Mathews, Richard. Worlds Beyond the World: The Fantastic Vision of William Morris. San Bernardino San Bernardino, city, United States
San Bernardino (săn bûr'nədē`nō), city (1990 pop. 164,164), seat of San Bernardino co., S Calif., at the foot of the San Bernardino Mts.; inc. 1854.
, CA: Borgo, 1978.

McCarthy, Fiona. William Morris: A Life for Our Time. London: Faber & Faber, 1994.

McGann, Jerome J. A Critique of Modern Textual Criticism textual criticism
n.
1. The study of manuscripts or printings to determine the original or most authoritative form of a text, especially of a piece of literature.

2.
. Chicago: University of Chicago P, 1983.

Morris, William Morris, William, 1834–96, English poet, artist, craftsman, designer, social reformer, and printer. He has long been considered one of the great Victorians and has been called the greatest English designer of the 19th cent. . Child Christopher and Goldilind the Fair. Collected Works of William Morris. Ed. May Morris. Vol. 17. London: Longmans, Green, 1913. 133-261.

__. Love is Enough. Collected Works of William Morris. Ed. May Morris. Vol. 9. London: Longmans, Green, 1911. 3-89.

Murrin, Michael. "The Dialectic dialectic (dīəlĕk`tĭk) [Gr.,= art of conversation], in philosophy, term originally applied to the method of philosophizing by means of question and answer employed by certain ancient philosophers, notably Socrates.  of Multiple Worlds: An Analysis of C.S. Lewis's Narnia Stories." Seven: An Anglo-American Literary Review 3 (1982): 101-05.

Patterson, Nancy-Lou. "Halfe Like a Serpent: The Green Witch in the Silver Chair." Mythlore 11.2 (1984): 37-47

Skeat, Walter W., ed. The Lay of Havelock the Dane. London: N. Trubner, 1868.

Smithers Smithers is a surname, and may refer to: People
People with the surname Smithers
  • Collier Twentyman Smithers, British artist
  • Jan Smithers, American actress
  • Joy Smithers, Australian actress
  • William Smithers, American actor
, G.V., ed. Havelock the Dane. Oxford: Clarendon, 1987.

Talbot, Norman. "'But he were king, or kinges Eyr ...': Morris's Re-Telling of Havelok." Journal of the William Morris Society 10.4 (1994): 28-39.

(1) See All My Road Before Me, Surprised by Joy, and They Stand Together for examples.

(2) For details about Morris's life, the standard biography is Fiona MacCarthy's William Morris: A Life for Our Time. For Morris's rejection of Christianity, see McCarthy 94-95 and Mackail 78, 84.

(3) For an explication ex·pli·cate  
tr.v. ex·pli·cat·ed, ex·pli·cat·ing, ex·pli·cates
To make clear the meaning of; explain. See Synonyms at explain.



[Latin explic
 of the influence of MacDonald on The Silver Chair, see Kotzin; Patterson 46 n.9.

(4) For a treatment of Lewis's debts to both George MacDonald and William Morris, see Edwards.

(5) For an earlier edition that Lewis might also have known, see Madden. The standard edition of the poem is now Smithers.

(6) See also Mathews 48; Talbot 30.

(7) "Meadhamstead" is the capital of her kingdom.

(8) The similarity in names to Tolkien's wizard Gandalf is striking here, and Tolkien was, like Lewis, a devotee of Morris's romances, but Tolkien likely appropriated the name from a list of dwarfs' names included in the Old Norse Old Norse
n.
1. The North Germanic languages until the middle of the 14th century.

2.
a. Old Icelandic.

b. Old Norwegian.

Noun 1.
 Edda.

(9) For a rigorously skeptical position about the recovery of an author's intentions, see, for instance, McGann, especially pp. 37-49.

(10) For an explication of Lewis's treatment of eros, see Carnell.

(11) For Lewis's concept of the Wood between the Worlds, see Murrin.
COPYRIGHT 2007 Mythopoeic Society
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2007, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Boenig, Robert
Publication:Mythlore
Geographic Code:4EUUK
Date:Mar 22, 2007
Words:5527
Previous Article:The Fall and Repentance of Galadriel.("The Lord of the Rings" character)
Next Article:Pullman, Lewis, MacDonald, and The Anxiety of Influence.



Related Articles
OPEC Price Defence Efforts Need Another Output Cut, Despite A War On Iraq.
Black Gold.(Caspian Sea oil development)
IRAN - June 21 - UN Bans Sturgeon Fishing In Most Caspian.(Brief Article)
PRINCE INVESTS IN CREATORS OF `JURASSIC' RIDE.(BUSINESS)
VALLEY'S ANNUAL FAIR WINDS UP TODAY AT MIDNIGHT.(News)
Narnia in full color.(anniversary edition of C.S Lewis' classic work)(Brief Article)
'WIZARD' IS TWICE THE FUN FOR ACTORS DUAL CASTS FILLING LEAD ROLES.(News)
Disney pushes back Narnia.(Public Companies)
PUBLIC FORUM.(Editorial)(Editorial)(Letter to the editor)
Editorial.(Editorial)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles