In the classroom, educators have different views about positive reinforcement and how it should be used. Some view positive reinforcement techniques as a form of bribery offered to students to get them to do what they should be doing in the first place. Others say that too often classroom management involves negative reinforcement and that positive reinforcement occurs in the adult world, so it has a place in the classroom as well.
Career and technical education students who have jobs know that showing up on time every day and working hard is rewarded by a paycheck and perhaps a raise. Character education and service-learning projects that occur in career and technical education also result in positive reinforcement as young people find that acts of kindness are often returned and that the rewards of "doing good" are immeasurable.
When children are young, the positive reinforcement used by teachers may be stickers or gold stars; clearly it takes something different for older students. However, verbal praise is a more sophisticated version of the gold star and is employed by secondary and postsecondary educators as positive reinforcement. Educators might make note of a recent study, even though it was directed toward parents. The study cautions parents about the kind of praise they give their children, noting that praising children as "smart" may cause them to think they can put forth less effort because they are smart, whereas praising their efforts encourages them to continue that effort.
The Centre for Psychology at Canada's Athabasca University has a positive reinforcement stir-instructional exercise online and offers examples. In one of these examples, on the first of a professor's weekly quizzes the scores are low. The professor praises the performance of the students who answered the questions correctly, and as a result, the students' performance improved on the rest of the quizzes. While that seems a bit simplistic, it is presented as an example of a behavior that improved as a result of positive feedback. Non-examples are also presented to help define what is and is not positive reinforcement.
Charles H. Wolfgang, author of Solving Discipline and Classroom Management Problems, notes that positive reinforcement is not always good for a student, and negative reinforcement is not always bad. "The key," notes Wolfgang, "is what kind of behavior increases when these reinforcers are applied."
A punishment might work to stop bad behavior, but if it instead increases the status of the student among his or her peers, then it might serve to reinforce the bad behavior. A negative reprimand, on the other hand, might seem like negative reinforcement, but it could have positive consequences upon the student's behavior. Thus, says Wolfgang, a positive reinforcer may be defined by the behavior followed by a consequence that increases over time. A teacher may observe when certain types of reinforcement work for a student and will then know what to use in the future to reinforce positive behavior. Classroom management expert Fred Jones suggests offering incentives such as preferred activity time. In the career and technical education classroom, completing a task correctly and on time could result in more time to work on that special robotics project or that new fashion design.
Other positive reinforcement incentives may be given to the class as a group, such as the opportunity to watch a movie or play a game. Individual positive reinforcement might include extra credit points or being given the responsibility of team leader for a group project.
Teachers also use social reinforcers such as positive feedback, smiles, compliments and praise. This is a type of positive reinforcement that costs no money, and yet it may be among the most effective. As the old song goes, "Accentuate the positive, eliminate the negative." Of course, eliminating the negative might be a bit overly optimistic to say the least, but reducing it is at least a possibility with positive reinforcement as a classroom management technique.
Positive Reinforcement Connections
Here are some online resources with information about using positive reinforcement in the classroom.
"Positive Reinforcement: A Self-Instructional Exercise," Centre for Psychology, Athabasea University http://psych.athabascau.ca
University of Kansas Special Connections www.specialconnections.ku.edu/cgibin/cgiwrap/specconn/index.php
Positive Reinforcement www.usu.edu/teachall/text/behavior/ LRBIpdfs/Positive.pdf
Environmental Education is a Focus in April
ORGANIZATIONS SUCH AS THE NATIONAL Environmental Education and Training Foundation, the Alliance to Save Energy and the National Arbor Day Foundation are all making April the month to stress environmental education--and are offering free resources for educators to help them in that mission.
The three organizations are working together to make April 15-22, 2007 National Environmental Education Week, with a special focus this year on energy. Among the resources being offered are free lesson plans and activities for middle school students about the link between trees and energy from the National Arbor Day Foundation and downloadable lesson plans and energy curricula for all grade levels from the Alliance to Save Energy. The National Arbor Day Foundation also has a "Tree Planting Resource Kit" designed for high school students with advice about initiating community tree-planting events.
The National Environmental Education and Training Foundation, which has coordinated the weeklong event since 2004, notes that National Environmental Education Week is designed to increase the educational impact of Earth Day by creating a full week of educational preparation, learning and activities in K-12 classrooms, nature centers, zoos, museums and aquariums. For more information, visit www.eeweek.org.
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Title Annotation:||CLASSROOM CONNECTION|
|Date:||Apr 1, 2007|
|Previous Article:||Stay safe.|
|Next Article:||Taking the lead in an emergency.|