Printer Friendly

Plating anomalies and defects, Part 1: plating defects can have multiple origins, so don't jump to conclusions.

It is a good idea to begin this month's edition of Positive Plating by presenting a few different plating defects and discussing some of the possible causes and remedies to resolve the problem. Many of these defects have multiple origins. Defects can be the result of multiple problems throughout the manufacturing process, and this may not manifest in the process where the defect actually occurred. When trying to identify the root cause of a defect, it is often best to not jump to conclusions. Not understanding a defect's true genesis will lead to incorrect remedies to these issues. I will discuss some defects and possible remedies.

Blisters (Hole-Wall Pullaway)

The common complaint one hears is, "The copper plating is peeling." Ok, but where is it peeling from, off of the copper surface or from within the via? What about the interconnect? Is the peeling layer the electroless copper deposit or the electrolytic copper? These are the questions one must answer in order to properly trouble shoot the defect. FIGURE 1 shows a real-life example of a blistered or peeling deposit. The copper deposit has actually flaked off or blistered from the hole. In some cases, the deposit does not completely flake off the surface, but instead, pulls away from the hole wall. This condition is referred to as hole-wall pullaway (HWPA).

Now the question is where is the origin of the blister? In this case, the good news is that we are only looking at the electroless copper. There has yet to be an electrolytic copper deposit applied to the circuit board, but that is all one can tell at this point.

A more typical example of HWPA is depicted in FIGURE 2. The deposit pulled away from the hole-wall but did not fracture or flake off. Nonetheless, this is a defect and must be remedied. The root cause of HWPA is very similar to those that lead to flaking and blistering.

So, one is dealing with the origin of the blister or peeling deposit prior to electrolytic copper plating. TABLE 1 lists the most common causes for this type of defect. Further information about the hole wall condition can be determined by a careful review of the microsection or through SEM analysis.

Keep in mind that there is no substitute for process control. All of the operators should have a basic understanding of why certain processes must be controlled within the stated limits. This will go a long way in preventing costly rejects.



MICHAEL CARANO is global manager for strategic business development at OM Group, Inc. and can be reached at
TABLE 1. Common causes of NWPA.

Cause Look at

Excessive catalyzation Dwell times, temperatures

Smooth topography on resin * besmear process not able to
 produce a topography
 * excessive solvent penetration
 * Insufficient rinsing after
 cleaner/conditioner step
 * Inadequate etching of the
 resin-poor topography

Electroless copper deposition * Check rate coupons-is dep
rate too rate higher than normal?
high * Check operating temperature
 of electroless copper
 * Check concentrations of the
 key additives-copper, sodium
 hydroxide, HCHO, stabilizer

Cause Remedy

Excessive catalyzation Reduce time and temperatures
 in catalyst

Smooth topography on resin * Review resin type-higher Tg
 resins are more difficult to
 desmear-excessive lamination
 temperatures and cure
 times over cross link material.
 * Make sure cleaner conditioner
 is free-rinsing--consider
 reducing concentration
 and dwell times
 * Measure weight loss of the
 test coupons after Besmear

Electroless copper deposition * Check specific gravity of
rate too electroless copper solution
high --solution bail-out to bring
 specific gravity in range
 * Reduce operating temperature
 * Analyze and adjust
 concentrations to recommended
COPYRIGHT 2009 UP Media Group, Inc.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2009 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

 Reader Opinion




Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Carano, Michael
Publication:Printed Circuit Design & Fab
Date:Jun 1, 2009
Previous Article:Treasure hunt: in times of uncertainty, resources like time and talent can be game changing.
Next Article:PCB stackup analysis and design, Part 5: PCB stackup influences board impedance, signal integrity and the EMI performance of the system.

Terms of use | Copyright © 2015 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters