Printer Friendly
The Free Library
5,677,439 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

Only two American Indians at work in opinion writing. (Diversity of Opinion).


I think it's fair to say that never in the history of Minnesota The history of Minnesota is the story of a U.S. state shaped by its original Native American residents, European exploration and settlement, and the emergence of industries made possible by the state's natural resources.  has a journalist compared Crazy Horse with President Kennedy in an opinion column.

Quite probably, no other writer suggested that when Clayton Moore Clayton Moore (September 14, 1914 – December 28, 1999) was an American actor best known for playing the fictional western character The Lone Ranger.

Born as Jack Carlton Moore
 died, he take the "Lone Ranger Lone Ranger

arch foe of criminals in early west. [Radio: “The Lone Ranger” in Buxton, 143–144; Comics: Horn, 460; TV: Terrace, II, 34–35]

See : Crime Fighting


Lone Ranger
" reruns with him because the show's writers insisted on making Tonto so grammar-challenged. How could any Indian hang out with so many white people for so many years and never master pronouns?

Until I joined the St. Paul Pioneer Press
This article is about the Minnesota newspaper. For the chain of Illinois weeklies, see Pioneer Press.


The St. Paul Pioneer Press is a newspaper based in St. Paul, Minnesota, primarily serving the Twin Cities metropolitan area.
 editorial board, I doubt if any writer here thought through the economic impact of gambling on the state. Editorials often complained about the social costs of gambling, and rightly so. l argued, however, that social costs are half the story. Learn how many jobs have been created, I insisted, and how many people left welfare. Learn the way the new money has improved the lives of reservation and off-reservation Indians. Tell the whole story, I pleaded. Initially, the suggestion was met with mostly furrowed brows.

Maybe the owners of those brows can more readily answer the question of whether a person of American Indian American Indian
 or Native American or Amerindian or indigenous American

Any member of the various aboriginal peoples of the Western Hemisphere, with the exception of the Eskimos (Inuit) and the Aleuts.
 heritage makes a difference on an editorial board. Statistically, their replies would tell nearly the whole story because Indians are almost invisible in newsrooms across the country.

A survey by the American Society of Newspaper Editors last year determined that of 54,414 journalists, 307 were American Indian, or about one-half of one percent. Two-thirds of the country's daily newspapers answered the ASNE ASNE American Society of Newspaper Editors
ASNE American Society of Naval Engineers
ASNE Air and Space Natural Environment
ASNE Association Sport Nature Education (France) 
 survey.

The Native American Journalists 19th-century print journalists
  • Anne Newport Royall (1769-1854) - first female journalist in the U.S., first woman to interview a President, publisher and editor for Paul Pry (1831-36), and The Huntress (1836-54) in Washington, D.C.
 Association reports that two of its members are on editorial boards, Doreen Yellow Bird with the Grand Forks Herald The Grand Forks Herald is a daily broadsheet newspaper, begun in 1879, printed in Grand Forks, North Dakota. It is the primary daily paper for northeast North Dakota and northwest Minnesota. Its average daily circulation is 34,763 on Sundays and 31,524 on weekdays.  in North Dakota North Dakota, state in the N central United States. It is bordered by Minnesota, across the Red River of the North (E), South Dakota (S), Montana (W), and the Canadian provinces of Saskatchewan and Manitoba (N). , and me. Almost every year I call NAJA to learn if more Indians are on boards. Every year, the answer is no.

That reply is dispiriting dis·pir·it  
tr.v. dis·pir·it·ed, dis·pir·it·ing, dis·pir·its
To lower in or deprive of spirit; dishearten. See Synonyms at discourage.



[di(s)- + spirit.]

Adj.
 but understandable. I don't know Don't know (DK, DKed)

"Don't know the trade." A Street expression used whenever one party lacks knowledge of a trade or receives conflicting instructions from the other party.
 of too many Indians who would welcome the loneliness of this job with its predictable stream of hate mail after an "Indian" piece is published. To write for a mainstream newspaper means leaving a closely knit reservation. A lot of Indians simply can't and won't do that.

Even urban Indians, however, avoid journalism programs, largely because no one ever encouraged them, they have few role models, and education isn't valued. I remind Indian high school students that they come from an oral storytelling tradition that's at least 12,000 years old. I remind them that more of the truth about our people will emerge if they tell it. The kids listen, but too many run out of hope by the time we meet. Too many drop out of school.

That said, let me take you to a world of make believe. If every editorial board in the country had an Indian journalist with background in his or her tribe's culture and history, the overall quality of life for all Indians would vastly improve. The cumulative effect could change every corner of Indian country simply because the chorus would rise to a volume impossible to ignore.

This is not to say that all Indians speak in the same voice. But when only two are speaking on editorial boards-- Doreen and me--we produce less than a squeak. To complicate things further, many readers believe that all Indians are the same.

I try to remind people that I don't represent the views of all 250 Indian nations in the United States. Each has its own culture and history. Here's an example. While living in Milwaukee, non-Indians were puzzled that I didn't travel to see the white buffalo calf born on a farm west of the city. I explained that buffalo weren't culturally significant to the woodland Ojibwe.

Explanations of that kind are most effectively made to a broad audience, transforming opinion writing into a kind of classroom teaching. I think it's safe to say that the average adult in Minnesota knows squat about Indians. Not even elementary matters are understood, such as the special political status of Indians. We aren't just "minorities" based on race or ethnicity. A background and respect for treaty law is crucial to understanding the never-ending baffles Indians must fight to protect their cultures and traditions.

I've written about some of those battles. Many Minnesota Indians appreciate the effort. Once in a while at a pow wow or social gathering, someone will approach. "I saw that thing you wrote' I'm told. "Keep it up."

So I keep it up.

Someone has to.

NCEW NCEW National Conference of Editorial Writers  member Deborah Locke is an editorial writer with the St. Paul PioneerPress in Minnesota and a graduate of the Minority Writers Seminar. E-mail her at dlocke@pioneerpress.com
COPYRIGHT 2002 National Conference of Editorial Writers
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2002, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Locke, Deborah
Publication:The Masthead
Geographic Code:1USA
Date:Dec 22, 2002
Words:769
Previous Article:An opportunity and a challenge: racism, sexism, and ethnic biases are still alive and well. (Diversity of Opinion).
Next Article:A league of one among broadcast editorialists. (Diversity of Opinion).
Topics:



Related Articles
Fulfilling the executive's trust responsibility toward the native nations on environmental issues: a partial critique of the Clinton administration's...
Letting go of daily editorials.
The reluctance to change: a history lesson. (editorial writing)(The Masthead Symposium: Signed Editorials)
Medical Care for Leonard Peltier.(several individuals and groups are asking that President Clinton grant clemency for Leonard Peltier)(Brief Article)
Reading editorials for a living.(Brief Article)
Why The Washington Post Op-ed Is So Dull.(editorial pages)
Numbers are up, but many staffs lack diversity: forty-four percent of newspapers report they have no minorities in any part of the newsroom....
Opinion page editors must be willing to take a chance: bet on potential--and on your own skills to foster talent. (Diversity of Opinion).
Opinion writing often not on syllabus: in our efforts to isolate ourselves from the newsroom, we close the door to opinion writing as a career...
Commit to and plan for diversity: we've provided our readers a steady diet of diversity; consequently they focus more on a columnist's point of view....

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles