One for all: Steven Henry Madoff on the Venice Biennale. (Preview).THOSE WHO RECALL THE WAR between Vittorio Sgarbi, former undersecretary of the Italian culture ministry, and Francesco Bonami, director of visual arts visual arts npl → artes fpl plásticas visual arts npl → arts mpl plastiques visual arts npl → for the 50th Venice Biennale Venice Biennale International art exhibition held in the Castello district of Venice every two years and juried by an international committee. It was founded in 1895 as the International Exhibition of Art of the City of Venice to promote “the most noble activities of [see Artforum, May 2002], may wonder what became of the clangor over Bonami's appointment: It ended with a whimper when Sgarbi was summarily booted from office last summer. Even at its most heated, this was nothing more than a local skirmish compared with the real war and terrorism under the pall of which this Biennale The name Biennale is Italian and means "every other year", describing an event that happens every 2 years. One of the most important Biennales is an art exhibition that takes place for three months in Venice — the Venice Biennale — but there are numerous others: It is hard to believe that only two years have passed between Harald Szeemann's immensely hopeful "Plateau of Humankind," the central exhibition of the last Biennale, and Bonami's "Dreams and Conflicts: The Dictatorship of the Viewer." The world, splintered by September II and the calamity in Iraq, is changed, and the Biennale--at 108 years, the Years, The the seven decades of Eleanor Pargiter’s life. [Br. Lit.: Benét, 1109] See : Time world's oldest international art exposition, unfolding in the peaceful precincts of the Giardini and its environs--faces the pressures of a thunderous geopolitical ge·o·pol·i·tics n. (used with a sing. verb) 1. The study of the relationship among politics and geography, demography, and economics, especially with respect to the foreign policy of a nation. 2. a. climate. Which, it turns out, will be much its point. Bonami's structure for the exhibition reflects these straitened strait·en tr.v. strait·ened, strait·en·ing, strait·ens 1. a. To make narrow. b. To enclose in a limited area; confine. 2. , fractured times: He chose to cede unity and dominance to fragments and chance, in effect revoking his single voice of curatorial authority and replacing it with many independent voices, come what may. "One person with one vision isn't a logical way to do this kind of exhibition any longer," Bonami explains. "That's too monotonous for a show that's so big, and with so little time to prepare. And especially with bombs dropping, the world is telling us every day that there is no unifying subject. So I wanted to present a fragmentary set of identities in art--even if people say there is not enough of a connection and I get fried for it." But of course he will not be fried, or celebrated, alone. Bonami invited a dozen prominent and professionally intertwined curators--Hans-Ulrich Obrist, Catherine David, Daniel Birnbaum, Carlos Basualdo, and Gilane Tawadros among them--to organize exhibitions beside him. There will be eleven shows, which Bonami likens, in a passing moment of geekiness, to the nonlinear narrative of hypertext. From the works of some 265 artists in about 79,000 square feet of exhibition space, viewers will be invited to construct a "Dreams and Conflicts" all their own, "out of the relationships they discover for themselves," as the director puts it. This is where the second part of the title, "The Dictatorship of the Viewer," comes in. Bonami, whose day job is Manilow Senior Curator at the Museum of Contemporary Art in Chicago, remarks that "the viewer has become the dictator in museums today, demanding explanations of what they see. And museums are terrified ter·ri·fy tr.v. ter·ri·fied, ter·ri·fy·ing, ter·ri·fies 1. To fill with terror; make deeply afraid. See Synonyms at frighten. 2. To menace or threaten; intimidate. to lose even one customer. So the level of culture is lowered with blockbusters. On the other side, viewers are abused by work--videos especially--that demand the kind of time only a retired person has. The viewer, in this sense, is dictated to. So I want to address these things "These Things" is an EP by She Wants Revenge, released in 2005 by Perfect Kiss, a subsidiary of Geffen Records. Music Video The music video stars Shirley Manson, lead singer of the band Garbage. Track Listing 1. "These Things [Radio Edit]" - 3:17 2. by making a more challenging experience for viewers but also by limiting works that will not allow them to make their way through the art in a reasonable time." For the twenty-first century, Bonami proposes that the behemoth behemoth (bē`hĭmŏth, bĭhē`–) [Heb.,=plural of beast], large, fanciful primeval monster, like Leviathan, evoking the hippopotamus mentioned in the Book of Job. Biennale and its many elephantine Elephantine (ĕl'əfăntī`nē), island, SE Egypt, in the Nile below the First Cataract, near Aswan. In ancient times it was a military post guarding the southern frontier of Egypt. clones be broken down to make the art--and the world that the art represents--easier to approach and its exhibition more nimble. Bonami speaks of his shows as "live cells interacting in unpredictable ways." The monolith, he suggests, must be taken apart, made modular, and that is what he'll do. (Not that this hasn't been tried before in Venice, if on a smaller scale. Ten years ago, Achille Bonito Oliva Achille Bonito Oliva, (November 4, 1939) is a highly recognized and respected Italian contemporary art critic, author of essays on mannerism, and a teacher of History of Contemporary Art at La Sapienza University in Rome. handed out sections of the "Aperto" exhibition to different curators, including, tellingly enough, Bonami.) Yet despite the talk of autonomous shows, the aggregate may still amount to a monolith. Call it zeitgeist, curatorial preoccupation, or fashion--the thrust of these exhibitions is art mapped onto social and political frameworks. Just consider the shows' titles: Catherine David's "Contemporary Arab Presentations"; Hou Hanru's "Z.O.U. (Zone of Urgency)"; Basualdo's "The Structure of Survival"; "Utopia Station," curated by Obrist, Molly Nesbit, and Rirkrit Tiravanija Rirkrit Tiravanija (b. 1961 and pronounced RICK-rit Tira-VAN-it) is a Buenos Aires-born contemporary artist who divides his time in New York, Berlin and Bangkok. Work Tiravanija's artwork explores the social role of the artist. ; "Fault Lines: Contemporary African Art African art, art created by the peoples south of the Sahara. The predominant art forms are masks and figures, which were generally used in religious ceremonies. and Shifting Landscapes" by Tawadros; and "The Zone" by Massimiliano Gioni, who writes of his show with regard to migratory movements and of his exhibition space as a metaphor for Italy's role in European history. The terms and subjects that crop up repeatedly in the shows' summaries telegraph this Biennale's concerns: postcolonialism; disenfranchisement dis·en·fran·chise tr.v. dis·en·fran·chised, dis·en·fran·chis·ing, dis·en·fran·chis·es To disfranchise. dis ; "art itself as a social institution"; local versus global; "theater of resistance"; social transformation; social crises; nationalist struggles; race and power. A year ago, Bonami said pugnaciously pug·na·cious adj. Combative in nature; belligerent. See Synonyms at belligerent. [From Latin pugn that he wasn't interested in art that's like an essay on anthropology or sociology." When reminded of this recently, he laughed and said, "But for the shows I'm doing, this is not the case. For the rest, there is freedom to do what they want. And the range is broader than you think, from David's show, which is supersociological, to 'Utopia Station,' which includes every aspect of the creative mind, including science." True to his word, Bonami has curated "Clandestine," which gathers lesser-known artists not linked by any dominant theme or medium but that simply interest him, and "Pittura,' Painting: From Rauschenberg to Murakami, 1964-2003," a forty-year survey of the medium at the Biennale, both of which are devoted to art without any frontal social agenda. Yet "Delays and Revolutions," which Bonami cocurated with Birnbaum, is pulled inevitably toward the main sociopolitical so·ci·o·po·li·ti·cal adj. Involving both social and political factors. sociopolitical Adjective of or involving political and social factors track, despite its Harold Bloomish theme of artistic influence and misreading MISREADING, contracts. When a deed is read falsely to an illiterate or blind man, who is a party to it, such false reading amounts to a fraud, because the contract never had the assent of both parties. 5 Co. 19; 6 East, R. 309; Dane's Ab. c. 86, a, 3, Sec. 7; 2 John. R. 404; 12 John. R. . This is evident from the start: Off the front entryway of the Italian pavilion, where their show is mounted, there will be an installation by David Hammons David Hammons (born 1943) is an African-American artist mostly known for his works in and around New York City during the 1970s and 1980s. Much of his work, including Spade with Chains (1973), reflects his commitment to the civil rights and Black Power movements. , whose art is rooted in the marginalization mar·gin·al·ize tr.v. mar·gin·al·ized, mar·gin·al·iz·ing, mar·gin·al·iz·es To relegate or confine to a lower or outer limit or edge, as of social standing. of African-American culture, and a video by the Uruguayan Juan Pedro Fabra, which focuses its lens--albeit to painterly paint·er·ly adj. 1. Of, relating to, or characteristic of a painter; artistic. 2. a. Having qualities unique to the art of painting. b. effect--on training exercises of the Swedish army The Swedish Army (Swedish: Armén) is the army branch of the Swedish Armed Forces, the military of Sweden. Organization The peace time organization of the Swedish Army is divided into a number of regiments for the different corps. . Bonami, in fact, may be the only one among his colleagues who argues that the show(s) are thematically discontinuous--which seems, from a viewer's perspective, like a perverse, though interesting, ambition. After all, as Tiravanija says simply, "Francesco put people together who have a certain sensibility." Nesbit adds, "We've talked a lot with the other curators, and we all know each other anyway. Obviously, these are different projects, but it's a community of exchange, a big conversation, and what you'll see at the Biennale is a focus on that conversation." For Basualdo, the conversation's goal is to "reflect on what kind of role a social art practice may have today. Hopefully, there will be works in my section that argue for art not of consolation, not as refuge, not as a solution for what to do, but that show a moral value and that art can have its own agency in the world." Obrist echoes that same bittersweet bittersweet, name for two unrelated plants, belonging to different families, both fall-fruiting woody vines sometimes cultivated for their decorative scarlet berries. mix of hope and pragmatism when he describes the intellectual destination of "Utopia Station" by paraphrasing Immanuel Wallerstein Immanuel Maurice Wallerstein (born 28 September 1930, New York City) is a U.S. sociologist by credentials, but a historical social scientist, or world-systems analyst by trade. His monthly commentaries on world affairs are syndicated by Agence Global. , who writes in his book Utopistics of "an alternative, credibly better, and historically possible (but far from certain) future." No setting could better frame art as both zone of urgency and idyll idyll or idyl In literature, a simple descriptive work in poetry or prose that deals with rustic life or pastoral scenes or suggests a mood of peace and contentment. than the grounds of the Biennale. While "Dreams and Conflicts" will present a sense of up-to-the-minute global uncertainty, the thirty-two national pavilions, with their stately, embassy-like permanent quarters (and as many other countries with presentations installed throughout the city) represent a more conventional model of political turf; and they're typically funded by the host governments. Well-known artists will be here, too: Jean-Marc Busramante in the French pavilion; Fred Wilson Fred Wilson could refer to:
It is tantalizing tan·ta·lize tr.v. tan·ta·lized, tan·ta·liz·ing, tan·ta·liz·es To excite (another) by exposing something desirable while keeping it out of reach. to think that two models, new and old, will square off in Venice: one decentralized de·cen·tral·ize v. de·cen·tral·ized, de·cen·tral·iz·ing, de·cen·tral·iz·es v.tr. 1. To distribute the administrative functions or powers of (a central authority) among several local authorities. and politically decentering, the other reinforcing the authoritarian sanctities of centralized rule. Yet it's possible that the boundaries won't be so clear. The art in the national pavilions may question politics and authority as much as anything in "Dreams and Conflicts" does (obviously the case with Wilson and Ofili, for example), or it may not speak to political concerns at all. Of course, the curatorial efforts of Bonami's group may nor be so much decentering as marshaled to corroborate To support or enhance the believability of a fact or assertion by the presentation of additional information that confirms the truthfulness of the item. The testimony of a witness is corroborated if subsequent evidence, such as a coroner's report or the testimony of other a common ideological stance. Though the curatorial platforms are professed to be about openness, there is no suggestion that art supporting anything but liberal social and political views are part of this rainbow coalition. I'm not rallying for conservatism, but questioning the definition--in a Clintonesque way--of what "open" actually is. Viewers will soon find out. And lest we forget Lest We Forget is a phrase popularised in 1887, by Rudyard Kipling; it formed the refrain of his poem Recessional. As a title, it may refer to any of:
With a budget cut to about $6.2 million from Szeemann's $6.6 million and with more than twice the number of artists in their shows (Szeemann had 130), Bonami and his colleagues have had their hands full bringing the sheer amount of art--let alone great art--to Venice. More problematic still, Bonami worries that war and fear of terrorism may be a mighty deterrent, resulting in far fewer visitors than the estimated four hundred thousand who came two years ago. Yet he argues that the Biennale "is a counter to destructive acts," while Basualdo says that war could make audiences "look to this art more for answers than for entertainment." One thing is clear: Whether the art is collectively prescriptive or personally therapeutic, an international exhibition so full of hard questions about why humans can't get along and how they might couldn't be more perfectly, if sadly, timed. RELATED ARTICLE: DELAYS AND REVOLUTIONS Francesco Bonaml & Daniel Bimbaum Franz Ackermann Kai Aithoff Thomas Beyerle Matthew Barney Glenn Brown Maurizio Cattelan Johnas Dahlberg Tacita Dean Berlinde de Bruyckere Sam Durant Juan Pedro Fabra Fischli & Weiss Ceal Floyer Giuseppe Gabellone Ellen Gallagher Isa Genzken Carmit Gil Felix Gmelin Robert Gober Amit Goren Dan Graham Massimo Grimaldi Kevin Hanley David Hammons Damien Hirst Carsten Holler Piotr Janas Ian Kiar Din Q. Le Sarah Lucas Lucy McKenzie Kerry James Marshall Kerry James Marshall (October 17, 1955- ) is an artist born in Birmingham, Alabama. He grew up in South Central Los Angeles and now lives in Chicago and teaches at the School of Art and Design at the University of Illinois at Chicago. Helen Mirra Rivane Neuenschwander Gabriel Orozco Jennifer Pastor Richard Prince Carol Rama Charles Ray Tobias Rehberger Shirana Shahbazi Efrat Shvily Rudolf Stingel Jaan Toomik Andy Warhol THE STRUCTURE OF SURVIVAL Carlos Basualdo Caracas Group Carolina Caycedo Sanchez Alexandre da Cunha Paola Di Bello Yona Friedman Gego Fernanda Gomes Rachel Harrison Jose Antonio Hernandez-Diez Koo Jeong-a Chris Ledochowski Mikael Levin Marepe Cildo Meireles Oda Projesi Antonio Ole Olumuyiwa Olamide osifuye Marjetica Potrc Raqs Media Collective Raqs Media Collective is a group of three media practitioners - Jeebesh Bagchi (New Delhi, 1965), Monica Narula (New Delhi, 1969) and Shuddhabrata Sengupta (New Delhi, 1968) - based in New Delhi. Pedro Reyes Andreas Siekmann & Alice Creischer Grupo de Arte Callejero Robert Smithson Meyer Vaisman Dolores Dolores (or Delores) was a common given name (until the 1960s in the USA); it is cognate with the English word "dolorous" (meaning sorrowful) and equivalent in meaning. Zinny & Juan Maidagan INTERLUDES Darren Almond Pawel Althamer Pedro Cabrita Reis Thomas Demand Urs Fischer Jeppe Hein Sandi Hilal & Alessandro Petti pet·ti n. pl. pet·tis 1. A woman's petticoat. 2. A pettislip. Gabriel Kuri Mareaperto Onlus & Luca Gugliettat Alexandre Perigot Paola Pivi Piotr Uklanski CLANDESTINE Francesco Bonami Etti Abergel Avner Ben Gal Colin Darke Enrico David Flavio Favelli Ghazel Dryden Goodwin Hannah Greely Hakan Gursoytrak Michal Helfman Eva Koch Paulina Olowska Magnus von Plessens Jorge Queiroz Aida Ruilova Bojan Sarcevic Dana Schutz Doron Solomons Monika Sonowska Cheyney Thompson Tatian Trouve Nobuko Tsuchiya Amelie von Wuiffen Shizuka Yokomizo Liu Zheng CONTEMPORARY ARAB PRESENTATIONS Catherine David Tony Chakar Michel Lasserre & Paola Yacoub Rabih Mroue Walid Raad Walid Sadek THE EVERYDAY ALTERED Gabriel Orozco Abraham Cruzvillegas Jimmie Durham Daniel Guzman Damian Ortega Fernando Ortega Jean-Luc Moulene FAULT LINES: CONTEMPORARY AFRICAN ART AND SHIFTING LANDSCAPES Gilane Tawadros, with the Forum for African Arts Laylah Ali Kader Attia Samta Benyahia Zarina Bhimji Frank Bowling Clifford Charles Pitso Chinzima & Veliswa Gwintsa Rotimi Fani-Kayode Hassan Fathy Moshekwa Langa Salem Mekuria Sabah Naim Moataz Nasr Wael Shawky UTOPIA STATION Molly Nesbit, Hans-Ulrich Obrist, & Rirkrit Tiravanija Stefano Boeri Amicale de Temoins Ecke Bonk Inaki Bonillas Angela Bulloch Yung Ho Chang Santiago Cirugeda Tacita Dean Jeremy Deller Nico Dockx Trisha Donnelly Ingar Dragset & Michael Elmgreen Leif Elggren & Carl Michael von Hausswolff Carl Michael von Hausswolff (born 1956 in Linköping) is a composer, visual artist and curator based in Stockholm, Sweden. His main tools are recording devices (camera, tape deck, radar, sonar) used in an ongoing investigation of electricity, frequency, architectural space and Olafur Eliasson & Elner Thorsteinn Hans-Peter Feldmann Fischli & Weiss Alicia Framis Yona Friedman Yang Fudong Gilbert & George Liam Gillick Dominique Gonzalez Foerster Rodney Graham Joseph Grigely Henrik Hakansson Carsten Holler Karl Holmquist Marine Hugonnier Pierre Huyghe Arata Isozaki Janus Magazine llya Kabakov Julius Koller Kamin Lertchaiprasert Joep van Lieshout Armin Linke Steve McQueen Jonas Mekas Deimantas Narkevicius Nils Norman Roman Ondak Yoko Ono Gabriel Orozco Philippe Parreno Oliver Payne & Nick Relph Manfred Pernice Michelangelo Pistoletto Edi Rama & Ann Sala Martha Rosier Christoph Schlingensief Tino Sehgal Shimabuku Patti Smith Superflex Uglycute Agnes Varda Lawrence Weiner Cerith Wyn Evans Zerynthia (Association for Contemporary Art) Andrea Zittel PITTURA/PAINTING: FROM RAUSCHENBERG TO MURAKAMI, 1964-2003 Francesco Bonaml Robert Rauschenberg Lucio Fontana Bridget Riley Alberto Burn Andy Warhol Domenico Gnoli Richard Hamilton Philip Guston Roy Lichtenstein Enrico Casteliani Jan Hafstrom Maria Lassnig Gerhard Richter Jorg Immendorff Frank Auerbach Franz Gertsch Martin Kippenberger Anselm Kiefer Georg Baselitz Jean-Michel Basquiat Francesco Clemente Marlene Dumas Francis Bacon Sigmar Polke Carroll Dunham Erik Bulatov Damien Hirst Lari Pittman Gino De Dominicis Gino De Dominicis, was an Italian artist, born in 1947 in Ancona, died at the age of 51, on Nov. 29, 1998 at his home in Rome. De Dominicis was a controversial and mystifying figure in Italian art. John Currin Peter Doig Jenny Saville Elizabeth Peyton Gary Hume Luc Tuymans Margherita Manzelli Chuck Close Thomas Scheibitz Glenn Brown Takashi Murakami THE ZONE Massimillano Gloni Gruppo A12 Alessandra Ariatti Micol Assael Anna De Manincor-ZimmerFrei Diego Perrone Patrick Tuttofuoco Z.O.U. (ZONE OF URGENCY) Hou Hanrz Adel Abdessemed Alfredo Juan Aquilizan & Maria Isabel Aquilizan Atelier Bow-Wow & Momoya Kaijima Campement Urbain Canton Express Jota JOTA Jamboree On The Air JOTA Journal of Optimization Theory and Applications Castro Young-Hae Chang Heavy Industries Young-Hae Chang Heavy Industries (장영혜중공업) is a Seoul-based Web art group consisting of Marc Voge (U.S.A.) and Young-Hae Chang (Korea). Their work is characterized by text-based animation composed in Macromedia Flash[1] Yung Ho Chang & Atelier FCJZ Shulea Cheang Heri Dono Gu Dexin Huang Yong Ping Huang Yong Ping (born 1954) is contemporary French visual artist of Chinese origin. Huang's work combines many media and cultural influence, but is particularly strongly influence by the intellectual abstraction of Dada and by Chinese numerology traditions. Joo Jae-Hwan Sora so·ra n. A North American rail (Porzana carolina) having grayish-brown plumage and a short stout bill, commonly found in freshwater bogs or swamps. [Origin unknown.] Kim & Hong-suk Gim Surasi Kusolwong Kyupi-Kyupi Jun Nguyen-Hatsushiba Tsuyoshi Ozawa Tadaso Takamine Tsang Tsou-choi Wong Hoycheong Yan Lei & Fu Jie Yan Pei-Ming Yang Zhengzhou Zhang Peili Zhu Jia INDIVIDUAL SYSTEMS Igor Zabel Viktor Alimpiev & Marian Zhunin Pawel Althamer Art & Language Josef Dabernig IRWIN Group Luisa Lambri Yuri Leiderman Andrei Monastyrsky Pavel Mrkus Roman Opalka Marko Peljhan Florian Pumhosl Simon Starling Mladen Stilinovic Nahum Tevet Steven Henry Madoff is a frequent contributor to Artforum. |
|
||||||||||||||||||
Printer friendly
Cite/link
Email
Feedback
Reader Opinion