Printer Friendly
The Free Library
4,485,123 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

On the Couch.


Jews and the American Soul

Human Nature in the Twentieth Century

Andrew H. Heinze

Princeton University Press, $29.95, 376 pp.

One of the more remarkable revelations of Andrew Heinze's Jews and the American Soul is that a nineteenth-century mainstream style of Jewish musar, a kind of ethical handbook, was inspired by, and consciously modeled after, Benjamin Franklin's Poor Richard's Almanack. Among Jewish literati, Franklin became known as "the musar Sage in Philadelphia," and an 1833 Viennese Hebrew paper said, "It was a goy that lit the candle that serves as the light of Israel."

Heinze, a professor of both American history and Jewish studies, points out that Franklin and an important wing of nineteenth-century musar authors were grappling with a common problem--how to develop a practical set of ethics without appealing to divine sanctions. Franklin was a secularist living in the waning days of the fire-and-brimstone brimstone: see sulfur. Puritanism Puritanism, in the 16th and 17th cent., a movement for reform in the Church of England that had a profound influence on the social, political, ethical, and theological ideas of England and America.

Origins



Historically Puritanism began early (c.1560) in the reign of Queen Elizabeth I as a movement for religious reform.
 that had dominated early eighteenth-century America. Similarly, European Jewish writers in the Reform and Ethical Culture traditions were struggling to escape the shackles of the intensely mystic, rabbinic religion that had been a cultural analogue of America's Great Awakening Great Awakening, series of religious revivals that swept over the American colonies about the middle of the 18th cent. It resulted in doctrinal changes and influenced social and political thought. In New England it was started (1734) by the rousing preaching of Jonathan Edwards.. And just as Franklin never lost his essentially Protestant worldview, the Jewish secular writers stayed grounded in a uniquely Jewish sensibility.

It is precisely the interpenetration of the American and the Jewish outlook, as epitomized by the Franklin story, that Heinze wishes to explore in Jews and the American Soul. More specifically, he argues that the signal Jewish contribution to American culture has been in the realm of psychology, ranging from the thunderous impact of Freudianism through the popular ministrations and down-to-earth advice of Dr. Joyce Brothers and the Friedman sisters--Abigail Van Buren (Dear Abby) and Anne Landers--to kitschy bestsellers like Harold Kushner's When Bad Things Happen to Good People. Even the musar consciously modeled on the Almanack, he notes, show an interest in the subconscious springs of human action missing from the flatly empiricist Franklin. While Franklin dispensed practical rules for efficient living, Jewish writers probed further into the why of ineffective behavior, opening the door to that endlessly fascinating subject, oneself.

Freud's impact on America far eclipsed that on his native continent. So complex and far-reaching a phenomenon is not susceptible to straightforward explanations, and Heinze doesn't attempt any. But he usefully points out America's uniquely receptive cultural context--the ideology of self-improvement and "getting ahead," a long tradition of advice literature, and most important at the turn of the century, an almost childish faith in the efficacy of "science" to address any problem. This was the era when Henry Adams was trying to tease out a "dynamic theory of history" that could approach the exactitude of physics, and the new discipline of sociology was searching for the laws of the "social-equilibrating apparatus" that underlay observed social interactions. Once Freud had been hailed as a scientific genius, on a par with Newton and Darwin, all forms of pyschologic speculation were instantly ratified.

Heinze is also quite good at tracking the influences running the other way. The doyen of American psychology was Harvard's William James. James called his philosophy "pragmatism," but was quite at home with the irrational, as attested by his Varieties of Religious Experience; James was also among the first to introduce Freud to a wider American audience. Pragmatism imposed a "functionalist" spin on American psychiatry--more focused on practical solutions of adjustment in a sea of interpersonal complexity. Functionalism

functionalism, in anthropology and sociology

functionalism, in anthropology and sociology, a theory stressing the importance of interdependence among all behavior patterns and institutions within a social system to its long-term survival. It was supported by French sociologist Émile Durkheim in the late 19th cent., a reaction against the evolutionary speculations of such theorists as E. B. Tylor.
's influence can be seen in the work of Alfred Adler, who reinterpreted the Freudian family dynamic of sexuality into a struggle for dominance: his "inferiority complex" struck a much more responsive chord in America than Freudian seduction theory. Dale Carnegie's perennial bestseller How to Win Friends and Influence People was, at bottom, an American popularization of Adler.

Psychotherapy, at least of the non-pharmaceutical variety, is inherently anecdotal, and so is Heinze's book. While there is an overall chronological structure, with some deft summaries of cultural and intellectual contexts, including the ebbs and flows of anti-Semitism, the greatest portion of the book is composed of thumbnail sketches of Jewish American psychiatric contributors of varying degrees of importance and obscurity. Although Heinze writes well and often colorfully, this is, after all, a university press book, and the imperative of comprehensiveness may wear on the general reader.

Heinze is celebrating the contribution of psychology to American culture. But at one point he permits himself a brief reflection that laypeople may have misinterpreted Abraham Maslow Abraham 1908-1970.
American psychologist and a founder of humanistic psychology who developed a model of human motivation in which a higher need is expressed only after lower needs are fulfilled.
's ideals of "self-actualization" and the "peak experience." It is one of the few instances where he implies that the social consequences of the movement he extols were anything but entirely positive. Similarly, in his recitations of early psychoanalytic diagnoses and case histories, one might have expected at least some acknowledgement of their high quota of nonsense.

My own curmudgeonly belief is that the mysterious intergalactic energy source called "dark matter" is just an emanation
1. Something that issues from a source; an emission.
2. Any of several radioactive gases that are isotopes of radon and are products of radioactive decay.
 of the universal whine of the American upper-middle class in search of an ever-elusive "self-fulfillment." The consequences reach beyond the disposable incomes of analysts. Whining was first endorsed as national policy in 1957 when Congress, after aggressive lobbying by the psychotherapeutic community, funded a study to determine whether Americans were "happy or unhappy, worried or unworried, optimistic or pessimistic in their outlook? Do they feel strong or weak, adequate or inadequate? What troubles Americans, as they see themselves?" Over the next two decades, the United States discharged tens of thousands of seriously ill people from state mental hospitals and redirected funds to middle-class psychotherapy. Ostensibly, the money was supposed to provide "community care" for the released hospital patients, but that was a lie.

It can be fairly argued that mental illness is both America's most undertreated and most overtreated health condition. Heinze's very useful book is just one side of the story of how we got there.

Charles R. Morris is the author of American Catholic (Times) and Money, Greed, and Risk (Crown), among other books.
COPYRIGHT 2005 Commonweal Foundation
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2005, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Morris, Charles R.
Publication:Commonweal
Article Type:Book Review
Date:Mar 25, 2005
Words:989
Previous Article:What Comes Next?(Book Review)
Next Article:Fast times.(The Last Word)
Topics:



Related Articles
Intellectual Memoirs: New York, 1936-1938.(Brief Article)
The Hidden Life of Dogs.(Brief Article)
Strip Show: Performances of Gender and Desire. (Books).
Reversible Errors.(Book Review)
The World and the Wild. (Book Reviews).(Book Review)
Jazz Composition: Theory and Practice.(Book Review)
The Handy Geology Answer Book.(Brief Article)(Book Review)
The 2,000 Best Games & Activities.(Brief Article)(Children's Review)(Book Review)
Engaging Young Children in Mathematics.(Brief Article)(Book Review)
A Book About Design: Complicated Doesn't Make It Good.(Brief article)(Book review)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2008 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles