Printer Friendly
The Free Library
14,718,654 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

Old advice for a new age.


A half-century ago, at the first convention of the National Conference of Editorial Writers, renowned newspaperman Henry Louis Mencken admonished our founders with these words: "No editorial writer," he said, "ought to be permitted to sit in an editorial room for month after month and year after year, contemplating his umbilicus umbilicus /um·bil·i·cus/ (um-bil´i-kus) [L.] the navel; the scar marking the site of attachment of the umbilical cord in the fetus.

um·bil·i·cus
n. pl um·bil·i·ci
See navel.
. He ought to go out and meet people."

Simple words (with the exception of umbilicus!), simple message: Get out of your ivory editorial tower and listen to the people lest you make a mockery of your profession.

Mencken's message retains its relevancy today, which explains its presence within the corner of cyberspace Coined by William Gibson in his 1984 novel "Neuromancer," it is a futuristic computer network that people use by plugging their minds into it! The term now refers to the Internet or to the online or digital world in general. See Internet and virtual reality. Contrast with meatspace.  we know as NCEW NCEW National Conference of Editorial Writers  Online, and it is a message every online (and perhaps offline) commentator ignores at his or her own risk. Why? The one-word answer: interactivity.

You see, there are no ivory towers on the Internet. "The people" have rejected both the editorial elitism e·lit·ism or é·lit·ism  
n.
1. The belief that certain persons or members of certain classes or groups deserve favored treatment by virtue of their perceived superiority, as in intellect, social status, or financial resources.
 of the past and the hit-and-run punditry of the present. They have demanded a voice in the national discourse, and the World Wide Web has given them that voice - one that often is unfiltered Please wikify (format) this article or section as suggested in the Guide to layout and the Manual of Style.
Remove this template after wikifying. This article has been tagged since
 and unlimited.

We can either embrace the reality of 21st century journalism or be vilified and abandoned by a more enlightened audience that no longer wants to be told how it is but wants to tell us how it should be.

I speak from the perspective of a journalist with but one year of online experience, but let me tell you, it has been a most humbling year.

The first essay I authored for IntellectualCapital .com had to be pulled offline because I naively quoted an Internet junkie junkie Popular health A popular term for a person, usually an IV narcotic abusing addict, whose life is disorganized vis-á-vis family and societal structure, whose existence revolves around obtaining–often through theft, prostitution or other illicit  who had a reputation as a bigot bigot - A person who is religiously attached to a particular computer, language, operating system, editor, or other tool (see religious issues). Usually found with a specifier; thus, "Cray bigot", "ITS bigot", "APL bigot", "VMS bigot", "Berkeley bigot". . An incredulous in·cred·u·lous  
adj.
1. Skeptical; disbelieving: incredulous of stories about flying saucers.

2. Expressive of disbelief: an incredulous stare.
 reader immediately questioned my judgment on the bulletin board at the end of my article, and I had to endure the embarrassment of a rewrite.

Several months later, I spent days on the bulletin board sniping with a reader determined to read into my words something I had not written. "Suddenly," I whined at one point, "I know how politicians must feel when their audiences twists their words out of context."

I could have handled both cases differently - by deleting the comments of the first reader who challenged the character of my source and by arrogantly refusing to clarify my writing to the second.

But I have since learned, again by painful experience, that the delete button should be used sparingly spar·ing  
adj.
1. Given to or marked by prudence and restraint in the use of material resources.

2. Deficient or limited in quantity, fullness, or extent.

3. Forbearing; lenient.
 on Web-based "letters to the editor."

A few months back, I made the mistake of deleting a bulletin-board comment that I thought was "off topic," a violation of our "Code of Conduct." I spent much of the next morning deleting the vulgar and fraudulent flames of the same reader, one of the resident lunatics on our bulletin boards.

Once the flaming began, I had two choices: 1) offer a mea culpa me·a cul·pa  
n.
An acknowledgment of a personal error or fault.



[Latin me culp
 of sorts to save me the hassle of a day in the trenches as "IC moderator;" or 2) ask the technical team to block a disgruntled dis·grun·tle  
tr.v. dis·grun·tled, dis·grun·tling, dis·grun·tles
To make discontented.



[dis- + gruntle, to grumble (from Middle English gruntelen; see
 reader's access to our site entirely. I chose the former.

Why? Because even maniacal ma·ni·a·cal or ma·ni·ac
adj.
Suggestive of or afflicted with insanity.
 readers sometimes have something noteworthy to say. In interactivity, as in life, you learn to take the good with the bad. We do moderate our discussions at IC - we even hired a man whose job in large part is to do just that - but we cherish the value most of our readers add to the debate.

More importantly, we have learned that folks appreciate a little robust debate with the writers whose work they take the time to read. A perfect example: In a recent article in defense of animal rights, the author engaged his readers in a week-long debate about the merits of his argument - and the readers profusely pro·fuse  
adj.
1. Plentiful; copious.

2. Giving or given freely and abundantly; extravagant: were profuse in their compliments.
 lauded the author for listening to them even when he continued to question their logic.

So what can fellow NCEW members take from my experience? Simple: Learn to listen to your readers/viewers. Give them a voice rather than force-feeding them only those of your choosing.

Attach e-mail addresses to the end of every editorial and/or column you publish, both in print and on the Web. And for those editorialists who have the luxury of a Web page, broadcasters included, encourage debate by creating bulletin boards and "Pass it on" features for every opinion piece.

As several NCEW members noted in a November listserv thread on call-in and e-mail letters to the editor, your audience will appreciate the effort - and sometimes will reward you with insightful commentary. Your readers also will make you a better writer, both by noting your mistakes, sometimes with glee, and by directing you to information you might not have found otherwise.

Yes, you will have to moderate the discussion at times, but hey, that is what editors do.

Above all, remember the words of H.L. Mencken. They are a testament to a man who shaped the public opinion of his day and a reminder to those who would emulate him in this Information Age.

NCEW member K. Daniel Glover is associate editor of IntellectualCapital.com, a weekly opinion magazine published only on the Internet. He is also a freelance columnist. His e-mail address is Danny@a2s2.com
COPYRIGHT 1999 National Conference of Editorial Writers
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1999, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Glover, K. Daniel
Publication:The Masthead
Date:Mar 22, 1999
Words:866
Previous Article:Mea culpa: one size fits all.
Next Article:Online: make it short, make it sing.
Topics:



Related Articles
Age relations and the social order in early New England: the evidence from manners.
The question of regular mammograms. (National Institutes of Health and American Cancer Society offer conflicting views on value of mammograms for...
World population nears 6 billion.
Shiftwork a challenge for aging worker.
Affluent Call Preserving Wealth A Top Financial-Planning Goal.(Lincoln Financial Group study)(Brief Article)(Statistical Data Included)
A Guide for the Young Economist: Writing and Speaking Effectively about Economics.
KCET SPECIAL GEARED TOWARD OLDER DRIVERS.(L.A. LIFE)
OLDER JOB HUNTERS NEED FLEXIBLE SKILLS, PLENTY OF PATIENCE.(BUSINESS)(Statistical Data Included)
Weigelt, Udo Old Beaver.(Book Review)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles