Printer Friendly
The Free Library
18,914,768 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

NSTL Testing Shows Listeners Prefer Microsoft's Windows Media Technologies 4.0 Over RealNetworks' G2 and MP3.


MANHASSET, N.Y.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--April 13, 1999--

NSTL (National Software Testing Lab, Blue Bell, PA, www.nstl.com) An independent organization established in 1983 that evaluates computer hardware and software in the PC, mobile and gaming markets. It adheres to controlled testing methods to ensure objective results. , Inc. a CMP CMP (cytidine monophosphate): see cytosine.


(1) (CMP Media LLC, Manhasset, NY, www.cmp.com) Part of United Business Media, CMP is a leading integrated media company that offers a wide variety of publications and services in the information
 Media company, today announced results of a consumer study comparing the audio quality of Microsoft (Nasdaq: MSFT MSFT Microsoft (stock symbol)
MSFT Movimento Sociale Fiamma Tricolore (Italy)
MSFT Multi-Stage Fitness Test
MSFT Master of Science in Family Therapy
MSFT Macalester Students for Fair Trade
) Windows Media Technologies See Windows Media.  4.0 to RealNetworks (Nasdaq: RNWK RNWK Real Networks (stock symbol) ) RealSystem G2 and MP3. The test results show For More Information: that the 81% of listeners of sample audio clips found that the clips compressed with Windows Media Microsoft's audio and video framework for Windows, which embraces playback, encoding and streaming. Windows Media Player is the digital jukebox and media player that comes with every version of Windows.  sounded more like the original music than did the clips compressed with RealSystem G2. Steve Rubel Steve Rubel is a public relations executive and blogger. While with the firm CooperKatz & Co., he advised clients on using blogs in their business strategy and started his own blog, Micro Persuasion, in 2004.  And 71% of the listeners found the Windows Media clips were closer to the original or 516-562-7434 indistinguishable from MP3 clips of twice the size. The size differential is due to the fact srubel@cmp.com that the Windows Media test clips were encoded at a one half the data rate of the MP3 clips, resulting in files that are half the size and download in half the time. Barry Zusman CMP Media Inc.

"In this subjective test, consumers found the Windows Media clips sounded more like the Phone: 516-562-7040 "original" music clips than did RealNetworks' G2." said Thom DeRosa, NSTL's senior project Email: bzusman@cmp.com manager. "The download and play test yielded similar results with most users finding half size Windows Media files either closer to the original CD or indistinguishable from MP3."

Microsoft contracted NSTL to study the preferences of people using rock and classical sound clips. NSTL created a "blind" sample and asked each user which clip sounded most like the original music. NSTL tested preference of 77 people solicited from the general population.

Four multimedia systems were set up in an office-type environment. Each system was equipped with a Sound Blaster! Live audio card, and a Cambridge Soundworks, Inc. Microworks speaker system, including a sub-woofer. Audio players were installed with the default configuration and the volume was fixed at a reasonable level for the office environment. Test subjects listened to the original audio file and then listened to two comparison audio clips. They were then asked which of the two clips sounded more like the original. The original and the sample clips were played again if the test subject requested. The length of the audio clips was fixed at approximately ten seconds. The order in which the clips were played was varied to minimize bias in the listening order.

The sample audio clips were installed on the test system and streamed from the hard drive to avoid any issues associated with Internet traffic and to normalize normalize

to convert a set of data by, for example, converting them to logarithms or reciprocals so that their previous non-normal distribution is converted to a normal one.
 the test process.

The original audio clips were pcm wave files at 44.1 khz, 16-bit stereo, resulting in approximately 1,379 kilo-bits per second (Kbps).

The MP3 audio clips were encoded using 128 Kbps CBR (1) (Computer-Based Reference) Reference materials accessible by computer in order to help people do their jobs quicker. For example, this database on disk!

(2) (Constant Bit Rate) A uniform transmission rate.
 (constant bit rate) joint stereo encoder from MusicMatch Jukebox. The RealSystem G2 audio clips were encoded using RealNetworks 20 and 32 Kbps stereo music encoder. The Window Media clips were encoded using Microsoft's Windows Media Encoder Windows Media Encoder is a production tool developed by Microsoft which enables content developers to convert both live and prerecorded audio, video, and computer screen images to Windows Media formats for live and on-demand delivery.  4.0 using the MSAudio codec (1) (enCOder/DECoder) A hardware circuit that performs analog-to-digital conversion (ADC) and digital-to-analog (DAC) conversion. When analog signals are entered into a computer, cellphone or other device via a microphone or video source such as VHS tape or analog TV,  at 20 and 32 Kbps stereo music settings for the G2 comparison and 64 Kbps for the MP3 comparison.

More information about the NSTL test results are available at http://www.NSTL.com. NSTL, Inc. 625 Ridge Pike

About NSTL

NSTL, Inc. (http://www.NSTL.com) is a division of CMP Media and is the world's leading independent information technology testing organization. Established in 1983, NSTL was the first organization dedicated to testing the functionality, usability, and performance of personal computer hardware and software. NSTL is committed to providing accurate, objective, independent IT testing and consulting services for hardware and software manufacturers, corporations, and government agencies. Headquartered in suburban Philadelphia, NSTL has labs in Taiwan, Singapore, Japan, the U.K., Argentina, and Canada.

CMP Media Inc. (Nasdaq: CMPX CMPX Complex ) is a leading high-tech media company that provides essential information and marketing services to the entire technology spectrum--the builders, sellers and users of technology worldwide. With its portfolio of newspapers, magazines, custom publishing, Internet products, research, consulting and conferences, CMP is uniquely positioned to offer marketers comprehensive, integrated solutions tailored to meet their individual needs. Online editions of the company's print publications, along with products and services created exclusively for the Internet, can be found on CMPnet at http://www.CMPnet.com. NSTL, the company's independent testing lab and consulting organization, serves government, corporate and technology vendor clients around the world.
COPYRIGHT 1999 Business Wire
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1999, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Publication:Business Wire
Geographic Code:1USA
Date:Apr 14, 1999
Words:720
Previous Article:RadioWave.com is Enhanced by Microsoft Windows Media Technologies Version 4.0 Best Audio Online Provides Listeners with FM Quality Experience.
Next Article:SanDisk Products and New Microsoft Technology Provide Copy Protected Music for Internet Music Player Market.
Topics:



Related Articles
Digital Bitcasting's MPEG Upgrade Propels RealNetworks' RealSystem G2 into Broadband Media Streaming.
KILL BW1626-4/13, CMP-MEDIA and KILL BW1218, CQN-NY-CMP-MEDIA.
Online music all the rage at Internet World Conference.(major Los Angeles, CA, Internet industry event Spring Internet World '99)
Multi-Vendor Y2K Site: Too Little, Too Late?(Industry Trend or Event)
REALNETWORKS, WEBGLIDE TEAM UP TO MARKET PRODUCT THAT STREAMS HIGH- QUALITY 'CGV'.(Company Business and Marketing)
Yahoo! Extends Worldwide License Agreement With RealNetworks.(Company Business and Marketing)
NSTL TESTING OF WINDOWS 2000 'DISK DEFRAGMENTER' RELEASED IN SEVEN LANGUAGES AT PC EXPO.(Software Review)(Evaluation)
Report Claims Microsoft Seeks To Eliminate MP3.(Product Development)
REALNETWORKS LAUNCHES NEW SYSTEM.(RealONE to replace existing products, become content portal)(Brief Article)
DIGITAL L.A. : MICROSOFT BECOMES THE LATEST PLAYER IN WIDE-OPEN FIELD.(L.A. LIFE)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2010 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles