Printer Friendly
The Free Library
14,587,697 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

Movement analysis - an aid to early diagnosis of cerebral palsy.


The purpose of this article is to review research related to the use of clinical analysis of movement as an aid to the early diagnosis of cerebral palsy cerebral palsy (sərē`brəl pôl`zē), disability caused by brain damage before or during birth or in the first years, resulting in a loss of voluntary muscular control and coordination.  (CP). A historical perspective of clinical techniques used by physicians and physical therapists in the early diagnosis of CP will be presented first, including recent research findings on clinical signs predictive of this movement disorder List of Movement disorders
  • Akinesia (lack of movement)
  • Athetosis (contorted torsion or twisting)
  • Ataxia
  • Ballismus (violent involuntary rapid and irregular movements)
  • Hemiballismus (
. Future trends in the use of movement analysis as an aid to the detection of CP will be discussed as well.

Historical Perspective on Early Diagnosis of Cerebral Palsy

The most universally accepted definition of CP was provided by Bax in 1964: "A disorder of movement and posture due to a defect or lesion of the immature brain."(l(p295)) Bennett(2) has further defined CP as a nonprogressive disability resulting from damage or defect in the brain that occurs during the period of rapid brain growth-either prenatally, perinatally, or up to 3 to 5 years following birth. Classification of the different types of CP has been based historically on predominant neurological signs, including abnormalities in muscle tone and extrapyramidal extrapyramidal /ex·tra·py·ram·i·dal/ (-pi-ram´i-d'l) outside the pyramidal tracts; see under system.

ex·tra·py·ram·i·dal
adj.
 functions.(3) Barabas and Taft(3) have listed six different types of CP using this form of classification system: spastic spastic /spas·tic/ (spas´tik)
1. of the nature of or characterized by spasms.

2. hypertonic, so that the muscles are stiff and movements awkward.


spas·tic
adj.
1.
, choreathetoid, ataxic a·tax·ic or a·tac·tic
adj.
Of, relating to, or characterized by ataxia.
, dystonic, hypotonic/atonic, and mixed; spastic CP has been further classified by the limb involvement as either quadriplegia quadriplegia: see paraplegia. , hemiplegia hemiplegia /hemi·ple·gia/ (-ple´jah) paralysis of one side of the body.hemiple´gic

alternate hemiplegia  paralysis of one side of the face and the opposite side of the body.
, or diplegia diplegia /di·ple·gia/ (di-ple´jah) paralysis of like parts on either side of the body.diple´gic

di·ple·gia
n.
Paralysis of corresponding parts on both sides of the body.
. The value to physical therapists of such a medically oriented classification system has been questioned by Sahrmann, who has suggested that physical therapists themselves must

classify or categorize, by specific assessments,

the components of the

movement dysfunction that will provide

definitive guidelines for treatment

and for a prognosis.(4(P1705)) For example, physical therapists are beginning to use kinematic kin·e·mat·ics  
n. (used with a sing. verb)
The branch of mechanics that studies the motion of a body or a system of bodies without consideration given to its mass or the forces acting on it.
 data to quantitatively describe movement in children with CP with the goal of developing specific guidelines for treatment.(5)

Descriptive Literature on Early Diagnosis of Cerebral Palsy

Until the late 1970s, most of the literature on the early diagnosis of CP was based on clinical impressions of neurologists, pediatricians, and physical therapists who had acquired extensive experience in evaluating children with this developmental disorder developmental disorder Psychiatry An impairment in normal development of language, motor, cognitive and/or motor skills, generally recognized before age 18 which is expected to continue indefinitely and constitutes a substantial impairment Etiology Mental . Emphasis was placed on the assessment of muscle tone, absence or persistence of primitive or postural reflexes, attainment of righting reactions, and asymmetries in motor development.(6-9) muscle tone has been defined traditionally as resistance to passive elongation or stretch(10) in the assessment of infants at risk for CP, tone has been differentiated further as active tone or passive tone. As Wilson has noted,

Active tone is defined as the power

and adaptability of the muscles during

spontaneous movement, and passive

tone refers to resistance of the muscle

when movements are imposed by the

examiner.(11) The historical emphasis on primitive reflexes as diagnostic markers for early CP raises interesting questions about the role of infant reflexes in development. Oppenheim, in citing the work of McGraw,(12) Peiper, (13) and Touwen,(14) has commented that infantile or primary reflexes typically disappear within the first year or so of life. (15(p.87)) Easton, (16(p.591)) however, has suggested that reflexes "form the basic language of the motor program" and underlie most, if not all, volitional vo·li·tion  
n.
1. The act or an instance of making a conscious choice or decision.

2. A conscious choice or decision.

3. The power or faculty of choosing; the will.
 movements. In attempting to diagnose CP during infancy, child neurologists and developmental pediatricians have concerned themselves primarily with the persistence or exaggeration of primitive reflexes.(17)

Contradictory views on the prognostic importance of the various primitive reflexes among experts in the field of neuromotor assessment prompted the following comments from Scherzer, a leading developmental pediatrician:

The literature is replete with differing

views of the significance of early reflex

behaviors. For example, St.-Anne Dargassies

... places little importance on

the Galant reflex Galant reflex is a newborn reflex. It is elicited by holding the newborn in ventral suspension (face down) and stroking along the one side of the spine. The normal reaction is for the newborn to laterally flex toward the stimulated side. , but considers

crossed extension to be critical in maturation.

Taft . . stresses the predictive

significance only of the asymmetric

tonic neck and crossed extension reflexes.

Our own clinical experience of

predictability has led to the use of the

following reflexes: Moro, palmar grasp,

rooting, sucking, and asymmetric tonic

neck. The postural reflexes we emphasize

include neck and body righting,

parachute (protective extension), and

Landau. . . . Delineation of which reflex

behaviors have the most reliable predictive

value would be a major contribution,

worthy of extensive study by

any research group.(18(P126))

As Scherzer(18) noted in his concluding comment, it is only through systematic research efforts, both retrospective and prospective, that real clues to the early diagnosis of this disorder can be uncovered. Fortunately, databased studies conducted during the past two decades have begun to identify important clinical signs that can be used in the early identification of CP. Unfortunately, there has been little attempt to summarize or consolidate these findings in order to identify commonalities across these studies. As a result, those movement behaviors that are most predictive of CP are just beginning to be identified.(19) The goal of the following section is to provide a summary of those findings.

Research Findings on Early Diagnostic Signs of Cerebral Palsy

In a descriptive study of 1,743 term newborn infants, Amiel-Tison and colleagues(20) examined the importance of neck extensor extensor /ex·ten·sor/ (-ser) [L.]
1. causing extension.

2. a muscle that extends a joint.


ex·ten·sor
n.
A muscle that extends or straightens a limb or body part.
 hypertonia hypertonia /hy·per·to·nia/ (-to´ne-ah) a condition of excessive tone of the skeletal muscles; increased resistance of muscle to passive stretching.

hy·per·to·ni·a
n.
 as a clinical sign of insult to the central nervous system. This study was based on the clinical impressions of the authors that there was an association between increased neck extensor muscle tone and perinatal insult to the central nervous system.

Six procedures were used to examine active and passive tone of the neck. Initially, the infant's neck position was observed with the infant positioned supine in order to evaluate the presence of spontaneous hyperextension hy·per·ex·ten·sion
n.
Extension of a joint beyond its normal range of motion.



hyper·ex·tend
. The infant's head was passively flexed four times to determine whether there was increasing resistance to passive flexion flexion /flex·ion/ (flek´shun) the act of bending or the condition of being bent.

flex·ion
n.
1. The act of bending a joint or limb in the body by the action of flexors.

2.
. With the infant still lying supine, the examiner then attempted to provoke opisthotonus opisthotonus Neurology A type of spasm in which the head and heels arch backward in extreme hyperextension and the body forms a reverse bow; opisthotonus may be seen in scorpion stings, due to cholinergic hyperstimulation by venom  by lifting the infant slightly between the neck and scapulae. Active flexor flexor /flex·or/ (flek´ser)
1. causing flexion.

2. a muscle that flexes a joint.


flexor retina´culum  see entries under retinaculum.
 and extensor tone of the neck were assessed by pulling the infant into a sitting position from the supine position The supine position is a position of the body; lying down with the face up, as opposed to the prone position, which is face down.

Using terms defined in the anatomical position, the posterior is down and anterior is up.
 and by then pushing the infant smoothly back into a supine position. The examiners observed the infant's ability to cocontract flexor and extensor muscles Extensor muscles
A group of muscles in the forearm that serve to lift or extend the wrist and hand. Tennis elbow results from overuse and inflammation of the tendons that attach these muscles to the outside of the elbow.

Mentioned in: Tennis Elbow
. By rocking the infant backward and forward Adv. 1. backward and forward - moving from one place to another and back again; "he traveled back and forth between Los Angeles and New York"; "the treetops whipped to and fro in a frightening manner"; "the old man just sat on the porch and rocked back and forth all  in supported sitting, the examiner assessed the equality of tone" of the flexor and extensor muscles. Normal and abnormal reactions were described for each of the procedures; infants were considered to show neck extensor hypertonia if they demonstrated abnormalities in both active and passive tone.

There were 57 infants who showed neurologic abnormalities beyond the first 3 days of life. For example, disturbances such as tone or reflex disturbances, irritability, and seizures were noted. Of those 57 infants, 47% had neck extensor hypertonia. Of 31 infants with transient neurological signs (less than 3 days), 6% showed neck extensor hypertonia, whereas only 0.7% of the remaining 1,655 neurologically normal infants showed neck extensor hypertonia (for 1 day). The prognostic significance of neonatal extensor hypertonia among this sample of term infants was questionable because only 5 of the 43 infants followed to the age of 1 year showed persistent neurological abnormalities. The authors stressed the need, however, to conduct future studies with follow-up at least until school age. They also emphasized the danger of examining individual neurological signs in isolation.(20)

This was a descriptive study with limited prognostic value; however, it represents one of the earliest attempts to systematically document the presence of specific neurological signs by using a standardized assessment procedure. Later studies have corroborated cor·rob·o·rate  
tr.v. cor·rob·o·rat·ed, cor·rob·o·rat·ing, cor·rob·o·rates
To strengthen or support with other evidence; make more certain. See Synonyms at confirm.
 the importance of neck extensor hypertonia as an important diagnostic sign for the early identification of CP. In 1981, Ellenberg and Nelson(21) published the results of a retrospective
''For the KRS-One album, see A Retrospective (album)
Another European Lou Reed compilation. Track listing
  1. "I Can't Stand It"
  2. "Walk on the Wild Side"
  3. "Satellite of Love"
  4. "Vicious"
  5. "Caroline Says I"
  6. "Sweet Jane" [Live]
 study that examined the relative value of certain physical findings and behavioral responses of 4-month-old infants in predicting CP at early school age.

Because the study was part of the Collaborative Perinatal Project of the National Institute of Neurological and Communicative Disorders and Stroke, the sample consisted of approximately 32,300 infants who were examined at 4 months of age and then again at 7 years of age. Diagnoses of CP were made, as appropriate, at the examination at age 7 years. The predictive value pre·dic·tive value
n.
The likelihood that a positive test result indicates disease or that a negative test result excludes disease.



predictive value

a measure used by clinicians to interpret diagnostic test results.
 of physical and behavioral measurements at 4 months of age was analyzed by using corrected chi square chi square (kī),
n a nonparametric statistic used with discrete data in the form of frequency count (nominal data) or percentages or proportions that can be reduced to frequencies.
 statistics to demonstrate the incidence of children who showed each behavior versus children without the behavior. Predictive behaviors were examined for "low birth-weight" infants(=/<2,500 g) as well as for "term birth-weight" infants(=/>2,500 g). Relative risk was defined as

the number of times more frequently

CP occurred among children with a

given characteristic compared with

those without that characteristic.(21(p7O7))

Movement behaviors found at 4 months of age that were associated with an increased risk for CP among the low birth-weight infants in the sample included tremulous tremulous /trem·u·lous/ (-u-lus) pertaining to or characterized by tremors.

trem·u·lous
adj.
Characterized by tremor.
 or jittery patterns of movement. in the term birth-weight infants, writhing movements were associated with later CP. Asymmetrical movements were not predictive of CP in general or of hemiplegic hem·i·ple·gia  
n.
Paralysis affecting only one side of the body.



[Late Greek hmipl
 CP in either birth-weight group.

Specific developmental milestones Developmental milestones are tasks most children learn, or physical developments, that commonly appear in certain age ranges. For example:
  • Ability to lift and control the orientation of the head
  • Crawling begins
  • Walking begins
  • Speech begins
 were associated with an increased relative risk for CP. These developmental milestones included the infant's failure to maintain hands open "Hands Open" is the first American single from Snow Patrol's fourth album, Eyes Open.

It received substantial radio play on modern rock radio, peaking at #21 on the U.S. Billboard Modern Rock Tracks chart.
, to support weight on the forearms in the prone position Word history
The word prone, meaning "naturally inclined to something, apt, liable,", is recorded in English since 1382; the meaning "lying face-down" is first recorded in 1578 but is also referred to as "laying down" or "going prone".
, to hold the head erect in supported sitting, or to engage interest in her or his mirror image. These behaviors were associated with relative risks of 4, 12, 15, and 17, respectively. Muscle tone abnormalities at age 4 months were strongly related to later CP, with neck and trunk hypertonia being of even greater relative risk (74 and 71, respectively) than hypertonia in the limbs (55 in the arms and 52 in the legs). Hypertonia was associated consistently with greater relative risks than hypotonia hypotonia /hy·po·to·nia/ (-ton´e-ah) diminished tone of the skeletal muscles.

hy·po·to·ni·a
n.
1. Reduced tension or pressure, as of the intraocular fluid in the eyeball.

2.
, particularly in the low birth-weight infants.(21) The finding that neck extensor hypertonia at age 4 months was associated with a 74-fold increase in later CP supported the contention of Amiel-Tison and colleagues(2O) that this is an important diagnostic marker for central nervous system insult.

Because Nelson and Ellenberg(22) previously studied prognostic indicators of CP among newborn infants in this same sample, they concluded that neck extensor hypertonia at 4 months of age was an even greater cause for concern than neck extensor hypertonia during the neonatal period Noun 1. neonatal period - the first 28 days of life
time of life - a period of time during which a person is normally in a particular life state
. Whereas the presence of this sign was followed by later CP in 4% of the term birth-weight neonates but in none of the low birth-weight neonates, 15% of term 4-month-olds and 42% of low birth-weight 4-month-olds who demonstrated this sign received later diagnoses of CP.(21) This sign was absent in 99.9% of infants who did not develop later CP.

In 1983, Touwen and Hadders-Algra(23) published a prognostic study of the effects of neck and trunk hyperextension and shoulder retraction In the law of Defamation, a formal recanting of the libelous or slanderous material.

Retraction is not a defense to defamation, but under certain circumstances, it is admissible in Mitigation of Damages. Cross-references

Libel and Slander.
 in infancy on neurological outcome at 18 months of age. Their sample consisted of 105 infants, all of whom showed hyperextension of the neck and trunk with shoulder retraction at an initial examination conducted during the first few months postnatally and subsequently at home (according to according to
prep.
1. As stated or indicated by; on the authority of: according to historians.

2. In keeping with: according to instructions.

3.
 the mothers). Forty-two were fullterm infants, and 63 were preterm preterm /pre·term/ (-term´) before completion of the full term; said of pregnancy or of an infant.

pre·term
adj.
. The investigators assessed the infants two or three times during the first few months postnatally using Touwen's(24) Standardized neurological examination The neurological examination is the physical examination of the nervous system. It attempts to identify or exclude signs of nervous system disease, and - if these signs are present - to produce a likely anatomical or physiological explanation that can be tested through medical . Based on neurological findings from this examination, the infants were classified as

marked, when evident signs of hypertonia,

hypotonia, hemisyndrome or

deviant reactions and responses were

found; mild, when comparable signs

were present with, however, less intensity;

none, if no neurological devi - ations were found besides the target

symptoms.(23(p2O2))

The final follow-up visit in Touwen and Hadders-Algra's (23) study was conducted at approximately age 18 months or when the infant could walk independently. Of the 38 infants with no additional neurological signs, 37 were neurologically normal at the last follow-up visit, and 1 was classified as "suspect," which indicated the presence of "mild neurological signs, such as mild hypotonia or slight hypotonia.(23(p2O3)) For the 45 infants labeled initially as mild, 23 developed normally, 21 were deemed suspect, and 1 was severely impaired. Of the remaining 22 infants, who had been classified as marked during the early months postnatally, 20 were severely impaired and 2 were identified as suspect at the final follow-up visit. Based on these findings, the authors concluded:

Hyperextension and shoulder retraction

in neonatally neurologically normal

infants appeared to be without

much clinical significance, even when

some slight additional neurological

abnormality is present.(23(p2O4))

Nonetheless, the fact that 42.8% of infants identified initially because of this sign were subsequently labeled as either suspect or abnormal at about 18 months of age suggests that this sign is an important diagnostic predictor of neurological dysfunction, especially if found in combination with other neurological signs. The authors did not statistically analyze the relative risk for having this sign or any of the other neurological findings during the first few postnatal postnatal /post·na·tal/ (-na´t'l) occurring after birth, with reference to the newborn.

post·na·tal
adj.
Of or occurring after birth, especially in the period immediately after birth.
 months; thus, comparison of their results with those of Ellenberg and Nelson(2l) or with those of subsequent studies(25) is not really possible. Although most researchers agree that no single neurological sign is predictive of later CP, statistical analyses can at least measure the relative effectiveness of different signs, with the goal of improving prediction in subsequent prospective studies. The focus by Touwen and HaddersAlgra(23) on an isolated neurological sign provides limited prognostic information for the practicing clinician. In a retrospective study, Harris(25)statistically analyzed the predictive power The predictive power of a scientific theory refers to its ability to generate testable predictions. Theories with strong predictive power are highly valued, because the predictions can often encourage the falsification of the theory.  of selected items from the Movement Assessment of Infants (MAI MAI Mail (File Name Extension)
MAI Multilateral Agreement on Investment
MAI Maius (Latin: May)
MAI Ministerul Administratiei si Internelor (Romanian) 
)(26) in identifying CP in a sample of low birth-weight infants who were examined initially at 4 months' corrected age. The MAI is a 65-item neuromotor assessment tool developed by physical therapists to examine motor behaviors in four areas: muscle tone, primitive reflexes, automatic reactions, and volitional movement. Based on a 4-month-profile" developed by Chandler and colleagues,(26) 48 of the 65 items of the MAI can be scored as either "risk" or "no-risk." The 229 infants in this sample were followed until 3 to 8 years of age. A variety of standardized and nonstandardized tests were administered at the follow-up visits. Medical diagnoses of different types of CP were made for 36 of the children. Using chi-square tests, Harris analyzed the presence or absence of risk scores for each of the 48 risk items for the group of children with CP and a group who were deemed "normal," or nonhandicapped, at the final follow-up visit (n = 1 18). Data for a third group of children with developmental delay developmental delay
n.
A chronological delay in the appearance of normal developmental milestones achieved during infancy and early childhood, caused by organic, psychological, or environmental factors.
 were not analyzed at this time.(25) There were 32 NIAI items that discriminated between the group of children with CP and the nonhandicapped children. In addition, the group of children with CP was subdivided into three diagnostic categories: spastic diplegia spastic diplegia A feature of cerebral palsy, which affects both legs, often unequally, characterized by hip flexion and internal rotation, due to the overactivity of the iliopsoas, rectus femorus, hip adductors; knee extension, due to overactivity of hamstrings, , spastic hemiplegia spastic hemiplegia
n.
Hemiplegia accompanied by spasms of the muscles of the affected side.
, and quadriplegia. Each diagnostic category contained 7 items that were significantly different for the children with spastic diplegia and spastic hemiplegia versus the nonhandicapped group. For the subgroup with quadriplegia, many of whom were moderately to severely involved, 35 items were significant predictors. Similarities between Harris'S25 findings and those of the previous studies by Amiel-Tison et al,(20) Ellenberg and Nelson,(21) and Touwen and HaddersAlgra(23) will be highlighted in an effort to examine commonalities across the four studies.

Although the MAI does not have a specific item labeled as "neck hyperextension," the item that most closely measures this behavior is a primitive reflex item-tonic labyrinthine lab·y·rin·thine
adj.
Of, relating to, resembling, or constituting a labyrinth.



labyrinthine

pertaining to or emanating from a labyrinth.
 reflex in the supine position. Using procedures similar to those described by Amiel-Tison and colleagues(2O) and Touwen and Hadders-Algra,(23) this behavior is assessed through both visually observing the child's neck and shoulder girdle shoulder girdle
n.
The pectoral girdle, especially of a human.
 and passively moving the child's head, shoulders, and hips against gravity.(26) A risk score is attained if there is only "occasional arching of the neck and/or some retraction at the shoulder girdle.(26(p3l)) These criteria suggest a milder degree of neck hyperextension and shoulder retraction than was used to determine risk in the studies by Amiel-Tison and colleagues(2O) and Touwen and Hadders-Algra.(23) This MAI item was significantly discriminative dis·crim·i·na·tive  
adj.
1. Drawing distinctions.

2. Marked by or showing prejudice: discriminative hiring practices.
 of later CP, both in the CP group as a whole and in the quadriplegic quadriplegic /quad·ri·ple·gic/ (-ple´jik)
1. of, pertaining to, or characterized by quadriplegia.

2. an individual with quadriplegia.
 subgroup. Fifty-four percent of the children in the CP group and 90% of the children in the quadriplegic subgroup received a risk score for this item versus approximately 18% of the nonhandicapped group. Thus, all four studies reviewed suggest that this is an extremely important movement behavior to assess as an aid to the early diagnosis of CP (Table).

Another diagnostic predictor common to findings in the studies by Ellenberg and Nelson(2l) and Harris(25) was the infant's ability to support weight on the forearms. This behavior is measured in part by several different MAI items: the infant's antigravity an·ti·grav·i·ty  
n.
The hypothetical effect of reducing or canceling a gravitational field.



an
 muscle tone when placed in the prone position, the tonic labyrinthine reflex The tonic labyrinthine reflex (TLR) is a primitive reflex found in newborn humans. With this reflex, tilting the head back while lying on the back causes the back to stiffen and even arch backwards, causes the legs to straighten, stiffen, and push together, causes the toes  in the prone position, and active weight bearing through the shoulders in the prone position. The first two behaviors were significantly different for the CP group as a whole. The volitional movement item-active weight bearing through the shoulders-was scored as a risk behavior for 34.3% of the children who developed CP versus 12.8% of the children who were labeled nonhandicapped at the final follow-up visit. A child's inability to support weight on the forearms at 4 months of age had a relative risk of 12 in Ellenberg and Nelson's study; 4.8% of low birth-weight infants and 2.1% of term birth-weight infants who showed this sign had CP at the age of 7 years. The similarities in these findings across two studies conducted on 4-month-old infants suggest that the inability to assume and maintain a prone-on-elbows posture is an important diagnostic risk behavior (Table). One difference between the two studies, however, is that Harris assessed infants at 4 months' corrected age, whereas Ellenberg and Nelson used the infants' chronological age chron·o·log·i·cal age
n. Abbr. CA
The number of years a person has lived, used especially in psychometrics as a standard against which certain variables, such as behavior and intelligence, are measured.
. Another difference between the two studies concerns their respective samples. Harris's sample consisted primarily of premature infants; Ellenberg and Nelson's much larger sample consisted of both term and preterm infants.

A common finding across these two studies(2l,25) Was the lack of predictive significance of asymmetries (Table). Ellenberg and Nelson concluded:

Asymmetrical movements were not a

statistically significant predictor of CP

in general, nor of hemiparesis hemiparesis /hemi·pa·re·sis/ (-pah-re´sis) paresis affecting one side of the body.

hem·i·pa·re·sis
n.
Slight paralysis or weakness affecting one side of the body.
 in particular,

in either birthweight group or

in the total.(2l(p7O7)) The MAI provides for assessment of asymmetry in each of the four sections of the tool. Harris concluded:

For the overall CP group, asymmetry

was a predictive finding only in the

section on muscle tone p=0.021). For

the subgroups, asymmetry of tone was

predictive only for the quadriplegia

group. In the sections on automatic

reactions and volitional movement,

there were higher proportions of

asymmetry risk scores among the

group of children who were subsequently

non-handicapped than for the

CP group as a whole.(25(p5,6))

These findings suggest that asymmetries, except perhaps in the area of muscle tone, are normal movement behaviors at 4 months of age and probably earlier. Whether asymmetrical movement behaviors are predictive of CP at 5 or 6 months of age or even later remains open to study. The inability to sit with support with head erect was 15 times more common among infants who later developed CP than among infants with subsequent normal development in Ellenberg and Nelson's(21) study. The most analogous MAI item is a volitional movement item that assesses the child's ability to maintain a stable head position in supported or independent sitting. A risk score is attained if the infant's head bobs, even if there is "some ability to hold head upright.(26(p47)) Risk scores for this item were obtained by 33.3% of children in the CP group as a whole and by 60% of children in the quadriplegia subgroup versus 11.3% of the normally developing children, making this behavior a significant discriminator dis·crim·i·na·tor  
n.
1. One that discriminates.

2. Electronics A device that converts a property of an input signal, such as frequency or phase, into an amplitude variation, depending on how the signal differs from a
 of later CP. This dual finding suggests the importance of assessing head control in supported sitting as a diagnostic marker of later CP, at least for 4-month-old infants (Table). Common to both studies by Ellenberg and Nelson(2l) and Harris(25) was the importance of abnormal muscle tone as a predictor of CP. Whereas the earlier study by Ellenberg and Nelson demonstrated that hypertonia was a more ominous sign than hypotonia, the data analysis by Harris did not differentiate these two types of tone, despite the fact that the MAI does allow for scoring of both hypotonia and hypertonia. Whereas Ellenberg and Nelson's study showed that abnormal truncal truncal /trun·cal/ (trung´k'l) pertaining to the trunk.

trun·cal
adj.
1. Of or relating to the trunk of the body.

2. Of or relating to an arterial or nerve trunk.
 tone had a greater relative risk than abnormal tone of the extremities, Harris's study using the MAI demonstrated that risk scores for both behaviors occurred in a significantly higher proportion of children in the CP group than in the nonhandicapped group (42.9% versus 16.1% for trunk tone; 60% versus 26.5% for extremity tone).

Another somewhat contradictory finding between Ellenberg and Nelson's(21) study and Harris'S25 study was related to the presence of tremulousness. Whereas tremulousness in the low birth-weight children was associated with a sixfold sixfold
Adjective

1. having six times as many or as much

2. composed of six parts

Adverb

by six times as many or as much

Adj. 1.
 increase in the rate of CP by Ellenberg and Nelson, the MAI item measuring tremulousness did not significantly predict later handicap for the CP group as a whole or for any of the subgroups. Nonetheless, the proportion of children in the CP group who demonstrated a risk score on tremulousness was more than twice as great as the proportion of nonhandicapped children with a risk score in Harris's MAI study (17.1% versus 6.8%).

Neither Ellenberg and Nelson's(21) study nor Harris's(25) study demonstrated predictive significance of the positive support reflex among low birth-weight infants, except for the subgroup of children with quadriplegia in Harris's study. Clinical implications of Recent Research Findings Although it is difficult to draw perfect comparisons among studies that used different assessment tools and different samples of infants assessed at somewhat different ages, it is nonetheless helpful to try to assess similarities and differences among these studies with the aim of identifying movement behaviors that could be the most predictive of CP in both clinical and research settings. Attempts should also be made to behaviorally define these movements for consistency in visual analysis rather than to infer their underlying cause. An example is the MAI item "tonic labyrinthine reflex in supine." The movement behaviors that are actually being measured are neck hyperextension and shoulder retraction. Whether these deviant behaviors are caused by abnormal primitive reflex patterns, abnormal muscle tone, or a combination of these factors is of less concern to the physical therapy diagnostician than is a reliable means of assessing their presence or absence or their relative strength or frequency. The fact that the incidence of these behaviors ranged from 42% to 90% of the infants who later developed CP or other neurological handicap across the three prognostic studies(2l,23,25) suggests that assessment of these behaviors is extremely important. Other movement behaviors that appear to be of diagnostic value in the 4-month-old infant are the ability to bear weight on the forearms in the prone position and the ability to maintain a stable head position in supported or independent sitting.(21,25) Similar prognostic "milestone" behaviors need to be developed for other age levels based on prospective longitudinal studies longitudinal studies,
n.pl the epidemiologic studies that record data from a respresentative sample at repeated intervals over an extended span of time rather than at a single or limited number over a short period.
. The lack of predictive significance of asymmetrical movements at 4 months of age is another important commonality across the studies by Ellenberg and Nelson(2l) and Harris.25 Pediatric pediatric /pe·di·at·ric/ (pe?de-at´rik) pertaining to the health of children.

pe·di·at·ric
adj.
Of or relating to pediatrics.
 physical therapists traditionally have placed great import on the presence of asymmetrical movements; although such movements may be important in the older infant with early CP, they are probably of little prognostic significance in infants up to at least 4 months of age unless they are extreme and obviously interfere with normal movement patterns.

Muscle tone abnormalities also appear to be important predictors of CP in 4-month-old infants. It is probably more important to operationally define movement differences as seen in antigravity postures, for example, than to infer that these differences are due to underlying tone disorders. Of the six individual muscle tone items on the MAI, three are active tone items that involve a visual analysis of the infant's ability to move against gravity in the prone, supine, and prone suspension positions.(26) All three of these "tone" items were highly significant predictors of later CP. In contrast, of the three passive tone items-which involve handling and passive manipulation rather than visual analysis of movement patterns-only one extensibility) was as significant a predictor. These findings support MilaniComparetti's(27) clinical assertion that watching how the infant moves against gravity is of greater diagnostic value than trying to stimulate responses through passive manipulation or handling.

The ultimate goal of early diagnosis of CP is the provision of early therapeutic intervention, often in the form of developmentally based physical therapy or occupational therapy. Recent research(28) examining the relative efficacy of early physical therapy intervention, in the form of neurodevelopmental treatment NDT NDT Newfoundland Daylight Time ), as compared with a more global infant stimulation program, suggested that the latter approach effected more positive developmental motor outcomes than did the NDT approach. Criticism has been directed at this study because of apparent inequities between the two groups in terms of severity of neurological impairment and because of the researchers' use of outcome measures that were not sensitive to the goals of NDT.(29,30) Future efficacy research in CP should include outcome measures that are congruent with the aims of treatment. For example, Kluzik and colleagues(5) studied the effects of NDT on qualitative aspects of reaching in children with spastic quadriplegia via quantitative kinematic analysis of the "smoothness" of the reach. Earlier diagnosis of CP (ie, within the first postnatal year) will enhance our abilities to examine further the efficacy of early treatment. Although the study by Palmer and colleagues(2l), included infants with spastic diplegia, ranging in age initially from 12 to 19 months, no study has been published attempting to examine the effectiveness of early physical therapy intervention for infants with CP who are less than 1 year of age. Future Trends in Movement Analysis for the Early Diagnosis of Cerebral Palsy As we expand our role to become diagnosticians, we must rely increasingly on reliable and standardized techniques for assessing movement differences as an aid to diagnosis. Assessment tools such as the NLAA NLAA Norwegian Lundehund Association of America
NLAA Nothing Left At All (Cranberries song)
NLAA National Legal Aid Association
 have been shown to be both reliable and valid in the assessment of high-risk infants,(31-33) but additional research is needed to increase the sensitivity and specificity of such tools in the early diagnosis of CP.

The traditional medical emphasis on the passive assessment of muscle tone and primitive reflexes must be replaced by a new focus on systematic analysis of movement differences through visual observation, videotapes, and kinematic recordings. The assessment of primitive reflexes has perhaps been overemphasized to the exclusion of more important and more functional movement behaviors such as early motor patterns required for feeding, visual tracking, eye-hand coordination, and parent-infant interaction. Research(3l,33) on the reliability and predictive validity In psychometrics, predictive validity is the extent to which a scale predicts scores on some criterion measure.

For example, the validity of a cognitive test for job performance is the correlation between test scores and, for example, supervisor performance ratings.
 of the MAI has shown that primitive reflexes, as a group, "are the least reliable and valid predictors of later motor handicap.(33(p339)) Through movement analysis of videotapes of neurologically normal and high-risk infants, physical therapists could begin to operationally define movement differences between these two groups. Longitudinal follow-up of such infants could assist in determining which movement behaviors were most predictive of later neurological handicap. Attempts must be made to quantify the frequency and variety of movement patterns through standardized observational protocols. Exciting progress is being made in the area of kinematic analysis of infant movements by physical therapist researchers using digitized data from videotapes to examine organization of infant movements(34,35) and possible differences in movement between preterm and full-term infants.(36) Longitudinal follow-up of the developmental outcome of these infants would allow for evaluation of the prognostic significance of movement differences. Another exciting avenue for future research is the diagnosis of movement differences in utero in utero (in u´ter-o) [L.] within the uterus.

in u·ter·o
adj.
In the uterus.



in utero adv.
 through the use of fetal ultrasound. MilaniComparetti(37) has proposed that perinatally acquired CP could perhaps be prevented or minimized by obstetrical obstetrical, obstetric

pertaining to or emanating from obstetrics.


obstetrical anesthesia
an anesthetic procedure designed especially for patients undergoing cesarean operation or intrauterine manipulation of the fetus.
 modifications for infants identified in utero as having impaired movements. As physical therapists become increasingly involved in fetal analysis of movement differences,38 it iS hoped that we can assist in prenatal diagnosis Prenatal diagnosis
The determination of whether a fetus possesses a disease or disorder while it is still in the womb.

Mentioned in: Wiskott-Aldrich Syndrome

prenatal diagnosis 
 of CP. As specialists in movement analysis, physical therapists must continue to conduct research that will aid in the diagnosis and treatment planning In radiotherapy, Treatment Planning is the process in which a team consisting of radiation oncologists, medical radiation physicists and dosimetrists plan the appropriate external beam radiotherapy treatment technique for a patient with cancer. Typically, medical imaging (i.e.  for movement disorders Movement Disorders Definition

Movement disorders are a group of diseases and syndromes affecting the ability to produce and control movement.
Description
 such as CP. As Rose concluded in his description of the roles and functions of physical therapy diagnosis, "Excellence in practice, now and in the future, requires physical therapists to be skillful skill·ful  
adj.
1. Possessing or exercising skill; expert. See Synonyms at proficient.

2. Characterized by, exhibiting, or requiring skill.
 diagnosticians.(39(P537)) It is hoped that this review of recent research on diagnostic movement predictors of CP will assist physical therapists in their ability to identify children with CP and physical therapist researchers in developing hypotheses for prospective studies aimed at further defining and classifying this important movement disorder during early infancy. References 1 Box MCO MCO Managed care organization, see there . Terminology and classification of cerebral palsy. Dev Med Child Neurol. 1964;6:295-297. 2 Bennett FC. Cerebral palsy: the how and why of early diagnosis. Consultant. 1984;24:151-173. 3 Barabas G, Taft LT. The early signs and differential diagnosis differential diagnosis
n.
Determination of which one of two or more diseases with similar symptoms is the one from which the patient is suffering. Also called differentiation.
 of cerebral palsy. Pediatr Ann. 1986;15:203-214. 4 Sahrmann SA. Diagnosis by the physical therapist-a prerequisite for treatment: a special communication. Phys Ther. 1988;68: 1703-1706. 5 Kluzik JA, Fetters fet·ter  
n.
1. A chain or shackle for the ankles or feet.

2. Something that serves to restrict; a restraint.

tr.v. fet·tered, fet·ter·ing, fet·ters
1. To put fetters on; shackle.
 L, Coryell J. Quantification of control: a preliminary study of effects of neurodevelopmental treatment on reaching in children with cerebral palsy. Phys Ther. 1990;70:65-76. 6 Paine RS. The early diagnosis of cerebral palsy. RI Medf 1961;44:522-527. 7 Illingworth RS. The diagnosis of cerebral palsy in the first year of life. Dev Med Child Neurol 1966;8:178-194. 8 Milani-Comparetti A, Gidoni EA. Routine developmental examination in normal and retarded children. Dev Med Child Neurol 1967;9:631-636. 9 Bobath B, Bobath K. Motor Development in the Different Types of Cerebral Palsy. London, England: William Heinemann William Heinemann (18 May 1863 – 5 October 1920) was the founder of the Heinemann publishing house in London.

He was born in 1863, in Surbiton, Surrey. In his early life he wanted to be a musician, either as a performer or a composer, but, realising that he lacked the
 Medical Books Ltd; 1975:2-19. 10 Dorland's Illustrated Medical Dictionary. 27th ed. Philadelphia, Pa: WB Saunders Co; 1988. 11 Wilson JM. Cerebral palsy. In: Campbell SK, ed. Pediatric Neurologic Physical Therapy. New York New York, state, United States
New York, Middle Atlantic state of the United States. It is bordered by Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and the Atlantic Ocean (E), New Jersey and Pennsylvania (S), Lakes Erie and Ontario and the Canadian province of
, NY: Churchill Livingstone Inc; 1985:353-408. 12 McGraw MB. Cited by: Oppenheim RW. Ontogenic on·tog·e·ny  
n. pl. on·tog·e·nies
The origin and development of an individual organism from embryo to adult. Also called ontogenesis.



on
 adaptations and retrogressive ret·ro·gress  
intr.v. ret·ro·gressed, ret·ro·gress·ing, ret·ro·gress·es
1. To return to an earlier, inferior, or less complex condition.

2. To go or move backward.
 processes in the development of the nervous system and behaviour: a neuroembryological perspective. In: Connolly Kj, Prechtl HFR HFR Hedge Fund Research, Inc.
HFR High Flux Reactor
HFR Hedge Fund Returns (mergers/arbitrages)
HFR Huge Fast Router (Cisco)
HFR Hold for Release
HFR Hybrid Fiber Radio
HFR High Force Research
, eds. Maturation and Development: Biological and Psychological Perspectives. Philadelphia, Pa: JB Lippincott Co; 1981:73-109. 13 Peiper A. Cited by: Oppenheim RW. Ontogenic adaptations and retrogressive processes in the development of the nervous system and behaviour: a neuroembryological perspective. In: Connolly Kj, Prechtl HFR, eds. Maturation and Development.. Biological and Psychological Perspectives. Philadelphia, Pa: JB Lippincott Co; 1981:73-109. 14 Touwen BCL BCL - The successor to Atlas Commercial Language.

["The Provisional BCL Manual", D. Hendry, U London 1966].
. Cited by: Oppenheim RW. Ontogenic adaptations and retrogressive processes in the development of the nervous system and behaviour: a neuroembryological perspective. In: Connolly KJ, Prechtl HFR, eds. Maturation and Development: Biological and Psychological Perspectives. Philadelphia, Pa: JB Lippincott Co; 1981:73-109. 15 Oppenheim RW. Ontogenetic on·to·ge·net·ic
adj.
Of or relating to ontogeny.
 adaptations and retrogressive processes in the development of the nervous system and behaviour: a neuroembryological perspective. In: Connolly Kj, Prechti HFR, eds. Maturation and Development, Biological and Psychological Perspectives. Philadelphia, Pa: JB Lippincott Co; 1981:73-109. 16 Easton TA. On the normal use of reflexes. American Scientist. 1972;60:591-599. 17 Capute Aj. Early neuromotor reflexes in infancy. Pediatr Ann. 1986; 15:217-226. 18 Scherzer AL. Primitive reflex profile. Dev Med Child Neurol. 1985;27:126-127. Letters to the Editor. 19 Harris SR. Early identification of cerebral palsy. In: Gottlieb M, Williams J, eds. Developmental-Behavioral Disorders Selected Topics vol 4). New York, NY: Plenum Publishing Corp. In press. 20 Amiel-Tison C, Korobkin R, Esquevaucouloux M. Neck extensor hypertonia: a clinical sign of insult to the central nervous system of the newborn. Early Hum Dev. 1977;1/2: 188-190. 21 Ellenberg JH, Nelson KB. Early recognition of infants at high risk for cerebral palsy: examination at age four months. Dev Med Child Neurol 1981;23:705-716. 22 Nelson KB, Ellenberg JH. Neonatal signs as predictors of cerebral palsy. Pediatrics. 1979;64:225-232. 23 Touwen BCL, Hadders-Algra M. Hyperextension of neck and trunk and shoulder retraction in infancy: a prognostic study. Neuropediatrics. 1983;14:202-205. 24 Touwen BCL. Neurological Development in Infancy. Philadelphia, Pa: JB Lippincott Co; 1976. 25 Harris SR. Early neuromotor predictors of cerebral palsy in low-birthweight infants. Dev Med Child Neurol. 1987;29:508-519. 26 Chandler LS, Andrews MS, Swanson MW. The Movement Assessment of Infants: A Manual Rolling Bay, Wash: Chandler, Andrews, & Swanson; 1980:1-53, 27 Milani-Comparetti AM. Developmental diagnosis. Read at the 10th Annual Sensorimotor sensorimotor /sen·so·ri·mo·tor/ (sen?sor-e-mo´ter) both sensory and motor.

sen·so·ri·mo·tor
adj.
Of, relating to, or combining the functions of the sensory and motor activities.
 Integration Symposium; july 9-11, 1982; San Diego, Calif 28 Palmer FB, Shapiro BK, Wachtel RC, et al. The effects of physical therapy on cerebral palsy: a controlled trial controlled trial Clinical research A clinical study in which one group of participants receives an experimental drug while the other receives either a placebo or an approved–'gold standard' therapy. See Blinding, Double-blinded.  in infants with spastic diplegia. N Engl J Med. 1988;318:803-808. 29 Mettler JL. Commentary. Physical & Occupational Therapy in Pediatrics 1989;9(2):5-7. 30 Harris SR. Commentary on "The effects of physical therapy on cerebral palsy: a controlled trial in infants with spastic diplegia." Physical & Occupational Therapy in Pediatrics. 1989;9(3):1-4. 31 Harris SR, Haley SM, Tada WL, Swanson MW. Reliability of observational measures of the Movement Assessment of infants. Phys Ther 1984;64:471-475. 32 Haley SM, Harris SR, Tada WI, Swanson MW. Item reliability of the Movement Assessment of Infants. Physical & Occupational Therapy in Pediatrics. 1986;6(l):21-39. 33 Harris SR, Swanson MW, Andrews MS, et al. Predictive validity of the Movement Assessment of Infants. j Dev Behav Pediatr. 1984;5:336-342. 34 Heriza CB. Organization of leg movements in preterm infants. Phys Ther. 1988;68: 1340-1346. 35 Gross MT, Cochrane CG. A method for quantifying the activity and rest periods of spontaneous kicking. Physical & Occupational Therapy in Pediatrics. 1988;3(2):59-70. 36 Heriza CB. Comparison of leg movements in preterm infants at term with healthy fullterm infants. Phys Ther. 1988;68:1687-1693. 37 Milani-Comparetti A. The neurophysiologic and clinical implications of studies on fetal motor behavior. Semin Perinatol 1981;5: 183-189. 38 Sparling spar·ling  
n.
1. The common European smelt (Osperus eperlanus).

2. A young or immature herring.



[Middle English sperlinge, from Old French esperlinge,
 JW. A Study of the Use of Prenatal Ultrasound and Its Relationship to Parental Adaptation and Infant Behavior. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill is a public, coeducational, research university located in Chapel Hill, North Carolina, United States. Also known as The University of North Carolina, Carolina, North Carolina, or simply UNC ; 1987. Doctoral dissertation. 39 Rose SJ. Physical therapy diagnosis: role and function. Phys Ther. 1989;69:535-537.
COPYRIGHT 1991 American Physical Therapy Association, Inc.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1991, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:a review of cerebral palsy diagnostic procedures
Author:Harris, Susan R.
Publication:Physical Therapy
Date:Mar 1, 1991
Words:5700
Previous Article:Chronic pain - assessment of orthopedic physical therapists' knowledge and attitudes.
Next Article:Implications of a dynamical systems approach to understanding infant kicking behavior.
Topics:



Related Articles
Issues in measuring change in motor function in children with cerebral palsy: a special communication.
Measurement and treatment in cerebral palsy: an argument for a new approach.
Dorsal rhizotomy for children with cerebral palsy: support for concepts of motor control.
Measuring quality of movement in cerebral palsy: a review of instruments.
Lower-extremity surgery for children with cerebral palsy: physical therapy management. (Pediatric Orthopedics Series: Part 2)
Motor behavior and neural changes following perinatal and adult-onset brain damage: implications for therapeutic interventions.
Community adapted aquatics programming: need and necessity. (aquatic programs for disabled children)(includes glossary)
Effects of a Functional Therapy Program on Motor Abilities of Children With Cerebral Palsy.(Statistical Data Included)
Dynamic resources used in ambulation by children with spastic hemiplegic cerebral palsy: relationship to kinematics, energetics, and...
Performance of physical activities by adolescents with cerebral palsy.(Research Report)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles