Printer Friendly
The Free Library
14,650,879 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

Memo to the U.S. Congress: thou shalt not bear false history.


While many members of Congress decry de·cry  
tr.v. de·cried, de·cry·ing, de·cries
1. To condemn openly.

2. To depreciate (currency, for example) by official proclamation or by rumor.
 the lack of historical knowledge among our youth, the evidence is overwhelming that there is a fundamental ignorance of American history in the Congress itself.

The most recent evidence of that fact came to national attention last March when U.S. House members rallied to the side of Judge Roy Moore For the baseball player, see .
Roy Moore is a controversial American jurist and politician noted for his refusal, as the elected Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Alabama, to remove a monument of the Ten Commandments from the courthouse despite orders from a federal court
, an Alabama judge who was ordered on church-state grounds to remove a plaque of the Ten Commandments Ten Commandments or Decalogue [Gr.,=ten words], in the Bible, the summary of divine law given by God to Moses on Mt. Sinai. They have a paramount place in the ethical system in Judaism, Christianity, and Islam.  from his courtroom wall. The congressional defense was translated into House Concurrent Resolution An action of Congress passed in the form of an enactment of one house, with the other house in agreement, which expresses the ideas of Congress on a particular subject.  31, a non-binding measure that praised Moore and insisted: "The public display, including display in government offices and courthouses, of the Ten Commandments should be permitted."

The proponents of H.Con.Res. 31 included Rep. Joe Scarborough For the artist of the same, see Joe Scarborough (artist)
Charles Joseph "Joe" Scarborough (born April 9 1963) is the host of the program Morning Joe and former host of Scarborough Country
 (R-Fla.), who took to the House floor to contend that foes of Judge Moore's Ten Commandments display were wrong in saying they wished only to protect the Constitution., Scarborough argued this was true because, "The father of the Constitution, James Madison, stated while he was drafting the Constitution: `We have staked the entire future of the American civilization not upon the power of government, but upon the capacity of the individual to govern himself, to control himself and sustain himself according to according to
prep.
1. As stated or indicated by; on the authority of: according to historians.

2. In keeping with: according to instructions.

3.
 the Ten Commandments of God.'"

That alleged Madison quotation has been cited frequently over the past 50 years, but never with a primary source. There's a reason for that: It is proper to state that Madison cannot be found to have said anything even vaguely similar to the words attributed to him.

David Mattern, an editor of the Madison Papers, in 1993 commented on the so-called Madison "quote." "We did not find anything in our files," he concluded, "remotely like the sentiment expressed in the extract you sent us. In addition, the idea is inconsistent with everything we know about Madison's views on religion and government, views he expressed time and again in public and in private."

Scarborough moved from his bogus Madison material to George Washington. The Florida Republican claimed the father of our country had stood up at his Farewell Address and said, "It is impossible to govern rightly without God and the Ten Commandments."

As a minor note, Washington did not deliver his address standing up, but rather sent it to a newspaper for publication. Further, Washington did not write the words Scarborough cited in his Farewell. Equally interesting, the editors of the George Washington Papers inform me that a computer check of the entire corpus of the first President's writing reveal not a single reference to the Ten Commandments.

To make matters worse Scarborough, having disseminated two completely false statements, had the audacity to say that Thomas Jefferson agreed with the two comments that were never uttered.

Rep. Robert Aderholt Robert Aderholt (born July 22 1965) is an American politician and a Republican member of the United States House of Representatives since 1997, representing Alabama's At-large congressional district (map).  (R-Ala.) took the floor to argue that religious liberty pioneer Roger Williams intended "to protect the church, not the State." This is patently false and misses the entire thrust of the Williams experiment in freedom of conscience that brought to colonial Rhode Island Rhode Island, island, United States
Rhode Island, island, 15 mi (24 km) long and 5 mi (8 km) wide, S R.I., at the entrance to Narragansett Bay. It is the largest island in the state, with steep cliffs and excellent beaches.
 atheists, Jews, agnostics and all manner of dissenting Christians. He was banished from Massachusetts where the church was protected by the state.

Rep. Bob Riley

For other people named Bob Riley, see Bob Riley (disambiguation).
Robert Renfroe "Bob" Riley (born October 3, 1944) is an American politician in the Republican Party.
 (R-Ala) returned to the fabricated fab·ri·cate  
tr.v. fab·ri·cat·ed, fab·ri·cat·ing, fab·ri·cates
1. To make; create.

2. To construct by combining or assembling diverse, typically standardized parts:
 statement attributed to Madison and followed with yet another alleged quote, this time from Jefferson. According to Riley, Jefferson said. "...[T]he Bill of Rights are built on the foundations of ethics and morality found in the Ten Commandments." The editors of the Jefferson Papers at Princeton assured me they found no evidence that the Sage of Monticello ever said any such thing.

When the pro-Moore members of Congress concluded their time at the microphone they had referred to Thomas Jefferson five times, James Madison four times, George Washington twice and John Adams once. Of those 12 references, 1 0 are completely false. Of the remaining two, one is a garbled misquote mis·quote  
tr.v. mis·quot·ed, mis·quot·ing, mis·quotes
To quote incorrectly.



mis
 from Jefferson's Notes on the State of Virginia, Query XVII; the other, a reference to John Adams that seems genuine. Finally, neither of the two quotes that have some degree of verifiability mention the Ten Commandments.

Relying almost exclusively on these egregious e·gre·gious  
adj.
Conspicuously bad or offensive. See Synonyms at flagrant.



[From Latin
 historical distortions, Republicans in Congress castigated their opponents as supporters of moral corruption. Rep. Scarborough, the most historically ill-informed of the lot, offered -- with his voice in high-pitched piety -- arguably ar·gu·a·ble  
adj.
1. Open to argument: an arguable question, still unresolved.

2. That can be argued plausibly; defensible in argument: three arguable points of law.
 the most ridiculous sentence in the debate. Citing the Madison and Washington quotes, he said, "Now, if the revisionists do not like that, that is fine, but please, do not insult Americans' intelligence, please do not try to do a verbal burning of our American history books."

Regrettably, the House passed H.Con.Res. 31 by a whopping 295-125 margin. And many among that majority on March 5 had come to office decrying the sad state of public education. How would they know?
COPYRIGHT 1997 Americans United for Separation of Church and State
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1997, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Alley, Robert, s.
Publication:Church & State
Date:Jun 1, 1997
Words:800
Previous Article:Istook amendment revised to mollify religious groups, introduced in House.
Next Article:From the west coast to the Big Apple: the AU road show.
Topics:



Related Articles
The Immorality of the Ten Commandments.
I Am Zipporah.(commandments for women)(Brief Article)
The 10 Commandments And Public Schools: Shall We Post The Penalties Too?(Brief Article)
The ten commandments of writing.
A Flightless Bird His Secretary Hopes Will Fly the Coop.
HOUSE EASES GUN LAW; 10 COMMANDMENTS OK'D IN SCHOOL.(News)
Ten requests for Father's Day.
'Moses moments' inspire entrants.(World)
Thou shalt not worship false pop idols.(catholic tastes)(www.shipoffools.com)(Brief Article)
"The Ten Commandments": Deutsches Hygiene-Museum.(DRESDEN)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles