Medical coverage of high school athletics in North Carolina.
Methods: A questionnaire, mailed to all athletic directors at public and private North Carolina high school members of the North Carolina High School Athletic Association, was used to assess medical coverage.
Results: Only 56% of the schools had coverage by either nationally or state certified athletic trainers. Although 71% of schools had physician coverage at some athletic events, less than 10% of physician coverage included monitoring of athletic practices. Only 27% of the schools surveyed felt that their existing medical coverage of athletic events could be considered adequate.
Conclusions: These preliminary findings suggest that medical coverage of high school athletics in North Carolina, as in other states, is lacking and inconsistent.
Key Words: high school athletics, competitive sports, sports medicine, medical coverage
Recent epidemiologic data indicates that 55.1% of American high school students participated on at least one sports team. (1) In addition, of those children surveyed, 37.7% reported seeking medical treatment as a result of their activities. (1) Existing data is limited but shows that the quality of medical care for high school athletics is frequently inadequate, (2-4) with larger schools receiving better coverage than smaller schools. (5) Furthermore, the majority of existing data on medical coverage of high school athletics focuses on football, with very little mention of women's sports or other popular men's sports, such as soccer. Finally, few guidelines exist which outline recommendations for medical coverage of high school athletic events, and little is known about compliance of schools with existing medical recommendations. The difficult task of injury evaluation and the decision to return the athlete to competition may significantly impact the athlete if done poorly. Inexperienced and or unqualified providers might put the athlete at risk for a negative outcome, such as re-injury. The external pressure from fans, coaches and parents make this task more difficult. Despite this caveat, having medical care present to care for serious injuries would be a desirable state as opposed to having no qualified provider present.
The primary purpose of this study was to quantitatively assess the quality and extent of on site, or sideline, medical coverage in high school athletics. A secondary aim was to explore any differences in coverage among men and women's sports. A tertiary aim was to identify any relationships between quality of coverage and high school size.
A letter with an enclosed survey was sent to the athletic director of every public and private high school in North Carolina (n = 343). The letter described the purpose of the study and gave brief instructions for completing the attached survey. The athletic directors were instructed to return the survey via the provided stamped, self-addressed envelope. The survey assessed demographic data, including sports division, number of students, and the size of surrounding community. The survey was designed to collect information regarding 1) extent of medical coverage for individual athletic games and practices; 2) qualifications of those personnel providing medical coverage; and 3) financial compensation to medical personnel. A copy of the survey is provided in appendix A. In addition, athletic directors were asked to comment on their perceived adequacy of the medical coverage and also to report coverage separately for football, men's sports other than football, and women's sports.
Descriptive statistics, including measures of central tendency, dispersion, and skewness were computed for school size. A square root transformation was performed on the variable representing number of students because it was found to be not normally distributed. Spearman rank order correlations were used to examine the relationship between school size and coverage of athletic events by sports medicine personnel.
The response rate for the survey was 40%, with 139 of the high schools returning completed, interpretable surveys. The average size of the high schools was 1,132 students ([+ or -] 613.74). Characteristics of the participating high schools are provided in Table 1. Seventy-one percent of the surveys were completed by the school's athletic director, 1% were completed by the assistant athletic director, 6% by a coach, 21% by an athletic trainer, and 2% by another unspecified individual.
Coverage of Athletic Events by Athletic Trainers
Forty-eight percent (n = 65) of schools did not report access to a nationally certified athletic trainer, and only 20% (n = 29) of schools had a state certified athletic trainer. More than half (59%, n = 81) of the schools involved student trainers in the care of their athletes.
Coverage of Athletic Events by Physicians
Seventy-eight percent (n = 109) of schools reported having physician coverage at some athletic events. Of those schools reporting some physician coverage, 52% (n = 72) had orthopaedic coverage and 35% (n = 49) had coverage by a primary care physician (Table 2).
Other Medical Coverage
Twenty-six percent (n = 36) of the schools reported that they did not have ambulance coverage of football games. Close to half of the schools relied on ambulances to volunteer their services (n = 55, 42%). In addition, 14% (n = 19) of schools reported coverage by chiropractors. Many schools (51%, n = 72) relied on coverage by nonlicensed, noncertified sports medicine personnel.
The majority of schools (78%, n = 108) reported physician coverage of football games, with only a few reporting physician coverage of men's sports other than football (13%, n = 18) and women' sports (12%, n = 16). There was a strong correlation between physician coverage of men's sports other than football and women's sports (r = 0.935, P < 0.001). More schools reported having men's coaches certified in CPR than women's coaches (71% v. 59%, respectively). The reverse was true for first aid, with 71% of women's coaches certified and 63% of men's coaches certified.
Size of School Relationships
There was a significant relationship between school size and presence of a nationally certified athletic trainer (r = -0.292, P = 0.001). No such relationship existed for state certified athletic trainers or student trainers. There was a significant correlation between school size and coverage of athletic events by physicians (r = 0.391, P < 0.001). In addition, there was a significant correlation between school size and coverage of athletic events by an orthopaedic surgeon (r = 0.428, P < 0.001). No significant relationship existed between school size and coverage by primary care providers or chiropractors, although there was a trend for coverage by primary care doctors and chiropractors at small schools. There was no relationship between size of school and certification of coaches in first aid or CPR. Finally, there was no relationship between school size and coverage by nonlicensed, noncertified personnel.
Perception of Coverage
The person completing the questionnaire was asked if they felt their school's medical coverage of athletics was adequate. Answers were nearly equally distributed; with 49% (n = 67) reporting inadequate coverage and 51% (n = 70) reporting at least adequate coverage. A few schools did not answer this question (n = 3). Stepwise multiple regression analysis was performed to determine the significant independent predictors of perception of medical coverage of athletics. Presence of a nationally certified athletic trainer was the only significant independent predictor of perception of adequate medical coverage (r = 0.274, P = 0.006), while controlling for school size, presence of a physician, and person completing the survey. In addition, there was a significant trend for schools with orthopaedic surgeons covering events to report medical coverage as inadequate (r = -0.189, P = 0.028).
These findings represent the first known study of medical coverage of high school athletic events in the state of North Carolina. This study contains data from 139 high schools with a total student population of 229,466. In this study, only half (52%, n = 71) of schools had a nationally certified athletic trainer. In addition, 51% (n = 72) of schools relied on noncertified, nonlicensed sports medicine personnel. This is disconcerting due to the nationwide initiative to have licensed, certified personnel in all high schools. In this study, approximately half of the athletes were cared for by nonlicensed, noncertified sports medicine personnel, which may increase their risk of receiving improper care, as it is estimated that as many as one-third of high school athletes will become injured and lose time in their sport in any given season. (6) The lack of qualified caregivers is especially alarming given the recent increase in catastrophic sports-related injuries. (7) Recent media and position statements by The National Athletic Trainers' Association (NATA) (8) and the American Academy of Family Practice (AAFP) (9) have highlighted the need for licensed, certified sports medicine personnel, particularly athletic trainers. This notion is reinforced by the fact that in this study, schools with nationally certified athletic trainers reported adequate medical coverage significantly more than schools without.
Approximately half of the schools relied on student trainers to augment coverage of athletic teams, and student training programs were not limited to large schools. This is a positive finding, as student trainers can help reduce the workload of staff trainers. While not licensed or qualified to provide medical coverage independently, student trainers can operate under the supervision of a licensed athletic trainer and perform such tasks as icing injuries after games or practice, assisting athletes with rehabilitative exercises, and general training room maintenance. In addition, by incorporating a student training program, young people will be exposed to the field of sports medicine as a possible career choice.
Although physician involvement was more widespread than the researchers expected, it was still mainly limited to larger high schools. Even at high schools with physician coverage, that coverage was usually provided solely to football (65%, n = 91). In addition, very few physicians in training were providing medical coverage. Given the large number of medical schools (n = 4) and primary care residency programs (n = 14) in North Carolina, only 3% (n = 5) of the high schools reported coverage by a medical student or resident physician. Several programs in other states, such as the LOCUS program in Wisconsin, encourage medical students to become involved in youth sports. (10) It appears from this survey, however, that residents are not actively providing coverage for local high school sports in North Carolina. The utilization of this resource would provide additional immediate coverage for some high schools, and expand the amount of coverage in the future by encouraging these physicians to continue their involvement with local high school athletics as they go into practice. Encouraging physicians to volunteer for the medical coverage of events of a high school helps to further strengthen the bond between the community and the medical providers and does not increase the financial cost to the school.
The largest disparity in coverage was not between men's and women's sports, but between football and all other sports, regardless of gender. This sentiment of interest in football is echoed in the scientific literature, whereas a disproportionate number of manuscripts have been published on high school football in comparison with women's sports and men's sports other than football. Since the passage of federal Title IX legislation in 1972, the number of females participating in high school athletics has increased dramatically. (7) While the majority of injury rates for males and females are equivalent, the rate of ACL injuries has been found to be up to eight times the rate in females as compared with males. Such differences in injury rates may necessitate the redistribution of personnel and resources for the treatment and prevention of such injuries. (11,12)
Fewer schools than expected returned the study questionnaire. Several factors may assist in explaining the reduced response rate. Many high school athletic directors serve in multiple capacities in their schools; for example, some may also be teachers or guidance counselors. Time constraints imposed on these personnel may have limited their ability to complete and return the survey within the study period. This may be evidenced by the large portion of surveys that were filled out by someone other than the athletic director (30%), even though the introductory letter specified that the athletic director should complete them. The low response rate for this study may limit the representativeness of the sample; however, we did have reasonable representation of school settings (rural, small city, etc.) and athletic divisions. In addition to the low response rate, athletic directors from schools known to the researchers to utilize residents did not correctly identify the resident involvement in the coverage for their school. While this may be an oversight, it may reduce the reporting of resident and medical coverage that actually exists at the schools surveyed.
Confusion over what type of medical coverage actually existed was more apparent at schools where the athletic director, and not an athletic trainer, completed the questionnaire. This seems to demonstrate that allied health personnel such as certified and/or licensed athletic trainers may be better trained to understand and predict the needs and requirements for event coverage than the athletic director, who has multiple responsibilities. The ideal model would thus be to have a certified athletic trainer on staff to advise the athletic director on decisions regarding the medical coverage of events.
The Healthy People 2010 initiative has included reducing injury rates as one of its 28 focus areas. (13) Injury treatment and prevention provided by qualified personnel will help reduce morbidity and disability among high school athletes by making accurate diagnosis and treatment available in a timely manner. High school sporting events have comparable injury rates to intercollegiate athletics, and receive far less medical coverage. In addition, a disparity exists between football and other sports in terms of extent and quality of medicine coverage. Finally, many high schools rely on noncertified sports medicine personnel to provide medical coverage, which may place athletes at increased risk for improper treatment. In addition, this lack of certified medical providers may increase the high school's assumed liability.
[FIGURE 1 OMITTED]
High schools should focus on hiring trained, certified athletic trainers and qualified sports medicine providers. As this is a costly endeavor, it would be beneficial for local medical communities to become involved, on a volunteer basis, in providing coverage for high school sporting events. This is especially true in smaller communities, where our survey indicated there was a lack of orthopaedic physician involvement. Increasing the utilization of student athletic trainers, medical students, and physicians in training should significantly expand the availability of medical coverage and expose these groups to the field of sports medicine. Finally, high schools and the local medical communities should work to provide coverage for all high school sports and not limit their coverage to football. Physicians in the community should be open to voluntarily providing medical coverage to the local schools.
The treatment of sideline injuries is an important aspect for the prevention of catastrophic injuries. One might argue that it is more important to focus on the primary prevention of injury and catastrophic deaths in athletics. A complete preparticipation examination and cardiac screening is the accepted practice in the United States. The involvement and open communication between the physician, parent, athlete, coach and training staff is vital to screen and diagnose medical problems of the athlete before and throughout the season. Having a medical team in place for all athletes will help to increase the likelihood of proper evaluation of symptoms that are harbingers of conditions which might lead to sudden death, such as cardiac disease, heat illness and uncontrolled respiratory problems.
Approximately half of the responding schools in this study did not feel that their sports-related medical coverage was sufficient. Furthermore, half the participating schools relied on noncertified, nonlicensed personnel to provide sports medicine care. Involvement of physicians and other qualified sports medicine personnel from preparticipation screening to sideline coverage is one possible avenue for improving athletes' health and reducing the risk of sports-related injuries, including catastrophic events (Figure 1).
1. Kann L, Kinchen SA, Williams BI, et al. State and Local YRBSS Coodinators. Youth Risk Behavior Surveillance System. Youth risk behavior surveillance-UnitedStates, 1999. MMWR CDC Surveill Summ 2000;49:1-32.
2. Vangsness CT Jr, Hunt T, Uram M, et al. Survey of health care coverage of high school football in southern California. Am J Sports Med 1994;22:719-722.
3. Rutherford DS, Niedfeldt MW, Young CC. Medical coverage of high school football in Wisconsin in 1997. Clin J Sport Med 1999;9:209-215.
4. Lindaman LM. Physician care for interscholastic athletes in Michigan. Am J Sports Med 1991;19:82-87.
5. Carek PJ, Dunn J, Hawkins A. Health care coverage of high school athletics in South Carolina: does school size make a difference? J S C Med Assoc 1999;95:420-5.
6. Weaver NL, Marshall SW, Miller MD. Preventing sports injuries: opportunities for intervention in youth athletics. Patient Educ Couns 2002;46:199-204.
7. National Center for Catastrophic Sport Injury Research Data Tables. Twenty-first Annual Report. Available at: http://www.unc.edu/depts/nccsi/. Accessed February 11, 2005.
8. National Athletic Trainers' Association. Official statement on ATC's in high schools. Available at: http://www.nata.org/publicinformation/atcsinhighschool.htm. Accessed May 6, 2004.
9. American Academy of Family Practice. Athletic Trainers for High School Athletes. Available at: http://www.aafp.org/x7088.xml. Accessed May 6, 2004.
10. Haq C, Grosch M, Carufel-Wert D. Leadership Opportunities with Communities, the Medically Underserved, and Special Populations (LOCUS). Acad Med 2002;77:740.
11. Arendt E, Dick R. Knee Injury Patterns Among Men and Women in Collegiate Basketball and Soccer: NCAA Data and Review of Literature. Am J Sports Med 1995;23:694-701.
12. Arendt EA, Agel, Dick R. Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury Patterns Among Collegiate Men and Women. J Athletic Training 1999;34:86-92.
13. US Department of Health and Human Services. Healthy People 2010, 2nd ed. With Understanding and Improving Health and Objectives for Improving Health. 2 vols. Washington, DC, US Government Printing Office, 2000.</p> <pre> Silence is argument carried out by other means. --Che Guevara </pre> <p>Douglas F. Aukerman, MD, Melissa McManama Aukerman, MS, and Douglas Browning, MD, ATC-L
From the Department of Orthopaedics and Sports Medicine and Family Medicine and the Department of Kinesiology, the Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA; and the Department of Family and Community Medicine, Wake Forest University, Winston-Salem, NC.
Reprint requests to Douglas F. Aukerman, MD, Assistant Professor, Department of Orthopaedics, The Pennsylvania State University, 1850 East Park Avenue, Suite 112 University Park, Pennsylvania 16805. Email: firstname.lastname@example.org
Accepted October 10, 2005.
RELATED ARTICLE: Key Points
* The majority of high schools that participated in this study did not have physician coverage of sporting events other than football games.
* Most of the coaches at the participating high schools did not have CPR or first aid certification.
* Only about half of the high schools employed board certified, licensed sports medicine personnel (e.g. ATC-L). The remainder of these schools relied on unlicensed personnel, such as teachers and coaches to provide sports medicine care.
* Adequate sports medicine care of high school athletes, including qualified physicians and licensed athletic trainers, will assist in 1) decreased injury rates, 2) decreased loss of playing time due to accurate diagnosis and treatment, and 3) decreased rate of re-injury due to proper rehabilitation.
Table 1. Demographics of participating high schools Characteristic Percent (n) Athletic division 1A 4 (6) 2A 25 (34) 3A 26 (36) 4A 45 (63) Community descriptor Rural town 28 Small town 24 Small city 17 Medium city 13 Large city 18 Table 2. Specialty of physicians providing coverage for participating high schools Medical specialty Percent (n) Orthopaedics 52 (72) Primary care 35 (49) Family medicine 30 (41) Internal medicine 5 (7) Pediatrics 3 (4) General medicine 5 (7) Other specialty 7 (10)
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Title Annotation:||Original Article|
|Publication:||Southern Medical Journal|
|Date:||Feb 1, 2006|
|Previous Article:||Cost-effectiveness strategies to treat osteoporosis in elderly women.|
|Next Article:||Lead and copper in drinking water fountains-information for physicians.|
|Colleges may be liable for athletes' eating disorders, report says.|
|AD FINALIST TO INTERVIEW ON CAMPUS.|
|Confronting the risk of high school athletics.|
|And now a word from our friends ...|