Mediacom's CEO Calls on Members of Congress to Demand that Sinclair's CEO Answer Allegations.MIDDLETOWN, N.Y. -- Rocco B. Commisso Rocco B. Commisso is the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of Mediacom. He was born in Calabria, Italy, he immigrated to the U.S. at age 12. Work
in full National Association of Securities Dealers Automated Quotations U.S. market for over-the-counter securities. Established in 1971 by the National Association of Securities Dealers (NASD), NASDAQ is an automated quotation system that reports on : MCCC MCCC Marie Curie Cancer Care (UK) MCCC Mercer County Community College (New Jersey) MCCC Montgomery County Community College (Pottstown, PA) ), is calling on members of Congress who represent Mediacom's employees and customers in 23 states to demand that David Smith, President and CEO of Sinclair Broadcast Group The Sinclair Broadcast Group (SBG) NASDAQ: SBGI is the operator of the largest number of local television stations in the United States with a total of 59 stations across the country in 38 primarily small and medium markets, many of which are located in the South and , Inc. (NASDAQ: SBGI SBGI Society of British Gas Industries ), appear before Congress to answer the specific allegations made by Mediacom in its letter to Congress on January 13, 2007. David Smith's response letter to members of Congress dated Tuesday, January 16, 2007 simply failed to answer any of the specific allegations made by Mediacom and did not even attempt to justify Sinclair's continuing discrimination that has adversely impacted two million Mediacom cable viewers in 700,000 households in smaller communities across America. David Smith's effort to characterize the dispute as a "simple commercial negotiation" between two companies ignores two fundamental facts: -- First, millions of television viewers across the country are being adversely affected by the negotiations, and Sinclair has made it clear in numerous public statements that it simply does not care about how its behavior affects consumers. If Sinclair succeeds in its strategy to use Mediacom and its subscribers to set an example for the entire cable industry, consumers will wind up paying $6 billion or more a year in extra costs while receiving nothing new in return. Last February, David Smith publicly stated that broadcasters should be paid $4.50 per subscriber or more for retransmission consent. More recent statements by him and Barry Faber, Sinclair's General Counsel, make clear this would just be the beginning--in their view, each broadcast station should be paid at least $2.00 per subscriber per month, meaning that in a market with six broadcast stations, consumers would see at least $12 per month added to their cable and DBS bills just so they can continue to receive broadcast station programs that are supposed to be free over-the-air. -- Second, David Smith glosses over the fact that Sinclair is a broadcaster making free use of taxpayer-owned spectrum. Concerned that negotiations over retransmission consent, unlike ordinary commercial negotiations, have such a potential for adversely affecting the public interest, Congress decided that the parties to retransmission consent negotiations should be subject to rules that require them to observe specified standards, including a requirement that the broadcaster not engage in discriminatory pricing not justified by competitive marketplace conditions. Even if Sinclair's outrageous conduct were to be upheld after all appeals are exhausted, that would simply mean that the law does not work as intended and Congress needs to act to immediately fix the broken statutory scheme so that American television viewers are protected from the choice of either paying billions of dollars in higher cable and DBS (Direct Broadcast Satellite) A one-way TV broadcast service from a communications satellite to a small round or oval dish antenna no larger than 20" in diameter. bills or a return to rabbit-ears to watch free over-the-air television. Other key points not addressed by David Smith's letter include the following: * On January 14, Mediacom renewed its efforts to submit the dispute to binding arbitration before the FCC's Media Bureau, as recommended by the FCC (1) (Federal Communications Commission, Washington, DC, www.fcc.gov) The U.S. government agency that regulates interstate and international communications including wire, cable, radio, TV and satellite. The FCC was created under the U.S. and by members of Congress. As recently as yesterday, Chairman Martin, at a Washington press conference, publicly urged Sinclair to submit to binding arbitration. To date, Sinclair has not even told Mediacom whether it will agree in principle to such arbitration. In fact, it has repeatedly stalled in giving Mediacom an answer to that simple question, which Mediacom asked yet again just yesterday. Today, an email from Mr. Faber indicated that executives at Sinclair are so busy that no response to our question could be expected until next week at the earliest. * David Smith's assertion that arbitration is an "unusual approach" in resolving issues in commercial transactions appears in conflict with Sinclair's own business practices. Sinclair routinely enters into a variety of agreements that contain arbitration clauses including, most notably, binding arbitration provisions in the employment contract between Barry Faber, General Counsel and VP, and Sinclair. (See below for examples). Moreover, various organizations report that thousands of commercial arbitrations are conducted every year. In addition, arbitration has been utilized in other circumstances involving matters within the FCC's jurisdiction, including disputes over telephony interconnection agreements and in at least three prominent situations involving retransmission consent Retransmission consent is an option granted to US television stations as part of the law that granted such stations the option to elect must-carry rights. Under retransmission consent, a full-power US television station may elect to negotiate with a cable system operator for . * The FCC possesses broad and ample authority under the Communications Act The establishment of the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) in 1934, the regulatory body for interstate and foreign telecommunications. Its mission is to provide high-quality services at reasonable cost to everyone in the U.S. on a nondiscriminatory basis. to protect the public interest, which could include ordering/authorizing carriage of a programming service. (See below for a number of examples of such actions by the FCC during the past 10 years.) * David Smith's letter incorrectly implies that the full FCC has already voted on this complaint when, in reality, only the Media Bureau has acted to date. The FCC Commissioners have yet to decide the merits of Mediacom's bad faith complaint against Sinclair. * The Iowa court has not ruled on the merits on the merits adj. referring to a judgment, decision or ruling of a court based upon the facts presented in evidence and the law applied to that evidence. A judge decides a case "on the merits" when he/she bases the decision on the fundamental issues and considers of Mediacom's anti-trust claims. The only action to date is the Court's denial of a preliminary injunction A temporary order made by a court at the request of one party that prevents the other party from pursuing a particular course of conduct until the conclusion of a trial on the merits. A preliminary injunction is regarded as extraordinary relief. request. Mediacom has not yet had its day in court on the full merits of its claims. If Mediacom prevails in this litigation An action brought in court to enforce a particular right. The act or process of bringing a lawsuit in and of itself; a judicial contest; any dispute. When a person begins a civil lawsuit, the person enters into a process called litigation. , Sinclair will be exposed to millions of dollars of damages payable to Mediacom. * David Smith's letter ducks the issue of Sinclair's abusive behavior abusive behavior Public health Any of various behaviors–aggressive, coercive or controlling, destructive, harassing, intimidating, isolating, threatening–which a batterer may use to control a domestic partner/victim. See Domestic violence. and discriminatory conduct, a continuation of Sinclair's apparent strategy to simply ignore concerns articulated by key state and federal officials.
-- Sinclair rebuffed last week's request to submit to binding
arbitration and resume carriage signed by the entire
bi-partisan Iowa Congressional Delegation.
-- Yesterday, six Iowa State Senators called for Sinclair to
authorize interim carriage since the Iowa Government
Oversight Committee cancelled a meeting yesterday
"to accede to Sinclair's request for a delay."
(See below for the full text of the Iowa Senate News
Release.)
* Sinclair has issued at least two extensions of time to permit Time Warner to continue carriage of Sinclair's stations while the parties negotiate. Mediacom has repeatedly offered to accept the same terms given to Time Warner, but Sinclair refuses. * Sinclair makes much of Mediacom's public airing of the dispute. Sinclair, however, was the first one to go public by: (1) issuing the stations' termination notice on the afternoon that Mediacom was pricing a public debt offering in late September, 2006; (2) making damaging and inflammatory comments to the investment community in their November 1, 2006 Earnings Call and predicting severe financial consequences to Mediacom if the Sinclair stations went dark on Mediacom cable systems; and (3) instituting a campaign together with DirecTV to entice Mediacom customers to switch to Mediacom's largest competitor (Sinclair has not used those same tactics in its ongoing negotiations with Time Warner). In order to avoid further confusion and help elected officials obtain a better understanding of all the facts in the dispute between Mediacom and Sinclair, today Mediacom's CEO challenges David Smith to join him in testifying unconditionally and under oath before Congress about the retransmission consent dispute between the companies. Congress may be required to do what the FCC has not yet done: hold Sinclair publicly accountable for its discrimination against Mediacom, its customers, and employees. Examples of Sinclair's use or acceptance of binding arbitration provisions in non-Mediacom agreements:
1. Employment agreements. Sinclair apparently requires binding
arbitration provisions in employment contracts. For example,
Sinclair has sought to enforce a binding arbitration provision when
sued by a former local sales manager (sex discrimination among
other claims) (cited as 2003 WL 22972357 (Ohio App. 2 Dist.))
(2003): has an employment agreement of Barry Faber, Sinclair Vice
President and General Counsel, from 2004 that requires binding
arbitration (publicly available at
http://onecle.com/contracts/sinclair/faber.emp.2004.08.04.shtml);
and has an employment agreement of David D. Smith, Sinclair
President and CEO, from 1995 that requires binding arbitration
(publicly available at
http://onecle.com/contracts/sinclair/smith-david.emp.1995.06.12.shtml
).
2. Network affiliation agreements. Sinclair has utilized arbitration
provisions in network affiliation agreements in the past. For
example, the KDSM (Des Moines) agreement with the Fox Television
Network requires binding arbitration (2002)
(publicly available at
http://contracts.onecle.com/sinclair/fox.affil.2002.07.01.shtml).
3. Acquisitions. In a variety of transactions by Sinclair or its
affiliates, including the purchase of numerous radio and television
stations, the definitive agreements have required arbitration
certain matters. Binding arbitration provisions were included, for
example, in agreements related to the acquisition of, or from, STC
Broadcasting, Inc (1999)
(publicly available at
http://contracts.onecle.com/sinclair/stc.apa.1999.03.05.shtml);
Tuscaloosa Broadcasting, Inc and others (1998)
(publicly available at
http://contracts.onecle.com/sinclair/stc.apa.1998.02.03.shtml);
Grant Television, Inc.; and River City Broadcasting (acquisition of
KDSM and WLOS in 1996) (publicly available at
http://contracts.onecle.com/sinclair/river-city.apa.1996.04.10.shtml).
4. Smith Family LLCs. Sinclair's President and CEO and members of his
family agreed to a broad arbitration clause as part of a 1997
amendment to an Operating Agreement of an LLC to which they were
parties (publicly available at
http://sec.edgar-online.com/2004/12/20/0001104659-04-040463/
Section6.asp). (Due to its length, this URL may need to be
copied/pasted into your Internet browser's address field. Remove
the extra space if one exists.)
Examples of FCC's Broad Authority Under the Communications Act to Protect the Public Interest The FCC possesses broad and ample authority under the Communications Act to protect the public interest. See, for example, 47 U.S.C. Sections 154(i) and 303(j). This would include ordering/authorizing carriage of a programming service (in this case, Sinclair's off-air signals). Such actions are not new to the FCC. Consider the following examples during the past 10 years: 1. The FCC ordered Time Warner Cable systems to carry at least one commercial news programming service other than CNN. Turner Broadcasting System, Inc., 11 FCC Rcd 19595 (1996). 2. The FCC effectively granted retransmission consent at no cost to seven cable operators for a broadcast signal where the broadcaster violated statutory notice requirement. In the Matter of U.S. Cable Group, L.P., 14 FCC Rcd 21074 (1999). 3. The FCC ordered Time Warner Cable to reinstate carriage of ABC off-air stations owned by Disney during "sweeps" ratings period. Time Warner Cable, 16 FCC Rcd 5403 (2001). 4. The FCC ordered Time Warner Cable to carry programming of the NFL Network. Time Warner Cable, 21 FCC Rcd 9016 (2006). 5. The FCC ordered Fox to submit to arbitration of retransmission consent disputes involving its owned and operated stations and to allow cable systems to carry such stations while the arbitration was underway. News/Hughes Merger Order, 19 FCC Rcd 473, paragraph 222 (2004). 6. The FCC gave Mid-Atlantic Sports Network the option to invoke arbitration to obtain carriage on certain of Comcast's cable systems in lieu of a hearing on MASN's complaint that Comcast was discriminating against MASN because it was an independent programmer. TCR Sports Broadcasting Holding, L.L.P., 39 CR 205 (2006). News Release Issued by Iowa Senators Joe Bolkcom Joseph Bolkcom (born July 29, 1956) is a member of the Iowa Senate, where he is currently an assistant majority leader. He was elected to the Senate in 1998. He was reelected in 2002, and again in 2006. He previously served six years on the Johnson County Board of Supervisors. , Sen. Bob Dvorsky, Sen. Rob Hogg Robert M. "Rob" Hogg is the Iowa State Senator from the 19th District. He has served in the Iowa Senate since 2006. He received his BA from the University of Iowa and his JD and MA from the University of Minnesota. , Sen. Jack Hatch Jack G. Hatch is the Iowa State Senator from the 33rd District. He has served in the Iowa Senate since 2002 and is currently an assistant majority leader. He received his BS and MPA from Drake University. , Sen. Wally Horn Wally E. Horn is the Iowa State Senator from the 17th District. He received his BS and MA Northeastern Missouri State Teachers College. Horn currently serves on several committees in the Iowa Senate - the Judiciary committee; the Labor and Business Relations committee; the and Sen. Matt McCoy Matt McCoy could be:
Senators call on Sinclair to restore programming
until Oversight hearings are conducted
Six State Senators Noun 1. state senator - a member of a state senate senator - a member of a senate today released this statement this afternoon: "We are disappointed to learn about the cancellation of today's meeting of the Joint Government Oversight Committee of the Iowa Legislature to review the facts in the Mediacom-Sinclair retransmission Retransmission might refer to:
"Resolution of this protracted pro·tract tr.v. pro·tract·ed, pro·tract·ing, pro·tracts 1. To draw out or lengthen in time; prolong: disputants who needlessly protracted the negotiations. 2. dispute is overdue. Iowans want this dispute to stop disrupting their lives." "While we understand that the Government Oversight Committee members have cancelled today's meeting to accede to accede to verb 1. agree to, accept, grant, endorse, consent to, give in to, surrender to, yield to, concede to, acquiesce in, assent to, comply with, concur to 2. Sinclair's request for a delay, we also believe that resolution of this protracted dispute is overdue." "Today, we are calling on Sinclair to immediately allow Mediacom to resume carrying the KDSM KDSM Korea Defense Service Medal (US DoD) signal in Des Moines Des Moines, city, United States Des Moines (dĭ moin`), city (1990 pop. 193,187), state capital and seat of Polk co., S central Iowa, at the junction of the Des Moines and Raccoon rivers; inc. market and the KGAN signal in Cedar Rapids Cedar Rapids, city (1990 pop. 108,751), seat of Linn co., E central Iowa, on the Cedar River; inc. as a city 1856. The second largest city in Iowa, it is named for the surging rapids in the river. until both sides have a chance to appear before the Government Oversight Committee and to resolve this dispute." "Clearly, a resumption of carriage is in the best interests of Iowa's television viewing public. It would show tremendous good faith on Sinclair's part and go a long way toward restoring public confidence and showing viewers that they aren't pawns Pawn(s) may refer to:
-end-
Mediacom Communications is the nation's 8th largest cable television company and one of the leading cable operators focused on serving the smaller cities and towns in the United States United States, officially United States of America, republic (2005 est. pop. 295,734,000), 3,539,227 sq mi (9,166,598 sq km), North America. The United States is the world's third largest country in population and the fourth largest country in area. . Mediacom Communications offers a wide array of broadband products and services, including traditional video services, digital television, video-on-demand, digital video recorders See DVR. , high-definition television high-definition television (HDTV) Any system producing significantly greater picture resolution than that of the ordinary 525-line (625-line in Europe) television screen. Conventional television transmits signals in analog form. , high-speed Internet See broadband. access and phone service. |
|
||||||||||||||

Printer friendly
Cite/link
Email
Feedback
Reader Opinion