The ride in Japan has not always been easy--with headquarters in Kobe, the company was severely affected by the 1995 Hanshin earthquake and some brands, such as Pringles, have faced turbulence caused by regulatory violations. Nevertheless, P&G and its affiliated brands have managed to maintain the trust of the Japanese consumer. How has its marketing techniques adapted to a constantly evolving and notoriously fickle market? A look at some of their success stories and strategies is illuminating.
Managing brand management
External Relations Supervisor, Daisuke Hase, sums up P&G's marketing mantra in one simple phrase: "Receptive messages in receptive moments. We have two moments to touch consumers, when they choose the product in the store and when they use it at home--what we consider the 'two moments of choice.' The first moment is what we focus on seriously when marketing products." But how to influence consumers to purchase a particular product in an over-saturated market? To narrow in and strengthen advertising effectiveness, the company employs another principal, "What, Who, How." Here marketers pinpoint a product's image (what) and target demographic (who) in order to determine what vehicle (how) is most effective in relaying their message to consumers.
These are simple marketing principles, but not something to be taken for granted. P&G views the competitive nature of the Japanese market and the fickleness of consumers as a challenging but important factor in their success. As former president Werner Geissler observed, "The consumers in Japan are most demanding in the world in terms of product quality, and there are superior competitors in the market. We believe Japan is the toughest market in the world and competing in such an environment makes us work better, stronger and quicker. Japan is the source of our innovation." This difficult test market is the perfect arena for P&G to hone its marketing skills.
Smelling sweet: Fabreze
For P&G innovation does not necessarily equate to product innovation alone. Focusing on transforming the way a product is seen by consumers instead of changing the formula itself is one of the keys to the company's global success.
Fabreze odor removing fabric spray is P&G's crowning glory in innovative marketing. Although Japanese consumers are known to be very sensitive to odors, surveys indicated that many felt the smell of home fabrics was unavoidable and thus no product existed exclusively for fabric odor removal. P&G's first challenge in marketing Fabreze was to create both a new product category and to create consumer demand. To do so, Fabreze was first promoted under the concept of "Clean the un-washable; detergent for washables, Fabreze for everything else." With advertisements focusing on the moldy smells of laundry hung to dry indoors during Japan's rainy season, as well as the smell of sweat that un-washable futons exude in summer, P&G created the need for Fabreze by instilling in consumers the habit of spraying down clothes and bedding on a daily basis.
This marketing was highly successful and sales of the product took off, but hit a ceiling about four years later. Such quick growth, leading to a level-off in sales, had also occurred in Fabreze's birthplace, the US, and marketing teams stateside were still stumped on how to pick things up. Going back to the "What, Who, How" formula, P&G narrowed in on uses of the product outside the home. Up until that time, Fabreze's principal shopper demographic had been housewives who, "generally focus exclusively on the household itself; they know surprisingly little about their family's activity outside of the home," as Marketing Manager Minoru Mitamura recently explained to Nikkei Business. In 2002 P&G chose Hokkaido as a test market, changed television commercials in the area and began campaigns promoting Fabreze trials for sports and camping equipment, motorcycle helmets and other non-household goods. Positive results were almost immediate as sales in the trial area rose, and after taking the campaign national the next year, 2003 sales of Fabreze increased from [yen]100 billion to [yen]150 billion. When the company's next test market (Canada) displayed the same positive results, the campaign went global under the name "Hokkaido Model." Says Mitamura, "With a product that's already on top, we simply consider how to expand our market. With Fabreze, this means creating new consumer habits."
Communication as a point-of-entry for marketing
Another area in which P&G has made strides is marketing using educational information. While globally the company has been making a move to online media for some time, P&G Japan took its first foray into informative marketing with the "womama" website in 2006. Providing new and expecting mothers with information related to health, beauty and child-rearing, P&G aimed to work with other companies to provide totality in the site's content but found a lack of available collaborators and trouble linking the site to in-store campaigns.
As a second try the company then brought the global "BeingGirl" website to Japanese shores, providing its teenage target demographic with health and beauty information under the same "For Girls, By Girls" premise as its international counterparts. The site, a vehicle for promoting the feminine sanitary product Whisper, was highly successful, but P&G soon realized that its target was not a group of desktop PC users. With over 90% of high school girls connecting to the Internet on their mobile phones, according to a report by Impress R&D, the company turned its attentions to the cellular world.
In early 2007, a collaboration with Sony Digital Entertainment produced the interactive mobile site "BeingGirl" [infinity] Hitokoto" under the same theme of providing a forum for beauty, fashion and health as well as weather and horoscope information. Again, focusing on Whisper products, the site features an email service that sends out alerts notifying users of the "four periods" of their menstrual cycles. By November of the same year, the site had over 32,000 registered users and was nominated in the Asia Mobile Awards 2007 for Best Mobile Advertising.
As with other developing strategies, Japan is currently the learning center for mobile marketing before P&G expands the concept globally.
Corporate brand management
Effective marketing techniques paired with high-quality products is a natural formula for brand success, but this does little to explain why the P&G name itself is so successful. And while its reputation would lead one to believe differently, Hase asserts that the Proctor & Gamble is not as well known in Japan as in neighboring China or the US. "P&G does brand marketing and brand management, but we do not intentionally promote our company name unless it's to build rapport for a new product. Actually, ten or so years ago, not many of our competitors in Japan even did brand marketing. P&G was the first company to start a brand management system; we don't tag our name on a product unless necessary."
However, while Hase adamantly insists the company does little corporate brand promotion. P&G's factsheet boasts a long list of activities to the contrary. Since entering the Japanese market, it has contributed to various scholarships, given significant financial support to local schools, donated over US$1 million to victims of the 1995 Great Hanshin Earthquake, and funded the establishment of a counseling center for working mothers. P&G also provides marketing advice for their home city of Kobe, as well as accepting inquires from foreign companies considering a move into the area.
Even for all its successes, the company is still working to overcome challenges. Word-of-mouth and viral campaigning are its current targets. Abroad, P&G came under criticism for the debatable ethics of its revolutionary "Tremor" scheme. The program aims at teenage consumers by recruiting socially active youth to promote products through daily conversation, and has been criticized, in the words of Commercial Alert Executive Director Gary Ruskin in BusinessWeek, as the "commercialization of human relations."
While the company says nothing like Tremor is in the works for Japan, it has ventured into viral marketing. When P&G decided Herbal Essence needed a makeover, they teamed up with actress/singer Anna Tsuchiya and created a hoax where the starlet suddenly "disappeared." A week later she returned, claiming that she had gone off in search of paradise--and come back with Herbal Essence. The effect worked, and news of both events and information on three new products spread rapidly around the Internet.
Viral marketing through bloggers is also currently in testing, and the company won't discuss details. They are quick to state however that bloggers aren't paid to write good PR and that currently only samples are being sent. But for a company that is, in the words of Debbie Howard (President of Japan Market Resource Network), "one of the best marketing companies in the world," they still haven't discovered how to effectively utilize what is considered a key marketing tool. Says Hase, "Word-of-mouth is a never-ending journey. It's so important, but something we really struggle with."
For a fuller version of this article, please visit the online version where you can also make comments: www.japaninc.com/mgz_may-july_2008_marketing101