Long-Forgotten Tunnel Revived For Homeland Defense Training.
The tunnel, built in 1953 as part of the West Virginia Turnpike, was permanently closed when I-77 opened between Beckley and Charleston I-1987. The Federal Highway Administration used the facility in the mid-1990s as a test facility for ventilation of smoke from tunnel fires. Four years ago, the tunnel became a storage site for the West Virginia Turnpike.
To turn the tunnel into a training facility, Congress appropriated $5 million in fiscal 2001, and $3 million in 2000. One of the program's biggest supporters is Sen. Robert Byrd, D-W.Va.
The contractor who won a competition to transform the tunnel into a training siteis Research Planning, Inc. (RPI). Program manager Mel Wick estimated that RPI would need a total of $27.3 million to make the tunnel fully operational. After that, he noted, it will cost $5 million a year to sustain the facility and run the training.
The project was criticized as pork-barrel spending by some members of Congress, notably Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz. But Byrd said the tunnel meets a legitimate counter-terrorism need. It will allow "military tacticians the opportunity to test new strategies and techniques to respond to terrorists that may attack American targets," said Byrd.
Ted Kramer, the deputy project manager for RPI, said the company broke down the project into six phases. Phase one through five include research and development of training scenarios, as well as turning the tunnel into a functional training facility. The sixth phase begins after the facility--called the Center for National Response--is completed, and it will address its long-term maintenance.
"There's no other place in the country where you can go in to this kind of an environment, and do this kind of training," said Kramer. "There have been some aboveground buildings with their interiors designed to replicate the inside of tunnels. It's just not the same. You walk in and say, 'Oh, this is a building, and now I have a small tunnel to work through, but it's still in a building.'"
According to RPI, the tunnel was 99 per cent ready for training in May, although it already has hosted several training sessions.
South Charleston Fire Chief C.W. Sigman brought his team for training in the tunnel, and said the feeling of "reality" considerably adds to the training for first responders. "It does a really good job of putting you in a restricted area ... where you have scarce conditions," he said.
Inside the tunnel, a row of dim lights reveals a two-lane, 2,800 foot-long highway. But before too long, it begins to look like a subway or railway tunnel with real cars on the tracks. There also are trailers, where residents could be harboring illicit drug operations, and areas swamped with rubble.
The training environments can be adapted to specific customer needs--to rehearse scenarios such as subway poison-gas attacks or underground explosions. RPI has built in a subway mezzanine and platform, laid rubble props and an 18-wheel tanker truck loaded with simulated hazardous materials. A 120-foot wide, 3-foot-high passageway has been designed to train first responders to operate in confined spaces.
A National Guard team from Illinois already has trained in the tunnel, while West Virginia local firefighters come there regularly for weekend exercises.
"Other training areas are good about training the individual, but we need a place where teams can train and act like it is a real incident," said Sigman. In April, his firefighter teams participated in a joint exercise with the West Virginia Red Cross and a Dow Chemical Reponse Team, simulating a chlorine gas sabotage act. "We need to improve our response capabilities. [The tunnel] gives us another facility [where] we are out of the public eye, and we can do the things we need to do without scaring the public."
The only drawback to the tunnel, Sigman found, is that it doesn't have any classroom facilities or break-out rooms where teams can revise the exercises.
"In here, you have different air, you have different lights, a different sound, and that adds something to the training, " explained Kramer. "And when you put them in a Level-A [protective] suit, with a breathing bottle on the inside, because they are encapsulated, and when you say 'go find somebody in this rubble scene, take your meters of air quality and other instruments, they look down there and say, 'Damn, it's a long way.'"
As the trainees bring out a casualty, Kramer noted, "the adrenaline starts to kick in, and they know that this could be for real. In this environment, dark and closed, it makes a difference."
To create this site, RPI "had to turn the tunnel back to life," said Kramer. Of $25 million worth of testing equipment that had been stored in the tunnel, nothing was salvageable or commercially re-sellable. The contractor had to replace the lights, which were mostly burnt out; tear off the insulation on the walls, and clean out the burnt walls. At this time, the tunnel still has no running water and no sewage system. "A lot of money will have to go toward that," said Wick. He also mentioned that the electrical renovation cost $1.2 million.
The refurbishing of the tunnel has been a boon to West Virginians. The clean-up, mezzanine prop set, lights, trailer rentals have all been supplied by local contractors. All nine RPI representatives onsite are from West Virginia. After being told that there are no weapons and hazardous materials tested in the tunnel, the local residents, according to Kramer, seemed to be enthusiastic about new activities going on in their usually quiet neighborhood.
While the tunnel is still the property of the West Virginia Highway Authority, it will be turned over to the National Guard.
To RPI's Kramer, that makes sense, "because it is federal money, and every car, every truck, every piece of glass that we buy is actually federal property, and it makes that whole arena a lot cleaner."
The decision to making the tunnel a National Guard asset is not without controversy
Amy Smithson, of the Henry L. Stimson Center, said the West Virginia training site is a redundant capability, because a facility for anti-terrorism training already exists elsewhere in the United States. The Justice Department, she said, has opened a live training facility at a former Army base, in Fort McClellan, Ala. So why, Smithson asked, "is the National Guard building another training boot camp in West Virginia?"
The taxpayers, she said, "can rightfully question whether preparedness has taken a backseat to political favors."
In an October 2000 study, Smithson recommended that anti-terrorism training for first responders be handed by local and state academies, as well as by nursing and medical schools.
"It's all a fight about territory," said a law-enforcement official who attended are cent conference on homeland defense in Washington, DC. The source, asking not to be quoted by name, said the government is "working its way down" with the training, starting with the National Guard and federal agencies. "It will take some time until it gets to the locals." For many agencies, the source said, Fort McClellan is too far away and many cannot afford to travel there. But for those within a five-hour radius of West Virginia, the tunnel would be more accessible.
A more important consideration than the location is the uniformity of training standards, said Albert J. Mauroni, a policy analyst for Analytical Services, Inc. in Arlington, Va. (see related story, p. 34). "What we have to guard against is having too many of these [weapons of mass destruction] training sites," he said. "We are going to be at different levels of proficiency."
Mauroni has first-hand experience working at the Fort McClellan facility. That site is useful, he said, but it can't fulfill every need. "There are a series of rooms, you know you have live-agents all around you, it gives you experience with the equipment, but that doesn't simulate what is going to happen in a subway."
The tunnel facility, said Mauroni, can test how proficiently first-responder teams work together. "You need both. As long there's a coordinated national effort," he said. It would be wasteful for Fort McClellan to build an underground site and for the Memorial Tunnel to add live-agent training. It would duplicate efforts and create different standards instead of having one national standard provided by the two training centers, said Mauroni. "It would be overkill, pardon the pun."
It takes RPI several months to put together a comprehensive training program, based on the needs of a particular agency, said Kramer. Even for the local firefighters who come for a weekend, preparation can take several weeks.
So far, RPI hasn't charged any user fees to trainees for using the tunnel, and according to Wick, the company hopes that training in the tunnel will be free of charge. But that all depends on the funding provided by Congress. Without public funds, the company will have to charge user fees. The company declined to provide specific numbers. Wick said he hopes the training facility will be incorporated into the Justice Department's homeland defense program.
At press time, there were no training drills scheduled at the tunnel beyond July, but Kramer said that RPI has received inquiries from the FBI, the Federal Emergency Management Agency and the Environmental Protection Agency. "We have a lot of open training dates in the future," said Kramer.
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Date:||Jun 1, 2001|
|Previous Article:||Pentagon Endorses Biometrics To Enhance Computer Security.|
|Next Article:||Pentagon Unfairly Criticized In Chem-Bio Defense Effort.|