Letters to the editor.Dear Editor, Kate Shatzkin's profile of Donald E. Melnick, MD, FACPE FACPE Fellow of the American College of Physician Executives (The Physician Executive, 30(4) July/August 2004) convinces me that Dr. Melnick is bright, religious and sincere. I'm not convinced, however, that his effort to push implementation of the Clinical Skills Examination is well considered or appropriate. The article notes that the American Medical Association American Medical Association (AMA), professional physicians' organization (founded 1847). Its goals are to protect the interests of American physicians, advance public health, and support the growth of medical science. adopted a policy statement opposing this exam. As an AMA (Automatic Message Accounting) The recording and reporting of telephone calls within a telephone system. It includes the calling and called parties and start and stop times of the call. delegate assigned to the reference committee that considered this issue, I was there for the full deliberation deliberation n. the act of considering, discussing, and, hopefully, reaching a conclusion, such as a jury's discussions, voting and decision-making. DELIBERATION, contracts, crimes. . I didn't have an opinion about the Clinical Skills Exam before the testimony was taken, but afterward af·ter·ward also af·ter·wards adv. At a later time; subsequently. Adv. 1. afterward - happening at a time subsequent to a reference time; "he apologized subsequently"; "he's going to the store but he'll be back here I was convinced that this test is not ready for general application. The main objection to the Clinical Skills Exam came from our AMA student delegates. They objected to the high cost (something Dr. Melnick mostly dismisses as insignificant.) The students rightly argued that the limited number of testing sites is also a huge burden for many. I can tell you that these concerns are important to our medical students, who already carry heavy debt burdens. More significantly, the students and other delegates objected that the Clinical Skills Exam has not been shown to actually improve the quality of care given by our young doctors. Perhaps it will, but this is still a theoretical construct. Any graduating medical student who fails this exam will not be able to enter residency A duration of stay required by state and local laws that entitles a person to the legal protection and benefits provided by applicable statutes. States have required state residency for a variety of rights, including the right to vote, the right to run for public office, the ; how is this to be handled? No one could say. This could hurt many training programs. Moreover, such a subjective examination has a much higher chance for inadvertent bias, which worries minority students greatly. Most medical boards have dispensed with oral exams Noun 1. oral exam - an examination conducted by spoken communication oral, oral examination, viva, viva voce exam, examination, test - a set of questions or exercises evaluating skill or knowledge; "when the test was stolen the professor had to make a new for this very reason. The AMA opposition to the Clinical Skills Exam was based on extensive testimony from both proponents and opponents of the test. The final AMA policy was based on carefully considered arguments and especially the concerns of the affected medical students. Many see this test as another way in which the National Board of Medical Examiners A public official charged with investigating all sudden, suspicious, unexplained, or unnatural deaths within the area of his or her appointed jurisdiction. A medical examiner differs from a Coroner in that a medical examiner is a physician. can make itself ever more necessary. How long before all of us in practice will be required to take a clinical skills exam every few years? I'm sure we could do this and pass, but I'm not convinced that medicine will be any better for all the effort and the cost. Earl R. Washburn, MD AMA Delegate Placerville, CA |
|
||||||||||||||||
Printer friendly
Cite/link
Email
Feedback
Reader Opinion