Printer Friendly
The Free Library
14,587,697 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

Kelley's 'pathographies' strive to accent the negative.


NANCY Sinatra Nancy Sandra Sinatra (born June 8, 1940, in Jersey City, New Jersey) is an American singer and actress. She is the daughter of popular singer Frank Sinatra and his first wife, Nancy Barbato, and remains best known for her 1966 signature hit "These Boots Are Made for Walkin'". , the famed chanteuse chan·teuse  
n.
A woman singer, especially a nightclub singer.



[French, feminine of chanteur, singer, from chanter, to sing; see chant.]
 who brought us "These Boots Are Made for Walkin'" those many years ago, had this to say about Kitty Kelley
For the actress, see Kitty Kelly


Kitty Kelley (born April 4, 1942) is an American investigative journalist and author of several best-selling biographies of celebrities and politicians, most of them unauthorized.
: "I hope she gets run over by a truck."

Even getting stomped all over by neon-colored thigh boots would be too good for her, in Nancy Sinatra's view. And that view is widely shared--nearly universal, from what I can tell, among those unlucky celebrities whom Kelley has written about, including Elizabeth Taylor Noun 1. Elizabeth Taylor - United States film actress (born in England) who was a childhood star; as an adult she often co-starred with Richard Burton (born in 1932)
Taylor
, the British royal family, and Nancy's late father Frank.

The circle of Kelley's victims has now expanded to include President Bush and his family, going back four generations. The Bushes don't seem too pleased about it either, judging by the campaign launched last week by the White House and other Republican operatives to discredit her and her book.

It's not terribly hard to do. As proof that there are no lengths to which I won't go in furtherance of my craft, I began reading "The Family: The Real Story of the Bush Dynasty" the moment a copy dropped in my sweaty palms. And I read it all--choking down 700 pages of Kelley's glutinous glutinous /glu·ti·nous/ (gloo´ti-nus) adhesive; sticky.

glu·ti·nous
adj.
Adhesive; sticky.



glu
 prose.

Remember me the next time you say you hate your job.

In 1988, the novelist Joyce Carol Oates Noun 1. Joyce Carol Oates - United States writer (born in 1938)
Oates
 coined the perfect term to describe what Kelley does--pathography, a biography that "overemphasizes the negative aspects of a person's life and work, such as failure, unhappiness, illness and tragedy." (The word is so useful nowadays that it's already made the American Heritage American Heritage can refer to:
  • American Heritage (magazine)
  • American Heritage (band)
  • The American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language
  • American Heritage Rivers
  • American Heritage School, a small private school in Broward County, Florida
 Dictionary, from which I cribbed this definition.)

Thus Kelley depicts the Bush family--like the Sinatras, Kennedys, Windsors, and other clans that have received the Kelley treatment--in a delirium delirium

Condition of disorientation, confused thinking, and rapid alternation between mental states. The patient is restless, cannot concentrate, and undergoes emotional changes (e.g., anxiety, apathy, euphoria), sometimes with hallucinations.
 of dysfunction, drunkenness, depression, dishonesty and (I've run out of "d" words) serial adultery.

Pathographies sell, for obvious reasons--who doesn't like to be reassured that the lives of the rich and beautiful are, in reality, just as pathetic as our own?--but the pathographer herself faces unavoidable difficulties.

Chief among these is the very implausibility of the task she sets for herself. Very few people live the lives of unredeemed squalor that the pathographer hopes to portray. So she is forced to fudge.

Testimony from sources who have something unflattering to say, no matter how distant or unreliable they may be, is credulously cred·u·lous  
adj.
1. Disposed to believe too readily; gullible.

2. Arising from or characterized by credulity. See Usage Note at credible.
 repealed, sometimes in direct quotes that run for pages. More often than not these sources are unnamed. Yet even when they are identified, problems remain.

Kelley's source for one particularly scurrilous allegation is, amazingly, the pornographer Larry Flynt. When Kelley writes about Bush's National Guard service, she relies on a Texan named Bill Burkett Bill Burkett was the CBS source in the Killian documents affair of 2004.

He claimed that in 1997, while outside the governor's office in Austin, he overheard a conversation about "wanting to bury George W. Bush's Vietnam service record." This has been disputed.
. CBS News CBS News is the news division of American television and radio network CBS. Its current president is Sean McManus who is also head of CBS Sports. Current productions
Current television shows
  • CBS Morning News
  • The Early Show
 and Dan Rather relied on him for that, too, and now say he deliberately misled them.

Positive information, on the other hand, is included rarely and grudgingly. The pathographer will always skirt her subjects' substantial accomplishments in favor of an unseemly fascination for the private and unprovable.

Just as she wrote a 600-page book about Sinatra and scarcely mentioned his singing--the only reason, after all, anyone would be interested in him--so she manages to chronicle the Bushes with almost no understanding of the political currents that shaped them.

To take one example: Prescott Bush, the current president's grandfather, was a large and consequential figure in the liberal Republicanism of the Eisenhower era. You'd never know it by Kelley, who tries to prove instead that he was an imperious im·pe·ri·ous  
adj.
1. Arrogantly domineering or overbearing. See Synonyms at dictatorial.

2. Urgent; pressing.

3. Obsolete Regal; imperial.
 drunk.

Occasionally you come across anecdotes that a lawyer would call an "admission against interest"--charming stories running counter to Kelley's theme of unrelieved Bush depravity and which can therefore, by the rules of evidence, be presumed true.

One example: Though he's disdained Yale since his graduation in 1968, George W. Bush agreed to host a 35th class reunion.

One classmate, Petra Leilani Akwai, had undergone a sex change since graduation, and partygoers waited to see the reaction of Bush--understood by all correct-thinking liberals to be a crude and backward boor.

Akwai greeted the president in the receiving line.

"You might remember me as Peter when we left Yale,'" she said.

"And now you've come back as yourself," Bush said.

These and other stories from the best reason yet lot President Bush's re-election. All thanks go to Kitty Kelley.

Andrew Ferguson is a columnist with Bloomberg News.
COPYRIGHT 2004 CBJ, L.P.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2004, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:Commentary; Kitty Kelley
Author:Ferguson, Andrew
Publication:Los Angeles Business Journal
Geographic Code:1USA
Date:Sep 27, 2004
Words:713
Previous Article:Ready to burst?(LABJ forum)
Next Article:Bloggers emerge as fact checkers of new age.(Commentary)
Topics:



Related Articles
Camelot and Camelittle. (Edward M. Kennedy; Kitty Kelley's book on Nancy Reagan)
Here Kitty, Kitty. (public reaction to Kitty Kelley's book "Nancy Reagan: The Unauthorized Biography") (editorial)
The Capitol Years.
Page H. Kelley: Old Testament scholar and devoted Baptist.(Critical Essay)
Coming clean.(Editorials)(Newspapers try to heal damaged credibility)(Editorial)
RANGE ROVERS FAMILY DEVOTED TO RANCHING LIFESTYLE.(News)
THESE SIBLINGS AREN'T RIVALS MOORPARK SERVES FAMILY COMBO.(News)
Modern industrialized processes, from factories to farms, have characteristic noxious byproducts, from smog to hog waste.(author Kitty Kelley's book...
The Foundations of Texan Philanthropy.(Book Review)
SIMI VALLEY STANDOUT IS BIG-TIME PLAYER SENIOR IS KEY COMPONENT OF THE PIONEERS' OFFENSE.(News)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles