Judge turns to child's play.
A federal judge in Florida recently borrowed from the culture of
the schoolyard to resolve a dispute between two lawyers in an insurance
lawsuit: He ordered them to "convene at a neutral location"
and "engage in one game of rock, paper, scissors." The judge,
Gregory A. Presnell of Federal District Court in Orlando, called his
innovation "a new form of alternative dispute resolution." The
two attorneys in the case had been unable to agree on a location for
taking a deposition (testimony given outside court) from a witness.
Presnell's order called for the lawyers to hold their
rock-paper-scissors showdown on the courthouse steps if they were unable
to agree on a location for the game as well. But the adversaries got
together the next day and quickly agreed on a location for the
deposition. So as not to be held in contempt of the judge's order,
the lawyers filed a motion asking him to call off the game. Judge
Presnell responded: "With civility restored (at least for now), it
is ordered that the motion is granted."
COPYRIGHT 2006 Scholastic, Inc.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2006, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
|
Reader Opinion