Job ready graduates: a tourism industry perspective.
Keywords: tourism education, skills shortages, tourism industry careers
In order to meet the needs of the forecasted 9.4 million international visitors and 338.8 million domestic visitor by 2010 (DITR DITR Department of Industry Tourism and Resources (Australia) , 2002), it is important for the Australian tourism sector to attract highly skilled workers with relevant skills to meet industry needs. Tourism higher education, as a major platform for human capital development for the tourism industry (Ladkin, 2005), has a mission to assure the quality of graduates and equip e·quip
tr.v. e·quipped, e·quip·ping, e·quips
a. To supply with necessities such as tools or provisions.
b. them with the particular skills and attributes to enable them to function as sophisticated professionals. Questions are generated consequently: what are the tourism managers' perceptions towards the universities' graduates skills and attributes? Are these skills and attributes all important, or performed very well?
Although some studies have been carried out in the field of tourism employment as discussed later in this paper, little information is available on the outcomes from current tourism education that best equip graduates for employment in the tourism sector. This paper reports on a study exploring the managers' perceptions of skills and attributes required in the tourism industry in Australia and compares:
1. the generic skills and tourism discipline attributes developed by tourism higher education in Australia Education in Australia is primarily regulated by the individual state governments. Generally education in Australia follows the three-tier model which includes Primary education (Primary Schools), followed by Secondary education (Secondary Schools / High Schools) and Tertiary with
2. the skills and attributes perceived as important by tourism industry practitioners.
The study is grounded on previous research into desirable graduate attributes in tourism education (Airey and
Tribe, 2005; King and Craig-Smith, 2005; Pearce, 2005; Ayres, 2006) and addresses the concern for an ongoing pool of skilled employees to facilitate growth in the Australian tourism industry. The results of this research should benefit both tourism higher education providers in Australia and those involved in human resource development in the tourism industry.
In Australia, the graduate attributes or skills may differ from institution to institution (Pearce, 2005). Each university develops generic skills according to according to
1. As stated or indicated by; on the authority of: according to historians.
2. In keeping with: according to instructions.
3. its location and unique offerings. These are often a reflection of universities' missions and educational philosophies. It is therefore not surprising that the attributes of graduating students developed by the many tourism programs may be diverse.
The findings from this study will highlight industry's perceptions of the relevance of these educational outcomes.
The academic community has investigated a variety of different areas related to tourism employment. For example, a range of issues relating to relating to relate prep → concernant
relating to relate prep → bezüglich +gen, mit Bezug auf +acc interest in tourism and hospitality employment, including work motivation, success perception and job acquisition strategies has been explored by Ross (1992, 1993, 1997). The attitudes to career from UK and Greek perspectives in tourism have been examined by Airey and Frontistis (1997). The professionalism in tourism employment, the movement of labour into tourism in terms of attraction to and satisfaction with the industry, and seasonality issues as being problematic in terms of labour supply have been investigated respectively by Hjalager and Andersen (2001), Szivas et al. (2003), and Jolliffe and Farnsworth (2003). Despite the rapid growth of the tourism industry, the subsequent increase in the number of jobs and the growth in educational courses, few studies about education needs for the tourism industry are reported in the literature and little information is available to those who are involved in human resource management in the tourism industry (Ayres, 2006).
The Australian Standing Committee on Employment and Workplace Relations noted that the tourism sector is of critical economic importance in Australia, especially for employment in regional areas. A major concern is that a lack of suitable staff will undermine the industry's ability to meet the expectations of service quality that tourism promotions have created. The demand for tourism services to meet international standards led to an increasing trend to employ a highly skilled labour force. In addition, the ongoing development of tourism policy and guidelines guidelines,
n.pl a set of standards, criteria, or specifications to be used or followed in the performance of certain tasks. for innovative best practice is underpinned by a pool of highly skilled tourism professionals.
The present tertiary education Tertiary education, also referred to as third-stage, third level education, or higher education, is the educational level following the completion of a school providing a secondary education, such as a high school, secondary school, or gymnasium. system in Australia consists of higher education (universities) and vocational education (TAFE TAFE (in Australia) Technical and Further Education institutes). The differences between the two are often characterised in terms of the qualifications they deliver (e.g., higher education refers to Bachelor, Masters and PhD degrees, while TAFE refers to Certificates and Diplomas). This distinction is, however, blurred blur
v. blurred, blur·ring, blurs
1. To make indistinct and hazy in outline or appearance; obscure.
2. To smear or stain; smudge.
3. because some universities now offer diplomas and some TAFE institutes offer degrees. It is therefore more important to note how the educational goals of each level differ. As Young (2007) states, TAFE education is heavily influenced by the immediate needs of industry. Thus, tourism vocational education appears to emphasise the specific skills needed by employers. In contrast, higher education highlights innovation and critical thinking. Tourism degree graduates are exposed to a broad range of tourism economic and planning issues that relate to the industry's development and growth. The combination of theory and practice aims to prepare students to analyse an·a·lyse
v. Chiefly British
Variant of analyze.
analyse or US -lyze
[-lysing, -lysed] or -lyzing, tourism markets, assess regional weaknesses and strengths, and understand security, marketing, infrastructure and costs associated with tourism. The development of tourism higher education is essential to maintain the supply of talents suitable for the rapid growth of the tourism industry in quantity and quality.
Tourism degrees are important. Tourism education must do much more than reflect the immediate needs of the workplace or the immediate demands of entry-level employment positions (Tribe and Airey, 2005). Tourism education, aiming to provide new insights into the management of tourism activity, will make itself relevant for the future. An improved understanding of how best to educate would bring benefits to both individuals who wish to develop a career in tourism and the tourism industry as a whole (Ladkin, 2005).
The curriculum for tourism higher education aims to meet the needs of students, employers and government funding bodies, but there is no agreement on how best to do this (Morgan, 2004). In the academic literature, the debates about the tourism higher education curriculum have focused on issues of standardization or diversification Diversification
A risk management technique that mixes a wide variety of investments within a portfolio. It is designed to minimize the impact of any one security on overall portfolio performance.
Diversification is possibly the greatest way to reduce the risk. , more specialised or broader subjects in the curriculum (Tan TAN
See tax anticipation note (TAN). & Morgan, 2002; Fayos-Sola, 1997; Koh, 1995; Airey & Johnson, 1999; Riley et al., 2002; Airey, 2005; Amoah & Baum, 1997; Cooper, et al., 1996; McKercher, 2002; King et al., 2003). The emphasis of the debates, however, have tended to be on the form rather than the essence of curriculum design. Tourism education has the aim to provide job ready graduates who are able to apply their skills and knowledge to tourism management practice. It is without doubt that the vitality of tourism education relies on a robust relationship with the tourism industry.
In Australia, professional accreditation accreditation,
n a process of formal recognition of a school or institution attesting to the required ability and performance in an area of education, training, or practice. has not been implemented in university-based tourism education programs (Tan and Morgan, 2002) and most tourism management programs were designed by educators with little or no empirical input from the industry (McKercher, 2002). Thus, there is a need for the industry and education providers to bridge the gap and to work closely together. Industry and education must work in partnership to promote the professionalisation Noun 1. professionalisation - the social process whereby people come to engage in an activity for pay or as a means of livelihood; "the professionalization of American sports"; "the professionalization of warfare"
professionalization of tourism as an activity and ensure the education for a tourism career is relevant to employers within the sector. This could lead to a market-based tourism curriculum, which is positive for all parties since it would be developed based on industry needs rather than on the judgements of tourism educators (Koh, 1995) or formal government policy. More empirical input from the tourism industry will assist tourism curriculum design to stride over the limitations from educators and policy makers (Wang, 2008). This study provides an avenue by which the tourism industry is given a voice that will influence future tourism curriculum decision-making.
As mentioned, the purpose of the study reported in this article is to understand what skills and attributes best equip graduates from tourism education for employment in the tourism sector. The method involved two steps: a content analysis of tourism skills sets and a survey to identify the required skills sets needed by the tourism industry in Australia. Because there is no comparable framework of tourism skills sets identified, content analysis is useful in this case as it enables analysis of non-structured skills and attributes information to be identified. Examples of content analysis in tourism education research include studies of an analysis of British postgraduate postgraduate
after first degree graduation, the registerable degree in veterinary science.
may be a research degree, e.g. PhD, or a course-work masterate with a vocational bias, or any combination of these. courses in tourism (Flohr, 2001), a content analysis of teaching methods (Okumus & Wong, 2004), and an analysis of research in tourism education (Tribe, 2005). A content analysis method was conducted to analyse tourism graduates skills and attributes. In order to investigate what education institutions provide in the way of tourism skills sets, graduates' generic skills and tourism discipline-specific attributes were examined as the foundation of this study in seven Australian member institutions of the International Centre of Excellence in Tourism and Hospitality Education (THE-ICE). These seven universities are some of Australia's leading institutions in the field of tourism and hospitality education and research. Considering they are all very different universities, located in different places in Australia, it is expected that they are representative of tourism higher education in Australia (Wang et al., 2008).
According to Pearce (2005), a more widespread trend in tourism education across the country has been attention not just to the content of tourism degrees but also to the qualities of graduates. The skills and attributes have been variously referred to as generic skills and graduate attributes. In the Australian context, the Commonwealth Government has provided each university with a mandate to build up a list of generic skills. This applies not just to the university body, as many tourism programs in Australia have also developed discipline-specific attributes for tourism and travel students. For many tourism programs, the task of building these skills into the subjects in tourism curricula is an ongoing and critical issue in Australian tourism education (Pearce, 2005). A collation COLLATION, descents. A term used in the laws of Louisiana. Collation -of goods is the supposed or real return to the mass of the succession, which an heir makes of the property he received in advance of his share or otherwise, in order that such property may be divided, together with the of skills and attributes was conducted in this study as an attempt to understand what students need to develop through tourism education for the purpose of employment in the tourism sector.
As a second step, and building on the content analysis, a web-based questionnaire survey was conducted to explore the tourism industry's perception of the skills and attributes needed for employment in the tourism sector in Australia. This survey was conducted within a sample of Australian tourism managers who had access to email and Internet.
Content Analysis of Skills and Attributes
For the purpose of this study, the collation of skills and attributes not only focused on university generic skills, but also on tourism-specific attributes which are deemed essential for tourism employment. All seven THE-ICE institutions present information about skills and attributes on their homepages, including the University of Queensland The University of Queensland (UQ) is the longest-established university in the state of Queensland, Australia, a member of Australia's Group of Eight, and the Sandstone Universities. It is also a founding member of the international Universitas 21 organisation. (Statement of Graduate Attributes, UQ, 2006), the University of Canberra The University of Canberra is an Australian university, located in Canberra, the capital of Australia. It is the second largest university in Canberra. The University was one of nine Australian universities recognised by the Australian government in 2006 for high achievement in (Policies and procedures Policies and Procedures are a set of documents that describe an organization's policies for operation and the procedures necessary to fulfill the policies. They are often initiated because of some external requirement, such as environmental compliance or other governmental , UC, 2002), Murdoch University (The nine attributes of a Murdoch graduate and the sub attributes, 2006), Charles Darwin University The university is named after Charles Darwin, the celebrated English naturalist. History
The university has evolved over the years from mergers of several higher education institutions. (Graduate attributes and employment skills, CDU CDU Christlich-Demokratische Union (German: Christian Democratic Party)
CDU Clasificación Decimal Universal (Spanish)
CDU Control & Display Unit
CDU Control Display Unit , 2006), Southern Cross University (A guide to flexible teaching for quality learning, SCU SCU Santa Clara University
SCU Southern Cross University (New South Wales, Australia)
SCU Southern California University of Health Sciences (Whittier, California)
SCU Serious Crimes Unit
SCU Special Care Unit , 2006), Victoria University (Employability skills, VU, 2006), and Griffith University Griffith University is an Australian public university with five campuses in Queensland between Brisbane and the Gold Coast. In 2007 there were more than 33,000 enrolled students and 3,000 staff. (Griffith policies on graduate skills, 2006). Detailed information is provided in Appendix A.
University genetic skills tend to include the following: critical thinking, problem-solving, communication, teamwork (product, software, tool) Teamwork - A SASD tool from Sterling Software, formerly CADRE Technologies, which supports the Shlaer/Mellor Object-Oriented method and the Yourdon-DeMarco, Hatley-Pirbhai, Constantine and Buhr notations. skills, creativity, organisational ability, work ethics ethics, in philosophy, the study and evaluation of human conduct in the light of moral principles. Moral principles may be viewed either as the standard of conduct that individuals have constructed for themselves or as the body of obligations and duties that a and technology. According to the Department of Education, Science and Training, some skills and attributes can be explained in more depth. For example, communication refers to oral communication and written communication; initiative and enterprise refers to being creative and translating ideas into action; planning and organising refers to being resourceful re·source·ful
Able to act effectively or imaginatively, especially in difficult situations.
re·sourceful·ly adv. , managing time, and allocating people and other resources to a task; self-management refers to having knowledge and confidence in one's own vision and goals; and technology refers to computer skills (DEST DEST Destination
DEST Department of Education, Science and Training (Australia)
DEST Department of the Environment, Sport and Territories (Australia) , 2006). The list of skills and attributes in this study therefore includes these more detailed skills.
Tourism discipline attributes tend to include the following: customer service skills, attention to detail, adaptability a·dapt·a·ble
Capable of adapting or of being adapted.
a·dapta·bil at work, relationship management skills, marketing and sales skills, management skills, and industry knowledge. According to A Guide to Flexible Teaching for Quality Learning (Southern Cross University, 2006), students graduating from the School of Tourism and Hospitality Management demonstrate 11 attributes, including a substantial knowledge of tourism and hospitality industries within both local and international contexts, and a deep understanding of those skills relevant to working and managing in tourism and/or hospitality (See details in Appendix A).
According to Graduate Attributes Challenge Report (Palenthiran et al., 2006), a well-rounded employee is a person who has a balance of academic achievements, technical and personal skills acquired at university, personal values through family upbringing, and any work experience. Work experience is highly regarded because it shows that an employee is well-equipped with knowledge and practical understanding of a particular job (Palenthiran et al., 2006). Communication skills and good grades are the key to graduate employment (Graduate Career, Australia, 2007). These attributes, including relevant work experience, academic grades, and practical skills, have also been added into the list.
The collation of a total of 27 skills and attributes forms a comprehensive list of university generic skills and tourism-specific attributes needed for employment in the tourism sector, as presented in Table 1.
Based on the content analysis of the skills and attributes provided by the seven THE-ICE education institutions, a web-based questionnaire surveys was developed. A convenience sample of Australian tourism managers (N > 1042) was drawn from seven tourism sectors (accommodation; transportation; travel agency and tour operator services A variety of telephone services that require human intervention, including person-to-person calls, collect calls, credit card billing and directory and dialing assistance. Such services are performed by LECs, IXCs and alternative operator services (AOS), organizations that are used by ; cafe and restaurant/food and beverage; meeting, incentive, conference and events; government and non-government tourism organisation; and others). Utilising the clustered stratified sampling Noun 1. stratified sampling - the population is divided into subpopulations (strata) and random samples are taken of each stratum
proportional sampling, representative sampling
sampling - (statistics) the selection of a suitable sample for study technique, the manager sample was randomly selected from various organisation lists and websites. The online newsletters of STCRC was used (further details of samples can be found in Wang, 2008). A total of 200 (less than 19.2% response) surveys was received from industry managers. This article provides results on an Importance-Performance Analysis (IPA IPA - International Phonetic Alphabet ) on the tourism industry's perception of skills and attributes for the purpose of employment in the tourism sector.
Importance-Performance Analysis (IPA)
The importance-performance theory was first developed by Martilla and James in 1977. It provides management with a useful focus for developing marketing strategies. IPA is a low-cost, easily understood technique for measuring attribute importance and performance, and can further the development of effective marketing programs (Martilla & James, 1977). IPA is an appropriate approach in this study, for the importance of attributes reflects the needs and expectations of the tourism industry, while the performance of attributes reflects the satisfaction about the products that are actually delivered.
IPA was conducted to identify the needs and expectations of the tourism industry. A structured self-administered questionnaire was first distributed to managers in tourism industries. Respondents In the context of marketing research, a representative sample drawn from a larger population of people from whom information is collected and used to develop or confirm marketing strategy. were asked to indicate the level of importance and performance level of several variables in regard to the skills and attributes that the tourism industry needs. The results were typically presented on a two-dimensional grid which consisted of vertical and horizontal axes axes
[L., Gr.] plural of axis. The straight lines which intersect at right angles and on which graphs are drawn. Usually the horizontal axis is the x-axis and the vertical one the y-axis. Called also axes of reference. scaling the importance and performance of mean values of both importance and performance scores (Byeong-Yong & Oh, 2002). Once the importance and performance of each attribute had been plotted, the resulting importance-performance space was divided into four quadrants. The cross that separates the quadrants can be based on different principles, although a cross point made up of the average importance and the average performance seems to be the one most frequently applied and is called the data-centred quadrant quadrant, in analytic geometry
1 In analytic geometry, one of the four regions of the plane determined by two lines, the x-axis and the y-axis. approach (Jacob & Kai kai
NZ informal food [Maori]
noun N.Z. (informal) food, grub (slang) provisions, fare, board, commons, eats (slang , 2006). This study used the data-centred quadrant approach to analyse the data. The cross point of these quadrants was determined by the average importance and the average performance.
The total score of each skill and attribute was obtained from a sum of scores coded from the responses. A high score showed a positive attitude, while a low score showed a negative attitude. The mean score of perspectives towards each attribute of skills was calculated from the skills' total scores. The possible responses for the importance of each skill and attribute were Extremely Unimportant un·im·por·tant
Not important; petty.
unim·portance n. , Unimportant, Neutral, Important, Extremely Important, and N/A.
Results and Discussion
In the survey, the participants were asked to provide their views on the merit of skills and attributes needed to work in the tourism sector.
The Important Skills and Attributes in the Tourism Industry
The participants (tourism managers) were asked to rate the level of importance of 27 skills and attributes (See Table 1) on a 1-5 five-item Likert Scale Likert scale A subjective scoring system that allows a person being surveyed to quantify likes and preferences on a 5-point scale, with 1 being the least important, relevant, interesting, most ho-hum, or other, and 5 being most excellent, yeehah important, etc questionnaire: 0 = N/A, 1 = Extremely Unimportant, 2 = Unimportant, 3 = Neutral, 4 = Important and 5 = Extremely Important. This list of 27 attributes was developed from the generic skills of Australian universities and specific graduate attributes of tourism degree programs in THE-ICE institutions. The mean scores of the perceptions on each attribute by tourism managers are presented in Table 2. The results indicate the importance attributed to skills and attributes by tourism managers ranged from 3.18 to 4.86, with 4.26 as the mean value.
According to the tourism managers' perceptions, the top three important attributes are Oral Communication, Relationship Management Skills and Work Ethics in the tourism industry. The three attributes ranked as the least important include Research Skills, Legal Understanding, and Academic Grades
This sample of tourism industry professionals highly value operational skills, such as Work Ethics (no. 3), Customer Service Skills (no. 4), Adaptability at Work (no. 6), and Attention to Detail (no. 8). Tourism practitioners, however, appear to rate strategic skills as less important, such as Decision Making (no. 12), Management Skills (no. 14), and Leadership Ability (no. 17).
'How to do' skills such as Customer Service Skills (no. 4), have higher priority than 'How to think' skills such as Critical Thinking (no. 21).
In addition, the Industry Survey also asked participants to provide OTHER skills and attributes that they considered important for the tourism industry but which were not shown in the survey list. Their responses are summarised below:
* some attributes for business purposes, such as partnership building, government and local shires relationship, business focus based on client needs
* some general skills, such as public speaking, foreign language, stress management
* some personality and background attributes, such as enthusiasm, high emotional intelligence (EI), etiquette etiquette, name for the codes of rules governing social or diplomatic intercourse. These codes vary from the more or less flexible laws of social usage (differing according to local customs or taboos) to the rigid conventions of court and military circles, and they and cultural differences, life and travel experience.
The Performance of Skills and Attributes of Employees/Co-Workers
Participants were asked to rate their level of satisfaction with their employees'/co-workers' skills and attributes using another 1-5 Likert Scale questionnaire: 0 = N/A, 1 = Extremely Dissatisfied dis·sat·is·fied
Feeling or exhibiting a lack of contentment or satisfaction.
dis·satis·fied , 2 = Dissatisfied, 3 = Neutral, 4 = Satisfied and 5 = Extremely Satisfied. The mean score of perceptions towards each attribute are presented in Table 2. The results indicate the performance (satisfaction) attributed to skills and attributes by tourism managers ranged from 3.41 to 4.15, with 3.88 as the mean value.
According to the tourism managers' perceptions, the top three satisfactory attributes relating to their employees'/co-workers' skills and attributes are Customer Service Skills, Confidence and Work Ethics. The three attributes rated as the least satisfactory include Academic Grades, Research Skills and Legal Understanding. The attribute perceived as the most satisfactory is Customer Service Skills, while the attribute perceived as the least satisfactory is Legal Understanding.
Gaps Between the Importance and Performance Level of Skills and Attributes
T tests in Table 2 indicate statistically significant importance-performance gaps (Sig. =0.000) in 23 attributes out of a total of 27. No significant importance-performance gaps were recorded for Research Skills, Legal Understanding, Events Management Skills, and Relevant Work Experience (Sig. > 0.05). Table 2 illustrates that the importance of attributes with a t value > 0 exceeds their performance ratings See benchmark. , (e.g., Oral Communication). In other words Adv. 1. in other words - otherwise stated; "in other words, we are broke"
put differently , according to respondents, tourism employees/co-workers do not perform as well as expected. In contrast, the importance of skills and attributes with a t value < 0 is lower than their performance (e.g., Academic Grades). A visual summary of the importance- performance of the skills and attributes in the tourism industry is illustrated in Figure 1. The differences between the importance level and performance level on each attribute are highlighted. In summary, an overall evaluation of the skills and attributes in the tourism industry shows that the mean score of the importance (mean = 4.26) is higher than the performance (mean = 3.88), which indicates skills and attributes are not at a level reflective of the importance assigned to them by respondents (Mount, 2000; O'Neill and Palmer, 2004).
[FIGURE 1 OMITTED]
Importance-Performance Analysis (IPA) of Skills and Attributes
In the last section, IPA was used to present the gaps between the importance and performance level of each attribute (See Figure 1). It was shown that the importance level is generally higher than the performance level of skills and attributes. In this section, an importance-performance matrix was used to present the overall positions of skills and attributes in relation to mean importance and performance. The results of tourism managers' perceptions towards the 27 attributes are plotted graphically on a two-dimensional grid, which consists of vertical and horizontal axes scaling the mean values of the importance and performance scores (See Figure 2). After plotting each attribute on an importance-performance space, the resulting space was divided into four quadrants, A = Concentrate here, B = Keep up the good work, C = Low priority, D = Possible overkill overkill Vox populi An excess of anything . The cross that separates the quadrants represents the mean importance (= 4.26, horizontal axis) and the mean performance (= 3.88, vertical axis). This traditional importance-performance matrix assists in a quick and efficient interpretation of the results. This matrix can provide guidance for strategy formulation formulation /for·mu·la·tion/ (for?mu-la´shun) the act or product of formulating.
American Law Institute Formulation and can be used to prescribe pre·scribe
To give directions, either orally or in writing, for the preparation and administration of a remedy to be used in the treatment of a disease. prioritisation of attributes for improvement (Kitcharoen, 2004).
Quadrant A: Concentrate here. Quadrant A reflects the fact that certain attributes have not been developed as well as they should, considering the importance placed on them. For example, the respondents felt that Negotiation Skills (Attribute 13) are very important, but that there is low satisfaction in terms of performance. Five skills and attributes are plotted in this quadrant: Written Communication (Attribute 2), Problem-Solving Skills (Attribute 16), Decision-Making skills (Attribute 12), Negotiation Skills (Attribute 13) and Management Skills (Attribute 4). It should be noted that all attributes in quadrant A in Figure 2 are generic attributes across universities.
Quadrant B: Keep up with the good work. Attributes plotted in quadrant B have both high importance level and high performance level. For example, the respondents were pleased by their employees'/co-workers' Oral Communication Skills (Attribute 1) and Work Ethics (Attribute 27). Nearly half (11 of 27) of all the skills and attributes are in this quadrant, which indicates overall satisfaction about employees'/co-workers' skills and attributes in the tourism industry. According to Figure 2, more than half (6 of 11) of skills and attributes in quadrant B are discipline-specific attributes.
Quadrant C: Low priority. Quadrant C indicates low prioritisation of attributes for improvement. At the high end of the quadrant are Leadership Ability (Attribute 3) and Marketing and Sales Skills (Attribute 18), which are well below the average performance level, even though these attributes are deemed to be important. However, Academic Grades (Attribute 26), Legal Understanding (Attribute 17) and Research Skills (Attribute 9), which are in the same quadrant, would be deemed to have lower priority because of both lower importance and lower performance levels attributed to these attributes by the respondents. It is interesting to note that even though Academic Grades (Attribute 26) has low priority for improvement according to the industry perceptions, Industry Knowledge (Attribute 21) is regarded as an important attribute. It appears a gap of importance level between Academic Grades and Industry Knowledge. Further study might be useful to be conducted to interpret the differences. Two discipline-specific attributes, Marketing and Sales Skills (Attribute 18) and Events Management Skills (Attribute 19), are in quadrant C in Figure 2.
[FIGURE 2 OMITTED]
Quadrant D: Possible overkill. Quadrant D reflects the fact that certain attributes are very strong, but deemed relatively unimportant by the respondents. For example, Relevant Work Experience (Attribute 25) was judged to be stronger than the average performance level, but the respondents attached relatively little importance to this attribute. At the high end of the quadrant are Computer Skills (Attribute 15) and Networking Ability (Attribute 23), which are well above the performance level, but a little bit below the average importance level. Only one discipline-specific attribute, namely Relevant Work Experience (Attribute 25), is in Quadrant D in Figure 2.
Comparison of Perceptions of Skills Between Senior and Junior Management
Table 3 presents a comparison of respective views of skill and attributes between senior and junior tourism mangers. It is interesting to note there is no considerable variance between senior and junior management and results of a t test revealed that there were no statistically significant differences. The differences between the views of senior and junior managers are mainly on several skills and attributes presented as below.
First, senior managers place a higher value on Practical Skills than junior managers do. However, junior managers place a higher value on Industry Knowledge than senior managers do. Second, it is not surprising to find senior managers consider the attribute of Leadership Ability as important, while junior managers consider the attributes of Networking Ability and Negotiation Skills as more important.
Conclusions and Recommendation
The research under discussion provides a snapshot (1) A saved copy of memory including the contents of all memory bytes, hardware registers and status indicators. It is periodically taken in order to restore the system in the event of failure.
(2) A saved copy of a file before it is updated. of the perceptions of the tourism industry in respect to the skills and attributes necessary in the pursuit of a career in tourism, and provides useful information for the curriculum design of university level tourism courses. Australia is a knowledge-based economy and universities have become an engine for developing human capital. One of the clear purposes of higher education is to produce graduates with the skills that are highly regarded by employers and that enable them to contribute to the country's prosperity and social capital (Nelson, 2002; Cleary et al., 2007).
Higher education institutions, including universities have been pushed to use funding effectively and to design curricula close to the needs of the workplace as a result of economic rationalism Economic rationalism is an Australian term in discussion of microeconomic policy, applicable to the economic policy of many governments around the world, in particular during the 1980s and 1990s. . Education in current political thinking, particularly since the 1990s, is about equipping e·quip
tr.v. e·quipped, e·quip·ping, e·quips
a. To supply with necessities such as tools or provisions.
b. people for work. If education cannot supply job-ready people, then why would governments fund it and why would students choose it? Knowledge for knowledge's sake is an idealistic i·de·al·is·tic
Of, relating to, or having the nature of an idealist or idealism.
ide·al·is unaffordable un·af·ford·a·ble
Too expensive: medical care that has become unaffordable for many.
un luxury, and higher education must be relevant to the needs of employers. Tourism higher education, with its strong vocationally oriented o·ri·ent
1. Orient The countries of Asia, especially of eastern Asia.
a. The luster characteristic of a pearl of high quality.
b. A pearl having exceptional luster.
3. nature, needs to be relevant to the needs and expectations of the tourism industry. As Fayos-Sola (1997) stated, the adoption of the UNWTO's TEDQUAL TEDQUAL Tourism Education Quality methodology in the tourism education could benefit all stakeholders Stakeholders
All parties that have an interest, financial or otherwise, in a firm-stockholders, creditors, bondholders, employees, customers, management, the community, and the government. during the process. Students acquire smooth placement and promotion; employers find the right staff to lead the prospects of the industry; and government bodies effectively manage the labour market (Magablih, 2009). With the emphasis on stakeholder stakeholder n. a person having in his/her possession (holding) money or property in which he/she has no interest, right or title, awaiting the outcome of a dispute between two or more claimants to the money or property. engagement (particularly from the tourism industry), this research provides industry-based information for the development of professionals for the global tourism industry through the improvement of curriculum design, as well as tourism human resource management.
DOI (Digital Object Identifier) A method of applying a persistent name to documents, publications and other resources on the Internet rather than using a URL, which can change over time. 10.1375/jhtm.16.1.62
University Generic Skills and Tourism Specific Attributes
Southern Cross University need students graduating from the School of Tourism and Hospitality Management to demonstrate the following 11 attributes:
1. A commitment to excellence in all scholarly and intellectual activities
2. A substantial knowledge of tourism and hospitality industries within both local and international contexts
3. An awareness of the cultural, environmental and economic impacts of tourism and hospitality management
4. A deep understanding of those skills relevant to working and managing in tourism and/or hospitality
5. The ability to communicate effectively, and be self-aware and empathetic em·pa·thet·ic
6. Be culturally tolerant and demonstrate appropriate intercultural competence
7. Have an understanding of ethical standards and professionalism
8. Be lifelong independent learners, reflective in practice, and information literate
9. Be creative, strategic and critical thinkers with highly developed problem solving problem solving
Process involved in finding a solution to a problem. Many animals routinely solve problems of locomotion, food finding, and shelter through trial and error. skills
10. Have an understanding of team dynamics
11. Exhibit a positive work attitude and work ethic work ethic
A set of values based on the moral virtues of hard work and diligence.
a belief in the moral value of work in order to achieve successful outcomes
(A guide to flexible teaching for quality learning, SCU, 2006).
Griffith University adopts the following 12 graduate skills:
1. Rigorous standards of scholarship
2. Equity and social justice
3. Sense of civic responsibility
4. Respect for social and international diversity
5. Communicate effectively
6. Be information literate
7. Solve problems
8. Make critical evaluations
9. Work autonomously and in teams
10. Be creative and innovative
11. Behave ethically in social, professional and work environments
12. Be responsible and effective citizens
(Griffith policies on graduate skills, 2006).
Murdoch University describes nine attributes for a graduate:
2. Critical and creative thinking
3. Social interaction
4. Independent and lifelong learning Lifelong learning is the concept that "It's never too soon or too late for learning", a philosophy that has taken root in a whole host of different organisations. Lifelong learning is attitudinal; that one can and should be open to new ideas, decisions, skills or behaviors.
6. Social justice
7. Global perspective
9. In-depth knowledge of a field of study
(The nine attributes of a Murdoch graduate and the subattributes, 2006).
The University of Canberra has developed the following 10 skills and attributes as generic skills:
2. Information literacy Several conceptions and definitions of information literacy have become prevalent. For example, one conception defines information literacy in terms of a set of competencies that an informed citizen of an information society ought to possess to participate intelligently and and numeracy numeracy Mathematical literacy Neurology The ability to understand mathematical concepts, perform calculations and interpret and use statistical information. Cf Acalculia.
3. Information and communication technology
4. Problem solving
5. Working with others
6. Effective workplace skills
7. Professional ethics professional ethics,
n the rules governing the conduct, transactions, and relationships within a profession and among its publics.
professional ethics liability,
8. Social responsibility
9. Lifelong learning
10. Personal attributes
(Policies and procedures of UC, 2002).
Charles Darwin University has developed the following eight skills:
1. Technology skills
2. Problem-solving skills
3. Planning and organising skills
4. Self-management skills
5. Initiative and enterprise skills
6. Learning skills
7. Communication skills
8. Team work skills
(Graduate attributes and employment skills of CDU, 2006).
The University of Queensland provides a list of 13 tourism graduate attributes for tourism and travel students:
1. Ability to speak another language (a definite advantage.
2. Ability to think logically
3. Attention to detail
4. Enjoyment from dealing with people
5. Excellent interpersonal in·ter·per·son·al
1. Of or relating to the interactions between individuals: interpersonal skills.
2. and supervisory skills
6. Good grooming and presentation
7. Good health (passing a medical examination may be required in some positions.
8. Good marketing skills
9. Organisational/management ability
10. Patience and tact
11. Understanding of a range of services
12. Well-developed oral and written communication skills
13. Willingness to work irregular hours
(Statement of graduate attributes, UQ, 2006).
Victoria University highlights following eight attributes as employability skills:
2. Team work
4. Using initiative and enterprise
5. Planning and organising
(Employability skills, VU, 2006).
A guide to flexible teaching for quality learning. (2006). Retrieved from Southern Cross University website: http://www.scu.edu.au/services/ tl/pathways/designing/designing2.html#decide_generic_skills
Airey, D. (2005). Growth and development. In D. Airey & J. Tribe (Eds.), An international handbook of tourism education (pp. 13-24). Oxford: Elsevier.
Airey, D., & Frontistis, A. (1997). Attitudes to careers in tourism: An Anglo Greek comparison. Tourism Management, 18(3), 149-158.
Airey, D., & Tribe, J. (2005) Issues for the future. In D. Airey & J. Tribe (Eds.), An international handbook of tourism education (pp. 501-506). Oxford: Elsevier.
Airey, D., & Johnson, S. (1999). The content of tourism degree courses in the UK. Tourism Management, 20(2), 229-235.
Amoah, V., & Baum, T. (1997). Tourism education: Policy versus practice. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management, 9(1), 5-12.
Australia's House of Representatives, Employment, Workplace Relations and Workforce Participation Committee (2007). A new approach needed to increase the tourism workforce. Canberra, Australia: Author.
Ayres, H.J. (2006). Influence on career development in Australian tourism. Doctoral thesis, University of Canberra, Australia.
Byeong-Yong, K., & Oh, M. (2002). An extended application of importance-performance analysis. Journal of Hospitality and Leisure Marketing, 9(3/4), 107-125.
Cleary, M., Flynn, R., Thomasson, S., Alexander, R., & McDonald, B. (2007). Graduate employability skills: Prepared for the Business, Industry and Higher Education Collaboration Council, Commonwealth of Australia Commonwealth of Australia: see Australia. . Available at http://www.dest.gov.au/hi
Cooper, C., Shepherd, R., & Westlake, J. (1996) Educating the educators in tourism." A manual of tourism and hospitality education. Guildford, Surrey: World Tourism Organization and University of Surrey The University of Surrey is a public university in Guildford, England. It received its charter on 9 September 1966, and was situated near Battersea Park in south-west London. The institution was known as Battersea College of Technology before gaining university status. .
Department of Education, Science and Training (DEST). (2006). Employability skills: From framework to practice. Canberra, Australia: Author.
Department of Industry, Tourism and Resources (DITR) (2002). Tourism workforce and training (Research Report No. 4). Canberra, Australia: Author.
Fayos-Sola, E. (1997). Introduction to TEDQUAL: A methodology for quality in tourism education and training. Madrid: The World Tourism Organization.
Flohr, S. (2001). An analysis of British postgraduate courses in tourism: What roles does sustainability play within higher education? Journal of Sustainable Tourism There are many different definitions of sustainable tourism. Sustainable tourism in its purest sense, is an industry which attempts to make a low impact on the environment and local culture, while helping to generate income and employment for locals, as well as to promote the , 9(6), 505-513.
Employability skills for the future. (2002). Victoria University. Available at http://tls.vu.edu.au/sled/QTIU/programs/employability/ ACCI ACCI Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry
ACCI American Council on Consumer Interests
ACCI Association of Crafts & Creative Industries
ACCI American Consortium of Certified Interpreters
ACCI African Center for Crop Improvement
ACCI Air Compliance Consultants Inc. _ Employability%20 skills.pdf
Generic skills and attributes of University of Canberra graduates from undergraduate and postgraduate coursework coursework
work done by a student and assessed as part of an educational course
Noun 1. coursework - work assigned to and done by a student during a course of study; usually it is evaluated as part of the student's courses. (2007). Retrieved from University of Canberra website: http://www.canberra.edu.au/uc/policiesda/acad/generic.html
Graduate attributes and employment skills. (2007). Retrieved from Charles Darwin University website: http://www.cdu.edu.au/graduateattributes/ employabilityskills.html
Graduate attributes of tourism and hospitality courses. (2007). Retrieved from Southern Cross University website:http://www.scu.edu.au/schools/ tourism/index.php/47/
Graduate Career, Australia. (2007). A summary of the graduate outlook survey. Graduate Career Australia Ltd. Available at http://www.graduatecareers.com.au/content/download/ 3440/14411/file/Snapshot%20-%20Graduate%20Outlook%202007.pdf
Hjalager, A., & Andersen, S. (2001). Tourism employment: Contingent work Contingent work, also sometimes known as casual work, is a neologism which describes a type of employment relationship between an employer and employee. There is no universally agreed consensus on what type of working arrangement constitutes contingent work or professional career? Employee Relations, 23(2), 115-129.
Jacob, K.E., & Kai, K. (2006). Enhancing importance-performance analysis. International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management, 55(1/2).
Jolliffe, L., & Farnsworth, R. (2003). Seasonality in tourism employment: Human resource challenges. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality, 15(6), 312-316.
King, B., Mckercher, B., & Waryszak, R. (2003). A comparative study of hospitality and tourism graduates in Australia and Hong Kong Hong Kong (hŏng kŏng), Mandarin Xianggang, special administrative region of China, formerly a British crown colony (2005 est. pop. 6,899,000), land area 422 sq mi (1,092 sq km), adjacent to Guangdong prov. . International Journal of Tourism Research, 5, 409-420.
King, B., & Craig-Smith, S. (2005). International tourism education: Australasia. In D. Airey, & J. Tribe (Eds.), An international handbook of tourism education (pp. 111-121). Oxford: Elsevier.
Kitcharoen, K. (2004). The importance-performance analysis of service quality in administrative departments of private universities in Thailand The following is a list of academic institutes of higher education in Thailand. Public Universities
Koh, K. (1995). Designing the four-year tourism management curriculum: A marketing approach. Journal of Travel Research, Summer, 68-72.
Ladkin, A. (2005). Careers and employment. In D. Airey & J. Tribe (Eds.), An international handbook of tourism education (pp. 437-450). Oxford: Elsevier.
Magablih, K. (2009). Tourism education quality (TEDQUAL) in Jordan: a conceptual approach. Retrieved July 26, 2009 from www.ul.edu.lb/ fthm/papers/1st%20Axis/Quality.doc
Martilla, J.A. & James, J.C. (1977). Importance-performance analysis. Journey of Marketing, 41(1), 77-79.
McKercher, B. (2002). The future of tourism education: An Australian scenario. Tourism and Hospitality Research, 3(3), 199.
Morgan, M.E. (2004). From production line to drama school: higher education for the future of tourism. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management, 16(2), 91.
Mount, D.J. (2000). Determination of significant issues: Applying a quantitative method to Importance Performance analysis. Journal of Quality Assurance in Hospitality & Tourism, 1(3), 49-63.
Nelson, B. (2002). Higher education at the crossroads. Canberra: Commonwealth Department of Education, Science and Training.
Okumus, F., & Wong, K.F. (2004, September). A content analysis of strategic management syllabi syl·la·bi
A plural of syllabus. : Which teaching methods are used and are they appropriate? Workshop held at the 2004 ISTTE ISTTE International Society of Travel and Tourism Educators Annual Conference, Hong Kong SAR (Segmentation And Reassembly) The protocol that converts data to cells for transmission over an ATM network. It is the lower part of the ATM Adaption Layer (AAL), which is responsible for the entire operation. See AAL.
SAR - segmentation and reassembly , China.
O'Neill, M.A, & Palmer, A. (2004). Importance-performance analysis: A useful tool for directing continuous quality improvement in higher education. Quality Assurance in Education, 12(1), 39-52.
Palenthiran, K., Bhattarai, P, Geng, L., & Deng, W. (2006). Graduate attributes challenge report. Available at http://www.uow.edu.au/ careers/discover/TEC/2006/CommerceAccountingFinance.pdf
Pearce, P.L. (2005). Australian tourism education: the quest for Verb 1. quest for - go in search of or hunt for; "pursue a hobby"
quest after, go after, pursue
look for, search, seek - try to locate or discover, or try to establish the existence of; "The police are searching for clues"; "They are searching for the status. In C.H. Hsu (Ed.), Global tourism higher education: past, present, and future (pp. 251-267). NY: The Haworth Hospitality Press.
Riley, M., Ladkin, A., & Szivas, E. (2002). Tourism employment." Analysis and planning. UK: Channel View Publications.
Ross, G.F. (1992). Working at leisure: Secondary school students' occupational and training preferences for tourism and hospitality industry work. Australian Journal of Leisure and Recreation, 1 (3), 21-22.
Ross, G.F. (1993). Management and life values as predictors of tourism/hospitality industry employment interest levels among potential employees. Asia-Pacific Journal of Human Resources The fancy word for "people." The human resources department within an organization, years ago known as the "personnel department," manages the administrative aspects of the employees. , 31 (2), 104-117.
Ross, G.F. (1997). Tourism/hospitality industry employment acquisition strategies, higher education preferences and the work ethic among Australian secondary school graduates. Managing Leisure, 2, 82-93.
Statement of graduate attributes. (2006). Retrieved from The University of Queensland website: http://www.uq.edu.au/hupp/index.html? policy=3.20.5
Szivas, E., Riley, M., & Airey, D. (2003). Labour mobility into tourism. Annals an·nals
1. A chronological record of the events of successive years.
2. A descriptive account or record; a history: "the short and simple annals of the poor" of Tourism Research, 30(1), 64-76.
Tan, J., & Morgan, D. (2002). Future development of Australian Tourism Curriculum: Views from Education and the Tourism Industry. Pacific Tourism Review, 6, 61-65.
The context for graduate skills development. (2006). Retrieved from Griffith University website: http://www.griffith.edu.au/centre/gihe/griffith_ graduate/skills.htm
The nine attributes of a Murdoch graduate and the sub-attributes. (2006). Retrieved from Murdoch University website: http://www.tlc.murdoch.edu.au/gradatt/attributes.html
Tribe, J. (2005). Overview of research. In: D. Airey & J. Tribe (Eds.), An international handbook of tourism education (pp. 25-43). Oxford: Elsevier.
Wang, J. (2008), A gap analysis between tourism curriculum and industry needs & expectations: A case of THE-ICE institutions in Australia. Masters thesis, University of Canberra, Australia.
Wang, J., Ayres, H., & Huyton, J. (2008). Is tourism education meeting the needs of the tourism industry? An Australian case study. Journal of Tourism and Hospitality Education (Forthcoming).
Yong, I. (2007). Building better pathways to higher education. Retrieved from Swinburne University website: http://www.swinburne.edu. au/chance/vc/documents/opinionpieces/BuildingBetterPathways.pdf
School of Tourism, The University of Queensland, Australia
Helen Ayres and Jeremy Huyton
University of Canberra, Australia
Jie Wang, The School of Tourism, University of Queensland, Brisbane QLD QLD or Qld Queensland 4072, Australia. E-mail: email@example.com
Table 1 A List of 27 Skills and Attributes Graduate attributes: Skills and Attributes 1 Academic Grades 2 Adaptability at Work 3 Attention to Detail 4 Computer Skills 5 Confidence 6 Creativity 7 Critical Thinking 8 Customer Service Skills 9 Decision Making 10 Events Management Skills 11 Industry Knowledge 12 Leadership Ability 13 Legal Understanding 14 Management Skills 15 Marketing and Sales Skills 16 Negotiation Skills 17 Networking Ability 18 Oral Communication 19 Organisational Ability 20 Practical Skills 21 Problem Solving Skills 22 Relationship Management Skills 23 Relevant Work Experience 24 Research Skills 25 Team Working Skills 26 Work Ethics 27 Written Communication Note. * list in alphabetical order. Table 2 Tourism Managers' Views on Skills and Attributes Graduate attributes: Importance (b) Skills and Attributes Mean SD Rank (a) Oral communication 4.86 0.41 1 Relationship management 4.67 0.55 2 skills Work ethics 4.61 0.60 3 Customer service skills 4.59 0.60 4 Team working skills 4.57 0.57 5 Adaptability at work 4.52 0.60 6 Written communication 4.51 0.65 7 Attention to detail 4.49 0.58 8 Confidence 4.41 0.62 9 Problem-solving skills 4.41 0.61 9 Organisational ability 4.40 0.61 11 Decision-making 4.38 0.59 12 Negotiation skills 4.36 0.66 13 Management skills 4.31 0.60 14 Practical skills 4.31 0.72 14 Industry knowledge 4.30 0.73 16 Leadership ability 4.26 0.55 17 Marketing and sales 4.26 0.68 17 skills Networking ability 4.26 0.72 19 Computer skills 4.22 0.59 20 Critical thinking 4.18 0.72 21 Creativity 4.10 0.72 22 Events management skills 3.85 0.82 23 Relevant work experience 3.84 0.81 24 Research skills 372 0.85 25 Legal understanding 3.54 0.76 26 Academic grades 3.18 0.84 27 The total average score 4.26 Graduate attributes: Performance (c) Skills and Attributes Mean SD Rank (a) Oral communication 4.07 0.68 6 Relationship management 3.89 0.73 13 skills Work ethics 4.121 0.77 3 Customer service skills 4.15 0.81 1 Team working skills 4.09 0.80 5 Adaptability at work 4.03 0.72 7 Written communication 3.86 0.82 16 Attention to detail 3.89 0.82 13 Confidence 4.122 0.62 2 Problem-solving skills 3.87 0.68 15 Organisational ability 3.97 0.77 8 Decision-making 3.77 0.76 20 Negotiation skills 3.74 0.73 22 Management skills 3.77 0.74 20 Practical skills 3.93 0.74 10 Industry knowledge 4.10 0.69 4 Leadership ability 3.79 0.80 19 Marketing and sales 3.82 0.82 18 skills Networking ability 3.93 0.82 10 Computer skills 3.95 0.74 9 Critical thinking 3.71 0.78 24 Creativity 3.73 0.75 23 Events management skills 3.85 0.79 17 Relevant work experience 3.90 0.72 12 Research skills 3.60 0.78 26 Legal understanding 3.41 0.78 27 Academic grades 3.62 0.70 25 The total average score 3.88 Graduate attributes: T test Mean Sig. Skills and Attributes Difference T value (2-tailed) Oral communication 0.80 13.043 0.000 Relationship management 0.78 11.407 0.000 skills Work ethics 0.49 6.731 0.000 Customer service skills 0.45 5.852 0.000 Team working skills 0.48 6.583 0.000 Adaptability at work 0.49 6.968 0.000 Written communication 0.65 8.291 0.000 Attention to detail 0.60 8.023 0.000 Confidence 0.29 4.387 0.000 Problem-solving skills 0.54 8.015 0.000 Organisational ability 0.43 5.925 0.000 Decision-making 0.61 8.452 0.000 Negotiation skills 0.63 8.552 0.000 Management skills 0.55 7.704 0.000 Practical skills 0.38 4.905 0.000 Industry knowledge 0.20 2.678 0.008 Leadership ability 0.47 6.372 0.000 Marketing and sales 0.44 5.614 0.000 skills Networking ability 0.33 4.052 0.000 Computer skills 0.27 3.852 0.000 Critical thinking 0.47 5.896 0.000 Creativity 0.37 4.71 0.000 Events management skills -0.01 -0.061 0.951 Relevant work experience -0.06 -0.725 0.469 Research skills 0.11 1.313 0.190 Legal understanding 0.14 1.653 0.099 Academic grades -0.44 -5.166 0.000 The total average score 0.387 Note: (a.) Rank in order of Importance 1 = highest mean score, 27 = lowest mean score. (b.) Level of importance. 1-5 scale; 1 = Extremely Unimportant, ... 5 = Extremely Important. (c.) Level of performance (satisfaction); 1-5 scale, 1 = Extremely Dissatisfied, ... 5 = Extremely Satisfied. Table 3 Perceptions of Skills Compared Between Senior and Junior Management (n= 200) Skills and attributes View of Senior View of Junior Mean (b) Rank (a) Mean (b) Rank (a) Oral communication 4.83 1 4.89 1 Relationship management 4.64 2 4.69 2 skills Customer service skills 4.54 3 4.63 4 Team working skills 4.53 4 4.60 5 Work ethics 4.52 5 4.67 3 Adaptability at work 4.48 6 4.54 7 Written communication 4.43 7 4.56 6 Attention to detail 4.43 7 4.53 8 Problem-solving skills 4.39 9 4.43 9 Confidence 4.38 10 4.43 9 Organisational ability 4.38 10 4.42 11 Decision-making 4.37 12 4.39 13 Practical skills 4.35 13 4.29 17 Management skills 4.31 14 4.32 15 Negotiation skills 4.29 15 4.42 11 Leadership ability 4.26 16 4.26 20 Marketing and sales 4.22 17 4.29 17 skills Critical thinking 4.19 18 4.18 21 Industry knowledge 4.18 19 4.38 14 Networking ability 4.17 20 4.32 15 Computer skills 4.14 21 4.28 19 Creativity 4.08 22 4.11 22 Events management skills 3.78 23 3.89 24 Relevant work experience 3.71 24 3.92 23 Research skills 3.58 25 3.81 25 Legal understanding 3.48 26 3.58 26 Academic grades 3.14 27 3.20 27 Skills and attributes Difference t test of rank Sig. T value (2-tailed) Oral communication 0 -0.876 0.383 Relationship management 0 -0.672 0.503 skills Customer service skills -1 -1.014 0.312 Team working skills -1 -0.753 0.453 Work ethics 2 -1.648 0.102 Adaptability at work -1 -0.643 0.521 Written communication 1 -1.351 0.178 Attention to detail -1 -1.187 0.237 Problem-solving skills 0 -0.397 0.692 Confidence 1 -0.629 0.530 Organisational ability -1 -0.451 0.653 Decision-making -1 -0.198 0.844 Practical skills -4 0.565 0.573 Management skills -1 -0.047 0.962 Negotiation skills 4 -1.343 0.181 Leadership ability -4 -0.042 0.967 Marketing and sales 0 -0.686 0.493 skills Critical thinking -3 0.185 0.854 Industry knowledge 5 -1.792 0.075 Networking ability 5 -1.380 0.169 Computer skills 2 -1.527 0.129 Creativity 0 -0.341 0.734 Events management skills -1 -0.952 0.342 Relevant work experience 1 -1.707 0.090 Research skills 0 -1.784 0.076 Legal understanding 0 -0.924 0.357 Academic grades 0 -0.462 0.645 Note: (a.) Rank in order of importance. 1 = highest mean score, 27 = lowest mean score. (b.) Level of importance. 1-5 scale, 1 = Extremely unimportant, 5 = Extremely important.