Printer Friendly
The Free Library
4,487,687 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

Jefferson Davis's Generals.


Edited by Gabor S. Boritt. Gettysburg Civil War Institute Books. (New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999. Pp. [xviii], 217. Paper, $14.95, ISBN 0-19-513921-6; cloth, $27.50, ISBN 0-19-512062-0.)

In this volume, which consists of eight essays that were originally presented at a 1998 Gettysburg Civil War Institute conference, Craig L. Symonds leads off with an examination of the "fatal relationship" between President Jefferson Davis and General Joseph E. Johnston. Symonds argues that their troubled, dysfunctional partnership was rooted in their personalities and experiences, took the form of a lack of communication, greatly hampered the Rebels' war effort, and was "primarily Johnston's fault" (p. 14). Emory M. Thomas then examines the "ambivalent visions of victory" held by Davis and Robert E. Lee. Thomas maintains that in 1862, when the secessionists adopted an "offensive defense" strategy (p. 31), Lee emphasized the former part of the formula and Davis the latter. For this reason, the president and his general found themselves "operating in less than concert" (p. 37), and that lack of strategic coordination hampered military operations in Virginia.

In his essay T. Michael Parrish maintains that although General P. G. T. Beauregard disliked Davis personally, lacked confidence in the president's conduct of the war, and expressed such feelings in private, he fully accepted Davis's authority as commander-in-chief and did not break openly with Davis until after the war. Parrish thinks that most historians have misjudged the wartime relationship between the two. Steven E. Woodworth evaluates General Braxton Bragg, pronouncing him a much better commander than most have thought. The real problem, Woodworth argues, was Davis's refusal to deal with Bragg's troublemaking subordinate Leonidas Polk, who "spread the poison of discontent" inside Bragg's army (p. 79).

Herman Hattaway describes John Bell Hood as a general whom Davis "elevated too high" when he named him to army command in July 1864 (p. 84). Lesley J. Gordon explores the role of Varina (Mrs. Jefferson) Davis and the wives of four Rebel generals (Johnston, Bragg, Beauregard, and Lee). Harold Holzer describes Davis's image as it was portrayed in the popular prints of the period. James M. McPherson closes the collection with an essay on Davis and Confederate strategy that asks, "Was the Best Defense a Good Offense?"

As always with such collections, these studies vary in quality and readability, but all are thought-provoking and informative. Gordon's is arguably the weakest, but the fault lies with the lack of sources for her topic. Her thesis--that generals' wives can and often do play a significant role in their husbands' careers--is certainly valid and cries out for more study. (We should note, however, that Mrs. Beauregard spent the war in New Orleans, a city under Federal occupation after April 1862, and for that reason she could have played virtually no role in her husband's Civil War career, even had she not died in March 1864.)

I think the collection would have been greatly improved had it included a study of the man who may well have been the most important general to Jefferson Davis--Albert Sidney Johnston. An index would also have helped, since many individuals and topics pop up in two or more of the essays. The real problem here, however, is one of focus and subject matter. "Jefferson Davis," an adjective in the book's title, becomes a noun insofar as he is the major subject of all the essays except Gordon's. Three of the essays (Gordon's, Holzer's, and McPherson's) have almost nothing to do with Davis's generals. The book really needs a title that more accurately reflects its subject matter.
RICHARD M. MCMURRY
Roanoke, Virginia
COPYRIGHT 2002 Southern Historical Association
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2002, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:McMurry, Richard M.
Publication:Journal of Southern History
Article Type:Book Review
Date:Nov 1, 2002
Words:600
Previous Article:The Bell Irvin Wiley Reader.(Book Review)(Brief Article)
Next Article:Lincoln at Home: Two Glimpses of Abraham Lincoln's Family Life.(Book Review)(Brief Article)



Related Articles
Jefferson Davis: Unconquerable Heart.
The Reunion.(Review)
"To Live and Die in Dixie": How the South Formed a Nation.
Jefferson Davis, American.
An Honorable Defeat: the Last Days of the Confederate Government.(Book Review)
Look Away! A History of the Confederate States of America.(Book Review)
Davis, Kenneth C. Don't know much about Thomas Jefferson.(Brief Article)(Young Adult Review)(Book Review)
Winfield Scott and the Profession of Arms.(Book Review)
Jefferson Davis: The Essential Writings.(Book Notes)(Brief Article)(Book Review)
The Death and Resurrection of Jefferson Davis.(Book review)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2008 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles