Jarhead and deskilling in the military: potential implications for the Australian labour market.Abstract
This paper uses a popular culture medium to examine the notion of deskilling Deskilling is the process by which skilled labor within an industry or economy is eliminated by the introduction of technologies operated by semiskilled or unskilled workers. in one particular sector, viz., the military. Jarhead jar·head
A U.S. Marine.
[Perhaps from the shape of the hat the Marines once wore.] was released to cinemas in 2005 and follows the experiences of United States United States, officially United States of America, republic (2005 est. pop. 295,734,000), 3,539,227 sq mi (9,166,598 sq km), North America. The United States is the world's third largest country in population and the fourth largest country in area. Marine, Anthony Swofford, in the first Gulf War of the early 1990s. We witness the central character undergo intensive training to become one of the Marine's highly skilled employees--a sniper See sniping software. . We observe Swofford and his colleagues' increasing frustrations with their inability to 'ply their trade'. While the sniper was a highly skilled, indeed elite, fighter in earlier conflicts, technological developments have left this skilled artisan as a bystander by·stand·er
A person who is present at an event without participating in it.
a person present but not involved; onlooker; spectator
Noun 1. in modern set-piece warfare. This paper adds to our understanding of the tensions between traditional skilled occupations and technological development, in addition to the tensions between military skills and non-military employment. Using the Hollywood movie Jarhead as a lens, the audience witnesses the manner in which technology leads to a divergence in workplace skills. Finally, this paper considers the implications for the Australian labour market.
Jarhead, released to cinemas in 2005, follows the experiences of Anthony Swofford (Jake Gyllenhaal Jacob Benjamin Gyllenhaal (born December 19 1980) is an Academy Award-nominated American actor. The son of director Stephen Gyllenhaal and screenwriter Naomi Foner, Gyllenhaal began acting at 11 years old. ) and is based on his bestselling memoir of the first Gulf War entitled Jarhead: A Marine's Chronicle of the Gulf War and Other Battles (2003). Nicknamed Swoff, Jarhead's protagonist is a young man who, as with many Marine Corps enlistees, comes from a Marine Corps family. He is a third-generation enlistee. Upon signing up, Swoff is sent to the mandatory Marine Corps boot camp Software from Apple that enables an Intel x86-based Macintosh to host the Windows XP operating system. Boot Camp is used to divide the hard disk into Windows and Mac partitions, to install the necessary drivers and to create a dual boot environment. , where he becomes a 'Jarhead'. As Swoff explains, this is the self-imposed Marine Corps moniker (1) A name, title or alias. See alias.
(2) A COM object that is used to create instances of other objects. Monikers save programmers time when coding various types of COM-based functions such as linking one document to another (OLE). See COM and OLE. referring to 'the resemblance to a jar of the regulation high and tight haircut', in addition to the status of the raw recruit Noun 1. raw recruit - an inexperienced and untrained recruit
military recruit, recruit - a recently enlisted soldier as 'an empty vessel' ready to acquire new skills. Indeed, Swoff does acquire new skills. He becomes one of the Marine Corps' elite, a sniper. Snipers have traditionally played a substantial and significant role in combat owing to owing to
Because of; on account of: I couldn't attend, owing to illness.
owing to prep → debido a, por causa de their highly developed skills; however, Jarhead tells us a different story, with the highly-skilled craft-workers becoming obsolete in their chosen career because of technological development.
This paper uses a popular culture medium, viz., the 'Hollywood blockbuster' film, to explore the tensions between technology and the skilled worker. Furthermore, it examines the current position of the Australian Defence Force
The Australian Defence Force (ADF) is the military organisation responsible for the defence of Australia. (ADF (1) (Application Development Facility) An IBM programmer-oriented mainframe application generator that runs under IMS.
(2) (Automatic Document Feeder) A paper stacker that feeds one sheet of paper at a time into the unit. ) as a major employer in the Australian labour market. There has been substantial media, academic and political debate in Australia about the lack of skilled trades-people within the Australian labour market (Hall and Fenwick 2006). As one of Australia's largest employers, the ADF faces the same 'skills shortage' as that confronting private enterprise. This is particularly relevant to the Australian context at this point in time. Indeed, the ADF is currently facing substantial problems with recruiting new personnel, especially in view of former Prime Minister John Howard's announcement in August 2006 that two more infantry battalions would be added to the Royal Australian Regiment The Royal Australian Regiment (RAR) is the parent regiment for regular infantry battalions of the Australian Army, making up the majority of the Royal Australian Infantry Corps. (RAR RAR Retinoic Acid Receptor
RAR Resource Adapter Archive (J2EE)
RAR Royal Australian Regiment
RAR Risk Assessment Report
RAR Roshal Archive (WinRAR compressed file format; file extension) ), a total of around 2,600 men (Bartlett 2006). As a consequence, we suggest that the development, the maintenance, the use and, what is more, the transferability of skills is an important issue for the ADF.
This paper will first provide a synopsis of Jarhead. It will then investigate the notion of skills in the workplace, starting with the seminal research of Harry Braverman Harry Braverman (1920 – 1976) was an American Communist and political writer. He sometimes used the pseudonym Harry Frankel.
Braverman became active in the American Trotskyist movement in 1937 and soon joined the newly founded Socialist Workers Party. (1974) that ignited ig·nite
v. ig·nit·ed, ig·nit·ing, ig·nites
a. To cause to burn.
b. To set fire to.
2. To subject to great heat, especially to make luminous by heat. a substantial debate on the role that technology plays in influencing workplace skills. This done, the paper will explore the tensions within Jarhead when the highly-skilled craft-worker finds technology making their skills irrelevant. Finally, the paper will discuss military employees, with particular reference to the skills acquired in their training and the transferability of these skills to non-military labour markets.
The Elite of the Elite--The Marine Corps Sniper
The Marine Corps boot camp is a dehumanising ritual made especially famous by Stanley Kubrick's brutal Full Metal Jacket Noun 1. full metal jacket - a lead bullet that is covered with a jacket of a harder metal (usually copper)
bullet, slug - a projectile that is fired from a gun , in addition to more light-hearted fare such as 1960s sitcom Gomer Pyle Gomer Pyle was the simple-minded gas station attendant and later auto mechanic in the American TV sitcom The Andy Griffith Show, played by Jim Nabors. Nabors continued the character in his own starring vehicle, Gomer Pyle, U.S.M.C. from 1964-69. , U.S.M.C. Despite this, the boot camp also embodies the acquisition and development of specialist skills. Thus, as part of his intensive Marine Corps training, Swoff learns the trade of the Scout/Sniper. The U.S. Marine Corps, which is larger than the armies of most countries, regards itself as an elite body. Indeed, it is known as 'The President's Own' (the Marine Corps supplies the President's helicopter) and is trained for highly specialised duties such as amphibious assault Noun 1. amphibious assault - an amphibious operation attacking a land base that is carried out by troops that are landed by naval ships
amphibious operation - a military operation by both land and sea forces
and helicopter insertion, the successful execution of which requires extensive training and intensive skills development. Moreover, the Corps is 'designed to project American power onto hostile shores' (Moskin 1979, p. 704), and thus acts as a mobile force-in-readiness, as it has done since the campaign against the Barbary pirates Noun 1. Barbary pirate - a pirate along the Barbary Coast
buccaneer, sea robber, sea rover, pirate - someone who robs at sea or plunders the land from the sea without having a commission from any sovereign nation in 1805 (Selby 1972). Thus the snipers, with their additional combat skills, represent, at least from the Corps' perspective, the elite of the elite. As Staff Sergeant staff sergeant
a. Abbr. SSG A noncommissioned rank in the U.S. Army that is above sergeant and below sergeant first class.
b. Abbr. SSgt A noncommissioned rank in the U.S. Sykes, Swoff's mentor, explains, 'It's an honour' and an 'opportunity' to be a Scout/Sniper.
With his companions, Swoff travels to the Middle East expecting to battle the forces of Saddam Hussein Saddam Hussein
(born April 28, 1937, Tikrit, Iraq—died Dec. 30, 2006, Baghdad) President of Iraq (1979–2003). He joined the Ba'th Party in 1957. Following participation in a failed attempt to assassinate Iraqi Pres. as part of Operation Desert Shield. Although Swoff and his comrades-in-arms initially expect to be on active duty for two weeks, he eventually spends' 165 days, 14 hours, five minutes' camped in the desert waiting for 'his' war to begin. As we see, it never really does Warren Trotter, better known as Really Doe, is an American rapper from Chicago, Illinois. He is affiliated with Kanye West and his G.O.O.D. Music family and label. Discography
1. Producing thunder or a similar sound.
2. Loud and unrestrained in a way that suggests thunder: thunderous applause. tones of war in the distance. Importantly, the combat is so distant it is often beyond the reach of a sniper's bullet. Modern war is now technological war, or at least that is the point that Jarhead emphasises. What is more, the Marine on the ground is no longer necessarily 'First to Fight', the motto used since the First World War (Moskin 1979), but is now often a bystander in armed conflict.
The sniper is charged with one of the most dangerous, skilful skil·ful
adj. Chiefly British
Variant of skillful.
skilful or US skillful
having or showing skill
skilfully or US
and lonely missions, that is, hunting down enemy officers and targets of opportunity by means of stealth, and then escaping detection after claiming the target (Henderson 1988; Sasser and Roberts 1990). A sniper is also an extremely efficient killer. In Vietnam, for example, the average number of bullets used per kill by snipers was 1.3 to 1.7, while ordinary infantrymen expended ex·pend
tr.v. ex·pend·ed, ex·pend·ing, ex·pends
1. To lay out; spend: expending tax revenues on government operations. See Synonyms at spend.
2. more than 200,000 bullets to kill one enemy soldier (Sasser and Roberts 1990; Lanning 1998). Those snipers famously fa·mous·ly
1. In a way or to an extent that is well known: "his famously neurotic mannerisms [are] lampooned in the novels of Evelyn Waugh" deployed in the mud of no-man's land No-Man's land Hand surgery A fanciful term for the fibrous sheath of the flexor tendons of the hand, specifically in the zone from the distal palmar crease to the proximal interphalangeal joint. See Rule of threes. during the First World War could stay motionless and without food for hours at a time, a constant menace whose impact on the course of the war was far more psychological than tangible. Sniping continued into the Second World War, as is witnessed in Enemy at the Gates (2001), which is set on the Russian front during the street-fighting in the Battle of Stalingrad The Battle of Stalingrad was a battle between Germany and its allies and the Soviet Union for the Soviet city of Stalingrad (today known as Volgograd) that took place between August 21 1942 and February 2 1943, as part of World War II. and celebrates the exploits of two elite German and Russian marksmen (Gilbert 1997, pp. 94-95), and into the Vietnam era Vietnam Era is a term used by the United States Department of Veterans Affairs to classify veterans of the Vietnam War. The Vietnam Era is considered to have begun in 1964 and ended in 1975. The U.S. Congress, U.S. , where it plays an integral part in the second act in Full Metal Jacket, a film in many ways comparable to Jarhead.
In today's world, the sniper, as Jarhead suggests, is largely redundant in set-piece combat situations (such as Operation Desert Storm Noun 1. Operation Desert Storm - the United States and its allies defeated Iraq in a ground war that lasted 100 hours (1991)
Gulf War, Persian Gulf War - a war fought between Iraq and a coalition led by the United States that freed Kuwait from Iraqi invaders; ) where mechanical contrivances dominate the battlefield. Yet the sniper, as always, has an important role to play in drawn-out campaigns, or in counter-insurgency operations, where the sniper effectively acts as a force multiplier A capability that, when added to and employed by a combat force, significantly increases the combat potential of that force and thus enhances the probability of successful mission accomplishment. . It is a paradox that Swoff's expertise would have proved an invaluable asset in present-day Iraq, where the sniper's presence has again been used effectively to limit the success of Iraqi insurgence in·sur·gence
The action or an instance of rebellion; an insurrection.
1. the state or condition of being in revolt or insurrection.
2. an uprising. .
The core element of interest to us is the inability to use the highly developed skills acquired by Swoff and his comrades-in-arms in the Surveillance and Target Acquisition For the RSTA/ISTAR/STA doctrine, see .
For Artillery STA, see .
For the USMC snipers, see . (STA) Platoon of the Second Battalion, Seventh Marines. We witness the rigours of the boot camp at Camp Pendleton and the incessant and demanding vigil of DI Fitch (Scott MacDonald), Swoff's transfer to the elite scouting unit described above, where Marine lifer lif·er
a. A prisoner serving a life sentence.
b. One who makes a career in one of the armed forces.
2. Informal A right-to-lifer. Staff Sergeant Sykes (Jamie Foxx Jamie Foxx (born December 13, 1967) is an American actor, singer, and stand-up comic. Foxx is possibly best-known for his performance of musician Ray Charles in Ray, and for his collaborations with director Michael Mann. ) further indoctrinates him in the ways of the Corps, and the close interdependent in·ter·de·pen·dent
Mutually dependent: "Today, the mission of one institution can be accomplished only by recognizing that it lives in an interdependent world with conflicts and overlapping interests" association formed by Swoff with his spotter Troy (Peter Sarsgaard), the other 'half of the sniper team' responsible for locating targets and providing cover (Henderson 1988, p. 5). Together, the sniper and his spotter, as Lieutenant General John H. Hay Jr. once pointed out, form a 'a carefully designed "weapon system"' (Lanning 1998, p. 2). Swoff and Troy train to locate and terminate their targets with their specialised sniping weapons. These finely-honed and potentially lethal skills are rendered superfluous su·per·flu·ous
Being beyond what is required or sufficient.
[Middle English, from Old French superflueux, from Latin superfluus, from superfluere, to overflow : when precision-guided weapons use laser, radar and satellite technology as a means to increase the probability of hitting the target.
Braverman, Deskilling and Divergent Skill Development
From an industrial relations industrial relations
Relations between the management of an industrial enterprise and its employees.
the relations between management and workers perspective, Jarhead recalls some of the key tenets of Harry Braverman's Labor and Monopoly Capital Monopoly Capital: An Essay on the American Economic and Social Order is an essay from 1966 by Paul Sweezy and Paul A. Baran. It made a major contribution to Marxist theory by shifting attention from the assumption of a competitive economy to monopolistic aspects of giant (1974). In this provocative work, Braverman proposes that, within capitalist economies, there is a general tendency for work of all forms to become progressively deskilled, so that workers are essentially there to operate the machines, rather than apply well-developed manual skills to the workplace. Braverman considers 'skill' to be the knowledge contained within craft workers within their trades. He explains:
From earliest times to the Industrial Revolution the craft of skilled trade was the basic unit, the elementary cell of the labor process. In each craft, the worker was presumed to be the master of a body of traditional knowledge, and methods and procedures were left to his or her discretion. In each such worker reposed the accumulated knowledge of materials and processes by which production was accomplished in the craft. The potter, tanner, smith, weaver, carpenter, baker, miller, glassmaker, cobbler, etc., each representing a branch of the social division of labor was a repository of human technique for the labor processes of that branch (1974, p. 109).
In Braverman's view, Taylorist methods of work organisation, which embody an extension of managerial control and the gradual separation of job conception and execution, came to increasingly dominate the workplace. Thus knowledge about job execution was stripped from the employees and became the preserve of management--part of what Braverman referred to as the 'degradation of work'. Braverman's approach to understanding skills in the workplace has been criticised for providing a romanticised view of craft work, for relying too heavily on an objective view of skill ignoring its political and social construction, for neglecting the gendered dimension of skill, and for paying too little attention to alternative managerial strategies that might be used to control employees (Bradley, Erikson, Stephenson and Williams 2000; Grint 1998, pp. 179-186; Noon and Blyton 1997, pp. 108-111).
There has been substantial research on the topic for those who support Braverman's thesis (e.g., Zimbalist 1979), and those who take a more critical stance (e.g., Wood 1982; Storey 1985). Although the notion of deskilling remains problematic, there is arguably ar·gu·a·ble
1. Open to argument: an arguable question, still unresolved.
2. That can be argued plausibly; defensible in argument: three arguable points of law. enough a much less significant level of skill utilisation in many contemporary work situations. With the substantial and rapid growth of technology in recent years, we have witnessed--at the very least--significant changes in the skills utilised throughout various industries. The military is not immune to fluctuations in the labour market, nor is it immune to changes in technological development. Rather, by its very nature, the military in Australia and elsewhere are more likely to be at the cutting edge of technological development in particular areas.
Braverman re-invigorated labour process theory and the notion of deskilling in the 1970s (Thompson 1989). Yet many of his ideas stem from the work of Adam Smith. Smith suggested that economic development was based around the division of labour. The skills of a master pin-maker were neither as efficient nor productive on a purely quantitative basis as when the tasks were divided. It would therefore be far more efficient and productive if the tasks were divided and if different people were to perform different tasks. For example, with regard to the pin factory, one worker would draw the wire, another would 'head' the pin, and another worker would sharpen the pin, and so on (Piore 2002). Thus deskilling, by means of changing the structure of artisan trades and technological progress, was required in order to develop increased economic returns to the capitalist. Braverman (1974) developed this argument with a view to suggesting that it was more than strategy--in fact, it was in the nature of capitalist production to develop technology that leads to the deskilling of the previously skilled tradesperson.
Braverman's work was a product of its time and a typically Marxist approach to skilling in the workplace (Penn and Scattergood 1985; Sawchuck 2006). Many of the concerns regarding the role of technology in deskilling antedated In banking, antedated refers to cheques which have been written by the maker, and dated at some point in the past. In the United States antedated cheques are described in the Uniform Commercial Code's Article 3, Section 113. the incredible level of technological development experienced during the last thirty years. It is important to bear in mind that we now have the benefit of hindsight and a wealth of data, both of which enable us to understand more clearly the impact that technology has in the workplace. These last three decades have witnessed substantial debate and much research on the actual impact of technology on workplace skills. The results of this research have been as diverse as the technology and skills investigated. For example, Osterman (1986) explored the change of skills required after computer technology was introduced to twenty different industries. Osterman found that the skills required by both low-skilled workers and managers had changed, which led to a reduction in employment opportunities for both groups of workers. Taking a more recent view of skills, Sanders (2005) argues that the position of low-skilled workers in the labour market has deteriorated significantly over the past three decades.
A number of other authors (e.g. Caroli and van Reenan 1999, Chennells and van Reenan 1999; Kaiser 1998; Machin 1996) have found, in their respective research, that technology requires the most skilled workers to increase their skills, yet has a negative impact on the skills required by the low-skill workers. In addition, there is a substantial body of research, conducted in a range of industries, that fails to find any clear evidence of the deskilling traditionally associated with technology (see e.g. Jones 1982; Martin 1981; Penn and Scattergood 1985).
We can see, then, that there is no simple explanation for what is occurring with workplace skills in recent decades. This body of research developed into a new model of skill and technology interaction that Penn and Scattergood (1985) denominate de·nom·i·nate
tr.v. de·nom·i·nat·ed, de·nom·i·nat·ing, de·nom·i·nates
1. To issue or express in terms of a given monetary unit: securities that are denominated in dollars or yen. 'compensatory theory'. This neo-Marxist approach extracts some of the problems associated with Braverman's deskilling thesis and presents a range of propositions. These propositions include the recognition that technological change, presents situations of both skilling and de-skilling, and that various occupational groups are disadvantaged, while others are advantaged. This approach is particularly relevant to our interpretation of the experiences of Swoff and his elite colleagues in Jarhead and, indeed, members of the Australian military.
Jarhead shows that elite soldiers such as U.S. Marines have become the subject of deskilling, as has occurred in other technologically advanced armed forces. Whereas Marines might once have employed their expert combat skills in the field, they, like the common infantry 'grunts', who might be described as 'semiskilled workers' (Braverman 1974, p. 431), are simply used to occupy territory captured by sophisticated equipment such as tanks, cruise missiles cruise missile, low-flying, continuously powered offensive missile designed to evade defense systems. Although the German V-1 (1944) was a simple cruise missile, the cruise missile did not realize its potential until the 1970s, when the United States sought to and, of course, military aircraft. In the case of the first Gulf War, the initial air-strikes so destroyed the Iraqi capacity to fight that front-line soldiers, such as Swoff and his comrades-in-arms, found themselves in a theatre without any front line, or anyone to fight. One Marine is even prompted to wonder: 'Are we ever going to get to kill anyone?'
The movie begins with Swoff's learning that the abuse traditionally associated with training camps is, in fact, now his reality. He realises that joining the Corps might have been a mistake. Nevertheless, after months of dragging his pack-laden body through mud and other hostile training environments, with the constant haranguing of the instructors, Swoff and his companions become the elite of the elite--Marine Corps snipers--and are flown in to Saudi Arabia Saudi Arabia (sä`dē ərā`bēə, sou`–, sô–), officially Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, kingdom (2005 est. pop. in preparation for the ground assault to come.
After almost 200 days of existence in an alien land, Swoff complains that his comrades do little more than patrol the empty desert, we hydrate hydrate (hī`drāt), chemical compound that contains water. A common hydrate is the familiar blue vitriol, a crystalline form of cupric sulfate. Chemically, it is cupric sulfate pentahydrate, CuSO4·5H2O. , we navigate imaginary minefields, we throw hand grenades into nowhere, we fire at nothing ... and we hydrate some more.
When the members of the STA Platoon are called upon to engage the enemy, they merely wander about, with weapons at the ready, through the charred remains of civilians who have been bombed in their escape from the war-zone. The frustrations of the snipers are high at this point. They have spent months in training refining their expertise and months in camp maintaining their skills. Upon being 'zoomed' by a military jet, one Marine, as he digs his sleeping hole in the desert, is moved to exclaim ex·claim
v. ex·claimed, ex·claim·ing, ex·claims
To cry out suddenly or vehemently, as from surprise or emotion: The children exclaimed with excitement.
v. : 'They're going to win the war all by themselves. And they'll be sleeping in their own beds tonight too.' Troy joins in to complain about the inability of snipers to use their skills:
This war's gonna move too fast for us. We can shoot 1000 yards. To go that far in Vietnam that would take a week. In World War One, a year. Here, it's gonna take about ten fucking seconds. By the time we have our rifles dialled, the war's gonna be about a mile down the road.
Indeed, Troy's frustration becomes even more relevant when he and Swoff are assigned a mission to locate and kill 'two high-ranking [Iraqi] officers' of Saddam Hussein's elite Republican Guard--the precise mission for which they have been trained. The sniper and spotter travel towards their target and find a location where they can execute their skills. Having received authorisation to carry out their orders, Swoff has his target sighted, and his finger on the trigger of his M40A1 rifle. As the tension builds within Swoff, Troy and even the audience, an American officer, Major Lincoln, bursts in and orders the snipers to desist. He decides to call in air support to take out the airbase
Major Lincoln: We got air, I'm calling it in.
Troy: We have permission to take the shot.
Major Lincoln: Tough break, you were just gonna shoot one guy, watch this, it'll blow your fucking minds ...
Troy: Requesting permission to take the shot, sir.
Major Lincoln: Request denied. You never know how many chances you're gonna get to see this.
Troy pleads with Major Lincoln to take the shot. But the officer, to Troy's increasing frustration, continues to ignore him.
Troy: We have the goddam god´dam
adj. 1. A more intense and vulgar form of darned; - often taken as profane and offensive.
Adj. 1. goddam shot. It's what we're here for.... It's my kill, that's my kill, that's my kill, you fucking desk-jockey.... You don't know Don't know (DK, DKed)
"Don't know the trade." A Street expression used whenever one party lacks knowledge of a trade or receives conflicting instructions from the other party. what we go through to kill. He doesn't know.
While Troy breaks down and proceeds to cry, two jets lay a pattern of bombs and destroy the Iraqi-held airbase.
Later, Swoff, now mentally exhausted from his recent experience, complains that he 'never shot [his] ... rifle', to which Troy replies that he 'can shoot it now'. Swoff fires his rifle into the night-time sky, for want of any better target. This, more than any other aspect of the film, encapsulates the biting critique of deskilling that the film embodies. The finely-honed and potentially lethal craftsmanship of the STA Platoon thus counts for very little in a war where its skills are not required. Whilst Jarhead illustrates the story of the sniper, we could reasonably presume there are many roles within the military that have progressively been altered or superseded by technological developments.
In a poignant scene towards the end of the movie, the Marines are in a bus travelling through a welcome home parade in the United States. A Vietnam veteran This article is about veterans of the Vietnam War. For the French psychedelic musical group, see Vietnam Veterans.
Vietnam veteran is a phrase used to describe someone who served in the armed forces of participating countries during the Vietnam War. , who is clearly suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), mental disorder that follows an occurrence of extreme psychological stress, such as that encountered in war or resulting from violence, childhood abuse, sexual abuse, or serious accident. (PTSD PTSD posttraumatic stress disorder.
posttraumatic stress disorder
Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) ), climbs onto the bus in order to congratulate the efforts of his fellow Marines ('You did it clean, you made us proud'), and then sits down. The audience is shown the possible future of the Gulf War veteran through the Marines' brief connection with this vet. Swoff shares the experience by stating that 'every war is different, every war is the same.' It is not a bright future. Indeed, we see Troy's funeral, with the underlying assumption that his death was a suicide. This end, of course, is not one reserved exclusively for the repatriated Marine. However, we can conclude that the frustrations associated with being unable to perform their expert marksmanship Marksmanship
(1846–1917) famed sharpshooter in Wild West show. [Am. Hist.: Flexner, 67]
son of Pan, companion to Muses; skilled in archery. [Gk. Myth. in a hostile environment See: operational environment. would be a contributing factor to a veteran's post-war experiences. This paper will now turn towards the Australian Defence Force and the role of skill-development within the ADF.
The ADF and the Australian Labour Market
The Australian Defence Force plays a substantial role in the Australian labour market. In fact, with almost 100,000 employees, the ADF is one of Australia's largest employers (ABS 2005), and, as explained previously, is set to expand in the face of the nation's increasing commitment to global peace-keeping operations and the ongoing 'war on terror.' At present, it employs approximately 50,000 full-time military personnel, almost 20,000 'Reserves' and almost 15,000 civilians (Defence Portfolio Budget Statements 2006-7). Changing labour market conditions do not influence only private enterprise. Indeed, despite its position as a behemoth behemoth (bē`hĭmŏth, bĭhē`–) [Heb.,=plural of beast], large, fanciful primeval monster, like Leviathan, evoking the hippopotamus mentioned in the Book of Job. of the Australian labour market, the ADF, before recent announcements regarding the recruitment of more combatant personnel, is currently faced with a shortfall of 1,500 employees based on projected employment rates.
While this labour shortfall is usually addressed through the use of increased civilian staff (Portfolio Budget Statements 2006-07), in 2007 the Australian government announced significant retention and recruitment initiatives. In total, the ADF is investing $3.1 billion on retention and recruitment strategies throughout the next decade (Department of Defence 2007). Of this amount, $371 million is being used to reform recruiting processes, and $71 million is to be used to introduce a new ADF apprenticeship scheme (Department of Defence 2007). In addition, $96 million is to be spent on retention and completion bonuses for skilled tradespeople trades·peo·ple
1. People engaged in retail trade.
2. Skilled workers.
Noun 1. tradespeople - people engaged in trade . That is, enlistees can receive up to $10,000 per year after completing their trade training (Nelson 2006). It has been noted, at an international level, that there is an increasing desire on the part of the military to employ people with the requisite knowledge, skills and abilities to perform highly sophisticated tasks, something which has intensified recruiting competition between military and private sector organisations (Hindelang, Schwerin and Farmer 2004). Clearly, the ADF recruitment drive is a substantial one. What makes the issue of competitive recruiting even more salient is that it is taking place at a time when there is considerable political and media attention focussed on the 'skills shortage' within the Australian labour market (see, e.g., the Commonwealth government's website on the 'National Skills Shortage Strategy').
The ADF also recognises that there is a reasonably high level of exit intention with the defence force in Australia. Between 30 and 39 percent of ADF employees indicate that they are 'actively looking at leaving the service' (Department of Defence, 2007, p8). Currently, there is an actual separation rate of more than 11 per cent. Targeted retention bonuses and allowances and initiatives to improve conditions are aimed to reduce this turnover in an attempt to alleviate labour shortfalls. It is recognised, however, that turnover will occur, and the ADF has allocated $125 million for ADF members who are considering alternative careers to receive independent professional career advice (Department of Defence 2007).
While there is limited research on workplace issues within the ADF, we can draw some conclusions from a substantial North American North American
named after North America.
North American blastomycosis
see North American blastomycosis.
North American cattle tick
see boophilusannulatus. literature. In the United States, the main reasons for joining the military among young men (16 to 21 years of age) are money for education and job training (Hattiangadi, Lee and Quester 2004). Hence the development of skills that can be used across workplaces is one of the two primary reasons for young men to join the military. This also seems to have been the case for Swoff, who seems to have joined the Corps on the way to college--Marine lifers are rarely caught reading Camus in the latrines. In addition, we witness the following exchange between D.I. Fitch and Swoff:
D.I. Fitch: What the fuck are you even doing here?
Swoff: Sir, I got lost on the way to college, sir!
It is therefore easy to understand the frustrations that arise when young men (primarily) join the various arms of service in order to learn skills, train extensively with a view to developing the acquired skills, and are then unable to use these skills in the workplace. As a consequence, re-enlistment becomes problematic when employees feel that they spend so many hours training to 'do nothing'. While more than 50 per cent of ADF personnel view their opportunity to increase their skills as 'sufficient' (Department of Defence 2007), the inability to use many of these skills would be contributing to up to 39 per cent of the ADF personnel actively seeking to leave their current defence employment.
Two other issues further complicate employment matters for the military. First, while the military operates within the same labour market as private enterprise, the military has a closed and internal labour market for senior positions (Bartle 2002). Thus, in the event of a recruiting shortfall and problematic retention rates, there will be fewer employees (and of potentially lesser quality) to promote to higher rankings (Dadeker and Paton 1997). With such a specific culture and managerial strategy built around the requirements of the battlefield, recruiting managers from the private sector is simply not possible.
The second issue relates to retirement. The defence force has a retirement system based on length of service rather than age. In view of this, military personnel often 'retire' or transfer to civilian life in their mid- to late forties (Spiegel and Shultz 2003), while the common civilian retirement age ranges between 60 and 65 years. This means that the military must place a high priority on factors that impact a person's decision to re-enlist rather than return to civilian life (Hindelang, Schwerin and Farmer 2004). We argue that the development, maintenance and utilisation of skills would be a significant factor in the decision to remain with the armed forces.
Skills development and employee retention are clearly areas of importance for the ADF. Whilst Jarhead shows us the story of the sniper--the frustrations of highly-skilled military operatives being placed in a state of flux--there are no doubt more stories of similar frustration. Herein lies the paradox for the ADF and other military organisations throughout the world. Particular skill sets are required and consequently developed. The organisation may never be sure, however, when these skills will be deployed or operationalised. One might well ask: how does the organisation retain, and therefore collect a return on its investment in skills, especially if the employees are unable to utilise their skills, become jaded jad·ed
1. Worn out; wearied: "My father's words had left me jaded and depressed" William Styron.
2. , and then wish to leave the organisation? For the employees in question, we need to ask: how many of their skills are directly transferable to the civilian community and are the transitionary support mechanisms adequate? Tradespeople and administrative staff within the ADF might be well placed, and indeed better trained than equivalent staff outside the ADF, but personnel trained for combat duty are obviously more problematic.
At the present time, the ADF does provides a substantial program for transitional employees--soldiers leaving the military for retirement or retraining re·train
tr. & intr.v. re·trained, re·train·ing, re·trains
To train or undergo training again.
re·train in order to join the civilian workforce. From a labour market perspective, more research is required, and many issues need to be examined. These issues include the transferability of skills, the success of transition for employees, and the impact that recruitment of former ADF personnel has on the destination organisation. Labour process theory and, indeed, Jarhead tell us that there is an ongoing development of skills within our labour force. Technology can remove the skill previously required for some tasks and increase the skill requirements of others. Just as importantly, specific skills may still be required. The use of those skills might need to be relocated within the production process, however, as is the case with the use of snipers in the current counter-insurgency operations within Iraq. More important is that skills transferability should be built into our rapidly developing and technology-based workforce. The Marine Corps and the ADF as organisations, in addition to the Australian labour market, are not immune to the changing nature of skills within society.
This paper has used a popular culture medium to examine the notion of deskilling in the military, a prominent and oftentimes of·ten·times also oft·times
Adv. 1. oftentimes - many times at short intervals; "we often met over a cup of coffee"
frequently, oft, often, ofttimes controversial sector of the workforce. Jarhead, the 2005 'Hollywood blockbuster,' tells the story of U.S. Marine, Anthony Swofford, in the first Gulf War of the early 1990s. After intensive training to become one of the Marine's most highly skilled employees, Swofford and his colleagues become increasingly frustrated frus·trate
tr.v. frus·trat·ed, frus·trat·ing, frus·trates
a. To prevent from accomplishing a purpose or fulfilling a desire; thwart: with their inability to 'ply their trade'. Technological developments, as least as Jarhead portrays them, have rendered the sniper, an elite fighter in earlier conflicts, largely redundant in battles such as those encountered in the first Gulf War. This paper has sought to contribute to our understanding of the tensions between traditional skilled occupations and technological development, and the attitudes of those who find themselves and their expert human skills replaced by faceless technological development, something which is manifest in the seminal research of Harry Braverman, who ignited a substantial debate on the role that technology plays in influencing workplace skills.
Finally, this paper drew on the current labour market implications for the Australian Defence Force, one of this nation's largest employers. For the ADF, tensions exist between the recruitment and retention of employees and the manner in which employee skills are utilised within the ADF, and beyond into civilian employment. Jarhead thus serves as a cinematic representation of the angst angst 1
A feeling of anxiety or apprehension often accompanied by depression.
angstrom felt by those skilled workers made redundant by technology, even if it ignores the fact that snipers (including those of the Marine Corps) continue to play a valuable role in modem warfare in certain situations. It also represents a statement regarding the difficulties of repatriating soldiers with skill-sets that have no immediately obvious civilian application. These are issues that current defence forces--including the ADF--must face in tighter labour markets if they are to realise their recruitment targets and promote military service as an alternative to civilian career paths.
Australian Bureau of Statistics The Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) is the Australian government agency that collects and publishes statistical information about Australia and its people. Population and Housing
The agency undertakes the Australian Census of Population and Housing. (2005), Year Book Australia, 2005, Catalogue 1301.0, ABS, Canberra.
Battle, R. (2002), 'The Use of Personality Types in Solving Recruitment and Retention Problems in the British Army', in Ross, P, Lyons, M., Allan, C. and Townsend, K. (convenors), Employment Relations Theory, Strategy and Practice: The Challenges for the 21st Century, Proceedings of the 10th Annual Conference of the International Employment Relations Association, pp. 117-130.
Bartlett, L. (2006), 'Australia Boosts Army to Face Growing Foreign Threats: PM', AFP (1) (AppleTalk Filing Protocol) The file sharing protocol used in an AppleTalk network. In order for non-Apple networks to access data in an AppleShare server, their protocols must translate into the AFP language. See file sharing protocol. News, August 24, http://news.yahoo.com/s/afp/20060824/wl_asia_afp/ australiamilitary
Bradley, H., Erikson, M., Stephenson, C. and Williams, S. (2000), Myths at Work, Polity Press, Cambridge, MA.
Braverman, H. (1974), Labor and Monopoly Capital: The Degradation of Work in the Twentieth Century, Monthly Review Press, New York New York, state, United States
New York, Middle Atlantic state of the United States. It is bordered by Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and the Atlantic Ocean (E), New Jersey and Pennsylvania (S), Lakes Erie and Ontario and the Canadian province of .
Caroli, E. and Van Reenen, J. (1999), 'Skills and Organisational Change: Evidence from British and French Establishments in the 1980s and 1990s', Mimeo Institute for Fiscal Studies, London.
Chennells, L. and van Reenan, J. (1999), 'Has Technology Hurt Less Skilled Workers? An Econometric e·con·o·met·rics
n. (used with a sing. verb)
Application of mathematical and statistical techniques to economics in the study of problems, the analysis of data, and the development and testing of theories and models. Survey of the Effects of Technical Change on the Structure of Pay and Jobs', The Institute for Fiscal Studies Working Paper Series, No W99.27.
Dadeker, C., and Paton, F. (1997), The Military and Social Change: A Personnel Strategy for the British Armed Forces, Brassey's for the Centre of Defence Studies, London.
Defence Portfolio Budget Statements (2006-7), Commonwealth Government of Australia
Department of Defence (2007), '2006 Defence Attitude Survey Summary of Results', Department of Defence, Canberra, http://www.defence.gov.au/dpe
Fenwick, T. and Hall, R. (2006), 'Skills in the Knowledge Economy: Changing Meanings in Changing Conditions', Journal of Industrial Relations, vol 48, pp. 571-574.
Gilbert, A (1997), Stalk stalk (stawk) an elongated anatomical structure resembling the stem of a plant.
allantoic stalk and Kill: The Sniper Experience, St. Martin's St. Martin's or St. Martins may refer to:
Grint, A. (1998), The Sociology of Work, 2nd ed., Polity Press, Blackwell.
Hattiangadi, A., Lee, G. and Quester, A. (2004), Recruiting Hispanics: The Marine Corps Experience--Final Report, The CNA (Certified NetWare Administrator) See Novell certification. Corporation, Alexandria. http://www.cna.org/documents/D0009071.A2.pdf
Henderson, C. (1988), Marine Sniper: 93 Confirmed Kills, Berkeley, New York.
Hindelang, R., Schwerin, M. and Farmer, W. (2004), 'Quality of Life (QOL QOL,
n quality of life, a subjective assessment of one's emotional and physical well-being. ) in the U.S. Marine Corps: The Validation of a QOL Model for Predicting Reenlistment Intentions', Military Psychology, vol. 16, pp. 115-134.
Jones, B. (1982), 'Destruction or Redistribution of Engineering Skills? The Case of Numerical Control', in Wood, S. (ed.), The Degradation of Work? Skill, Deskilling and the Labour Process, Heinemann, London.
Kaiser, U. (1998), 'The Impact of New Technology on the Demand for Heterogenous (spelling) heterogenous - It's spelled heterogeneous. Labour',
Centre for European Economic Research (ZEW ZEW Zentrum für Europäische Wirtschaftsforschung (German: Centre for European Economic Research) ) Working Paper.
Lanning, M. L. (1998), Inside the Crosshairs, Ballantine New York.
Machin, S. (1996), 'Changes in the Relative Demand for Skills in the UK Labour Market', in Booth, A. and Snower, D. (eds), Acquiring Skills: Market Failures, Their Symptoms and Policy Responses, Cambridge University Press Cambridge University Press (known colloquially as CUP) is a publisher given a Royal Charter by Henry VIII in 1534, and one of the two privileged presses (the other being Oxford University Press). , pp. 129-146.
Martin, R. (1981), New Technology and Industrial Relations in Fleet Street, Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Moskin, J. R. (1979), The Story of the U.S. Marine Corps, Paddington Press, New York.
Nelson, B. (2006), $194 Million To Recruit And Retain ADF Personnel, Defence Minister Media Release 061/2006, 9 May.
Noon, M. and Blyton, P. (1997), The Realities of Work, Macmillan, Basingstoke.
Osterman, P. (1986), 'The Effect of Computers on the Employment of Clerks and Managers', Industrial and Labour Relations labour relations (US), labor relations npl → relations fpl dans l'entreprise
labour relations labour npl → Beziehungen pl Review, vol. 39, pp. 175-185.
Penn, R. and Scattergood, H. (1985), 'Deskilling or Enskilling?: An Empirical Investigation of Recent Theories of the Labour Process', The British Journal of Sociology, vol. 36, pp. 611-630.
Piore, M. (2002), 'The Reconfiguration of Work and Employment Relations in the United States at the Turn of the Century', paper prepared for the ILO ILO
International Labor Organization
Noun 1. ILO - the United Nations agency concerned with the interests of labor
International Labor Organization, International Labour Organization Symposium L'avenir du travail TRAVAIL. The act of child-bearing.
2. A woman is said to be in her travail from the time the pains of child-bearing commence until her delivery. 5 Pick. 63; 6 Greenl. R. 460.
3. de l'emploi et de la protection sociale: dynamique du changement et protection des travailleurs, http://www.yale. edu/ccr/piore.pdf
Thompson, P. (1989), The Nature of Work: An Introduction to Debates on the Labour Process, Macmillan Press, London.
Sanders, M. (2005), Technology and the Decline in Demand for Unskilled Labour: A Theoretical Analysis of the US and European Labour Markets, Edward Elgar Sir Edward William Elgar, 1st Baronet, OM, GCVO (2 June 1857 – 23 February 1934) was an English Romantic composer. Several of his first major orchestral works, including the Enigma Variations and the Pomp and Circumstance Marches, were greeted with acclaim. , Cheltenham.
Sasser, C. W. and Roberts, C. (1990), One Shot-One Kill, Pocket Books, New York.
Sawchuck, P. (2006). 'Use-Value and the Rethinking of Skills', Journal of Industrial Relations, vol 48, pp. 593-617.
Selby, J. (1972), United States Marine Corps United States Marine Corps (USMC)
Separate military service within the U.S. Department of the Navy (see U.S. Navy), charged with providing marine troops for seizure and defense of advanced bases and with conducting operations on land and in the air in connection with , Osprey osprey (ŏs`prē), common name for a bird of prey related to the hawk and the New World vulture and found near water in most parts of the world. , London.
Spiegel, P. E. and Shultz, K. S. (2003), 'The Influence of Preretirement Planning and Transferability of Skills on Naval Officer's Retirement Satisfaction and Adjustment', Military Psychology, vol. 15, pp. 285-307.
Storey, J. (1985), 'The Means of Management Control', Sociology, vol 19, pp. 193-211.
Wood, S. (ed.) (1982), The Degradation of Work? Skill, Deskilling and the Labour Process, Heinemann, London.
Zimbalist, A. (1979), Case Studies on the Labor Process, Monthly Review Press, New York.
Keith Townsend * and Michael B. Charles **
* Griffith University Griffith University is an Australian public university with five campuses in Queensland between Brisbane and the Gold Coast. In 2007 there were more than 33,000 enrolled students and 3,000 staff.
** Southern Cross University