Printer Friendly
The Free Library
14,679,288 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

Indian by day, American by night.


Students at a call center training institute in New Delhi New Delhi (dĕl`ē), city (1991 pop. 294,149), capital of India and of Delhi state, N central India, on the right bank of the Yamuna River.  are learning how to speak English, American-style.

"It's peetzah, not piza, beeautiful, not bootiful," the instructor admonishes them. "And you have to learn to be more polite," says Surinder Singh Gill of Hero Mindmine. "You can't say, 'You have ordered it. Here's the bill.' That's very rude. Say something like, 'Thank you for ordering at Domino's.' That's much more proper."

In an adjoining room, other students are studying an interactive computer program that shows them how an "average" American family American Family is a photographic artwork exhibition by Renée Cox. See also
  • An American Family, a 1973 documentary broadcast on PBS
  • , a 2002-2004 PBS drama starring Edward James Olmos and Constance Marie.
 lives. The all-white faces that pop up on the screen reside in a huge house. A member of the family, Chris, practices ballet. The students are instructed to hear the narration--in an American accent--and answer questions about the family. In spite of my protestations, instructor Anuja Mehta asks a student to get out of his chair so I can sit down. Mehta gives me a pair of headphones Head-mounted speakers. Headphones have a strap that rests on top of the head, positioning a pair of speakers over both ears. For listening to music or monitoring live performances and audio tracks, both left and right channels are required.  to try the program out.

"Many of these people had no clue what a ballet or a tutu tutu

coriariaarborea.
 was," sighs Mehta. "You have no idea how much we're broadening their horizons."

In another part of India, the British Empire British Empire, overseas territories linked to Great Britain in a variety of constitutional relationships, established over a period of three centuries. The establishment of the empire resulted primarily from commercial and political motives and emigration movements  is striking back with a vengeance. "Sixteh, seventeh, eighteh, nineteh," intones Anupama Asthana in her best British accent to a group of students in Bangalore. "Bloody rude," she adds. On a board in the classroom, there's a cartoon of Prince Charles Noun 1. Prince Charles - the eldest son of Elizabeth II and heir to the English throne (born in 1948)
Charles
. Numbers below the cartoon inform the students about the London weather and the fate of the stock market there. Headlines give the latest on the European Union European Union (EU), name given since the ratification (Nov., 1993) of the Treaty of European Union, or Maastricht Treaty, to the

European Community
 expansion.

Welcome to the Anglo-Americanization of India, or at least of urban English-speaking youth. The call center industry is extracting a sliver sliver

in wool processing a continuous band of carded and combed wool which has not yet been twisted into yarn.
 of Indians who are actively de-Indianizing themselves and adopting Western names and identities, accents and culture.

I recently toured a number of call centers to see how they function and the impact they're having on Indian society. I even went to one call center that The New York New York, state, United States
New York, Middle Atlantic state of the United States. It is bordered by Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and the Atlantic Ocean (E), New Jersey and Pennsylvania (S), Lakes Erie and Ontario and the Canadian province of
 Times columnist Thomas Friedman Thomas Lauren Friedman, OBE (born July 20, 1953), is an American journalist. He is an op-ed contributor to The New York Times, whose column appears twice weekly and mainly addresses topics on foreign affairs.  had visited and glowed about. He said what "an uplifting experience" it was and how the workers "seem to have gained self-confidence and self-worth." Friedman has also trumpeted the "social revolution" that has come to India because of the formation of a new class of young urban "zippies" due to outsourcing.

What I found, however, was not so delightful.

Call center training institutes are springing up all over die bigger cities in India This is a list of cities in India - * indicates capital cities of states of India. A
  • Abohar
  • Abu Road
  • Adilabad
  • Ariyalur
  • Agartala*
  • Agra
  • Ahmedabad
  • Ahmednagar
  • Aizwal*
  • Ajmer
  • Ajjampura
  • Akola
  • Aligarh
  • Allahabad
  • alala
, helping young people, for a fee, to de-Indianize themselves. Hero Mindmine, which proclaims itself the largest national chain, says that it has trained 25,000 students nationwide since it opened three years ago, with a claimed 90 percent placement rate. The process of transformation at such institutes involves listening to CDs and other audiovisual material for an American accent, plus voice samples, activities, and role play, says Snehal Kulshreshtha of Hero Mindmine. Some companies prefer that employees put on an accent and others prefer "accent neutralization neutralization, chemical reaction, according to the Arrhenius theory of acids and bases, in which a water solution of acid is mixed with a water solution of base to form a salt and water; this reaction is complete only if the resulting solution has neither acidic nor ," he says. The American cultural offerings that Hero Mindmine uses are Full House, Frasier, and Friends, while CNN CNN
 or Cable News Network

Subsidiary company of Turner Broadcasting Systems. It was created by Ted Turner in 1980 to present 24-hour live news broadcasts, using satellites to transmit reports from news bureaus around the world.
 and Fox News are used to teach them the American "lifestyle," he adds.

Often, these training institutes are hole-in-the-wall operations. I visited one such classroom in Bangalore. A few students sat around in a small room on the fifth floor listening to a young, smartly dressed instructor, Sanjay, teach them the "correct" intonation intonation

In phonetics, the melodic pattern of an utterance. Intonation is primarily a matter of variation in the pitch level of the voice (see tone), but in languages such as English, stress and rhythm are also involved.
.

"We try to neutralize neutralize

to render neutral.
 their accent so that there is no m.t.i.--mother tongue influence," says Sunil Wadhwa of Hero Mindmine, using the buzzword A term that refers to the latest technology or a term that sounds catchy. If not a flash in the pan, new technologies become mainstream. For example, Java was a hot buzzword in the 1990s, but should remain a major topic for decades.  of choice in the call center industry. "We teach them about U.S. culture U.S. culture has two main meanings:
  • Culture of the United States
  • Arts and entertainment in the United States
, the U.S. accent, and U.S. vowels and consonants This is a list of all consonants, ordered by place and manner of articulation. Ordered by place of articulation
Labial consonants

Bilabial consonants

  • bilabial click [ʘ] 
."

At a Hero Mindmine classroom in New Delhi, students are critiquing each other's presentations.

"Brijesh didn't say his vowels clearly," says Rajesh. "He said 'fund,' not 'found.' He said 'Ruzza,' not 'Russhia.' And he used Hindi filler words."

"It's Japaan, not Jahpahn, Ahfrica, not Afreeka," adds Gill, the instructor.

A board next to Gill urged the students to "conquire (sic) the heights of their carrier (sic)." It also urged them to "speak correct language without making any mistakes" and to "overcome regional accents in our speech and to have correct pronunciation."

"It's, 'May I put you on hold?' not, 'Can you hold?' " Gill admonishes Rajesh after Rajesh has finished role-playing selling airline tickets to a Westerner west·ern·er also West·ern·er  
n.
A native or inhabitant of the west, especially the western United States.


Westerner
Noun

a person from the west of a country or region

Noun 1.
. "And remember, Americans and the British are very specific with their times. When they say one minute, they mean one minute. When they say two minutes, they mean two minutes."

This typecasting The word typecasting (past participle typecast) can mean more than one thing:
  • type conversion in computer programming
  • type conversion in aviation
  • typecasting (acting) in acting
  • Typecast, a Filipino band
  • Typecast (horse), American Champion racehorse
 of cultures is a major part of the industry.

People in the East and West have different working styles and communication styles," says Lynda Ongel Lepcha, who has set up a New Delhi call center training institute, Holistic Enterprise, that teaches employees on-site. "We in India are monochronic, while in the U.S. they are polychronic. We in India do one activity at a time, while in the U.S. they do several activities at a time. We in India have no active hobbies. Americans have active hobbies. In the West, it is 'I, me, myself'; in India, the collective is more important."

Lepcha denies that she asks people to adopt American accents but then offers lessons on how Americans pronounce things differently than Indians.

"They say Beddy, we say Betty," Lepcha explains. "They say budder, we say butter."

Lepcha launches into the differences between American and British customers.

"With Americans WYSWYG--What You See Is What You Get," Lepcha says. "So Americans shout and scream when they get angry. The British use sarcasm instead."

As I am leaving her residence-cum-office, I notice several tapes of Sex and the City. I ask about them.

"Oh, they are part of my husband's collection," laughs Lepcha. "But we also use them to train employees about American culture."

A sign in a training classroom at Saffron saffron, name for a fall-flowering plant (Crocus sativus) of the family Iridaceae (iris family) and also for a dye obtained therefrom. The plant is native to Asia Minor, where for centuries it has been cultivated for its aromatic orange-yellow stigmas (see  Global, a call center I visited near New Delhi, said, "Do not speak Hindi," next to exhortations to the staff to be efficient and courteous. Beside this was a chart with the right way to say "kweschon" and "pronounciation." When I entered the operational hub, a variety of British accents were buzzing in the room--all coming from the mouths of Indians answering phones for customers in Britain. A team leader was at the end of every row, to help "motivate" the employees and to "listen in on their calls," in the words of Shraddha Sharma, a business manager with the firm. It was quite a performance. And many of the call center workers seem to relish the opportunity to try out their acting chops, often even internalizing their roles.

"What's your name?" I asked a call center employee in Bangalore. "Stephen P. Y.," he replied, in a clipped British accent. I didn't have the heart to ask him his real name. The part only seemed to suit him too well.

At another Bangalore call center, I bumped into an accent trainer while I was leaving the building. He spoke with a thick British accent and used words like "menagerie" and "demon" that an Indian would seldom use. When I asked him where he was from, he seemed genuinely offended. "My roots are in India," he huffed.

At other times, the employees seem to easily slip in and out of roles. When I was questioning an employee at a Bangalore call center, he spoke with an Indian accent and gave me his real name, only to acquire a British accent and identity when he answered the phone. To add to his bewildering be·wil·der  
tr.v. be·wil·dered, be·wil·der·ing, be·wil·ders
1. To confuse or befuddle, especially with numerous conflicting situations, objects, or statements. See Synonyms at puzzle.

2.
 multiple identities, he had put on a fake American accent and name while working at a previous job, be told me.

What's the big deal anyway? Don't we all perform a variety of roles in our daily lives, including at work? Is the acquiring of an accent and a name that much of a departure?

"Immigrants do it all the time when they emigrate em·i·grate  
intr.v. em·i·grat·ed, em·i·grat·ing, em·i·grates
To leave one country or region to settle in another. See Usage Note at migrate.
," argues Anand Kasturi, an instructor at the Indian Institute The Indian Institute in central Oxford, England is located at the north end of Catte Street on the corner with Holywell Street and faching down Broad Street from the east.[1]  of Management in Bangalore, who has written his Ph.D. dissertation on call centers. "They shorten their names or Westernize west·ern·ize  
tr.v. west·ern·ized, west·ern·iz·ing, west·ern·iz·es
To convert to the customs of Western civilization.



west
 them.

How is it all that different for people working in call centers?"

"There's little identity crisis about changing the name," says Shahzada Khurram of Saffron Global.

Not so, counters Arjun Raina, a call center trainer. Raina, also a theater artist, has made the plight of call center workers his passion. He has appeared on 60 Minutes and has written and performed a play, A Terrible Beauty Is Born, on the subject. He was inspired to do the play after learning of a call center employee with an assumed name who committed suicide.

"When an immigrant settles abroad and changes his name, he does so voluntarily," says Raina. "Here, the worker has no choice. When you're faking the name, you're making invisible the country, and the labor force is functioning as an invisible labor force. They are Indian by day and American by night. Someone told me that since he had traces of a Punjabi accent even after his training, he banned all his relatives from visiting him for three months."

"It's the ultimate humiliation," says Professor Harish Trivedi of Delhi University in The Week, an Indian newsmagazine news·mag·a·zine  
n.
1. A magazine, usually published weekly, containing reports and analyses of current events.

2. A television program that presents a variety of topics, usually on current events, often by using interviews and
. "We are being asked to pretend to be foreigners Foreigners

alienage

the condition of being an alien.

androlepsy

Law. the seizure of foreign subjects to enforce a claim for justice or other right against their nation.

gypsyologist, gipsyologist

Rare.
. No one wants to know us as Indians; our identity is not good enough."

Call center workers have to face other challenges, too, such as inconvenient working hours, a heavy workload, and unpleasant customers.

Lepcha of Holistic Enterprise is one of the few industry people willing to touch on these problems. A lot of the workforce has to work the night shift because of the time difference between India and the United States United States, officially United States of America, republic (2005 est. pop. 295,734,000), 3,539,227 sq mi (9,166,598 sq km), North America. The United States is the world's third largest country in population and the fourth largest country in area. . This often plays havoc with their biological clocks Biological clocks

Self-sustained circadian (approximately 24-hour) rhythms regulating daily activities such as sleep and wakefulness were described as early as 1729.
, Lepcha says, causing many of them, especially women, to drop out.

Defenders of the industry are determined, however, to put a happy face on the experiences of employees.

"They are enjoying themselves," says Wadhwa of Hero Mindmine.

"They are more or less happy."

"People get used to the night shift and even enjoy it," says M. K. Thimmiah, managing director of Mainstay in Bangalore. Thomas Friedman told Terry Gross of Fresh Air that this schedule fits "in very nicely with the indian day." Khurram of Saffron Global claims that working at night is "not really an issue, perhaps only for one in fifty."

Not true, says Raina.

"You can feel the stress in a call center once you're there," Raina says. "There's lots of anxiety and stress."

Raina claims that call center employees can be forced to handle between 500 and 700 calls a night. Executives at the call centers I visited gave me lower numbers, with one corporate spokesperson saying that the range is between 150 and 300 calls a night and another saying that the average was 250 calls per shift.

The London Guardian reveals that employees are so closely monitored that even going to the bathroom can affect their pay, which is often linked to their job performance. "In call centers, a half-hour lunch break and two fifteen-minute snack breaks each day are considered a generous benefit," the paper notes.

Raina also pointed out the strain of listening to abusive customers. Subbu, the founder and CEO (1) (Chief Executive Officer) The highest individual in command of an organization. Typically the president of the company, the CEO reports to the Chairman of the Board.  of Convergeon, a Bangalore-based training institute, said that industry sources tell him that 30 percent to 40 percent of people ask the telemarketers if they are from India. "People feel that Americans should do these jobs, not Indians," he said.

Corporate personnel have a different perspective.

"Look at the bright side--the customer doesn't shout at you, he shouts at a name," Khurram of Saffron Global says cheerfully.

"That's what they get paid for," said an executive at 24/7 Customer when I asked him if handling angry customers was an issue with employees.

How do employees feel?

It was hard to say, since all the interviews I was granted were under the vigilant eye of company executives.

Shubhanil, an employee at Mainstay, spoke with me under the watchful gaze of J. A. S. Diaz, the company's executive director. Was the acquiring of a fake name and accent a problem? Not really, he replied. Is the call volume a problem? "Not here," he replied nervously, "but at the previous company I worked for, Transworks, I got no rest."

Syed Ahmed, another employee at Mainstay, revealed the truth about why so many call center employees turn to these jobs. "When you have a master's in engineering and you don't have a job, the frustration can be immense." Diaz nodded approvingly.

The employees knew that even mild criticism would not be taken well. When "Stephen P. Y." complained to me about the cafeteria food and that the company-provided taxi service was erratic, Shimonti Sikdar, an assistant manager at 24/7 Customer, went into a tizzy tiz·zy  
n. pl. tiz·zies Slang
A state of nervous excitement or confusion; a dither.



[Origin unknown.
. "You're not going to print that, are you?" she exclaimed.

The fear of losing a job is so intense that people are not willing to speak to a reporter even outside the premises of a call center. A number of friends of my cousins are working in the industry but refused to speak to me when my cousins approached them on my behalf. (My joke that The Progressive is not widely available on the newsstands in india didn't seem to reassure them.)

Friedman has been extolling the economic benefits of these call center jobs, but they are more meager mea·ger also mea·gre  
adj.
1. Deficient in quantity, fullness, or extent; scanty.

2. Deficient in richness, fertility, or vigor; feeble: the meager soil of an eroded plain.

3.
 than he makes them out to be.

The call center sector employs between 150,000 and 250,000 people. That is less than 0.1 percent of India's labor pool of 500 million. Approximately 70 percent of India's population lives in villages and sees little economic effect even from jobs spun off by the industry, such as in software, retail, or transportation. (Few villagers speak English fluently enough to get jobs in the call centers.) The benefits of the sector are largely bypassing those most in need.

People associated with the industry are quick to point out to me the upside of call centers. The industry has "helped in the emancipation of women," Kulshreshtha of Hero Mindmine says, since they are working now. (He actually means urban English-educated women; poorer women have always been working in India.)

"India has awakened a·wak·en  
tr. & intr.v. a·wak·ened, a·wak·en·ing, a·wak·ens
To awake; waken. See Usage Note at wake1.



[Middle English awakenen, from Old English
," he says proudly. "We now give our students workshops on the finer points of golf and wine. Globalization globalization

Process by which the experience of everyday life, marked by the diffusion of commodities and ideas, is becoming standardized around the world. Factors that have contributed to globalization include increasingly sophisticated communications and transportation
 means the death of distance."

Industry wages, although decent by Indian standards, are not enough to support a family. Starting salaries are from 8,000 to 12,000 rupees a month, or between $175 and $265 at current conversion rates. (The purchasing power Purchasing Power

1. The value of a currency expressed in terms of the amount of goods or services that one unit of money can buy. Purchasing power is important because, all else being equal, inflation decreases the amount of goods or services you'd be able to purchase.

2.
 of this wage in India, however, is higher than the amount in dollars would suggest.) While these wages pay better than entry-level white-collar jobs in some other sectors, they are not sufficient for an urban middle class family to live comfortably on. Many young people who work in the centers still live at home and hence save on housing and utilities. Plus, the work is stultifying.

"The jobs are so low grade that no one is interested in upgrading of skills," Raina adds. "Companies are going further down the social hierarchy Social hierarchy

A fundamental aspect of social organization that is established by fighting or display behavior and results in a ranking of the animals in a group.
 to hire tougher people who can handle the job. Wages are consequently going down. In accounts like collections, it really doesn't matter if you have the right accent or not."

The incentive for American and British companies is huge. Thimmiah of Mainstay says that call centers like his offer a 30 percent to 50 percent savings over those based in the West. Not surprisingly, the call center industry is rapidly expanding. 24/7 Customer, the call center Friedman and I both visited, has grown to 3,000 people from just 1,000 last year, and is expected to increase to 8,000 employees by the end of the year.

But employee turnover is heavy. "Attrition is very high--it's 22 percent," says an executive at 24/7 Customer. Subbu of Convergeon says that the industry suffers from an annual 40 percent attrition rate Noun 1. attrition rate - the rate of shrinkage in size or number
rate of attrition

rate - a magnitude or frequency relative to a time unit; "they traveled at a rate of 55 miles per hour"; "the rate of change was faster than expected"


. (Unions are absent because of the intense turnover rate and because a lot of the workers, due to their social background, would not be caught dead trying to unionize.)

Unfortunately, jobs such as those in the call center industry are frequently the only game in town for English-speaking urbanites. And if they have to give up their names, their identities, their accents, and their culture in the process, it's a concession many are willing to make.

Upon returning from India, I made a call to the JCPenney credit card department. On the other end was a woman from India who said her name was Rachel, but her bad American accent gave her away. I realized then that these call center trainers have a long way to go.

Peetzah anyone?

Amitabh Pal is Managing Editor of The Progressive.
COPYRIGHT 2004 The Progressive, Inc.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2004, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Pal, Amitabh
Publication:The Progressive
Article Type:Brief Article
Geographic Code:1USA
Date:Aug 1, 2004
Words:2822
Previous Article:Fire hazard: Bush leaves nuclear plants at risk.(Cover Story)
Next Article:Presidential Side Show.(Poem)
Topics:



Related Articles
Securities Pro.
Wehmeyer's article on the Indian image in New Orleans altars the Caribbean connection.
`NATURALLY NATIVE' AN ACHIEVEMENT WITH LOTS ON ITS MIND.(L.A. Life)
The Wichita Indians: Traders of Texas and the Southern Plains, 1540-1845.(Brief Article)
The first free state project: the brief, tumultuous history of Franklin.
Barreiro, Jose & Johnson, Tim, eds. America is Indian Country: Opinions and Perspectives from Indian Country Today.(Young adult review)(Brief...
Keeping up with the call center.(indian call centers services)
Religious Right groups file briefs to defend Colson prison program.(PEOPLE & EVENTS)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles