Impacting teacher candidates' knowledge, skills, and dispositions regarding diversity: faculty triggers (1).
The increasing diversity of students within our educational systems demands improved training within teacher education programs at institutions of higher education (IHE IHE Integrating the Healthcare Enterprise
IHE Institutions of Higher Education
IHE International Institute for Infrastructural, Hydraulic and Environmental Engineering (historical acronym only, replaced by: IHE Delft, the Foundation) ). This is, also, evident through standards of state and national accrediting bodies, through professional organizations guidance, and through demands of consumers of public education.
Along with training, assessment of teacher candidate knowledge, skills and dispositions about multicultural/diversity is critical (NCATE NCATE National Council for Accreditation of Teacher Education , 2002). It can assist institutions of higher education in making programmatic pro·gram·mat·ic
1. Of, relating to, or having a program.
2. Following an overall plan or schedule: a step-by-step, programmatic approach to problem solving.
3. decisions as to diversity issues. It can, also, help provide evidence that the diverse needs of children, youth, and their families within our public school systems will be better met than in times past.
Faculty members within teacher education programs have great demands placed upon them. This includes making sure courses have diversity issues embedded Inserted into. See embedded system. throughout them, that field experiences provide hands-on learning with a diverse population of students, that teacher candidates learn to meet individual needs along with collective needs, and that assessment of candidates is successfully conducted. Yet, how are we assuring that faculty members are provided with the training needed to meet these expectations? Where do the knowledge, skills and dispositions regarding diversity issues emanate em·a·nate
intr. & tr.v. em·a·nat·ed, em·a·nat·ing, em·a·nates
To come or send forth, as from a source: light that emanated from a lamp; a stove that emanated a steady heat. with faculty who are charged with training our teacher candidates?
capacity to refract light.
a difference between the focal length of the cornea and lens, and the length of the eye, resulting in myopia or hyperopia. Errors
The Conceptual Framework For the concept in aesthetics and art criticism, see .
A conceptual framework is used in research to outline possible courses of action or to present a preferred approach to a system analysis project. (CF) of the College of Education at a Midwest Midwest or Middle West, region of the United States centered on the western Great Lakes and the upper-middle Mississippi valley. It is a somewhat imprecise term that has been applied to the northern section of the land between the Appalachians university states that:
The unit's CF reflects the unit's commitment to preparing candidates to support learning for all students and provides a conceptual understanding of how knowledge, dispositions, and skills related to diversity are integrated across the curriculum, instruction, field experiences, assessments, and evaluations.
Okay, that is all well and good; however, faculty members at this university may wonder how they are suppose to assure this happens in the program in which they work.
One problem is that the diversity representation of faculty at IHEs and teachers in our public school system do not always mirror the diversity of the students in their classrooms/programs (Campbell-Whatley, 2003; Dieker, Voltz Voltz is a rechargeable battery-based guitar pedals power supply with the following characteristics:
A location in the United Kingdom:
1. To bring into being; create.
2. To come into being; start. . If teachers who represent diverse cultures are not entering teacher education programs at doctoral levels, it will be increasingly difficult to gain adequate representation at IHE levels. It is, therefore, imperative that recruitment efforts be developed that help bring diversity within teaching and faculty positions over the next generations in order to overcome these refractive errors. In the mean time, current faculty at IHEs (who represent more mainstream cultures) must be afforded the training required to meet the diverse needs of teacher candidates in personnel preparation programs.
According to according to
1. As stated or indicated by; on the authority of: according to historians.
2. In keeping with: according to instructions.
3. Miller, Strosnider, and Dooley (2000), of the teachers who have graduated from teacher education programs since the mid 1990s, most have been required to take at least one course that addressed multicultural diversity. If this translates as a separate course, not embedded as core content within/across all courses or assessments throughout their program, it may set up dispositions of separatism sep·a·ra·tist
1. One who secedes or advocates separation, especially from an established church; a sectarian or separationist.
2. without this being the intension in·ten·sion
1. The state or quality of being intense; intensity.
2. The act of becoming intense or more intense; intensification.
3. Logic The sum of the attributes contained in a term. . Hidalgo Hidalgo, state, Mexico
Hidalgo (ēthäl`gō), state (1990 pop. 1,888,366), 8,058 sq mi (20,870 sq km), central Mexico. Pachuca de Soto is the capital. , Chavez-Chavez, and Ramage Ram´age
n. 1. Boughs or branches.
2. Warbling of birds in trees.
a. 1. Wild; untamed.
Ramage branches collectively, 1656. (2002) suggest that teacher educators promote a curriculum infusion INFUSION, med. jur. A pharmaceutical operation, which consists in pouring a hot or cold fluid upon a substance, whose medical properties it is desired to extract. Infusion is also used for the product of this operation. Although infusion differs from decoction, (q.v. approach to diversity training rather than a one-course serves all model.
The early course(s) on multicultural issues, typically, translated only to content about children of African or Latino heritage in urban or inner city settings (Miller, Strosnider, & Dooley, 2000). More recently, requirements have moved beyond this to issues of multicultural/diversity (which encompasses a broader range of learners to include race, ethnicity ethnicity Vox populi Racial status–ie, African American, Asian, Caucasian, Hispanic , physical or mental condition, gender, age, geographic region, sexual orientation sexual orientation
The direction of one's sexual interest toward members of the same, opposite, or both sexes, especially a direction seen to be dictated by physiologic rather than sociologic forces. , religion, language/linguistic, marital status marital status,
n the legal standing of a person in regard to his or her marriage state. , socioeconomic status, or other elements within the definition) (Gibson & Follo
From Rhizomes to Research
The Multicultural/Diversity Outcomes Assessment Project (MC/D) team members (from a participating university located in the Midwest) met often to discuss its plan for the assessment of its candidates within the teacher education programs regarding issues of multicultural/diversity. Discussions ensued about what measurement tools to use, how to distribute them, if the assessment instruments could be embedded within courses, or if they could be placed on-line. The work at hand was exciting, and setting aside time to work with valued and knowledgeable colleagues brought energy to the project. Yet, just as a rhizome rhizome (rī`zōm) or rootstock, fleshy, creeping underground stem by means of which certain plants propagate themselves. Buds that form at the joints produce new shoots. sends out roots below to produce new stems and leaves elsewhere, the faculty team began to reach out, discussing broader interests regarding diversity issues within the College of Education. One area of conversation included how the faculty members, who train our candidates, were informed about diversity issues, and whether they could or should be included in the assessments of diversity. Talk of whether assessing faculty would be threatening in any way ensued. It was known that some studies had minimal response to assessment of faculty on diversity issues in the past (e.g., Gibson & Follo, 1998; Miller, Strosnider, & Dooley, 2000). Like all researchers, however, questions began to shoot up as to how information could be gleaned from faculty to produce answers without feeling threatened. Informally, project team members began to ask each other what affected their practice regarding diversity. Shortly, thereafter, a research question emerged and approval was sought from the IHE's Office of Research Administration to add the research as a part of the assessment conducted within the MC/D project.
The Research Question
In order to meet the needs of a busy faculty, information about the MC/D project and the following research question was sent out to all faculty members within the College of Education via email: "What 'triggers' can you identify regarding your knowledge, skills, and/or dispositions about diversity that affected/changed your practice (whether teaching, research or service)." Triggers were more fully defined in the email request so potential participants knew this translated to what training, interactions, or experiences impacted them enough to change their practices.
The Research Participants
The response from faculty was slow in coming, so the question was distributed again via the email system. As faculty members were met in passing, reminders and encouragement were provided to respond to the request. Following the multiple requests, a total of 17 participants (out of a possible 75, which is a 23% return rate) produced data to be analyzed an·a·lyze
tr.v. an·a·lyzed, an·a·lyz·ing, an·a·lyz·es
1. To examine methodically by separating into parts and studying their interrelations.
2. Chemistry To make a chemical analysis of.
3. . Participants included faculty from the departments of Curriculum and Instruction, Educational Leadership, and Communication Disorders and Sciences within the College of Education. Diversity among participants included faculty who were Americans with Asian heritage (first generation immigrant The term First generation immigrant may be used to describe either of two  classes of people:
The participants in this study generated data in three ways. First, most of the participants provided a reply to the email request/research questions. Some, after giving what they wrote more serious consideration, followed up by sending additional email responses, furthering their reply. Others, when met in passing, shared their experiences in person. During these encounters, the researcher immediately located paper/pencil and recorded these responses in the form of field notes. Others, met in passing, stated they did get the email request, but chose not to reply (these individuals were not asked why, so reasons remain unknown).
Second, syllabi syl·la·bi
A plural of syllabus. from 2001 through 2004 used by the participants responding to the email or in-person request were evaluated to determine what, if any, information could be gleaned that demonstrated what and how multicultural diversity content/performance was embedded in teacher education courses and how it changed over time. Finally, a follow-up follow-up,
n the process of monitoring the progress of a patient after a period of active treatment.
follow-up plan email request was distributed to all of the faculty in the College of Education within the participating university. The email request was intended so participants could provide additional information regarding their perceived needs for continued professional development in the area of multicultural diversity.
Gathering and Analyzing the Data
Triggers. In order to better understand the subjective experiences, perspectives, and views of faculty participants of what triggered their change in practice regarding diversity, answers were analyzed using a constant comparative method of qualitative analysis Qualitative Analysis
Securities analysis that uses subjective judgment based on nonquantifiable information, such as management expertise, industry cycles, strength of research and development, and labor relations. (Maykut & Morehouse Morehouse is a surname, and may refer to
Syllabi. Following the email and in-person interviews, syllabi were reviewed to obtain whether the participants (the 17 participants who responded to the trigger request) were embedding 1. (mathematics) embedding - One instance of some mathematical object contained with in another instance, e.g. a group which is a subgroup.
2. (theory) embedding - (domain theory) A complete partial order F in [X -> Y] is an embedding if content regarding multicultural diversity within their courses taught in the Teacher Education program at the university. Data was compared across the academic years of 2001 through 2004 to note (a) whether or not multicultural information was included within the syllabus/course, and (b) whether or not changes in syllabi/courses regarding multicultural diversity were noted across the target years.
Perceived Professional Development Needs. Finally, email and hard copy survey responses from faculty in the College of Education were analyzed to look for patterns of need for continued professional development in the area of multicultural diversity. Note that only one request was made by email with a follow-up hard copy survey request distributed at a faculty meeting. Further follow-up reminders, thereafter, were not distributed.
Reporting the Results
Trigger Data. Final participants (n=17) were quite articulate articulate /ar·tic·u·late/ (ahr-tik´u-lat)
1. to pronounce clearly and distinctly.
2. to make speech sounds by manipulation of the vocal organs.
3. to express in coherent verbal form.
4. in how they gained the knowledge, skills and dispositions about issues of diversity that impacted what was embedded into their practices. Following analysis of the narrative data (email/interview), ten coded categories emerged to explain what triggered (i.e., affected/impacted) changes across their responsibilities (e.g., teaching, scholarship and service). Those categories consisted of (a) professional bodies that set standards/ guidelines guidelines,
n.pl a set of standards, criteria, or specifications to be used or followed in the performance of certain tasks. for diversity in professional training within educational programs; (b) lived experiences, including those from across their childhood through adulthood; (c) reading of research/literature; (d) involvement from specific grant/other projects that included issues of diversity; (e) interactions and/or friendships from others who influenced or inspired them; (f) information gained from reviewing evaluation/assessment instruments; (g) threats of legal action/grievances; (h) videos; (i) attending conferences; and (j) a final category emerged regarding emphasis from participants wanting to make sure that the researcher knew their definition of diversity went beyond just color. Appendix A summarizes the codes, changes and number of participants within each code.
The category that emerged as the one most discussed by participants was their lived experiences. These examples included those from childhood through adulthood, including personal encounters within their courses. One participant told of an experience in class that triggered change:
As I taught the Introduction to the Exceptional Learner course, we were discussing whether we thought there were biases built into the identification process of special education. A lively conversation began with candidates talking about how tests were old, so didn't contain information relevant to today's society. Others talked about how tests were normed. One student, an American girl with African heritage, stated that she remembered a time in grade school where she would walk the halls past one room that she thought was the classroom where all Black males were sent. She found out later it was the special education room. This remark stopped the conversations cold. From that experience, I immediately began a search of the literature for determining biases within special education testing. I included this information thereafter in every course I taught.
Another participant, along these same lines, remarked:
I remember visiting a middle school in USD 259 with a very diverse population of students. When we passed the classroom where students with gifts and talents were in attendance, diversity in that class was clearly missing. The population of students did not match the population in other classes.
Others talked of professional experiences prior to coming to a position at an IHE:
Having loved teaching in Detroit, I asked to teach in a low-income school where about 25% of the students were minority, both Black and Native American. I then took a position as a teacher corps team leader in a minority-teaching grant. We had 6 team leaders (I was the minority white person) and 40 interns (4 white). My real enculturation began here. I studied minority students. I worked with minority peers and candidates. I worked in minority schools. I attended and taught minority studies workshops. I would go to a restaurant with one of the Black team leaders whose husband was a vice chancellor at KU. Never did they approach her to ask her to follow them to be seated, they always approached me. Never did they ask her first what she wanted to eat, they always asked me first. Politely with a grin I would say 'please ask her first.' I attended dinners, ate things I had never eaten (chitlins and greens are not my favorite, but with Tobasco, I went back for seconds).
Some participants talked of personal experiences within community events that impacted a change in attitudes:
I remember a time when I went to a Cinco de Mayo celebration held within a Hispanic community. I couldn't wait to eat some of the food being served out of individual booths. I had my three small children with me, in order for them to experience a cultural celebration different from their own. We appeared to be one of very few White faces in the crowd. We were enjoying the music when we decided we were hungry. I finally found the booth that served authentic tamales--my favorite. We waited quite a while in line, finally making our way to the front of the line. I turned in our order for tamales only to be told they were all out of food--so sorry. I was so disappointed, but thanked them and turned to leave. While walking away, I turned to encourage one of my children to hurry and catch up, only to see that the individuals in line after us (Hispanic heritage) were being served the food. My first reaction was of extreme anger--how could they have done this--it was discrimination. Then, within seconds, I thought--oh, I get it; now I can begin to understand the angry feelings of many of them in similar situations. From that moment, my attitude changed.
Other categories included how participants sought out knowledge from reading relevant literature, from choosing specific sessions on diversity at professional conferences, and from professional organizations.
Your question is a good one but also a difficult one to answer. I started integrating issues of diversity into my teaching and research quite a few years ago. I'm hoping I remember correctly! I suppose the "triggers" were two. First, ASHA has been promoting the importance of cultural and linguistic diversity (CLD) for quite a few years. A person in higher ed would be hard pressed not to know of the importance of infusing the curriculum with diversity or being aware of having a diverse population when studying specific aspect of language and literacy research. Second, just being in child/adolescent language and literacy, it is difficult not to understand the effect that CLD has on language and literacy acquisition. As far as how my teaching and research has changed, I guess there are two more answers. First, I integrate literature and lecture much more on the effects of CLD on language and literacy development. Second, I try to ensure I have a range of CLD in the participants in my studies.
From the 17 participants, 10 made sure that the researcher understood first that they have been influenced in areas of diversity beyond that of race/ethnicity only.
In both Masters programs, we have teachers from large school districts (urban) and people from small school districts (suburban and rural). This has made me reexamine the various strategies that I present in methods classes as most of my teaching experience is in urban settings. I seek examples of major topics from students in suburban and rural settings to add to the course content--so application is more easily pictured by students.
This same respondent In Equity practice, the party who answers a bill or other proceeding in equity. The party against whom an appeal or motion, an application for a court order, is instituted and who is required to answer in order to protect his or her interests. provided additional information for this category by stating "Poverty is another diversity issue with the teachers in my classes and how they can 'deal' with it so that students learn." One participant who is Australian provided the following:
More recent and more subtle influences on my current behavior and attitude have resulted from my own experience as "not so much a stranger in a foreign land." The fact that I look like many of my colleagues in this institution has de-emphasized that my heritage and background experience are different. In this culture there seems to be an unspoken belief that race or ethnicity doesn't really count unless one's skin is a dramatically different color or unless one belongs to one of a small number of officially recognized minorities. Reflection on the situations that result from this disparity is instructive personally and professionally.
A few participants talked of gaining additional knowledge and skills from grant projects in which they were involved:
When I think of the way my treatment of diversity issues has evolved in the past two years, three triggers come to mind. The first was the IMPACT Project. Though I have always included issues of special education in my elementary methods courses (science methods and integrated mathematics-science methods), my knowledge of those issues was largely based in experience as a classroom teacher, and my formal knowledge was somewhat superficial. The IMPACT Project helped to deepen my knowledge and consider some new possibilities. The way that this new knowledge was enacted in my classroom was greatly influenced by the second trigger: team teaching for a semester with one of our special education faculty who also has expertise in mathematics. As a result of her modeling, I've become much more insistent that my students take their responsibilities seriously during field experiences. Finally, I've been increasingly influenced by the situations that I see as I supervise my students in their field experiences. Many of them are placed in schools and classrooms with significant numbers of children with limited English proficiency, and it has become abundantly clear that they must be prepared to reach this population as well. What we find, of course, is that many of the strategies that are most successful in reaching special needs populations are also very successful in meeting the needs of the general population. With thoughtful planning, the adjustments in instruction and assessment often turn out to be quite minor.
Reading and listening to what affected and changed participant's knowledge, skills and disabilities about issues of diversity, again, produced a rhizome effect. As more and more participants mentioned that it was their "lived experiences" (largest coded category) that impacted a change, additional questions began to emerge for future research efforts. For example, if this is true of faculty, would it, also, be true of our current candidates. Do preservice and graduate level professional programs need to make sure that candidates have increased and more diverse experiences within their programs? Do programs need to rethink re·think
tr. & intr.v. re·thought , re·think·ing, re·thinks
To reconsider (something) or to involve oneself in reconsideration.
re what those experiences consist of, rather than just assuming that placements in diverse schools alone will meet requirements and produce educators with the required knowledge, skills and dispositions?
Syllabi Review. Syllabi from faculty participants were examined between the academic years of 2001 through 2004. Specific content was searched for information about multicultural diversity within the course title, course description, major topics, candidate/student outcomes, and assessments. One immediate, notable difference was that syllabi for the years of 2001, 2002, and 2003 had various formats of preparation by the faculty members teaching the courses. By 2004, however, all faculty members used a common template (1) A pre-designed document or data file formatted for common purposes such as a fax, invoice or business letter. If the document contains an automated process, such as a word processing macro or spreadsheet formula, then the programming is already written and embedded in the that aligned the major topics and candidate learning outcomes with the College of Education's (COE See common operating environment. ) Conceptual Framework (which includes the guiding principle of human development and diversity), the NCATE standard on diversity (NCATE, 2002), and state standards (which for some included standards with indicators requiring content of multicultural diversity). Additionally, syllabi were all noted to increase the content for multicultural diversity between the years reviewed. Examples of changes in selected syllabi (three of the 17 faculty participants, representing courses at the early childhood, elementary and secondary levels) regarding inclusion of content about multicultural diversity across the years Across The Years is one of a few ultrarunning festivals still taking place in the USA. Founded in 1983 by Harold Sieglaff the race has changed over the years in location as well as organisation. Today the race is held at Nardini Manor about 45 minutes from downtown Phoenix, AZ. of 2001 through 2004 are found in Appendix B.
Knowing that the university underwent NCATE accreditation accreditation,
n a process of formal recognition of a school or institution attesting to the required ability and performance in an area of education, training, or practice. review in the fall of 2004, the use of a common syllabus A headnote; a short note preceding the text of a reported case that briefly summarizes the rulings of the court on the points decided in the case.
The syllabus appears before the text of the opinion. template that aligned content with the COE Conceptual Framework and the standards became a trigger for change for all faculty members in the teacher education programs. Additionally, as faculty prepared for the NCATE review during the fall of 2004, the diversity standard (NCATE, 2002) became a topic of discussion that contributed to faculty focusing on how their syllabi reflected what was taught in the course (faculty participant emails and interviews).
Perceived Needs for Continued Professional Development. As a final, culminating act of this research, faculty participants were provided with both an email and follow-up survey request (handed out at a faculty meeting) asking what they perceived as further professional development needs in the area of multicultural diversity. Faculty responses (n=12) were analyzed for distinct categories. The needs included: (a) need for additional resource support such as attending trainings at conferences and/or workshops on diversity/multicultural education, and additional videos or other materials that could be viewed in courses regarding issues of multicultural diversity; (b) additional training on recruiting and retaining of candidates/students who are from diverse backgrounds, (c) additional training on how to work with candidates/students who are from diverse backgrounds in order to provide the support needed to be successful in their programs, and (d) additional training on the culture of poverty to make sure this diversity is included in our courses and field experiences.
This information is intended as only a beginning to understanding how faculty members within IHEs gain their own knowledge, skills and dispositions regarding multicultural/diversity. The participants were limited in numbers in numbered parts; as, a book published in numbers.
See also: Number and to only one university teacher education program. Additionally, faculty were not observed regarding whether or not what was said in their emails or interviews or what was reflected in their course syllabi was actually taught/included within their courses/practice. Therefore, there are limitations to this current study. In order to fully understand the issues, the what, when, why, and how of ways faculty gain the information embedded in their programs, and how it "triggers" change in their practices, additional research needs to be conducted.
The field of education is uniquely poised to make real differences for our future. Through quality educational programs, students will learn to live and work together in an increasingly diverse global society. By providing strong adult models, including teachers and other educators, that mirror the children's and youth's culture, by sharing dispositions that all children belong and are valued members of our society, and by meeting individual needs at higher levels, all of our futures will be brighter.
First steps toward meeting this goal is to increase not only the knowledge, skills, and dispositions of teacher candidates/students, but to, also, increase it for the faculty who train them. Inquiring inquiring,
v to draw information from a client—whether by verbal questioning or physical examination—to assess the person's state of health. about the current strengths and needs of faculty regarding multicultural education can be a beginning. Providing resources, whether sending faculty to conferences/workshops or conducting in-house training, can be an asset. Existing literature can be obtained for faculty that provides strategies for multicultural education of teachers (e.g., Smith, 1998; Vavrus, 2002).
Secondly, in order to meet the diverse needs of students and their families within our school systems, greater effort must be placed in recruiting and retaining diverse teacher candidates and the faculty who teach them. Research has been conducted regarding effective strategies for recruitment of diverse teacher candidates and faculty (Patton Pat·ton , Charley 1881-1934.
American blues singer and guitarist who wrote several blues standards, including "Mississippi Boll Weevil Blues," and helped pioneer the Mississippi blues style. , Williams, Floyd Floyd is a variant spelling of the Welsh name Lloyd, which means grey, and may refer to: Places
Bowers Bowers is a surname, and may refer to
Even though teacher preparation programs at IHE may not be where education on diversity begins, or where it should begin, for candidates/ future educators, but it can certainly affect changes thereafter. Teacher education programs can make diversity the core of its pedagogy, content knowledge, field/community experiences, and assessments so that future educators can better meet the diverse needs of students within their classrooms/programs. Faculty can, also, connect and collaborate with other departments across campus to assist in embedding diversity content into other courses. Assessing candidate knowledge, skills and dispositions regarding diversity can provide valuable information for individual and/or program improvement. In order to begin this process, however, efforts must be placed on educating the trainers of these future teachers.
This study gives only a beginning insight into what triggers faculty at institutions of higher education to fit diversity into their practices, whether teaching, research or service. It cannot be assumed that all faculty, whether long-term veterans or newly hired doctoral program graduates, have extensive preparation in the area of diversity, or that what is embedded in their practice comes only through their formal training. Ongoing recruitment and retention of a diverse faculty, professional develop and personal experiences in the area of multicultural diversity, in its broadest sense (e.g., beyond race and inclusive of inclusive of
Taking into consideration or account; including. the culture of poverty), through a variety of venues, and additional resources must be provided in order for real change to occur.
Appendix A Trigger Data Category/Code Changes Suggested Number for Triggers Due to Triggers1 of Respondents Who Mentioned This Trigger Professional * Used as guides to embed 4 Bodies Who Set into courses/syllabi Standards/ Guidelines * Used as guides to better 3 (NCATE, document what is currently ASHA, CEC) done regarding diversity within courses * Used as knowledge-base 4 for many areas of "diversity" Total Respondents to this Trigger Code = 4/17 Lived * Increased/changed 14 Experiences dispositions regarding (Childhood biases, inequities in self experiences 2/10; As teachers in * Used in class lecture 6 programs 5/10; Via students * Use in class discussions 12 comments or behaviors in * Used in research, as 3 courses/class 6/10; examples In a leadership role 1/10; * Used to guide interactions 2 Observations with students within educational settings during * Prompted additional 4 students supervised learning (read books, took visits 5/10) classes, attended conferences) Total Respondents to this Trigger Code = 14/17 Research/Literature * Used information, 5/17 (Seek out written embed in areas of forms of knowledge) teaching and research Specific Projects * Increased information 1 (IMPACT grant, for class lecture SpEd focus), MC/D grant * Changed dispositions (to 1 (inclusive become more inclusive) diversity focus) * No response to change 1 Total Respondents to this Trigger Code = 3/17 Individuals Who * Changed dispositions 4 Have Influenced or Inspired * Use information in course 3 (Interactions and work relationships Total Respondents developed between to this Trigger faculty and another Code = 4/17 who had a different cultural background) Beyond "Color" * Faculty who described 10/17 as a Definition triggers beyond just as described by race/color (including exceptionality, SES level, geographic location, gender, international views, sexual orientation) Lack of valid and * Seeking additional 1/17 reliable assessment knowledge/skills on how to instruments modify assessments so they are appropriate (not biased) for students with special needs Threat of legal * No change mentioned 1/17 action or grievance being filed Watching Videos * No change mentioned 1/17 Attended * Included information in 1 Conferences courses * No change mentioned 1 Total Respondents to this Trigger Code = 2/17 Appendix B Syllabi and Multicultural Content Changes over Time for Three Courses Course--Instructional Strategies Preschool Education 2001 2002 2003 2004 MC/D Content: MC/D Content: MC/D Content: MC/D Content: Major Topics: Major Topics: Major Topics: [Aligned with COE (only place Same as 2001, Same as 2001 Conceptual that included plus added in and 2002 Framework: Human diversity): special Development and education Diversity; NCATE Standard 4; and "DAP Assessments: Assessments: State Licensure Curriculum- Comprehensive Multicultural Standards.] multicultural" Written Unit - Story Outline added in to and Lesson Major Topics: "Integrated remember the Plan (choose remained the same as Curriculum- different ages, a book from 2003 socially stages, another understanding families, and culture than Assessment: self and cultures of the your own and Same as 2003 others" children. make an outline that Outcomes: can be tied Added included: into a lesson "Incorporate plan) concepts and materials from many Graduate cultures in planning Project was learning added to environments for create a DAP young children;" and activity "Demonstrate respect related to for differences in multicultural family values and lesson plan describe strategies for working in partnership with families to encourage young children's development." Course--Instructional Strategies in Math and Science Elementary School 2001 2002 2003 2004 MC/D Content: MC/D Content: MC/D Content: MC/D Content: [Aligned with COE Major Topics: Same as 2001 Same as 2002, Conceptual "Teaching except added: Framework: Human mathematics Textbooks- Development and and science to Readings Guided Diversity; NCATE ALL students - included the Inquiry Standard 4; and diversity" National Math Section - "4. State Licensure and Science How will Standards.] Student Standards, multiple Outcomes: which calls diverse Same as 2003, plus "Plan, teach & for issues of perspectives added in display a diversity enhance the Assessments: Added knowledge of teaching of in Teacher Work diversity mathematics Sample, which issues" and science includes in your requirements of classroom?" identifying special cultures within the school placement and how individual needs, based on culture, would be met. Course--Instructional Strategies Secondary 2001 2002 2003 2004 MC/D Content: MC/D Content: MC/D Content: MC/D Content: [Aligned with COE Major Topics: Same as 2001 Major Topics: Conceptual "Gender and "No child Framework: Human ethnic equity left behind, Development and issues in meeting needs Diversity; NCATE science" of all Standard 4; and students" State Licensure Outcomes: "Gender and Standards.] "Demonstrate ethnicity an awareness equity issues Major Topics and of and a way in science" Outcomes were the of addressing same, except added gender equity Outcomes: to Outcomes and while teaching "Identify linked to COE science." strategies Conceptual for reaching Framework:"The every student teacher understands in the the abilities and classroom. developmental Describe the readiness of students students to learn and the science content and strategies skills" and "The which meet teacher understands their needs." the psychological "Demonstrate and social an awareness environment of and a way conducive to the of addressing students' gender equity intellectual, while social, and personal teaching growth in science science" education"
Bowers, C. A., & Apffel-Marglin, F. (2005). Rethinking Freire Freire is a surname, and may refer to:
Process by which the experience of everyday life, marked by the diffusion of commodities and ideas, is becoming standardized around the world. Factors that have contributed to globalization include increasingly sophisticated communications and transportation and the environmental crisis. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Lawrence.
1 City (1990 pop. 26,763), Marion co., central Ind., a residential suburb of Indianapolis, on the West Fork of the White River. It has light manufacturing.
2 City (1990 pop. 65,608), seat of Douglas co., NE Kans. Erlbaum.
Campbell-Whatley, G. D. (2003). Recruiting and retaining of culturally and linguistically diverse groups iin special education: Defining the problem. Teacher Education and Special Education, 26(4), 255-263.
Dieker, L., Voltz, D., & Epanchin, B. (2002). Report of the wingspread conference: Preparing teachers to work with diverse learners. Teacher Education and Special Education, 25(1), 1-10.
Fenwick, L. T. (2001). Patterns of excellence: Policy perspectives in diversity in teaching and school leadership. Atlanta Atlanta (ətlăn`tə, ăt–), city (1990 pop. 394,017), state capital and seat of Fulton co., NW Ga., on the Chattahoochee R. and Peachtree Creek, near the Appalachian foothills; inc. 1847. , GA: Southern Education Foundation.
Gibson, S. L., & Follo, E. J. (1998). The status of multicultural education in Michigan Michigan (mĭsh`ĭgən), upper midwestern state of the United States. It consists of two peninsulas thrusting into the Great Lakes and has borders with Ohio and Indiana (S), Wisconsin (W), and the Canadian province of Ontario (N,E). . Multicultural Education, 6(2), 17-22.
Hidalgo, F., Chavez-Chavez, R., & Ramage, J. C. (2002). Multicultural education landscape for reform in the twenty-first century. Retrieved September September: see month. 9, 2004, from http://education.nmsu.edu/ci/mce/ruchavez/publications/ 8_MULTICULTURAL %EDUCATION.htm/.
Maykut, P., & Morehouse, R. (1994). Beginning qualitative research Qualitative research
Traditional analysis of firm-specific prospects for future earnings. It may be based on data collected by the analysts, there is no formal quantitative framework used to generate projections. : A philosophic and practical guide. Washington, DC: Falmer
Miller, M., Strosnider, R., & Dooley, E. (2000). States' requirements for teachers' preparation for diversity. Multicultural Education, 8(2), 15-18.
National Council for Accreditation of Teacher Education (2002). Professional standards for the accreditation of schools, colleges, and departments of education. Washington, DC: Author.
Patton, J. M., Williams, B. R., Floyd, L. O., & Cobb, T. R. (2003). Recruiting and retaining culturally and linguistically diverse teachers in special education: Models for successful personnel preparation. Teacher Education and Special Education, 26(4), 288-303.
Smith, G. P. (1998). Common sense about uncommon knowledge Uncommon Knowledge was a weekly 30-minute current affairs show hosted by Peter Robinson and co-produced and presented by San Jose, California, PBS member station KTEH from 1997 to 2005. : The knowledge bases for diversity. Washington, DC: American Association of Colleges for Teacher Education Publications.
Vavrus, M. (2002). Transforming the multicultural education of teachers: Theory, research, and practice. New York New York, state, United States
New York, Middle Atlantic state of the United States. It is bordered by Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and the Atlantic Ocean (E), New Jersey and Pennsylvania (S), Lakes Erie and Ontario and the Canadian province of : Teachers College Press.
Linda Mitchell Mitchell, city (1990 pop. 13,798), seat of Davison co., SE S.Dak.; inc. 1881. Mitchell is a trade, distribution, and shipping center for a dairy and livestock area.
Wichita State University Wichita State University (WSU) is an American state-supported university located in the city of Wichita, Kansas. WSU is one of six state universities governed by the Kansas Board of Regents. The current President is Dr. Donald Beggs.
(1) This paper was presented at the 2nd National Conference on Assessment of Multicultural/Diversity Outcomes, April 3, 2004, Kansas City, Missouri Kansas City is the largest city in the state of Missouri. It encompasses parts of Jackson, Clay, Cass, and Platte counties and is the anchor city of the Kansas City Metropolitan Area, the second largest in Missouri, which includes counties in both Missouri and Kansas. .
(2) Note that not all participants provided how their triggers changed their practice.