IRS liable for making disclosures to doctor's patients.Barrett, a plastic surgeon plastic surgeon A surgeon specialized in reconstruction or cosmetic enhancement of various body regions, most commonly the face–nose, chin, and cheeks, breasts and buttocks; PSs remove fat deposits through liposuction; PSs reduce scarring or disfigurement , was under civil investigation by the Internal Revenue Service. When a $100,000 discrepancy was revealed between Barrett's books and bank records, the IRS An abbreviation for the Internal Revenue Service, a federal agency charged with the responsibility of administering and enforcing internal revenue laws. transferred the case to the criminal investigation division (CID Cid or Cid Campeador (sĭd, Span. thēth kämpāäthōr`) [Span.,=lord conqueror], d. 1099, Spanish soldier and national hero, whose real name was Rodrigo (or Ruy) Díaz de Vivar. ). The special agent conducting the CID investigation issued administrative summonses to the hospitals where Barrett had admitting privileges admitting privilege Managed care The right, by virtue of membership on a hospital's medical staff, to admit private Pts in a particular medical center or hospital, and to render specific diagnostic or therapeutic services in that hospital. See Staff privileges. and obtained the names of 386 of his patients. The agent sent them form letters, asking how much they paid Barrett and whether they paid him in cash. The letters contained Barrett's name and address and the fact that the CID was investigating him--all items of "tax return information." Barrett sued the IRS under Internal Revenue Code The Internal Revenue Code is the body of law that codifies all federal tax laws, including income, estate, gift, excise, alcohol, tobacco, and employment taxes. These laws constitute title 26 of the U.S. Code (26 U.S.C.A. § 1 et seq. section 7431, which gives taxpayers the right to sue for a U.S. government employee's knowing or negligent negligent adj., adv. careless in not fulfilling responsibility. (See: negligence) disclosure of tax return information in violation of IRC (Internet Relay Chat) Computer conferencing on the Internet. There are hundreds of IRC channels on numerous subjects that are hosted on IRC servers around the world. After joining a channel, your messages are broadcast to everyone listening to that channel. section 6103. Section 6103 generally provides that tax returns and tax return information are to be kept confidential and outlines exceptions to the rule. One exception, in section 6103 (k)(6), allows IRS employees to disclose return information for investigative purposes, but only to the extent the disclosure is necessary to obtain information not otherwise reasonably available. Barrett argued the information should have been obtained by other means, namely examination of bank statements and detailed cross-referencing between bank statements and other taxpayer documents. The district court held for the IRS, saying the disclosures were necessary to obtain information not otherwise reasonably available. (Barrett, DC S. Tex., 1993.) Barrett appealed to the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals. Result: For Barrett. It was not necessary for the IRS to disclose the criminal nature of the investigation to obtain the information it sought. The IRS is liable to Barrett for unlawful disclosure under section 6103, and the amount of damages to be awarded will be determined by the district court. * Barrett (5th Cir., 1995). |
|
||||||||||||||||||
Printer friendly
Cite/link
Email
Feedback
Reader Opinion