IN SEARCH OF GENDER-SENSITIVE CONCEPTS AND MEASURES OF POVERTY, INEQUALITY AND WELL-BEING.INTRODUCTION(1)
Despite many decades of feminist research, it is still not possible to obtain a full picture of women's levels of economic well-being. Throughout the twentieth century feminists drew attention to the large and persistent gap between men's and women's average incomes from paid work. More specifically, feminist research provided information from the 1980s onwards on·ward
Moving or tending forward.
adv. also on·wards
In a direction or toward a position that is ahead in space or time; forward.
Adv. 1. about women and poverty (Millar and Glendinning 1987), including the poverty and economic inequality
Economic inequality refers to disparities in the distribution of economic assets and income. experienced by women within heterosexual partnerships (Pahl 1980, Vogler 1989, Vogler and Pahl 1993), the effects of poverty on women's health Women's Health Definition
Women's health is the effect of gender on disease and health that encompasses a broad range of biological and psychosocial issues. (Payne 1991, Graham 1993) and the feminisation Noun 1. feminisation - the process of becoming feminized; the development of female characteristics (loss of facial hair or breast enlargement) in a male because of hormonal disorders or castration
feminization of poverty (Scott 1984). However, researchers have pointed out that they have been and continue to be hampered by a shortage of useful and reliable national and international data on women's economic position (Payne 1991:46, Graham 1993:17). This is to a large extent because of major deficiencies in the ways in which data on poverty and inequality have been conceptualised and gathered by governments and international organisations Noun 1. international organisation - an international alliance involving many different countries
global organization, international organization, world organisation, world organization .
Well-established ways of conceptualising and measuring poverty Although the most severe poverty is in the developing world, there is evidence of poverty in every region. In developed countries, this condition results in wandering homeless people and poor suburbs and ghettos. , such as Gross Domestic Product (GDP GDP (guanosine diphosphate): see guanine. ), have been strongly criticised for their narrowness (their primary focus on market income, production and consumption) and the difficulties of making meaningful comparisons between the richer OECD OECD: see Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development. nations and countries with very low GDP. In particular, some critics of these measures of poverty focus on their gender blindness (Waring 1989). Because these conventional measures of poverty and inequality focus on market-based activities, whereas much of women's work continues to be unpaid, such measures provide at best only a partial picture of women's economic situation.
In the 1990s, partly as a response to some of the inadequacies of established conceptualisations and indicators, there was a growth in the number and type of ways of understanding and measuring poverty, inequality and well-being. In this paper I briefly look at Genuine Progress Indicators The Genuine Progress Indicator (GPI) is a concept in green economics and welfare economics that has been suggested as a replacement metric for gross domestic product (GDP) as a metric of economic growth. , the United Nations Human Development Index and the concepts of social exclusion social exclusion
Sociol the failure of society to provide certain people with those rights normally available to its members, such as employment, health care, education, etc. , time-poverty and health variations. Some of these have already been adopted by governments to varying extents, whilst others have so far been used primarily by critics wishing to illustrate the deficiencies in existing ways of looking at poverty, inequality and well-being. What the newer measures have in common is that they not only measure income or market production and consumption, but also look at a wide variety of indices such as mortality, health, leisure, opportunities, the environment and participation in social life.
This paper examines the extent to which both established and newer conceptualisations and measures of poverty, inequality and well-being are capable of taking greater account of women's material situation.
GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT AND GROSS NATIONAL PRODUCT
The most commonly used indicators of the wealth of nations have been per capita [Latin, By the heads or polls.] A term used in the Descent and Distribution of the estate of one who dies without a will. It means to share and share alike according to the number of individuals. Gross Domestic Product (GDP) and, to a lesser extent, Gross National Product (GNP GNP
See: Gross National Product ). GDP, the more commonly used measure, is defined as the monetary value of final goods and services In economics, economic output is divided into physical goods and intangible services. Consumption of goods and services is assumed to produce utility (unless the "good" is a "bad"). It is often used when referring to a Goods and Services Tax. provided in a country. GNP is defined as the total value of wages, rents, interest and profits of a nation's residents (Hamilton 1997). The difference between them is that GNP includes interest from overseas investments and excludes dividends paid to foreign capital. Usually it is assumed that growth in GDP and/or GNP (also known as economic growth) results in improvements in well-being. Seldom is this assumption challenged. It is often assumed that if a country slips in its rate of GNP per capita, its residents must be becoming poorer or worse off compared with those in countries that can boast faster economic growth.
In fact, however, economic growth can be occurring in terms of per capita GNP and/or GDP, whilst at the same time people are becoming worse off. This is partly because of what GNP and GDP actually measure, as Waring (1989) has pointed out. The current concept of economic growth gives value to disasters (or at least the clean-up operations), arms production and wars, environmental pollution and any market-based work. It accords no value to clean air and water, native flora or fauna fauna
All the species of animals found in a particular region, period, or special environment. Five faunal realms, based on terrestrial animal species, are generally recognized: Holarctic, including Nearactic (North America) and Paleartic (Eurasia and northern Africa); , or indeed to any non-market activity, including essential work like bearing and raising children and household work. In 1993 the United Nations Commission, which is responsible for the System of National Accounts, recommended that the value of goods produced by households, including for their own consumption, be included in GDP. However, the value of services produced in households for use by household members, such as childcare and cooking (work done chiefly by women) is still not included in the main accounts (Fleming and Spellerberg 1999:9).
The use of GDP and GNP becomes especially problematic in countries where inequality is increasing, and where there are significant numbers of people at the extremes of wealth and poverty. This is because GNP and GDP provide measures of averaged data and so are unable to capture income inequality. In New Zealand New Zealand (zē`lənd), island country (2005 est. pop. 4,035,000), 104,454 sq mi (270,534 sq km), in the S Pacific Ocean, over 1,000 mi (1,600 km) SE of Australia. The capital is Wellington; the largest city and leading port is Auckland. , between 1984 and 1998, the richest 10 per cent of the population became substantially better off, whilst the majority became poorer, and those on the lowest incomes became substantially worse off (Podder and Chatterjee 1998). Women have long been the majority of those on low incomes, and in recent years structural adjustment policies world-wide have been increasing women's poverty relative to men's and increasing the amount of unpaid work performed by women (Sparr 1994:21-8). The use of GDP and GNP as measures serves to disguise this transfer of income away from poor women. As a result of shortcomings A shortcoming is a character flaw.
Shortcomings may also be:
GENUINE PROGRESS INDICATORS (GPIS GPIS Graphics Peripheral Interface Standard )
Like the conventional measures described above, Genuine Progress Indicators (GPIs) aim to measure the economic progress of nations or their decline over time. However, in other respects they differ sharply from GDP and GNP.
GPIs have been developed by alternative economists in the USA (Daly and Cobb 1990), the UK (Jackson and Marks 1994) and Australia (Hamilton 1997). Their main aim is to question the value base of the conventional measures used by governments, and in particular GNP and GDP. The underlying assumptions of GPIs are at variance with those of conventional measurements. According to according to
1. As stated or indicated by; on the authority of: according to historians.
2. In keeping with: according to instructions.
3. Hamilton (1997:2), "They are based on the assumption that we live in a society rather than an economy; and further that society is embedded Inserted into. See embedded system. in and depends on the natural environment".
GPIs include items which GDP and GNP leave out, such as the value of unpaid work in the home and community (Hamilton 1997:8). In addition, GPIs include a debit account for "bads" such as crime, unemployment, environmental pollution and "defensive spending" (for example on extra policing, burglar BURGLAR. One who commits a burglary. (q. v.) alarms, vitamins and health care) which conventional measures do not. The concept of sustainability is also central to GPIs, so that whilst some increases in consumption are regarded as good, environmental costs (for example the costs of commuting) are debited. Like GDP and GNP, however, GPIs do not measure inequalities such as the difference between women's and men's earnings known as the "gender pay gap". It is not their role to measure inequality within nations (although the existence and consequences of inequality, captured by other measures, may be used in the debit accounts of GPIs). However, because GPIs place value on non-market contributions to the national well-being, they are more likely to lead to a valuing of unpaid household work, around 70 per cent of which is performed by women (Bittman 1991:32).
Nonetheless, systems of accounting, even alternative systems, which measure the economic well-being of whole nations, fail to capture gender inequality. Therefore it is necessary to look at ways of conceptualising and measuring poverty, inequality and well-being within nations, and which can also be used as a basis for comparison between nations. The most accessible of these is measurement of incomes.
How well do measurements of income provide an accurate picture of women's poverty, inequality and well-being? The answer seems to be that, in the OECD nations at least, it is probably the most accurate way of measuring poverty and inequality and one of the best predictors of other aspects of well-being such as health. Measuring incomes is vital because most women (and men) in the OECD nations do not usually have access to land and capital, and so are reliant on a cash income to cover basic needs such as food, clothing and housing.
Measuring income poverty in a meaningful way, even within the richer nations, is nevertheless still problematic. This is partly because people with the same income often have very different financial outgoings. For example, housing costs vary between areas and between individuals, depending on family size and whether that family is renting, paying a mortgage or owns their home freehold Freehold, borough, United States
Freehold, borough (1990 pop. 10,742), seat of Monmouth co., E central N.J.; settled c.1650, called Monmouth Courthouse (1715–1801), inc. as a town 1869, as a borough 1919. . Single mothers are particularly likely to be poor, partly because they require the use of an entire house, but are less likely than couples or widows to own their home freehold, and they generally have only one income from which to pay all the housing costs. Childcare costs generally also come out of mothers' incomes, even when the women are partnered, despite the fact that women's incomes are usually lower than those of male partners.
The gender-sensitivity of the measurement of incomes is variable. The overall effect of this variability is to understate un·der·state
v. un·der·stat·ed, un·der·stat·ing, un·der·states
1. To state with less completeness or truth than seems warranted by the facts.
2. the extent of women's poverty. For example, it is possible to obtain a relatively clear picture of the material standard of living of women raising children alone on state welfare benefits, since most benefits are income tested, and beneficiaries also provide information about their major expenses such as rent and their dependants. There is plenty of evidence that lone mothers on benefits are poor (Millar 1992, Edin and Lein 1997)(2). However, there is still little information collected (apart from mainly small-scale research projects) about the personal incomes of partnered women, especially those who are unemployed or out of the paid labour force.
In fact, large-scale collection of data on women's personal disposable incomes disposable income
Portion of an individual's income over which the recipient has complete discretion. To assess disposable income, it is necessary to determine total income, including not only wages and salaries, interest and dividend payments, and business profits, but also seldom occurs, because of the persistent assumption that women receive a full share of household income. For example, the incomes of couples and/or households have continued to be aggregated by governments in studies such as the Household Labour Force Survey and in the research design of major international studies such as the Luxembourg Income Study The Luxembourg Income Study, asbl (LIS) is a non-profit project which produces a cross-national database of micro-economic income data for social science research. The project started in 1983 and is headquartered in Luxembourg. . This is despite the fact that feminist researchers have demonstrated that intrahousehold distribution of income is frequently inequitable and that some women living in relationships with high-income earners are nevertheless extremely poor (Vogler 1989, Vogler and Pahl 1983).
Even when fairly comprehensive data is collected on the differences between men and women's incomes, the information derived is frequently made available in ways that tend to downplay down·play
tr.v. down·played, down·play·ing, down·plays
To minimize the significance of; play down: downplayed the bad news.
Verb 1. the gender difference in pay. For example, the statistics most often quoted on the gap between male and female earnings are those pertaining per·tain
intr.v. per·tained, per·tain·ing, per·tains
1. To have reference; relate: evidence that pertains to the accident.
2. to the difference in hourly rates. In most of the English-speaking nations women receive around 20 per cent less pay per hour than men (Briar briar: see brier. 1994)(3). However, because women in most nations have shorter hours of paid work than men and also tend to have the most insecure in·se·cure
1. Lacking emotional stability; not well-adjusted.
2. Lacking self-confidence; plagued by anxiety.
in employment, the gap between women and men's weekly and annual incomes is much wider than the gap in hourly rates. Further, it is weekly and annual incomes that are more likely to determine women's standard of living.
The collection of data on incomes, despite flaws in the manner it is collected, remains potentially one of the most useful ways of studying the extent of women's poverty, and the degree of inequality between women and men within a country. Examining incomes can also be a simple and useful way of comparing the amount of poverty amongst women between as well as within the relatively wealthy OECD countries. There are numerous ways of defining low incomes (Dex DEX - A cross between Modula-2 and C by W. van Oortmerssen.
Amiga version 1.2. et al. 1994) and there is not the space to consider them all here. However, a commonly used indicator of poverty in comparative social policy is less than 50 per cent of (equivalised) average (median) income, although in New Zealand, where average incomes are low, the figure of 60 per cent is sometimes used (Waldegrave et al. 1999).
However, in Asia, Africa and Latin America Latin America, the Spanish-speaking, Portuguese-speaking, and French-speaking countries (except Canada) of North America, South America, Central America, and the West Indies. a poverty line is set at $1 a day (United Nations 1995), and in these circumstances it is difficult to make meaningful international comparisons between women in the richer OECD nations and those in poorer countries. It is for this reason that we now turn to a consideration of indicators that include other measures of poverty, inequality and well-being than only income.
UN HUMAN DEVELOPMENT INDEX AND HUMAN POVERTY INDEX
The United Nations (UN) was previously responsible for a system of national accounts that measured only market activities: the United Nations System of National Accounts The United Nations System of National Accounts (often abbreviated as "SNA" or "UNSNA") is an international standard system of national accounts, first published in 1953.
Handbooks with cumulated revisions were published in 1968 and 1993. (UNSNA UNSNA United Nations System of National Account ). However, the UN now argues that existing measures of poverty place too much emphasis on income. During the 1990s, when the UN had a major focus on poverty, it developed a Human Development Index (HDI HDI Human Development Index (UNDP yardstick of human welfare)
HDI Help Desk Institute
HDI Humpty Dumpty Institute (New York, New York)
HDI High Density Interconnect ). According to this index, poverty is defined as a lack of choices and opportunities for a tolerable tol·er·a·ble
1. Capable of being tolerated; endurable.
2. Fairly good; passable. See Synonyms at average.
tol life. The UN argues, in the context of this index, that poverty has several dimensions: short life, illiteracy illiteracy, inability to meet a certain minimum criterion of reading and writing skill. Definition of Illiteracy
The exact nature of the criterion varies, so that illiteracy must be defined in each case before the term can be used in a meaningful , exclusion and lack of access to public and private resources. Respect and social standing are also part of the HDI (United Nations Development Project 1997:5). Arguably ar·gu·a·ble
1. Open to argument: an arguable question, still unresolved.
2. That can be argued plausibly; defensible in argument: three arguable points of law. , income is less relevant if someone has access to clean water, land, seeds, housing materials and a close community with a rich cultural life. According to the HDI, poverty exists when these are lacking.
The HDI contains a Human Poverty Index (HPI HPI
history of present illness ). The HPI for developing countries uses three indicators of deprivation: mortality (short life span), illiteracy and a composite index Composite Index
A grouping of equities, indexes or other factors combined in a standardized way, providing a useful statistical measure of overall market or sector performance over time. Also known simply as a "composite". of access to health services health services Managed care The benefits covered under a health contract (including safe water, and malnutrition malnutrition, insufficiency of one or more nutritional elements necessary for health and well-being. Primary malnutrition is caused by the lack of essential foodstuffs—usually vitamins, minerals, or proteins—in the diet. among children under five). The data within this index is not disaggregated Broken up into parts. by gender (Fakuda-Parr 1999, Durbin 1999), but Elizabeth Durbin (1999:106-107) argues that the HPI could be made gender-sensitive and thus able to reflect women's poverty. Many of the social statistics that would facilitate such an analysis are already collected in many of the poorer countries. Statistics on maternal mortality rates maternal mortality rate Epidemiology The number of pregnancy-related deaths/100,000 ♀ of reproductive age; the number of maternal deaths related to childbearing divided by number of live births–or number of live births + fetal deaths/yr. are one such indicator: the necessary statistics are available in most countries and give an indication of women's health status and access to health care. Other information is available which reflect women's status in society: for example, policies on marriage, divorce, contraception contraception: see birth control.
Birth control by prevention of conception or impregnation. The most common method is sterilization. The most effective temporary methods are nearly 99% effective if used consistently and correctly. , the prevention of genital mutilation genital mutilation The destruction or removal of a portion or the entire external genitalia, which may occur in the context of a crime of passion or as part of a cultural rite. See Bobbittize, Cutter, Female circumcision, Self-mutilation. , women's representation in politics; access to credit, land and housing; and the levels of reported domestic violence, rape, murder and suicide of women (Durbin 1999:107).
In short, the HDI has some potential for becoming more gender sensitive and thus capturing dimensions of poverty which are not usually included in studies of poverty, inequality and well-being world-wide. These additional elements are likely to be most useful for measuring the success (or otherwise) of third world nations in improving levels of well-being amongst their female population.
The Human Development Index, whilst potentially useful for research on women's levels of poverty, inequality and well-being in the poorer nations, is less easily used by the richer nations. This also makes comparisons difficult, and disguises the extent to which women may face similar issues in the richer and poorer worlds. Women in the OECD nations are likely to fare well according to many of the indices used in the HPI, such as access to education and clean water; yet poverty, inequality and related problems of poor health still face many women within the richer nations. For example, it has been found that even in the affluent USA, many people living on welfare benefits and low wages, especially women raising children alone, experience hunger (Eisinger 1998, Edin and Lein 1997: 48-50). The question therefore is: how do we find ways of conceptualising women's poverty, inequality and well-being that are easily applicable to both richer and poorer nations and permit comparisons to be made?
We have seen that some indicators of women's poverty and inequality, such as income, are easier to use in a meaningful way in the richer nations, whilst other indices, such as the HPI, were designed for and are more applicable to studies of poorer nations. By contrast, the concept of social exclusion can be used in both the richer OECD nations and the so-called third world. Research on social exclusion has in fact been taking place in both richer and poorer nations (Gore and Figueiredo 1996). However, the concept is highly politically contestable and takes different forms according to the political situations and traditions of nations.
The term "social exclusion" was coined in France in 1974. The "excluded" were those who were not covered not covered Health care adjective Referring to a procedure, test or other health service to which a policy holder or insurance beneficiary is not entitled under the terms of the policy or payment system–eg, Medicare. Cf Covered. by Social Insurance for any reason. French policy documents refer to exclusions, plural PLURAL. A term used in grammar, which signifies more than one.
2. Sometimes, however, it may be so expressed that it means only one, as, if a man were to devise to another all he was worth, if he, the testator, died without children, and he died leaving one , which captures the multi-dimensionality of the original idea (Silver 1998:46). These dimensions cover economic, political and social aspects, including unemployment, racism and the denial of social rights. One reason for the adoption of the concept of social exclusion in France has been the widespread support from trade unions, employees and the unemployed: at times this support has been expressed in the form of strikes and large-scale demonstrations. However, the notion of social exclusion has spread, and since the 1990s the concept has been extensively used in the European Union European Union (EU), name given since the ratification (Nov., 1993) of the Treaty of European Union, or Maastricht Treaty, to the
European Community (EU) and by international agencies such as the UN and the International Labour Organisation (ILO ILO
International Labor Organization
Noun 1. ILO - the United Nations agency concerned with the interests of labor
International Labor Organization, International Labour Organization ), both in place of and in addition to the term "poverty". In addition, the EU has developed anti-exclusion legislation.
The opposite and antidote antidote
Remedy to counteract the effects of a poison or toxin. Administered by mouth, intravenously, or sometimes on the skin, it may work by directly neutralizing the poison; causing an opposite effect in the body; binding to the poison to prevent its absorption, to exclusion is solidarity, which is a popular concept in some nations of the EU. For example, the EU White Paper on Social Security set out an action plan for 1994-9 to combat exclusion and promote solidarity (Silver 1998:56). Solidaristic policies promote inclusion, interdependence in·ter·de·pen·dent
Mutually dependent: "Today, the mission of one institution can be accomplished only by recognizing that it lives in an interdependent world with conflicts and overlapping interests" and mutual responsibility, and the better-off express solidarity with those who have fewer resources through income transfers (Spicker 1991:17). The concept of solidarity has particular implications for women's material well-being. Nations with solidaristic policies, such as France, Sweden and Denmark, tend to have more generous provision of child care and paid parental leave parental leave
A leave of absence granted to a parent to care for a new baby. , a smaller "gender pay gap" and better benefits for mothers parenting alone (Bradshaw et al. 1996).
Overcoming social exclusion also means promoting participation (Figueiredo and de Haan De Haan or de Haan may refer any of the following people or places:
Overall the various facets of European anti-exclusion legislation tend to centre on assistance into paid work. These elements include: job creation, job-related training, business development, changing the labour market regulations (for example reducing the length of the working week), employment-friendly tax reforms, equity in the paid work force, equal employment opportunities, family-friendly policies and improved access to and standards of childcare (Silver 1998). As a result, women in countries such as Sweden and France have much higher labour force participation rates than in most of the English-speaking nations, where assistance to mothers wishing to enter paid work is relatively minimal (Bradshaw et al 1996). The goal of inclusion makes it easier for women to participate in paid work, although it is debatable de·bat·a·ble
1. Being such that formal argument or discussion is possible.
2. Open to dispute; questionable.
3. In dispute, as land or territory claimed by more than one country. whether it is easier for women in solidaristic nations to contest the differential values accorded to paid and unpaid work. Nevertheless, there is evidence that women in those European and Scandinavian nations Noun 1. Scandinavian nation - any one of the countries occupying Scandinavia
European country, European nation - any one of the countries occupying the European continent which utilise the concept of social exclusion and promote solidarity, such as Sweden, Denmark and France, enjoy a higher material standard of living than in most other nations (Bradshaw et al 1996).
As suggested above, the interpretation of social exclusion varies between nations. Those English-speaking nations which have adopted the concept (mainly the USA and UK) have done so in ways that are at variance with some of the key principles adopted in Europe (despite Britain's membership of the EU). The European concept of social exclusion assumes that society at large is the excluding agent and has a responsibility to make amends AMENDS. A satisfaction, given by a wrong doer to the party injured for a wrong committed. 1 Lilly's Reg. 81.
2. By statute 24 Geo. II. c. 44, in England, and by similar statutes in some of the United States, justices of the peace, upon being notified of an . However, in the UK and USA, the concept of social exclusion is given a neo-liberal interpretation. Instead of a focus on the responsibility of society, there is a shift to a notion of individual culpability culpability (See: culpable) (Peace 1997:116). In the UK, for example, the Blair government emphasises supply-side factors, repeatedly mentioning the responsibilities of the excluded, such as geographical mobility in search of work (Silver 1998:50). Further, a single dimension of social exclusion -- unemployment -- has become the focus, and people who are excluded for other reasons become excluded from discourses of exclusion (Peace 1997:116). This has implications for women, who may be excluded as a result of unsupported parenthood rather than unemployment.
It appears that there has been a lack of gender analysis of the concept of social exclusion so far. A recent literature search revealed only one source that linked women or gender with social exclusion in its title (Sweetman 1996), and even this contained no analysis of the concept in relation to women. We need to know more precisely how and under what circumstances the concept of social exclusion has been and can be used to improve the situation of women. Time-use data can assist this process by showing precisely how and why women are excluded from participation in social life.
Time-poverty exists when people have excessive hours of work, paid or not, and inadequate time for rest and recreation. Since everyone uses time, and the number of hours in a day is finite, the measurement of time-poverty can take place in both the wealthier nations and the poorer ones. Time-use surveys have a wide variety of uses (Fleming and Spellerberg 1999), including the measurement of unpaid work. They are able to capture the time-poverty experienced by mothers in the OECD nations who are increasingly attempting to combine paid and unpaid work; or that of third world women and girls obliged o·blige
v. o·bliged, o·blig·ing, o·blig·es
1. To constrain by physical, legal, social, or moral means.
2. to walk long distances daily to gather fuel and collect water. In addition, in the English-speaking world, over-employment (excessive hours of paid work) is also increasingly an issue (Schorr 1991). Time-poverty and over-employment are not always associated with low income (though they frequently are) and do not normally appear in poverty statistics.
Attention has been given in recent years in the USA and UK to the extension of working hours performed by men, particularly by husbands and fathers (Schorr 1991, Hewitt 1993). However, whilst this is justly recognised as a problem for these men and their families, excessive paid work is only a part of the story. To obtain a full picture of the extent of time-poverty it is necessary to look at the combination of paid and unpaid work. In Australia, it has been shown that the people who work the longest total hours are married mothers, followed by solo mothers. Solo fathers work the next longest total hours, followed by married fathers (Bryson 1996:213). World-wide, women work significantly longer total hours than men, although less of that work is paid (United Nations 1995). Time-use statistics have been collected for 14 industrial nations, nine developing countries and eight countries in Eastern Europe Eastern Europe
The countries of eastern Europe, especially those that were allied with the USSR in the Warsaw Pact, which was established in 1955 and dissolved in 1991. , and women work longer total hours than men in almost every country (United Nations 1995, Fleming and Spellerberg 1999)(4).
There are variations between nations in the extent of the gap between men's and women's time-poverty, and also major variations within some countries between the urban and rural areas: in the rural areas of Kenya, for example, women work vastly longer hours than men (United Nations 1995). In Sweden, one of the most egalitarian e·gal·i·tar·i·an
Affirming, promoting, or characterized by belief in equal political, economic, social, and civil rights for all people. nations, a 1995 study showed that total time spent in work was becoming more equal between women and men: between 1984 and 1993 the "gender-gap" in total hours of work shrank shrank
A past tense of shrink.
a past tense of shrink
shrank shrink from four hours to 1.75 hours per week. However, even in Sweden men still do much less unpaid work than women do: 10.5 hours less per week (United Nations 1995:95). This indicates that women are working fewer hours in paid work than men, which could be expected to reduce women's pay and affect the balance of power within the home and explain women's performing the bulk of the unpaid work. However, even where women are normally employed full-time and pay differentials are small, women tend to perform the familiar "double shift" of paid and unpaid work. In the countries of Eastern Europe, for example, women have greater time-poverty compared with men than in Western Europe Western Europe
The countries of western Europe, especially those that are allied with the United States and Canada in the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (established 1949 and usually known as NATO). , because women have tended to be in full-time paid employment as well as retaining primary responsibility for unpaid domestic work.
Despite variations, therefore, the overall pattern world-wide is one of women working longer hours overall than men and being paid for fewer hours of their work. This profoundly affects women's material well-being and social position relative to men.
Time-use surveys have increased in popularity, especially since World War II, and have developed a consistency of method that has contributed to a growing body of knowledge about unpaid work in the home and community within nations and world-wide (Fleming and Spellerberg 1999). Time-use data is a rich source of information about women's economic well-being. There is, however, a good deal of scope for governments to make greater use of this type of research, particularly in terms of :including unpaid work in official measurements of production, but also in terms of resourcing and rewarding nonmarket productive work.
Studies of health variations focus upon the ways in which health varies according to other factors, such as income and social class. Poor health is now recognised in some measures (for example, in the UN HPI) as a dimension of poverty and inequality, whilst good health is seen as more than the absence of disease, and is an important indicator of well-being. Like some of the other concepts and measures described above, health variations may be researched in both richer and poorer nations. At present, however, large-scale studies of health variations in populations are reliant upon statistics derived from government sources and large-scale surveys, which, as we have seen, often conceal or underestimate women's poverty.
In the richer nations of the world, inequalities in health status have been found to be strongly linked to differences in income and social class, income being the single biggest determinant determinant, a polynomial expression that is inherent in the entries of a square matrix. The size n of the square matrix, as determined from the number of entries in any row or column, is called the order of the determinant. (National Health Committee 1998:23). Whilst absolute poverty (lack or shortages of essentials for survival) can be most clearly linked with higher levels of mortality and morbidity, research has found that relative poverty, and the stress associated with it, is also strongly linked with poor mental and physical health.
It might be expected that social statistics would illustrate clear links between women's lower personal incomes and their tendency to self-report poorer health than men. However, this has not been clearly established by large-scale research on variations in health status, the majority of which have focused on men. One reason for the lower priority given to research on women's health has been that women tend to survive longer than men do. Women's self-reported ill health tend to be more common than men's but is more likely to be long term and chronic, affecting well-being but less likely to be fatal (Payne 1991). However, the lack of concentration on inequalities in women's health also occurs partly because of problems with the data available to researchers. It is difficult for researchers to obtain large-scale data on women's individual incomes or social class. This is because heterosexual partnered women's incomes continue to be aggregated with those of their husbands; and most women's social class is similarly derived from that of their husbands or fathers.
When we do have information on women's personal disposable incomes (often derived from smaller studies), a very clear association emerges between women's poverty and ill health. For instance, solo mothers, who are now the poorest group in a number of English-speaking nations, report higher levels of disability and of both chronic and acute illness than either solo fathers or partnered mothers (Payne 1991:121). Other studies have shown that women living on benefits in rented accommodation are considerably more likely to have a longstanding illness than those who own their own home (Graham 1993:175).
Studies of health inequalities are potentially useful gender-sensitive ways of contributing to an understanding of the causes and effects of poverty and inequality. However, at present it is difficult to conduct studies of health variations on a large scale because of the ways in which the essential information on variables such as income and social class is collected. Thus, the gendering of long-established social indicators, such as income and social class, spills over and affects some of the newer ways of measuring poverty, inequality and well-being.
How well do the conventional and newer concepts and measures of poverty, inequality and well-being discussed in this paper provide a clear picture of women's material situation? We have seen that, at present, some concepts and measures, including GDP, GPIs, the UN HPI and the concept of social exclusion, do not treat gender as a variable. Information on health variations is useful but currently limited by a shortage of information on women's health status by individual income or social class. At present, arguably, the most accessible sources of information about women's economic situation are time-use data and statistics on incomes, and these also have limitations.
However, most of the concepts and measures described in this paper have the potential to be more gender-sensitive than they are at present. Statistics collected for GNP, for example, would more accurately reflect women's contribution to production if they included the value of unpaid work as part of the main accounts rather than as optional satellite accounts. It has already been shown that the value of such work can be calculated (Ironmonger ironmonger - [IBM] A hardware specialist (derogatory). Compare sandbender, polygon pusher. 1989); and time-use surveys can provide the necessary information about the amounts and types of unpaid work performed. Some time-use surveys, themselves, also have the potential to become more gender-sensitive, by including questions on multi-tasking. Time-use surveys that do collect this information have found that women are particularly likely to be performing several jobs at once. However, at present some time-use surveys omit o·mit
tr.v. o·mit·ted, o·mit·ting, o·mits
1. To fail to include or mention; leave out: omit a word.
a. To pass over; neglect.
b. to ask the question "What else were you doing?" (Fleming and Spellerberg 1999).
Information on incomes collected and disseminated by governments and other large data-collecting agencies such as the United Nations would be more gender-sensitive if individual rather than household incomes were the focus, and if more information on women's individual annual incomes was made available. This would also assist research on women and health variations, and so help to pinpoint precisely what features of poverty and inequality contribute to health breakdown, and what is needed to promote health and well-being (Graham 1993, Payne 1991). We have already seen that the information about well-being in poorer nations, as contained in the UN HDI and HPI, could be made gender-sensitive by disaggregating the data by sex and utilising information that already exists on women's health and social status (Durbin 1999).
The use of the concept of social exclusion to provide a basis for gender-equity policies, as used in Europe, also appears to have considerable potential to improve the economic situation of women by easing their path into paid work, increasing women's rewards from paid work and providing at least partial compensation for their work as mothers. However, it appears that a proper gender analysis of social exclusion has yet to be undertaken, and could form a basis for future research.
How likely is it that these indices and ways of looking at poverty will become more gender-sensitive? Ways of conceptualising and measuring poverty, inequality and well-being are political and contestable, and thus are subject to constant reinterpretation re·in·ter·pret
tr.v. re·in·ter·pret·ed, re·in·ter·pret·ing, re·in·ter·prets
To interpret again or anew.
re and change. Indices and concepts, to a considerable extent, reflect the values of the people responsible for framing them. Concepts and measures potentially can be framed in ways that expose the poverty of disadvantaged groups, such as women, and that act as a basis for action to improve the situation of these groups. However, the choice of concepts and measures also can be used by governments to present the results of their policies in a more favourable light, or to restrict demands for assistance. What is clear is that the conceptualisation (artificial intelligence) conceptualisation - The collection of objects, concepts and other entities that are assumed to exist in some area of interest and the relationships that hold among them. and measurement of some aspects women's poverty and inequality has undergone some changes as a result of pressure for change, and this is likely to continue.
(1) An earlier version of this paper was presented at the 1999 Women's Studies women's studies
pl.n. (used with a sing. or pl. verb)
An academic curriculum focusing on the roles and contributions of women in fields such as literature, history, and the social sciences. Association Annual Conference at Victoria University of Wellington
Victoria University of Wellington, also known in Māori as , and the paper appears in the proceedings of that conference. Celia Briar wishes to thank the anonymous referee whose input assisted in the process of turning the conference paper into a journal article.
(2) In New Zealand, prior to 1991, there was a participation basis to benefits, as recommended in the Royal Commission of Social Security in 1974. The benefit cuts which took effect from 1991 were apparently based on minimum subsistence subsistence,
n the state of being supported or remaining alive with a minimum of essentials. budgets, as recommended by Edith Brashares, a US Treasury consultant about social security (Viet-Wilson 1998). Her recommendations were adopted as the new Minimum Income Standard by Treasury and the Department of Social Welfare (Stephens 1992). The reduced benefits were derived from the American Orshanky Poverty Line (OPL OPL Open Publication License
OPL Olympus Product Line (Sun)
OPL outer plexiform layer
OPL Organiser Programming Language (PSION)
OPL On-Premise Laundry
OPL Optical Path Length
OPL Open Public License ) (Brashares 1993). This was achieved by calculating a minimum dietary and multiplying the food share by five to cover total income needs. The University of Otago The University of Otago (Māori: Te Whare Wānanga o Otāgo) in Dunedin is New Zealand's oldest university with over 20,000 students enrolled during 2006. prepared the basic dietary and the cost was similar to the amount spent on the food for one prison inmate INMATE. One who dwells in a part of another's house, the latter dwelling, at the same time, in the said house. Kitch. 45, b; Com. Dig. Justices of the Peace, B 85; 1 B. & Cr. 578; 8 E. C. L. R. 153; 2 Dowl. & Ry. 743; 8 B. & Cr. 71; 15 E. C. L. R. 154; 2 Man. & Ry. 227; 9 B. & Cr. in 1989. This was multiplied by a factor of four and intended to cover all other household needs, including rent, rates, power bills, clothing, medical expenses and emergencies.
(3) This gap is smaller in nations that have effective legislation covering equal pay for work of equal value, but wider in the USA where the equal pay legislation is weak.
(4) However, Fleming and Spellerberg (1999) point out that not all of these surveys in fact took place on a national scale.
Bittman, M. (1991) Juggling Time: How Australian families use time, Office of the Status of Women, Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet is a government office in some Commonwealth Realms.
Bradshaw, J., S.Kennedy, M.Kilkey, S.Hutton, A.Corden, T.Eardley, H.Holmes and J.Neale (1996) The Employment of Lone Parents lone parent n → parent m unique
lone parent lone n → Alleinerziehende(r) f(m)
lone parent n (unmarried) (= : a comparison of policy in 20 countries, Family Policy Studies Centre, London.
Brashares, E. (1993) "Assessing Income Adequacy in New Zealand" New Zealand Economic Papers 27(2):185-207.
Briar, C. (1994) "Tracing the Patterns: the development of EEO EEO Equal Employment Opportunity
EEO Equal Employment Office
EEO Eastern European Outreach (Murrieta, CA)
EEO Extremely Elliptical Orbit
EEO Exotic Electro-Optics, Inc. policies in New Zealand and overseas" in J. Sayers and M. Tremaine (eds.) The Vision and the Reality, Dunmore Press, Palmerston North Palmerston North, city (1996 pop. 73,095), S North Island, New Zealand. It is a transportation and farm-marketing center with diverse industries. The city's agricultural college, founded in 1926, became Massey Univ. in 1964. .
Briar, C. (1997) Working for Women? Gendered work and welfare policies in twentieth century Britain, UCL UCL University College London
UCL Université Catholique de Louvain
UCL UEFA Champions League
UCL Upper Confidence Limit
UCL University of Central Lancashire
UCL Upper Control Limit
UCL Unfair Competition Law
UCL Ulnar Collateral Ligament Press, London.
Bryson, L. (1996) "Revaluing the Household Economy" Women's Studies International Forum 19(3):207-219.
Daly, H.E. and C.W. Cobb (1990) For the Common Good: Redirecting the economy towards community, the environment and a sustainable future, Beacon Press This article or section needs sources or references that appear in reliable, third-party publications. Alone, primary sources and sources affiliated with the subject of this article are not sufficient for an accurate encyclopedia article. , Boston.
Dex, S., S. Lissenburgh and M. Taylor (1994) Women and Low Pay: Identifying the issues, Equal Opportunities Commission, Manchester.
Durbin, E. (1999) "Towards a Gendered Human Poverty Measure" Feminist Economics Feminist economics broadly refers to a developing branch of economics that applies feminist insights and critiques to economics. Research under this heading is often interdisciplinary, critical, or heterodox. 5(2)105108.
Edin, K. and L. Lein (1997) Making Ends Meet: How single mothers survive welfare and low paid jobs, Russell Sage Russell Sage (4 August 1816 - 22 July 1906) was a financier and politician from New York.
Sage was born at Verona in Oneida County, New York. He received a public school education and worked as a farm hand until he was 15, when he became an errand boy in a grocery conducted Foundation, New York New York, state, United States
New York, Middle Atlantic state of the United States. It is bordered by Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and the Atlantic Ocean (E), New Jersey and Pennsylvania (S), Lakes Erie and Ontario and the Canadian province of .
Eisinger, P. (1998) Towards an End to Hunger in America, Brookings Institution Brookings Institution, at Washington, D.C.; chartered 1927 as a consolidation of the Institute for Government Research (est. 1916), the Institute of Economics (est. 1922), and the Robert S. Brookings Graduate School of Economics and Government (est. 1924). Press, Washington D.C..
Fakuda-Parr, S. (1999) "What does Feminisation of Poverty Mean? It isn't just lack of income" Feminist Economics 5(2):99-103.
Figueiredo, J.B and A. de Haan (eds.) (1998) Social Exclusion: an ILO perspective, ILO, Geneva Geneva, canton and city, Switzerland
Geneva (jənē`və), Fr. Genève, canton (1990 pop. 373,019), 109 sq mi (282 sq km), SW Switzerland, surrounding the southwest tip of the Lake of Geneva. .
Fleming, R. and A. Spellerberg (1999) Using Time Use Data: a history of time use surveys and uses of time use data, Statistics New Zealand Statistics New Zealand (In Māori, Tatauranga Aotearoa) is the state sector organisation of New Zealand which is responsible for the country's official statistics, under the authority of the 1975 Statistics Act. , Wellington.
Gore, C. and J.B. Figueiredo (1996) Social Exclusion and Anti-Poverty Strategies, ILO, Geneva.
Graham, H. (1993) Hardship and Health in Women's Lives, Harvester harvester, farm machine that mechanically harvests a crop. Small-grain harvesting has been mechanized to a certain extent since early times. In the modern period the first harvester to gain general acceptance was made by Cyrus McCormick in 1831 (see reaper). Wheatsheaf, London.
Hamilton, C. (1997) The Genuine Progress Indicator: a new index of changes in well being in Australia, Discussion Paper No.14, The Australia Institute, Lyneham ACT.
Hewitt, P (1993) About Time: the revolution in work and family life, IPP/Rivers Oram Press, London.
Ironmonger, D. (1989) Households Work, Allen and Unwin, Sydney.
Jackson, T. and N. Marks (1994) Measuring Sustainable Economic Welfare: a pilot index, 19501990, Stockholm Environment Institute This article or section needs sources or references that appear in reliable, third-party publications. Alone, primary sources and sources affiliated with the subject of this article are not sufficient for an accurate encyclopedia article. .
Millar, J. (1992) "Lone Mother and Poverty" in C. Glendinning and J. Millar (eds.) Women and Poverty in Britain: the 1990s, Harvester Wheatsheaf, Hemel Hempstead Hemel Hempstead (hĕm`əl), town (1991 pop. 80,110), Hertfordshire, SE England. Hemel Hempstead was designated one of the new towns in 1946 to alleviate overpopulation in London. It is a market town and London suburb. .
Millar, J. and C. Glendinning (eds.) (1987) Women and Poverty in Britain, Harvester Wheatsheaf, London.
National Health Committee (1998) The Social Cultural and Economic Determinants of Health in New Zealand: action to improve health, National Advisory Council on Health and Disability, Wellington.
Pahl, J. (1980) "Patterns of Money Management within Marriage" Journal of Social Policy 9(3):313-35.
Payne, S. (1991) Poverty and Women's Health, Harvester Wheatsheaf, London.
Peace, R. (1997) "Excluded from Exclusion: Who Misses out in the New Language?" in M.O'Brien and C.Briar (eds.) Beyond Poverty Conference Proceedings, People Centre Press, Auckland.
Podder, N. and S. Chatterjee (1998) "Sharing the National Cake: income inequality trends" paper presented to the Annual Conference of the New Zealand Association of Economists, Government Buildings, Wellington, September 2-4.
Schorr, J.B. (1991) The Overworked American: The unexpected decline of leisure, Basic Books, New York.
Scott, H. (1984) Working Your Way to the Bottom: the feminisation of poverty, Pandora Press, London.
Silver, H. (1998) "Policies to Reinforce Social Cohesion in Europe" in J.B.Figueiredo and A.de Haan (eds.) Social Exclusion: an ILO Perspective, ILO, Geneva.
Sparr, P. (1994) "What is Structural Adjustment?" in P. Sparr (ed.) Mortgaging Women's Lives: feminist critiques of structural adjustment, Zed Books, London.
Stephens, B. (1992) "Budgeting with the Benefit Cuts" in J. Boston and P. Dalziel (eds.) The Decent Society? Oxford University Press, Auckland.
Sweetman, C. (ed.) (1996) Women, Employment and Exclusion, Oxfam, Oxford. United Nations Development Programme (1995) Human Development Report 1995, Oxford University Press, New York.
United Nations Development Project (1997) Human Development Report, Oxford University Press, New York.
Viet-Wilson,J. (1998) Setting Adequacy Standards: how governments define minimum incomes, The Policy Press, Bristol.
Vogler, C. (1989) Labour Market Change and Patterns of Financial Allocation within Households, ESRC ESRC Economic and Social Research Council (UK)
ESRC Environmental Sciences Research Center
ESRC Engineers & Scientists Resources & Construction (US Army Corps of Engineers)
ESRC Exxonmobil Singapore Recreation Club Social Change and Economic Life Initiative, Oxford.
Vogler, C. and J. Pahl (1993) "Social and Eonomic Change and the Organisation of Money within Marriage Work", Employment and Society 7(1):71-95.
Waldegrave, C., P. King and S. Stuart (1999) The Monetary Constraints and Consumer Behaviour in New Zealand Low Income Households, The Family Centre Social Policy Research Unit, Lower Hutt Lower Hutt, New Zealand: see Hutt City. .
Waring, M. (1989) Counting for Nothing: what men value and what women are worth, Allen and Unwin/Port Nicholson Press, Wellington.
Celia Briar Social Policy and Social Work Massey University Massey University (Māori: Te Kunenga ki Purehuroa) is New Zealand's largest university with approximately 40,000 students. It has campuses in Palmerston North (sites at Turitea and Hokowhitu), Wellington (in the suburb of Mt Cook) and