How the socialism of W. E. B. Du Bois still matters: black socialism in The Quest of the Silver Fleece--and beyond.
One prominent trend in African American African American Multiculture A person having origins in any of the black racial groups of Africa. See Race. and African diaspora The African diaspora is the diaspora created by the movements and cultures of Africans and their descendants throughout the world, to places such as the Americas, (including the United States, Canada, the Caribbean, Central America, and South America) Europe and Asia. studies involves the search for a more thoroughly egalitarian black politics, especially by reopening the question of race and economic equality. The radicalism of W. E. B. Du Bois Noun 1. W. E. B. Du Bois - United States civil rights leader and political activist who campaigned for equality for Black Americans (1868-1963)
Du Bois, William Edward Burghardt Du Bois figures prominently in much of this work, including recent books by Joy James, Kate Baldwin, Alys Eve Weinbaum, and Nikhil Pal Singh. We share this interest in Du Bois's radical social democracy, while at the same time offering an alternative genealogy of its origin and development. In the readings of all the recent critics named above and a number of earlier critics, too, the significant phase of Du Bois's radicalism dates from his contact with Third International socialism, whether initiated by his visit to the Soviet Union in 1926 (at the earliest) or his immersion in Marxism in the early 1930s (the consensus view). (1) What we find is a much earlier emergence of radicalism: in the socialism that Du Bois Du Bois (d`bois, dəbois`), city (1990 pop. 8,286), Clearfield co., W central Pa., in the region of the Allegheny plateau; inc. 1881. formulated in the 1910s, with his characteristic emphasis on cooperative black economics developing by his 1911 novel, The Quest of the Silver Fleece, and his analysis of imperialism and capitalist exploitation in evidence by his 1915 monograph, The Negro.
The following essay both describes the early development of Du Bois's socialism and analyzes the significance of that development. We find three ramifications ramifications npl → Auswirkungen pl especially for interpretations of Du Bois and, by extension, for an understanding of African American socialism. First, an early date prevents Du Bois's radical social democracy from being dismissed as an idiosyncracy of his elder years: instead of being the product of his marginalization mar·gin·al·ize
tr.v. mar·gin·al·ized, mar·gin·al·iz·ing, mar·gin·al·iz·es
To relegate or confine to a lower or outer limit or edge, as of social standing. by the civil rights establishment, Du Bois's socialism was cultivated and maintained during the period when he was the most visible and influential of black Americans, and it was articulated in the pages of the Crisis whereby it reached tens of thousands of NAACP NAACP
in full National Association for the Advancement of Colored People
Oldest and largest U.S. civil rights organization. It was founded in 1909 to secure political, educational, social, and economic equality for African Americans; W.E.B. Du Bois and Ida B. members. An earlier emergence of Du Bois's socialism thus places social democracy closer to the center of African American politics than has usually been supposed. Second, an early date for Du Bois's socialism counteracts the impression that it was unduly influenced by models ill-suited to black America, particularly the supposedly "color-blind col·or·blind or col·or-blind
1. Partially or totally unable to distinguish certain colors.
a. Not subject to racial prejudices.
b. " socialism of the Second Internationale. Therefore, although American socialists of this period were seldom able to recognize fully the theoretical contributions being made by Du Bois and other black socialists, those contributions stand, in retrospect, as vital and original developments in American socialism. Moreover, our understanding of Du Boisian socialism has a third important implication, for it helps disentangle Du Bois's socialism from the influence of the Comintern, thereby facilitating a proper emphasis not only on the independence of Du Boisian black socialism but also on Du Bois's commitment to democratic and nonviolent means to achieve social democratic ends.
"The battle is scarcely even begun": The Quest of the Silver Fleece and Black Socialism Before the NAACP
In speaking of socialism during the Progressive Era, we agree with Adolph Reed, Jr., that the central term in question must be clearly specified. After all, "socialism" enjoyed such wide cultural currency that it was "identified variously with support of trusts, public ownership of utilities, corporate regulation, municipal reform, trade unionism, industrial unionism Industrial unionism is a labor union organizing method through which all workers in the same industry are organized into the same union—regardless of skill or trade—thus giving workers in one industry, or in all industries, more leverage in bargaining and in strike , or any of a myriad of other social and economic policies" (Reed 83). And indeed, the earliest references to socialism to be found in Du Bois's writings do not indicate commitment to any particular political program. They do, however, begin to set Du Bois apart from the more conservative exponents of collectivist col·lec·tiv·ism
The principles or system of ownership and control of the means of production and distribution by the people collectively, usually under the supervision of a government. ideas, insofar in·so·far
To such an extent.
Adv. 1. insofar - to the degree or extent that; "insofar as it can be ascertained, the horse lung is comparable to that of man"; "so far as it is reasonably practical he should practice as he saw collectivism collectivism
Any of several types of social organization that ascribe central importance to the groups to which individuals belong (e.g., state, nation, ethnic group, or social class). It may be contrasted with individualism. as a means to a more equal distribution of wealth as opposed to merely an efficient method for organizing an unruly public. (2) So, for example, in a 1904 letter to Isaac Rubinow, a Socialist party Socialist party, in U.S. history, political party formed to promote public control of the means of production and distribution. In 1898 the Social Democratic party was formed by a group led by Eugene V. Debs and Victor Berger. member, Du Bois indicated that he did not call himself a socialist but that he did share the fundamental convictions of the Social Democrats he had met in Germany, convictions about the equitable distribution of wealth and public ownership of industry (letter to Rubinow). (3) By 1908, Du Bois's reasons for endorsing William Jennings William Jennings is the name of several historical figures including:
Of, advocating, or tending toward socialism.
social·is Democracy" (Writings in Periodicals 63, 70).
The fullest expression of Du Bois's early socialism comes, however, not in his nonfiction prose but in his first novel his 1911 romance the Quest of the Silver Fleece, which offers both a specifically socialist critique of US economics and an alternative economic model originating in cooperative, southern black folkways folkways, term coined by William Graham Sumner in his treatise Folkways (1906) to denote those group habits that are common to a society or culture and are usually called customs. . Without this novel, we might be inclined to concur with Reed that Du Bois's socialism around 1910 amounts to little more than a specimen of a broadly collectivist zeitgeist, not distinguishable in any significant way from the conservative, technocratic socialism of soon-to-be fellow NAACP board members Mary White Ovington Mary White Ovington (born April 11, 1865 in Brooklyn, New York - died July 15, 1951) a suffragette, socialist, unitarian, journalist, and co-founder of the NAACP. , Charles Edward Russell Charles Edward Russell (25 September 1860 – 23 April 1941) was an American journalist, author, and activist. he was born in Davenport, Iowa, and died in Washington, DC.
His father was a newspaper editor at the Davenport Gazette, and a noted abolitionist. , or William English Walling William English Walling (1877-1936) (known as "English" to friends and family) was an American labor reformer and socialist born in Louisville, Kentucky. He was born into wealth and was educated at the University of Chicago and at Harvard Law School. (83). Given the prominence that these socialists have in various accounts of Du Bois's socialism, not only the novel's portrayal of socialism grounded in African American folk culture This article or section needs copy editing for grammar, style, cohesion, tone and/or spelling.
You can assist by [ editing it] now. but also its completion prior to Du Bois's arrival at the NAACP are critical. For Rampersad, Marable, Moses, and Reed, the white socialists on the NAACP board are seen as significant influences on Du Bois's decision to join the Socialist party and on Du Bois's understanding of the movement. (4) Yet the Quest of the Silver Fleece, while published the year Du Bois moved to New York City New York City: see New York, city.
New York City
City (pop., 2000: 8,008,278), southeastern New York, at the mouth of the Hudson River. The largest city in the U.S. and began his tenure as Crisis editor, was completed before Du Bois came North: drafted by 1905, revised shortly after the publication of Du Bois's 1909 biography of John Brown, and sent to the printer prior to Du Bois's assumption of the Crisis editorship (Lewis, Biography 444).
The claim that a fictional text might be used as historical evidence of a socialist commitment might appear surprising, but both Du Bois's choice of genre and his consistent blurring of the lines between fiction and nonfiction, fantasy and polemic, amply support this method. A multi-plot novel in the American muck-raking tradition, Quest of the Silver Fleece joins a fiction subgenre sub·gen·re
A subcategory within a particular genre: The academic mystery is a subgenre of the mystery novel. in which virtually all of the novels are written with a definite polemical purpose: most espousing a collectivist political philosophy; many, including Upton Sinclair's The Jungle, also prescribing socialist politics as the path to cooperative economics. As such, it was a subgenre well suited to Du Bois's political-artistic aims. At the height of the Harlem Renaissance Harlem Renaissance, term used to describe a flowering of African-American literature and art in the 1920s, mainly in the Harlem district of New York City. During the mass migration of African Americans from the rural agricultural South to the urban industrial North , he once proclaimed: "I stand in utter shamelessness and say that whatever art I have for writing has been used always for propaganda for gaining the right of black folk to love and enjoy. I do not care a damn for any art that is not used for propaganda" ("Criteria"). Though one might imagine fictional art to be merely a provisional trying out of alternative realities, Quest of the Silver Fleece constitutes a definite, socialist remedy for socioeconomic ills, coming from the pen of a writer whose fiction like the rest of his writing was meant to be politically purposive pur·po·sive
1. Having or serving a purpose.
2. Purposeful: purposive behavior.
Within the anticapitalist muck-raking tradition, Du Bois's Quest extends the range of the subgenre from the usual topics--industrial exploitation, white slavery white slavery
Forced prostitution. , northern metropolitan politics--to a white-on-black and southern nexus, including such topics as the exploitation of black sharecroppers and poor whites in the South, the combination of northern finance and the southern plantocracy plan·toc·ra·cy
n. pl. plan·toc·ra·cies
1. A ruling class formed of plantation owners.
2. Leadership or government by this class.
[plant(ation) + -cracy.] , and the corruption of patronage politics in Washington, DC. In the economically resurgent re·sur·gent
1. Experiencing or tending to bring about renewal or revival.
2. Sweeping or surging back again.
Adj. 1. South, Du Bois insists, a critique of capitalism Capitalism has been critiqued from many angles in its history. Markets
The "free market"
Though many associate the free market concept with capitalism, there are some critics —notably mutualists and some other anarchists – who believe that a must also be a critique of racism, for the new North-South economic collaboration purposely divides white mill workers from black farm laborers, while black sharecroppers are kept down perpetually by a narrowing, near-monopoly control over the cotton market. The collaboration is symbolized in the novel through a double romance intertwining two families: the southern Cresswells, who provide land, pedigree, and moral degeneration; the northern Taylors, who provide capital, self-serving philanthropy, New England New England, name applied to the region comprising six states of the NE United States—Maine, New Hampshire, Vermont, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, and Connecticut. The region is thought to have been so named by Capt. scruples in small matters and Wall Street ruthlessness in large ones.
While the white, upper-class romance-drama of the Cresswells and Taylors carries the burden of the novel's anticapitalist critique, a black, working-class plot presents the novel's constructive, socialist program. While the "upstairs" Cresswell-Taylor plot is certainly not lacking in interest, the "downstairs" plot involves the more genuine suspense: particularly insofar as the novel's thematic conflict between Talented Tenth social climbing and racial solidarity had the clearest of real-world implications for Du Bois's primary, black audience. Bles Alwyn represents the Talented Tenth: he is the most accomplished scholar in a southern college-preparatory school established by a noble New England schoolmarm and threatened by the misguided actions of Mary Taylor Mary Taylor can refer to:
A member or supporter of a small cooperative or a collectivist community.
com·mu set of values. In an early encounter with Mary Taylor, Zora's well-reasoned unruliness offers a parable about the values that might be cultivated outside capitalism. Confronted by Miss Taylor because one of her brooches has gone missing, Zora admits she has taken it and instigates the following dialogue on property ownership and theft:
Still Zora appeared to be unimpressed with the heinousness of her fault.
"Did you make that pin?" [Zora] asked.
"No, but it is mine." [Miss Taylor replied.]
"Why is it yours?"
"Because it was given to me."
"But you don't need it; you've got four other prettier ones--I counted."
"That makes no difference."
"Yes it does--folks ain't got no right to things they don't need."
"That makes no difference, Zora, and you know it. The pin is mine. You stole it. If you had wanted a pin and asked me I might have given you--"
The girl blazed.
"I don't want your old gifts," she almost hissed. "You don't own what you don't need and can't use...." (79)
Mary Taylor, representing the conventional view of property, owns her surplus of pins by virtue of her belonging to a social class in which pretty adornments can be afforded without regard for their cost or usefulness. Her possession of brooches she does not need is backed by legal "right" and moral sanction: to take one of the pins is to steal; in doing so Zora becomes a "thief," as Miss Taylor has tried to impress upon her. But here Zora introduces three key re-valuations of property promulgated prom·ul·gate
tr.v. prom·ul·gat·ed, prom·ul·gat·ing, prom·ul·gates
1. To make known (a decree, for example) by public declaration; announce officially. See Synonyms at announce.
2. by socialism: products of human culture must be socially useful; they are to be distributed according to according to
1. As stated or indicated by; on the authority of: according to historians.
2. In keeping with: according to instructions.
3. need; and if products are "owned" by anyone, they belong to those who actually make them (and then only for the sake of contributing to society those products that are useful and needed). (5) Soon after, the novel even develops the notion of alienated versus unalienated labor. Zora rejects Mary Taylor's suggestion, of domestic service as an attractive wage-earning job, finding the idea of "helping" someone she "loves" incompatible with receiving a wage for it (73). In contrast, her work with Bles, reclaiming swamp land on which they raise a glorious crop of cotton, is literally and figuratively a labor of love.
Reinforcing the importance of Zora's scheme of values is the romance between her and Bles, which though it organizes the "downstairs" plot of the novel actually works to challenge individualistic romance as an acceptable solution to social problems. In brief, when Bles discovers Zora has been "impure im·pure
adj. im·pur·er, im·pur·est
1. Not pure or clean; contaminated.
2. Not purified by religious rite; unclean.
3. Immoral or sinful: impure thoughts. ," a victim of her mother's trade as a procurer for white men, he at first abandons her and flees to Washington, DC, where he makes his mark in colored society and politics. But he throws it all over and returns to Zora when he realizes the fundamental selfishness of the Capitol's patronage politics and the critical importance of Zora's plans for economic self-help in the South. Significantly, Bles's connection with Zora is renewed not at first as romance but as shared service, as he becomes the manager of the cooperative colony that she has founded on an enlarged swampland tract. Du Bois's reliance on a small, social democratic colony in Quest of the Silver Fleece is, in some respects, a throwback throwback
see atavism. to a 19th-century, communitarian tradition in US socialism; in another respect, it anticipates Du Bois's advocacy of economic co-operatives in the Crisis during coming years, and even the audacious proposals for self-segregation that led to Du Bois's break with the NAACP over two decades later. Whether practical or not (most of the 19th-century communities had been short lived and were seldom self supporting [Berry 238-39]), in fictive fic·tive
1. Of, relating to, or able to engage in imaginative invention.
2. Of, relating to, or being fiction; fictional.
3. Not genuine; sham. terms Zora's colony presents a clear, and clearly socialist, indictment of the present socioeconomic order of the South. Collaborating with Miss Sarah Smith
Zora insists that the cooperative colony that she has founded is itself only the beginning of a movement that must finally encompass white as well as black working people to be fully successful and secure: "'Think of the servile ser·vile
1. Abjectly submissive; slavish.
a. Of or suitable to a slave or servant.
b. Of or relating to servitude or forced labor. black folk,'" Zora exclaims, "'the half awakened restless whites, the fat land waiting for the harvest, the masses panting panting
rapid, shallow breathing, a characteristic heat-losing reaction in dogs; represents an increase in dead-space ventilation resulting in heat loss without necessarily increasing oxygen uptake or carbon dioxide loss. to know--why, the battle is scarcely even begun'" (430). Du Bois offers, then, an embryonic plan for implementing socialism in the United States Socialism as an organized political movement in the United States began with utopian communities in the early 19th century and later became closely tied to the Socialist Labor Party (founded in 1876) and the Socialist Party of America (formed in 1901). , and particularly a plan for black communities to exercise agency rather than wait for a revolution led by white labor. Cooperative colonies are to serve as a sanctuary for exploited blacks, though only as a temporary refuge and a stepping stone to the liberation of all the exploited masses. For Zora, increasingly a mouthpiece for Du Bois's ideas in the novel's closing pages, alliance within the working class is made certain in the long run by economic forces, yet to hasten its arrival, blacks must focus on their own group development in order to "bring to that alliance as much independent economic strength as possible" (398).
This does not mean, however, that Du Bois underestimates the task of breaking down the color line color line
A barrier, created by custom, law, or economic differences, separating nonwhite persons from whites. Also called color bar.
Noun 1. dividing black and white proletarians. The leading spokesman and perennial presidential candidate of the Socialist party, Eugene V. Debs, had announced that, compared to white workers, black workers were "not one whit worse off"; he had therefore concluded, "We have nothing special to offer the Negro, and we cannot make separate appeals to all the races" (qtd. in Foner 114). (6) In contrast, Du Bois insisted not only that black workers were worse off but also that racism among white laborers was a primary stumbling block stum·bling block
An obstacle or impediment.
any obstacle that prevents something from taking place or progressing
Noun 1. to socialist development. White capitalists are presented in Quest as deliberately fomenting division and suspicion between white and black workers to keep both classes down, and racism is too fertile a soil for this plot to be readily foiled (391). A labor organizer from up North, just fired and bolting for home in frustration, speaks the truth about class division that his white co-workers are reluctant to hear: "[I]f you mutts think you're going to beat these big blokes at their own game of cheating niggers you're daffy. You take this from me: get together with the niggers and hold up this whole capitalist gang" (396). Such an antiracist stance is precisely what Du Bois expected of union organizers and of the Socialist party. But Du Bois here also predicts--largely accurately--the unresponsiveness of most southern white labor to true, color-blind labor solidarity.
All of this Du Bois formulated before his career at the NAACP was even underway, prior to his official affiliation with the Socialist party and during a period when few critics have acknowledged the seriousness of his socialism. (7) By the evidence of Quest of the Silver Fleece, Du Bois had by 1911 arrived at several positions credited to him only much later, after substantial contact with Marxism or with Third International socialism. For example, the novel clearly signals that racial division (perpetuated by denials such as Debs's about its reality) also "signifies class," a move that Weinbaum associates with later moments in Du Bois's career, in Darkwater (1920) and Du Bois's turn "toward Marxism" (195, 199). Still more dramatically, Zora's vision of a black cooperative community unmistakably articulates a view of black self-development that Singh finds specified in Du Bois's writing only at the time of his break with the NAACP in 1934: Du Bois's rejection of "the idea that blacks could only progress by standing with another recognized national group, whether it was liberal whites, communist radicals, 'exploiting capitalists,' or striking workers" (59). Although not the most conventional of polemical documents, Quest of the Silver Fleece offers an original and detailed socialist vision, limning many of the socioeconomic proposals offered by Du Bois over the next 30 years.
"What folk are you going to let starve?" Du Bois and the Second Internationale
Interpreters of Du Bois's early socialism should heed Adolph Reed's observation that socialism might mean many things in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century. They should also note that this fact raises not only conservative possibilities, highlighted by Reed when he speaks of bureaucratic collectivism Bureaucratic collectivism is a theory of class society. It is used by some Trotskyists to describe the nature of the Soviet Union under Joseph Stalin, and other similar states in Central and Eastern Europe and elsewhere (such as China , but also radical ones, for it means that specifically socialist ideas and ideals infused themselves through many groups that did not themselves adopt the socialist label. Hence, in the 1890s the People's party People's party: see Populist party. adopted a platform calling for public ownership of all major industries but purposely disclaiming the socialist banner. (8) In the same period, the Nationalist party Nationalist Party
or Kuomintang or Guomindang
Political party that governed all or part of mainland China from 1928 to 1949 and subsequently ruled Taiwan. campaigned for the socialization socialization /so·cial·iza·tion/ (so?shal-i-za´shun) the process by which society integrates the individual and the individual learns to behave in socially acceptable ways.
n. of all industry and equal wage distribution, but party founder and Looking Backward Looking Backward
Julian West awakens more than a century later to enjoy a new life in the Boston of A.D. 2000. [Am. Lit.: Looking Backward in Magill I, 520]
See : Time Travel author Edward Bellamy Edward Bellamy (March 26 1850 – May 22 1898) was an American author and socialist, most famous for his utopian novel, Looking Backward, set in the year 2000. Early life
Edward Bellamy was born in Chicopee Falls, Massachusetts. felt that "socialism" was too indeterminate and too moderate a term for his movement ("Socialism," passim PASSIM - A simulation language based on Pascal.
["PASSIM: A Discrete-Event Simulation Package for Pascal", D.H Uyeno et al, Simulation 35(6):183-190 (Dec 1980)]. ). With the formation of the Socialist party in 1901, the US socialist movement The Socialist Movement was an independent left-wing grouping in the United Kingdom that grew out the Socialist Conferences.
The Socialist Conference was a series of large meetings held in Chesterfield, Sheffield and Manchester in the years after the defeat of Britain’s was led by an organization that marched unabashedly un·a·bashed
1. Not disconcerted or embarrassed; poised.
2. Not concealed or disguised; obvious: unabashed disgust. under the socialist banner. But the older patterns of socialism going under various names and of influencing individuals and groups outside of the party (and even some eschewing the socialist label) persisted.
It is within this context that we understand Du Bois's brief membership in the Socialist Party of America The Socialist Party of America (SPA) was a socialist political party in the United States. It was formed in 1901 by a merger between the three-year-old Social Democratic Party and a wing of the older Socialist Labor Party of America. . He was a card-carrying Socialist for less than two years, joining the party in 1911 but resigning after his endorsement of Woodrow Wilson over Eugene Debs in the election of 1912 ("Last Word"). But as Manning Marable Manning Marable (b. 13 May 1950 in Dayton, Ohio) is an American political scholar. He holds the position of Professor of Public Affairs, Political Science, and History at Columbia University, where he founded and directed the Institute for Research in African-American Studies. notes, Du Bois "remained a Socialist" in principle and practice (90). In effect, the socialism defined in Quest of the Silver Fleece became refined through a long-running, intense dialogue with the socialism of the Second Internationale, an exchange made sharper because Du Bois judged white socialists as not living up to egalitarian principles that they shared--and in which Du Bois's commitment to economic equality was no less strong because he was not a party member.
Du Bois's editorializing on the Socialist party and its labor constituency during the first three years of the Crisis shows ample justification for Du Bois's distanced relationship with the party. The racist practices of organized labor Organized Labor
An association of workers united as a single, representative entity for the purpose of improving the workers' economic status and working conditions through collective bargaining with employers. Also known as "unions". were a perpetual outrage to the Crisis editor, prompting frequent comment. The majority of unions barred black workers from union membership and then cried foul when they worked as scabs. In his 1912 editorial "Organized Labor," Du Bois expressed hope in the trade unions' fight for economic justice, but only if that fight was for the benefit of all workers: "So long as union labor fights for humanity, its mission is divine; but when it fights for a clique (mathematics) clique - A maximal totally connected subgraph. Given a graph with nodes N, a clique C is a subset of N where every node in C is directly connected to every other node in C (i.e. C is totally connected), and C contains all such nodes (C is maximal). of Americans, ... they deserve themselves the starvation which they plan for their darker and poorer fellows" (131). Du Bois recognized clearly enough that the more supportive a union was of the Socialist party, the more likely it was to include blacks. In the second issue of the Crisis, Du Bois published reports that AFL AFL: see American Federation of Labor and Congress of Industrial Organizations. chief Samuel Gompers--an implacable anti-socialist--had recently endorsed the covenants of AFL locals explicitly forbidding black union membership ("Economic"). In contradistinction con·tra·dis·tinc·tion
Distinction by contrasting or opposing qualities.
contra·dis·tinc , Du Bois noted in 1912 that the Industrial Workers of the World Industrial Workers of the World (IWW), revolutionary industrial union organized in Chicago in 1905 by delegates from the Western Federation of Mines, which formed the nucleus of the IWW, and 42 other labor organizations. , the most radical union associated with the Socialist party, had been successfully organizing "mixed locals" in Texas, Louisiana, Arkansas, and Florida, and "this despite the fact that in some of the southern States Southern States
government of 11 Southern states that left the Union in 1860. [Am. Hist.: EB, III: 73]
popular name for Southern states in U.S. and for song. [Am. Hist. the laws prohibit public gatherings of black and white" ("Economics"). But this was about the time the IWW IWW: see Industrial Workers of the World. and the party split, and other Socialist labor leaders were less reliable. The Crisis reported in May 1913 that St. Louis labor unions had opposed the Republican mayoral candidate because he had formerly employed blacks on a construction project, and leading the opposition was "Tom Hale, formerly business agent of Union No. 1, and a Socialist, [who] declares that he will throw his vote away on the Democratic candidate rather than vote for a man who would not consent to employ white labor exclusively" ("The colored voters"). Socialist party organizers, Du Bois reported, failed to spread its propaganda to the black masses but complained bitterly when blacks did not support the socialist cause ("Forward").
In 1913, within a year of his break with the party, Du Bois published an article in a journal of socialist theory, The New Review, making clear that the party's tacit acceptance of labor racism lay at the root of his resignation. (9) The article is revealing not only for this reason, but also because it makes clear his own, ongoing reliance on socialist principles and, hence, the possibility that Du Bois remained truer to socialism outside the party than inside it. Claiming social democracy as his guiding principle, Du Bois argued that the party ceased to remain socialist when it failed to practice labor egalitarianism. He maintained that neither the means nor the ends currently promulgated by the Socialist party measured up to its own standards. Du Bois proposed "the test [of] the Excluded Class" as a measure both of who should be included in party activism and of who must be included on equal terms in the eventual socialist state The term socialist state (or socialist republic, or workers' state) can carry one of several different (but related) meanings:
If you are saving dying babies, whose babies are you going to let die? If you are feeding the hungry, what folk are you (regretfully, perhaps, but none less truly) going to let starve? If you are making a juster division of wealth, what people are you going to permit at present to remain in poverty? If you are giving all men votes (not only in the "political" but also in the economic world), what class of people are you going to allow to remain disfranchised? ("Socialism" 139)
Time and again, Du Bois would test the genuineness of socialist parties Socialist parties in European history, political organizations formed in European countries to achieve the goals of socialism. General History
In the late 19th cent. and programs by whether they regarded proletarian blacks and other people of color Noun 1. people of color - a race with skin pigmentation different from the white race (especially Blacks)
people of colour, colour, color
race - people who are believed to belong to the same genetic stock; "some biologists doubt that there are important as equals. He described himself as a pragmatist rather than a theoretician the·o·re·ti·cian
One who formulates, studies, or is expert in the theory of a science or an art.
Noun , one of those socialists "who suffer from the present industrial situation and who are anxious that, whatever the broad outcome may be, at any rate the present suffering which they know so well shall be stopped" (138). Yet Du Bois's insistence that social equality "Equal Rights" redirects here. for the motto, see Equal Rights (motto)
Social equality is a social state of affairs in which certain different people have the same status in a certain respect, at the very least in voting rights, freedom of speech and assembly, the extent of regardless of race must be demanded through the process of agitation as well as merely expected as the outcome of revolution amounts, as well, to an important theoretical caution against ends justifying means.
The heterogenous (spelling) heterogenous - It's spelled heterogeneous. socialists of the Second Internationale attempted to exercise party discipline over few matters save voting behavior: hence the necessity of Du Bois's resignation when he publicly endorsed Wilson. The stubborn pragmatism of Du Bois's electoral strategies in the 1910s is seen by Arnold Rampersad Arnold Rampersad (born 13 November 1941)is an acclaimed biographer and literary critic. The first volume his Life Of Langston Hughes was a Pulitzer Prize finalist. He was born in Trinidad. as a point of constant tension with Du Bois's underlying socialist idealism, part of a pattern of divided loyalties in Du Bois that prevents Rampersad from seeing him as an out-and-out socialist (159). Yet in a period when collectivist programs were being adopted to an extent by the major parties under the banner of Progressivism, and particularly given the need for blacks to gain genuine voting rights Voting rights
The right to vote on matters that are put to a vote of security holders. For example the right to vote for directors.
The type of voting and the amount of control held by the owners of a class of stock. before they could vote for any party at all, Du Bois might reasonably be understood as being an authentic socialist even while advocating strategic voting for non-socialist parties. In fact, such anomalous voting behavior may even be demanded in view of the special circumstances special circumstances n. in criminal cases, particularly homicides, actions of the accused or the situation under which the crime was committed for which state statutes allow or require imposition of a more severe punishment. of black suffrage. A key reason for the party's inattention in·at·ten·tion
Lack of attention, notice, or regard.
Noun 1. inattention - lack of attention
basic cognitive process - cognitive processes involved in obtaining and storing knowledge may have been its strategy of courting voters, whereas the vast majority of African Americans, concentrated in the South, were not voters. From within the Socialist party, Du Bois could criticize the party for its pandering to southern white (and bitterly racist) Populists. But really to gain leverage within the Socialist party meant gaining votes for blacks, and that could best be effected by appealing first of all to the political parties in power. The strategy is reflected clearly in an "Oath" for African American citizens published in the November 1917 Crisis. The first article in the oath stresses the importance of a black voting strategy that wins suffrage for other, disenfranchised blacks--a strategy demanding major party voting. But the second article is socialism, through and through: "I will make the second object of my voting the division of the Social Income on the principle that he who does not work, be he rich or poor, may not eat; and that Land and Capital ought to belong to the Many and not to the Few" ("Oath"). First get the vote by whatever means, Du Bois suggested, then use the vote to achieve socialism.
Already in 1908 Du Bois had expressed interest in endorsing Socialist candidates, even while worrying over the dilemma of third-party voting in the United States United States, officially United States of America, republic (2005 est. pop. 295,734,000), 3,539,227 sq mi (9,166,598 sq km), North America. The United States is the world's third largest country in population and the fourth largest country in area. (letter to Owens). His endorsements swung from Bryan in 1908 to Wilson in 1912, to the Socialist Alan Benson in 1916, back to the Republican Harding in 1920 ("Presidential"; "Mr. Hughes"). But even while endorsing Wilson, he had praised Debs's "manly stand on human rights irrespective of irrespective of
Without consideration of; regardless of.
preposition despite color," and his tepid advocacy of Harding was further undercut by a 1920 fantasy about outsider coalition-building: Just "suppose," he mused in a Crisis editorial, "the 'dirty foreigners' and the disfranchised Socialists and the disfranchised black should get together and vote together at the next election!" ("Last Word"; "Remember"). When increasing numbers of blacks were able to vote in the 1920s--albeit because of northward migration rather than any substantial gains in southern voting rights--Du Bois's resistance to Socialist candidates steadily broke down. In 1924, Du Bois gave his nod to the Independent-Progressive candidate, Robert La Follette La Fol·lette , Robert Marion 1855-1925.
American politician and reformer who served as a U.S. senator from Wisconsin (1906-1925). In 1924 he ran unsuccessfully for President on the Progressive Party ticket. , also the nominee of the Socialist party; in 1928 the Crisis editor favored Socialist Norman Thomas; and in 1932 Du Bois gave his stamp of approval to both the Socialist and Communist nominees, commenting waggishly wag·gish
Characteristic of or resembling a wag; jocular or witty.
waggish·ly adv. in the October Crisis, "[H]onest to God, if Herbert Hoover don't quit stopping the crisis, he's going to put [William Z.] Foster and [James W.] Ford in the White House next March" ("Socialists and Communists"; Du Bois, "As the Crow").
Du Bois's thinking on black socialism during his middle career--the 15 years between 1912 and 1926 when the Crisis enjoyed its greatest influence in black America--was by no means limited to theorizing about the relationship between black voters and the Socialist party, either. From the standpoint of black radicalism, his thinking about inter-class relations within black America is crucially important--and surprisingly advanced. Joy James asserts that until the late 1930s Du Bois persisted in regarding the "talented tenth" as a progressive vanguard by virtue of its social and economic privilege; only in his 1940 autobiography, Dusk of Dawn, does she see clear evidence that Du Bois reconceptualized the Talented Tenth as being defined by virtue of "the 'existential wealth' of political and moral leadership" rather than by social and economic distinction conventionally defined (23). But we find evidence of this evolution in Du Bois's thinking about the Talented Tenth already in Quest of the Silver Fleece, in which the ethical turning point for Bles comes when he rejects Washington DC's pigmentocracy in order to labor--physically as well as mentally--in a cooperative colony in the South. And the peasant heroine of the novel, Zora, leads her community (Bles included) regardless of the facts that she has had minimal formal education and is female. Even earlier, two of Du Bois's Atlanta studies, 1898's Some Efforts of American Negroes for their own Social Betterment and 1907's Economic Co-operation among Negro Americans, examined the race's cooperative efforts. In these studies, one of Du Bois's central conclusions was that similarity in incomes throughout the Negro community fostered cooperative efforts in churches, societies, and homes (Economic Co-operation 4). In some of Du Bois's earliest writings in the Crisis, Du Bois found that the shared, "class" interests of blacks were solidified by the common foe of white racism. In an editorial entitled "Baltimore," he exposed the hard truth that, though blacks had been told that "money talks," even upwardly mobile blacks had found it mute when they attempted to move in next door to white neighbors. The importance of altruistic black leadership to Du Bois is evident in his fear that outside capitalist influences threatened the livelihood of black communities by fostering the notion of each man for himself (Economic Co-operation 6). As Du Bois pointed out in "Business and Philanthropy," capitalism lured the best young men to go into business pursuits by teaching the tune "Business pays. Philanthropy begs" (64). There was, of course, some serious wishful thinking wishful thinking Psychology Dereitic thought that a thing or event should have a specified outcome in Du Bois's assumption that the majority of upwardly mobile blacks would spurn the capitalist ideology of individual self-interest. But this is quite another thing from the view advanced by James, that for most of his career Du Bois believed upwardly mobile blacks would advance the race regardless of their ideology. Even if, as Adolph Reed points out, Du Bois's earliest sociological studies are marked by the fear that professional blacks will be defined, via racial kinship, by negative stereotypes of working-class blacks, Du Bois's work--almost from the outset--is equally defined by fear that capitalist ideology would undermine inter-class solidarity, and the hope that such solidarity might serve as the basis for general racial progress. (10)
From a relatively early date, too, Du Bois saw inter-class black solidarity as not merely a matter of social courtesy or political exigency but of economic necessity. Perhaps the clearest indication that the cooperative economics in Quest of the Silver Fleece was not a mere, passing fancy comes in a pair of Crisis editorials from August 1917. In the first of these Du Bois concludes: "[E]conomic survival for the Negro in America means the building of his own industrial machine," in which "he must employ labor, ... organize industry, [and] enter American industrial development as a group, capable of offensive and defensive action, and not simply as an individual liable to be made the victim of the white employer and such of the white labor unions as dare" ("Occupations"). If it is difficult to discern here whether the reference to "employing labor" might mean that the black nation within a nation is to duplicate the hierarchy of the white capitalist system, Du Bois's next editorial states explicitly that both the economic structure and the values of independent black industry must be counter-cultural:
Shall we try the old paths of individual exploitation, develop a class of rich and grasping brigands of Industry, use them to exploit the mass of the black laboring people and reproduce in our own group all the industrial Hell of old Europe and America? No! ... [I]f we American Negroes are keen and intelligent we can evolve a new and efficient industrial co-operation quicker than any other group of people, for the simple reason that our inequalities of wealth are small, our group loyalty is growing stronger and stronger, and the necessity for a change in our industrial life is becoming imperative. ("Co-Operation")
Even as, in deference to the varied political affiliations of his readers, Du Bois omits the socialist label, he here expressly renews his call for an Afro-centric socialism that had first been sounded in Quest of the Silver Fleece and remained central to his thought throughout his career.
"The international laboring class of all colors": Du Bois's Transnational Socialism
The other core element of Du Bois's mature socialism, his international critique of capitalism and racism, did not emerge as early as Quest of the Silver Fleece. Yet in 1911 Du Bois did publish a report on the Universal Races Congress in which racist economic exploitation in the United States is linked with its imperialist equivalent abroad, suggesting that an early source for Du Bois's transnational socialism was his contact with Pan-Africanist colleagues: "[A] strong, masterly argument was made to show that the economic foundations of imperialism were as weak as those of the slave barons of the South and as wicked" ("Races" 208). In a 1913 editorial Du Bois still more explicitly links capitalism with imperialism--and presciently pre·scient
1. Of or relating to prescience.
2. Possessing prescience.
[French, from Old French, from Latin praesci identifies the imperial contest as the prime catalyst of war: "The modern lust for land and slaves in Africa, Asia and the South Seas South Seas, name given by early explorers to the whole of the Pacific Ocean. In recent times the name has been used to mean only the central Pacific, the S Pacific, and the SW Pacific. is the greatest and almost the only cause of war between the so-called civilized peoples" ("Peace"). Once the Great War erupted and the European Social Democratic parties all proved failures, Du Bois asserted a still more socialistic and international strategy for the labor movement than he had before the war--and a more truly international socialism, too, than the European social democracy was demanding. In The Negro (1915) Du Bois describes the path to socialism as lying through Pan-Africanism rather than through the narrower, European-led Social Democracy:
The Pan-African movement when it comes will not ... be merely a narrow racial propaganda. Already the more far-seeing Negroes sense the coming unities: a unity of the working classes everywhere, a unity of the colored races, a new unity of men. The proposed economic solution of the Negro problem in Africa and America has turned the thoughts of Negroes toward a realization of the fact that the modern white laborer of Europe and America has the key to the serfdom of black folk in his support of militarism and colonial expansion. He is beginning to say to these workingmen that, so long as black laborers are slaves, white laborers cannot be free. Already there are signs in South Africa and the United States of the beginning of understanding between the two classes. (241-42)
Notably--and somewhat at odds with his domestic prescription of black self-sufficiency--Du Bois envisions the agency of the Pan-Africanists as being directed towards heightened cooperation with (and even some dependency upon) white labor as well as greater racial unity among people of color worldwide. But regarding the emergence and maturation of Du Bois's socialism, the key point here is certainly that Du Bois was linking imperialism and capitalism, and prescribing the solidarity of people of color with international labor, long before either this analysis or remedy was popularized by the Bolsheviks--indeed, well before the Bolshevik Revolution itself. (11)
By Du Bois's 1919 essay collection, Darkwater, the international scene is prominent even when Du Bois writes on domestic subjects. It is evident, for example, in his response to the horrendous 1917 riots in East St. Louis, in which white union workers attacked black neighborhoods in retribution for black workers' accepting strike-replacement jobs. 39 blacks were killed and 600 left homeless in the riots--a cost all the more terrible considering that the white workers were scapegoating black workers whom they had excluded from their unions (Lewis, Biography 537). Intractable as the conflicts represented in East St. Louis were, Du Bois saw clearly the ethical principle demanded by the circumstances: "[O]ne answer looms above all--justice lies with the lowest; the plight of the lowest man--the plight of the black man--deserves the first answer, and the plight of the giants of industry, the last" (91). Du Bois thus joins ranks with labor radicals in faulting the capitalists, first of all; but he adds a thoroughly social democratic theoretical caveat, that the more oppressed op·press
tr.v. op·pressed, op·press·ing, op·press·es
1. To keep down by severe and unjust use of force or authority: a people who were oppressed by tyranny.
2. of laborers, not the less, should be given priority. In Du Bois's New Review article of 1913, this had been "the test [of] the Excluded Class." But then the "Excluded Class" had been American blacks alone; now Du Bois's editorial cast the "lowest man" as an international class. Du Bois finds the sociological ramifications of this moral test to multiply as its scope extends from East St. Louis to the world:
There are no races, in the sense of great, separate, pure breeds of men, differing in attainment, development, and capacity. There are great groups--now with common history, now with common interests, now with common ancestry; more and more common experience and present interest drive back the common blood and the world today consists, not of races, but of the imperial commercial group of master capitalists, international and predominantly white; the national middle classes of the several nations, white, yellow, and brown, with strong blood bonds, common languages, and common history; the international laboring class of all colors; the backward, oppressed groups of nature-folk, predominantly yellow, brown, and black. (Darkwater 98)
From this point, Du Bois's intellectual career would be increasingly driven by the convictions expressed, or implied, in this passage: The "international laboring class" must stand in solidarity--white workers alongside people of color. "Backward, oppressed groups" must be included in progressive modernity, not exploited. And "the national middle classes"--including Du Bois's favored Talented Tenth--must eschew their class privileges and use their abilities to serve the submerged and exploited classes. These themes are grandiosely elaborated in Du Bois's second full-length novel, Dark Princess Dark Princess is a russian Melodic Goth Metal band formed in 2004 out of Moscow. Lineup
Olga Romanova (The bands namesake Dark Princess) - vocals Aleksandr Lubimov - guitar Denis Stekanov - drums Ilya Klokov - guitar Stepan Zujev - keyboards Stanislav Fatyanov - bass (1928), which culminates in the marriage and political partnership of a Talented Tenth representative and an Indian princess who is leader of a Pan-Asian cabal. Both lead characters, however, must first mature politically and socially by immersing themselves in the lowest of the working classes and renouncing the personal rewards in politics and wealth that are readily available to them. Yet these very themes were fully developed by 1919 and had been clearly evident in Du Bois's work before November 1917. (12)
"No chestnuts from the fire": Du Bois and the Comintern
To this point, our argument has centered on Du Bois's socialism before the Bolshevik Revolution, as we have wished to redirect critical attention to the richness and interest of Du Bois's socialism apart from the influence of dogmatic Marxism. Having done so, we would also suggest that a fuller appreciation of Du Bois's early socialism also helps to cast the later socialism in a new light. Specifically, a clearer focus on Du Bois's earlier socialism offers an alternative to his later commitments, which at their worst became an apologetics apologetics
Branch of Christian theology devoted to the intellectual defense of faith. In Protestantism, apologetics is distinguished from polemics, the defense of a particular sect. In Roman Catholicism, apologetics refers to the defense of the whole of Catholic teaching. for mass murder and, even cast in the best light, may seem too closely tied to the Comintern line to suggest a useful politics after the decline of state-sponsored collectivism.
Tentatively in the years immediately following the Bolshevik Revolution, then more eagerly by the later 1920s, Du Bois's writing entered into dialogue with the socialist experiment in Russia. The success of the Bolshevik revolution and the strong leadership exercised by the Soviet Union at the head of the Third Internationale pointed to a new paradigm New Paradigm
In the investing world, a totally new way of doing things that has a huge effect on business.
The word "paradigm" is defined as a pattern or model, and it has been used in science to refer to a theoretical framework. that accepted the necessity of violence after centuries of bloody oppression by the Czars. In the 1920s, first-hand reports from American socialist visitors to the Soviet Union glowed with praise for the revolution. (13) In 1926 Du Bois went to see for himself, a trip that biographer David Levering Lewis David Levering Lewis is an American historian and two-time winner of the Pulitzer Prize for Biography or Autobiography, for part one and part two of his biography of W.E.B. Du Bois (in 1994 and 2001, respectively). describes as a life-transforming experience: "Never before in life had he been as stirred as he would be by two months in Russia" (Fight 200). Yet already in a Crisis editorial penned prior to his departure Du Bois had seemed more ready than before to excuse undemocratic and violent means if they lead ultimately to the goal of egalitarianism: "If [Russia] succeeds we will all forgive the tyranny as we have forgiven in ages gone many other tyrants. If she fails the End remains great even though the means were terrible" ("Germany"). By the 1950s, Du Bois had become an outright apologist Apologist
Any of the Christian writers, primarily in the 2nd century, who attempted to provide a defense of Christianity against Greco-Roman culture. Many of their writings were addressed to Roman emperors and were submitted to government secretaries in order to defend for Stalinism, an entanglement that has provided a considerable challenge for critics who focus on Du Bois's later socialism. In the unpublished manuscript of Russia and America (written in the 1950s) and in an editorial to the Soviet Literary Gazette (26 Sept. 1957; Aptheker 3: 412-15), Du Bois would in fact defend the cruelty of the Stalinist regime in an attempt to validate his conception of the socialist state.
The most direct defense of Du Bois's Cold War politics is suggested by Kate Baldwin's Beyond the Color Line and the Iron Curtain Iron Curtain
Political, military, and ideological barrier erected by the Soviet Union after World War II to seal off itself and its dependent eastern European allies from open contact with the West and other noncommunist areas. , which asserts that the idealism that led Du Bois and others to extol ex·tol also ex·toll
tr.v. ex·tolled also ex·tolled, ex·tol·ling also ex·toll·ing, ex·tols also ex·tolls
To praise highly; exalt. See Synonyms at praise. the Soviet experiment can, in fact, be disentangled from the specific abuses of Stalin and his lieutenants. Another defense is provided by Joy James, who emphasizes Du Bois's abandonment by Talented-Tenth blacks when he was charged with unAmerican activities at the beginning of the Cold War (26-27). By this view, Du Bois's association with the USSR USSR: see Union of Soviet Socialist Republics. was a natural and excusable reaction to ostracism ostracism (ŏs`trəsĭz'əm), ancient Athenian method of banishing a public figure. It was introduced after the fall of the family of Pisistratus. at home. For Nikhil Singh, too, Du Bois's "bitter disavowals of the United States and willful blindness Willful blindness is a term used in law to describe a situation in which an individual seeks to avoid civil or criminal liability for a wrongful act by intentionally putting himself in a position where he will be unaware of facts which would render him liable. to Stalin's crimes" were unmistakably a product of Cold War politics, a context in which the best path--a principled radicalism that was simultaneously anti-Stalinist--was also the most difficult to follow (177, 128). These defenses are all persuasive to some degree. But to us, Baldwin's project of separating socialist idealism from Stalinism seems largely unnecessary when the larger scope of Du Bois's socialism is more fully recognized. James's psychological explanation cannot warrant that Du Bois's later socialism should be trusted as a socio-political prescription, while Singh's historical explanation hardly constitutes an endorsement of Du Bois's approach under the quite different international conditions of the post-Soviet era. Our approach, in contrast, is to argue simply that Du Bois's dying legacy need not be taken as his best contribution to social democratic thought. Du Bois's late defense of revolutionary violence need not be excused because, through nearly his entire career, Du Bois himself had refused to make excuses for violence in the name of socialism. (14)
The question of revolutionary violence was not only central to debates between the American Socialist and Communist parties There are, at present, a number of communist parties active in various countries across the world, and a number who used to be active. The formation of communist parties in various countries was first initiated by the formation of the communist Third International by the Russian of the 1920s and '30s; it was a prominent issue in Du Bois's work going at least as far back as his 1909 biography of John Brown. Like the majority of American socialists, Du Bois did not advocate nonviolence out of an absolute, unconditional principle--and in this sense there was, from the outset, an opening for acceptance of revolutionary violence in Du Bois's thought (even as there was such an acceptance in the American founding fathers and mothers). But almost always, Du Bois defended violence in a just cause even while realizing that, in virtually all times and places, nonviolence is the best path to justice--even, or especially, for the wretched of the earth. In his 1909 biography, John Brown, he had written sympathetically of Brown's righteous war against slavery, yet Du Bois concluded that Brown's deeds of violence were, in the final analysis, less effective than the "spiritual value" of his martyrdom, his court testimony, and his dying words (174). So, too, in a key scene in Quest of the Silver Fleece when a mob threatens to destroy Zora's cooperative community, Du Bois provides clear backing for the right to bear arms The right to bear arms refers to the right that individuals have to weapons. This right is often presented in the context of military service and the broader right of self defense. in self defense: Bles and Zora encourage community members to arm themselves in defense of their village commons. But even as Du Bois's plot defuses the situation through the keystone-cops-style bungling bun·gle
v. bun·gled, bun·gling, bun·gles
To work or act ineptly or inefficiently.
To handle badly; botch. See Synonyms at botch.
n. of the white mob--a deus ex machina deus ex machina
Stage device in Greek and Roman drama in which a god appeared in the sky by means of a crane (Greek, mechane) to resolve the plot of a play. Plays by Sophocles and particularly Euripides sometimes require the device. preserving a comic ending--the narrator NARRATOR. A pleader who draws narrs serviens narrator, a sergeant at law. Fleta, 1. 2, c. 37. Obsolete. spells out through Bles's thoughts the more likely, real-world result of such a confrontation: "One desperate struggle, a whirl of blood, and the whole world would rise to crush him and his people. The white operator in yonder yon·der
In or at that indicated place: the house over yonder.
Being at an indicated distance, usually within sight: "Yonder hills," he said, pointing. town had but to flash the news, 'Negroes killing whites,' to bring all the country, all the State, all the nation, to red vengeance" (423). If the right to self defense is established here in principle, Bles's recognition of vicious racist culture suggests that this right must in many situations be waived. And the improbability im·prob·a·bil·i·ty
n. pl. im·prob·a·bil·i·ties
1. The quality or condition of being improbable.
2. Something improbable.
Noun 1. of the plot at this point indicates that the struggle for political and economic equality must be long, circuitous cir·cu·i·tous
Being or taking a roundabout, lengthy course: took a circuitous route to avoid the accident site. , and waged with patience: a series of events far too long and unpredictable to be told in the pages of a potboiler pot·boil·er
A literary or artistic work of poor quality, produced quickly for profit.
[From the phrase boil the pot, to provide one's livelihood. novel.
This line of thinking carries over well into Du Bois's Marxist phase of the late 1920s and '30s. For in spite of his interest in the Soviet experiment during this period, Du Bois determined that Russia, with its long history of Czarist repression and reactionary violence, formed an exceptional case. In America, Du Bois did not give up on the possibility of transforming capitalist society through the existing political system. Though the Sons and Daughters of the American Revolution Daughters of the American Revolution (DAR), a Colonial patriotic society in the United States, open to women having one or more ancestors who aided the cause of the Revolution. The society was organized (1890) at Washington, D.C. might blacklist (1) A list of e-mail addresses of known spammers. See spam, spam filter, Blacklist of Internet Advertisers, greylisting and blackholing. Contrast with white list.
(2) A list of Web sites that are considered off limits or dangerous. him and his compatriots for believing "in the administration of wealth and of the division of the income for the good of the community, rather than simply for private interests," he was "unaware that such an attitude [was] either revolutionary or dangerous" (letter to Bailey). In a series of letters exchanged between Du Bois and socialist George Streator during April of 1935, the former insisted that Marx had never meant to imply the necessity of bloody revolution in his Manifesto. In practice, insurrection might have worked for Russia, but it would never work in the United States, especially for its people of color (Aptheker 2:87-88). In his 1936 unpublished pamphlet "The Negro and Social Reconstruction," he described the futility of revolution: "This is a silly program even for white men. For American colored men, it is suicidal" (65). Echoing his fictional warning in Quest of the Silver Fleece, Du Bois insisted that whites would seek vengeance against the blacks, giving them no opportunity to rebuild the nation. Political reform gave Du Bois hope that progress could be effected through educated universal suffrage Noun 1. universal suffrage - suffrage for all adults who are not disqualified by the laws of the country
right to vote, suffrage, vote - a legal right guaranteed by the 15th amendment to the US Constitution; guaranteed to women by the 19th amendment; "American ("Negro and Social" 66). Economic reform in the New Deal was the first step toward more radical changes. If America could pull off the dramatic transformation needed for socialism with just a podium and a ballot box, it could celebrate its most democratic achievement in 150 years. Du Bois believed that it could. In 1938, with the Popular Front booming and one black Communist leader able to boast that "75%" of Harlem's black intellectuals had "party membership" or "regular meaningful contact with the party" (qtd. in Maxwell 1), Du Bois's old colleague Mary White Ovington saw Communism as the last, best hope for the rights of minorities: "I wish I had any hope that a minority group can [achieve] its economic place in a nation against the wish of the majority but since the Nazis['] attitude to the German Jews The Jewish presence in Germany is older than Christianity; the first Jewish population came with the Romans to the city Cologne. A "Golden Age" in the first millennium saw the emergence of the Ashkenazi Jews, while the persecution and expulsion that followed the Crusades led to the , exiling Einstein, my only hope is in Communism" (11 Mar. 1938). Although the previous year Du Bois had returned from a second, appreciative visit to the Soviet Union (Lewis, Fight 407-08), Du Bois cautioned Ovington in his reply: "Communism is the hope of us all but not the dogmatic Marxian program with war and murder in the forefront. Economic communism by the path of peace is possible" (Letter to Mary White Ovington).
In his interactions with the Comintern in the 1930s, Du Bois also continued to envision an Afro-centric socialism and defended that socialism against cooptation by white Communists. In effect, Du Bois was continuing with the Communists the same feud he had had with the Socialists, albeit with higher stakes given the role of violence in the Communists' program. Du Bois clashed with the party most spectactularly--and for our purposes, perhaps most instructively-regarding the Scottsboro case Scottsboro Case. In 1931 nine black youths were indicted at Scottsboro, Ala., on charges of having raped two white women in a freight car passing through Alabama. . For the Scottsboro struggle--in many ways the beginning of the end of Du Bois's tenure as Crisis editor--also clearly marked Du Bois's difference from Marxism and the party.
In the eyes of Du Bois and other black Americans, there was certainly much to admire in the Communist party's approach to the Scottsboro trials. (15) When the nine "Scottsboro boys The case of the Scottsboro Boys arose in Scottsboro, Alabama during the 1930s, when nine black youths, ranging in age from twelve to nineteen, were accused of raping two white women, Victoria Price and Ruby Bates, one of whom would later recant. " were convicted by a 1931 Alabama court on (false) rape charges, the vigorous and highly publicized appeals of the International Labor Defense The International Labor Defense (ILD) was a legal defense organization in the United States, headed by William L. Patterson. It was a US section of International Red Aid organisation, and associated with the Communist Party USA. (ILD (Inter Layer Dielectric) The insulation used between layers of aluminum or copper wire that interconnect the transistors in a chip. There are three to four layers in a memory chip and five to seven in a logic chip with hundreds of meters of wiring. ), the Communist party's legal arm, almost unquestionably un·ques·tion·a·ble
Beyond question or doubt. See Synonyms at authentic.
un·question·a·bil saved the lives of the defendants, whereas the tardy tar·dy
adj. tar·di·er, tar·di·est
1. Occurring, arriving, acting, or done after the scheduled, expected, or usual time; late.
2. Moving slowly; sluggish. and timid defense of the NAACP very probably would have permitted their execution (Goodman 82-84). Du Bois's analysis of Scottsboro in the Crisis resembled closely the Communists' contentions about the shared interests of poor southern blacks and whites, even while echoing his previous statement of that common interest in Quest of the Silver Fleece ("Blunders"). Moreover, the Communist party's stance on the Scottsboro boys clearly heightened Du Bois's interest in Marxism, which was discussed prominently in the 1932 and 1933 Crisis and set the stage for Du Bois's 1934 pronouncements that black cooperation ought to replace integration as the NAACP's primary mission. (16) As he had done in Quest, in two of the Atlanta studies, and in the Crisis, Du Bois advocated cooperative economics within the black community, although now he proposed it on a scale that amounted to acceptance, on tactical grounds, of nation-wide segregation. His grander conception of a "nation within a nation" may have been a response to the Stalinist notion of an African American "forty-ninth state"--or to the proposition of the black nationalist Black Nationalist
A member of a group of militant Black people who urge separatism from white people and the establishment of self-governing Black communities.
Black Nationalism n. socialist Cyril Briggs Cyril V. Briggs (born May 28, 1888; died October 18, 1966, Los Angeles, California) was an African-American writer and communist political activist.
Briggs was born in 1888 in Nevis, a Caribbean island. Cyril's father was an overseer on a plantation. that blacks in US states where they comprised a majority should exercise "self-determination" (Foner 310). (17) In any case, the NAACP board was even more disturbed by the editor's pro-segregation stance than it had been by his Communist dalliance. After a sharp debate within the NAACP in spring 1934, Du Bois's position on segregation was rejected and Du Bois felt compelled to resign from the NAACP board (Lewis, Fight 342-47).
But Du Bois found at least as much to fault as to credit in the Communists' handling of the Scottsboro trials. Without sharing the anti-Communist bias of NAACP chairman Walter White (Goodman 32), Du Bois shared his conviction that, in making Scottsboro into an international cause celeb ce·leb
A celebrity. and the center of its recruiting drive in black America, the party was subordinating the personal interests of the "boys" to the larger interests of the party. (18) In "The Negro and Communism," Du Bois's defining editorial on Scottsboro and, implicitly, on the ongoing struggle between the ILD and the NAACP over control of the case, Du Bois argued against direct alliance of black Americans with the Communist party Communist party, in China
Communist party, in China, ruling party of the world's most populous nation since 1949 and most important Communist party in the world since the disintegration of the USSR in 1991. under two major heads. First, Du Bois argued that the dictatorship of the proletariat The "dictatorship of the proletariat" is a term employed by Marxists that refers to a temporary state between the capitalist society and the classless and stateless communist society; during this transition period, "the state can be nothing but the revolutionary dictatorship of the , if established in the United States, would remove capitalists who had on occasion offered philanthropy and shown paternalistic pa·ter·nal·ism
A policy or practice of treating or governing people in a fatherly manner, especially by providing for their needs without giving them rights or responsibilities. care toward blacks in order to replace them with the poor whites who had historically shown the greatest contempt for blacks and carried out the larger share of mob violence--who had, for example, surrounded the jail on the first night of the Scottsboro defendants' imprisonment Imprisonment
See also Isolation.
former federal maximum security penitentiary, near San Francisco; “escapeproof.” [Am. Hist.: Flexner, 218]
German prison ship in World War II. [Br. Hist. and clamored for a lynching. Second, Du Bois asserted that black Americans who joined the Communist party would set themselves doubly apart for persecution--the stigma of radicalism added to the already heavy burden of racism. In spite of the antiracist attitudes displayed by Communist party leaders, and whatever the material interests held in common between white and black workers, racial difference was, and would remain for the foreseeable future, a more essential dividing line Noun 1. dividing line - a conceptual separation or distinction; "there is a narrow line between sanity and insanity"
demarcation, contrast, line
differentiation, distinction - a discrimination between things as different and distinct; "it is necessary to in American society than class difference. Therefore Du Bois warned against too close of an affiliation either with the capitalists or with the Communists, as he declared memorably: "American Negroes do not propose to be the shock troops shock troops
Soldiers specially chosen, trained, and armed to lead an attack.
[Translation of German Stosstruppen : Stoss, shock + Truppen, pl. of the Communist Revolution A communist revolution is a proletarian revolution inspired by the ideas of Marxism that aims to replace capitalism with communism, typically with socialism (state-run means of production) as an intermediate stage. , driven out in front to death, cruelty and humiliation in order to win victories for white workers. They are picking no chestnuts from the fire, neither for capital nor white labor." Were the Communist movement Communist Movement (in Spanish: Movimento Comunista, in Basque: Mugimendu Komunista, in Catalan: Moviment Comunista, in Galician: Movemento Comunista) was a political party in Spain. embraced by white labor, he would counsel a closer alliance, but until white workers as well as blacks perceived that "the real interests of the white worker are identical with the interests of the black worker," Du Bois could only advise that "the black worker is compelled in sheer self-defense to refuse to be made the sacrificial goat" ("Negro" 313).
It is the irony of Du Bois's position in the 1930s that he was simultaneously too egalitarian on class issues for the NAACP, whereas he was too egalitarian on race for the Communist party. This position is seen by Robinson, James, Singh, and ourselves as one of Du Bois's theoretical strengths. Yet we would remind critics and admirers of Du Bois that this very stance was articulated not only in the 1930s but in the pages of the Crisis and in his critical dialogue with Second International socialism for many years previous. Moreover, at the very moment in Du Bois's career when other recent commentators are prone to emphasize homologies between Du Bois's thought and that of the Communists, Du Bois's independence from the Communists is about as strong as it had formerly been from the Second International Socialists International Socialists is the name of the number of Trotskyist organisations.
Most organisations using this name are in the International Socialist Tendency. They are:
As well as attesting to the originality of Du Bois's social democratic thought, this historical fact underwrites the applicability of Du Bois's thought to an era after the collapse of the Soviet Union and during the transformation of China from state socialism 1. A form of socialism, esp. advocated in Germany, which, while retaining the right of private property and the institution of the family and other features of the present form of the state, would intervene by various measures intended to give or maintain equality of opportunity, to state capitalism Noun 1. state capitalism - an economic system that is primarily capitalistic but there is some degree of government ownership of the means of production
economic system, economy - the system of production and distribution and consumption . And while certain elements of Du Boisian socialism are anachronistic a·nach·ro·nism
1. The representation of someone as existing or something as happening in other than chronological, proper, or historical order.
2. to the twenty-first century and certain others disconcertingly dis·con·cert
tr.v. dis·con·cert·ed, dis·con·cert·ing, dis·con·certs
1. To upset the self-possession of; ruffle. See Synonyms at embarrass.
2. utopian, we would do well to hearken hear·ken also har·ken
v. hear·kened, hear·ken·ing, hear·kens
To listen attentively; give heed.
To listen to; hear. to a Du Boisian analysis on more than one contemporary issue. For black America at the start of the twenty-first century, increasingly riven rive
v. rived, riv·en also rived, riv·ing, rives
1. To rend or tear apart.
2. To break into pieces, as by a blow; cleave or split asunder.
3. by a class divide between the descendants of Du Bois's Talented Tenth and the majority of African Americans who have remained on the lowest rungs of the socioeconomic ladder, the Du Boisian call to social service and group solidarity remains an important antidote. (19) For those Americans working for social democracy, white as well as black, Du Bois's questioning is prescient pre·scient
1. Of or relating to prescience.
2. Possessing prescience.
[French, from Old French, from Latin praesci : "What folk are you going to let starve? What class of people are you going to allow to remain disfranchised?" These questions, we must recall are especially directed at white labor and white socialists who would seek their own empowerment at the expense of others, still less powerful. (20) As for political leaders of today who have proposed global free trade as a panacea for the social and economic development of all nations--and curiously, also, those who would demand the necessity for utter revolutionary change--the Du Bois who was a fellow traveler fellow traveler
One who sympathizes with or supports the tenets and program of an organized group, such as the Communist Party, without being a member.
Noun 1. of the reformist Second Internationale would encourage a closer look at the social democratic legacy even within our own political economy. At the same time, he would have us look to the developing world--not as a force to be harnessed or checked--but as the birthplace of democratic leaders and values. At the current historical moment dominated by fears of terrorism, this is perhaps the most difficult Du Boisian advice of all to heed. But for Du Bois, not only was peace the surest path to global social democracy, but truly global social democracy was the surest way to peace.
We gratefully acknowledge the National Endowment for the Humanities National Endowment for the Humanities (NEH)
U.S. independent agency. Founded in 1965, it supports research, education, preservation, and public programs in the humanities. and Augustana College Augustana College is the name of two colleges in the U.S., and the former name of one in Canada, all founded by Scandinavian immigrants:
Aptheker, Herbert, ed. The Correspondence of W. E. B. Du Bois. 3 vols. Amherst: U of Massachusetts P, 1973-1978.
Baldwin, Kate A. Beyond the Color Line and the Iron Curtain. Durham: Duke UP, 2002.
Barkin, Kenneth D. "'Berlin Days,' 1892-1894: W. E. B. Du Bois and German Political Economy." Boundary 2 27.3 (2000): 79-101.
Bellamy, Edward Bellamy, Edward (bĕl`əmē), 1850–98, American author, b. Chicopee Falls (now part of Chicopee), Mass. After being admitted to the bar he tried his hand at journalism and contributed short stories of genuine charm to various magazines. . Looking Backward, 2000-1887. 1888. New York New York, state, United States
New York, Middle Atlantic state of the United States. It is bordered by Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and the Atlantic Ocean (E), New Jersey and Pennsylvania (S), Lakes Erie and Ontario and the Canadian province of : Viking Penguin, 1986. --. "Socialism and Nationalism." New Nation 27 Jan. 1894: 38.
Berry, Brian Berry, Brian (Joe Lobley) (1934– ) geographer; born in Sedgley, Staffordshire, England. He moved to the United States in 1955 and took professorships at the University of Chicago, Harvard, and Carnegie-Mellon Universities before becoming Founders J. L. America's Utopian Experiments: Communal Havens from Long-Wave Crises. Hanover, NH: UP of New England, 1992.
Carter, Daniel. Scottsboro: A Tragedy of the American South. Baton Rouge Baton Rouge (băt`ən rzh) [Fr.,=red stick], city (1990 pop. 219,531), state capital and seat of East Baton Rouge parish, SE La. : Louisiana State UP, 1969.
Dawahare, Anthony. Nationalism, Marxism, and African American Literature African American literature is the body of literature produced in the United States by writers of African descent. The genre traces its origins to the works of such late 18th century writers as Phillis Wheatley and Olaudah Equiano, reached early high points with slave narratives between the Wars: A New Pandora's Box Pandora’s box
contained all evils; opened up, evils escape to afflict world. [Rom. Myth.: Brewer Dictionary, 799]
See : Evil . Jackson: UP of Mississippi, 2003.
Derber, Charles. What's Left? Radical Politics in the Postcommunist Era. Amherst: U of Massachusetts P, 1995.
Du Bois, W. E. B. "As the Crow Flies." Crisis 39 (1932): 310.
--. "Baltimore." Crisis 1 (1910): 11.
--. "Blunders." Crisis 39 (1932): 58.
--. "Business and Philanthropy." Crisis 2 (1911): 64-65.
--. "The colored voters of St. Louis...." Crisis 6 (1913): 11.
--. "Co-Operation." Crisis 14 (1917): 166.
--. "Criteria for Negro Art." Crisis 32 (1926): 296.
--. Darkwater: Voices from Within the Veil. 1920. New York: Schocken, 1969.
--. "Economic." Crisis I (1910): 9.
--. Economic Co-operation among Negro Americans. Atlanta: Atlanta UP, 1907.
--. "Economics." Crisis 4 (1912): 163.
--. "Forward Backward." Crisis 2 (1911): 244.
--. "Germany." Crisis 30 (1925): 62.
--. John Brown. Ed. John David Smith John David Smith (October 1786 – March 1849) was a businessman and political figure in Upper Canada.
He was born in New York City in 1786, the son of Elias Smith, a United Empire Loyalist. He came to the site of what is now Port Hope with his family in 1797. . 1909. Armonk, NY: M. E. Sharp, 1997.
--. "The Last Word in Politics." Crisis 5 (1912): 29.
--. Letter to Helen "To Helen" is the first of two poems to carry that name written by Edgar Allan Poe. The 15-line poem was written in honor of Jane Stanard, the mother of a childhood friend. It was first published in 1831 collection Poems of Edgar A. Tufts Bailey. 15 June 1928. Papers of W. E. B. Du Bois, microfilm edition. Reel 24, frame 1120.
--. Letter to Mary White Ovington. 21 Mar. 1938. Papers of W. E. B. Du Bois, microfilm edition. Reel 49, frame 385.
--. Letter to C. C. Owens. 17 April 1908. Papers of W E. B. Du Bois, microfilm edition. Reel 2, frame 1119.
--. Letter to Isaac Rubinow. 17 Nov. 1904. Papers of W. E. B. Du Bois, microfilm edition. Reel 2, frame 1300.
--. "Mr. Hughes." Crisis 13 (1916): 12.
--. The Negro. 1915. Philadelphia: U of Pennsylvania P, 2001.
--. "The Negro and Communism." Crisis 38 (1931): 313.
--. "The Negro and Social Reconstruction." Ts. Papers of W. E. B. Du Bois, microfilm edition. Reel
86, frames 800-850.
--. "The Oath of the Negro Voter." Crisis 15 (1917): 1.
--. "Occupations." Crisis 14 (1917): 166.
--. "Organized Labor." Crisis 4 (1912): 131.
--. "Peace." Crisis 6 (1913): 26.
--. "The Presidential Campaign." Crisis 12 (1916): 268.
--. The Quest of the Silver Fleece. 1911. Miami: Mnemosyme, 1969.
--. "The Races Congress." Crisis 2 (1911): 200-09.
--. "Remember." Crisis 19 (1920): 297.
--. "Russia and America: An Interpretation." Ts. Papers of W. E. B. Du Bois, microfilm edition. Reel 85, frames 395-561.
--. "Segregation-A Symposium." Crisis 45 (1934): 79-80.
--. "Socialism and the Negro Problem." New Review 1 (1913): 38-41.
--. "Socialists and Communists Bid for the Negro Vote." Crisis 39 (1932): 279-80+.
--. Some Efforts of American Negroes for Their Own Social Betterment. Atlanta: Atlanta UP, 1898.
--. "Toward a New Racial Philosophy." Crisis 40 (1933): 45.
--. Writings in Periodicals Edited by W. E. B. Du Bois: Selections from The Horizon. Ed. Herbert Aptheker Herbert Aptheker (July 31, 1915 - March 17, 2003) was an internationally known American Marxist historian and political activist. He authored over 50 volumes, mostly in the fields of African American history and general U.S. . White Plains, NY: Kraus Thomson, 1985.
Foley, Barbara. Radical Representations: Politics and Form in U.S. Proletarian Fiction, 1929-1941. Durham: Duke UP, 1993.
Foner, Philip S. American Socialism and Black Americans: From the Age of Jackson to World War II. Contributions in Afro-American and African Studies African studies (also known as Africana studies) is the study of Africa, and can encompass such fields as social and economic development, politics, history, culture, sociology, anthropology or linguistics. A specialist in African studies is referred to as an Africanist. 33. Westport, CT: Greenwood P, 1977.
Giddens, Anthony. The Third Way and its Critics. Cambridge, UK: Polity, 2000. --, ed. The Global Third Way Debate. Cambridge, UK: Polity, 2001.
Goodman, James. Stories of Scottsboro. New York: Pantheon, 1994.
Goodwyn, Lawrence. Democratic Promise: The Populist Moment in America. New York: Oxford UP, 1976.
Gramsci, Antonio Gramsci, Antonio (antôn`yô gräm`shē), 1891–1937, Italian political leader and theoretician. Originally a member of the Socialist party and a cofounder (1919) of the left-wing paper L'Ordine Nuovo, . Selections from the Prison Notebooks. Trans. Quintin Hoare and Geoffrey Nowell Smith. New York: International, 1971.
hooks, bell. Where We Stand: Class Matters. New York: Routledge, 2000.
James, Joy. Transcending the Talented Tenth: Black Leaders and American Intellectuals. New York: Routledge, 1997.
Kazin, Michael. The Populist Persuasion: An American History. New York: Basic Books, 1995.
Lee, Maurice. "Du Bois the Novelist: White Influence, Black Spirit, and The Quest of the Silver Fleece." African American Review The African American Review is a quarterly journal and the official publication of the Division on Black American Literature and Culture of the Modern Language Association. 33 (1999): 389-400.
Lewis, David Lewis, David (Kellogg)
(born Sept. 28, 1941, Oberlin, Ohio, U.S.—died Oct. 14, 2001, Princeton, N.J.) U.S. philosopher. He taught at the University of California at Los Angeles from 1966 to 1970 and thereafter at Princeton University. Levering. W. E. B. Du Bois: Biography of a Race, 1868-1919. New York: Holt, 1993.
--. W. E. B. Du Bois: The Fight for Equality and the American Century This article is about the term used for American power in the 20th century. For the investment company, see American Century Investments.
"American Century" is a term coined by Time , 1919-1963. New York: Holt, 2000.
Marable, Manning. W. E. B. Du Bois: Black Radical Democrat. Boston: Twayne, 1986.
Maxwell, William Maxwell, William
(born Aug. 16, 1908, Lincoln, Ill., U.S.—died July 31, 2000, New York, N.Y.) American editor and author. Maxwell taught English at the University of Illinois before joining the staff of The New Yorker magazine. J. New Negro, Old Left: African-American Writing and Communism Between the Wars. New York: Columbia UP, 1999.
McKay, Claude. "Soviet Russia." Crisis 27.2 (Dec. 1923): 64-65. --. "Soviet Russia and the Negro (Concluded)." Crisis 27.3 (Jan. 1924): 114-18.
Mills, Charles W. From Class to Race: Essays in White Marxism and Black Radicalism. Lanham, MD: Rowan & Littlefield, 2003.
Moses, Wilson Jeremiah. The Golden Age of Black Nationalism, 1850-1925. Hamden, CT: Archon Books, 1978.
"Negro Editors on Communism: A Symposium of the American Negro Press." Crisis 39.4 (Apr. 1932): 117.
"Negro Editors on Communism: A Symposium of the American Negro Press." Crisis 39.5 (May 1932): 156.
Ovington, Mary White Ovington, Mary White (1865–1951) civil rights reformer; born in Brooklyn, N.Y. Her Unitarian upbringing and attendance at the Harvard Annex (later Radcliffe College) (1888–91) inspired her to devote herself to social reforms. . Letter to W. E. B. Du Bois. 11 Mar. 1938. Papers of W. E. B. Du Bois, microfilm edition. Reel 49, frame 386.
Rampersad, Arnold. The Art and Imagination of W. E. B. Du Bois. Cambridge: Harvard UP, 1976.
Reed, Adolph L. W. E. B. Du Bois and American Political Thought: Fabianism and the Color Line. New York: Oxford UP, 1997.
Richards, Paul. "W. E. B. Du Bois and American Social History: The Evolution of a Marxist." Radical America 4.4 (Nov. 1970): 37-65.
Robinson, Cedric J. Black Marxism: The Making of the Black Radical Tradition. London: Zed, 1983.
Roediger, David. The Wages of Whiteness. London: Verso ver·so
n. pl. ver·sos
1. A left-hand page of a book or the reverse side of a leaf, as opposed to the recto.
2. The back of a coin or medal. , 1996.
Singh, Nikhil Pal. Black Is a Country: Race and the Unfinished Struggle for Democracy. Cambridge: Harvard UP, 2004.
Wald, Alan M. Writing from the Left: New Essays on Radical Culture and Politics. New York: Verso, 1994.
Weinbaum, Alys Eve. Wayward Reproductions: Genealogies of Race and Nation in Transatlantic Modem Thought. Durham: Duke UP, 2004.
Weinstein, James. The Long Detour: The History and Future of the American Left. Boulder, CO: Westview, 2003.
(1.) Singh refers principally to "Du Bois's writings from the 1930s" as the "worldly and radical vision that would remain stubbornly central to the long civil rights era" (214). James sees a radicalized Du Bois as being clearly established only in his 1940 autobiography, Dusk of Dawn (22-23), while a somewhat earlier interpreter, Cedric Robinson, finds that Du Bois "had at last come to the Black radical tradition" with the publication of his 1935 monograph Black Reconstruction in America (322). Among the major critics of Du Bois, the one closest to our account of Du Bois's socialism, and one of the few who considers the Quest of the Silver Fleece in any depth, is Rampersad.
(2.) Here we dispute Reed's contention that the differences between the varieties of collectivism are of less importance than the collectivist themes uniting "socialism, progressivism, managerialism In the field of administration, observers can characterise as managerialism those systems where they perceive a preponderance or excess of managerial techniques, solutions and personnel. , and social engineering in general" (19), while at the same time asserting that Du Bois definitely allied himself with the more egalitarian and anticapitalist versions of socialism.
(3.) Barkin recounts that Du Bois learned socialism not only from his contact with German Social Democratic politics but also from his principal Berlin University professors, who preached state socialism.
(4.) See not only Reed 83 but Rampersad 158, Moses 139-40, and Marable 89-90.
(5.) Neither in Zora's speech nor in Du Bois's writing of this period are the concepts considered with a high degree of sophistication so·phis·ti·cate
v. so·phis·ti·cat·ed, so·phis·ti·cat·ing, so·phis·ti·cates
1. To cause to become less natural, especially to make less naive and more worldly.
2. . But the key point here is Du Bois's conversance with socialist ideas. Rampersad is virtually alone in noting Du Bois's socialist mindset mind·set or mind-set
1. A fixed mental attitude or disposition that predetermines a person's responses to and interpretations of situations.
2. An inclination or a habit. at this relatively early moment in his career, quoting Zora's quip quip
1. A clever, witty remark often prompted by the occasion.
2. A clever, often sarcastic remark; a gibe. See Synonyms at joke.
3. A petty distinction or objection; a quibble.
4. that "You don't own what you don't need and can't use" as a "rephrasing re·phrase
tr.v. re·phrased, re·phras·ing, re·phras·es
To phrase again, especially to state in a new, clearer, or different way.
Noun 1. " of "a key Marxist slogan" (122). Zora's speech does indeed reflect some acquaintance with Marx's analysis of exchange, labor value, and use value. Her particular stress upon the claim posed by need reveals, at the same time, the influence of another socialist tradition, specifically American. While Marx's emphasis is on the right of the proletariat to the full product of its labor, American socialists including Edward Bellamy placed special emphasis upon need as the only humane principle of distribution (Bellamy 87, 110-12). Thus Zora's discussion of property reveals Du Bois's familiarity not only with Marxism but also with varieties of socialism outside of Marxism, even a wish to harmonize terms that receive quite different emphases in different socialist theoretical traditions.
(6.) It must also be noted, however, that the Second Internationale Socialist party was far more progressive on the question of race than is usually supposed. As Foner abundantly documents, "few issues were more widely discussed in the party press than the Negro question, and ... significant forces in the Socialist party fought racism in the party's ranks, took an advanced position on the Negro question, and did not confine themselves to parroting the usual line" (xiii).
(7.) Maurice Lee's insightful reading of Quest is one of the few to take seriously Du Bois's first novel as artistic accomplishment and social statement. To his interpretation, we would add fuller content to the "alternative, liminal liminal /lim·i·nal/ (lim´i-n'l) barely perceptible; pertaining to a threshold.
Relating to a threshold.
barely perceptible; pertaining to a threshold. voice" that the novel speaks. The "nation in the swamp ... a political, material body founded on higher principles," as Lee calls it, has a name and a definite history in American political economy: Socialism. Another of the novel's careful readers, Arnold Rampersad, names Du Bois's socialism repeatedly. With his analysis, our main difference is one of emphasis, for he asserts that the novel's "themes and ideas," including socialism, are "secondary" to his dramatization dram·a·ti·za·tion
1. The act or art of dramatizing: the dramatization of a novel.
2. A work adapted for dramatic presentation: of "the moral and political consequences of the black situation in America" (132), whereas we would maintain that socialist analysis and ideals are inseparable from the moral and political vision of the novel.
(8.) The Populist movement was widespread and popular enough to threaten seriously the hegemony of the two established parties. Having carried five states for their 1892 presidential nominee and seated multiple governors, US representatives, and senators in the next two years (Kazin 42), the People's party was impressive enough to invite cooptations, with Democrat William Jennings Bryan adopting the Populist platform of "free silver" in 1896 (Goodwyn 523-25).
(9.) The New Review was published beginning in January 1913 by William English Walling, with financial support from Mabel Dodge (Marable 84).
(10.) The elitism e·lit·ism or é·lit·ism
1. The belief that certain persons or members of certain classes or groups deserve favored treatment by virtue of their perceived superiority, as in intellect, social status, or financial resources. Reed describes in his chapter on The Philadelphia Negro, 27-41, is formidable indeed. Moreover, Reed is no doubt correct that Du Bois never abandoned his view of a hierarchy of talent to any extent amounting to absolute democratic egalitarianism. But Reed's assertion that Du Bois recommends the "stewardship" of "intellectuals" loses much of its elitist e·lit·ism or é·lit·ism
1. The belief that certain persons or members of certain classes or groups deserve favored treatment by virtue of their perceived superiority, as in intellect, social status, or financial resources. edge when one considers Du Bois's pronouncements, elsewhere, that black leaders were likely to be of working-class origin. One might as well charge Antonio Gramsci's conception of the "organic intellectual" as being elitist because such a leader might, in his or her present occupation, be an intellectual worker instead of a manual laborer (Gramsci 6).
(11.) Richards takes some pains to argue that Du Bois's socialist critique of imperialism was embryonic in the 1910s whereas Lenin's was fully fledged, yet he acknowledges that "The Negro ... anticipated a view of the labor aristocracy and its relationship to world imperialism which Lenin wrote about at about the same time" (54).
(12.) To gauge the development of Du Bois's socialism, we might consider the parallels between Du Bois's views and those of Cyril Briggs of the African Blood Brotherhood The African Blood Brotherhood (ABB) was a radical U.S. black liberation organization of the early 20th century that developed ties to the Communist Party. The group was a propaganda organization built on the model of the secret fraternity, organized in "posts" with a at about this juncture. When founded in secret in 1917, the Brotherhood called for many of the same reforms as did Du Bois. Full voting rights for blacks, guarantees of legal equality regardless of race, and union recognition of black workers-all planks in the Brotherhood's charter (Foner 309)--were also lobbied for by Du Bois in the Crisis. Another plank, "armed resistance to lynching" (309), was anticipated in Quest of the Silver Fleece, but could not readily be advocated publicly by Du Bois (nor could it be by the secret society of the Brotherhood). Only perhaps Briggs's call for "self-determination for Negroes in states where they constituted a majority" (310) definitely preceded Du Bois's call, in the 1930s, for black self-segregation, although, as we have seen, the concept was developed in a more modest and practical form in Quest.
(13.) Among the true believers--at least initially--was Claude McKay, whose account of his trip appeared in two separate feature articles in the 1923 and '24 Crisis ("Soviet Russia" and "Soviet Russia and the Negro").
(14.) Writing in the 1980s, Cedric Robinson makes clear his own approval of violent resistance to colonialism, and he indicates clearly Du Bois's tolerance for righteous violence whether on a small scale (the mutiny of a score of black soldiers stationed in Texas during World War I) or a large one (the participation of black soldiers in the Civil War) (324, 320). But Singh, the most penetrating of the recent critics on Du Bois, treats the political strategy of the Communist party in the 1930s as a Gramscian "war of position" in which the main stakes sought (and lost) were "an independent working-class politics (that is, a Labor Party)" and "public recognition of class division as an enduringly recalcitrant problem of social order and political rule" (84-85). We are more in sympathy with Singh's position than Robinson's, although we find his description of Communist party politics to be less an accurate account of the party's actual 1930s strategy than of Du Bois's social democratic politics.
(15.) Besides the several studies we have mentioned that regard Du Bois's socialist theorizing favorably partly because of Communist antiracism, there have been a number of outstanding recent studies of the Communist left and black American writers in the 1920s and '30s: Maxwell and Dawahare. Foley also includes substantial consideration of black Communists and Communist antiracism.
(16.) For an idea of this progression in Du Bois's editorship in the final three years of his tenure, see the following: "Negro Editors on Communism" (both symposia under this title); Du Bois, "Toward a New Racial Philosophy"; and Du Bois, "Segregation."
(17.) The ideas should not, we would caution, be treated as coterminous co·ter·mi·nous
Variant of conterminous.
Adj. 1. coterminous - being of equal extent or scope or duration
coextensive, conterminous , any more than Du Bois's perspective should be thought of as derivative. Singh's account usefully distinguishes between Stalin's conception of the black nation as having specific geographic boundaries and Du Bois's conception of it as a matter of "communication and communal regulation" throughout segregated black America (51).
(18.) On this point, the NAACP officials were probably correct. As Carter argues, the actions of the Communist party almost certainly hardened the authorities of the state of Alabama in their resolve not to free the "Scottsboro boys" even when their innocence was proven (135-36, 332).
(19.) Our application of this tenet to contemporary society essentially seconds an analysis made elsewhere by African American theorists. See James; also bell hooks, who in Class Matters asserts that "Progressive black 'elites' must humanely confront and challenge conservative peers. It is our task to forge a vision of solidarity in ending domination, which includes anti-racist struggle that realistically confronts class difference and constructively intervenes on the growing class antagonism between black folks with class privilege and the black masses who are daily being stripped of their power" (99-100).
(20.) Not only in Black Studies, but in the historiography, political economics, and theory of social democratic movements, the centrality of race as a socioeconomic category is being widely acknowledged. To cite a few instances: Roediger's Wages of Whiteness; Mills's From Class to Race; Part IV of Wald's Writing from the Left,, Weinstein's chapter entitled "Thigh Bone Connected to the Hip Bone: The Women's Movement, Civil Rights, and the War Machine"; Derber's chapter entitled "Reframing reframing (rē·frāˑ·ming),
n the revisiting and reconstruction of a patient's view of an experience to imbue it with a different usually more positive meaning in the Revolution: The Rebirth of the Latin American Left"; and Giddens's two books on "The Global Third Way."
Mark Van Wienen is Associate Professor of English at Northern Illinois University . His books are Partisans and Poets: The Political Work of American Poetry in the Great War (1997) and Rendezvous with Death: American Poems of the Great War (2002). He is currently at work on a study of socialism in American literature, focusing on W. E. B. Du Bois, Upton Sinclair, and Charlotte Perkins Gilman Charlotte Perkins Gilman (July 3 1860 – August 17 1935) was a prominent American poet, non-fiction writer, short story writer, novelist, lecturer, and social reformer. .
Julie Kraft is a doctoral student in Victorian Literature at Indiana University in Bloomington. This is her first publication.