Printer Friendly
The Free Library
14,701,771 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

How To Select A RAID Disk Array.


A PRIMER FOR VARS VARS Value Added Reseller
VARS Vehicle Accounting and Reporting System (US Immigration and Naturalization Service)
VARS Vertical and Azimuth Reference System
VARS Variant Stem
VARS Variables
 TO SHOW CLIENTS

Like any of today's high Today's High

The intra-day high trading price.

Notes:
In other words, this is the highest price that a stock traded at during the course of the day. More often than not this is higher than the closing price.
See also: Today's Low
 technology products, where the technology has evolved rapidly, it is easy to find the new topic confusing. However selecting a RAID disk array is much like choosing any other product. You just need to ask the right questions so you can sort out, from the plethora of products, those few that best suit your needs.

Determine Your Needs

Shopping for a RAID disk array can be simple once you know what you really need and understand what the technology actually can offer you. Simply, RAID disk arrays provide data storage, but with a higher degree of operational availability and performance depending upon the feature set available from various vendors. All RAID disk arrays will provide you with some level of storage, reliability, performance, and service for different prices. Your job is to determine which is the best fit for you.

Storage

All RAID disk arrays provide storage, but so does "just a bunch of disks See JBOD.

(jargon, storage) Just a Bunch Of Disks - (JBOD, or "Just a Bunch of Drives") A storage subsystems using multiple independent disk drives, as opposed to one form of RAID or another.
." Clearly, anyone can pile boxes on boxes to meet your total storage requirements. However, how well does the storage scale from single units to racks of storage? Do all the disks use a limited number of host interfaces? Do all the disks use a very small number of controllers? These are sources of potential data bottlenecks. Does the vendor offer a rack cabinet? Who provides uninterruptible power supplies See UPS.

(hardware) Uninterruptible Power Supply - (UPS) A battery powered power supply unit that is guaranteed to provide power to a computer in the event of interruptions in the incoming mains electrical power.
 and are they adequate? Does the system require software drivers that must be updated constantly or is the product a truly plug-and-play "open system"? Is the product scalable as your needs grow? Can it be moved to another platform and operating system operating system (OS)

Software that controls the operation of a computer, directs the input and output of data, keeps track of files, and controls the processing of computer programs.
 easily and without added expense?

RAID Reliability

Most vendors will provide you with an implementation of RAID where one extra disk is used for parity information to recreate lost data in the event of a single disk failure. You should avoid any vendor that does not meet even this minimum criterion. Given that most vendors will offer similar capabilities on this most basic issue, you should ask more detailed questions: How long does the controller take to rebuild the data? Does the controller permit an automatic "hot-spare" replacement? How easy is it to monitor and control the status of the array? Do you need to be at the system to monitor and control it or can you operate remotely? How?

RAID Levels

Much has been written on the various RAID "levels" and, in short, the word levels is a misnomer misnomer n. the wrong name.


MISNOMER. The act of using a wrong name.
     2. Misnomers, may be considered with regard to contracts, to devises and bequests, and to suits or actions.
     3.-1.
 and should be understood as merely RAID "modes." Each RAID mode is just a different, yet not necessarily better, means of operation.

RAID 1 offers complete duplication of data and this 100% data redundancy Writing data to two or more locations for backup and data recovery. For example, data can be stored on two or more disks or disk and tape or disk and the Internet. See disk redundancy and data recovery.  provides the best protection, but it is much too expensive for most applications. RAID 3 and RAID 5 each use one extra disk to store parity information needed to recreate data in the event of a single disk failure. RAID 3 uses a dedicated parity disk and is typically faster for throughput-oriented applications such as file transfer and other sequential applications. RAID 5 distributes the parity information across all disks in the array and is typically faster for transaction processing Updating the appropriate database records as soon as a transaction (order, payment, etc.) is entered into the computer. It may also imply that confirmations are sent at the same time.

Transaction processing systems are the backbone of an organization because they update constantly.
 and other random access applications. These results are relevant mostly in arrays that have little or no controller cache memory. In products with significant cache memory (64MB or more) on-board the controller, performance will be higher in all cases due to the distinctly higher abilities of the controller and will perform in a vastly superior manner regardless of RAID mode.

You should insist that your RAID vendor support standard RAID levels

Main article: RAID


The standard RAID levels are a basic set of RAID configurations and employ striping, mirroring, or parity. The standard RAID levels can be nested for other benefits (see Nested RAID levels).
, including 1, 3, and 5, as defined in the original University of California The University of California has a combined student body of more than 191,000 students, over 1,340,000 living alumni, and a combined systemwide and campus endowment of just over $7.3 billion (8th largest in the United States).  Berkeley RAID project. Only RAID 0-6 appear in that definition and RAID 2, 4, and 6 are rarely seen in commercial products. RAID 0 is merely disk striping The spreading of data over multiple disk drives to improve performance. Data are interleaved by bytes or blocks of bytes across the drives. For example, with four drives and a RAID controller that simultaneous reads and writes all drives, four times as much data is read or written in the , which has some performance advantages, but stores no parity Not using a parity bit to check for errors. For example, an 8-N-1 setting in a communications program, which was widely used before the Web, means each character transmitted contains (8) eight bits, (N) "no" ninth parity bit and (1) one additional stop bit to mark the end. See non-parity memory.  information and, thus, does not offer true RAID data protection. If the vendor has created additional RAID levels that are non-standard, e.g., outside the range of RAID 0-6, be wary that you are not buying into a proprietary architecture. However, certain RAID levels are merely combinations of two other RAID levels such as RAID 1+0 (also called RAID 10) where multiple RAID 1 pairs are striped for faster access or RAID 15 where two RAID 5 arrays are mirrored for added reliability. These combinations offer advantages over single RAID modes and are perfectly acceptable.

Hardware Fault Tolerance The introduction to this article provides insufficient context for those unfamiliar with the subject matter.
Please help [ improve the introduction] to meet Wikipedia's layout standards. You can discuss the issue on the talk page.
 

While all RAID vendors provide RAID in some form, vendors vary greatly in the degree of fault tolerance See fault tolerant.

(architecture) fault tolerance - 1. The ability of a system or component to continue normal operation despite the presence of hardware or software faults. This often involves some degree of redundancy.

2.
 they provide. To maximize system availability, you need redundancy in other system components that are most likely to fail, including power supplies and fans. Disk controllers, unlike all the other mechanical components, are completely electronic and, thus, are the most reliable components. You can optionally look for redundancy here too. These components, to the extent possible, should be "hot-swap" so that they can be replaced while the system is running, further increasing total system availability. You should also make sure that each individual enclosure has two AC power cords. You should install one into a dedicated uninterruptible power supply and one into a room outlet, preferably a protected outlet or second uninterruptible power supply. Any RAID disk array with cache memory on the RAID controller A disk controller card that supports one or more RAID configurations. Originally only for SCSI drives, RAID controllers have become very popular for PATA and SATA drives. See RAID.  should also have a battery backup See UPS.  module for added protection.

Quality Construction

This is an often-overlooked parameter in today's world of sleek-looking enclosure design. Don't be fooled by smooth rounded corners of plastic disk enclosures A disk enclosure is essentially a specialized chassis designed to hold and power disk drives while providing a mechanism to allow them to communicate to one or more separate computers. . Only all-metal disk carriers offer the thermal conductivity needed for proper heat dissipation Noun 1. heat dissipation - dissipation of heat
chilling, cooling, temperature reduction - the process of becoming cooler; a falling temperature
 for today's high speed, higher capacity disk drives that often run hot and require proper operating environments. Proper cooling is critical to achieve long and reliable disk drive life and metal carriers simply do this better. Metal carriers also shield the disk drives' high-speed signals from stray RFI (Radio Frequency Interference) High-frequency electromagnetic waves that emanate from electronic devices such as chips.

RFI - Radio Frequency Interference
 (Radio Frequency Interference See RFI.

(hardware, testing) Radio Frequency Interference - (RFI) Electromagnetic radiation which is emitted by electrical circuits carrying rapidly changing signals, as a by-product of their normal operation, and which causes unwanted signals (interference or noise) to be
) that may occur in an office or computer room environment. For 18GB drives and highspeed 10,000rpm drives, it is also important to minimize drive vibration to avoid excessive disk errors and time-consuming retries re·tries  
v.
Third person singular present tense of retry.
. A quality vendor will have a new drive mounting scheme to ensure reliable operation of 18GB and 10,000rpm disk drives and not just put these more sensitive drives into the same old plastic disk carriers that handled th eir 1GB, 2GB, 4GB, and 9GB drives.

Performance

This is a critical parameter for every server. After you spend all your money on a RAID disk array, is it going to give you the performance you need? Today, at competitive prices, you can get over 9,000 disk read/write operations per second for transaction-oriented applications and up to 35MB/sec actual sustained throughput for data transfer operations. If a vendor is not providing anything near these specs (SPECificationS) The details of the components built into a device. See specification. , all your applications will run needlessly slow. Today, computers process data in near zero time, thus the speed of all server applications run in proportion to the speed of the slowest device, which is the mechanical disk drive. Ask vendors for the performance specs of their RAID disk arrays and compare. Do not accept generalizations. If they are clueless clue·less  
adj.
Lacking understanding or knowledge.


clueless
Adjective

Slang helpless or stupid

Adj. 1.
 or do not publish their specs you can be assured that they do not measure up.

Service

Can your people service the unit or must you rely only on outside service providers? How easy is it to replace disk drives, power supplies, fans, and controllers? Can any moderately skilled technician perform these component replacements? How quickly can the components be replaced? Are they "hot-swap" replacements--can they be done while the system is still delivering data to users who are unaware of the problem? Does the vendor have on-site service available? Do they have an 800 hotline staffed by people who actually know the equipment? Is the service available on a 24x7 hour basis? Can you or a highly trained factory engineer dial in to your system from a remote site? Can your system automatically alert you via pager in the event of a warning or error condition?

Company

The company you select is as important as the product. Is the company merely a distributor of the product who may not know much about it or is it factory direct from the people who know the equipment? Are you considering buying the storage from the server manufacturer because it is most convenient or are you truly looking at your needs and choosing the right RAID disk array? Is the vendor completely committed to RAID disk array technology or do they have many other products or even thousands of other products that dilute their interest and expertise? Is it important to you to have the comfort that comes with a name brand ("no one ever got fired for buying IBM (International Business Machines Corporation, Armonk, NY, www.ibm.com) The world's largest computer company. IBM's product lines include the S/390 mainframes (zSeries), AS/400 midrange business systems (iSeries), RS/6000 workstations and servers (pSeries), Intel-based servers (xSeries) ") or do you just want the best product for your needs from a company that can stand behind the product? How long has the company been in the business? Do they enable you to be self-sufficient in a crisis or completely dependent? Do they use industry standard components? Do they offer systems designed to "open systems standards or have they managed to inc lude lude
n.
A pill or tablet that contains the drug methaqualone.
 proprietary compnents that lock you in to their architecture? Do they use the industry's best disk drives or less expensive models with correspondingly lower quality and reliability? Is the price fair, compared to other vendor's offerings, or is it too high or too low? Do the company's representatives in sales, sales support, and technical support seem to have the expertise needed to support the product? Do they exhibit genuine interest in providing solutions to your needs? Are they enthusiastic about their products and committed to showing you how much they can be of service or is their zeal devoted to separating you from your budget as quickly and efficiently as possible?

References

You should ask the company for references from other happy customers. Ask their customers how well they were treated before the sale and after the sale. Did the company meet its promises? Did the product live up to its claims? Did the performance reliability, and service get delivered? How smoothly did the installation process go? You can be sure that a company will treat you much the same as it treated others. Ask the people if they are happy with their purchase and if they would buy from the company again.

Guarantees

When comparing systems, vendors who are willing to guarantee performance in writing are more credible. If a vendor claims to offer a high performance system that runs fast, see if they will back up their claim. A vendor that believes their claim will gladly guarantee you the results that you are looking for Looking for

In the context of general equities, this describing a buy interest in which a dealer is asked to offer stock, often involving a capital commitment. Antithesis of in touch with.
 because they have the confidence, based upon prior experience with other customers, that you will get the performance you are paying for or they will let you return the system. Try to be as specific as possible with respect to your most important application.

Challenge the vendor to cut your month-end report times by 33% or serve twice as many web pages from your server or cut lengthy database inquiries from five seconds to two seconds. That way, you can test the RAID disk array immediately upon receipt and know right away if you received the advertised benefit. It also builds a case to justify the investment to management in the first place and communicates clearly to the vendor what you expect in return for your hard-earned cash. It also filters out vendors who know they can't really do it. All these are positive results. that come from being specific and getting a guarantee. You simplify the purchasing process Purchasing Purchasing is the formal process of buying goods and services.

The Purchasing Process can vary from one organization to another but there are some key elements that are common throughout

The process usually starts with a 'Demand' or requirements
, the management justification process, and increase your odds of success while minimizing risk and conserving your valuable time.

Checklist For installing RAID Without Any Worry: Prepare For Success

Successful installation is no accident. It happens by choosing the best equipment for the job and by preparing for successful installation, operation, and maintenance. "Plug and play" sometimes means plug it in and it immediately plays and sometimes means plug it in and play and play until it works. The truth is, as always, somewhere in between. By reviewing the following checklist, you can be assured that you have done as much as you can to ensure the success of your server storage installation.

Pre-Installation Checklist

* Configuration. Choose the configuration that meets your performance, storage, availability, and serviceability (system) serviceability - The ease with which corrective maintenance or preventative maintenance can be performed on a system (e.g. by a hardware service technician). Higher serviceability improves availability and reduces service cost.

Serviceability is one component of RAS.
 needs by consulting with your sales engineer. Stick with standard configurations for best price/performance and ease of serviceability unless your requirements dictate otherwise. Ask the difficult questions before buying anything. The higher the availability requirements, the more redundancy and component removability you require. Consider redundancy for disk channels, host buses, interface cards, and even servers in addition to the disk drives and internal disk array components.

* Backup. Ensure that your backup device See backup storage.  and procedure are adequate to handle the increased storage in the time available.

* Power. Ensure clean power and UPS protection. Add cache battery backup option for added data protection.

* Interference. Check for sources of electromagnetic interference See EMI.  such as banks of modems on web servers.

* Load. Is the system totally loaded already? Will the addition of one more device, especially a high performance RAID array, push the load limit over the edge?

* SCSI Interface SCSI interface - SCSI adaptor . Is the interface fast enough to avoid bottlenecking the new high performance equipment?

* Service. Decide who is going to perform remedial service. Do you need 24x7 service availability? On-site third party service? Will you train your people?

* Key phone numbers. Post 800 Hotline numbers in conspicuous places. Post beeper beeper - pager  number and, perhaps, home phone numbers of key internal personnel. Prepare pocket summaries with this information for key people to keep handy.

* Spare parts Spare parts, also referred to as Service Parts is a term used to indicate extra parts available and in proximity to the mechanical item, such as a automobile, boat, engine, for which they might be used.

Spare parts are also called “spares.
. Are advance replacement parts supplied overnight sufficient or do you need on-site spare parts?

* Remote alarms. Would you benefit if your system were programmed to "cry for help" by automatically dialing designated pagers with an optional alarm?

* Remote diagnostics Vehicle Diagnostics
Vehicle diagnostics enables a mechanic to diagnose the exact mechanical condition of the vehicle and its systems and components. Remote Diagnostics enables to perform such diagnosis without requiring the vehicle to physically be present for checkup.
. With an optional modem, you can enable your system to receive remote diagnostic calls. Temporary system passwords can be provided for use only when the Service is needed.

* Performance benchmark. Naturally, you will be curious to test how much faster everything runs with new high performance storage. Time your longest batch jobs and measure client response to lengthy transactions before and after installation. Call us with the benchmark information to see if you are getting the performance you paid for--or simply to share the excitement of any productivity increase you receive.

* Capacity assessment. Based upon performance benchmarks, you can make a reasonable estimate of how many users you can support on the existing server before you need to add another one.

During Installation

* Schedule downtime. Make sure that there will be time enough to properly install the system. Allow plenty of time and anticipate that it will take longer than expected--Murphy is ever present.

* Test period. The more critical the application, the longer the shake out period should be. Several days to several weeks of running diagnostics, exercisers, and representative applications is a reasonable precaution to take before committing your entire enterprise to a new piece of equipment--including RAID arrays.

* Training. Make sure one or, preferably, two or more people are trained on the system. Training includes setting up RAID arrays, swapping components, rebuilding arrays, simulating failures, and, most importantly Adv. 1. most importantly - above and beyond all other consideration; "above all, you must be independent"
above all, most especially
, practicing what to do in the event of actual failures.

After Installation

* Data protection. RAID is not different than any other storage device when it comes to protection from viruses and accidental or deliberate deletions. Implement the same file protection and record locking See file and record locking.  strategies you would use on a non-RAID system.

* Data recovery. Database and transaction processing systems A Transaction Processing System (TPS) is a type of information system. TPSs collect, store, modify, and retrieve the transactions of an organization. A transaction is an event that generates or modifies data that is eventually stored in an information system.  are often implemented on RAID systems. If yesterday's backup is too old to be a useful data recovery system, make sure you have the ability to roll the database forward in time with journal files or similar capabilities. Store journal files on a separate physical device from your primary database. No system is perfect, not even RAID systems. You still need to protect your data as you would with any storage device.

* Data backup. Typically, RAID systems significantly increase your total storage capacity. Make sure you do a complete backup frequently and incremental backups at least daily. Test data restoration periodically to ensure that you remember how to do it and to ensure proper operation of the tape system.

* Data security. Make extra backups and keep copies off site.

* Upgrades. Certainly, there are other improvements on your agenda. You should implement one major change at a time so that problems are easy to identify and correct if you are upgrading an existing server. You wouldn't want to upgrade the operating system and the application while also installing new storage and backup. If you need to make all these changes and want to avoid sequential disruptions, build an entire new server and then test it intensively before deploying. Keep the old server as a backup until the new one is proven.

* Communication. Stay in touch with your service provider. The person will be familiar with your installation and your capabilities when you need help and will be better prepared when the time comes Adv. 1. when the time comes - at the appropriate time; "we'll get to this question in due course"
in due course, in due season, in due time, in good time
.

Joel Leider is the CEO (1) (Chief Executive Officer) The highest individual in command of an organization. Typically the president of the company, the CEO reports to the Chairman of the Board.  of Winchester Systems (Woburn, MA).
COPYRIGHT 2000 West World Productions, Inc.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2000, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:LEIDER, JOEL
Publication:Computer Technology Review
Article Type:Buyers Guide
Date:Apr 1, 2000
Words:2885
Previous Article:Disk-Based Mirroring Is A Lot More Than Just Safe.(Technology Information)
Next Article:Who's First? Does It Matter?(Maxtor, Quantum, Western Digital drives)(Product Announcement)
Topics:



Related Articles
Optimizing Your RAID Array Performance.(Technology Information)
Time To Consider Fibre-To-Fibre RAID Controllers.(Industry Trend or Event)
Insuring The Reliability Of Fibre Channel RAID Storage.(Industry Trend or Event)
Optimizing RAID Controllers.(Technology Information)
XOR SUPPORT IN THE DISK DRIVES.(RAID systems, part 2)(Technology Tutorial)(Tutorial)
Fibre Channel Integrated Storage Solution for SANS Now Shipping.(IBM ProFibre Storage Array DF1100R RAID system)(Product Information)
LAND-5 Introduces Revolutionary RAID Technology.(Company Business and Marketing)(Brief Article)
Cost-optimizing RAID systems: comparing the availability, performance and cost of 36GB-drive striped parity (RAID-5) to 146GB-drive mirrored arrays.
RAIDn poised to revolutionize storage protection. (Top Technology Showcase).
The 411 on raid: when two is always better than one.(Office Technology)(Column)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles