Printer Friendly
The Free Library
14,759,108 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

Hong Kong blues.


Post-takeover, the media forecast is dark and gloomy.

"It's so gloomy," said a longtime Hong Kong Hong Kong (hŏng kŏng), Mandarin Xianggang, special administrative region of China, formerly a British crown colony (2005 est. pop. 6,899,000), land area 422 sq mi (1,092 sq km), adjacent to Guangdong prov.  media watcher. She was referring to the overcast sky and drizzling driz·zle  
v. driz·zled, driz·zling, driz·zles

v.intr.
To rain gently in fine, mistlike drops.

v.tr.
1.
 rain, seasonable Within a reasonable time; timely.

The term seasonable is usually used in connection with the performance of contractual obligations that must be completed "seasonably." The facts and circumstances of each case define a reasonable period of time.
 weather there in March.

But with less than 100 days until the British hand over Hong Kong to the Beijing government on July 1, that climate has also settled over Hong Kong's media. And the forecast suggests that the clouds won't be lifting any time soon, either. Although Beijing's designated ruler for Hong Kong, Tung Chee-Wa, has said that freedom of the press will be preserved, he seems to be thinking in terms of the mainland's definition of open dialogue.

Consider these snapshots from the March 19 issue of a leading English-language daily newspaper, the Hong Kong Standard:

* A front-page story about negotiations over whether advance units of Chinese air and ground forces will be on armed patrols - before July 1.

* Inside, on page 2, a brief story about the release of anti-Beijing protesters on bail pending their trial later this year - under Chinese rule.

* Deeper inside, a story about Tung Chee-Wa's claim that it is currently illegal for anyone to say, "Down with the Queen." Chris Patten Christopher Francis Patten, Baron Patten of Barnes, CH, PC (born 12 May 1944 in Bath, Somerset) is a prominent British Conservative politician and a Patron of the Tory Reform Group.

He was a Member of Parliament, eventually rising to a cabinet minister and party chairman.
, the colony's present governor, said Tung was misinformed.

* A short item on the last set of Hong Kong stamps featuring the image of the British queen, an event that led to lines outside of post offices, as thousands of people stood for several hours to try to buy what are soon to become collectors' items. (The Hong Kong government's Commission against Corruption is investigating charges of speculation. They were shocked - shocked! - to find collectors trying to buy the new stamps at face value so they can turn an easy profit after July, when their value is likely to skyrocket sky·rock·et  
n.
A firework that ascends high into the air where it explodes in a brilliant cascade of flares and starlike sparks.

intr. & tr.v.
.)

But the most interesting barometer of media climate was the front-page news on March 17 that Xinhua had just announced it would end its high-profile defense of Beijing policy. In the rest of the world, Xinhua is known as the official Chinese news agency. But in Hong Kong, Xinhua has also served as Beijing's diplomatic outpost, issuing Chinese visas and other official government documents. When the voice of Beijing and its official representative in the crown colony crown colony
n.
A British colony in which the government in London has some control of legislation, usually administered by an appointed governor.
 announces it will no longer speak out, there might be more there than the statement's text suggests.

One veteran Hong Kong journalist provided the interpretation: Who needs official propaganda when China no longer has any critics in the Hong Kong media? He's right. The Hong Kong media have become, to echo Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, the journalists who don't bark. One by one, the newspapers, magazines, and broadcasters have imposed self-censorship, deleting any language that could be construed as even mildly critical of any Chinese policy.

Not to worry, says another journalist, who asks that his name not be used. It's not ideological. It's not political. It's just business, he explains. News organizations have too much invested in Hong Kong to risk offending the new rulers.

Judging from the Standard's response, which is typical, the result is predictable: What do you do when Beijing suspends all travel visas from April to August for relatives and other visitors from China? Just print the official statement; don't go any further.

Need to write an editorial on politics? Criticize the British and Chris Patten, the British governor: "Patten stirs for the sake of doing....He has nothing to do." But remain eerily silent on Tung and his superiors in Beijing.

Politic's has even been largely removed from the front pages, in favor of huge play every day for stories on bookies trying to fix horse races Flat races
Argentina
  • Gran Premio Carlos Pellegrini
  • Gran Premio Estrellas
  • Gran Premio Jockey Club
  • Gran Premio Nacional (Argentine Derby)
  • Gran Premio Polla de Potrancas (Argentine 1000 Guineas)
 (shocking, shocking), a sprinkling of stories on the U.S. political fund-raising improprieties, and an endless variety of police-blotter stories.

As recently as last year, this was not the case. Independent reporters and editors at Hong Kong's news organizations wrote strong stories about China and Chinese politics, albeit sometimes in code. But the code was not too subtle, and Beijing did not need an Alan Turing (person) Alan Turing - Alan M. Turing, 1912-06-22/3? - 1954-06-07. A British mathematician, inventor of the Turing Machine. Turing also proposed the Turing test. Turing's work was fundamental in the theoretical foundations of computer science.  to translate the articles. Now even the coded stories have receded from view.

Milton Mueller, a Rutgers professor and widely respected expert on Hong Kong media regulation, is in the colony to study the changes in the media as July 1 approaches. He also has a U.S. passport and is planning to leave, so he can speak more freely than he can while in Hong Kong. "People simply are being very cautious about who they are associated with and what they say and who they say it about," said Mueller at a March conference held by the Freedom Forum, a nonpartisan international media research foundation.

Mueller cited the case of Jimmy Lai, the publisher of Next magazine and one of the best-known and most outspoken journalistic critics of Beijing policies. Lai once said he would go down fighting, as a matter of principle. Now he has reversed himself, saying it is for the good of his staff. What happened? Lai was trying to take his highly successful publishing company public on the Hong Kong stock exchange The Hong Kong Stock Exchange (Traditional Chinese: 香港交易所, also 港交所; abbreviated as HKEX; HKSE: 0388 ) is the stock exchange of Hong Kong. . And he told Lesley Stahl Lesley R. Stahl (born December 16, 1941, in Lynn, Massachusetts) is an American television journalist. As of 2007, she has reported for CBS on 60 Minutes for nearly 16 seasons.  of CBS's 60 Minutes that the day after his Hong Kong newspaper called one influential Beijing pol "a turtle's egg" (a not-too-polite way of questioning the identity of one's father), the Chinese government Ever since Republic of China founded in January 1st, 1912, China has had several regional and national governments. List
  • Chinese Soviet Republic
  • Provisional Government of the Republic of China
  • Reformed Government of the Republic of China
 confiscated con·fis·cate  
tr.v. con·fis·cat·ed, con·fis·cat·ing, con·fis·cates
1. To seize (private property) for the public treasury.

2. To seize by or as if by authority. See Synonyms at appropriate.

adj.
 Lai's businesses, scaring away his financial backers.

If there is a free news medium left in Hong Kong, it would seem to be the Internet: In January, the Hong Kong government announced it was going to back away from all of its previously announced proposals to regulate on-line content, opening the digital world to free expression.

But self-censorship is as strong online as over the air or in print: Mueller and others report Internet service providers Internet service provider (ISP)

Company that provides Internet connections and services to individuals and organizations. For a monthly fee, ISPs provide computer users with a connection to their site (see data transmission), as well as a log-in name and password.
 are growing reluctant to do business with critics of the Chinese government, or to host sites that are critical of Beijing. They want to stay in business after July 1.

Ah well, not to worry: It's not ideological. It's not political. It's just business.

Adam Clayton Powell III Adam Clayton Powell III (born July 17, 1946 to Adam Clayton Powell, Jr. and Hazel Scott) is Vice Provost for Globalization at the University of Southern California. Previously, he was Director of the Integrated Media Systems Center, the National Science Foundation's Engineering  (apowell@alum alum (ăl`əm), any one of a series of isomorphous double salts that are hydrated sulfates of a univalent cation (e.g., potassium, sodium, ammonium, cesium, or thallium) and a trivalent cation (e.g. .mit.edu) is vice president of technology and programs at the Freedom Forum.
COPYRIGHT 1997 Reason Foundation
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1997, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:Hong Kong post-takeover media forecast
Author:Powell, Adam Clayton, III
Publication:Reason
Date:Jun 1, 1997
Words:1027
Previous Article:Youth appeal. (protecting the youth from the dangers of online alcohol and tobacco advertising)
Next Article:Shut up, they explained. (adoption of zero-tolerance policies)
Topics:



Related Articles
Perfidious Albion.
Hong Kong playing field levels for U.S. companies as 1997 nears.
Handling Hong Kong.(reunification with China)
Two months after takeover, Hong Kong market 'largely unsettled.' (real estate market)(Industry Overview)
MAJOR PROMISES TO MONITOR CHINA'S RULE OF HONG KONG.(News)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles