Printer Friendly
The Free Library
14,716,216 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

Homeowners complain of Ralphs Grocery monopoly.


At what point does a grocery-store chain become a monopoly?

That question is not academic to the Studio City Residents Association. In the view of the group, which claims membership of 2,000 households, the proposed merger between the parent companies of Ralphs and Hughes Market crosses the line from mere dominance of the market into near monopoly.

The group wants state Attorney General Dan Lungren Daniel Edward (Dan) Lungren (born September 22, 1946), is a Republican of the United States House of Representatives representing California's 3rd congressional district (see map), located in the suburbs of Sacramento where he has served since 2005. , among other public officials, to look into the matter - and apparently, its lobbying efforts have had some effect. A spokeswoman for the attorney general confirmed that officials are studying the proposed merger as a result of public complaints.

In a Dec. 8 letter to Lungren, association President Tony Lucente wrote that the proposed merger of Ralphs parent Yucaipa Cos. and Hughes parent Quality Foods would "give Ralphs a virtual monopoly in Studio City, thereby severely reducing competition to the great disadvantage of Studio City residents."

He noted that a Ralphs store currently operates on Ventura Boulevard Ventura Boulevard is one of the primary east-west thouroughfares in the San Fernando Valley; as it was originally a part of the El Camino Real (the trail between Spanish missions), Ventura Boulevard is the oldest route in the San Fernando Valley. It was also U.S.  at Laurel Canyon Boulevard Laurel Canyon Boulevard is a major street in the city of Los Angeles, California. It starts off at Polk Street in Sylmar in the northern San Fernando Valley near the junction of the San Diego (Interstate 405) and the Golden State Freeways (Interstate 5). , while at Ventura Boulevard and Coldwater Canyon Avenue is a Hughes Market that is expected to be converted to a Ralphs.

Meanwhile, Ralphs has applied for a building permit for a new store at Ventura and Vineland Avenue.

"These stores are located approximately one mile apart." Lucente states in his letter.

Lucente claimed that "alternatives to Ralphs supermarkets for Studio City grocery shoppers are currently limited to the Hughes market at Coldwater and Ventura, which will disappear if the merger is allowed to proceed."

There is a Gelson's market just north of Studio City on Laurel Canyon Laurel Canyon can refer to several things:
  • Laurel Canyon, Los Angeles, California, an area in Hollywood Hills, Los Angeles, CA
  • Laurel Canyon Boulevard, a street that connects the San Fernando Valley to Hollywood that passes through Laurel Canyon
, Lucente acknowledged in the letter, but "this upscale store with upscale prices only services the needs of a small segment of the community."

The only other competitor, Whole Foods Market at Coldwater and Riverside Drive A number of cities around the world have a Riverside Drive.

In the United States:
  • Riverside Drive (Anderson, California)
  • Riverside Drive (Asotin County, Washington)
  • Riverside Drive (Austin, Texas)
  • Riverside Drive (Bandon, Oregon)
, "also serves a small section of the community," Lucente wrote.

In addition to Lungren, copies of Lucente's letter were sent to Joel Klein Joel I. Klein is Chancellor of the New York City Department of Education, the largest public school system in the United States with over 1.1 million students in over 1,420 schools. . U.S. assistant attorney general in the Justice Department's antitrust division. and the Department of Consumer Affairs.

A spokeswoman for Ralphs said company officials would not comment on the letter.

California is one of the few states with its own antitrust statutes - most antitrust issues are taken up by the U.S. Justice Department. But in 1992, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld the authority of the state attorney general to impose conditions, including the divestiture The breakup of AT&T. By federal court order, AT&T divested itself on January 1, 1984 of its 23 operating companies, which became known as the Regional Bell Operating Companies (RBOCs).  of certain assets, on companies undergoing mergers or acquisitions in California.

Staci Turner, a spokeswoman for the attorney general's office in Sacramento, said she "can't comment on any one specific letter." However, she acknowledged that "we are looking at the Ralphs and Hughes mergers. There has been a lot of public response on this issue."

Meanwhile, the residents association will continue to work against the merger, according to according to
prep.
1. As stated or indicated by; on the authority of: according to historians.

2. In keeping with: according to instructions.

3.
 Lucente.

"We will go through a series of actions to continue to press this issue," Lucente said, vowing to contact members of the state's congressional delegation.

"Everybody eats and everybody buys groceries. That is why it is appropriate for us to represent residents in our community," he said.

The U.S. assistant attorney general could not be reached for comment. An antitrust expert, however, said that the Studio City residents might get a sympathetic ear from authorities on both state and federal levels.

Antitrust regulators increasingly examine monopoly issues on a neighborhood-by-neighborhood basis - meaning they are likely to take resident complaints seriously, according to William S William, crown prince of Germany
William or Frederick William, 1882–1951, crown prince of Germany, son of William II. In World War I he commanded (1914) an army on the Western Front and was nominal commander in the German attack
. Grimes Grimes is a surname, that is believed to be of a Scandinavian decent and may refer to
  • Aoibhinn Grimes
  • Ashley Grimes
  • Barbara Grimes, a Chicago murder victim
  • Burleigh Grimes (1893–1985), US baseball player
  • Camryn Grimes
  • Charles Grimes
, chief counsel for the Congressional Subcommittee on Monopolies from 1980 to 1988, and now a professor at Southwestern School of Law.

The trend in antitrust regulation, Grimes said, is not to forbid the merger outright in the event of problems, but to require the chains to spin off or divest To deprive or take away.

Divest is usually used in reference to the relinquishment of authority, power, property, or title. If, for example, an individual is disinherited, he or she is divested of the right to inherit money.
 stores in certain areas.where competition appears lacking.

"Personally, I am happy to see the Studio City residents speak out about this," Grimes said. "I was thinking about organizing a group of Glendale residents on the same issue."
COPYRIGHT 1998 CBJ, L.P.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1998, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:Studio City, California
Author:Newman, Morris
Publication:Los Angeles Business Journal
Date:Jan 5, 1998
Words:660
Previous Article:Incorporations in state, county hit decade high. (California and Los Angeles County)
Next Article:L.A., Orange counties record modest hike in holiday sales. (Los Angeles County and Orange County, California)
Topics:



Related Articles
Sour grocery, IPO marts turn off Ralphs; supermarket firm shelves planned $91 million offering. (initial public offering; Ralph's Super Markets Inc.)...
Yucaipa will stack up hefty debt load if it buys Ralphs. (Yucaipa Cos.; Ralph's Grocery Co.)
Analysts see cumbersome but manageable Ralphs debt; Yucaipa puts price for Ralphs Grocery at $1.5 billion. (Yucaipa Cos.; Ralphs Grocery Co.)
Certified Grocers sees market share slipping away. (Certified Grocers of California Ltd.)
Supermarket merger sparks burst of activity. (Yucaipa Cos.; Ralph's Grocery Co.)
Local mogul expands supermarket empire. (Yucaipa Cos. owner Ronald Burkle)(Special Report: 100 Largest Private Companies)
Surveying the aisles. (profile on Ralphs Grocery Co. CEO George G. Golleher)
Some fear Ralphs merger will lead to higher prices. (Ralphs Grocery Co.'s merger with Hughes Markets Inc.)
L.A.-based supermarkets dwindle amid consolidation. (Los Angeles, CA)
RALPHS PLANS TO CLOSE 15 SUPERMARKETS RALPHS CLOSING 15 SUPERMARKETS.(Business)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles