Printer Friendly

High performance work practices and human resource management effectiveness: substitutes or complements?

Abstract

The human resource management literature has implicitly treated high performance work practices (HPWPs) and human resources The fancy word for "people." The human resources department within an organization, years ago known as the "personnel department," manages the administrative aspects of the employees.  management (HRM HRM Her/His Royal Majesty
HRM Human Resources Management
HRM Heart-Rate Monitor
HRM Halifax Regional Municipality (Canada)
HRM Hotel Restaurant Management
HRM Hrvatska Ratna Mornarica (Croatian Navy) 
) effectiveness as substitutes for one another with respect to their relationship with firm performance. We contend that HPWPs and HRM effectiveness act both as substitutes and as complements. Main effects reveal that only human resource management effectiveness affects market performance and that HPWPs affect innovation. However, interacting HPWPs with HRM effectiveness positively relates to both market performance and innovation in support of our hypothesis. The results suggest that effective HRM can offset HPWP's expense and that HPWPs can enhance the flexibility of effective HRM systems.

**********

High performance work practices (HPWPs), through significant investment in employees, have been touted as a way to make organizations more flexible and effective. Often HPWPs are viewed as an alternative to traditional productions systems that are firmly rooted in Fredrick Taylor's scientific management and subsequent Fordist principles. However, we contend that having effective human resource structures (HRM effectiveness) can enhance the return on HPWPs because HPWPs require a heavy investment in human capital, that is lost if the firm cannot attract and retain quality employees. Conversely con·verse 1  
intr.v. con·versed, con·vers·ing, con·vers·es
1. To engage in a spoken exchange of thoughts, ideas, or feelings; talk. See Synonyms at speak.

2.
, effective HRM systems can benefit from the innovative capabilities of HPWP that enhance the organization's ability to adapt and change. Hence, we address the question, "Are HPWPs and effective HRM systems complements or substitutes?" We empirically test this question using data from the banking industry. First, we review the literature that supports these predictions.

Literature Review and Hypotheses

High Performance Work Practices

No one has consistently defined, or even uniformly named HPWPs (Baker, 1999; Becket beck·et  
n. Nautical
A device, such as a looped rope, hook and eye, strap, or grommet, used to hold or fasten loose ropes, spars, or oars in position.



[Origin unknown.]

Noun 1.
 & Gerhart, 1996; Delaney & Goddard, 1997; Wood, 1999). They have been called "high performance work systems," "alternate work practices," and "flexible work practices" (Delaney & Goddard, 2001). Despite the name variances, many of these programs share common elements including rigorous recruitment and selection procedures, incentives based upon performance, and extensive training programs focused on the needs of the business (Becker, Huselid, Pickhus, & Spratt, 1997). Essentially HPWPs require heavy investment in human capital that is intended to enhance employee skills, knowledge, motivation, and flexibility with the expectation that the employer is providing employees the ability and the opportunity to provide input into workplace decisions (Van Buren, & Werner, 1996). Companies expect this empowerment em·pow·er  
tr.v. em·pow·ered, em·pow·er·ing, em·pow·ers
1. To invest with power, especially legal power or official authority. See Synonyms at authorize.

2.
 to enable employees to adapt quickly and readily to rapidly changing product and labor market labor market A place where labor is exchanged for wages; an LM is defined by geography, education and technical expertise, occupation, licensure or certification requirements, and job experience  conditions, and to improve operational efficiency and firm performance (Becker & Huselid, 1998; Cappelli & Neumark, 1999).

Although high performance work practices (HPWPs) have often been touted as being good for both employers and employees, these practices require significant investments in human capital via training, coordination of initiatives, and time for managerial and employee input. Because of the large investment in human capital, the value of these practices may be lost if the investment is not offset by increased efficiency and effectiveness. Among others, Cappelli and Neumark's (1999) review of the literature (Delaney & Goddard, 2001; Kling, 1995; U.S. Department of Labor, 1993) suggests, on average, that HPWPs are associated with increased productivity. However, Cappelli and Neumark (1999) caution that by examining only productivity effects, researchers ignore the cost side of the equation. Despite this caution, numerous other studies also find a strong relationship between HPWPs and firm performance - studies that do consider both the costs and the benefits of HPWPs (Huselid, 1995; MacDuffie (1995). Baker (1999: 28) concludes after extensively reviewing the literature, "The association of various practices with strong financial performance has been firmly established by a stream of relatively solid research." Delaney and Goddard's (2001) review also ascertained as·cer·tain  
tr.v. as·cer·tained, as·cer·tain·ing, as·cer·tains
1. To discover with certainty, as through examination or experimentation. See Synonyms at discover.

2.
 that most research, with two exceptions, also finds an association between HPWPs and firm performance. Interestingly, the Cappelli and Neumark's (1999) study was one of two that found the costs did not offset the benefits but they concluded that the effects were neutral (neither positive nor negative for the employer). For our purposes, we use a perceptual measure of performance on four dimensions: marketing, sales growth, profitability, and market share. In sum, the bulk of the evidence is that HPWPs are associated with increased firm performance. Thus, we hypothesize hy·poth·e·size  
v. hy·poth·e·sized, hy·poth·e·siz·ing, hy·poth·e·siz·es

v.tr.
To assert as a hypothesis.

v.intr.
To form a hypothesis.
:

Hypothesis 1 : More extensive use of High Performance Work Practices will be positively associated with market performance.

Nicholson, Rees, and Brooks-Rooney (1990) argue that human resources have an important role to play in facilitating innovation. HPWPs are focused upon such objectives as enabling people to think for themselves and to manage their own work (Lawler, 1986; Pfeffer, 1994). High performance work practices can increase innovation by: decentralizing de·cen·tral·ize  
v. de·cen·tral·ized, de·cen·tral·iz·ing, de·cen·tral·iz·es

v.tr.
1. To distribute the administrative functions or powers of (a central authority) among several local authorities.
 management in order to allow employees to discover and use knowledge; encouraging team practices that allow learning to grow through increased multi-disciplinary knowledge; and putting that knowledge to good use (Laursen, 2002). That thinking is consistent with the seminal work A seminal work is a work from which other works grow. The term usually refers to an intellectual or artistic achievement whose ideas and techniques have been adopted or responded to in later works by other people, either in the same field or in the general culture.  of Burns and Stalker (1961) who argued that the more organic the organizational form the more it stimulates organizational innovation. HPWPs systematically try to create organic organizations by moving decision-making downward. Laursen (2002) presents evidence that supports this contention. If the organizational objective is efficiency, more effective HRM systems are likely to increase firm performance, because HRM effectiveness focuses on building better production or service-delivery systems. In contrast, when a firm pursues innovative activities they are more likely to benefit from HPWPs since they move the level of decision making downward, making the organization better able to respond to environmental changes. Recent banking innovations have been associated with the ability to collect fees, and so we operationally define innovation as the proportion of non-interest income to total income.

Hypothesis 2: More extensive use of High Performance Work Practices will be positively associated with increased organizational innovation.

Human Resource Management Effectiveness

Pfeffer (1994) argues that sustained competitive advantage emerges from effective human resource management. Huselid, Jackson Jackson.

1 City (1990 pop. 37,446), seat of Jackson co., S Mich., on the Grand River; inc. 1857. It is an industrial and commercial center in a farm region.
, and Schuler (1997) define HRM effectiveness as "the delivery of high-quality technical and strategic HRM activities." Operationally, we define HRM effectiveness as human resource management satisfaction with various human resource activities. These notions of effectiveness are premised on the fact that it is difficult to implement HRM policies and practices successfully. The general assumption of the HPWPs literature is that firms implement these practices in a holistic Holistic
A practice of medicine that focuses on the whole patient, and addresses the social, emotional, and spiritual needs of a patient as well as their physical treatment.

Mentioned in: Aromatherapy, Stress Reduction, Traditional Chinese Medicine
, meaningful, and effective manner. However, as noted by Kling (1995) many firms implement these practices in a piecemeal piecemeal

patchy, e.g. necrosis of the liver in which groups of hepatocytes are separated by small groups of inflammatory cells and fine, fibrous septa following extension of the inflammatory process beyond the limiting plate.
 fashion, which means that their efficacy is eroded e·rode  
v. e·rod·ed, e·rod·ing, e·rodes

v.tr.
1. To wear (something) away by or as if by abrasion: Waves eroded the shore.

2. To eat into; corrode.
 by inconsistency in·con·sis·ten·cy  
n. pl. in·con·sis·ten·cies
1. The state or quality of being inconsistent.

2. Something inconsistent: many inconsistencies in your proposal.
 and a lack of supporting HRM systems. Further, firms may adopt HRM practices for institutional reasons in contrast to adopting and implementing practices to provide a potent organizational force (Huselid, et al., 1997). Russo and Fouts (1997) note, for example, that what matters is how a firm employs its organizational capabilities and its ability to manage human resources because resources or practices do not produce on their own. Further eroding firm effectiveness is an organizational environment confronting typical problems of turnover, absenteeism, and other workplace dysfunctions-particularly given the high level of investment in human capital that is required. Thus, HPWPs are by no means synonymous with synonymous with
adjective equivalent to, the same as, identical to, similar to, identified with, equal to, tantamount to, interchangeable with, one and the same as
 effective HRM systems.

Traditional HRM systems, predicated on an efficiency objective, offer stable procedures and protocols with set processes for dealing with routine employment problems such as absenteeism, discipline, and discharge. As noted by Perrow (1986, p. 4), "Bureaucracies are set up to deal with stable routine tasks; that is the basis of organization efficiency." Traditional HRM systems establish rules and procedures that promote consistency and fairness throughout the organization. Thus, an effective HRM system should enhance the firm's ability to attract and retain qualified employees and promote efficiency.

However, effective HRM practices most likely lack the flexibility of HPWPs. If the firm is pursuing an innovation objective, then effective HRM practices may interfere with this goal by focusing on routines and rules that do not provide an environment conducive con·du·cive  
adj.
Tending to cause or bring about; contributive: working conditions not conducive to productivity. See Synonyms at favorable.
 for stimulating innovation. Further, organizations that are structured to deal with stable routine tasks are less able to adapt to uncertain, dynamic environments. Consequently, we expect that:

Hypothesis 3: Perceived human resource effectiveness will be positively associated with market performance.

Hypothesis 4: Perceived human resource effectiveness will be negatively associated with innovation.

The Interaction of HPWPs and HRM Effectiveness

Many organizations today face complex environments. Lawler (1986) notes that firms' management strategies must adjust and conform to Verb 1. conform to - satisfy a condition or restriction; "Does this paper meet the requirements for the degree?"
fit, meet

coordinate - be co-ordinated; "These activities coordinate well"
 the existing business environment. The present business environment demands that firms respond to change and, at the same time, promote efficiency. Thus, firms that can combine effectiveness and flexibility objectives may be in the optimal strategic position whether they are pursuing objectives of innovation or market performance.

Contingency contingency n. an event that might not occur.  theories posit that the relationship between the relevant independent and the dependent variables vary by different levels of a critical contingency variable. The organization's strategy remains the primary contingency factor in the human resource management literature (Delery & Doty, 1996). Numerous studies support the contingency perspective, which remains a viable approach to human resource management (Arthur, 1994; Ichnowski, Shaw, & Prennushi 1997; Kochan & Osterman, 1994; Youndt, Snell Snell , George 1903-1996.

American geneticist. He shared a 1980 Nobel Prize for discoveries concerning cell structure that enhanced understanding of the immunological system, resulting in higher success rates in organ transplantation.
, Dean, Jr., & Lepak, 1996). For example, Youndt, et al.'s (1996) results reveal that manufacturing strategy moderates the HRM practice-performance relationship, and thus, supports the contingency approach. While noteworthy, none of the previous studies have focused on the use of internal contingencies Contingencies (ISSN 1048-9851) is the bimonthly magazine of the American Academy of Actuaries, providing a large and diverse readership with general interest and technical articles on a wide range of issues related to the actuarial profession.  in looking at HPWPs and their fit with external contingencies such as business strategy. Internal contingencies include those factors encompassed by the HRM system such as types of human capital, HRM processes, HRM practices, technical HRM effectiveness, and strategic HRM effectiveness (Ferris, Arthur, Berkson, Kaplan, Harrel-Cook, & Frink, 1998; Ferris, Hochwarter, Buckley, Harrel-Cook, & Frink, 1999). We posit that the alignment of internal factors, in our case HPWPs and HRM effectiveness, relates to additional performance gains above and beyond main effects. Thus,

Hypothesis 5: More extensive use of High Performance Work Practices with HRM effectiveness will be positively associated with market performance.

Hypothesis 6: More extensive use of High Performance Work Practices with HRM effectiveness will be positively associated with organizational innovation.

Methodology

Data

To examine within-industry differences, we studied a single industry, banking. The banking industry has become a highly competitive environment because of banking industry deregulation Deregulation

The reduction or elimination of government power in a particular industry, usually enacted to create more competition within the industry.

Notes:
Traditional areas that have been deregulated are the telephone and airline industries.
. The regulatory changes coincided with such technological advances as ATMs, telephone banking, pc-based banking, and information system advances. The industry responded to the changes by a significant wave of consolidation that reduced the industry from 1:2,000 to 8,000 banks between the years 1987 to 1995 (Berger, Kashyap, and Scalise, 1995). Regulation essentially prevented firms from implementing the full range of strategic choices (Johnson, Sambharya, & Bobko, 1989). Deregulation freed financial institutions to exercise strategic choice.

The firm was the unit of analysis for this study. We employed both secondary data sources and a questionnaire. The questionnaire provided information on HPWPs, HRM effectiveness, and market performance. We drew objective measures of organizational innovation and the four control variables from the Sheshunoff Bank Search database. The Sheshunoff database contains data from financial reports that the government is mandated to gather.

Banks in California California (kăl'ĭfôr`nyə), most populous state in the United States, located in the Far West; bordered by Oregon (N), Nevada and, across the Colorado River, Arizona (E), Mexico (S), and the Pacific Ocean (W). , Kentucky Kentucky, state, United States
Kentucky (kəntŭk`ē, kĭn–), one of the so-called border states of the S central United States. It is bordered by West Virginia and Virginia (E); Tennessee (S); the Mississippi R.
, and North Carolina North Carolina, state in the SE United States. It is bordered by the Atlantic Ocean (E), South Carolina and Georgia (S), Tennessee (W), and Virginia (N). Facts and Figures


Area, 52,586 sq mi (136,198 sq km). Pop.
 were surveyed to gain greater variation across dependent measures (e.g., market performance). After we pre-tested and modified the questionnaire, we contacted each bank to obtain the name of the human resource director. When possible, we contacted those directors directly and asked them to participate. In week one, we telephoned 576 banks, but 100 contacts initially refused to participate, so we mailed 476 surveys. In week two, we sent a reminder card. In week three we sent another survey. In week four we repeated the process with the same set of firms that we used in round I, starting with a telephone call to ask for their participation again. An additional 83 HRM executives declined to participate in the second round mainly due to (1) time constraints CONSTRAINTS - A language for solving constraints using value inference.

["CONSTRAINTS: A Language for Expressing Almost-Hierarchical Descriptions", G.J. Sussman et al, Artif Intell 14(1):1-39 (Aug 1980)].
 posed by the volatile nature of the banking industry (mergers, acquisitions) and (2) unwillingness to provide organizational demography demography (dĭmŏg`rəfē), science of human population. Demography represents a fundamental approach to the understanding of human society.  (race and gender composition) data that was a separate component of the survey. Eighty surveys were returned, presenting a 20 percent overall response rate from those agreeing to be surveyed and i 3.8 percent response rate for the entire sample.

We sought to assess whether characteristics of individual banks made their HRM managers less likely to complete and return the survey. Following the work of Osterman (1994) as well as Delery and Doty's (1996) banking study, we used a logistic regression In statistics, logistic regression is a regression model for binomially distributed response/dependent variables. It is useful for modeling the probability of an event occurring as a function of other factors. , with the dependent variable defined as a dummy variable This article is not about "dummy variables" as that term is usually understood in mathematics. See free variables and bound variables.

In regression analysis, a dummy variable
 --coded l if the HRM director responded and 0 if the director did not. Following Delery and Doty (1996) we used holding company affiliation and total assets. Organizational innovation was included as one of our independent variables because that is one of the key variables of interest in this study and we did not want our sample limited to the most innovative banks. None of the variables were significant and that indicates a lack of support for a response bias.

Dependent Measures

Table 1 lists the variables with their individual items where appropriate, their data source, and their coding. Lumpkin and Dess (1996) note that research testing hypotheses should include multiple performance measures to avoid misleading descriptive and normative nor·ma·tive  
adj.
Of, relating to, or prescribing a norm or standard: normative grammar.



nor
 theory building. Such measures should include intermediate and bottom-line measures of firm effectiveness. We collected perceived market performance assessment measures directly from the HRM executives. Following Delaney and Huselid (1996), we asked the respondents In the context of marketing research, a representative sample drawn from a larger population of people from whom information is collected and used to develop or confirm marketing strategy.  the following: "Compared to other organizations that do the same kind of work, how would you compare your organization's performance over the last three years (i.e., 1994, 1995, 1996) in terms of: 1) marketing, 2) growth in sales, 3) profitability, and 4) market share. Each item was measured on a four-point Likert-type scale ranging from 1 = worst to 4 = much better and averaged to form the composite measure of acceptable reliability ([alpha] = .81). Marketing refers to the success in targeting and reaching a larger customer base. Although related, this process is distinct from actual market share or growth in sales. From a measurement standpoint The Standpoint is a newspaper published in the British Virgin Islands. It was originally published under the name Pennysaver, largely as a shopping-coupon promotional newspaper, but since emerged as one of the most influential sources of journalism in the , a company can tell by an increase in customer interest in products (i.e., service inquiries). Again, this does not refer to the increase in customers which would be market share. This perceptual bottom-line measure was associated with an objective measure, return-on-equity (r = .40, p < .01).

Organizational innovation is our other dependent measure. Since deregulation, many banks have introduced new products and services that do not fit the traditional margin-maximizing schema where margin is the difference between the loan rate and the deposit rate. Instead, fee income such as origination Origination

The process through which a mortgage lender creates a mortgage secured by some amount of the mortgagor's real property.

Notes:
Also known as loan origination, everyone must go through the origination process when securing a mortgage for a piece of real
 fees from corporate cash management accounts, letters of credit, and home mortgages have become an increasing important source of bank revenues. Hence, the proportion of total income generated by these alternative fee-based products and services represents an important measure of banking innovation. This measure was obtained from the Sheshunoff bank database by calculating the ratio of non-interest income/total income consistent with Richard and Johnson (1999).

Independent Variables

We used a ten-item scale validated val·i·date  
tr.v. val·i·dat·ed, val·i·dat·ing, val·i·dates
1. To declare or make legally valid.

2. To mark with an indication of official sanction.

3.
 and deemed reliable by Huselid (1995) to capture High Performance Work Practices. By using an existing scale, we avoid the criticism that comes from employing a new and inconsistent set of HPWPs that do not allow comparison to previous research (Becker & Gerhart, 1996). We asked the respondents to indicate what percent of time they devote to ten HPWPs. These percentages were then summed to comprise the HPWP measure. We also found the scale to have internal reliability ([alpha] = .90).

Human resource management effectiveness was measured from a scale derived by Huselid, et al. (1997). The operational definition includes activities that align align (līn),
v to move the teeth into their proper positions to conform to the line of occlusion.
 the human capital pool with long-term business needs. The human resource managers were asked to use a five-point scale to report their satisfaction with the results being achieved with employee participation and empowerment, teamwork (product, software, tool) Teamwork - A SASD tool from Sterling Software, formerly CADRE Technologies, which supports the Shlaer/Mellor Object-Oriented method and the Yourdon-DeMarco, Hatley-Pirbhai, Constantine and Buhr notations. , workforce planning-flexibility and deployment, advanced issue identification-strategic studies, management and executive development, succession and development planning (managers), workforce productivity and quality of output, and employee and manager communications. The items were measured on a Likert-type scale ranging from (I) highly satisfied to (5) very dissatisfied dis·sat·is·fied  
adj.
Feeling or exhibiting a lack of contentment or satisfaction.



dis·satis·fied
 and were reversed coded to ease interpretation. The sum of all eight items measured effectiveness. There was acceptable internal reliability ([alpha] = .89).

Controls

Several control variables were used. We operationalized firm size by using the total dollar value of assets obtained from Sheshunoff. Previous research has shown a relationship between size and profitability in the banking industry (Delery & Doty, 1996; Ramaswamy, 1997). Sheshunoff also provided the data used to construct an indicator variable that was included to measure whether the bank is part of a holding company (= 1 if holding company; = 0 other). Two dummy Sham; make-believe; pretended; imitation. Person who serves in place of another, or who serves until the proper person is named or available to take his place (e.g., dummy corporate directors; dummy owners of real estate).  variables controlled for state differences (California = 1; other = 0; and Kentucky = 1; 0 = other--leaving North Carolina as the omitted state.

Analysis

Hierarchical A structure made up of different levels like a company organization chart. The higher levels have control or precedence over the lower levels. Hierarchical structures are a one-to-many relationship; each item having one or more items below it.  regression analysis In statistics, a mathematical method of modeling the relationships among three or more variables. It is used to predict the value of one variable given the values of the others. For example, a model might estimate sales based on age and gender.  was employed to test the hypotheses. In the first step, the control variables were entered. The second step, HRM effectiveness and HPWPs were added to test Hypotheses 1 through 4, which examined whether HPWPs and HRM effectiveness related significantly to the dependent measures after accounting for the controls. Step 3 tested the interaction effects proposed in the fifth and sixth hypotheses.

Results

Correlations

Table 2 provides descriptive statistical information (e.g., means, standard deviations, and correlations) for all measures.

Table 3 shows the results of our hierarchical regression regression, in psychology: see defense mechanism.
regression

In statistics, a process for determining a line or curve that best represents the general trend of a data set.
 for market performance and organization innovation.

Hypothesis 1 states that there will be a positive relationship between HPWPs and market performance. In the second step of the outcome regression, with total assets, holding company ownership, and state controlled, HPWPs were not significantly related to market performance ([beta] = .08, p = .25). Thus, no support was found for this hypothesis. The second hypothesis posits a positive relationship between HPWPs and innovation. In Step 2 of the regression, after entering the control variables, HPWPs were significantly and positively related to organization innovation ([beta] = .22, p = .03), lending support for this hypothesis.

The third hypothesis predicted that HRM effectiveness would positively relate to market performance and, after entering the control variables, this hypothesis was supported ([beta] = .24, p = .03). Hypothesis 4 predicted that HRM effectiveness would relate negatively to innovation, in the second step of the organization innovation regression, the coefficient coefficient /co·ef·fi·cient/ (ko?ah-fish´int)
1. an expression of the change or effect produced by variation in certain factors, or of the ratio between two different quantities.

2.
 was only marginally significant but in the predicted negative direction. Thus, this hypothesis received minimal support ([beta] = -. 19, p = .07).

Hypotheses 5 and 6 state that HPWPs and HRM effectiveness will influence market performance and organizational innovation through a positive interaction effect. In the third step, the interaction effect significantly resulted in a change in [R.sup.2] increase for both market performance ([beta] = .35, p = .017) and organization innovation ([beta] = .33, p = .019). The results suggest that internal alignment between HPWPs and HRM effectiveness increase both market performance and organization innovation, supporting the last two hypotheses. In sum, we received support for the second, third, fifth and six hypotheses. The fourth hypothesis received marginal support.

Discussion

Many have viewed HPWPs as a substitute for traditional HRM, believing that firms must choose either to implement HPWPs or to approach HRM in the textbook textbook Informatics A treatise on a particular subject. See Bible.  manner consistent with traditional bureaucratic bu·reau·crat  
n.
1. An official of a bureaucracy.

2. An official who is rigidly devoted to the details of administrative procedure.



bu
 organizations. This view, consistent with the strategic approach, suggests that firms must match their human resource management practices with their business strategy to achieve superior results. Based upon this reasoning, we hypothesized and found support for the argument that HPWPs are associated with increased innovation, HRM effectiveness is associated with increased performance, and together both HPWPs and HRM effectiveness is associated with both goals. However, we took strategic theory further to argue that although HPWPs and HRM effectiveness are typically viewed as substitutes, they may complement each other. Thus, HPWPs apparently yield more benefits in an environment where HRM is managed well, and HR management is enhanced because HPWPs lend flexibility. Our results are consistent with this view.

HRM researchers have suggested that HPWPs universally benefit all employers (Pfeffer, 1994; Huselid, 1995). The contingency theorists contend that strategic fit is crucial for superior performance so that firms must match their HRM practices with their business strategies. They argue that high investments in training and employees will pay off in terms of employee commitment and work effort. However, because HPWPs do not come cheaply, firms either need to offset these expenses with productivity increases or operate in an innovative environment that can absorb these costs (Cappelli & Neumark, 1999). Thus, HPWPs are less compatible with firms pursuing efficiency objectives and more compatible with firms whose success is more dependent on innovation as opposed to efficiency. A major benefit of HPWPs is to move the level of decision making downward to reduce the need for formal supervision so that employees are to think for themselves. These objectives may be of great importance for employers seeking to innovate in·no·vate  
v. in·no·vat·ed, in·no·vat·ing, in·no·vates

v.tr.
To begin or introduce (something new) for or as if for the first time.

v.intr.
To begin or introduce something new.
 or provide a responsive service, but may be problematic for employers pursuing efficiency objectives. Notably, employers who have highly developed hierarchical and formal structures that follow an evolved model of scientific management may not benefit from HPWPs. These employers have designed formal rules and procedures specifically to avoid employees thinking for themselves. Thus, we argued that employers with innovation objectives would benefit more from HPWPs than would employers seeking a market efficiency objective. On the other hand, employers who are seeking market efficiencies would directly benefit more if HRM were implemented effectively.

Our results support these suppositions. Market performance correlated cor·re·late  
v. cor·re·lat·ed, cor·re·lat·ing, cor·re·lates

v.tr.
1. To put or bring into causal, complementary, parallel, or reciprocal relation.

2.
 with HRM effectiveness but there was no evidence of HPWPs having direct effects on market performance. This is consistent with the general research trend that finds either positive or neutral effects of these work practices on performance (for example, Cappelli & Neumark, 1999). Thus, this suggests that performance objectives are best met through effective management and that HPWPs alone are not the panacea to performance concerns. On the other hand, HPWPs correlated strongly with innovation objectives suggesting that they are much more consistent with generating ideas rather than efficiencies. Weak evidence hinted that innovation may be stymied by HRM effectiveness, after controlling for HPWPs, suggesting that effectiveness alone may be too rigid to enhance innovation, interestingly, we also found significant moderating effects suggesting that well designed and integrated HRM systems with HPWPs may enhance both performance and innovation objectives.

Thus, these results modify the strategic human resource management notion of fit--the idea that firms must match their HRM objectives with the firm's business strategy. Our results send a powerful message to firms: if you can do only one thing well (e.g., HRM effectiveness) then pursue an HRM system that fits with the firm's strategic objective (e.g., performance). Thus, fit is important if your capabilities are not well developed. However, if you can effectively use human capital and implement HPWPs, then do both.

Porter (1980) deemed that some organizations are "stuck-in-the middle"--they lack a clearly defined strategic position, take a defensive position, react to the environment, and drift drift, deposit of mixed clay, gravel, sand, and boulders transported and laid down by glaciers. Stratified, or glaciofluvial, drift is carried by waters flowing from the melting ice of a glacier.  along without specific goals and objectives. At best they muddle along; at worst they fail. He argued that these groups, trying to be all things to all people, are instead nothing to everyone. Although those arguments are compelling, our results suggest that having a combined focus, if done well, can work and pays off--it depends upon how well the multiple strategies are executed. Clearly, doing one thing well will provide a return if it is consistent with business strategy. But doing two things well is even better and enables organizations to perform on multiple dimensions.

As resource-based scholars suggest, it is hard to implement effective management practices. Our research findings imply that employers may want to first establish their objective, focus on HRM policies and practices to achieve that objective, and then work to expand their capabilities to incorporate alternative practices that will enhance their primary strategy. Given these findings, we answer the question posed in the title of the paper--HPWPs and HRM effectiveness may be both substitutes and complements. The main effects suggest that they are substitutes as they relate to different dependent variables, but the interactions show that if HPWPs and HRM effectiveness are combined they can also have complementary effects.

These results are subject to the limitation of common method variance The discrepancy between what a party to a lawsuit alleges will be proved in pleadings and what the party actually proves at trial.

In Zoning law, an official permit to use property in a manner that departs from the way in which other property in the same locality
 because one of the dependent variables, with the exception of innovation, and the key independent variables were collected from the same respondent In Equity practice, the party who answers a bill or other proceeding in equity. The party against whom an appeal or motion, an application for a court order, is instituted and who is required to answer in order to protect his or her interests.  at the same time. Hence, future studies will need to examine these questions using more objective performance measures to see if these relationships hold.

In sum, this research suggests that firms first need to concentrate their efforts on fit. Once fit is established, then the firms can extend their HRM practices to other domains. Firms that have both HPWPs and HRM effectiveness are the most successful on both innovation and market performance measures. Although scholars have indicated that doing both is hard, our results indicate that it may be well worth it.

References

Arthur, J. B. (I 994). Effects of human resource systems on manufacturing performance and turnover. Academy of Management Journal, 37, 670-87.

Baker, T. (1999). Doing well by doing good. Washington, D.C.: Economic Policy Institute.

Becket, B., & Gerhart, B. (1996). The impact of human resource management on organizational performance: Progress and prospects. Academy of Management Journal, 39, 779-802.

Becker, B. & Huselid, M.A. (1998). High performance work systems and firm performance: A synthesis of research and managerial implications. In G.R. Ferris (Ed.) Research in personnel and human resource management, vol. 16. (pp. 53-101), Stamford, CT: JAI JAI Java Advanced Imaging
JAI Justice et Affaires Interiéures (French: Justice and Home Affairs)
JAI Journal of ASTM International
JAI Just An Idea
JAI Jazz Alliance International
JAI Joint Africa Institute
 Press.

Becker, BB., Huselid, M.A., Pinkhaus, P.S. & Spratt, M.F. (1997). HR as a source of shareholder value: Research and recommendations. Human resource management, 36, 39-47.

Berger, A.N., Kashyap, A.K. & Scalise, J.M. (1995). The transformation of the U.S. banking industry: What a long, strange trip it's been. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 55-218.

Burns, T., & Stalker, G. M. (1961). The management of innovation. London: Sage.

Cappeili, P. & Neumark, D. (1999). Do high performance work practices improve establishment-level outcomes? Cambridge: National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper 7374.

Delaney, J. T., & Goddard, J. (2001). An industrial relations industrial relations
pl.n.
Relations between the management of an industrial enterprise and its employees.


industrial relations
Noun, pl

the relations between management and workers
 perspective on the high-performance paradigm. Human Resource Management Review., 11, 395-429.

Delaney, J. T., & Huselid, M. A. (1996). The impact of human resource management practices on perceptions of organizational performance. Academy of Management Journal, 39, 749-70.

Delery, J. E., & Doty, D. H. (1996). Theoretical frameworks in strategic human resource management: Universalistic, contingency, and configurational perspectives. Academy of Management Journal, 39, 802-35.

Ferris, G. R., Arthur, M., Berkson, H. M., Kaplan, D. M., Harrel-Cook, G., & Frink, D. D. (1998). Toward a social context theory of the human resource management-organization effectiveness relationship. Human Resource Management Review, 8, 235-264

Ferris, G. R., Hochwarter, W. A., Buckley, M. R., Harrel-Cook, G., & Frink, D. D. (1999). Human resource management: Some new directions. Journal of Management, 25, 385-15.

Huselid, M. A. (1995). The impact of human resource management on turnover, productivity, and corporate performance. Academy of Management Journal, 38, 635-72.

Huselid, M. A., Jackson, S. E., & Schuler, R. S. (1997). Technical and strategic human resource effectiveness as determinants of firm performance. Academy of Management Journal, 40: 171-88.

Ichniowski, C., Shaw, K. & Prennushi, G. (1997). The effects of human resource management practices on productivity: A study of steel finishing lines. American Economic Review, 87, 29 l-313.

Johnson, N.B., Sambharya, R.B. & Bobko, P. (1989). Deregulation, business strategy, and wages in the airline industry. Industrial Relations, 28, 419-430.

Kling, J. (1995). High performance work systems and firm performance. Monthly_ Labor Review, 118(5), 29-37.

Kochan, T. A., & Osterman, P. (1994). The mutual gains enterprise: For going a winning partnership among labor management and government. Boston: Harvard Business School Harvard Business School, officially named the Harvard Business School: George F. Baker Foundation, and also known as HBS, is one of the graduate schools of Harvard University.  Press.

Laursen, K. (2002). The importance of sectoral differences in the application of complementary HRM practices for innovation performance. International Journal of the Economics of Business. 9, 139-156.

Lawler, E. E. III. (1986). High-involvement management. San Francisco San Francisco (săn frănsĭs`kō), city (1990 pop. 723,959), coextensive with San Francisco co., W Calif., on the tip of a peninsula between the Pacific Ocean and San Francisco Bay, which are connected by the strait known as the Golden : Jossey-Bass.

Lumpkin, G. T., & Dess, G. G. (1996). Clarifying the entrepreneurial en·tre·pre·neur  
n.
A person who organizes, operates, and assumes the risk for a business venture.



[French, from Old French, from entreprendre, to undertake; see enterprise.
 orientation construct and linking it to performance. Academe of Management Review, 21, 135-72.

MacDuffie, J. (1995). Human resource bundles and manufacturing performance: Organizational logic and flexible production systems in the world auto industry. Industrial and Labor Relations Review Industrial and Labor Relations Review is a publication of the Cornell University School of Industrial and Labor Relations. It is an interdisciplinary journal publishing original research on all aspects of labor relations. , 48, 197-221.

Nicholason, N. & Rees, A., Brooks-Rooney, A. (1990). Strategy, innovation, and performance. Journal of Management Studies. 27, 511-534.

Osterman, P. (1994). How common is workplace transformation and who adopts it? Industrial Relations and Labor Relations Review, 47, 173-188.

Perrow, C. (1086). Complex organizations. New York New York, state, United States
New York, Middle Atlantic state of the United States. It is bordered by Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and the Atlantic Ocean (E), New Jersey and Pennsylvania (S), Lakes Erie and Ontario and the Canadian province of
: McGraw-Hill.

Pfeffer, J. (1994). Competitive advantage through people. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press.

Porter, M. (1980). Competitive strategy. New York: Free Press.

Ramaswamy, K. (1997). The performance impact of strategic similarity Similarity is some degree of symmetry in either analogy and resemblance between two or more concepts or objects. The notion of similarity rests either on exact or approximate repetitions of patterns in the compared items.  in horizontal mergers: Evidence from the U.S. banking industry. Academy of Management Journal, 40, 697-715.

Richard, O. C. & Johnson, N. B. (1999). Making the connection between formal human resource diversity practices and organizational effectiveness: Beyond management fashion. Performance Impact Quarterly, 12, 77-96.

Russo, M. V., & Fouts, P.A. (1997). A resource-based perspective on corporate environmental performance and profitability. Academy of Management Journal, 40, 534-559.

U.S. Department of Labor.(1993). High performance work practices and firm performance. Washington, DC: US DOL DOL - Display Oriented Language. Subsystem of DOCUS. Sammet 1969, p.678. .

Van Buren, M. E., & Werner, J. M. (1996). High performance work systems. Business and Economic, 43, 15-35.

Wood, S. (1999). Human resource management and performance. International journal of management reviews, 1, 367-413.

Youndt, M. A., Snell, S. A., Dean, J. W., Lepak, D. P. (1996). Human resource management, manufacturing strategy, and firm performance. Academy of Management Journal, 39, 836-66.

Orlando C. Richard

University of Texas at Dallas History
The university was originally started as a research arm of Texas Instruments as the Graduate Research Center of the Southwest in 1961. The institute (by then renamed the Southwest Center for Advanced Studies) which at the time was located at Southern Methodist
 

Richardson, TX

Nancy Brown Johnson

University of Kentucky Coordinates:  The University of Kentucky, also referred to as UK, is a public, co-educational university located in Lexington, Kentucky.  

Lexington, KY

Nancy Brown Johnson earned her Ph.D. in Business from the University of Kansas The University of Kansas (often referred to as KU or just Kansas) is an institution of higher learning in Lawrence, Kansas. The main campus resides atop Mount Oread.  in 1986. Since that time she has been a member of the Management Faculty at the University of Kentucky. Her primary research interests relate to compensation and justice topics including deregulation and wages, international compensation, and justice and union participation. She has published articles in Industrial and Labor Relations Review, Industrial Relations, Human Resource Management Review, and the British Journal of Industrial Relations.

Orlando C. Richard is an assistant professor of management at the University of Texas at Dallas. His research interests include cultural diversity and its organizational impact and human resource management system effects.
Table 1
Variables, Data Sources, and Measures

Variable Name                             Variable Source

Size                                      Sheshunoff database
Holding company affiliated                Sheshunoff database

California dummy control                  Sample selection

Kentucky dummy control                    Sample selection

High Performance Work Practices           Survey
  ([alpha] = .90)
  What percentage of the workforce ...
  * is included in a formal
    information-sharing program
    (e.g., newsletter)?
  * hold jobs that have been included
    in a formal job analysis?
  * is regularly administered
    attitude surveys?
  * participate in Quality of Life
    (QWL) Quality Circles (QC), and/or
    labor management participation
    programs?
  * is eligible For company incentive
    plans, profit-sharing plans,
    and/or gainsharing plans?
  * received training by an
    experienced employee (i.e., someone
    employed more than one year)?
  * has access to a formal grievance
    procedure and/or complaint
    resolution system?
  * has their merit increase or other
    incentive pay determined by a
    performance appraisal?
  * receives formal performance
    appraisals?
  * are promoted based primarily on
    merit (as opposed to seniority)?
Human Resource Management                 Survey
    Effectiveness ([alpha] =.89)
  Satisfaction with the results being
    achieved with Their employee
    participation and empowerment
  Teamwork
  Workforce planning-flexibility and
    deployment
  Advanced issue
    identification-strategic studies
  Management and executive
    development
  Succession and development planning
  Workforce productivity and quality
    output
  Employee and manager communications
Market Performance ([alpha] = .81)        Survey
  Compared to other organizations
    that do the same kind of work, how
    would you compare your
    organization's performance over the
    fast 3 years in terms of Marketing,
    Growth in Sales. Profitability, and
    Market Share
Innovation                                Sheshunoff database

Variable Name                             Coding

Size                                      Total assets
Holding company affiliated                Dummy code where 1 = holding
                                          and 0 = other
California dummy control                  California = 1 and other
                                          states = 0
Kentucky dummy control                    Kentucky = 1 and other
                                          states = 0
High Performance Work Practices           Sum of the ten items
  ([alpha] = .90)                         percentages.
  What percentage of the workforce ...
  * is included in a formal
    information-sharing program
    (e.g., newsletter)?
  * hold jobs that have been included
    in a formal job analysis?
  * is regularly administered
    attitude surveys?
  * participate in Quality of Life
    (QWL) Quality Circles (QC), and/or
    labor management participation
    programs?
  * is eligible For company incentive
    plans, profit-sharing plans,
    and/or gainsharing plans?
  * received training by an
    experienced employee (i.e., someone
    employed more than one year)?
  * has access to a formal grievance
    procedure and/or complaint
    resolution system?
  * has their merit increase or other
    incentive pay determined by a
    performance appraisal?
  * receives formal performance
    appraisals?
  * are promoted based primarily on
    merit (as opposed to seniority)?
Human Resource Management                 Each item was on a five
    Effectiveness ([alpha] =.89)          point Likert scale ranging
  Satisfaction with the results being     from 1 = highly satisfied to
    achieved with Their employee          5 = very dissatisfied,
    participation and empowerment         reversed coded, and summed.
  Teamwork
  Workforce planning-flexibility and
    deployment
  Advanced issue
    identification-strategic studies
  Management and executive
    development
  Succession and development planning
  Workforce productivity and quality
    output
  Employee and manager communications
Market Performance ([alpha] = .81)        Average of the four
  Compared to other organizations         performance items on a four
    that do the same kind of work, how    point Likert scale ranging
    would you compare your                from 1 = worst to 4 = much
    organization's performance over the   better.
    fast 3 years in terms of Marketing,
    Growth in Sales. Profitability, and
    Market Share
Innovation                                Ratio of net-interest income
                                          to total income.

Table 2
Correlations

                                      Standard
Variable                      Mean    Deviation      1         2

1. Size                       11.72     1.41      1.00
2. Holding                     .48       .50       .34 **   1.00
3. California                  .66       .48      -.01      -.22 **
4. Kentucky                    .18       .38      -.05       .36 **
5. HPWPs                       508       158       .30 **    .26 *
6. HRM Effectness              28         5        .19       .08
7. Market Performance           3        .65       .15       .14
8. Organizational Innovation   .43       .40      -.05      -.06

Variable                         3       4      5       6       7

1. Size
2. Holding
3. California                 1.00
4. Kentucky                   -.64 **   1.00
5. HPWPs                      -.O1       .05   1.00
6. HRM Effectness              .28 *    -.19   -.02   1.00
7. Market Performance         -.24 *     .19    .09    .26 *   1.00
8. Organizational Innovation   .13 **   -.02    .32   -.21     -.18

Variable                       8

1. Size
2. Holding
3. California
4. Kentucky
5. HPWPs
6. HRM Effectness
7. Market Performance
8. Organizational Innovation  1.00

* p < .05;

** p < .01 (two-tailed tests) n=74

Table 3
Simultaneous Hierarchical Regression Results for Dependent Outcomes

Variable                          Market Performance
                               [R.sup.2] Change   [beta]

Step 1: Controls                .08
  Size                                              .11
  Holding                                           .04
  California                                       -.19
  Kentucky                                          .05

Step 2: Main Effects            .06 ([dagger])
  HPWPs                                             .08
  HRM Effectiveness                                 .24 *

Step 3: Interaction             .06 (*)
  HPWPs X HRM Effectiveness                         .35 *
N                                                    78

[R.sup.2]                       .20

Adjusted [R.sup.2]              .11

Equation F-Value               2.27 *

Variable                               Innovation
                               [R.sup.2] Change       [beta]

Step 1: Controls                .04
  Size                                             .11
  Holding                                         -.01
  California                                       .23 ([dagger])
  Kentucky                                         .12

Step 2: Main Effects            .07 *
  HPWPs                                            .22 *
  HRM Effectiveness                               -.19 ([dagger])

Step 3: Interaction             .05 *
  HPWPs X HRM Effectiveness                        .33 *
N                                                   78

[R.sup.2]                       .16

Adjusted [R.sup.2]              .07

Equation F-Value               1.84 ([dagger])

Standardized betas reported

([dagger]) p <.10

* p < .05

** p < .01; one-tailed tests.
COPYRIGHT 2004 Center for Business and Economic Research
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2004 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Richard, Orlando C.; Johnson, Nancy Brown
Publication:Journal of Business Strategies
Geographic Code:1USA
Date:Sep 22, 2004
Words:5789
Previous Article:A fine-grained analysis of director dependence: examining board composition in detail.
Next Article:The impact of horizontal strategic alliances on the U.S. steel industry.
Topics:

Terms of use | Copyright © 2014 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters