Printer Friendly

Hand gels falter.

Alcohol-based gels may not effectively eliminate from people's hands a type of virus that causes millions of cases of diarrhea worldwide each year, say researchers.

Such hand sanitizers are rising in popularity because of their convenience, says Christine Moe of Emory University in Atlanta. Unlike washing with soap and water, using these gels doesn't require rinsing or drying one's hands.

Because the gels have been shown to kill a wide variety of bacteria and viruses, Moe adds, they're becoming a common fixture in places where frequent hand washing is necessary. Until now, however, researchers hadn't tested the effectiveness of such sanitizers against noroviruses, a family of viruses that causes gastrointestinal infections and has become notorious for spreading among passengers on cruise ships.

Moe and her colleagues recruited five volunteers to come into the lab. The scientists spread a known amount of Norwalk virus, a common type of norovirus, on the volunteers' fingers. To each of three fingers, the researchers then applied one of three cleansing agents--antibacterial soap rinsed with water, plain water, or a popular alcohol-based hand sanitizer. Each volunteer's fourth finger remained unwashed for comparison.

To the researchers' surprise, plain water was most effective, removing 96 percent of Norwalk virus. Antibacterial soap was close behind, reducing viral counts by 88 percent. The alcohol-based hand gels reduced the virus by only about half.

Alcohol-based hand gels "are better than nothing, but in areas where soap mad water are available, people should use those first," Moe says.--C.B.
COPYRIGHT 2006 Science Service, Inc.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2006, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:HYGIENE
Publication:Science News
Date:Jun 10, 2006
Words:248
Previous Article:For women, weight gain spells heartburn.
Next Article:Dive suits could spread disease.
Topics:


Related Articles
Handwashing versus alcohol-based gels--FDA information.
A bit of home.
Splish splash ...: adding alcohol-based handrubs to hand hygiene routines contributes to patient safety, saves lives and adds to operational...
Clean up your act! personal hygiene can hamper or help your success.
Scrubbing down: free soap, hygiene tips cut kids' illnesses.
Handwashing antiseptics: the product selection challenge; Interview with Rita McCormick, RN, CIC, senior infection control practitioner, University...
Hand sanitizer alert.

Terms of use | Copyright © 2014 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters