Printer Friendly

HMO'S EXPENSES DETAILED : ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS VARY FROM 3% TO 25%.

Byline: Deborah Adamson Daily News Staff Writer

California HMOs allocated as much as a quarter of their revenues to pay for administrative costs that include multimillion-dollar executive compensation packages and advertising expenses, according to a report released Friday by the California Medical Association.

In a survey of 35 HMOs, the report by the San Francisco-based doctors group said that administrative costs ranged from a high around 25 percent of revenues to a low around 3 percent among health plans with at least 20,000 enrollees.

Kaiser Foundation Health Plan spent the smallest percentage on administrative costs while Community Health Plan allocated the largest.

That bites into the percentage spent on medical treatment.

Medical spending ran the gamut from a low of 74.3 percent of revenues at CaliforniaCare, the HMO of Woodland Hills-based Wellpoint Health Networks, to a high of 96.5 percent at Oakland-based Kaiser.

``When consumers and businesses are choosing their health plan and they see plans with high overhead or administrative costs, they should ask why,'' said Dr. Jack Lewin, chief executive of the medical association.

``They should find out if they are getting full value for their premiums,'' he said

The top 10 in spending the largest portion on medical care were Kaiser, Monarch Plan, Priority Health Services, Contra Costa Health Plan, Santa Barbara Regional Health Initiative, National Health Plan, Health Plan of San Mateo, Health Plan of the Redwoods, Solano Partnership Health Plan and Inter Valley Health Plan. Seven are nonprofit HMOs.

The bottom 10 were CaliforniaCare, Community Health Plan, Community Health Group, Foundation Health, MetLife, Molina Medical Centers, Maxicare, Lifeguard, Health Net and Aetna. Seven of them are for-profit firms.

The report said that Health Net, the HMO of Woodland Hills-based Health Systems International, last year paid almost $2 million to its president, Malik Hasan. Wellpoint's CEO, Leonard Schaeffer, received salary and other compensation of $1.2 million in the company's last fiscal year.

For-profit companies spend less on medical care on the average than their nonprofit counterparts - 83 percent vs. 86 percent.

Administrative costs also were lower at nonprofits, at 12 percent of revenue on the average, compared with 14 percent at for-profits.

But Alan Tomiyama, spokesman for the California Association of HMOs in San Francisco, took issue with the report's validity.

He said there is no direct correlation between how much one spends on medical care and the quality of care. Furthermore, the report compares ``apples to oranges'' since it does not take into account individual differences among the plans, he said.

``It overlooks a significant number of important factors like the size of the plan, plan type and composition of benefit packages,'' Tomiyama said.

HMO SPENDING

A new survey shows the percentage of revenue spent on medical care by the 10 largest health maintenance organizations in California.

HMOs Percent spent

on medical care

Kaiser 96.5

CaliforniaCare 74.3

Health Net 80.1

PacifiCare 83.6

FHP Inc. 83.8

Prudential 87.4

CIGNA 86.0

Foundation Health 77.4

Aetna 81.4

Blue Shield HMO 82.4

SOURCE: California Medical Association

CAPTION(S):

Box

Box: HMO SPENDING (See Text)
COPYRIGHT 1997 Daily News
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1997, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:BUSINESS
Publication:Daily News (Los Angeles, CA)
Article Type:Statistical Data Included
Date:Feb 22, 1997
Words:519
Previous Article:BIZWATCH : MARKETS.
Next Article:PRUDENTIAL, STATE SETTLE FRAUD LAWSUIT : INSURER TO PAY $15.4 MILLION OVER SALES TACTICS.


Related Articles
Physician bonding techniques surveyed.
The challenge of containing health care costs.
Physician perspectives on the structure and function of group practice HMOs.
Consumer's guide to health insurance.
HMOS NEED WAY TO REMAIN WITH MEDICARE.
Development of an HMO cost management system.
Are factor substitutions in HMO industry operations cost saving?

Terms of use | Copyright © 2014 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters