Governing under the influence; Washington alcoholics: their aides protect them, the media shields them.Governing Under the Influence Deaver Cites Alcoholism as Perjury perjury (pûr`jərē), in criminal law, the act of willfully and knowingly stating a falsehood under oath or under affirmation in judicial or administrative proceedings. Trial Defense. The New York New York, state, United States New York, Middle Atlantic state of the United States. It is bordered by Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and the Atlantic Ocean (E), New Jersey and Pennsylvania (S), Lakes Erie and Ontario and the Canadian province of Times, October 3, 1987 Give me a break, I thought. Who's Deaver trying to fool? It just doesn't add up. First, if he was so intoxicated in·tox·i·cate v. in·tox·i·cat·ed, in·tox·i·cat·ing, in·tox·i·cates v.tr. 1. To stupefy or excite by the action of a chemical substance such as alcohol. 2. , could he really have survived as a top White House aide or superlobbyist? Second, if he were constantly guzzling scotch as he claims, wouldn't his colleagues have been suspicious? And if he were that blitzed blitzed adj. Slang Drunk or intoxicated. , wouldn't reporters have jumped on the story? Deaver's defense may or may not have been contrived, but the scenario behind it is plausible. Yes, alcoholics can do their jobs at the same time they ruin themselves. Yes, olleagues can be oblivious to the effects of even heavy drinking
"I suspect," writes former Senator Herman Talmadge Herman Eugene Talmadge (August 9, 1913 – March 21, 2002) was an American politician who served as Governor of the U.S. state of Georgia briefly in 1947 and again from 1948 to 1955, and as a U.S. Senator from 1957 until 1981. , "alcoholism is as much of an occupational disease among politicians as black lung black lung: see pneumoconiosis. is among coal miners." Washington is certainly not the only place where both alcoholism and misunderstanding about alcoholism are widespread. But Washington has its own elaborate system that can disguise the problem and conceal its effect on the city's work product, public policy. Often, it creates a special alcoholic's trap: the more important a public officials is, the less likely he will be forced to confront his problem drinking. "I knew several alcoholics," says Richard Bolling, former chairman of the House Rules Committee and a recovering alcoholic, "and they all were in important positions." One would think that this would be a point of interest to the media. Ironically, the recent press willingness to peep through the bushes at a public figure's private conduct has focused on fuzzy "character" and "judgment" issues. Reporters have often overlooked a problem that would seem to relate much more directly to "job performance," the one criterion both critics and defenders of the press agree is fair game. So where are all the drunk politician stories? From 1965 to 1980, some of the most important leadership positions on Capitol Hill were held by congressmen with drinking problems, including the majority leader (Hale Boggs) and the chairmen of the Ways and Means WAYS AND MEANS. In legislative assemblies there is usually appointed a committee whose duties are to inquire into, and propose to the house, the ways and means to be adopted to raise funds for the use of the government. This body is called the committee of ways and means. (Wilbur Mills Wilbur Daigh Mills (May 24, 1909 - May 2, 1992), was a powerful Democratic member of the United States House of Representatives from the state of Arkansas. He was chairman of the House Ways and Means Committee in the 1960s, and briefly a candidate for President of the United ), Rules (Bolling), and Armed Services The Constitution authorizes Congress to raise, support, and regulate armed services for the national defense. The President of the United States is commander in chief of all the branches of the services and has ultimate control over most military matters. (L. Mendel Rivers Lucius Mendel Rivers (28 September 1905 – 28 December 1970), was a United States Representative from South Carolina for nearly thirty years. Born in Gumville, South Carolina, Rivers attended the public schools and the College of Charleston in Charleston, South Carolina. ) committees. The noticeable effects of their drinking ran quite a spectrum. At one end was Rivers, who was regularly drying out at Bethesda Naval Hospital during the same period he had access to top classified defense and intelligence information. At the other was Bolling, who showed no signs of excessive drinking but later conceded he was an alcoholic. Reporters who covered Rivers knew about his drinking. But it wasn't exposed in print until columnists Drew Pearson Drew Pearson is the name of:
Jackson Northman Anderson (October 19, 1922 – December 17, 2005) was an American newspaper columnist and is considered one of the fathers of modern began writing about it. They focused on Rivers's sensitive position as chairman of the Armed Services Committee The term Armed Services Committee could refer to:
(1) (Confidentiality Integrity Authentication) The three important concerns with regards to information security. Encryption is used to provide confidentiality (privacy, secrecy). . "While Congress has spent millions exposing communists and non-conformists," Pearson and Anderson wrote in 1967, "it has carefully protected its own security risks." They reported that the markup for the $18 billion military authorization bill had to be delayed five times while Rivers was "resting" in Bethesda Naval Hospital. Committee colleagues, they wrote, "have urged [Rivers] to stay on the wagon at least long enough to win" key battles against the Johnson administration There have been two Presidents of the United States with the surname "Johnson":
tr.v. strewed, strewn or strewed, strew·ing, strews 1. To spread here and there; scatter: strewing flowers down the aisle. 2. with bottles and the safe would be wide open." Alcohol problems stalked Majority Leader Hale Boggs too and similarly went unreported until Anderson and Pearson got the story. "House Speaker Carl Albert is so wary of Boggs's behavior," Anderson wrote, "that he is afraid to step down from the chair and turn control of the House over to the man who is supposed to be his prime assistant." Questions about Albert's own drinking were raised in Anderson's column and later spilled onto the news pages when the speaker smashed up his car outside his favorite bar, the Zebra Room. Witnesses described him as "obviously drunk." Across the rotunda rotunda In Classical and Neoclassical architecture, a building or room that is circular in plan and covered with a dome. The Pantheon is a Classical Roman rotunda. The Villa Rotonda at Vicenza, designed by Andrea Palladio, is an Italian Renaissance example. in the Senate, alcohol problems among top leaders were just as prevalent. Former senators who have acknowledged alcoholism included the chairman of the Agriculture Committee (Herman Talmadge); the chairman of the Finance Committee (Russell Long), who went on the wagon in the 1970s; and a senior liberal (Harrison Williams Harrison Williams is the name of:
prep. 1. As stated or indicated by; on the authority of: according to historians. 2. In keeping with: according to instructions. 3. Robert Parker Robert Parker may refer to:
n. 1. The candidate or nominee for the lesser of two closely associated political offices. 2. A companion. 3. A horse used to set the pace in a race for another horse. in 1956. One Senate leader in the 1960s was so drunk that he urinated in his pants and passed out on the Senate floor, according to Parker. As Wayne Morse Wayne Lyman Morse (October 20, 1900 – July 22, 1974) was a United States Senator from Oregon from 1945 until 1969. In 1953, he made a filibuster for 22 hours and 26 minutes protesting the Tidelands Oil legislation, which at the time was the longest one-person filibuster in , who served in the Senate from 1945 to 1969, once said: "There has never been one night session of the Senate in all my experience that hasn't witnessed at least one senator making a fool of himself and disgracing the Senate." These congressmen do not exhaust the list. Harold Hughes Harold Everett Hughes (February 10 1922 – October 23 1996) was the Democratic Governor of Iowa from 1963 until 1969; he had been a Republican earlier in his life. Hughes also served as a Democratic United States Senator from 1969 until 1975. , an alcoholic who had stopped drinking before joining the Senate in 1970, says that during his one term about ten colleagues sought his help for drinking problems. "And I'm sure there were a lot more who could have used it," he says. Pleading guilty But these are examples from the past, you say, replaced by a health-conscious generation more likely to sneak off Verb 1. sneak off - leave furtively and stealthily; "The lecture was boring and many students slipped out when the instructor turned towards the blackboard" slip away, sneak away, sneak out, steal away to the gym to shoot hoops than to a hideaway to do shots. True, the acknowledged alcoholics are gone from Congress (an important reason why they're more willing to discuss their problems), and alcoholism is less visible on the Hill. But there is plenty of evidence that drinking remains a serious problem among Washington's political leaders. To begin with, there are the statistics. Nationally, per capita [Latin, By the heads or polls.] A term used in the Descent and Distribution of the estate of one who dies without a will. It means to share and share alike according to the number of individuals. alchohol consumption rose steadily from 1960 to a peak in 1981, from which it has declined only slightly. The National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism The National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism (NIAAA), as part of the U.S. National Institutes of Health, supports and conducts biomedical and behavioral research on the causes, consequences, treatment, and prevention of alcoholism and alcohol-related problems. estimates that alcohol abuse today remains at roughly the same level as it was two decades ago and that 10 percent of U.S. adults are alcoholics. Washington still has the highest per capita consumption of alcohol in the country. "I'd feel very safe in saying 10 to 12 percent of members of Congress are in trouble with alcohol," says Bob Witt, a counselor who has treated members of Congress and staff. N. Burton Grace, director of the Total Health and Education Counseling center, which runs a drunk-driver counseling program for the District of Columbia District of Columbia, federal district (2000 pop. 572,059, a 5.7% decrease in population since the 1990 census), 69 sq mi (179 sq km), on the east bank of the Potomac River, coextensive with the city of Washington, D.C. (the capital of the United States). , says just as many public officials are enrolled in his program as ten years ago. "For us to pretend there aren't members of Congress [with drinking problems]," says former Senator Hughes, "is pure bullshit." Beyond the numbers there are recent examples. Rep. Charlie Wilson of Texas says he had a drinking problem until 1985, when he stopped. "I drank a lot and I drank every day." Since he went public, he says, two other members of the House have told him they wished they could stop drinking. Former Rep. Robert Bauman Robert Edmund Bauman (born April 4, 1937) is a former member of the U.S. House of Representatives from Maryland's 1st congressional district. He was elected to the House as a Republican in an August 1973 special election, replacing William O. , a recovering alcoholic who left the House in 1980, says, "I do know of members who drank during session. I knew of congressmen who ran open bars." In recent interviews, aides recalled members showing up drunk on the House and Senate floors. Rep. Barney Frank Barnett "Barney" Frank (born March 31, 1940) is an American politician and a member of the United States House of Representatives. He is a Democrat and has represented Massachusetts's At-large congressional district since 1981. has seen such incidents as well. "There have been a couple of times where people have been obviously drunk on the floor," he says. Moreover, there are at least six current members of Congress who have been stopped for driving while intoxicated driving while intoxicated n. see driving under the influence. or under the influence of alcohol. While driving drunk doesn't mean someone is an alcoholic, counselors say it often indicates a drinking problem. In 1985, Senator Robert Kasten of Wisconsin was arrested after driving through a red light and down the wrong side of the road. He was sentenced to attend a D.C. counseling program for social drinking. Last June, Rep. Dan Rostenkowski Daniel David "Dan" Rostenkowski (born January 2, 1928 in Chicago, Illinois) was a United States Representative from Illinois from 1959 to 1995. He was a member of the United States Democratic Party. He attended Loyola University Chicago. pleaded guilty to drunk driving after doing 70 mph in a 55-mph zone. Rostenkowski, the chairman of the House Ways and Means Committee, had his license revoked. And going further back in history, there's Chappaquidick. Edward Kennedy's alcohol consumption the night he drove off the narrow Cape Cod Cape Cod, narrow peninsula of glacial origin, 399 sq mi (1,033 sq km), SE Mass., extending 65 mi (105 km) E and N into the Atlantic Ocean. It is generally flat, with sand dunes, low hills, and numerous lakes. bridge with Mary Jo Kopechne Mary Jo Kopechne (July 26, 1940 – July 18, 1969) was an American teacher, secretary and administrator, notable for her death in a car accident on Chappaquiddick Island in a car driven by Senator Ted Kennedy. has been a topic of speculation for 18 years. Kennedy said at the time that he'd had only two drinks before escorting Kopechne from the party they attended. A controversial book scheduled for publication in the spring disputes that claim. According to its author, Leo Leo, in astronomy Leo [Lat.,=the lion], northern constellation lying S of Ursa Major and on the ecliptic (apparent path of the sun through the heavens) between Cancer and Virgo; it is one of the constellations of the zodiac. Damore, the book quotes a guest at the party Kennedy attended earlier in the evening as saying the senator had three scotch-and-sodas before going to the second party where he concedes he had two more. Other Kennedy biographies are sprinkled with references to incidents of drunkenness early in his career. Buttermilk buttermilk residual fluid after removal of fat from milk in butter manufacture; a protein-rich supplement fed to pigs. and bourbon Washington officials with a penchant for drinking have no shortage of cocktail parties and receptions to tempt them. The foreign policy establishment thrives on the well-stocked embassy party. Congressmen and their staff face a deluge of receptions. Wilson says he drank excessively because of job pressure and the "god awful" boredom of the mandatory cocktail party circuit. In her autobiography, Betty Ford, a recovering alcoholic, described how alcohol was central to the constant celebration and socializing, from the "magical martinis in the White House" to the "endless toasts at political parties." Former Senator Talmadge's recent autobiography makes a similar point. "A person living and working in Washington, D.C. could attend receptions and parties night and day seven days a week," he writes. "Many of these are social gatherings, but quite a few are also occasions where political business is transacted . . .. [S]omeone who genuinely liked to drink and socialize so·cial·ize v. so·cial·ized, so·cial·iz·ing, so·cial·iz·es v.tr. 1. To place under government or group ownership or control. 2. To make fit for companionship with others; make sociable. was in constant danger of getting hooked on the stuff." While public officials may have easier access to liquor than most people do, all alcohol abusers find ways to drink. What distinguishes the culture of official Washington is the shortage of checks on excessive drinking. It's here that the perks of power play perverse tricks. Alcoholism treatment professionals refer to an "enabler," a person who enables an alcoholic to avoid facing his or her problem. It may be a wife who calls work to tell the boss that her hungover husband has the flu. Or the daughter who cleans up the mess her drunken mother leaves at night. Washington officials, particularly congressmen, live in a colony of enablers--colleagues, family members, and aides adept at disguising drinking problems from the public. A key part of a staff member's job is to cover up for the weaknesses of his boss. That's as true for the senile senile /se·nile/ (se´nil) pertaining to old age; manifesting senility. se·nile adj. 1. Relating to, characteristic of, or resulting from old age. 2. congressman as it is for the alcoholic; the difference is that a senile congressman will not become more senile because of staff help. One former top aide to a senator says that when television cameras first came to the Senate in June 1986 he and other staff members were so concerned their boss might be seen on the floor drunk that they agreed to accompany him there during night sessions. "There is such a cocoon cocoon: see pupa. of protection by staff and reporters," he says. "You've got this entire staff where public images and presentation is the major part of the job." It's always difficult to confront an alcoholic about his or her drinking. Add to that the personality traits of many Capitol Hill aides--"there are a lot of sycophants," former Rep. Bauman notes--and the chances of such confrontations are even less likely. The same principle operates in other branches of the government. In the executive branch, senior civil servants are all too happy to step in and assume the responsibilities of political appointees with drinking problems. The intervention increases the civil servants' power and keeps the appointee APPOINTEE. A person who is appointed or selected for a particular purpose; as the appointee under a power, is the person who is to receive the benefit of the trust or power. from looking bad with the boss. But it also decreases the likelihood that the superior will confront his alcohol abuse. "I have seen some folks at the assistant secretary level in major departments who were clearly incompetent or impaired," says Don Phillips, president of Cope, Inc., a private firm that runs treatment programs for federal employees. "Then a significant person under him assumed a majority of the responsibilities." Colleagues and close friends are no likelier to confront a legislator. "Other politicos in the state who have a vested interest Vested Interest A financial or personal stake one entity has in an asset, security, or transaction. Notes: For example, if you have a mortgage, your bank has a vested interest on the sale of your house. See also: Right in the senator, good friends for years who still have an interest, staff, press, they all [will be reluctant to say anything]," says a former administrative assistant to a senator. Even family members may be hesitant for fear that a confrontation might go public and lose the legislator the seat. In at least one case in 1971, legislators not only tolerated a colleague's drunkenness but counted on it. Richard Bolling recalls that part of the strategy for expanding the House Rules Committee assumed a particular congressman would stay so drunk he wouldn't show up for a key vote. "I'm not proud of it, but it happened," he says. Special privileges have held true even in the Senate dining room, where serving alcohol has been forbidden for many years. Thirsty senators have been able to get around the rules with a system of codes, says Robert Parker. He says, for example, one senator would order tomato juice, which to Parker meant Bloody Mays. Former Senate doorkeeper Hurst, wrote in his book, The Sweetest Little Club in the World that Senator Carl Hayden would enter the Senate dining room in the morning "after a toot the night before" and ask for buttermilk. "This was the signal for a certain waiter to go get something from the private stock--a double shot of bourbon, which was served to the senator in an iced-tea glass of buttermilk." This band of protection often enables public officials to keep drinking even when most people would have been caught. In part, that's because most problem drinkers have bosses. And an increasing number of companies have employee assistance programs in which supervisors can help, often force, employees to get treatment early. Congress has required all federal agencies to set up these programs too. But Congress exempted itself. Even the police contribute to the problem, often showing reluctance to arrest congressmen for drunk driving or other crimes. After Carl Albert was stopped after his suspicious car accident, when Congress was still setting the salaries for D.C. police, he told officers on the scene, "You can't arrest me. I got you your raise." Often they either don't want to rock the boat or believe that these incidents fall under the immunity provision of the Constitution, which protects a congressman from being arrested during the performance of duties like driving home from the Capitol. In March 1983, police in Montgomery County, Maryland Montgomery County of the U.S. state of Maryland is situated just north of Washington, D.C. and Southwest of Baltimore. It is one of the most affluent counties in the nation[1], and has the highest percentage (29. stopped Rep. Louis Stokes Louis Stokes (born February 23, 1925 in Cleveland, Ohio) is a Democratic politician from Ohio. He served in the United States House of Representatives. Born in Cleveland, Stokes and his brother Carl B. for drunk driving but initially didn't file charges because they thought congressional immunity protected him. Two days later, after a police department lawyer informed them that drunk driving wasn't a constitutional right for congressmen, police charged him. Stokes, who said he had had only two drinks, was found guilty of driving while under the influence but not guilty of the more serious charge of driving while intoxicated. Exhibiting what might be considered a strong case of denial, he castigated the media for its "rush to judgment" in reporting the incident. "I always knew that someday, racism and bigotry in the media would raise its ugly head against me, too." Stokes, then chairman of the House Ethics Committee ethics committee A multidisciplinary hospital body composed of a broad spectrum of personnel–eg, physicians, nurses, social workers, priests, and others, which addresses the moral and ethical issues within the hospital. See DNR, Institutional review board. , paid for his legal fees out of campaign funds. Today Stokes is chairman of the House Intelligence Committee. One former congressman told a recent meeting of Alcoholics Anonymous Alcoholics Anonymous (AA), worldwide organization dedicated to the treatment of alcoholics; founded 1935 by two alcoholics, one a New York broker, the other an Ohio physician. that he once woke up in a cab not knowing where he was. He started screaming at the cab driver cab·driv·er also cab driver n. One who drives a taxicab for hire. cab driver n → taxista m/f cab driver n → , who retaliated by taking him to a police station where the drunk congressman then tried to beat up a cop. The police detained him but released him when he finally explained he was a congressman. Being a member of Congress, he told the AA meeting, hurt him in the long run because it kept him from getting help. Won't even appear drunk Surely, one can't help but think, an official in the spotlight couldn't cover up a drinking problem for long. It soon would become obvious at least to colleagues and friends and probably to the press. Hence the skepticism about Deaver's claims. But to understand how people can perform competently at the same time alcohol is wearing them down and impairing their abilities, we need to understand how alcohol affects the brain. For starters, you don't have to be an alcoholic for drinking to affect the mind's work capacity. Alcoholism is a medical condition in which the body develops a chemical dependency chemical dependency n. A physical and psychological habituation to a mood- or mind-altering drug, such as alcohol or cocaine. chemical dependency on alcohol. When an alcoholic stops drinking, he or she will experience withdrawal symptoms Withdrawal symptoms A group of physical or mental symptoms that may occur when a person suddenly stops using a drug to which he or she has become dependent. . Heavy drinkers who are not alcoholics can still suffer impairment in a variety of ways. Physically, the alcohol wears down the body. Emotionally, it is likely to cause increased irritability irritability /ir·ri·ta·bil·i·ty/ (ir?i-tah-bil´i-te) the quality of being irritable. myotatic irritability the ability of a muscle to contract in response to stretching. and other behavioral changes. And mentally, it causes what physicians call "cognitive impairment," hindering the ability to recall information, make sound judgments, think creatively, and solve problems. Most of us known from occasional nights of excess that when we get drunk we will be impaired both while intoxicated and the next morning. But for regular drinkers cognitive impairment lasts longer, diminishing those intellectual functions even when the person isn't drunk or hung over, according to Dr. Boris Tabakoff, scientific director for the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcholism. And, as Harold Hughes, notes without a trace of sarcasm, "The mind is the key organ used as a member of Congress." Consider the case of Wilbur Mills, whose drinking occurred mostly after hours Adv. 1. after hours - not during regular hours; "he often worked after hours" . When I asked Mills, who now speaks on behalf of Alcoholics Anonymous, whether he thought his drinking had affected his work quality he said, "No. At least it didn't affect my judgment." How did he know? "I went back and checked my votes." And why did he have to go back and check his votes? "Well," he said, "I was experiencing alcoholic blackouts throughout the whole period." Brain cells can adapt over time and learn to function in the presence of alcohol. This is the building of tolerance. The problem is that when the person wakes up in the morning and doesn't get alcohol, the cell has to adjust back to functioning without alcohol. Over time, the constant adjustment and readjustment re·ad·just tr.v. re·ad·just·ed, re·ad·just·ing, re·ad·justs To adjust or arrange again. re causes enduring, sometimes irreversible damage. So there's a key difference between a politician who sleeps around with models half his age and a politician who drinks too much: one activity kills brain cells and the other doesn't. Heavy drinkers can develop such a high tolerance that they won't even appear drunk. And the mind as a whole can adapt by managing the brain's incapacity The absence of legal ability, competence, or qualifications. An individual incapacitated by infancy, for example, does not have the legal ability to enter into certain types of agreements, such as marriage or contracts. , the mental equivalent of favoring a healthy leg over an injured one. For example, an individual can perform adequately, or even well, by concentrating on a smaller number of jobs and delegating the rest. "I am often amazed to see how fighter pilots, air traffic controllers, commanding officers--people with really demanding jobs--manage to do jobs well," says Douglas M. Grodon, who runs the treatment program at Bethesda Naval Hospital. In fact, Wilbur Mills seemed so adept at guiding complex tax bills through the House that most reporters were surprised to learn of his problem once he announced it. So it's not suspicious that many of Michael Deaver's friends and colleagues claim to have been surprised when they heard about his problem. "There was little to give me away," he writes in the draft of a book to be released in February. For one thing, Deaver devoured three rolls of breath mints List of breath mints is a comprehensive list of breath mint brands:
Slang for an individual homeowner who strips the equity out of his or her home through mortgage refinancing. Proceeds are generally not re-invested, but spent on consumer goods. Notes: Most people get rich by saving and investing wisely. or make love to my wife--or anyone else's wife--on the steps of Congress. But clearly I was headed for a disaster." A cozy, comfortable arrangement Where does this leave reporters? While alcohol abuse is likely to affect a legislator's mental capacity, it might not noticeably affect his job performance. Even the most alert reporter will have some trouble determining how the congressman's gray matter is faring on any given day. Knowing how much a member drinks isn't enough to go on because different people handle alcohol differently. Besides, it's very difficult to distinguish a legislator who can't figure out the National Porkbarrel Appreciation Act because too much liquor has tormented his brain cells from one who can't figure it out under any circumstances. Even personality changes can be ascribed to many different causes. One reporter who covered Deaver now recalls episodes that, in retrospect, may have shown hints of alcoholism but that he wrote off as signs of pressure typical to many White House officials. "There was some erraticness," the reporter says, "but he wasn't erratic in a way that was different from anyone else." For a long time, such subtleties weren't a problem: reporters and editors didn't cover alcoholism at all. More startling star·tle v. star·tled, star·tling, star·tles v.tr. 1. To cause to make a quick involuntary movement or start. 2. To alarm, frighten, or surprise suddenly. See Synonyms at frighten. than Drew Pearson's and Jack Anderson's scoop about Mendel Rivers was that none of the defense reporters who covered Rivers broke the story first. Even more remarkable, reporters covering Joe McCarthy knew he drank heavily but didn't report it until after his censure. "It was part of that response to ignore personal peccadillos," says Seth Kantor, a long time Capitol Hill correspondent, now with Cox newspapers. One reason is that heavy drinking was common among journalists themselves and was often seen as a sign of bravado. In a recent column arguing that reporters who work in glass cubicles shouldn't throw stones, David Broder recalled that during the 1960 presidential campaign, if one journalist was too smashed to file, another reporter would cover for him, filing under the incapacitated in·ca·pac·i·tate tr.v. in·ca·pac·i·tat·ed, in·ca·pac·i·tat·ing, in·ca·pac·i·tates 1. To deprive of strength or ability; disable. 2. To make legally ineligible; disqualify. journalist's byline, using chunks from other reporters' articles. Journalists, in turn, ignored the "private foibles" of the candidates. "It was a cozy, comfortable arrangement all around," Broder wrote. In addition, reporters often knew of an official's drinking but refrained from putting it in print because they could point to no direct effect on job performance. Alan Cromley of the Daily Oklahoman, says he wrote about Carl Albert's traffic problems, but little more, even though he had heard about Albert occasionally being intoxicated at cocktail parties. "He could have made a real spectacle and it probably wouldn't have been written about," Cromley says. "We just never saw any evidence it affected his job." Similarly, reporters covering Herman Talmadge got dramatically conflicting signals. They noted that despite his drinking the senator was always up jogging at 4:30 a.m. and at the office early. "Everybody knew he drank occasionally, but he had work habits that were so phenomenal that we ignored it," recalls Jim Stewart Jim Stewart might refer to:
Reporters held out for a blatant example of liquor altering public policy. Eileen Shanahan, who covered Russell Long for The New York Times, found it was nearly impossible to meet this standard. She knew Long had a drinking problem because she had seen him clearly intoxicated on a number of occasions. In 1967, she thought she finally had a chance to write about it. Long was holding up an important tax bill as a way of killing an income tax checkoff A system whereby an employer regularly deducts a portion of an employee's wages to pay union dues or initiation fees. The checkoff system is very attractive to a union since the collection of dues can be costly and time-consuming. for presidential candidates. "Each morning [Majority Leader Mike] Mansfield would talk him into letting the bill go," Shanahan says. "Then, in the afternoon, Long, full of booze, would harangue the Senate about how awful that provision was" and refuse to let the bill through. This went on for about a week. Shanahan filed a story that said something to this effect: "Russell Long, clearly intoxicated, said such and such . . .." But her editors at The New York Times didn't think it was fit to print. "How do you know he was intoxicated?" Shanahan recalls them cabling from New York. "Because I stood next to him and his breath nearly knocked me off my feet," she said. "How do you know he didn't just have bad breath?" they asked. "Because a few times he was so rambunctious two guys had to carry him off the floor," she said. "How do you know he wasn't just overtaken by a sudden fever?" Shanahan lost the argument, which she describes as one of the biggest fights of her career. The reference never appeared in print. Other reporters wrote simply that Long was in "high spirits Noun 1. high spirits - a feeling of joy and pride lightness, elation joy, joyfulness, joyousness - the emotion of great happiness euphoria, euphory - a feeling of great (usually exaggerated) elation high spirits npl ." Journalistic mores probably have changed enough that if this incident were to happen today, at least some newspapers would write about it. But there are still reasons thorough coverage of drinking may not occur. For example, as the Rivers case shows, the reporters who are most likely to know if a congressman drinks too much are the ones who can least afford to alienate him. Hometown reporters in Washington or beat reporters covering a certain area will be reluctant to cut off their news lifelines. More often journalists are simply warded off by the sheer ambiguity of the cases. Unlike adultery or drug consumption, which pose yes or no questions--did he do it or not?--problem drinking is more difficult to judge. The dominant rule among journalists has always been: if you can't prove it affects job performance, don't write about it. And since that's almost impossible to do, very little is written. But there are signs of change. For example, Texas papers did report on the drinking of "Goodtime Charlie" Wilson. Unfortunately, they usually referred to it euphemistically eu·phe·mism n. The act or an example of substituting a mild, indirect, or vague term for one considered harsh, blunt, or offensive: "Euphemisms such as 'slumber room' . . . as "partying," only a modest step away from the coverage of the senator in "high spirits." After Wilson quit drinking, the press started to ask the right questions. The Lufkin News, for example, quoted Wilson's administrative assistant, Charlie Schnabel, as saying that abstinence has "given [Wilson] more time to think and work on the mornings after." The drinking had "created what I call a dependability gap," Schnabel said. "People began to think he could no longer be depended on." The big test case for how journalists will cover drinking in the post-Gary Hart era is that of Senator Daniel P. Moynihan. Here the press is groping grope v. groped, grop·ing, gropes v.intr. 1. To reach about uncertainly; feel one's way: groped for the telephone. 2. a bit, but is headed in the right direction. Several publications have weitten that Moynihan might have an alcohol problem. In an article last year by David Remnick, The Washington Post took an important step toward a new coverage of drinking. Remnick quoted by name a source who gave one estimate of how much Moynihan drinks, an amount that some might consider a lot. The source: Moynihan himself. "I go home and have two or three drinks with my wife," Moynihan said, "and split a bottle of claret." When Remnick asked if drinking was "for him a problem in any way, Moynihan is quiet for awhile, then says slowly, 'No. I hope not. Here I am 59 years old . . . without a day's break since 1965 or 1964. A steady life--one wife, three kids, three mortgages.'" Both the Post and The New York Times also quoted former Moynihan aides who said the senator's drinking didn't affect his job performance. They point to Moynihan's leadership on welfare reform as proof that he hasn't lost a step. "It's not the kind of thing where he's ever incapacitated when he has to be working," an exaide told the Times. Indeed, while several of the former staff people I talked to said that they thought Moynihan drinks a lot--some said too much for his own good--none could cite an instance when drinking had noticeably affected the senator's work. None of the other articles have offered such proof either. Of course determining sobriety is particularly difficult with Moynihan because he always sounds a little like he's drunk. He slightly slurs his speech, wanders off on puzzling historical digressions about Lord Palmerston and the history of the interstate highway system, and spits out words in a staccato blitz that challenges the most attentive listener. But former staff members say they have never seen him publicly intoxicated. If drinking has affected Moynihan it has been in more ambiguous ways, in making him more "feckless feck·less adj. 1. Lacking purpose or vitality; feeble or ineffective. 2. Careless and irresponsible. [Scots feck, effect (alteration of effect) + -less. ," as one former aide delicately put it, or in thwarting his potential. But that is impossible to prove, and even if one could, it would be difficult to show how it hurt the people of New York. As his wife Elizabeth said, "He hasn't been arrested for drunk driving or fallen into the fountain at the Plaza." Coming to Moynihan's defense in a Newsweek column, George Will George Frederick Will (born May 4, 1941) is a Pulitzer Prize-winning, conservative American newspaper columnist, journalist, and author. Education and early career Will was born in Champaign, Illinois, the son of Frederick L. Will and Louise Hendrickson Will. attacked the reporting as "voyeurism Voyeurism See also Eavesdropping. Actaeon turned into stag for watching Artemis bathe. [Gk. Myth.: Leach, 8] elders of Babylon watch Susanna bathe. in the name of the public's sacred 'right to know.'" Will did land some punches, justifiably criticizing the Times for using innuendo-packed fuzz words. The Times avoided having to discuss how much Moynihan drinks by writing that "political analysts" were predicting that "an aggressive challenger" will tar Moynihan by "raising awkward questions about Mr. Moynihan's longstanding reputation as a hard-drinking Irishman." But Will went on to castigate cas·ti·gate tr.v. cas·ti·gat·ed, cas·ti·gat·ing, cas·ti·gates 1. To inflict severe punishment on. See Synonyms at punish. 2. To criticize severely. the press for writing about Moynihan's drinking without proof that it affected his job performance, declaring that "a personal attribute [i.e. Moynihan's drinking] becomes a legitimate public concern when it affects the person's conduct of public responsibilities." Will misses the lesson of the Talmadge, Wilson, Deaver, Bauman, and Mills cases: alcohol may be impairing abilities and performance in subtle but important ways without causing a blatant failure to discharge "public responsibilities." Simply put, the old standard offered by Will and others misses most public officials whose job performance is being affected by alcohol. "That's wrong" Heavy, regular drinking should be reported-- even if it never occurs during session and even if there's no definitive proof that it affects job performance. If a public official has so little self-control that he appears drunk in front of colleagues or the press, it is worth noting. But that reporting should only be part of a larger story about the official. Has he slipped over the years? Is he trusted by his colleagues? In other words Adv. 1. in other words - otherwise stated; "in other words, we are broke" put differently , put it in perspective. As Laurence Barrett, who covered Deaver for Time, says, reporters shouldn't write about drinking by "painting it in electric blue and billboarding it," but by putting it in perspective. The Post's failure to come up with conclusive proof that liquor has made Moynihan a worse senator does not mean his drinking isn't newsworthy. In fact, in most cases voters have not kicked officials out of office when a drinking problem has became public, particularly if the legislator was trying to get help. Charlie Wilson's district returned him to office by a two-to-one margin after he revealed he drank excessively. The problem shouldn't be ignored until the legislator pisses in his pants on the floor of the Senate. Wilbur Mills wishes someone had confronted him. He is now known as the guy who showed up with Fanne Foxe Fanne Foxe (born Annabelle Battistella on February 14, 1936 in Nueve de Julio, Argentina) was a dancer best known for being involved in a sex scandal surrounding Arkansas congressman Wilbur Mills, one of the most powerful men in the House of Representatives and a 1972 at the Tidal Basin instead of one of the most respected members of Congress of his time. He doesn't blame anyone else for his own troubles. But the one touch of indignation he did show during our conversation concerned the staff and press who had covered up for other alcoholic congressmen. "They turned their head, they shielded them and that's wrong," he says. "No alcoholic should be shielded if they ever want to get permanently sober." |
|
||||||||||||||||

Printer friendly
Cite/link
Email
Feedback
Reader Opinion