Printer Friendly
The Free Library
6,673,412 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

Good hosts: we consider the effects of Germany's willingness to be a receptive host for the ambitions of foreign architects.


One of the most formative experiences of my architectural education was an early '80s field trip to the newly completed Staatsgalerie in Stuttgart. As callow students we were astonished a·ston·ish  
tr.v. as·ton·ished, as·ton·ish·ing, as·ton·ish·es
To fill with sudden wonder or amazement. See Synonyms at surprise.
 by the scale and assurance of it all, beguiled be·guile  
tr.v. be·guiled, be·guil·ing, be·guiles
1. To deceive by guile; delude. See Synonyms at deceive.

2.
 by the ironic take on Classicism, the integration of museum and city, the punky punk·y  
n.
Variant of punkie.

Noun 1. punky - minute two-winged insect that sucks the blood of mammals and birds and other insects
biting midge, no-see-um, punkey, punkie
 blasts of colour. Our end of year projects were peppered with striated striated /stri·at·ed/ (stri´at-ed) having stripes or striae.

striate, striated

having streaks or striae, e.g. striate retinopathy.


striate border
see brush border.
 stone drums, fat pink balustrades and serpentine glazing, the follies of impressionable youth imitating without really understanding.

But what made an equally profound impression was the sense of esteem in which Stirling was evidently held, not only by his client and the local politicians, whose vision and support enabled him to realise such a major project, but also by the public, who voted with their feet and transformed what was essentially a provincial museum into a hugely popular national cultural attraction. In Germany anything seemed possible, but back in Britain, Big Jim was regarded as a difficult figure making difficult buildings that seemed to wilfully court both critical opprobrium OPPROBRIUM, civil law. Ignominy; shame; infamy. (q.v.)  and practical problems. (Our earlier field trips had also taken us to the Cambridge History Faculty Library and the leaking, languishing Florey Building in Oxford). Stuttgart effectively made Stirling and provided the onus for a series of large-scale German projects that consolidated his reputation.

Over twenty years later, I can imagine another equally callow generation of students being toured, equally awestruck awe·struck   also awe·strick·en
adj.
Full of awe.


awestruck
Adjective

overcome or filled with awe

Adj. 1.
, around Zaha Hadid's Phaeno Science Centre in Wolfsburg (p42). Doubtless they will go on to imitate Hadid's concrete contortions while maybe also pondering the paradox of how it is that she can build so confidently and inventively outwith Wikipedia does not currently have an encyclopedia article for .

You may like to search Wiktionary for "" instead.

To begin an article here, feel free to [ edit this page], but please do not create a mere dictionary definition.
 the UK. Hadid is another 'difficult' prophet without honour in Britain who owes much of her career to German patronage. Vitra kickstarted it with the request to design a Fire Station for its Weil am Rhein Weil am Rhein is a German town and commune situated on the east bank of the River Rhine, and close to the point at which the Swiss, French and German borders meet. It is the most southwesterly town in Germany.  campus (AR June 1993). Gradually she has moved into cruise control, with projects such as Landform land·form  
n.
One of the features that make up the earth's surface, such as a plain, mountain, or valley.



landform  

A recognizable, naturally formed feature on the Earth's surface.
 One (also in Weil), the administration centre for BMW BMW
 in full Bayerische Motoren Werke AG

German automaker. Founded as an aircraft engine manufacturer in 1916, the company assumed the name Bayerische Motoren Werke and became known for its high-speed motorcycles in the 1920s.
 in Leipzig (AR June 2005) and now the publicly popular and critically acclaimed Phaeno, which may turn out to be her Staatsgalerie.

Hadid and Stirling are by no means the only 'britischer Architekten' to thrive in Germany. Norman Foster famously remodelled the Reichstag (AR July 1999), though politicians drew the line at his attempts to streamline the 'big fat hen' of the German eagle. Will Alsop began his career on a Hamburg quayside quay·side  
n.
The area adjacent to a quay or wharf or a system of quays, especially in a port city.

quayside quay nKai m 
, Ian Ritchie reinterpreted Crystal Palace for the Leipziger Messchalle (AR December 1993) and Nicholas Grimshaw made an armadillo-shaped mark on Berlin with his Ludwig Erhard Haus (AR January 1999). David Chipperfield's architecture of sobriety and reticence has also found fertile ground with a new Literature Museum in Marbach and his ongoing remodelling of Berlin's Museum Island.

Germany--host nation

In the year in which Germany hosts the World Cup and an impressive roster of foreign architects are eagerly pursuing commissions there, it seems appropriate to consider Germany's reputation as a host nation for architecture. Thus the projects shown in this issue are not necessarily typical of German architecture, yet certain German conditions--imaginative patronage, civic ambition, technical inventiveness, the status and role of the architect--have helped to make them possible. Why does Germany still seem a receptive milieu for challenging architectural ideas from abroad and what are the wider implications of such apparent enlightenment?

Since reunification re·u·ni·fy  
tr.v. re·u·ni·fied, re·u·ni·fy·ing, re·u·ni·fies
To cause (a group, party, state, or sect) to become unified again after being divided.
, Germany has assiduously courted foreign superstars to drive forward high profile projects, notably in the recasting and rebuilding of Berlin, but also in other urban centres, from Hamburg in the north to Munich in the south, and eastwards in the depressed zones of the former GDR GDR

See Global Depositary Receipt (GDR).
. Ritchie's Leipziger Messehalle and Hadid's BMW building, for instance, are quavering beacons in a post industrial wasteland whose populace is still defecting to the west. In this issue, Herzog & de Meuron's library for the Technical University of Cottbus (p64) near the Polish border attempts to inject some civic bravado into a chronically despondent urban condition.

Meinhard von Gerkan of Hamburg-based practice von Gerkan Marg has clear views on why outsiders are so highly favoured. 'I suspect that Germany's great willingness to import foreign architects is due to a cultural and political inferiority complex. This may be the result of its history, or a subliminal subliminal /sub·lim·i·nal/ (-lim´i-n'l) below the threshold of sensation or conscious awareness.

sub·lim·i·nal
adj.
1. Below the threshold of conscious perception. Used of stimuli.
 compensation for the very pronounced German self confidence in public affairs.' (1) Big imported stars have the resources to gear up for the costly circus of international competitions and the chutzpah chutz·pah also hutz·pah  
n.
Utter nerve; effrontery: "has the chutzpah to claim a lock on God and morality" New York Times.
 required to provide glossy signature buildings (the German car industry, for instance, is falling over itself to commission marketable foreign talent, AR June 2005). Some, though, are still capable of giving their pattern books a local twist. Frank Gehry's MARTa Museum in Herford (p56) is a surprising essay in local brick while Renzo Piano's department store in Cologne (p60) manifests wider urban ambitions. The omnipresence of brilliant outsiders, however, can be a double-edged sword, contriving to marginalise Verb 1. marginalise - relegate to a lower or outer edge, as of specific groups of people; "We must not marginalize the poor in our society"
marginalize

interact - act together or towards others or with others; "He should interact more with his colleagues"
 native talent. It must be hoped that the younger generation of German architects will still be able to find a voice despite their country's recent history of political convulsion convulsion, sudden, violent, involuntary contraction of the muscles of the body, often accompanied by loss of consciousness. It is not known what causes the abnormal impulses from the brain that result in convulsive seizures, since the disturbance may arise in normal  and economic stagnation.

David Chipperfield has some interesting theories on the success of the foreign legion, believing that many German architects lack a degree of flexibility especially when dealing with client committees and that a willingness to compromise is seen both by the German profession and its architectural critics as a measure of weakness. In an essay on Chipperfield's German museum projects, Kurt Forster notes that '... (German) architects have inscribed in·scribe  
tr.v. in·scribed, in·scrib·ing, in·scribes
1.
a. To write, print, carve, or engrave (words or letters) on or in a surface.

b. To mark or engrave (a surface) with words or letters.
 stubbornness on their banners in order to defend and realise their artistic aspirations'. (2) But Chipperfield also acknowledges that the status of the architect in Germany still counts for something. 'In Germany there is a demand that the architect performs. You are asked to be an architect. In Britain you have to smuggle it in through the back door. You are essentially seen as a professional consultant who will bring some design to the project. In Germany you are seen as the cultural captain, you are making these decisions and you can respond to that'. (3)

Crucially, this notion of the supreme generalist is backed up by a sophisticated engineering culture and a responsive building industry. 'The German construction industry is the most confident in the world', remarked Wolfsburg project architect Christos Passas at a recent Architectural Association lecture. Even so, the complexity of the Phaeno Science Centre structure taxed the technical capabilities of its builders. Paul Scott, project engineer of Adams Kara Taylor, observes that 'In Germany there are quite traditional ways of producing drawings. We had to step out of that for this project. Drawing traditions were questioned a lot, as were materials and the way things were built.' (4) Yet somehow this untried and untested synergy of architecture and engineering, computer whizzery and craft skills came together and its reservoir of accumulated knowledge will gradually feed back into and enrich the continuum of architectural evolution. Only, perhaps, in Germany.

(1) New Britische Architektur in Deutschland/New British Architecture in Germany, Michael Jenner, Munich, Prestel, 2000, p25.

(2) DAM Jahrbuch 2005, edited by Ingeborg Flagge et al. Munich, Prestel, 2005, p22.

(3) Jenner, ibid, p25.

(4) Concrete Quarterly, Summer 2004.
COPYRIGHT 2006 EMAP Architecture
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2006, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Slessor, Catherine
Publication:The Architectural Review
Geographic Code:4EUGE
Date:Apr 1, 2006
Words:1199
Previous Article:Peter Cook: from London to Vienna via Paris and Norway--the style is international.
Next Article:Destination Wolfsburg: burg or a berg ... stronghold or floating mass?... Phaeno is open to interpretation.
Topics:



Related Articles
Die Fuggerkapelle bei St. Anna in Augsburg.
Obituary.(Samuel Mockbee)(Obituary)
Frank Lloyd Wright. (Art Watch).(Museo de Arte Moderno hosts the exposition "Frank Lloyd Wright and the living city")(Brief Article)
Greening the European City. (View).
Human Hubner: the Steiner system of education offers many lessons to society in general. Peter Hubner crystallizes them.
DOG DAYS IN AMERICA CHINESE STUDENTS EXPERIENCE NEW YEAR IN FOREIGN LAND.(Valley News)
US-EU Split Over Iran.
Planning overseas assignments.(Checklist 006)
ARAB-EUROPEAN RELATIONS - Sept 28 - EU Makes 'Progress' With Iran.
IRAN - Iran Oil Show To Cut Sanctions Cost.

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles