Gender and preferences for malaria prevention in Tigray, Ethiopia.
One of the goals of the literature on intrahousehold allocation is to determine whether husbands and wives would make the same choices when confronted with decisions regarding family welfare. The literature to date suggests that they would not, a finding that has important policy implications. For example, if wives purchase more health care for their families than husbands, policies that place more resources in the hands of women would have significantly different impacts on household welfare than policies to increase the incomes of men. This depends, of course, on women having the opportunity and resources to make these purchase decisions.
This paper examines whether husbands and wives in northern Ethiopia make the same choices with regard to an important form of health care--malaria prevention (2) Specifically, we compare husbands' and wives' demand functions for two different goods that prevent malaria malaria, infectious parasitic disease that can be either acute or chronic and is frequently recurrent. Malaria is common in Africa, Central and South America, the Mediterranean countries, Asia, and many of the Pacific islands. . Our interest lies not only in seeing whether the demand functions of husbands and wives differ, but also in how these demand functions are affected by family composition. Holding family size constant, will households with more children buy more bednets or fewer bednets, and will this decision differ between husbands and wives?
While the policy implications of these decisions are important in their own right, this research also contributes to the growing literature on intra-household allocation decisions. As noted by Thomas (1997), tests of the hypothesis that families maximize a common utility function (the common preference hypothesis) rely on the maintained assumption that purchase decisions depend only on the sum of non-earned incomes in the family. Rejection of the hypothesis rests on showing that the distribution of non-earned incomes within the family affects spending. Measuring non-earned income is, however, fraught fraught
1. Filled with a specified element or elements; charged: an incident fraught with danger; an evening fraught with high drama.
2. with difficulty.
We present a new approach to testing the common preference hypothesis. If one is willing to accept that stated choices reflect preferences, then confronting husbands and wives with such choices provides an alternative method of testing whether they have the same preferences. If preferences differ between husbands and wives, then the common preference model cannot hold.
We illustrate this approach using data collected in the Tembien region of Tigray, Ethiopia, in January 1997. Heads of household or their spouses were asked how many hypothetical Hypothetical is an adjective, meaning of or pertaining to a hypothesis. See:
Whether husbands and wives in Ethiopia have the same demands for malaria prevention depends in part on the form that prevention takes. In the case of a hypothetical malaria vaccine--a private good that, by assumption, would protect each person inoculated with the vaccine for one year--wives would purchase more vaccines for their families at each price than would husbands. There is however, no difference in the impact of family composition on vaccine demand between husbands and wives. In both cases, families with more children purchase/ewer vaccines, holding family size constant.
For bednets--a private good that within households has some of the properties of a public good--we cannot reject the null hypothesis null hypothesis,
n theoretical assumption that a given therapy will have results not statistically different from another treatment.
n that the demand functions are the same. This may be because of the quasi-public nature of the good or because the bednet scenario was administered to about half as many respondents as the vaccine scenario, making it more difficult to reject the null hypothesis of common preferences.
This section develops a theoretical model that combines Becker's (1981) benevolent dictator The benevolent dictator is a more modern version of the classical "enlightened despot", being an undemocratic or authoritarian leader who exercises his or her political power for the benefit of the people rather than exclusively for his or her own self-interest or benefit, or for model and Grossman's (1972) health production model. Becker assumes that a single individual, such as a head of household or their spouse, makes the consumption choices for the entire household. Let us call this person the decision-maker and assume he or she is benevolent be·nev·o·lent
1. Characterized by or suggestive of doing good.
2. Of, concerned with, or organized for the benefit of charity. . Each family member i enters the decision-maker's utility function. Utility is a function of consumption of a numeraire ([X.sub.i]), leisure time ([L.sub.i]), the amount of time spent ill with malaria ([S.sub.i]), and a vector of decision-maker characteristics (Z) such as education, age, and gender. Assuming n family members, utility is given by
U = u[([X.sub.l], ... [X.sub.n],[L.sub.l], ... , [L.sub.n], [S.sub.l], ... [S.sub.n], Z).sup.3] (1)
Grossman's model relates the individual's choice of health inputs to health outcomes. The time spent ill ([S.sub.i]) with malaria by each individual is a function of preventive care Preventive care is a set of measures taken in advance of symptoms to prevent illness or injury. This type of care is best exemplified by routine physical examinations and immunizations. The emphasis is on preventing illnesses before they occur. See also
[S.sub.i] = s([A.sub.i], [M.sub.i], [H.sub.i], E). (2)
The decision-maker maximizes utility subject to the household budget constraint A Budget Constraint represents the combinations of goods and services that a consumer can purchase given current prices and his income. Consumer theory uses the concepts of a budget constraint and a preference ordering to analyze consumer choices. ,
[n.summation summation n. the final argument of an attorney at the close of a trial in which he/she attempts to convince the judge and/or jury of the virtues of the client's case. (See: closing argument) over (i=1)] [I.sub.i] + [n.summation over (i=1)] [w.sub.i] (T - [L.sub.i] - [S.sub.i]) = [n.summation over (i=1)] [X.sub.i] + [p.sub.a] [n.summation over (i=1)] [A.sub.i] + [p.sub.m] [n.summation over (i=1)] [M.sub.i]. (3)
where [n.summation over (i=1)] [I.sub.i] is the sum of each individual's non-earned income (I) and [n.summation over (i=1)] [w.sub.i] (T - [L.sub.i] - [S.sub.i]) is earned income, which is equal to the sum of each individual's wages (w) times the total time available for work (T) minus leisure time (L) and time spent sick (S) with malaria. The sum of these equals total household consumption. This budget constraint indicates household expenditures on consumption, prevention, and treatment cannot exceed household income. The decision-maker selects values of vectors X, L, A, and M to maximize household utility subject to the budget constraint and to the health production functions. This yields a household demand function for preventive care, where [A.sup.*] is the number of vaccines chosen by the decision-maker:
[A.sup.*] = g(I, with, [p.sub.a], [p.sub.m], Z, H, E) (4)
This function indicates that demand for malaria prevention depends on household non-earned income, a vector of wages for each household member, as well as the prices of preventive and mitigating health care, a vector of decision-maker characteristics, a vector of baseline health for each individual, and the prevalence of mosquitoes.
The demand function can be used to examine how the quantity of preventive care purchased changes with the gender of the respondent In Equity practice, the party who answers a bill or other proceeding in equity. The party against whom an appeal or motion, an application for a court order, is instituted and who is required to answer in order to protect his or her interests. and the composition of the household. For example, the literature on intrahousehold allocation suggests that improvements in child health have also been associated with a mothers control over family resources. If true, then we would expect women to purchase more preventive care for their children than men do. Holding household size constant, do households with a large number of children purchase more or less vaccines? How is the answer to this question affected by the gender of the respondent? Answering these questions begins to provide insights into the intrahousehold allocation of preventive health care.
The value of protecting n household members with hypothetical vaccines is the maximum amount of income that can be taken away from the decision-maker while giving him or her [A.sup.*] vaccines and keeping utility constant. Formally, this is the area under the decision-maker's income-compensated (Hicksian) demand curve for vaccines. This can be approximated using equation (4). The total value the decision-maker places on preventing malaria in themselves and members of their household or Willingness To Pay Willingness to pay (WTP) generally refers to the value of a good to a person as what they are willing to pay, sacrifice or exchange for it. See also
WTP Willingness To Pay
WTP Water Treatment Plant
WTP We the People
WTP Waste Treatment Plant
WTP Wireless Transaction Protocol
WTP Winnie The Pooh
WTP Washington Transportation Plan ) for prevention is the area under the demand curve and to the left of household size. This can be written as:
[MATHEMATICAL EXPRESSION NOT REPRODUCIBLE IN ASCII ASCII or American Standard Code for Information Interchange, a set of codes used to represent letters, numbers, a few symbols, and control characters. Originally designed for teletype operations, it has found wide application in computers. ] (5)
Study Site, Research Design, and Sampling
The data were collected in 1997 in the Tembien sector of Tigray province Tigray was a province of Ethiopia. The Tigray Region superseded the province in 1995. By the time of its demise, Tigray had absorbed a number of its neighboring provinces, including Semien, Tembien, Agame and Enderta. , northern Ethiopia as part of a project to assess the demand for malaria prevention and to compute To perform mathematical operations or general computer processing. For an explanation of "The 3 C's," or how the computer processes data, see computer. the medical costs and productivity losses associated with the disease. (4) The value people place on preventing malaria is a function of their economic circumstances and the severity of the disease. In Tigray, the primary activity is subsistence subsistence,
n the state of being supported or remaining alive with a minimum of essentials. cultivation cultivation, tilling or manipulation of the soil, done primarily to eliminate weeds that compete with crops for water and nutrients. Cultivation may be used in crusted soils to increase soil aeration and infiltration of water; it may also be used to move soil to or . Given the relatively small size of their land holdings, the low productivity of their land, and difficulties in gaining access to inputs and technology, many households are unable to produce enough food (Relief Society of Tigray, 1995).
These problems are compounded by the incidence of malaria, which reaches its peak during the harvest each year (Figure 1). Government control activities include spraying in the early part of the transmission season, encouraging environmental control by communities, and training health workers to recognize and treat malaria with chloroquine.
The research design was tailored to the study area. Two-thirds of the households sampled were presented with the hypothetical vaccine scenario and one third with the bednet scenario. Each household was randomly assigned one of five prices for either the hypothetical vaccine or the bednet.
A three-part survey instrument was administered. The first part asked questions about a household's current health status, knowledge of malaria, and expenditures on malaria prevention and treatment. The second part presented the respondent with one of two contingent valuation Contingent valuation is a survey-based economic technique for the valuation of non-market resources, such as environmental preservation or the impact of contamination. While these resources do give people utility, certain aspects of them do not have a market price as they are not scenarios. The third part requested information on the socioeconomic characteristics of the household members.
The hypothetical vaccine scenario started by explaining to the respondent that such a vaccine was not currently and might never become available. Then the enumerator e·nu·mer·ate
tr.v. e·nu·mer·at·ed, e·nu·mer·at·ing, e·nu·mer·ates
1. To count off or name one by one; list: A spokesperson enumerated the strikers' demands.
2. described a vaccine that would prevent the recipient from contracting malaria for one year. The scenario included a detailed description of the commodity, checked respondent understanding of how it worked, and provided reminders of substitute goods and the budget constraint. It was also emphasized that a separate vaccine would need to be purchased for each member of the household in order to protect them from getting malaria for one year.
The respondent was then asked whether he or she would purchase one or more vaccines at one of five randomly assigned prices. The lowest price was Birr birr 1
1. A whirring sound.
2. Strong forward momentum; driving force.
intr.v. birred, birr·ing, birrs
To make a whirring sound. 5 (US$ 1) and the highest price Birr 200 (US$ 32). If the respondent answered 'yes' to the original choice question, he or she was asked how many vaccines would be purchased.
In a separate split sample, respondents received a bednet contingent valuation scenario. This scenario coupled an explanation of how using a bednet reduces the probability of contracting malaria with a demonstration of a double-size polyester polyester, synthetic fiber, produced by the polymerization of the product formed when an alcohol and organic acid react. The outstanding characteristic of polyesters is their ability to resist wrinkling and to spring back into shape when creased. bednet impregnated im·preg·nate
tr.v. im·preg·nat·ed, im·preg·nat·ing, im·preg·nates
1. To make pregnant; inseminate.
2. To fertilize (an ovum, for example).
3. with 1 percent deltamethrin. Again, the scenario checked respondent understanding of how the commodity works, and provided reminders of substitute goods and budget constraints. The respondent was then offered the opportunity to purchase one or more bednets at one of five randomly assigned prices. Prices per bednet ranged from a low of Birr 8 (US$ 1) to a high of Birr 100 (US$ 16).
The sampling strategy employed a three-stage design. Districts were selected in the first stage; villages were selected in the second stage; and households were selected in the third stage. Two points about the choice of respondent should be noted. First, only one individual, either a man or a woman, was interviewed in each household. Second, there was no protocol for selecting whether a man or woman was interviewed. While the choice of households was intended to be random, we cannot guarantee that the gender of the respondent was selected at random.
Eight hundred and eighty-nine field interviews were completed (5). Forty-one respondents were not familiar with malaria and were dropped from the study. This left 569 respondents who received, the hypothetical vaccine scenario and 279 the bednet scenario (Table 1). Approximately 114 interviews were completed for each of the 5 hypothetical vaccine prices and 56 for each of the 5 bednet prices. Fifty-seven percent of our respondents were women and 43 percent were men; thirty-four percent of female respondents were single heads-of-household. (6)
Household Demographic Characteristics
The average household interviewed consisted of five members: two adults, one teenager (12-19 years of age), and two children (0-11 years of age). The mean age of respondents in our sample is 42, with men being slightly above the mean and women being slightly below it. Literacy is low, with only 13 percent of those interviewed claiming they can read a newspaper with ease. There is a considerable disparity dis·par·i·ty
n. pl. dis·par·i·ties
1. The condition or fact of being unequal, as in age, rank, or degree; difference: "narrow the economic disparities among regions and industries" in literacy by gender, with 22 percent of the men in our sample responding that they could read a newspaper with ease, while only 7 percent of women responded in this manner.
Labor markets in Tembien are not well developed, making it difficult to measure wages, (w), in the theoretical model. It is possible to use an agricultural production function-in which output depends on the time input of each family member-to impute impute v. 1) to attach to a person responsibility (and therefore financial liability) for acts or injuries to another, because of a particular relationship, such as mother to child, guardian to ward, employer to employee, or business associates. wages for each household member. However, obtaining measures of time input for each family member remains a difficult empirical task that we chose not to undertake. Instead, we estimate household income and use this as a proxy forw.
Adding together crop production, annualized annualized
Of or relating to a variable that has been mathematically converted to a yearly rate. Inflation and interest rates are generally annualized since it is on this basis that these two variables are ordinarily stated and compared. livestock holdings, and off-farm income provides a measure of annual household income. Mean household income is Birr 1,387 (US$ 220) and the median is Birr 1,157 (US$ 183). There are a number of households with very low incomes. One explanation for this is that these households do not produce enough food to support themselves but have coping mechanisms, such as participating in local 'food for work' programs, not captured in the survey.
There are significant gender-based differences in reported agricultural income, with men reporting larger figures than women do. This suggests either a systematic difference in households in which men and women were interviewed (non-equivalence of test groups) or gender-based recall error (measurement error). Separating households by respondent gender and marital status marital status,
n the legal standing of a person in regard to his or her marriage state. reveals that female-headed households are significantly worse off than all others. This may be because of the absence of adult males to undertake plowing at the onset of the rainy rain·y
adj. rain·i·er, rain·i·est
Characterized by, full of, or bringing rain.
There is also a difference in the incomes reported by married men and women (jointly headed households). Examination of non-agricultural measures of wealth in these households, such as off-farm income, housing characteristics, and household assets (lanterns, beds, radios, shoes, and jerricans) reveals that there are no other significant economic differences between these groups (Table 2). This suggests that there are no systematic differences in economic status between married households with male respondents and those with female respondents.
A possible explanation for differences in the reporting of income can be found in the traditional division of household responsibilities. In northern Ethiopia, while both sexes are equally involved in agricultural production, men are responsible for marketing agricultural surplus (livestock and grain) and women for minding the granary. This could explain why men report higher agricultural income than women: men recall production while women recall consumption.
Malaria in Study Area
Malaria is endemic endemic /en·dem·ic/ (en-dem´ik) present or usually prevalent in a population at all times.
1. in Tembien, with peak transmission coinciding with the beginning of the harvest. Both Plasmodium falciparum Plasmodium fal·cip·a·rum
A protozoan that causes falciparum malaria. and Plasmodium vivax Plasmodium vi·vax
A protozoan that is the most common malarial parasite of humans, causing vivax malaria. are present, with Plasmodium falciparum predominating (Ghebreyesus et al, 1996). (7) There appear to be gender-based differences in the respondents' perception of whether malaria is more serious for adults or for children (Table 3). Forty-eight percent of men believe that malaria is more serious for children, while 48 percent believe that it is equally serious for adults and children. Thirty-seven percent of women believe that malaria is more serious for children and 59 percent believe that it is equally serious for both adults and children. That male respondents perceive malaria to be more serious for children than female respondents counters the conventional wisdom that females are more sensitive to the health of children than males.
Malaria is widespread, with 78 percent of respondents reporting that they have had malaria at least once in their lifetime. Incidence is evenly distributed across household members. Fifty-eight percent of respondents had malaria at least once in the last two years. Fifty-three percent report that at least one other adult in their household had the disease in the last two years. Forty-nine percent report that at least one teenager or child in their household had malaria in the last two years.
A number of factors might contribute to a disparity in reported malaria incidence between the sexes in their lifetime (86 percent for men and 72 percent for women). First, men are generally more mobile than women and children, and thus may be more exposed to infection. Second, 98 percent of the community health workers are men carrying out their duties from their homes (Ghebreyesus et al. 1996). Focus group discussions have revealed that women are reluctant to see male health workers for cultural reasons, thus they may under-report the occurrence of malaria (Ghebreyesus et al. 1996). Finally, males may receive treatment more often and report a higher incidence than females because their health is given priority by the household. This is because males perform critical strenuous stren·u·ous
1. Requiring great effort, energy, or exertion: a strenuous task.
2. Vigorously active; energetic or zealous. agricultural activities, such as plowing, that support the household's agricultural production.
Analysis of Contingent Valuation Responses
The principal choice question asked respondents how many vaccines or bednets they would purchase at one of five randomly assigned prices. Thirty-nine percent of respondents agreed to purchase one or more vaccines. Conditional on buying any, the mean quantity purchased was four and the median three. Sixty-two percent of respondents agreed to purchase one or more bednets, the mean and median quantity purchased were both one.
Cross tabulations reveal that for both vaccines and bednets the quantity purchased decreases with an increase in price (Table 4 and Table 5). The null hypothesis that number purchased does not vary systematically with price is rejected for both goods. (8) This suggests that respondents seriously considered the price information in the scenario and that their responses depended upon the price they received.
This is valuable information for the design of malaria prevention programs. Figure 2, which is based on a sub-sample of Table 4, simulates the purchasing behavior of married men and women in a hypothetical 200-household village. At prices above Birr 20 (US$ 3) per vaccine, married females' demand lies to the right of married males' demand.
The figure suggests that at prices over Birr 20 (US$ 3), demand is systematically higher for married females than for married males. Both revenue and population coverage can be increased by targeting married women. For example, at a price of Birr 40 (US$ 6) per vaccine, an additional Birr 3,160 (US$500) in revenue could be collected by targeting. Not only are revenues increased but coverage also goes up, with seven percent more of the population receiving the vaccine at this price. Of course, this kind of targeting depends on two conditions. The first is that women have some level of decision making power in the household and the second is that the cost of targeting women over targeting households does not outweigh out·weigh
tr.v. out·weighed, out·weigh·ing, out·weighs
1. To weigh more than.
2. To be more significant than; exceed in value or importance: The benefits outweigh the risks. the benefits.
The theoretical model relates the number of hypothetical vaccines a respondent agrees to purchase to a vector of explanatory ex·plan·a·to·ry
Serving or intended to explain: an explanatory paragraph.
ex·plan variables. These variables include household non-earned income, wages, and the prices of preventive and mitigating health care. The discrete nature of the dependent variable and the large number of zeroes and small values suggests that a count regression model is appropriate. The probability density function Probability density function
The function that describes the change of certain realizations for a continuous random variable. , however, is modified so that household size is an upper bound for each observation. In the case of the Poisson model this implies,
[MATHEMATICAL EXPRESSION NOT REPRODUCIBLE IN ASCII] (6)
We refer to this as the Truncated truncated adjective Shortened Poisson model. This model yields convenient expressions for WTP for prevention, which is the area under the household demand curve between zero and n. More formally:
[MATHEMATICAL EXPRESSION NOT REPRODUCIBLE IN ASCII] and [MATHEMATICAL EXPRESSION NOT REPRODUCIBLE IN ASCII] otherwise, (7)
where [MATHEMATICAL EXPRESSION NOT REPRODUCIBLE IN ASCII] is the price at which the decision-maker buys vaccines for all household members.
The Truncated Poisson model can also be used to address the issue of intrahousehold resource allocation resource allocation Managed care The constellation of activities and decisions which form the basis for prioritizing health care needs . The simplest approach to explaining behavioral differences between men and women is to hold all coefficients in the [beta] vector constant across men and women, except for the intercept. This is equivalent to including a dummy variable This article is not about "dummy variables" as that term is usually understood in mathematics. See free variables and bound variables.
In regression analysis, a dummy variable for gender in the model. We refer to this as the "reduced" model.
There are more general tests of behavioral differences between males and females with respect to the decision to purchase malaria prevention. One is to specify the statistical model so that [[lambda].sub.i] = exp exp
2. exponential ([X.sub.1i][[beta].sub.1] + [X.sub.2i][[beta].sub.2]) where [X.sub.2i] is a vector of explanatory variables interacted with gender (female=l). This is similar to specifying separate structural equations to explain the purchasing behavior of men and women but assumes a common error variance. We call this the "full" model.
If the [beta] coefficients of men and women are the same with regard to purchasing malaria prevention, then their responses may be pooled and treated as identical within the context of the statistical model [[lambda].sub.i] = exp([X.sub.1i][[beta].sub.1]). To test this hypothesis we specify the null hypothesis as [H.sub.0]: [[beta].sub.2] = 0 and the alternative as [H.sub.1]: at least one of the parameters in [[beta].sub.2] is not zero. A rejection of the null hypothesis implies that two populations differ, suggesting that we estimate separate models for men and women.
Equation (4) suggests that the number of vaccines or bednets purchased should depend on the price of the good, household income, and size. It might also depend on family composition-the number of adults, teenagers, and children in the family, and on characteristics of the respondent-gender, age, marital status and education-which may influence preferences for-health related goods. The mean and standard deviation of each of the variables are summarized in Table 6.
Household income enters the demand function in log form. Twenty-eight percent of the observations for off-farm wages were missing. These were replaced with zeroes and a dummy variable for missing wages, which takes on a value of one if the wage observation is not present, was included in the model.
The decision-maker's demand also depends on each family member's susceptibility susceptibility
the state of being susceptible. Refers usually to infectious disease but may be to physical factors such as wetting or to psychological factors such as harassment. to malaria and the prevalence of the disease. Susceptibility is a household-specific measure of direct cost of illness in the past year. It is computed as the product of the sample mean direct cost of illness for adults, teenagers, and children times the number of episodes in each age category in the household in the previous year. (9) This weighted average approach was used to avoid issues of endogeneity. A proxy for the prevalence of malaria, altitude altitude, vertical distance of an object above some datum plane, such as mean sea level or a reference point on the earth's surface. It is usually measured by the reduction in atmospheric pressure with height, as shown on a barometer or altimeter. , is also included in the model. This is a good exogenous Exogenous
Describes facts outside the control of the firm. Converse of endogenous. predictor of incidence because the vector is more common at lower altitudes.
Household size can be included in the model as either a discrete or a continuous variable. Both specifications were tested and the magnitude of the coefficients, the number of significant variables, and the WTP results were virtually identical. For brevity Brevity
of short life. [Br. Lit.: I Henry IV]
symbolic of transitoriness of life. [Art: Hall, 54]
cherry orchards where fruit was briefly sold; symbolic of transience. , the results including household size as a continuous variable are presented here.
Household composition is measured by two variables, the number of teenagers and the number of children. Since the number of adults is the omitted category, these variables reflect the trade-off between teenagers or children and adults.
Respondent-level parameters include marital status, gender, age, and ability to read a newspaper. Marital status is captured by a dummy Sham; make-believe; pretended; imitation. Person who serves in place of another, or who serves until the proper person is named or available to take his place (e.g., dummy corporate directors; dummy owners of real estate). equal to one if the respondent is married and his or her spouse is alive. Gender is a dichotomous di·chot·o·mous
1. Divided or dividing into two parts or classifications.
2. Characterized by dichotomy.
di·chot variable in the reduced model, equal to one if the respondent is female. Literacy is measured by whether or not the respondent can read a newspaper with ease.
The model was estimated with both village and enumerator fixed effects. Village effects were not significant and therefore are not included in the final specification. Enumerator effects are significant and their inclusion in the model allows us to control for the influence of enumerators on respondent choices.
The multivariate results for the vaccine scenario are presented in Table 7. Column 1 of the table presents a model in which only the intercept term is allowed to differ by gender (the "reduced" model). Columns 2 and 3 of the table present vaccine demand functions estimated separately for men and for women. The reduced model for vaccines is generally consistent with economic theory. The quantity of vaccines the respondent agrees to purchase varies inversely with price. Respondents at higher altitudes (less exposed to the malaria vector) purchase less vaccines than respondents at lower altitudes. The quantity purchased increases with income and with the higher the cost of treatment. Age of respondent is significant and negative, indicating that older respondents purchase less vaccines. (10) While not presented in Table 7, the results from the model with the full set of interaction terms (the "full" model) indicate that there are significant differences in the effects of price, income, missing wages, household cost of illness, literacy, and age on male and female purchasing behavior. We therefore reject the null hypothesis that men and women have identical demand functions for vaccines and estimate separate demand functions.
Holding income fixed, the price elasticity of females' demand is significantly lower than it is for males, indicating that females are less sensitive to changes in price than males. Male demand is unit elastic at Birr 50 (US$ 8) and female demand unit elastic at Birr 70 (US$ 11). At a price of Birr 100 (US$ 16) the price elasticity of demand Price Elasticity of Demand
A measure of the responsiveness of the quantity demanded of a good to a change in its price. It is calculated as: for male respondents is -2.0 and for females -1.5, implying that a 10 percent increase in price will result in a 20 percent reduction in male demand but only a 15 percent reduction in female demand. These results are consistent with Figure 2.
The income elasticity of demand Income Elasticity of Demand
A measure of the relationship between a change in income and a change in quantity of a good demanded: is significantly higher for females than males. A 10 percent increase in household income produces only a 2.6 percent increase in male demand, whereas it produces a 6.1 percent increase in female demand. (11) Gertler and van der Gagg (1990) note that in industrialized in·dus·tri·al·ize
v. in·dus·tri·al·ized, in·dus·tri·al·iz·ing, in·dus·tri·al·iz·es
1. To develop industry in (a country or society, for example).
2. countries the income elasticity of demand for medical care is typically between 0.2 and 0.3. In Mali, Birdsall et al. (1983) found that the income elasticity of WTP for improvements in health services health services Managed care The benefits covered under a health contract and water supply was around 0.35. (12) In Taiwan, Alberini et al. (1997) place the income elasticity of WTP to avoid an episode of respiratory illness Noun 1. respiratory illness - a disease affecting the respiratory system
respiratory disease, respiratory disorder
adult respiratory distress syndrome, ARDS, wet lung, white lung - acute lung injury characterized by coughing and rales; inflammation of the at 0.45. That the income elasticity of demand is consistent with other studies increases our confidence in the validity of the results.
We can gain insights into intrahousehold allocation by examining the coefficients on teenagers and children in the reduced model. They are both negative and significant, suggesting that the quantity respondents agree to purchase decreases as adults are replaced by teenagers and children in the household. This result makes sense from a productivity perspective, because children contribute less to the household financially than do adults. Furthermore, the coefficient coefficient /co·ef·fi·cient/ (ko?ah-fish´int)
1. an expression of the change or effect produced by variation in certain factors, or of the ratio between two different quantities.
2. on the number of children is three times larger than it is on teenagers. This is consistent with teenagers being better substitutes for adult labor than younger children.
In the full model, there are no significant differences in the effect of the number of teenagers or children on the number of vaccines purchased by male and female decision-makers. In Table 7, the coefficient on children is of approximately the same magnitude for men and women. This suggests males and females have the same preferences for trading the health of adults against the health of children; it also begins to provide an answer to one of the questions posed at the outset of this paper. In the context of this study, both men and women appear to place the same priority on the health of adults over the health of other demographic categories in the household.
The negative coefficient for female respondents in the reduced model suggests that they would purchase fewer hypothetical vaccines than males; however, as noted earlier, this is a crude measure of gender-based differences in demand. The coefficient is negative because it is capturing the interaction between female-headed households and income. Female headed households are systematically worse off than all other types of households in the sample.
The large positive effect of female cost of illness is consistent with females spending more time caring for the ill in their household. The large positive effect of female literacy is consistent with the literature that indicates that there are large social benefits linked to female education in developing countries (World Bank, 1995). The larger negative effect of female age is also driven by the high percentage of older female-headed households in the sample.
Table 8 explores the implications of the male and female demand functions in Table 7 for willingness to pay (WTP) to prevent malaria among all household members. The table presents estimates of the integral under the vaccine demand function by respondent gender and marital status. The mean WTP of married females is about 18 percent more than it is for married males. Married males' median WTP for vaccines is Birr 151 (US$ 24) and for married females it is Birr 181 (US$ 29). The number of observations in single parent households is very low, decreasing confidence in these results.
That married females' are, at both the mean and median, willing to pay more for hypothetical vaccines than married males is consistent with the evidence in the literature on intrahousehold allocation. This literature suggests that giving women greater control over household resources will result in a more direct impact on household welfare, and in particular child welfare, than giving it to men. In Burkina Faso Burkina Faso (burkē`nə fä`sō), republic (2005 est. pop. 13,925,000), 105,869 sq mi (274,200 sq km), W Africa. It borders on Mali in the west and north, on Niger in the northeast, on Benin in the southeast, and on Togo, Ghana, and , reallocating factors of production from men's plots to women's plots increases overall crop yields by about ten percent (Udry et al., 1995). In Bangladesh, women borrowing 100 additional Taka ta·ka
See Table at currency.
[Bengali increase household consumption by 18 Taka, men by 11 Taka (Pitt and Khandker, 1999). In Brazil, Thomas (1997) finds that additional income leads women to increase spending on food by about three percent and men by about one-half of a percent.
It also raises an important policy issue. Even if wives are willing to pay more to protect their household from malaria than husbands are, they may not have the freedom to act on this. Under such conditions, it is ambiguous how the policy analyst should treat women's preferences. It should also be emphasized that the role women play in household decision making in Ethiopia differs depending on their ethnic and cultural affiliation. Therefore, project's design can be improved by understanding intrahousehold resource allocation in the target population.
The multivariate results for the bednet scenario are presented in Table 9, which is similar in structure to Table 7. While the signs of the coefficients in the reduced model for bednets are generally consistent with economic theory, only the coefficient of price is statistically significant at conventional levels. This is partly due to the smaller sample size for the bednet scenario (279 households v. 569 households for the vaccine scenario).
The smaller sample size may also explain why, when the model with the full set of gender interaction terms is estimated, we are unable to reject the null hypothesis that coefficient vector of the interaction terms is the zero vector. This result, nevertheless, suggests observations for men and women may be pooled and treated as identical. When this test is repeated on the sub-sample of jointly-headed households, the findings are the same.
Comparing males' and females' responses to questions about how much preventive health care they will purchase for their household begins to shed light on the questions asked in the introduction. In the formal test of the common preference model, we reject the null hypothesis that male and female behavioral characteristics can be pooled in the context of demand for vaccines. In the case of men and women living with their spouses, rejection of the null hypothesis suggests the common preference model will hold only if the husband or wife is a dictator dictator, originally a Roman magistrate appointed to rule the state in times of emergency; in modern usage, an absolutist or autocratic ruler who assumes extraconstitutional powers. From 501 B.C. until the abolition of the office in 44 B.C., Rome had 88 dictators. . As noted at the outset, this test rests on the assumption that there are gender specific utility functions (e.g. all husbands have comparable utility functions and all wives have comparable utility functions).
A more surprising result, however, is that are no significant differences in the rate at which male and female respondents substitute children for adults when choosing the number of vaccines to buy for their household. This suggests that both men and women consider the health of adults a priority because they are the primary income earners. Or, stated slightly differently, while married women are willing to pay more for vaccines than married men are, the choice of who in the household gets the vaccines is the same.
[FIGURE 1 OMITTED]
[FIGURE 2 OMITTED]
Alberini, A., M. Cropper CROPPER, contracts. One who, having no interest in the land, works it in consideration of receiving a portion of the crop for his labor. 2 Rawle, R. 12. , T. Fu, A. Krupnick, J. Liu, D. Shaw and W. Harrington. 1997. Valuing Health Effects of Air Pollution in Developing Countries: The Case of Taiwan, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 34: 107-126
Becker, G. 1981. Altruism altruism (ăl`trĭz`əm), concept in philosophy and psychology that holds that the interests of others, rather than of the self, can motivate an individual. in the Family and Selfishness in the Market Place Economica, 48(189): 1-15
Birdsall, M, F. Orivel, M. Aisnworth, and P. Chuhan. 1983. Three Studies on Cost Recovery in Social Sector Projects. CDP CDP (cytidine diphosphate): see cytosine.
(1) (Certificate in Data Processing) An earlier award for the successful completion of an examination in hardware, software, systems analysis, programming, management and accounting, Discussion Paper 1983-8. World Bank, Washington, DC
Cropper, M., J. Lampietti, C. Poulos, M. Haile, and D. Whittington. 1999. The Value of Preventing Malaria in Tigray ,Ehtiopia. Draft Report submitted to WHO/TDR.
Ghebreyesus, T., T. Alemayehu, A. Bosnian, K. Witten, and A. Teklehaimanot. 1996. Community Participation in Malaria Control in Tigray region Tigray Region (ትግራይ ክልል Tigrāy Kilil) is the northernmost of the nine ethnic regions (kililoch) of Ethiopia containing the homeland of the Tigray people. It was formerly known as Region 1. Ethiopia,^4cto Tropica, 61: 145-156
Grossman, M. 1972. On the Concept of Health Capital and the Demand for Health, Journal of Political Economy, 80(2): 223-55
Lampietti, J. A. 1999. Do Husbands and Wives Make the Same Choices? Evidence from Northern Ethiopia. Economics Letters Economics Letters is a scholarly peer-reviewed journal of economics that publishes concise communications (letters) that provide a means of rapid and efficient dissemination of new results, models and methods in all fields of economic research. Published by Elsevier. 62: 253-260
Loehman, E., and V. De. 1982. Application of Stochastic By guesswork; by chance; using or containing random values.
stochastic - probabilistic Choice Modeling to Policy Analysis of Public Goods: A Case Study of Air Quality Improvements, The Review of Economics and Statistics, 64(3): 474-480
Relief Society of Tigray. 1995. Farming Systems, Resource Management and Household Coping Strategies The German Freudian psychoanalyst Karen Horney defined four so-called coping strategies to define interpersonal relations, one describing psychologically healthy individuals, the others describing neurotic states. in Northern Ethiopia: Report of a Social and Agro-Ecological Baseline Study in Central Tigray.
Thomas. D. 1997. Incomes, Expenditures, and Health Outcomes: Evidence on Intrahousehold Resource Allocation. In Haddad L., J. Hoddinot, and H. Alderman ALDERMAN. An officer, generally appointed or elected in towns corporate, or cities, possessing various powers in different places.
2. The aldermen of the cities of Pennsylvania, possess all the powers and jurisdictions civil and criminal of justices of the , eds. Intrahousehold Resource Allocation in Developing Countries, Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Noun 1. Johns Hopkins - United States financier and philanthropist who left money to found the university and hospital that bear his name in Baltimore (1795-1873)
World Bank. 1995. Toward Gender Equality: The Role of Public Policy. The World Bank, Washington, DC
(1) The findings, interpretations, and conclusions expressed in this paper are entirely those of the authors and should not in any way be attributed to the World Health Organization or the World Bank.
(2) This paper builds on a paper by Lampietti (1999).
(3) This model is observationally equivalent to the common preference model in which members of the household have identical preferences over the vectors X, L, and S.
(4) A detailed description of the project and its results may be found in The Value of Preventing Malaria in Tigray, Ethiopia (Cropper et al. 1999).
(5) We had to delete To remove an item of data from a file or to remove a file from the disk. See file wipe, trash and undelete.
1. (operating system) delete - (Or "erase") To make a file inaccessible. one record because the contingent valuation question was not completed properly.
(6) A female head of household is defined as a female respondent who answered no to the survey question "Are you married?" or to the survey question "Is your spouse alive?"
(7) Plasmodium falciparum is the more virulent vir·u·lent
1. Extremely infectious, malignant, or poisonous. Used of a disease or toxin.
2. Capable of causing disease by breaking down protective mechanisms of the host. Used of a pathogen.
3. of the two species.
(8) For hypothetical vaccines [[chi square chi square (kī),
n a nonparametric statistic used with discrete data in the form of frequency count (nominal data) or percentages or proportions that can be reduced to frequencies. ].sub.(12)] = 136.33 and for bednets [[chi square].sub.(12)] = 52.04
(9) The missing observations (less than 1 percent) for this variable were imputed Attributed vicariously.
In the legal sense, the term imputed is used to describe an action, fact, or quality, the knowledge of which is charged to an individual based upon the actions of another for whom the individual is responsible rather than on the individual's using ordinary least squares regression.
(10) These results did not change when age and age squared were included in specification.
(11) In the reduced model the income elasticity of demand is 0.4, suggesting that a 10 percent increase in income results in a 4.0 percent increase in demand.
(12) The income elasticity of demand is not the same as the income elasticity of WTP when quantity is fixed, as it was in these studies.
Julian A. Lampietti (a), Christine Poulos (b), Maureen L. Cropper (a), Haile Mitiku (c), and Dale Whittington Dale Whittington (September 23, 1959 - June 14, 2003), was an American racecar driver.
Born in Orlando, Florida as the youngest of the three Whittington brothers. All three are sons of Dick Whittington, '50's race car owner.  . (b)
(a) The World Bank
(b) University of North Carolina North Carolina, state in the SE United States. It is bordered by the Atlantic Ocean (E), South Carolina and Georgia (S), Tennessee (W), and Virginia (N). Facts and Figures
Area, 52,586 sq mi (136,198 sq km). Pop. , Chapel Hill
(c) Mekele University College, Mekele, Ethiopia
This article is based on Julian A. Lampietti's Ph.D. dissertation dis·ser·ta·tion
A lengthy, formal treatise, especially one written by a candidate for the doctoral degree at a university; a thesis.
1. "Assessing Preferences for Health Care: Willingness to Pay for Malaria Prevention in Northern Ethiopia" (University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill is a public, coeducational, research university located in Chapel Hill, North Carolina, United States. Also known as The University of North Carolina, Carolina, North Carolina, or simply UNC , 1999). The research received financial support from the UNDP/World Bank/WHO Special Programme for Research and Training in Tropical Disease Tropical diseases are infectious diseases that either occur uniquely in tropical and subtropical regions (which is rare) or, more commonly, are either more widespread in the tropics or more difficult to prevent or control. (TDR TDR - time domain reflectometer ). Thanks are due to V. K. Smith for inspiring the ideas presented here and to Bill Evans
William John Evans (better known as Bill Evans) (August 16, 1929 – September 15, 1980) was one of the most famous and influential American jazz pianists of 20th-century. for providing the SAS (1) (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC, www.sas.com) A software company that specializes in data warehousing and decision support software based on the SAS System. Founded in 1976, SAS is one of the world's largest privately held software companies. See SAS System. code used to estimate the model. The field work would not have been possible without the help of K. Komives and T. Ghebreyesus. Earlier drafts of this paper benefited from comments by Robert Conrad, Milkeuger, John Villani, Andrew Mason, Hanan Jacoby, Lant Pritchett Lant Pritchett is an American developmental economist.
He was born in Utah in 1959 and raised in Boise, Idaho. He graduated from Brigham Young University in 1983 with a B.S. , Francois Bourginion, Shahidur Khandker, and Nobu Fuwa.
Table 1. Treatment and Sample Size Hypothetical vaccine scenario bednet scenario Price (Birr) n (percent) Price (Birr) n (percent) 5 117 (21%) 8 58 (21%) 20 120 (21%) 20 59 (21%) 40 117 (21%) 40 54 (19%) 100 118 (21%) 60 52 (19%) 200 97 (17%) 100 56 (20%) Total 569 (100%) Total 279 (100%) Table 2. Jointly Headed Household Income and Assets n Mean Men N Mean Women Annual agric. income (Birr) 342 1423 322 1207 * Annual wage income (Birr) 255 318 218 332 Number of rooms 342 1.25 321 1.21 Number of buildings 342 2.46 318 2.36 Lamp 342 1.12 322 1.10 Bed 342 0.13 322 0.14 Radio 342 0.34 322 0.18 Bicycle 342 0.02 321 0.01 Shoes 147 1.01 179 0.94 Jerrican 147 0.50 178 0.50 * indicates difference between men and women is significant at the 5 percent level Table 3. Perception of Seriousness of Malaria (percent) Total Male Female Adults 34 4% 4% Children 351 48% 37% * Equally serious for adults and children 459 48% 59% * Not serious for adults and children 2 0% 0% * Difference is significant at 5 percent level Table 4. Number of Hypothetical Vaccines Purchased by Price (n=569) Price (Birr) 0 vaccines 1-3 vaccines 4-6 vaccines >=7 vaccines 5 24% 35% 33% 8% 20 48% 25% 22% 6% 40 68% 21% 10% 2% 100 81% 10% 6% 3% 200 90% 6% 4% 0% Table 5. Number of Bednets Purchased by Price (n=279) Price (Birr) 0 nets 1 net 2 nets 3 or more nets 8 19% 21% 43% 17% 20 22% 33% 32% 13% 40 41% 37% 20% 2% 60 52% 23% 19% 6% 100 63% 25% 11% 2% Table 6. Means and Standard Deviations of Variables in Models Vaccine Model Variable N Mean Std.Dev. Number of vaccines purchased 569 1.45 2.19 Price (Birr) 569 68.30 68.22 Log income (Thousand Birr) 569 2.40 0.84 Missing wage (1 if no wage) 569 0.28 0.45 Number of teenagers 569 0.81 0.91 Number of children 569 1.95 1.35 Household direct COI (Birr) 569 18.25 16.48 Married (1 if married) 569 0.82 0.39 Gender (1 if female) 569 0.53 0.50 Read (1 if read easily) 569 0.38 0.49 Age (years) 569 42.56 14.25 Alt (hundred meters) 569 16.80 1.54 Household size 569 5.09 2.00 Enumerator_2 569 0.03 0.18 Enumerator_3 569 0.04 0.20 Enumerator_4 569 0.09 0.29 Enumerator_5 569 0.08 0.27 Enumerator_6 569 0.09 0.28 Enumerator_7 569 0.08 0.27 Enumerator_8 569 0.03 0.18 Enumerator_9 569 0.04 0.20 Enumerator_10 569 0.04 0.19 Enumerator_11 569 0.09 0.28 Enumerator_12 569 0.04 0.20 Enumerator_13 569 0.04 0.19 Enumerator_14 569 0.04 0.19 Enumerator_16 569 0.04 0.20 Enumerator_17 569 0.10 0.30 Enumerator_18 569 0.05 0.22 Enumerator_19 569 0.04 0.20 Bednet Model Variable N Mean Std.Dev. Number of vaccines purchased 279 1.07 1.14 Price (Birr) 279 44.89 32.78 Log income (Thousand Birr) 279 1.97 1.23 Missing wage (1 if no wage) 279 0.39 0.49 Number of teenagers 279 0.56 0.78 Number of children 279 1.74 1.33 Household direct COI (Birr) 279 22.26 16.45 Married (1 if married) 279 0.70 0.46 Gender (1 if female) 279 0.66 0.47 Read (1 if read easily) 279 0.53 0.50 Age (years) 279 41.04 15.04 Alt (hundred meters) 279 16.51 1.89 Household size 279 4.53 2.03 Enumerator_2 279 0.06 0.24 Enumerator_3 279 0.08 0.26 Enumerator_4 279 0.00 0.00 Enumerator_5 279 0.00 0.00 Enumerator_6 279 0.00 0.00 Enumerator_7 279 0.00 0.00 Enumerator_8 279 0.08 0.28 Enumerator_9 279 0.09 0.29 Enumerator_10 279 0.09 0.28 Enumerator_11 279 0.00 0.06 Enumerator_12 279 0.08 0.27 Enumerator_13 279 0.08 0.27 Enumerator_14 279 0.09 0.29 Enumerator_16 279 0.08 0.28 Enumerator_17 279 0.00 0.06 Enumerator_18 279 0.09 0.29 Enumerator_19 279 0.09 0.28 Table 7. Parameter Estimates for Hypothetical Vaccine Models (n = 569) Variable Reduced Model Males Females Price -0.016 (a) -0.020 (a) -0.015 (a) (Birr) 0.001 0.001 0.001 Log household income 0.391 (a) 0.256 (a) 0.608 (a) (log thousands of Birr) 0.047 0.085 0.085 Missing wage 0.062 -0.478 (b) 0.564 (a) (1 if no wage) 0.100 0.251 0.127 Number of teenagers -0.087 (b) -0.216 (a) -0.024 (number of individuals) 0.055 0.098 0.099 Number of children -0.305 (a) -0.22l (a) -0.239 (a) (number of individuals) 0.043 0.075 0.080 Household cost of illness 0.015 (a) -0.004 0.03l (a) (Birr) 0.002 0.003 0.004 Married 0.455 (a) 0.701 (b) 0.281 (1 if married) 0.131 0.434 0.183 Gender -0.308 (a) (1 if female) 0.070 Read 0.299 (a) 0.116 0.536 (a) (1 if read easily) 0.069 0.118 0.121 Age -0.023 (a) -0.008 (b) -0.03 (a) (years) 0.003 0.004 0.006 Altitude -0.095 (a) -0.098 (a) -0.026 (hundreds of meters) 0.018 0.031 0.035 Household size -0.025 -0.098 -0.118 (number of individuals) 0.040 0.067 0.081 Intercept 2.792 (a) 2.594 (a) -0.104 0.410 0.840 0.806 Notes: Standard errors are below parameter estimates. (a) Significant at the 5% level (b) Significant at the 10% level Variable Reduced Model Males Females Enumerator_2 -0.252 -0.119 0.349 0.433 0.713 0.891 Enumerator_3 1.765 (a) 1.416 (a) 0.825 (a) 0.198 0.401 0.452 Enumerator_4 -0.949 (a) -0.339 -0.955 (a) 0.193 0.325 0.470 Enumerator_5 -0.636 (a) -1.460 1.260 (a) 0.217 0.405 0.463 Enumerator_6 1.427 (a) 0.855a 1.148 (a) 0.185 0.356 0.393 Enumerator_7 -0.852 -1.114 0.215 0.350 Enumerator_8 0.051 -1.426 2.313 (a) 0.246 0.710 0.744 Enumerator_9 0.026 -0.726 1.413 (a) 0.292 0.618 0.683 Enumerator_lO 1.032 (a) 0.193 (a) 1.714 (a) 0.220 0.410 0.472 Enumerator_ll -0.426 (a) -1.043 1.079 (a) 0.207 0.386 0.431 Enumerator_12 -0.362 -0.714 1.066 (a) 0.240 0.438 0.521 Enumerator_13 1.201 (a) 0.478 (a) 1.557 (a) 0.213 0.366 0.453 Enumerator_14 0.865 (a) 1.953a -1.140 (a) 0.195 0.421 0.468 Enumerator_16 -1.693 (a) -2.151 0.418 (a) 0.345 0.507 0.722 Enumerator_17 0.131 -0.224b 0.410 (a) 0.192 0.368 0.415 Enumerator_18 0.143 -0.946 1.904 (a) 0.214 0.385 0.471 Enumerator_19 1.075 (a) 0.267 1.393 (a) 0.196 0.709 0.732 Notes: Standard errors are below parameter estimates. (a) Significant at the 5% level (b) Significant at the 10% level Table 8. Willingness to Pay by Respondent Gender and Marital Status (Birr) Hypothetical Vaccines Males Females Mean Median Mean Median Married 219 151 267 * 181 N 255 211 Single 210 123 161 95 N 11 92 * Indicates difference between mean male and female WTP is significant at 5% level Table 9. Parameter Estimates for Insecticide Treated Net Models (n = 279) Variable Reduced Males Females Model Price -0.015 (a) -0.017 (a) -0.015 (a) (Birr) 0.003 0.006 0.003 Log household income 0.092 0.198 0.055 (log thousands of Birr) 0.082 0.398 0.098 Missing wage 0.047 -0.084 0.219 (1 if no wage) 0.258 0.728 0.312 Number teenagers 0.143 0.418 0.056 (number) 0.144 0.417 0.188 Number children 0.048 0.332 -0.054 (number) 0.125 0.382 0.157 Household cost of illness -0.003 0.010 -0.009 (Birr) 0.006 0.016 0.007 Married -0.020 0.670 -0.090 (1 if married) 0.237 0.903 0.282 Gender 0.067 (1 if female) 0.189 Read 0.002 0.125 -0.120 (1 if read easily) 0.200 0.506 0.285 Age -0.010 -0.018 -0.007 (years) 0.007 0.019 0.009 Altitude 0.054 -0.003 0.084 (hundreds of meters) 0.046 0.126 0.057 Household size 0.039 -0.257 0.130 (number of individuals) 0.116 0.327 0.140 Intercept -0.368 0.996 -1.190 0.882 2.557 1.140 Notes: Standard errors are below parameter estimates. (a) Significant at the 5% level (b) Significant at the 10% level Variable Truncated Males Females Poisson Enumerator_2 -0.120 -1.437 0.161 0.405 2.064 0.448 Enumerator_3 0.729 -0.114 1.215 (a) 0.307 1.203 0.377 Enumerator_8 0.106 -0.445 0.342 0.365 1.358 0.441 Enumerator_9 0.491 -0.357 0.931 (b) 0.377 0.926 0.524 Enumerator_lO -0.056 -1.115 0.432 0.414 1.098 0.513 Enumerator_11 -0.783 -0.686 -1.086 (b) 0.383 0.814 0.606 Enumerator_13 0.027 -0.662 0.384 0.438 1.106 0.578 Enumerator_14 0.511 -0.409 0.831 (a) 0.325 0.740 0.398 Enumerator_16 -0.850 -0.712 -0.664 0.446 1.068 0.583 Enumerator_l8 -0.086 -0.632 0.255 0.397 0.901 0.511 Enumerator_19 0.058 -0.440 0.260 0.456 1.172 0.569 Notes: Standard errors are below parameter estimates. (a) Significant at the 5% level (b) Significant at the 10% level