Printer Friendly
The Free Library
4,488,568 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

Fruit use: eminent domain in New Orleans.


THE UNUSUAL term usufruct
Usufruct
A legal term describing a situation wherein a person or company has a temporary right to use and derive income from someone else's property (provided that it isn't damaged).

Notes:
Usufruct is recognized only in a few jurisdictions in North America.
See also: Personal Property
 comes from the Latin words usus and fructus, meaning "use" and "fruit." Napoleon converted the use of other people's figurative fruit into a legal concept, by which an owner of a property could sell or lease his right to profit from it to a second party. You can still find usufruct in the legal codes of most everywhere the emperor once cast his shadow, from France to Poland to Louisiana.

Now two affordable-housing advocates in New Orleans want to revive usufruct in the wake of Hurricane Katrina, so that--in theory, anyway--the 50,000 to 1,000 water-damaged properties in the area can be quickly rehabilitated by the state. According to tentative plans sketched by New Orleans Finance Authority Executive Director Mtumishi St. Julien and bond lawyer Wayne Neveu, homeowners who lacked money for repairs could sign the job over to the government, which would clean it up, rent it out to an "essential worker" (cop, firefighter, etc.), use the proceeds to pay the mortgage, and then in three or five years hit the owners with a bill in exchange for resuming the use of their fruits.

"You are not going to rebuild New Orleans unless you are able to get government access to private property private property n. land not owned by the government or dedicated to public use." St. Julien told the Los Angeles Times in October. "If government does not solve that problem, everything else is just talk. It is foolish to believe otherwise."

Luckily for those who shudder at the idea of the Louisiana government becoming the largest construction firm and residential real estate company on the Gulf Coast, the usufruct revival has yet to worm its way to the state legislature. Unluckily, the less obscure legal concepts of eminent domain and governmental "redevelopment corporations" are alive and well, and on the verge of being expanded in New Orleans by the U.S. Congress.

Rep. Richard Baker (R-La.) introduced the Louisiana Recovery Corporation Act on October 20. Although he tried gamely to distance himself from the Democratic usufructers and to insist the legislation fits his history as a "property-rights advocate," the results would be similar: a huge government entity buying the rights to private property, rebuilding, profiting, then negotiating with the owner years later.

And if the original owner doesn't like the government's terms? "The Corporation," the bill states, "may exercise the power of eminent domain."
COPYRIGHT 2006 Reason Foundation
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2006, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Welch, Matt
Publication:Reason
Geographic Code:1U7LA
Date:Feb 1, 2006
Words:389
Previous Article:Couch potato subsidies: TV goes digital.(Brief Article)
Next Article:Quotes.
Topics:



Related Articles
We want your house. (Eminent Domain Takings).(Brief Article)
AUTO TRACK PLANNED AT CALIFORNIA CITY.(News)
CITY AGENCY CONSIDERS ITS OPTIONS EMINENT DOMAIN AUTHORITY MAY BE EXTENDED 12 YEARS.(News)
Taking a closer look at the controversial Kelo case.(INSIDERS OUTLOOK)
"Like undermining motherhood and apple pie": why are California Dems in local government embracing eminent domain abuse?(Democrats)
Maintaining a fair balance in Eminent Domain.(INSIDE CONSTRUCTION & DESIGN)
Eminent domain--for the greater good? The U.S. Supreme Court decision in Kelo v. New London has prompted states to look at their own eminent domain...
Eminent domain battle is imminent.(real estate regulation)
Eminent domain shouldn't be curtailed by legislation.(COMMENTARY)
Searching for Alex Kozinski.(Letter to the editor)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2008 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles