Printer Friendly
The Free Library
23,383,293 articles and books

Fifty years of international business theory and beyond.


* As the field of international business has matured, there have been shills in the core unit of analysis. First, there was analysis at country level, using national statistics on trade and foreign direct investment (FDI FDI

See: Foreign direct investment
). Next, the focus shifted to the multinational enterprise (MNE) and the parent's firm specific advantages (FSAs). Eventually the MNE was analysed as a network and the subsidiary became a unit of analysis.

* We untangle the last fifty years of international business theory using a classification by these three units of analysis. This is the country-specific advantage (CSA (1) (Canadian Standards Association, Toronto, Ontario, A standards-defining organization founded in 1919. It is involved in many industries, including electronics, communications and information technology. ) and firm-specific advantage (FSA FSA Financial Services Authority
FSA Food Standards Agency (UK)
FSA Farm Service Agency (USDA)
FSA Financial Services Agency (Japan) 
) matrix. Will this integrative framework continue to be useful in the future?

We demonstrate that this is likely as the CSA/FSA matrix permits integration of potentially useful alternative units of analysis, including the broad region of the triad.

* Looking forward, we develop a new framework, visualized in two matrices, to show how distance really matters and how FSAs function in international business. Key to this are the concepts of compounded distance and resource recombination recombination, process of "shuffling" of genes by which new combinations can be generated. In recombination through sexual reproduction, the offspring's complete set of genes differs from that of either parent, being rather a combination of genes from both parents.  barriers facing MNEs when operating across national borders.

Keywords: Multinational enterprises (MNEs) * Firm specific advantages (FSAs) * Country specific advantages (CSAs) * Compounded distance * Subsidiary * Network * Regions * Resource recombination barriers * Theory


In this paper, we examine the literature on international business (IB) over the last fifty years. We do this in the first three sections. In the second half of the paper, we develop new frameworks to analyze unresolved Not completed; not finished; not linked together. See resolve.  issues in the theoretical and empirical literature of IB that will require research in the future.

As the field of IB has matured, there have been shifts in the core unit of analysis. In the pre-Hymer (1960) era, international economists dominated the field and focused on national competitiveness at the country level, using national statistics on trade and foreign investment. During the 1970s, the focus shifted to foreign direct investment by the multinational enterprise (MNE) and the transfer across borders of its firm specific advantages (FSAs), both stand-alone competences (such as patented R&D knowledge and brand names) and higher-order capabilities. As of the 1980s, more attention was devoted to the MNE as a differentiated network with the MNE subsidiary as the unit of analysis. In addition, inside the MNE, substantial academic work was performed focusing on entrepreneurial growth in specific cultural, economic and institutional contexts. Finally, a number of studies focused more on clusters and networks of independent companies.

The IB literature during the past 50 years has used various units of analysis. Mainstream neoclassical international economics builds upon the strong assumption that differences in factor endowments across borders will lead to international transactions, whether transfers of capital or goods. In other words Adv. 1. in other words - otherwise stated; "in other words, we are broke"
put differently
, it is assumed that there is not really an organizational challenge to be addressed in creating an efficient system of international exchange. Vernon (1966) and Dunning (1958) extend this work, but recognize the importance of firms in their pioneering IB studies, which represent the first stage of modern IB analysis. Vernon's product life cycle framework, published in 1966, basically argue that the United States United States, officially United States of America, republic (2005 est. pop. 295,734,000), 3,539,227 sq mi (9,166,598 sq km), North America. The United States is the world's third largest country in population and the fourth largest country in area.  has a technology-related, country specific advantage (CSA) embedded Inserted into. See embedded system.  in US owned multinational enterprises (MNEs). These US parent firms create miniature replicas (branch plants) in Canada and Western Europe Western Europe

The countries of western Europe, especially those that are allied with the United States and Canada in the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (established 1949 and usually known as NATO).
 such that technology would be transferred from the parent firm to these foreign subsidiaries. This leads to an indirect transfer of technology to host countries and to other benefits of foreign ownership. In the UK context, Dunning (1958) observes that the UK subsidiaries of US MNEs upgrade the macroeconomic mac·ro·ec·o·nom·ics  
n. (used with a sing. verb)
The study of the overall aspects and workings of a national economy, such as income, output, and the interrelationship among diverse economic sectors.
 infrastructure as they manufacture technologically intensive products and services; they upgrade UKjobs; they pay taxes; they increase productivity and otherwise improve the CSAs of the United Kingdom. Rugman (1980b) confirms this outcome in a Canadian context, with Canadian subsidiaries of US MNEs providing net economic benefits to Canada.

Clearly, the underlying unit of analysis in the work by Vernon (1966), Dunning (1958) and Rugman (I 980b) is the country factors, even though their analyses really focus on how these country factors interact with MNE activity as a conduit conduit /con·du·it/ (kon´doo-it) channel.

ileal conduit  the surgical anastomosis of the ureters to one end of a detached segment of ileum, the other end being used to form a stoma on the
 for their absorption at the micro-level in the home country, and subsequent diffusion/exploitation internationally.

Hymer (1960), as the intellectual father of the second stage in modern IB studies, pioneered a fundamental change in the unit of analysis adopted in IB studies: he positions the MNE and its FSAs at the core of his analytical approach. Hymer's great insight is his recognition of the MNE's possession of FSAs, required to offset the liability of foreignness (LOF LOF Loss Of Frame
LOF Loss of Function
LOF Leap of Faith
LOF Line Of Fire
LOF Lord of the Flies (book by William Golding)
LOF Lots of Fun
LOF Length of File
LOF Lube, Oil, & Filter
) when operating abroad (Hymer 1960; Zaheer 1995). Unfortunately, Hymer (1960) exaggerates the potential of MNEs to exploit their FSAs as monopolists by exerting efforts to close markets and exercising excessive market power. Structural market imperfections as a result of government regulation and MNEs creating entry barriers, ultimately at the expense of consumer welfare, may exist but are now less common (Dunning and Rugman 1985). The reality today is that few MNEs, even among the world's largest ones, actually benefit from uncontestable and uncontested monopolies. The absence of such market power is demonstrated by the relatively uncommon occurrence of truly global firms, with a balanced distribution of their sales and assets across the triad of North America North America, third largest continent (1990 est. pop. 365,000,000), c.9,400,000 sq mi (24,346,000 sq km), the northern of the two continents of the Western Hemisphere. , Europe and Asia: few firms appear able to emulate em·u·late  
tr.v. em·u·lat·ed, em·u·lat·ing, em·u·lates
1. To strive to equal or excel, especially through imitation: an older pupil whose accomplishments and style I emulated.

 their home region success in the host regions of the triad (Rugman 2005; Rugman and Verbeke 2004, 2008a, b, c).

The liability of foreignness, meaning the impact of various forms of distance (cultural, economic, institutional and geographic), explains why MNEs have difficulties operating in foreign markets, especially when facing rivals not hindered by such distance. The Uppsala model of international expansion proposed by Johanson and Vahlne (1977) essentially provides the mirror image of Hymer's analysis. The Uppsala model suggests that there are stages of internationalisation (programming) internationalisation - (i18n, globalisation, enabling, software enabling) The process and philosophy of making software portable to other locales.

For successful localisation, products must be technically and culturally neutral.
, whereby the potential benefits of exploiting FSAs abroad need to be weighted against the risks of operating in unknown foreign environments and the costs of learning to do business there. Consequently, according to according to
1. As stated or indicated by; on the authority of: according to historians.

2. In keeping with: according to instructions.

 the original 1977 model, firms initially expand in nearby geographic countries that may have similar CSAs. As the firm learns to overcome the LOF it then expands into more distant country markets, at which stage the unfamiliar cultural, economic, and political environment will be offset against the firm's ability of recombining its FSAs with host country CSAs.

Recent work by Hennart (2009b) rethinks the nature of such recombinations of FSAs and host country CSAs, and demonstrates that in many cases the boundary between CSAs and FSAs becomes somewhat blurred blur  
v. blurred, blur·ring, blurs
1. To make indistinct and hazy in outline or appearance; obscure.

2. To smear or stain; smudge.

. Indeed, if some of the CSAs leading to international expansion are actually not freely accessible, but access is controlled by host country actors (e.g., closed distribution networks preventing sales to customers or local monopolies on natural resources ownership and exploitation preventing purchasing these resources), then the challenge for the MNE is to develop relationships, i.e., a type of location bound (LB) FSA with powerful local actors to open up access to the desired CSAs. We define LB FSAs later.

The Uppsala model represents one intellectual approach to explain MNE entry mode selection. Here the firm can choose to exploit its FSAs abroad, either through exporting, FDI with wholly owned subsidiaries, licensing, or international joint ventures. In this literature, the country remains as a co-unit of analysis, along with the MNE. However, the nature of this research places more emphasis on MNE strategic management process issues and the roles of managers in the parent firm.

In the third stage of contemporary work in IB, the unit of analysis has become the subsidiary of the MNE and the subsidiary manager. The clearest expression of this approach can be found in Birkinshaw (1996, 1997, 2000). Refining work by Rugman and Bennett (1982), and Rugman (1983b) on world product mandates in a Canadian context, Birkinshaw (1996) has developed the concept of subsidiary initiatives, whereby the focus is really on innovative recombinations of both home and host country CSAs, and the FSAs held (or being newly developed) by the MNE's units in these countries. He observes that such innovative recombinations can ultimately generate new types of FSAs across the MNE network and strengthen the MNE's overall competitive advantage.

In summary, over the last fifty years, the literature of IB has developed from a somewhat basic focus on CSAs and FSAs that are clearly separate and distinguishable from each other (Rugman 1981) towards a more nuanced understanding of the linkages between them and the manner in which MNE managers in the home and host economies will interact to develop novel recombinations of home and host CSAs and the FSAs held by various MNE units, dispersed dis·perse  
v. dis·persed, dis·pers·ing, dis·pers·es
a. To drive off or scatter in different directions: The police dispersed the crowd.

 across borders. Overall, the unit of analysis has shifted from the country-level, to the parent MNE, and now increasingly to the subsidiary level, often with a focus of the subsidiary's role in the internal MNE network. Below, we expand on the implications of adopting alternative units of analysis in IB research.

From Country Level to Firm Level Analysis

Several theoretical approaches have been used to explain the MNE's strategic investment motives, foreign entry mode, ownership, structure decisions and performance. This section provides a reflective review and synthesis of the literature at firm level and the interactions between country and firm level. Hymer (1960) explains why a firm engages in international operations Internal Operations (I.O., IO or I/O) is a fictional American Intelligence Agency in Wildstorm comics. It was originally called International Operations. I.O. first appeared in WildC.A.T.S. volume 1 #1 (August, 1992) and was created by Brandon Choi and Jim Lee.  by bringing the focus from the country level to the firm level. Hymer moves towards an analysis of the MNE based upon industrial organization theories by showing that the MNE is an institution for international production rather than international exchange. He distinguishes between FDI and portfolio investment in terms of the presence of firm-level control in the former and the absence thereof in the latter. Hymer rejects country level portfolio investment theory with its simplifying (and empirically incorrect) assumptions of the movements of capital as an explanation for FDI, Dunning and Rugman (1985).

For Hymer, two conditions have to be fulfilled to explain the existence of FDI: (i) foreign firms must possess a countervailing advantage over local firms to make such investment viable, and (ii) the market for selling this advantage must be imperfect imperfect: see tense. . Hymer argues that for firms to own and control value-adding activities, they must possess some kind of monopolistic advantages sufficient to outweigh out·weigh  
tr.v. out·weighed, out·weigh·ing, out·weighs
1. To weigh more than.

2. To be more significant than; exceed in value or importance: The benefits outweigh the risks.
 the liability of foreignness (LOF), arising from lack of knowledge about local customs, differences in local tastes, and unfamiliar legal systems, when competing with indigenous firms in host country production. The MNE's proprietary FSAs typically include elements such as product differentiation Product Differentiation

A source of competitive advantage that depends on producing some item that is regarded to have unique and valuable characteristics.
 ability, superior marketing and distribution skills, trade marks TRADE MARKS. Signs, writings or tickets put upon manufactured goods, to distinguish them from others.
     2. It seems at one time to have been thought that no man acquired a right in a particular mark or stamp. 2 Atk. 484.
 or brand names, access to raw materials, economies of scale, access to capital, intangible assets such as proprietary technology, patents, management skills, the ability to achieve vertical and horizontal integration Horizontal Integration

When a company expands its business into different products that are similar to current lines.

For example, a hot dog vendor expanding into selling hamburgers. Compare this to vertical integration.
See also: Vertical Integration
, etc. Hymer focuses on imperfections in final output markets, as expressed in monopolistic advantages held by individual MNEs and entry barriers leading to reductions in consumer welfare. Hymer's pioneering views have been recognized as an influential contribution to the theory of the MNE and FDI. He was the first to contrast such firm-level FDI with the prevailing orthodoxy by economists who explain FDI as a country level financial (portfolio) investment decision determined by interest rate differentials across national borders. Hymer recognizes that FDI is a firm-level strategy decision rather than a capital-market financial decision (Dunning and Rugman 1985). Hence, FDI will occur mainly in imperfect markets.

Though also focusing on the firm as the unit of analysis, internalization Internalization

A decision by a brokerage to fill an order with the firm's own inventory of stock.

When a brokerage receives an order they have numerous choices as to how it should be filled.
 theory has its origins in the work of various scholars associated with the "Reading School": Buckley and Casson (1976, 2009), Rugman (1981), and Hennart (1982). Here, the MNE's existence is not caused by monopolistic advantages leading to entry barriers and consumer exploitation, but by its efficiency properties, i.e., its capacity to reduce transaction costs when replacing an inefficient or non-feasible arm's length transaction in the market by an internal transaction, inside the firm, especially in the context of transferring intermediate (mostly knowledge-based) outputs across borders (Rugman 1980a, b; Rugman et al. 1985; Grubaugh 1987). The MNE's activities typically enhance rather than reduce consumer welfare because efficiently coordinated transactions substitute for inefficient ones.

Internalization theory economists (Buckley and Casson 1976; Rugman 1981) explain why firms become involved in international production. Here, the emphasis switches from the conventional act of FDI at the country level, to the level of the "institution' making the investment, i.e. the MNE. The essential argument of internalization theory is that firms aim at maximizing profit by internalizing their intermediate markets (typically the markets for intangible assets such as technology, production knowhow, brands, etc.,) across national borders in the face of various market imperfections (such as the public goods externality Externality

A consequence of an economic activity that is experienced by unrelated third parties. An externality can be either positive or negative.

Pollution emitted by a factory that spoils the surrounding environment and affects the health of nearby residents is
 associated with pricing an intermediate product like knowledge, the lack of future markets, information asymmetries between buyers and sellers, government intervention in the form of trade barriers or the ineffective application of the national patent system).

Internalization theory extends to the MNE the central ideas of Coasian transaction cost economics theory (Coase 1937), developed in a domestic context. Rugman (1980b, 1981) indicates that while Hymer (1960), Kindleberger (1969) and Caves (1971, 1982) make market imperfections in final output markets the centre of their theory, none of these authors specifically identify internalization of intermediate product markets as the core of a theory to explain FDI and the existence of MNEs, in contrast to Buckley and Casson (1976) and Casson (1979). Buckley and Casson (1976) show that when markets for intermediate products are imperfect, there is an incentive to bypass them by creating internal markets. Here, interdependent activities are brought under common ownership and control. The internalization of markets across national boundaries de facto [Latin, In fact.] In fact, in deed, actually.

This phrase is used to characterize an officer, a government, a past action, or a state of affairs that must be accepted for all practical purposes, but is illegal or illegitimate.
 generates an MNE.

Rugman (1981) argues that internalization theory is a general theory of the MNE. He demonstrates that internalization encompasses within itself the reasons for international (as well as) domestic production. He emphasizes the role of MNEs in overcoming imperfections in various external markets, as well as the policy implications thereof (Hennart 2009a). Rugman applies the theory of internalization to the public debate on foreign ownership in Canada and he sharply criticizes the inappropriate regulation of MNEs (Rugman 1980b, 1981). Rugman argues that the efficiencies resulting from internalization are not acknowledged to their full extent, and instead regulatory measures imposed by government result from the unfounded assumption, in line with Hymer's view, that MNEs normally command monopolistic positions that they will systematically use to exploit the consumer.

Eden (2005) suggests that Rugman's most important contribution to internalization theory revolves around two elements: first, his role in building the theory of internalization as a general theory of the MNE and second, his bridging of the gap between internalization theory with strategic management thinking, by developing the concepts of location bound (LB) and non-location bound (NLB (Network Load Balancing) A clustering technology developed by Microsoft for Windows 2000 Advanced Server. This software-scaling technology spreads client requests among a group of servers linked together to support a particular application. ) firm specific advantages (FSAs) (Rugman and Verbeke 1992, 2001,2003).

Rugman (1981) emphasizes that each MNE commands an idiosyncratic id·i·o·syn·cra·sy  
n. pl. id·i·o·syn·cra·sies
1. A structural or behavioral characteristic peculiar to an individual or group.

2. A physiological or temperamental peculiarity.

 set of FSAs, which give it a competitive advantage relative to other firms. These FSAs arise when the MNE has developed special knowhow or a capability that is unavailable to others and cannot be duplicated by them, except in the long run at high costs. This thinking anticipates the modem resource based view (RBV RBV Resource-Based View
RBV Rancho Buena Vista (California)
RBV Return Beam Vidicon
RBV Rapid Battlefield Visualization
RBV Regionale BenuttingsVerkenner (Netherlands) 
) of the firm (Prahalad and Hamel Ham´el   

v. t. 1. Same as Hamble.
 1990; Barney 1991) developed a full decade later. In many cases, such FSAs arise from upstream research and development (R&D) expenditures that lead to new products or production processes. In other cases, innovation occurs at the more downstream level, and can lead to differentiated product lines, thereby generating an FSA in marketing or distribution. The critical capability of the MNE can also be some unique element of its management structure or core routines that confer an FSA (Rugman 1983a, 1985; Rugman and McIlveen 1985).

However, Rugman (1980b, 1981) notes that possessing FSAs is a necessary but not a sufficient condition for FDI to take place. One MNE objective may be to establish property rights over its FSAs so that these would not be dissipated dis·si·pat·ed  
1. Intemperate in the pursuit of pleasure; dissolute.

2. Wasted or squandered.

3. Irreversibly lost. Used of energy.
 to other firms. To the extent that national institutional regimes, such as patent protection systems, are considered insufficient to prevent unwanted dissipation Dissipation
See also Debauchery.

Breitmann, Hans

lax indulger. [Am. Lit.: Hans Breitmann’s Ballads]

Burley, John

wasteful ne’er-do-well. [Br. Lit.
, then internal markets replace external ones. The MNE transfers, deploys and exploits its FSAs through the use of foreign subsidiaries that monitor, meter and regulate the use of FSAs abroad. The internal market of the MNE permits it to maximize its worldwide earnings without incurring the risks of FSA dissipation by external actors such as licensing agents, franchisees, etc. (Rugman 1981). The great strength of the MNE is that it replaces exogenous Exogenous

Describes facts outside the control of the firm. Converse of endogenous.
 coordination systems prevailing in external markets (usually with pricing at their core) by coordination through a balanced mix of hierarchical control, socialization socialization /so·cial·iza·tion/ (so?shal-i-za´shun) the process by which society integrates the individual and the individual learns to behave in socially acceptable ways.

 and internal prices. In short, Rugman (1981) shows that MNEs develop in response to imperfections in the goods and factor markets. The CSAs of a nation that provide a basic level of comparative advantage are augmented by FSAs, internal to the MNE, and conferring competitive advantage.

Hennart (1982) developed a slightly different version of internalization theory as compared to Buckley and Casson (1976) and Rugman (1981). He shows that for international expansion to take place, setting up facilities abroad must be more efficient than exporting to foreign markets (which entails domestic internalization) and a firm must find it desirable to own the foreign facilities. This is the case if the MNE can organize inter-dependencies between economic actors located in different countries more efficiently than markets. Three conditions must be satisfied: first, interdependent actors must he located in different countries (otherwise, only domestic economic activity would occur); second, the MNE must be the most efficient governance system to organize these interdependencies (otherwise, only domestic actors located in different countries would be involved in international transactions, and not an MNE); third, the costs incurred by MNEs to organize these interdependencies in the market (as in the case of licensing) must be higher than those of organizing them within MNEs (see Hennart 2009a).

Managing interdependencies refers to (a) accessing, (b) recombining, and (c) orchestrating the productive usage of various sets of resources that are dispersed geographically. Such resources may involve knowhow, raw materials and components, marketing and distribution services, financial capital, etc. FDI takes place when firms internalize internalize

To send a customer order from a brokerage firm to the firm's own specialist or market maker. Internalizing an order allows a broker to share in the profit (spread between the bid and ask) of executing the order.
 markets for these resources. For example, an MNE that wants to exploit abroad its firm-specific knowledge will choose to transfer this knowledge internally rather than license it to foreign producers if the market for this knowledge is subject to high transaction costs (Hennart 1982), but the final decision on entry mode choice does not only depend on the MNE's FSAs. it also very much depends on the complementary resources needed by the MNE from foreign actors to make the exploitation of its own FSAs feasible and potentially profitable (which explains why IB is always concerned with managing interdependencies), Hennart (2009b)

The eclectic paradigm Eclectic Paradigm

A theory that provides a three-tiered framework for a company to follow when determining if it is beneficial to pursue direct foreign investment.

, developed and subsequently extended into five versions by Dunning (1977, 1988, 1998), integrates several theory streams on cross border activities at the country and firm levels to explain FDI (see Eden and Dai 2010 for a review of five versions of the eclectic paradigm). Dunning proposes that three types of advantages influence FDI: (i) ownership (O) advantages, (ii) location (L) advantages and (iii) internalization (l) advantages.

Ownership advantages can be divided into asset advantages (Oa) and transactional variables (Ot). Oa include various tangible and intangible assets such as patented technology, brand names, etc., whereas Ot refers to strengths in coordinating--and taking advantage of operating--a network of geographically dispersed affiliates.

Location (L) advantages reflect foreign countries having some country-specific advantages (CSAs) vis-a-vis other countries, in terms of natural resources, factors of production, demand conditions, etc. Location advantages also include elements of the cultural, legal, political and broad institutional environment in which the firm operates, and that make some countries more attractive than other ones. In addition, Dunning (1977) identifies the market structure at the country level and government policies as being potential location advantages. He also argues that the determinants of FDI may differ from one industry to another.

Internalization (1) advantages refer to benefits of creating, transferring, deploying, recombining and exploiting FSAs internally instead of via contractual arrangements with outside parties. Here, the common governance of geographically dispersed value-added activities within a single firm is comparatively more efficient and effective than governance by independent market actors or even by an equity joint venture where more than one firm is the residual claimant CLAIMANT. In the courts of admiralty, when the suit is in rem, the cause is entitled in the Dame of the libellant against the thing libelled, as A B v. Ten cases of calico and it preserves that title through the whole progress of the suit. . Firms decide to operate in foreign countries by considering the particular set of ownership and location advantages they face. The entry modes are selected on the basis of internalization advantages (or the lack thereof).

In addition to its contribution as a synthesizing framework, the OLI OLI Open Learning Initiative (RSA)
OLI Operation Lifesaver, Inc.
OLI Open Learning Institute (Britain)
OLI Originating Line Information (qualifies Automatic Number Identification) 
 paradigm allows identifying the key location advantages of four types of international production: natural resource seeking, market seeking, efficiency seeking, and strategic asset seeking (Dunning 1998). In contrast to the Hymer--Kindleberger--Caves approach, Dunning devotes some attention to managerial issues related to the FDI process, especially in terms of the complex trade-offs to be made when weighing alternative modes of operating in foreign countries and assessing the benefits thereof for the MNE itself and its various stakeholders Stakeholders

All parties that have an interest, financial or otherwise, in a firm-stockholders, creditors, bondholders, employees, customers, management, the community, and the government.
 in geographically dispersed jurisdictions.

Dunning's eclectic paradigm, however, struggles to integrate country and firm level interactions. From the firm's viewpoint, the (O) and (1) are not independent parameters in managerial decision making but need to be considered jointly, with (I) being the dominant consideration. The existence of the MNE itself, resulting from FDI, implies that (O) needed to be internalized in terms of the processes of (O) creation, transfer, deployment, recombination and profitable exploitation (Rugman 1985, 2010; Casson 1987). In this context, Itaki (1991) has voiced the strongest criticism of the eclectic paradigm, and has claimed that an (O) advantage could actually be derived from an (I) advantage, in which case it would be redundant to consider these two variables as separate determinants. Itaki has further pointed out the inseparability in·sep·a·ra·ble  
1. Impossible to separate or part: inseparable pieces of rock.

2. Very closely associated; constant: inseparable companions.
 of the (O) advantage from the (L) advantage. He argues that the (O) advantage in economic terms is unavoidably influenced by--and inseparable in·sep·a·ra·ble  
1. Impossible to separate or part: inseparable pieces of rock.

2. Very closely associated; constant: inseparable companions.
 from--location factors. Hence, (L) and (O) are simultaneously determined. Despite the above shortcomings, which reflect a relative lack of theoretical parsimony par·si·mo·ny  
1. Unusual or excessive frugality; extreme economy or stinginess.

2. Adoption of the simplest assumption in the formulation of a theory or in the interpretation of data, especially in accordance with the rule of
, Dunning's eclectic paradigm undoubtedly represents the most comprehensive framework to explain foreign entry mode choices and the economic efficiency implications thereof.

In parallel with the development of internalization theory, a group of Scandinavian researchers, including scholars from Uppsala University Uppsala University (Swedish Uppsala universitet) is a public university in Uppsala, Sweden, 64 kilometres (40 miles) north-northwest of Stockholm.[1] Founded in 1477, it claims to be the oldest university in Scandinavia, outdating the University of Copenhagen , Sweden (Johanson and Vahlne 1977) and the Helsinki School of Economics Helsinki School of Economics (HSE, Finnish: Helsingin kauppakorkeakoulu) is the premier business university in Finland, internationally accredited by AACSB[1], AMBA and EQUIS. , Finland (Luostarinen 1979) have attempted to explain the process by which firms from small, domestic markets such as the Scandinavian countries, internationalize in·ter·na·tion·al·ize  
tr.v. in·ter·na·tion·al·ized, in·ter·na·tion·al·iz·ing, in·ter·na·tion·al·iz·es
1. To make international.

2. To put under international control.
 their activities.

Drawing upon the classic works of Cyert and March (1963), and Aharoni (1966), the Scandinavian model proposes that internationalization The support for monetary values, time and date for countries around the world. It also embraces the use of native characters and symbols in the different alphabets. See localization, i18n, Unicode and IDN.

internationalization - internationalisation
 is a cumulative, path-dependent process whereby a firm's international expansion pattern is a function of its past international experience and knowledge base (Johanson and Wiedersheim 1975; Johanson and Vahlne 1977, 1990). Internationalization theory argues that a firm with little or no international experience, typically enters a foreign market by exporting. It progresses to establish a sales subsidiary and eventually to invest in production facilities. The driving force of this internationalization process is 'experiential market knowledge' (Johanson and Vahlne 1990).

Johanson and Vahlne (1977) also introduced the concept of 'psychic distance'. Psychic distance The term ‘Psychic Distance’ is a composite of the Greek word ‘Psychikos’ referring to an individual’s mind and soul (Simpson & Weiner 1989) and ‘Distance’ which is based on perceived cultural differences between a ‘home’ country and a  refers to the degree to which a firm is uncertain of the characteristics of a foreign market (Johanson and Wiedersheim 1975). Following the psychic distance concept, firms undertake international expansion in an incremental manner. Here, the internationalization model postulates that firms will first enter the foreign markets with which they are relatively familiar (i.e. geographically, culturally and institutionally proximate proximate /prox·i·mate/ (prok´si-mit) immediate or nearest.

Closely related in space, time, or order; very near; proximal.


immediate; nearest.
), and then, capitalizing on the knowledge acquired from exporting to--or investing in--those markets, successively progress to psychically psy·chic  
1. A person apparently responsive to psychic forces.

2. See medium.

adj. also psy·chi·cal
 and culturally more distant environments (Johanson and Wiedersheim 1975; Johanson and Vahlne 1977). Several empirical studies Empirical studies in social sciences are when the research ends are based on evidence and not just theory. This is done to comply with the scientific method that asserts the objective discovery of knowledge based on verifiable facts of evidence.  have indeed shown that the MNE's level of foreign experience directly influences its selection of a market entry mode, see for example, Loree and Guisinger's (1995) and Li (1994).

However, internationalization theory can be better aligned with the arguments of internalization theory. Rugman (1980a), and Fina and Rugman (1996) have pointed out that an MNE engages in foreign production in order to avoid dissipation of the rents derived from its FSAs that were created at considerable effort and costs. Therefore, internalization theory suggests that a firm consider explicitly the relative costs of servicing foreign markets by first, exporting to foreign markets with the FSAs embodied em·bod·y  
tr.v. em·bod·ied, em·bod·y·ing, em·bod·ies
1. To give a bodily form to; incarnate.

2. To represent in bodily or material form:
 in final products, second, engaging in FDI or third, licensing a foreign producer. This last option becomes attractive especially when the technology licensed is not any longer the technology on which the firm's survival and future growth depends.

The mode of entry changes over time as the relative costs and benefits associated with each of these strategies change. The above stages in serving foreign markets are almost the reverse of the internationalization stages, or the Aharoni (1966) approach, which use (1) licensing as the first step, (2) exporting, (3) establishment of local warehouse and direct local sales, (4) local assembly and packaging, (5) formation of joint venture, (6) foreign direct investment (that is, full scale local production and marketing by a wholly owned subsidiary Wholly Owned Subsidiary

A subsidiary whose parent company owns 100% of its common stock.

In other words, the parent company owns the company outright and there are no minority owners.
). Furthermore, Rugman (2005) also questions internationalization theory in that it lacks serious conceptual grounding and generalizability, especially in term of what exactly constitutes geographic proximity or experiential ex·pe·ri·en·tial  
Relating to or derived from experience.

 learning, and the mechanisms through which these concepts influence FDI decisions and geographic sales dispersion dispersion, in chemistry
dispersion, in chemistry, mixture in which fine particles of one substance are scattered throughout another substance. A dispersion is classed as a suspension, colloid, or solution.

Similarly, Ruigrok and Wagner (2003) also question internationalization theory in their study of German manufacturing companies. They argue that according to the principle of initial foreign location based on the 'psychic distance' premise, German firms are likely to target Switzerland and Austria (German--speaking countries). However, both countries are very small markets and they have never been able to attract substantial German FDI. Instead, the typical German firm expands early into other European, North American North American

named after North America.

North American blastomycosis
see North American blastomycosis.

North American cattle tick
see boophilusannulatus.
 and Asian countries. These nations are characterized by higher psychic distance. Thus, German firms appear to have pursued 'high distance' expansion strategies from the outset, driven by the nature of the location advantages of these larger (high distance) markets and possibly by the complementary resources offered by local actors in those environments.

The overall problem with the internationalization theory approach is that it largely neglects two critical elements. First, the nature of the MNE FSAs, which determines to a large extent the potential net benefits of internalization vis-a-vis alternative modes of operating in foreign markets (e.g., the importance of tacit versus fully codified cod·i·fy  
tr.v. cod·i·fied, cod·i·fy·ing, cod·i·fies
1. To reduce to a code: codify laws.

2. To arrange or systematize.
 knowledge). Second, the presence or absence of natural and government-imposed market imperfections (e.g., an ineffective patent protection system), which may make the use of external markets a non-starter. For example, exporting usually takes place in the absence of government-imposed market imperfections, i.e., when there are no barriers to free trade, whereas FDI precisely occurs when such barriers exist. In turn, licensing takes place when foreign markets are fully segmented, the firm no longer has much to lose by sharing its FSAs, and credible licensees can be found with the requisite resources that complement the MNE's FSAs.

From Firm Level to Subsidiary Level Analysis

Birkinshaw and Pedersen (2009) have summarized the research applying FDI theory and theories of the MNE to the subsidiary level and the interactions between MNE head office and its subsidiaries. Today, we recognize that while the relevant unit of analysis for most IB theory is still the MNE as a whole, because most key strategic decisions are taken at that level, there is often a problem in translating and applying firm-level theory to the subsidiary unit. The subsidiary becomes the key building block of the MNE, which is viewed as a differentiated network rather than a monolithic Single object. Self contained. One unit.  hierarchy. In other words, no serious MNE network analysis can be conducted without understanding each subsidiary's idiosyncratic resource base, strategy, assigned role inside the MNE, and linkages with other subsidiaries. In this context, Birkinshaw (1996, 1997) has shifted focus to the subsidiary manager and the possibility of having 'subsidiary initiatives' instrumental to FSA development. The shift in focus from the parent firm to the subsidiary as a unit of analysis has several origins.

First, a stream of research in Canada examined the extent to which Canadian subsidiaries of foreign MNEs can act autonomously with world product mandates (WPM wpm
words per minute

wpm words per minute

Noun 1. wpm - the rate at which words are produced (as in speaking or typing)
words per minute
). This is partly a host country level interaction with subsidiary level management, but vetted by the MNE's head office in the home country. In particular, the Canadian government wanted to see more R&D in the Canadian subsidiaries of US MNEs, Rugman and Bennett(1982), Poynter and Rugman (1982), Rugman (1983b), Rugman and Douglas (1986), D'Cruz (1986). In a public policy context, Rugman (1980b, 198l) criticizes the lack of effectiveness and efficiency associated with policy efforts to boost R&D spending in Canadian subsidiaries. He finds that the Canadian subsidiaries of US MNEs indeed do only half of the R&D per unit of sales as compared to their parent firms. However, the R&D expenditures of a set of Canadian owned companies of similar size is also well under half those of US parent MNEs. In other words, the relative lack of R&D found in Canadian subsidiaries of foreign MNEs is largely due to country factors rather than firm factors. Canada has poor CSAs as a location for R&D, and Canadian owned firms as well as US subsidiaries in Canada both lack FSAs related to R&D outputs. Rugman's conclusions on the inefficiency of attempts to boost artificial national R&D expenditures (which always reflect a cost, but not necessarily any benefit to the firms and country involved) have subsequently been validated by Moore (1996), Birkinshaw (1997) and others.

Second, research on the strategy and structure of the MNE moved from a focus upon the centralized cen·tral·ize  
v. cen·tral·ized, cen·tral·iz·ing, cen·tral·iz·es
1. To draw into or toward a center; consolidate.

, hierarchical multidivisional form typology typology /ty·pol·o·gy/ (ti-pol´ah-je) the study of types; the science of classifying, as bacteria according to type.


the study of types; the science of classifying, as bacteria according to type.
 of the 1960s and 1970s (Stopford and Wells 1972; Williamson 1981; Egelhoff 1982) towards an understanding of the linkages between the parent firm and its subsidiaries. This was a parent firm interaction with subsidiary managers. In particular, the popularization pop·u·lar·ize  
tr.v. pop·u·lar·ized, pop·u·lar·iz·ing, pop·u·lar·iz·es
1. To make popular: A famous dancer popularized the new hairstyle.

 of the Prahalad and Doz (1981, 1987) integration--responsiveness framework by Bartlett and Ghoshal (1989) established the intellectual foundation for a differentiated internal network perspective as the relevant organizational structure. This work builds on the conceptual insights of Prahalad and Doz (1981, 1987) who show that subsidiaries can develop LB FSAs, albeit sometimes associated with negative outcomes for the MNE, and therefore requiring recentralization, see Verbeke (2009) and also Mudambi and Navarra (2004) for an analysis of dysfunctionalities. Much subsequent work on MNE networks was performed in Scandinavia. Perhaps the best-known network framework is Hedlund's (1986). He argues that the M-form, parent driven MNE would be replaced by the N-form, or network based, MNE. The Scandinavian and Canadian interest in the subsidiary is a useful counterpoint counterpoint, in music, the art of combining melodies each of which is independent though forming part of a homogeneous texture. The term derives from the Latin for "point against point," meaning note against note in referring to the notation of plainsong.  to the earlier US-led focus on centralized and hierarchical MNEs from large economies.

The most influential exponent exponent, in mathematics, a number, letter, or algebraic expression written above and to the right of another number, letter, or expression called the base. In the expressions x2 and xn, the number 2 and the letter n  of the view that subsidiary managers can develop FSAs through subsidiary initiatives is Birkinshaw (1996, 1997, see also Birkinshaw and Hood 1998, 2001; Birkinshaw et al. 1998; Moore 2001; Moore and Birkinshaw 1998). Birkinshaw demonstrates that the subsidiary--and in some cases even the subsidiary manager as driver/facilitator of subsidiary initiatives--may represent a useful unit of analysis when trying to understand innovation processes inside the MNE. Many strategic decisions critical to innovation may be taken at the subsidiary level and can lead to new FSA generation.

In this context, Rugman and Verbeke (2009a) have suggested that CSAs of host countries may be used in a 'leveraged' way. MNEs make dual use of CSAs from the home and host countries, and subsidiaries throughout the MNE network may be critical in resource recombination efforts, a view consistent with the 'double diamond' framework of Rugman and Verbeke (1993). If MNE operations in various countries can be instrumental to new knowledge generation, this opens the door for two-way flows of FDI, sophisticated forms of parent-subsidiary relationships and complex network functioning inside MNEs (Rugman and Verbeke 2001; Rugman and D'Cruz 2000).

Rugman and Verbeke (1992, 2001, 2003) have argued that FSAs can be created anywhere in the MNE network, both in the parent company at home and in the foreign subsidiaries. FSAs can be location-bound (LB) or non-location bound (NLB). The LB FSAs reflect strengths deployable and exploitable in a limited geographic area, such as a single country or a limited set of countries or region, but cannot be profitably exploited outside of this area, whether as an intermediate output (e.g., managerial skills, R&D knowledge) or embodied in final products. LB FSAs may include an excellent local reputation, a well-positioned retail network, privileged relationships with domestic economic actors, etc. In contrast, NLB FSAs represent company strengths that can easily be transferred across locations at low cost, deployed and profitably exploited, with only limited need for resource recombination. Such NLB FSAs typically include the upstream patented technological knowledge, and the downstream brand names. The actual transfer across borders can again occur in the form of intermediate products or embodied in final outputs.

Rugman and Verbeke (200l) have shown that subsidiary initiatives may lead to the development of LB FSAs (a resource-based expression of host country national responsiveness) but these can be transformed into non-location bound (NLB) FSAs, namely when being augmented with best practice attributes inside the MNE network (e.g., as a result of productivity increases and added differentiation). Indeed, in synthesizing the literature on subsidiary initiatives, Rugman and Verbeke (2001) find ten generic types of capability development processes inside MNEs, of which Birkinshaw had identified those whereby subsidiary initiatives are critical.

This framework incorporates the thinking of Birkinshaw and Pedersen (2009) who align the resource based view (RBV) of the firm with the resources and capabilities developed and held in an MNE (Wernerfelt 1984; Rumelt 1984; Barney 1991; Mahoney and Pandian 1992; Peteraf 1993; Teece et al. 1997; Rugman and Verbeke 2002). Some FSAs are likely to be held at MNE parent firm level while others are held at subsidiary level.

Birkinshaw and Pedersen (2009) argue that if the subsidiary is a valid unit of analysis in its own right, it should be possible to unbundle To sell components in a system separately. Contrast with bundle.  resources and capabilities between the subsidiary and the MNE. Considering basic resources first, most tangible resources (plant, equipment and people) are held primarily at the subsidiary level, while most intangible resources (financial, organizational, and reputational) are held at the firm level. Capabilities are much harder to unbundle between firm and subsidiary levels of analysis. Some are clearly held at the firm level and shared across subsidiaries, such as a particular organizational culture. Others are more likely to be specific to a particular subsidiary, such as a particularly effective way of handling local labour relations labour relations (US), labor relations nplrelations fpl dans l'entreprise

labour relations labour nplBeziehungen pl
 or privileged relationships with government agencies to secure commercial contracts. Most capabilities, however, sit somewhere between the two levels. The criteria used to evaluate resources in the RBV in terms of their contribution to competitive advantage (valuable, rare, non-imitable, nonsubstitutable) are not necessarily the most relevant at the subsidiary level. Thus, Birkinshaw and Pedersen (2009) suggest that rather than simply analyzing subsidiary level resources in terms of their potential for competitive advantage, it is necessary to consider recombining them with other resources, or leveraging them on a worldwide basis. This process could generate NLB FSAs, in the spirit of Rugman and Verbeke (1992).

Essentially, Birkinshaw argues that subsidiary managers can develop both host country, LB FSAs but also NLB FSAs, through subsidiary initiatives. Subsidiary initiatives that lead to NLB knowledge reflect the subsidiary and its managers moving beyond their assigned charter, and gaining world product mandates or critical roles in international value added Value Added

The enhancement a company gives its product or service before offering the product to customers.

This can either increase the products price or value.
 chains inside the MNE's internal network, or developing subsidiary specific advantages (SSAs) (Rugman and Verbeke 2001).

Related work examining the role and function of subsidiary managers has been undertaken by Holm holm  
n. Chiefly British
An island in a river.

[Middle English, from Old Norse h
 and Pedersen (2000), Andersson et al. (2002, 2007), Forsgren et al. (1995), Foss and Pedersen (2002), Holm and Pedersen (2000), Malnight (1996) among others.

The above analysis suggests that research in the IB field has evolved over the last fifty years. The unit of analysis has shifted from the country level to the firm level and finally to the subsidiary level. MNE subsidiary strategy has received significant attention, especially in the context of the MNE as a differentiated network. Now we move on to explore the evolution of IB theories from an equilibrium oriented o·ri·ent  
1. Orient The countries of Asia, especially of eastern Asia.

a. The luster characteristic of a pearl of high quality.

b. A pearl having exceptional luster.

 theoretical focus to a more dynamic oriented conceptualization con·cep·tu·al·ize  
v. con·cep·tu·al·ized, con·cep·tu·al·iz·ing, con·cep·tu·al·iz·es
To form a concept or concepts of, and especially to interpret in a conceptual way:
. We show that the basic conceptual foundations of IB theory remain as logical developments of internalization theory and its offshoots.

The Classic Framework for IB Theory

The three basic units of analysis can be analyzed in the classic CSA/FSA matrix of Fig. 1, derived from Rugman (1981). Here the impact of country factors is depicted de·pict  
tr.v. de·pict·ed, de·pict·ing, de·picts
1. To represent in a picture or sculpture.

2. To represent in words; describe. See Synonyms at represent.
 on the vertical axis, ranging from weak to strong CSA impact on IB transactions (see Rugman and Verbeke 2009a for a comprehensive overview on location, competitiveness and the MNEs). Conversely con·verse 1  
intr.v. con·versed, con·vers·ing, con·vers·es
1. To engage in a spoken exchange of thoughts, ideas, or feelings; talk. See Synonyms at speak.

, on the horizontal axis, we depict de·pict  
tr.v. de·pict·ed, de·pict·ing, de·picts
1. To represent in a picture or sculpture.

2. To represent in words; describe. See Synonyms at represent.
 the importance of the firm factors, i.e., the FSAs, ranging again from a weak to a strong impact.


In cell 1 of Fig. 1, only CSAs matter to explain the scope and direction of IB activities. In cell 1, mainstream international economics explains how comparative advantage will lead the home country to export goods and services In economics, economic output is divided into physical goods and intangible services. Consumption of goods and services is assumed to produce utility (unless the "good" is a "bad"). It is often used when referring to a Goods and Services Tax.  which build upon its relatively abundant factor inputs of labour, capital and natural resources. For example, Canada will export newsprint newsprint

low grade paper used for newspapers. Old newspapers are fed to cattle as an alternative roughage and may occasionally be ingested by dogs. Significant amounts of lead are accumulated in tissues; no cases of poisoning have been recorded in cattle, though it has been
, Saudi Arabia Saudi Arabia (sä`dē ərā`bēə, sou`–, sô–), officially Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, kingdom (2005 est. pop.  will export oil, and China will attract manufacturing assembly through its abundant cheap labour. Cell 1 also captures cultural stereotypes, as popularized by Hofstede (1983) and the GLOBE (2006) studies by House et al. (2004), whereby cultural characteristics and cultural distance vis-a-vis other nations are viewed as instrumental or detrimental det·ri·men·tal  
Causing damage or harm; injurious.

 to a country's success in IB. In addition, cell 1 includes situations whereby political and administrative rules greatly affect 1B transactions. For example, host governments may restrict and regulate both imports and exports, as well as inward and outward FDI (Rugman 1980b; Rugman and Verbeke 2009b). In such cases, varied and complex interactions may occur between MNEs and host governments (Vernon 1971, 1991; see Rugman and Verbeke 2009b for a comprehensive overview).

In cell 4, the opposite situation prevails: here, country factors do not matter much, and competitive advantage results solely from FSAs unaffected by geography, in terms of locational impacts on their development, transfer across borders, deployability, recombination requirements and profitable exploitation. This situation is consistent with the view espoused by most mainstream resource based view (RBV) scholars in strategic management. These authors focus on FSAs only (referred to, inter alia [Latin, Among other things.] A phrase used in Pleading to designate that a particular statute set out therein is only a part of the statute that is relevant to the facts of the lawsuit and not the entire statute. , as core competences and capabilities), and do not recognize the importance of location and CSAs. Indeed, authors such as Wernerfelt (1984), Rumelt (1984) and Barney (1991) developed the RBV in isolation of country effects. Examples of strong FSAs in cell 4 include the allegedly location-independent brand equity of the firm, and the managerial resources and capabilities of the top management team to grow the firm (Penrose 1959).

In cell 3, both CSAs and FSAs matter. This is the unique stage for IB theory. Here, the firm being studied is an MNE, operating across multiple countries, and trying to coordinate various resource dependencies across borders. Both home and host country CSAs may be important in terms of how the FSAs are managed. CSAs affect the processes of developing, transferring across borders, deploying, recombining with other resources and profitably exploiting FSAs, which are always internalized to some extent. Such FSAs can include higher order governance capabilities and core operating routines following the firm's dominant logic.

Cell 3 situations also allow for complex intra-MNE network linkages, sometimes with sophisticated value chain relationships among the various subsidiaries involved, each holding specific sets of FSAs in particular value chain functions and benefiting from particular CSA bundles (Rugman et al. 2011). In each of these situations it is recombining resources across borders that matters, see Rugman and Verbeke (2001) and Verbeke (2009). Importantly, the three units of analysis intersect In a relational database, to match two files and produce a third file with records that are common in both. For example, intersecting an American file and a programmer file would yield American programmers.  and overlap here. The main focus when studying resource recombination patterns may be the MNE, but useful analysis also requires an understanding of which CSAs in the home and host countries can be leveraged by the firm, as well as sufficient appreciation for the geographical dispersion of MNE FSAs across the multiple units and subsidiaries in its internal network.

This CSA/FSA matrix is consistent with Meyer et al. (2009), who have advocated a combination of institutional analysis (focusing on a subset A group of commands or functions that do not include all the capabilities of the original specification. Software or hardware components designed for the subset will also work with the original.  of CSAs) and RBV thinking (with the resource based view providing tools for studying the nature and strength of FSAs). It is also consistent with the latest version of internationalization theory (Johanson and Vahlne 2009), which is now focused on understanding the liability of outsidership rather than the liability of foreignness. Outsidership is concerned with access to resources or rather the lack of such access, mainly because of relational shortcomings. Resources are needed to develop the requisite LB FSAs so as to link these with the MNE's extant ex·tant  
1. Still in existence; not destroyed, lost, or extinct: extant manuscripts.

2. Archaic Standing out; projecting.
 NLB FSAs, and to take full benefit of the CSAs of the host countries entered. We now turn to issues in the literature less resolved than discussed so far. These new issues are likely to be the basis for future research.

The Future of Distance in Intra-Firm and Inter-Firm Networks

The key scholarly and managerial challenge in IB, irrespective of irrespective of
Without consideration of; regardless of.

irrespective of
preposition despite 
 the unit of analysis selected, is to understand properly how 'distance' affects the transferability, deployability, recombination and profitable exploitation across borders of (quasi-) proprietary know-how, whether in the form of stand-alone competences or higher-order capabilities. The main weakness of many scholarly analyses is the incorrect assessment of what distance really means when performing IB transactions. This leads to overestimates of the non-location boundedness of extant FSAs and underestimates of the need for 'melding investments' in host environments, so as to create new, LB FSAs, often in concert with other economic actors. The outcome of such incorrect assessment in the IB literature is structurally flawed flaw 1  
1. An imperfection, often concealed, that impairs soundness: a flaw in the crystal that caused it to shatter. See Synonyms at blemish.

 theories of how MNEs really operate across borders.

Basically, there are three types of FSAs: stand alone FSAs (such as patented knowledge or a brand name), routines (i.e., the way things are done inside the firm), and recombination capabilities (i.e., the capacity to augment in a productive fashion the MNE's existing resource base with newly accessible resources) (Verbeke 2009). Traditional thinking is that each of these builds upon home country CSAs. Drawing upon home country CSAs typically leads to LB FSAs, tied to the home country. A portion of these stand-alone FSAs, routines and recombination capabilities can become internationally transferrable, deployable and profitably exploitable, i.e. this portion becomes non-location bound (NLB). FSAs in the NLB category typically include R&D knowledge, system integration capabilities, managerial capabilities, easy access to capital, and sometimes brand names, to the extent that foreign consumers confer value to these. However, upstream FSAs are usually much more NLB than downstream ones.

NLB FSAs can be transferred internationally through the MNE intra-firm network. However, in most cases, these must be complemented with investments in new LB FSAs in the host countries where they are to be exploited. The MNE may need to draw upon complementary resources held by external actors in the host country. It is only through these complementary resources, and the ensuing en·sue  
intr.v. en·sued, en·su·ing, en·sues
1. To follow as a consequence or result. See Synonyms at follow.

2. To take place subsequently.
 LB FSAs that the MNE is able to access host country CSAs (e.g., access to a large consumer market). If these resources can be freely purchased on the market, the MNE will develop the new LB FSAs on its own. In contrast, if these resources cannot be purchased, joint ventures and other types of alliances may result, especially if the MNE wishes to keep some direct control over its own NLB FSAs transferred abroad. In the case when there are strong imperfections in the markets for resources and no satisfactory joint venture partners can be found, the only option is a merger or acquisition. Here the MNE is forced to purchase not only the resources required for accessing the host country market, but a local firm in its entirety, including possible substantial unwanted assets and capabilities. Obviously, if the MNE can simply augment its internationally transferrable NLB FSAs with self-created LB FSAs, fully controlled by the MNE through its internal network, then FSA dissipation risks can be avoided.

However, host country subsidiaries may do much more than simply augment home-based, NLB FSAs with requisite local strengths. They may develop subsidiary specific advantages (SSAs) as a result of their autonomous initiatives. Rugman and Verbeke (2001) define SSAs as idiosyncratic strengths developed by host country subsidiary managers building upon host country CSAs. However, SSAs may represent not just LB knowledge but new, NLB strengths in the sense of having profit potential abroad. The challenge associated with SSAs is that the actual capability (or more specifically the capability carrier, such as the management team mastering the relevant knowledge) cannot be simply transferred across borders. In other words, the underlying knowledge is embedded in the subsidiary and its linkages with local actors. As Rugman and Verbeke (2001) point out, SSAs are often viewed with great skepticism by the corporate head office, as they do not constitute network knowledge by definition. An unresolved question is whether SSAs can somehow be 'upgraded' (e.g., through codifying knowledge and sending expatriates to the subsidiary to learn about the new capability), so that they would become relevant to the entire MNE subsidiary network.

Future research on geographic distance and SSAs might be usefully linked to recent empirical and theoretical work analyzing the regional nature of MNEs (Rugman and Verbeke 2004; Rugman 2005). Given that the empirical data show that the world's largest 500 firms operate mainly within their home region of the triad, it is apparent that SSAs, as well as more conventional NLB FSAs, are difficult to exploit profitably outside of their home region. The problem may not reside solely in technical difficulties associated with international FSA transfer, but also in challenges of (a) effective deployment in a host environment, depending upon the recipient's absorptive capacity In business administration, absorptive capacity is theory or model used to measure a firm's ability to value, assimilate, and apply new knowledge. It is studied on multiple levels (individual, group, firm, and national level). ; (b) appropriate recombination of the NLB FSAs with newly created or newly accessed LB FSAs; and (c) managerial effectiveness in profitably exploiting the newly created FSA bundles.

These challenges become compounded as 'distance' increases, whether economic, cultural, institutional, or merely geographic. It becomes more difficult for senior MNE managers at the head office to understand critical success factors and to act upon related challenges (a bounded rationality Many models of human behavior in the social sciences assume that humans can be reasonably approximated or described as "rational" entities (see for example rational choice theory).  problem). It also becomes more difficult to engage in proper monitoring and correction of human behavior, especially when efforts are diverted from engagement towards achieving company goals; this is a bounded reliability problem (Verbeke and Greidanus 2009). Regional boundaries such as in NAFTA NAFTA
 in full North American Free Trade Agreement

Trade pact signed by Canada, the U.S., and Mexico in 1992, which took effect in 1994. Inspired by the success of the European Community in reducing trade barriers among its members, NAFTA created the world's
 and the EU, as well the boundaries separating Asia from the rest of the world, represent a useful first cut at separating lower distance, intra-regional environments from higher distance, interregional in·ter·re·gion·al  
Of, involving, or connecting two or more regions: interregional migration; interregional banking. 
 ones. In other words, the location boundedness of FSAs is often mainly intraregional in nature: FSAs can be relatively easily transferred, deployed, recombined and profitably exploited throughout the home region compared to between regions. The comparatively easier resource recombination challenge, as compared to what prevails in host regions, is especially critical.

It remains somewhat of a puzzle as to why inter-regional distance remains so important, whereas the world economy otherwise appears to be moving towards greater integration with supporting political and institutional standardization being driven by improved information technology and information accessing capabilities. In our view it is the compounded distance, more specifically the need to manage various distance dimensions simultaneously, that really explains the regional nature of the world economy. The compounded distance is insufficiently captured in efforts to simply 'add' or otherwise aggregate various types of distance. Ghemawat (2001,2007) has an introductory discussion of this, though still adopting a largely additive additive

In foods, any of various chemical substances added to produce desirable effects. Additives include such substances as artificial or natural colourings and flavourings; stabilizers, emulsifiers, and thickeners; preservatives and humectants (moisture-retainers); and
 approach. Future research should engage in further careful reflection and testing of the compounded distance concept.

The key insight here is that the various distance dimensions typically measured in IB studies are not independent of each other. For example, regional economic integration fosters institutional coordination, and may contribute to lowering actual cultural distance by increasing mobility of labour and managerial best practices. At the same time, improving the common transport infrastructure, adding transport connections (e.g., in air travel) in terms of frequency and quality may reduce the impact of geographical distance. In addition, one specific parameter related to distance dimension has been neglected systematically in large-scale studies analyzing the geographic scope of international expansion patterns. This is the presence and the strength of the relationships between the MNE and relevant actors operating in the host environment. As noted earlier, Johanson and Vahlne (2009) have argued in their extension of internationalization theory that being an outsider in foreign networks may explain the absence of competitive success. The liability of host region outsidership, meaning simply that most MNEs have few if any powerful relationships with actors in host regions, may go a long way in explaining the absence of international success in these host regions. Relationships may well be the key missing factor (as a LB FSA) to overcome compounded distance and to allow access to coveted cov·et  
v. cov·et·ed, cov·et·ing, cov·ets
1. To feel blameworthy desire for (that which is another's). See Synonyms at envy.

2. To wish for longingly. See Synonyms at desire.
 CSAs in host regions.

At this time, it remains unclear as to the extent to which forces of global integration can actually overcome the currently triad region barriers observed by Rugman (2005). Researchers will need to continue to examine carefully the extent to which region-bound FSAs, including SSAs held by MNE subsidiaries, can be transformed from their apparent apparent current regional exploitability into NLB FSAs with a truly global reach, meaning that they can easily be transferred, deployed, and recombined with other resources to the extent necessary, and profitably exploited around the world.

The above analysis can be related to the earlier Fig. 1. The most interesting aspect of Fig. 1 lies in cell 3, whereby the MNE successfully accesses and leverages CSAs in home and host environments, and is able to put together bundles of LB and NLB FSAs to achieve success in a variety of host environments. The requirements of this approach go far beyond merely adapting homegrown FSAs to the host country environment, as in the national responsiveness strategy of Bartlett and Ghoshal (1989). For example, in the case where a Birkinshaw type SSA (Serial Storage Architecture) A fault tolerant peripheral interface from IBM that transfers data at 80 and 160 Mbytes/sec. SSA uses SCSI commands, allowing existing software to drive SSA peripherals, which are typically disk drives.  held by an MNE subsidiary in cell 3 is critical to MNE international growth and profitability, the challenge for the MNE head office is to provide sufficient resources to the subsidiary to allow global deployment and exploitation (by allowing a world product mandate or providing the status of global centre of excellence). Alternatively, investments must be made to turn the SSA into a strength that can be transferred inside the MNE network (e.g., through codifying knowledge, or by sending subsidiary experts to other units to provide training, or by allowing direct interaction and knowledge transfers among subsidiaries, etc.) and the subsequent, dispersed exploitation out of many units.

Essentially this section has discussed potential combinations of home and host country CSAs and associated FSAs. All of this provides sophisticated substance to cell 3 of Fig. 1. The future for research in IB needs to expand upon this type of deep analysis of cell 3 in Fig. 1. In particular, efforts are still in their infancy to understand the nature and extent of recombination efforts, whereby extant FSA bundles are melded with complementary resources in host environments, so as to access host country CSAs.

A critical feature of internalization theory is its focus on governance. In other words, disciplined execution of the FSA-CSA recombination processes described above requires much more than suggested by the rather simplistic sim·plism  
The tendency to oversimplify an issue or a problem by ignoring complexities or complications.

[French simplisme, from simple, simple, from Old French; see simple
 case-based analysis of Bartlett and Ghoshal (1989) and their broad integration--responsiveness framework. This framework provides little guidance in terms of proper governance beyond some general suggestions on how to improve normative nor·ma·tive  
Of, relating to, or prescribing a norm or standard: normative grammar.

 integration, i.e., socialization, Rugman et al. (2011).

Similarly, limited case analysis on the so-called metanational by Doz et al. (2001), in terms of building globally deployable NLB FSAs based on the CSAs of peripheral host country environments, is not particularly useful. Doz and his co-authors place the future of the MNE in the hands of small sensing and magnet units, almost the equivalent of US Army Delta Force units. These units are supposed to work outside of the realm of the MNE's operating divisions. Sensors are supposed to identify and seek out geographically dispersed, unique, and hitherto fully ignored bodies of valuable knowledge. Magnets are then supposed to follow up the sensors' activities, and to recombine re·com·bine
To undergo or cause genetic recombination; form new combinations.
 the various unique pieces of knowledge identified by the sensors into commercially viable products. In a final stage, the MNE's operating divisions must then implement the 'new solutions' put forward by the sensors and magnets. The operating divisions' role is simply to engage in scaling up and ensuring the commercial viability of the products pushed onto the MNE network by the sensors and magnets.

Verbeke and Kenworthy (2008) have argued, however, that the metanational form of governance is unlikely to displace dis·place  
tr.v. dis·placed, dis·plac·ing, dis·plac·es
1. To move or shift from the usual place or position, especially to force to leave a homeland:
 the conventional, hierarchical, M-form organizational structure, especially in terms of how novel resource recombinations are turned into actual non-location bound FSAs. They have focused on the need to view resource recombination, i.e., the innovation process, 'in its entirety'. This means that R&D or other efforts to develop/access new knowledge cannot be structurally divorced from production and marketing/sales. This is broadly consistent with the thinking of Buckley (2009) on the global factory.

There are good reasons why most large MNEs are organized in divisions (typically geographic and product divisions) and into national units with specific mandates in tightly coordinated, international value chains: such governance is comparatively more efficient and effective than alternative forms of organization. The modern M-form allows economizing on bounded rationality and bounded reliability, and implementing innovation processes in their entirety, from technological FSA development to after sales service to customers, a view consistent with Wolf and Egelhoff's (2010) critical analysis of various forms of network organizations proposed by IB scholars who neglect the limitations of networks as compared to, for example, modern matrix structures. Using an information processing information processing: see data processing.
information processing

Acquisition, recording, organization, retrieval, display, and dissemination of information. Today the term usually refers to computer-based operations.
 approach, Wolf and Egelhoff (2011) convincingly argue that decentralized de·cen·tral·ize  
v. de·cen·tral·ized, de·cen·tral·iz·ing, de·cen·tral·iz·es
1. To distribute the administrative functions or powers of (a central authority) among several local authorities.
 network organizations simply do not work as compared to M-form structures such as matrix organizations, when the MNE operates in multiple high distance environments, needs to focus at least partly on the efficiency of existing operations, and must balance the exploitation of NLB FSAs with developing LB FSAs.

In other words, much of the traditional international management strategy literature still makes simplistic assumptions that global strategies are feasible, and can be implemented without much attention devoted to governance. In fact, global strategies and truly global NLB FSA bundles are likely to be extremely rare, as demonstrated, inter alia, by the regional nature of MNEs in terms of their (limited) sales and asset dispersion, and the regional elements in their governance structures (Rugman and Verbeke 2008a). Future research will likely build upon the theoretical and empirical insights of Rugman and Verbeke (2004) and hopefully recognize regional strategy and structure as an efficient alternative to non-feasible global approaches, especially in the context of internal governance. Global governance Global governance refers to political interaction and the creation and empowering of international organizations aimed at solving problems that affect more than one state or region, when there is no democratic power of enforcing compliance.  sometimes does appear possible in the context of global alliances such as in the airline industry, where individual airlines perform largely regional roles, and select particular, narrow value chain activities where resources can be pooled and recombined to create NLB alliance specific advantages (ASAs), which unfortunately are lost to an airline when it decides to leave the alliance.

Other Units of Analysis and the Role of Distance in IB

In focused, contemporary IB studies, nine other units of analysis have been adopted, in addition to the "big three" discussed in earlier sections. These sets include: first, the entrepreneur; the MNE head office and the top management team; and the value chain; Second, the expatriate Expatriate

An employee who is a U.S. citizen living and working in a foreign country.
; the centre of excellence; and the model factory. Third, the outsourcing agreement; the joint venture/strategic alliance and the cluster.

The first three additional units of analysis are really subsets of the firm as the main unit of analysis, but with a focus on, respectively, who established the firm, what governance mechanism leads the firm and how the firm's value added functions are dispersed across space. The second set of three additional units is concerned mainly with what occurs at the subsidiary level, but with a focus on, respectively, who is sent by the head office to perform a number of tasks in the subsidiary, what unique role the subsidiary can perform inside the MNE network and how it can be a model for exceptional value creation. The third set explicitly looks at the complementary resources provided by external actors that can be productively recombined with extant FSAs.

Here, the critical point to remember is that any serious IB analysis always considers the CSAs of home and host countries, as well as bundles of LB and NL FSAs. The challenge is always to explain, predict or guide how competitive success can be achieved outside of the home nation, or how such success is hampered by a variety of internal and external constraints. For example, the strategic challenges facing an entrepreneur with international expansion ambitions are similar to those facing a large MNE, especially in terms of the bounded rationality and bounded reliability constraints to be overcome, and the transaction costs related to these constraints (Casson 1982).

The above also holds for the analysis of networks. The problem with some of the strategy and IB literature is an exaggerated focus on the benefits of networks, but a relative neglect of its costs. Network theory needs to be applied to IB with caution. When there are intra-firm alignments the network approach is fully consistent with analysis at the parent and subsidiary level, as discussed above. However, inter-firm linkages, which include joint ventures and strategic alliances do not relate easily to basic IB theory, especially internalization theory. Here, the network literature largely ignores the ownership issue, in the sense of required FSA protection against dissipation and the appropriate distribution of the cooperation benefits and costs among the partners, who are all residual claimants (Narula and Hagedoorn 1999; Gulati et al. 2006).

In more general terms, the main challenge associated with the myriad of alternative units of analysis adopted in the IB literature is that the authors sometimes lose track of the continued relevance of distance and its various dimensions. One example is the study of so-called 'born globals' whereby authors often simply assume that cell 3 of Fig. 1 opportunities are available to them across the world without understanding the challenges of international expansion, especially outside of the home region. In many ways, a simplistic use of cell 3 in Fig. 1 thinking represents a 'born global illusion' for international entrepreneurship, Rugman and Almodovar (2011).

Studies on another unit of analysis, namely the value chain, are often also associated with a rather shallow understanding of the compounded distance concept. A value chain dispersed across borders equates to a firm making strategic decisions to access particular home and host country CSAs by deploying idiosyncratic FSA bundles in each country and then coordinating these bundles. In this context, the often expressed view that MNEs pursue 'global sourcing' and are engaged in a 'global race for talent', rather than pursuing more focused and selective initiatives in these areas, such as 'regional sourcing' or 'local sourcing', often leads to absurd conclusions, (Rugman et al. 2009). More specifically, most of the literature on offshoring
Offshore may refer to oil and natural gas production at sea; see oil platform.

Offshoring describes the relocation of business processes from one country to another.
 and outsourcing is largely a cell 1 in Fig. 1 phenomenon. Western firms have offshored manufacturing to China due to China's CSA in cheap labour. Similarly, IT has been offshored to India due to India's relatively cheap, skilled and educated labour.

The relevant insight is that offshoring is difficult. The distance to countries such as China and India may be large for Western MNEs, and therefore offshoring efforts are not deployed globally but are very targeted, often towards large cosmopolitan cos·mo·pol·i·tan
Growing or occurring in many parts of the world; widely distributed.

A cosmopolitan organism.
 centres. Within these centres, widely available knowledge of business best practices, competent legal and financial counselling, and a pool of experienced managers may alleviate the bounded rationality and bounded reliability challenges to be overcome. In most cases, substantial melding investments must be performed for the MNE to be successful in recombining the MNE's extant NLB FSAs with the FSAs of local resource providers. Here, the additional distance challenge is that outside suppliers of offshoring services may want to work up the 'smiling curve', i.e, move towards both more upstream and downstream value chain activities as compared to typical component supply or basic ICT (1) (Information and Communications Technology) An umbrella term for the information technology field. See IT.

(2) (International Computers and Tabulators) See ICL.

1. (testing) ICT - In Circuit Test.
 services, thereby creating more value added per unit delivered, Mudambi (2008). However, there is a danger for the MNE in that it may ultimately lose its competitive edge in some of these activities vis-a-vis offshoring services providers, especially in higher distance, peripheral markets.

Fortunately, much of the work on the 'global factory', which looks at the production side of the value chain is consistent with the complexities of cell 3 in Fig. 1 thinking, see Buckley and Ghauri (2004), Buckley and Hashai (2005), Buckley (2009). In examining the changing location and ownership strategies of MNEs, namely, the 'hub and spoke' and the 'global factory', Buckley and Ghauri (2004) show the increasingly sophisticated decision making of managers in MNEs to slice more finely the value added activities of firms. In finding optimum locations for each closely defined activity, they are deepening deep·en  
tr. & intr.v. deep·ened, deep·en·ing, deep·ens
To make or become deep or deeper.

Noun 1. deepening - a process of becoming deeper and more profound
 the international division of labour. Ownership strategies are also becoming increasingly complex, leading many MNEs to apply a control matrix, whereby operating strategies are decided upon location by location, and can range from wholly owned subsidiary units via FDI to market relationships such as subcontracting, with joint ventures as options on subsequent decisions in a dynamic pattern, Li and Rugman (2007). However, fully understanding cell 3 complexities, probably means that here again the so-called global factory may be an illusion, and that the reality may be more one of 'regional factories'.

The implication of the above is not only that distance still matters, but should never be underestimated in IB studies (especially not the compounded distance), as suggested by Fig. 2. The vertical axis of Fig. 2 lists the various possible units of analysis, whereby we include here, for illustrative il·lus·tra·tive  
Acting or serving as an illustration.

il·lustra·tive·ly adv.

Adj. 1.
 purposes only, four units of analysis, consistent with cell 3 in Fig. 1: the entrepreneur, the MNE, the MNE subsidiary with intra-firm networks, and inter-firm arrangements. The horizontal axis dichotomizes the reach of MNE FSAs/capabilities into 'global NLB FSAs' versus 'limited NLB FSAs'.

The relevance of Fig. 2 is that we can position a substantial number of contemporary IB concepts on the left hand side. Cell 1 represents the so-called 'born global firm' with an ambitious entrepreneur at its core who has worldwide growth ambitions. Cell 2 represents the global MNE with sales and assets dispersed in a balanced fashion across the globe, of which there are only nine examples, Rugman (2005), or the metanational with its sensors and magnets gathering knowledge from the far comers of the planet. Cell 3 represents the MNE subsidiary with a global mandate. Finally, cell 4 represents global outsourcing networks and global alliances.

Unfortunately, the real world cases that can actually be placed in cells 1 to 4 are few and far between due to the tyranny Tyranny
Big Brother

omnipresent leader of a totalitarian nightmare world. [Br. Lit.: 1984]


rules Thebes with cruel decrees. [Gk. Lit.: Antigone]


Austrian governor treats Swiss despotically; shot by Tell.
 of compounded distance. Most 'born globals' are really 'born regionals' in cell 5. Most large MNEs have a home region sales and asset concentration, and operate with geographic divisions in cell 6, Rugman and Verbeke (2004, 2008a, b, c). Most MNE subsidiaries perform a regional mandate role in the internal MNE network in cell 7. Finally, most outsourcing networks and alliances, even those designed by the largest MNEs in the world, are again very selective in terms of geographic coverage, placing them in cell 8. Global outsourcing/offshoring in cell 4 is largely a non-starter, because of the transaction costs associated with it. In short, in the future, much more research needs to be done on the right hand side of Fig. 2; the IB field needs to move beyond the left field of Fig. 2. We need to focus instead on the limits to globalization globalization

Process by which the experience of everyday life, marked by the diffusion of commodities and ideas, is becoming standardized around the world. Factors that have contributed to globalization include increasingly sophisticated communications and transportation
, resulting from two sets of parameters, as shown in Fig. 3.


The essence of explaining the literature on global versus regional strategies can be divined with reference to Fig. 3. As explained above, much of the literature in IB ignores the complexity of geographic distance. Therefore, we place the complexity of the cultural, institutional, economic, and geographic components of 'compounded distance' on the vertical axis. Essentially, each MNE needs to identify the relevant weighting of the components of the compounded distance it faces. It then needs to build on its extant FSAs base to further develop new FSAs which will overcome the 'resource recombination barriers' it faces. Therefore, on the horizontal axis of Fig. 3, we place the resource recombination barriers to the growth of the MNE. The presence of compounded distance means that it is not sufficient to 'add' the isolated effects of cultural, institutional, economic and geographic distance components. There may be multiplicative effects arising from these distance dimensions, especially in interregional as opposed to intraregional settings. In other words, rather than looking at CSAs as sources of net benefits to the MNE, as suggested by Fig. 1, the focus should shift instead to the challenge of accessing these CSAs.


The existence of resource recombination barriers demonstrates the difficulties of creating the right mix of FSAs that would guarantee competitiveness in, for example, a host region market. In other words, it is important not simply to assume the presence of FSAs in the MNE that would almost automatically confer competitive advantage, as suggested by Fig. 1, but instead to recognize that, typically, NLB FSAs need to be melded with LB FSAs, a process that may encounter severe implementation problems, inter alia, when each segment of the firm's value chain requires idiosyncratic resource recombination efforts, Rugman et al. (2011). A similar approach to finding, and testing, several types of LB FSAs appears in Lo et al. (2010).

In cell 1, there is a mix of high compounded distance and low resource recombination barriers: this is the assumption of a complex world, combined with the MNE's ability to create the right FSA mix without too much difficulty. This is the main assumption adopted in, for example the transnational and metanational illusions. In cell 2, a low compounded distance and low resource recombination barriers suggest a simple world where all is global (global firms, born globals, global mandates, etc.). Cell 3 in turn shows the regional solution, whereby firms face high compounded distance, and at the same times struggle with important resource recombination barriers when entering into host regions. Finally, cell 4 describes the often-observed position of smaller firms with mainly LB FSAs because of high resource recombination barriers. Such firms have great difficulty overcoming even limited compounded distance (across the national borders of the home region). These firms operate mostly on a local level.

In conclusion, Fig. 3 helps us to build upon the tension between the literature on simplistic aspects of globalization and global strategies, as compared to the realities of more complex decision making required by MNEs dealing with the realities of compounded distance and resource recombination barriers. In cell 1 of Fig. 3, the world is complex, in terms of compounded distance but the literature on metanationals and transnationals simply assumes that firms can overcome this. In reality, there are complexities facing the firm in developing new FSAs to overcome resource recombination barriers. In the future, IB research needs to engage with cell 3 rather than continuing to be bogged down in cell 1. In a similar manner, much of the literature over the last fifty years has dealt with cell 2 of Fig. 3. This has led to simplistic work on global firms, global mandates and born global firms which basically assume that the world is simple as both compounded distance and resource recombination barriers are ignored. In reality, even if compounded distance is not a critical challenge, there remain firms that operate in cell 4, developing mainly LB FSAs, and operating domestically. These firms lack the motivation to expand internationally, for example, because of an uncontested domestic market. In summary, future research in IB needs to distinguish much more carefully between the four cells of Fig. 3. In the concluding section, we suggest that such future research may well benefit from a focus upon the regional nature of IB.

Conclusions--Regional versus Global Strategies

We have shown that the three key units of analysis in IB theory over the past fifty years have been the country, the firm (MNE) and the subsidiary. The most promising area for further IB theory development is in essence the study of the interactions among these three parameters, with the subsidiary as the key building block. In particular, we have shown that the subsidiary has emerged as a new unit of analysis due to the importance of network thinking from strategic management. Here, the SSA concept represents the culmination of fifty years of IB analysis. An SSA results from (a) recombining knowledge transferred from the network with newly created knowledge; (b) autonomously assumed (extended) subsidiary roles; and (c) subsidiary knowledge embedded in idiosyncratic host country locations. Paradoxically, the SSA concept is conceptually almost the opposite to conventional network thinking in mainstream strategy, with its exaggerated focus on knowledge sharing.

Looking ahead, it is apparent that, irrespective of the unit of analysis chosen, the region--as an expression of how distance matters in IB--has emerged as an important parameter. Here, theoretical work is in its infancy as the focus of recent research on the nature and extent of regional versus global activity by MNEs has been largely empirical. This research only became possible due to changes in accounting standards in the late 1990s, which required firms to identify the broad regions of the triad in which their sales and assets take place, Rugman (2000, 2005). There is confirmation of the lack of global firms and the importance of the region as a unit of analysis in Fisch and Oesterle (2003); Asmussen (2009); Collinson and Rugman (2008); Rugman and Oh (2008); Hejazi (2007); Kolk (2010); Sethi (2009); Yin and Choi (2005); Rugman and Verbeke (2008a, b, c); Grosse (2005).

There needs to be more conceptually driven inquiry to solve the empirical puzzle that most of even the largest MNEs appear unable to move beyond their home region and go global. A transaction cost economics (TCE TCE


TCE Environment A volatile chlorinated hydrocarbon that boils at 88ºC and is highly soluble–1000 ppm in water, with various industrial uses Toxicity Peripheral neuropathy, carcinogenic.
) based analysis may be particularly useful here, Rugman and Verbeke (2005). Such analysis would recognize the barriers to recombining extant NLB FSAs held by the MNE, with LB FSAs to be provided by third parties (in the absence of well functioning external markets for the resources underlying these LB FSAs). This resource recombination process, in turn, may be a precondition pre·con·di·tion  
A condition that must exist or be established before something can occur or be considered; a prerequisite.

 to accessing the coveted CSAs in host markets, such as a large customer base at the downstream end or a highly skilled and productive workforce at the upstream end of the value chain, but requires overcoming resource recombination barriers.

Currently there appears to be a liability of interregional foreignness facing even the largest MNEs, though this concept has only been sketched by Rugman and Verbeke (2004, 2007). If the great majority of the world's 500 largest firms grow their sales and assets mainly within their home region, this suggests that their business models and strategies are home region based. There must be prohibitive pro·hib·i·tive   also pro·hib·i·to·ry
1. Prohibiting; forbidding: took prohibitive measures.

 resource recombination barriers associated with adapting or changing their business models to achieve truly global sales in the other two regions of the triad. Thus, IB theory must redirect re·di·rect  
tr.v. re·di·rect·ed, re·di·rect·ing, re·di·rects
To change the direction or course of.

A redirect examination.

 thinking at the country level on the liability of inter-regional foreignness caused by compounded distance and move this towards a focus upon regional strategy. In other words, the country level of analysis may need to move towards a regional level when assessing the impacts of differences in culture, political regulation, economic and financial institutions etc. New research on the multinationality and performance relationship needs to incorporate this regional dimension, Rugman and Oh (2007, 2010), Lee (2010), Oh (2010), Wolf et al. (2008), Li and Li (2007), while avoiding the pitfalls of the past research on this topic (Verbeke and Brugman 2009).

In related work, Fisch and Oesterle (2003) point out that the term 'globalization' has become overused, and has apparently replaced the term 'internationalization'. There are both conceptual research gaps concerning the difference between globalization and internationalization, and a lack of empirical knowledge about the actual level of globalization of MNEs. In the spirit of Rugman (2000), Fisch and Oesterle (2003) present a new quantitative tool, which combines geographic spread and cultural diversity measures, so as to integrate multiple dimensions of internationalization into a globalization index This article includes a list of countries of the world sorted by their globalization, the global connectivity, integration and interdependence in the economic, social, technological, cultural, political, and ecological spheres.  instead of a simple internationalization measure. Fisch and Oesterle (2003) apply this measure to assess the globalization of the most internationalized German MNEs, among the top 100 non-financial MNEs from developed economies. The results suggest that these MNEs are neither globalized nor show a straightforward path towards globalization in the past decade. This outcome contradicts the common assumption of global MNEs. This new construct can be operationalized to measure the degree of internationalization (Glaum and Oesterle 2007). More research like this needs to be undertaken on the metrics metrics Managed care A popular term for standards by which the quality of a product, service, or outcome of a particular form of Pt management is evaluated. See TQM.  of internationalization, not globalization.

In terms of international human resource development and cross-cultural studies Cross-cultural comparisons take several forms. One is comparison of case studies, another is controlled comparison among variants of a common derivation, and a third is comparison within a sample of cases. , a regional focus will require fundamental rethinking of the traditional country focus. If MNEs operate regionally, then what is the use of Hofstede (1983), House et al. (2004), GLOBE (2006) and the Kogut and Singh (1988) metrics? These traditional empirical shortcuts for cross-cultural analysis may need to be revised at a regional level. For example, Tung and Verbeke (2010) have suggested recently that analysis of expatriates and the training of senior executives for Chinese firms may be subject to an 'inverse resonance' and that there may be a need to adopt a regional focus, e.g., an Asian-Asian perspective rather than the traditional Western-Asian perspective. In many ways, the ten theoretical problems in cross-cultural research identified by Shenkar (2001) remain unresolved, mainly because research in this area is poorly embedded in IB theory. In this context, Wolf et al. (2008) examine the economic, psychological, and sociological reasons for home-region oriented MNEs (Rugman and Verbeke 2004; Rugman 2005).

In terms of political integration, the experiment of the EU offers many insights into the benefits of economic integration on a regional level with common institutions and regulations. But does this apply to NAFTA, in which the extent of social and political integration is much less than in the EU? Or to Asia, where at best a NAFTA type set of loose integration is more likely to arise than the tightly regulatory structure of the EU? Why is it that North American and Asian MNEs are nearly as home region based as European ones, without the same degree of political and social integration?

A final example of the need for better theoretical analysis, building upon the regional phenomenon, is the work on international entrepreneurship and so-called born global firms. Close scrutiny of the 'born global' phenomenon, whereby companies internationalize near or at their founding (Knight and Cavusgil 1996), suggests that these firms actually achieve their exports sales largely within the 'home region'. For example, Knight et al. (2004) investigate the 292 'born global' firms in Denmark and the United States. Their findings are that Danish firms generate on average of 71% of their total sales from abroad, mainly in Europe, compared to 47% for the American sample. This reflects the small size of the Danish domestic market and Denmark's proximity to numerous neighbouring countries in Europe, of which Germany accounts for 50% of their sales. The American firms generate 53% of their total sales in the United States. To be more accurate, these firms can be described as 'born regional', not 'born global', (Rugman 2000; Fisch and Oesterle 2003).

There appears to be no robust empirical evidence of any 'born global' firms other than a few IT firms from India and possibly some small firms from Israel, Rugman and Almodovar (2011). Instead, there are born regionals (Lee 2010; Lopez et al. 2009). Further, when a small firm makes opportunistic opportunistic /op·por·tu·nis·tic/ (op?er-tldbomacn-is´tik)
1. denoting a microorganism which does not ordinarily cause disease but becomes pathogenic under certain circumstances.

 foreign sales, these are usually in the form of exports, not FDI. Yet, the classic article on international new venture (born globals) by Oviatt and McDougall (1994) uses Dunning's OLI framework of MNEs to explain born global activity, instead of maintaining a more appropriate focus upon exports and international marketing. Again, this area of research is still very weakly embedded in basic IB theory.

In conclusion, future theoretical work in IB must continue to study the linkages among the key units of analysis adopted in the previous fifty years, with a focus on the subsidiary as the key building block, taking into account the reality of regional strategy and structure for most MNEs. We need to avoid being sidetracked by ill-conceived concepts such as the metanational and empirically illiterate ILLITERATE. This term is applied to one unacquainted with letters.
     2. When an ignorant man, unable to read, signs a deed or agreement, or makes his mark instead of a signature, and he alleges, and can provide that it was falsely read to him, he is not bound by
 subfields of research such as the born global literature, which ignores the costs of distance. We should focus instead on the limits to globalization, resulting from severe frictions, i.e. resource recombination barriers, occurring when attempts are made to conduct business beyond the home region, where compounded distance may be high. It is only by linking brave new empirical work on emerging issues, such as the regional solution, with good basic theory, i.e. sophisticated, comparative institutional analysis, as provided by internalization theory, that the field of international business will continue to prosper in the future.

Acknowledgements: We are pleased to acknowledge helpful comments from two referees, and from Professors Peter Buckley, Mark Casson, Michael-Joerg Oesterle, and Joachim Wolf. We also received helpful comments from participants at seminars at the University of Leeds Organisation
The various schools, institutes and centres of the University are arranged into nine faculties, each with a dean, pro-deans and central functions:
  • Arts
  • Biological Sciences
  • Business
  • Education, Social Sciences and Law
, York University York University, at North York, Ont., Canada; nondenominational; coeducational; founded 1959 as an affiliate of the Univ. of Toronto, became independent 1965.  and the University of Reading.


Aharoni, Y. (1966). The foreign investment decision process. Boston: Division of Research, Graduate School of Business Administration, Harvard University Harvard University, mainly at Cambridge, Mass., including Harvard College, the oldest American college. Harvard College

Harvard College, originally for men, was founded in 1636 with a grant from the General Court of the Massachusetts Bay Colony.

Andersson, U., Forsgren, M., & Holm, U. (2002). The strategic impact of external networks: Subsidiary performance and competence development in the multinational corporation. Strategic Management Journal, 23(11), 979-996.

Andersson, U., Forsgren, M., & Holm, U. (2007). Balancing subsidiary influence in the federative fed·er·a·tive  
Forming, belonging to, or of the nature of a federation.


See: Multinational corporation
: A business network view. Journal of International Business Studies JIBS, the Journal of International Business Studies, (ISSN: 0047-2506, eISSN: 1478-6990) is the official publication of the Academy of International Business (AIB) and is published by Palgrave Macmillan. , 38(5), 802-818.

Asmussen, C. G. (2009). Local, regional, or global? Quantifying MNE geographic scope. Journal of International Business Studies, 40(7), 1192-1205. Barney, J. B. (1991). Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage. Journal of Management, 17(1), 99-120.

Bartlett, C., & Ghoshal, S. (1989). Managing across borders The transnational solution. Boston: Harvard Business School Harvard Business School, officially named the Harvard Business School: George F. Baker Foundation, and also known as HBS, is one of the graduate schools of Harvard University.  Press.

Birkinshaw, J. M. (1996). How multinational subsidiary mandates are gained and lost. Journal of International Business Studies, 27(3), 467-496.

Birkinshaw, J. M. (1997). Entrepreneurship in multinational corporations: The characteristics of subsidiary initiatives. Strategic Management Journal, 18(3), 207-229.

Birkinshaw, J. M. (2000). The determinants and consequences of subsidiary initiative in multinational corporations. Entrepreneurship Theory and Practise prac·tise  
v. & n. Chiefly British
Variant of practice.

practis·er n.
, 24(1), 9-35.

Birkinshaw, J. M., & Hood, N. (1998) Multinational subsidiary evolution: Capability and charter change in foreign owned subsidiary companies. Academy of Management Review, 23(4), 773-795.

Birkinshaw, J. M., & Hood, N. (2001). Unleash innovation in foreign subsidiaries. Harvard Business Review Harvard Business Review is a general management magazine published since 1922 by Harvard Business School Publishing, owned by the Harvard Business School. A monthly research-based magazine written for business practitioners, it claims a high ranking business readership and , 79(3), 131-137.

Birkinshaw, J., & Pedersen, T. (2009). Strategy and management in MNE subsidiaries. In A. M. Rugman (Ed.), The Oxford handbook of international business (2nd ed., pp. 367-388). Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Birkinshaw, J. M., Hood, N., & Jonsson, S. (1998). Building firm specific advantages in multinational corporation: The role of subsidiary initiative. Strategic Management Journal, 19(3), 221-241.

Buckley, P. J. (2009). Internalization thinking From the multinational enterprise to the global factory. International Business Review, 18(3), 224-235.

Buckley, P., & Casson, M. (1976). The future of the multinational enterprise. Basingstoke: Macmillan.

Buckley, P., & Casson, M. (2009). The internalisation Noun 1. internalisation - learning (of values or attitudes etc.) that is incorporated within yourself
internalization, incorporation

learning, acquisition - the cognitive process of acquiring skill or knowledge; "the child's acquisition of language"
 theory of the multinational enterprise--A review of the progress of a research agenda after 30 years. Journal of International Business Studies, 40(9), 1563-1580.

Buckley, P. J., & Ghauri, P. N. (2004). Globalization, economic geography, and the strategy of the multinational enterprises. Journal of International Business Studies. 35(2), 81-98.

Buckley, P. J., & Hashai, N. (2005). Firm configuration and internationalization: A model. International Business Review, 14(6), 655-675.

Casson, M. (1979). Alternatives to the multinational enterprise. New York New York, state, United States
New York, Middle Atlantic state of the United States. It is bordered by Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and the Atlantic Ocean (E), New Jersey and Pennsylvania (S), Lakes Erie and Ontario and the Canadian province of
: Holmes & Meier.

Casson, M. (1982). The entrepreneur. Oxford: Martin Robertson.

Casson, M. (1987). The firm and the market. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.

Caves, R. E. (1971). International corporations: The industrial economics of foreign investment. Economica, 38(149), 1-27.

Caves, R. E. (1982, 1996). Multinational enterprises and economic analysis (1st and 2nd edn.) Cambridge: Cambridge University Press Cambridge University Press (known colloquially as CUP) is a publisher given a Royal Charter by Henry VIII in 1534, and one of the two privileged presses (the other being Oxford University Press). .

Coase, R. H. (1937). The nature of the firm. Economica, 4(16), 386-405.

Collinson, S., & Rugman, A. M. (2008). The regional nature of Japanese multinational business. Journal of International Business Studies, 39(2), 215-230.

Cyert, R. M., & March, J. G. (1963). A behavioural Adj. 1. behavioural - of or relating to behavior; "behavioral sciences"
 theory of the firm. New Jersey: Prentice Hall Prentice Hall is a leading educational publisher. It is an imprint of Pearson Education, Inc., based in Upper Saddle River, New Jersey, USA. Prentice Hall publishes print and digital content for the 6-12 and higher education market. History
In 1913, law professor Dr.

D'Cruz, J. (1986). Managing the multinational subsidiaries. In H. Etemad & L. S. Dulude (Eds.), Managing the multinational subsidiary (pp. 75-89). London: Croom Helm.

Doz, Y., Santos Santos (sän`ts), city (1996 pop. 412,288), São Paulo state, SE Brazil, on the island of São Vicente in the Atlantic just off the mainland. , J., & Williamson, P. (2001). From global to metanational: How companies win in the knowledge economy. Harvard: Harvard Business School Press.

Dunning, J. H. (1958). American investment in British manufacturing industry. London: Allen & Unwin.

Dunning, J. H. (1977). Trade, location of economic activity and the MNEs: A search for an eclectic paradigm. In P. Wijikman (Ed.), The international allocation of economic activity (pp. 395-418). London: Macmillan.

Dunning, J. H. (1988). The eclectic paradigm of international production: A restatement Restatement

A revision in a company's earlier financial statements.

The need for restating financial figures can result from fraud, misrepresentation, or a simple clerical error.
 and some possible extension. Journal of International Business Studies. 19(1), 1-31.

Dunning, J. H. (1998). Location and the multinational enterprise: A neglected factor? Journal of International Business Studies. 29(1), 45-66.

Dunning, J. H., & Rugman, A. M. (1985). The influence of Hymer's dissertation dis·ser·ta·tion  
A lengthy, formal treatise, especially one written by a candidate for the doctoral degree at a university; a thesis.


 on the theory of foreign direct investment. American economic review. Papers and proceedings, 75(2), 228-260.

Eden, L. (2005). Cave! Hic HIC Habitat International Coalition
HIC Health Insurance Commission
HIC Head Injury Criterion
HIC Health Information Center
HIC Health Insurance Claim
HIC Humanitarian Information Center
HIC Hydrophobic Interaction Chromatography
HIC Health Informatics Conference
 Dragones! Alan M. Rugman's contribution to the field of international business. In A. Verbeke (Ed.), Research in global strategic management: Vol. 11. Internalization, international diversification International diversification

The attempt to reduce risk by investing in more than one nation. By diversifying across nations whose economic cycles are not perfectly correlated, investors can typically reduce the variability of their returns.
 and the multinational enterprise, essays in honour of Alan M. Rugman (pp. 9-27). Oxford: Elsevier.

Eden, L., & Dai, L. (2010). Rethinking the O in Dunning's OLI/eclectic paradigm. Multinational Business Review, 18(2), 13-24.

Egelhoff, W. (1982). Strategy and structure in multinational corporations: A revision of the Stopford and Wells model. Administrative Science Quarterly Administrative Science Quarterly, founded in 1956, is one of the most eminent academic journals in the field of organizational studies. It is published by Cornell University.

People claimed to have been involved as founders include James D.
, 27(3), 435-458.

Fina, E., & Rugman, A. M. (1996). A test of internalization theory and internationalization theory: The Upjohn company. Management International Review, 36(3), 199-213.

Fisch, J. H., & Oesterle, M.-J. (2003). Exploring the globalization of German MNCs with the complex spread and diversity measure. Schmalenbach Business Review, 55(1), 2-21.

Forsgren, M., Holm, U., & Johanson, J. (1995). Division headquarters go abroad: A step in the internationalization and the multinational corporation. Journal of Management Studies, 32(4), 475-491.

Foss, N. J., & Pedersen, T. (2002). Transferring knowledge in MNCs: The role of sources of subsidiary knowledge and organizational context. Journal of international Management, 8(1), 1-19.

Ghemawat, P. (2001). Distance still matters: The hard reality of global expansion. Harvard Business Review, 79(8), 137-147.

Ghemawat, P. (2007). Redefining global strategy: Crossing borders in a world where differences still matter. Harvard: Harvard Business School Press.

Glaum, M., & Oesterle, M.-J. (2007). 40 years of research on internationalization and firm performance: More questions than answers? Management International Review 47(3), 307-317, Focused Issue.

Grosse, R. (2005). Are the largest financial institutions really "global'"? Management International Review, 45(1), 129-145.

Grubaugh, S. J. (1987). Determinants of direct foreign investment. Review of Economics and Statistics, 69(1), 149-152.

Gulati, R., Nohria, N., & Zaheer, A. (2006). Strategic networks. Strategic Management Journal, 21(3), 203-215.

Hedlund, G. (1986). The hypermodern MNC: A heterarchy? Human Resource Management, 25(1), 9-35.

Hejazi, W. (2007). Reconsidering the concentration of US MNE activity: Is it global, regional, or national? Management International Review, 47(1), 5-27.

Hennart, J. F. (1982). A theory of multinational enterprise. Ann Arbor Ann Arbor, city (1990 pop. 109,592), seat of Washtenaw co., S Mich., on the Huron River; inc. 1851. It is a research and educational center, with a large number of government and industrial research and development firms, many in high-technology fields such as : University of Michigan (body, education) University of Michigan - A large cosmopolitan university in the Midwest USA. Over 50000 students are enrolled at the University of Michigan's three campuses. The students come from 50 states and over 100 foreign countries.  Press.

Hennart, J. F. (2009a). Theories of the multinational enterprise. In A. M. Rugman (Ed.), The Oxford handbook of international business (2nd ed., pp. 125-145). Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Hennart, J. F. (2009b). Down with MNE centric theories! Market entry and expansion as the bundling of MNE and local assets. Journal of International Business Studies, 40(9), 1432-1454.

Hofstede, G. (1983). The cultural relativity cultural relativity,
n technique for understanding the various ways in which people explain their behavior.
 of organizational practices and theories. Journal of International Business Studies, 14(2), 75-89.

Hofstede, G. (2006). What did GLOBE really measure? Researchers' minds versus respondents' minds. Journal of International Business Studies, 37(6), 882-896.

Holm, U., & Pedersen, T. (2000). The emergence and impact of centres of excellence: A subsidiary perspectives. London: McMillan.

House, R. J., Hanges, P. J., Javidan, M., Dorfman, P. W., & Gupta, V. (2004). Culture, leadership and organizations. The GLOBE study of 62 societies. Thousand Oaks Thousand Oaks, residential city (1990 pop. 104,352), Ventura co., S Calif., in a farm area; inc. 1964. Avocados, citrus, vegetables, strawberries, and nursery products are grown. : Sage.

Hymer, S. H. (1960). The international operations of national firms: A study of direct foreign investment. Ph.D thesis, MIT MIT - Massachusetts Institute of Technology  (published by MIT Press, Cambridge: MA under the same title in 1976).

Hymer, S. H. (1976). The international operations of national firms: A study of direct foreign investment. Cambridge: MIT Press.

Itaki, M. (1991). A critical assessment of the eclectic e·clec·tic  
1. Selecting or employing individual elements from a variety of sources, systems, or styles: an eclectic taste in music; an eclectic approach to managing the economy.

 theory of the multinational enterprise. Journal of International Business Studies, 22(3), 445-460.

Johanson, J., & Vahlne, J.-E. (1977). The internationalization process of the firm: A model of knowledge development and increasing foreign market commitments. Journal of International Business Studies, 8(1), 23-32.

Johanson, J., & Vahlne, J.-E. (1990). The mechanism of internationalization. International Marketing Review, 7(4), 11-24.

Johanson, J., & Vahlne, J.-E. (2009). The Uppsala internationalization process model revisited: From liability of foreignness to liability of outsidership. Journal of International Business Studies, 40(9), 1411-1431.

Johanson, J., & Wiedersheim, P. F. (1975). The internationalization of the firm--The four Swedish cases. Journal of Management Studies, 12(3), 305-322.

Kindleberger, C. P. (1969). American business abroad: Six lectures on direct investment. London: Yale University Yale University, at New Haven, Conn.; coeducational. Chartered as a collegiate school for men in 1701 largely as a result of the efforts of James Pierpont, it opened at Killingworth (now Clinton) in 1702, moved (1707) to Saybrook (now Old Saybrook), and in 1716 was  Press.

Knight, G. A., & Cavusgil, S. T. (1996). The born global firms: A challenge to the traditional international theory. In S. Cavusgil & T. Madsen (Eds.), Advances in International Marketing (Vol. 8, pp. 11-26). Greenwich: JAI JAI Java Advanced Imaging
JAI Justice et Affaires Interiéures (French: Justice and Home Affairs)
JAI Journal of ASTM International
JAI Just An Idea
JAI Jazz Alliance International
JAI Joint Africa Institute

Knight, G. A., Madsen, T. K., & Servais, P. (2004). An inquiry into bona global firms in Europe and the USA. International Marketing Review, 21(6), 645-665.

Kogut, B., & Singh, H. (1988). The effect of national culture on the choice of entry mode. Journal of International Business Studies. 19(3), 411-432.

Kolk, A. (2010). Social and sustainability dimensions of regionalization regionalization Managed care The subdivision of a broadly available service–eg, a blood bank, into quasi-autonomous regional centers, capable of making decisions and providing more cost-effective and/or faster service to hospitals and health care facilities,  and (Semi) globalization. Multinational Business Review: 18(1), 51-72.

Lee, I. H. (2010). The M curve: The performance of born-regional firms from Korea. Multinational Business Review, 18(4), 1-22.

Li, J. (1994). Experience effects and international question: strategies of service MNCs in the Asia Pacific region. Management International Review, 34(3), 217-234.

Li, L., & Li. D. (2007). Testing the global and regional strategies of multinational enterprise. In A. M. Rugman (Ed.), Research in global strategic management: Vol. 13. The regional aspects of multinationality and performance (pp 263-269). Oxford: Elsevier.

Li, J., & Rugman, A. M. (2007). Real options and the theory of foreign direct investment. International Business Review, 16(6), 687-712.

Lo, F-Y., Mahoney, J. T., & Tan, D. (2010). The relationship between location bound advantages and international strategy: An empirical investigation. Working Paper. Working_papers/papers/10-0103.pdf.

Lopez, L. E., Kundu, S. K., & Ciravegna, L. (2009). Born global vs. born regional: Evidence from an exploratory study on the Costa Rican software industry. Journal of International Business Studies. 40(7), 1228-1238.

Loree, D., & Guisinger, S. (1995). Policy and non-policy determinants of US equity foreign direct investment. Journal of International Business Studies, 26(2), 281-299.

Luostarinen, R. (1979). Internationalization of the firm. Helsinki: Academie Economicae, Helsinki School of Economics.

Mahoney, J. T., & Pandian, J. R. (1992). The resource based view within the conversation of strategic management. Strategic Management Journal, 13(5), 363-380.

Malnight, T. (1996). The transition from decentralized to network-based MNC structures: An evolutionary perspective. Journal of International Business Studies, 27(1), 43-66.

Meyer, K. E., Estrin, S., Kumar B. S., & Peng, M. W. (2009). Institutions, resources, and entry strategies in emerging economies. Strategic Management Journal, 30(1), 61-80.

Moore, K. (1996). Capturing international responsibilities in the Canadian pharmaceutical industry. Industry Canada Industry Canada is the department of the Government of Canada with responsibility for regional economic development, investment, and innovation/research and development. The department employs 6104 FTEs across Canada.  Working Paper.

Moore, K. (2001). A strategy for subsidiaries: Centres of excellence to build subsidiary specific advantages. Management International Review, 41(3), 275-290.

Moore, K., & Birkinshaw, J. (1998). Managing knowledge in global service firms; centres of excellence. Academy of Management Executive, 12(4), 81-92.

Mudambi, R. (2008). Location, control and innovation in knowledge-intensive industries. Journal of Economic Geography, 8(5), 699-725.

Mudambi, R., & Navarra, P. (2004). Is knowledge power? Knowledge flows, subsidiary power, and rent-seeking within MCs. Journal of International Business Studies, 35(5), 385-406.

Narula, R., & Hagedoorn, J. (1999). Innovating through strategic alliances: Moving towards international partnerships and contractual agreements. Technovation, 19(5), 283-294.

Oh, C. H. (2010). Value creation and home region internationalization of U.S. MNEs. Multinational Business Review, 18(4), 23-50.

Oviatt, B., & McDougall, P. (1994). Towards a theory of international new ventures. Journal of International Business Studies, 25(1), 45-64.

Penrose, E. (1959). The theory of the growth of the firm. New York: Wiley.

Peteraf, M. A. (1993). The cornerstones of competitive advantage: A resource-based view The resource-based view (RBV) is an economic tool used to determine the strategic resources available to a firm. The fundamental principle of the RBV is that the basis for a competitive advantage of a firm lies primarily in the application of the bundle of valuable resources at the . Strategic Management Journal, 14(3), 179-191.

Poynter, T. A., & Rugman, A. M. (1982). World product mandates: How will multinationals respond? Business Quarterly; 47(3), 54-61.

Prahalad, C. K., & Doz, Y. L. (1981). An approach to strategic control in MNCs. Sloan Management Review, 22(4), 5-14.

Prahalad, C. K., & Doz, Y. (1987). The multinational mission: Balancing local demands and global vision. New York: The Free Press.

Prahalad, C. K., & Hamel, G. (1990) The core competence Core competence

Primary area of expertise. Narrowly defined fields or tasks at which a company or business excels. Primary areas of specialty.
 of the corporation. Harvard Business Review, 68(3), 79-91.

Rugman, A. M. (1980a). A test of internalization theory. Managerial and Decision Economics, 2(4), 211-219.

Rugman, A. M. (1980b). Multinationals in Canada: Theory, performance and economic impact. Boston: Martinus Nijhoff Martinus Nijhoff (b. April 20 1894 - d. January 26 1953) was a Dutch poet and essayist. He studied literature in Amsterdam and law in Utrecht. His debut was made in 1916 with his volume De wandelaar ("The wanderer"). .

Rugman, A. M. (1981). Inside the multinationals: The economics of internal markets. New York: Columbia Press. Reissued by Palgrave Macmillan in 2006 as Inside the Multinationals, (25th Anniversary Edition), Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

Rugman, A. M. (1983a). The comparative performance of U.S. and European multinational enterprises, 1970-1979. Management International Review; 23(2), 4-14.

Rugman, A. M. (1983b). Multinationals and technology transfer. New York: Praeger.

Rugman, A. M. (1985). Internalization is still a general theory of foreign direct investment. Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv, 121(3), 570-575.

Rugman, A. M. (2000). The end of globalization. London: Random House.

Rugman, A. M. (2005). The regional multinationals: MNEs and "Global" strategic management. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Rugman, A. M. (2010). Reconciling internalization theory and the eclectic paradigm. Multinational Business Review, 18(2), 1-12

Rugman A. M., & Almodovar, P. (2011). The born global illusion and the regional nature of international business. In R. Ramamurti & N. Hashai (Eds.), Research in global strategic management: Vol. 15. The future of foreign direct investment and the multinational enterprise (pp. 265-283). Bingley: Emerald.

Rugman, A. M., & Bennett, J. (1982). Technology transfer and world product mandating in Canada. Columbia Journal of World Business, 17(4), 58-62.

Rugman, A. M., & Douglas, S. (1986). The strategic management of multinationals and world product mandating. Canadian Public Policy Canadian Public Policy is Canada's leading journal examining economic and social policy. The aim of the journal is to stimulate research and discussion of public policy problems in Canada. , 12(2), 320-328.

Rugman, A. M., & D'Cruz, J. (2000). Multinationals as flagship firms: Regional business networks. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Rugman, A. M., & McIlveen, J. (1985). Canadian multinationals: Identification, performance and strategic management. Management International Review. 25(3), 41-56.

Rugman, A. M., & Oh, C. H. (2007). Multinationality and regional performance, 2001-2005. In A. M. Rugman (Ed.), Research in global strategic management: Vol. 13. Regional aspects of multinationality and performance (pp. 31-43). Oxford: Elservier.

Rugman, A. M., & Oh, C. H. (2008). Korea's multinationals in a regional world. Journal of World Business, 43(1), 5-15.

Rugman, A. M., & Oh, C. H. (2010). Does the regional nature of multinationals affect the multinationality and performance relationship? International Business Review 19(5), 479-488.

Rugman, A. M., & Verbeke, A. (1992). A note on the transnational solution and the transaction cost theory of multinational strategic management. Journal of International Business Studies, 23(4), 761-771.

Rugman, A. M., & Verbeke, A. (1993). Foreign subsidiaries and multinational strategic management. Management International Review, Special Issue, 33(2), 71-84.

Rugman, A. M., & Verbeke, A. (2001). Subsidiary-specific advantages in multinational enterprises. Strategic Management Journal, 22(3), 237-250.

Rugman A. M., & Verbeke, A. (2002). Edith Penrose's contribution to the resource-based view of strategic management. Strategic Management Journal, 23(8), 769-780.

Rugman, A. M., & Verbeke, A. (2003). Extending the theory of the multinational enterprises: internalization theory and strategic management perspectives. Journal of International Business Studies, 34(2), 125-137.

Rugman, A. M., & Verbeke, A. (2004). A perspective on regional and global strategies of multinational enterprises. Journal of International Business Studies, 35(1), 3-18.

Rugman, A. M., & Verbeke, A. (2005). Towards a theory of regional multinationals: a transaction cost economics approach. Management International Review, Special Issue, 45(1), 5-17.

Rugman, A. M., & Verbeke, A. (2007). Liabilities of regional foreignness and the use of firm-level versus country-level data: A response to Dunning et al. (2007). Journal of International Business Studies, 38(1), 200-205.

Rugman, A. M., & Verbeke, A. (2008a). A regional solution to the strategy and structure of multinationals. European Management Journal, 26(5), 305-313.

Rugman, A. M., & Verbeke, A. (2008b). A new perspective on the regional and global strategies of multinational service firms. Management International Review, 48(4), 397-411.

Rugman, A. M., & Verbeke, A. (2008c). The theory and practice of regional strategy: A response to Osegowtisch and Sammartino. Journal of International Business Studies, 39(2), 326-332.

Rugman, A. M., & Verbeke, A. (2009a). Location, competitiveness and the multinational enterprise. In A. M. Rugman (Ed.), The Oxford handbook of international business (2nd ed., pp. 146-180). Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Rugman, A. M., & Verbeke, A. (2009b). Multinational enterprises and public policy. In A. M. Rugman (Ed.), The Oxford handbook of international business (2nd ed., pp. 228-255). Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Rugman, A. M., Lecraw, D. L., & Booth, L. D. (1985). International business: Firm and environment. New York: McGraw-Hill.

Rugman, A. M., Li, J., & Oh, C. H. (2009). Are supply chains global or regional? International Marketing Review, 26(4/5), 384-395.

Rugman, A. M., Verbeke, A., & Yuan, W. (2011). Re-conceptualizing Bartlett and Ghoshal's classification of national subsidiary roles in the multinational enterprise. Journal of Management Studies, 48(2), 253-277.

Ruigrok, W., & Wagner, H. (2003). Internationalization and performance: An organizational learning perspective. Management International Review; 43(1), 63-83.

Rumelt, R. P. (1984). Towards a strategic theory of the firm. In R. B. Lamb (Ed.), Competitive strategic management (pp. 556-570). Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall. Reprinted in N. J. Foss, Resources firms and strategies: A reader in the resource-based perspective (pp. 131-145). Oxford University Press, 1997.

Sethi, D. (2009). Are multinational enterprises from the emerging economies global or regional? European Management Journal, 27(5), 356-365.

Shenkar, O. (2001). Cultural distance revisited: Towards a more rigorous conceptualization and measurement of cultural differences. Journal of International Business Studies, 32(3), 519-535.

Stopford, J. M., & Wells, L. T. (1972). Managing the multinational enterprise: Organization of the firm and ownership of the subsidiaries. New York: Basic Books.

Teece, D., Pisano, G., & Shuene, A. (1997). Dynamic capabilities and strategic management. Strategic Management Journal, 18(8), 537-556.

Tung, R., & Verbeke, A. (2010). Beyond Hofstede and GLOBE: Improving the quality of cross cultural research. Journal of International Business Studies, 41(8), 1259-1274.

Verbeke, A. (2009). International business strategy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Verbeke, A., & Brugman, P. (2009). Triple testing the quality of multinationality--performance research: An internalization theory perspective. International Business Review, 18(3), 265-275.

Verbeke, A., & Greidanus, N. S. (2009). The end of the opportunism Opportunism
Arabella, Lady

squire’s wife matchmakes with money in mind. [Br. Lit.: Doctor Thorne]

Ashkenazi, Simcha

shrewdly and unscrupulously becomes merchant prince. [Yiddish Lit.
 vs trust debate: Bounded reliability as a new envelope concept in research on MNE governance. Journal of International Business Studies, 40(9), 1471-1495.

Verbeke, A., & Kenworthy, T. (2008). Multidivisional vs. Metanational governance of the multinational enterprise. Journal of International Business Studies, 39(6), 940-956.

Vernon, R. (1966). International investment and international trade in the product life cycle. The Quarterly Journal of Economics The Quarterly Journal of Economics, or QJE, is an economics journal published by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and edited at Harvard University's Department of Economics. Its current editors are Robert J. Barro, Edward L. Glaeser and Lawrence F. Katz. , 80(2), 190-207.

Vernon, R. (1971). Sovereignty at bay: The multinational spread of US enterprises. New York: Basic Books.

Vernon, R. (1991). Sovereignty at bay: Twenty years TWENTY YEARS. The lapse of twenty years raises a presumption of certain facts, and after such a time, the party against whom the presumption has been raised, will be required to prove a negative to establish his rights.
 after. Millennium Journal of International Studies, 20(2), 191-195.

Wernerfelt, B. (1984). A resource based view of the firm. Strategic Management Journal, 5(2), 171-180.

Williamson, O. E. (1981). The economics of organization: The transaction cost approach. The American Journal of Sociology, 87(3), 548-577

Wolf, J., & Egelhoff, W. G. (2010). Limitations of the network organization in MNCs. In J. PlaBarber & J. Alegre (Eds.), Progress in international business research (Vol. 5, pp. 143-172). Amsterdam: Emerald.

Wolf, J., & Egelhott, W. G. (2011). Network or matrix? How information-processing theory can help MNCs answer this question. In A. Bollingtoft, L. Donaldson, G. R Huber, D. Dojbak Hakonsson, & C. C. Snow (Eds.), Collaborative communities of firms--Purpose, process, and design. Springer springer

a North American term commonly used to describe heifers close to term with their first calf.
 Science: Business Media B.V (in press).

Wolf, J., Dunemann, T., & Egelhoff, W. G. (2008) Economic, psychological, and sociological theories for the explanation of home-region oriented MNCs. The best paper proceedings of the annual conference of the academy of management, Anaheim.

Yin, E., & Choi, C. J. (2005). The globalization myth: The case of China. Management International Review, 45(Special Issue 1), 103-120. Zaheer, S. (1995). Overcoming the liability of foreignness. Academy of Management Journal, 38(2), 341-363.

Received: 26.1 1.2010 / Revised: 30.03.2011 / Accepted: 13.09.2011 / Published online: 11.11.2011

[c] Gabler-Verlag 2011

Prof. A. M. Rugman ([mail]) * PhD Cand. Q. T. K. Nguyen Henley Business School, International Business and Strategy, University of Reading, Reading, UK

e-mail: a.rugman

Prof. A. Verbeke McCaig Chair in Management, Haskayne School of Business, University of Calgary, Calgary, Canada

DOI (Digital Object Identifier) A method of applying a persistent name to documents, publications and other resources on the Internet rather than using a URL, which can change over time. 10.1007/s11575-011-0102-3
COPYRIGHT 2011 Gabler Verlag
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2011 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

 Reader Opinion




Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Rugman, Alan M.; Verbeke, Alain; Nguyen, Quyen T.K.
Publication:Management International Review
Geographic Code:1CANA
Date:Nov 1, 2011
Previous Article:50 years of Management International Review and IB/IM research: an inventory and some suggestions for the field's development.
Next Article:Advancing new theory development in the field of international management: contributing factors, investigative approach, and proposed topics.

Terms of use | Copyright © 2014 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters