Printer Friendly
The Free Library
14,505,585 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

FAKE TV NEWS IS A REAL-LIFE PROBLEM.


Byline: Mariel Garza Columnist

Last September, Channel 7, the ABC ABC
 in full American Broadcasting Co.

Major U.S. television network. It began when the expanding national radio network NBC split into the separate Red and Blue networks in 1928.
 affiliate for Los Angeles Los Angeles (lôs ăn`jələs, lŏs, ăn`jəlēz'), city (1990 pop. 3,485,398), seat of Los Angeles co., S Calif.; inc. 1850. , aired a story during the 5 p.m. Tuesday newscast about a blood test to find allergies in kids.

It looked like a legit le·git  
adj. Slang
Legitimate.
 news story, with interviews, graphics, cute kids and a voice-over by a Channel 7 news reporter.

It wasn't, though. The report was a canned video news release, or VNR VNR Video News Release
VNR Van Nostrand Reinhold (publishing company)
VNR Video Noise Reduction
VNR Veranstaltungsnummer
VNR VFR Flight Not Recommended
VNR Video News Reel
VNR Very Nice Roll
VNR Variable Navigation Ratio
, produced for and paid by Quest Diagnostics Quest Diagnostics Incorporated (NYSE: DGX) is a United States corporation which provides clinical laboratory services . The company also has a business presence in England and Mexico.

Quest Diagnostics is a member of the Fortune 500 and the S&P 500.
, a company that runs labs around the country that do this very sort of testing. There was no disclosure by the station that the piece was an advertorial ad·ver·to·ri·al  
n.
An advertisement promoting the interests or opinions of a corporate sponsor, often presented in such a way as to resemble an editorial.



[adver(tisement) + (edi)torial.
.

To its credit, ABC7 acknowledged airing the VNR.

"ABC7 Eyewitness News Eyewitness News is a local television newscast format, widely used in different markets across the United States. It is also the name of a very popular music package offered by Gari Communications.  has a policy against using VNRs in their entirety or even using excerpts without appropriate attribution and original reporting to confirm or contradict the claims in the VNR," Cheryl Fair, vice president and news director said in an e-mail response to my request for comment.

"Nonetheless, a VNR about an allergy test called Immunocap did somehow slip through the cracks last September. We continue to review our editorial process to ensure full compliance with our policy."

There was really no point in denying it. The Center for Media and Democracy The Center for Media and Democracy (CMD) is a nonprofit American-based media research group founded in 1993 by environmentalist writer and political activist John Stauber. It publishes PR Watch, a quarterly newsletter edited by Laura A. Miller.  posted the video of that fake news report on its Web site, one of 36 VNRs aired on 77 stations all over the country including two others in L.A., KCBS KCBS Kansas City Barbecue Society
KCBS Korea Christian Book Service (now called KCB; Seoul, Korea)
KCBS Kerala Catholic Bible Society (Kerala, India) 
 (Channel 2) and KTLA KTLA KCBS TV in Los Angeles  (Channel 5) as part of the results of a new study (www.prwatch.org/fakenews/execsummary).

That may indeed have been a one-time oops by ABC7, but the center's study suggests that the practice of using VNRs and disguising them as news is widespread. But you wouldn't know it because most of the stations that were caught airing the corporate VNRs never identified them as fake news. Nor did they mention the "news" reports were bought and paid for by a corporate sponsor such as General Motors, Intel or Capital One, and were often one-sided and, in some cases, flat-out lies.

Those of us in the print media, however, miss no opportunity to smack around television news for being vapid, celebrity-driven and regurgitating the stories that we, the "real" journalists, report. Hey, they are our competition, not to mention better looking and better paid than we ink-stained schlubs.

But this goes far beyond lazy journalism into the land of sinister public manipulation.

Daniel Price, a Los Angeles consultant, novelist and co-author of the VNR study, said what was most surprising about the findings was the level of complicity among news stations.

Price expected to find the fake news to be used, "but not as much the active deception in part of newsrooms, to what extents they would go to disguise the VNRs." For instance, some stations used graphic embellishments to make the reports consistent with the stations. Others used voice-overs. One Fox station identified the "reporter" on the fake news report as being a Fox representative.

And what's worse is that it appears news stations didn't even check the veracity veracity (vras´itē),
n
 of the reports. If they had, the General Motors-sponsored segment claiming that the company had pioneered online car sales would have been found to be bogus. Price did a quick Nexus database search and found the claim was simply not true.

So what's the harm in fake news? Maybe nothing if the dispute is over who invented online car sales. But Price said many of the segments are produced for pharmaceutical companies. What if a doctor sees a fake news segment and prescribes a drug based on what appears to be a good news story, but really is well-disguised advertising?

So how can you tell the fake news from the real news on the TV news? You can't.

"Even I can't tell," said Price, noting that he suspected some pieces of being fake news only to discover they were just bad journalism. And since the study only tracked a small percentage of VNRs for a 10-month period, there's probably much more fake news than we know.

Anyone worried about the prevalence of fake news could contact the Federal Communications Commission Federal Communications Commission (FCC), independent executive agency of the U.S. government established in 1934 to regulate interstate and foreign communications in the public interest.  and demand that it put a stop to advertising passed off as news. But there's something else you could do right away: Read newspapers instead.

Yes, I am biased. We may not be perfect, but when one of us tries to pass off a press release as our own work, we get in trouble. And it won't be long before print Web sites have just as much on-demand video as news.

Besides, you can tell by our paychecks we don't do this job for the money.
COPYRIGHT 2006 Daily News
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2006, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:Viewpoint
Publication:Daily News (Los Angeles, CA)
Date:Apr 9, 2006
Words:774
Previous Article:REALITY OR ENTERTAINMENT? MAYBE HOLLYWOOD IS `IN TOUCH' AFTER ALL.(Viewpoint)
Next Article:'WILL & GRACE' GLAAD TO BE HONORED.(News)
Topics:



Related Articles
Battling for integrity. (NCEW vs. Planted Opinions).(National Conference of Editorial Writers)
Determination of the solids retainment effectiveness of disposable swim diapers.(Practical Stuff!)
The power of fake news.(National)
Tina Fey.(Big Gay Following)(Interview)
FDA, companies test RFID tracking to prevent drug counterfeiting.
PUBLIC FORUM DUMPING SOCIETY.(Editorial)(Letter to the Editor)(Editorial)
PUBLIC FORUM.(Editorial)(Editorial)(Letter to the editor)
PUBLIC FORUM.(Editorial)(Editorial)(Letter to the editor)
License to recruit? Admissions-sponsored student blogging can get real results for your institution.(INTERNET TECHNOLOGY)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles