Elton Mayo: the Hawthorne experiments.Professor George Elton Mayo George Elton Mayo (December 26, 1880 - September 7, 1949) was a psychologist and sociologist.
He lectured at the University of Queensland from 1919 to 1923 before moving to the University of Pennsylvania, but spent most of his career at Harvard Business School (1926 - 1947), (1880-1949) has secured fame as the leader in a series of experiments which became one of the great turning-points in management thinking. At the Hawthorne plant of Western Electric, he discovered that job satisfaction increased through employee participation in decisions rather than through short-term incentives.
Mayo's importance to management lies in the fact that he established evidence on the value of a management approach and style which, although not necessarily an alternative to FW Taylor's scientific management, presented facts which Taylorites could not ignore.
Background and career
An Australian by birth, Mayo read psychology at Adelaide University and, in 1911, was appointed lecturer lecturer A person who is primarily–if not entirely—involved in the teaching activities of an academic center, who is not expected to perform research or Pt management; in general, lectureships are non-tenured positions in Logic, Ethics and Psychology (and later Professor of Philosophy), at the University of Queensland The University of Queensland (UQ) is the longest-established university in the state of Queensland, Australia, a member of Australia's Group of Eight, and the Sandstone Universities. It is also a founding member of the international Universitas 21 organisation. .
Anxious to move to the USA for professional reasons, he took a post at Pennsylvania University Pennsylvania University may refer to one of two unrelated universities:
The Hawthorne Experiments began in 1924, Mayo's involvement in them in 1928, after he had moved to the Harvard University Harvard University, mainly at Cambridge, Mass., including Harvard College, the oldest American college. Harvard College
Harvard College, originally for men, was founded in 1636 with a grant from the General Court of the Massachusetts Bay Colony. School of Business Administration as Associate Professor of Industrial Research. Later awarded a Chair, he remained at Harvard until his retirement in 1947. During the Second World War, Mayo contributed to the development of supervisor training within his Training Within Industry (TWI Twi
A variety of the Akan language spoken in Ghana. ) programme, which was widely adopted in the USA. The last two years of his life were spent in Britain as an advisor to the British government on problems within industry. Mayo wrote about democracy and freedom and the social problems of industrialised Adj. 1. industrialised - made industrial; converted to industrialism; "industrialized areas"
industrial - having highly developed industries; "the industrial revolution"; "an industrial nation" civilisation. It is as the author of 'Human Problems of an Industrial Civilisation' which reports on the Hawthorne Experiments, that he is known for his contribution to management thinking, even though he disclaimed responsibility for the design and direction of the project.
The Hawthorne plant of Western Electric was located in Chicago. It had some 29,000 employees and manufactured telephones and telephone equipment, principally for AT & T. The company had a reputation for advanced personnel policies and had welcomed a research study by the National Research Council into the relationship between work-place lighting and individual efficiency.
The study began in 1924 by isolating i·so·late
tr.v. i·so·lat·ed, i·so·lat·ing, i·so·lates
1. To set apart or cut off from others.
2. To place in quarantine.
3. two groups of workers in order to experiment with the impact of various incentives on their productivity. Improvements to levels of lighting produced increases in productivity, but so too did reversion reversion: see atavism. to standard lighting and even below-standard lighting in both groups. The initial assumption therefore was that increased output stemmed stemmed
1. Having the stems removed.
2. Provided with a stem or a specific type of stem. Often used in combination: stemmed goblets; long-stemmed roses. from variation alone.
Other incentives--including payment incentives and rest pauses--were manipulated at regular intervals, and although output levels varied, the trend was inexorably in·ex·o·ra·ble
Not capable of being persuaded by entreaty; relentless: an inexorable opponent; a feeling of inexorable doom. See Synonyms at inflexible. upwards. Whatever experimentation was applied, output went up. Although it had been fairly conclusively con·clu·sive
Serving to put an end to doubt, question, or uncertainty; decisive. See Synonyms at decisive.
con·clusive·ly adv. determined that lighting had little or nothing to do with output levels, the Assistant Works Manager (George Pennock) agreed that something peculiar was going on and that experimentation should continue.
Early deductions--Supervision and Employee attitudes
In the winter of 1927, Pennock invited Clair Turner, Professor of Biology and Public Health at MIT MIT - Massachusetts Institute of Technology , to consult. Turner quickly resolved that rest pauses in themselves were not the cause for increased output, although it was observed that longer rest pauses gave rise to more social interaction, which in turn impacted on mental attitudes. Turner attributed the rise in output to: the small group; the type of supervision; earnings; the novelty Novelty is the quality of being new. Although it may be said to have an objective dimension (e.g. a new style of art coming into being, such as abstract art or impressionism) it essentially exists in the subjective perceptions of individuals. of the experiment, and the increased attention to the experimentees generated by the experiment itself.
Pennock had been among the first to note that supervisory style was important. The supervisor involved in the illumination illumination, in art
illumination, in art, decoration of manuscripts and books with colored, gilded pictures, often referred to as miniatures (see miniature painting); historiated and decorated initials; and ornamental border designs. experiment had been relaxed and friendly; he got to know the operators well and was not too worried about company policies and procedures Policies and Procedures are a set of documents that describe an organization's policies for operation and the procedures necessary to fulfill the policies. They are often initiated because of some external requirement, such as environmental compliance or other governmental . Discipline was secured through enlightened leadership and understanding, and an esprit de corps esprit de corps Graduate education The degree of happiness of the 'campers' in a place grew up within the group. This was in stark contrast to standard practice before the experiment.
When Pennock invited Turner to participate, he also invited Mayo (although it is unknown whether this was as a result of Mayo's achievements at the Philadelphian Spinning Mill, or because of a desire to involve Harvard). Visits in 1929 and 1930 indicated to Mayo "a remarkable change of attitude in the group". Mayo's view was that the Test Room Workers had turned into a social unit, enjoyed all the attention they were getting, and had developed a sense of participation in the project.
In order to understand this further Mayo instituted a series of interviews. These provided the workers with an opportunity to express their views and let off steam. It emerged that they would feel better for discussing a situation even if it did not change. Further exploration into worker complaints revealed that some had little or no basis in fact but were actually symptoms or indicators of personal situations causing distress.
By focusing on a more open, conversational, listening and caring interview approach, Mayo had struck a key which linked the style of supervision and the level of morale to levels of productivity.
Further research--Social Groups
A third stage in the Research programme took place in the Bank Wiring Room with a similar application of incentives to productivity. Here it emerged that:
output was restricted--the group had a standard for output which was respected by individuals in the group;
* the group was indifferent INDIFFERENT. To have no bias nor partiality. 7 Conn. 229. A juror, an arbitrator, and a witness, ought to be indifferent, and when they are not so, they may be challenged. See 9 Conn. 42. to the employer's financial incentive scheme;
* the group developed a code of behaviour of its own based on solidarity in opposition to the management, and
* output was determined by informal social groups rather than by management.
Mayo had read the work of FW Taylor who had already established that social groups were capable of exercising very strong control over the work behaviour of individual members (Taylor had called it 'systematic soldiering'). The interesting evelopment which Mayo noted, however, was that whereas in the first set of experiments productivity went up as the experiments progressed, in the other--the Bank Wiring Room--productivity was restricted.
In The Human Problems of an Industrial Civilisation, Mayo wrote:
"Human collaboration in work, in primitive and developed societies, has always depended for its perpetuation per·pet·u·ate
tr.v. per·pet·u·at·ed, per·pet·u·at·ing, per·pet·u·ates
1. To cause to continue indefinitely; make perpetual.
2. upon the evolution of a non-logical social code which regulates the relations between persons and their attitudes to one another. Insistence upon a merely economic logic of production ... interferes with the development of such a code and consequently gives rise in the group to a sense of human defeat. This ... results in the formation of a social code at a lower level and in opposition to the economic logic. One of its symptoms is 'restriction'."
The question which needed to be asked, therefore, was "What was different between the two groups?" . The answer was found to lie with the attitude of the observer--where the observer encouraged participation and took the workers into his confidence, productivity went up; where the observer merely watched and adopted the trappings of traditional supervisory practice, output was restricted.
For industry to benefit from the experiments at Hawthorne, Mayo first concluded that supervisors needed training in understanding the personal problems of workers, and also in listening and interviewing techniques. He held that the new supervisor should be less aloof, more people-oriented, more concerned, and skilled in handling personal and social situations.
It was only later, after a period of reflection, that Mayo was able to conclude that:
* job satisfaction increased as workers were given more freedom to determine the conditions of their working environment and to set their own standards of output;
* intensified in·ten·si·fy
v. in·ten·si·fied, in·ten·si·fy·ing, in·ten·si·fies
1. To make intense or more intense: interaction and cooperation created a high level of group cohesion cohesion: see adhesion and cohesion.
The tendency of atoms or molecules to coalesce into extended condensed states. This tendency is practically universal. ;
* job satisfaction and output depended more on cooperation and a feeling of worth than on physical working conditions.
In Mayo's view, workers had been unable to find satisfactory outlets for expressing personal problems and dissatisfactions in their work life. The problem, as Mayo perceived it, was that managers thought the answers to industrial problems resided in technical efficiency, when actually the answer was a human and social one.
Mayo's contribution lies in recognising from the Hawthorne experiments that the formality formality, in chemistry: see chemical equilibrium; concentration. of strict rules and procedures spawns informal approaches and groups with their base in human emotions, sentiments, problems and interactions. The manager, therefore, should strive for an equilibrium between the technical organisation and the human one and hence should develop skills in handling human relations human relations npl → relaciones fpl humanas and situations. These include diagnostic skills in understanding human behaviour and interpersonal skills "Interpersonal skills" refers to mental and communicative algorithms applied during social communications and interactions in order to reach certain effects or results. The term "interpersonal skills" is used often in business contexts to refer to the measure of a person's ability in counselling, motivating, leading and communicating.
Mayo has been acclaimed ac·claim
v. ac·claimed, ac·claim·ing, ac·claims
1. To praise enthusiastically and often publicly; applaud. See Synonyms at praise.
2. by his followers followers
see dairy herd. as the Founder of the Human Relations school of management, and he has been criticised by sociologists for not going far enough in his interpretations.
Reading Mayo's conclusions and interpretations cause no surprise--let alone discovery--in the 1990s; his findings are increasingly commonplace among social scientists, trade unionists and managers alike. Perhaps that is a measure of his achievement, because most critics and commentators agree that he was the first, not necessarily to state the case, but to demonstrate, infer and provide evidence from it to shift management thinking in a direction other than the widespread and entrenched en·trench also in·trench
v. en·trenched, en·trench·ing, en·trench·es
1. To provide with a trench, especially for the purpose of fortifying or defending.
2. dominance of Taylor's scientific management.
Hawthorne--thanks to both Mayo and one of his major colleagues and collaborators (F J Roethlisberger) was widely reported and discussed. Roethlisberger said of Mayo that the data were not his, the results not his, but the interpretations were Mayo's. Without those interpretations, the results of Hawthorne would still be collecting dust in the archives.
The experiment also gave rise to the term--'Hawthorne effect'--a situation which arose because people were 'singled' out for special treatment, or a 'special situation' was created where workers could feel free to air their problems.
Mayo's conclusions influenced others who came in turn to be regarded as gurus:
his ideas on the emergence of 'informal' organisations were read by Argyris and others as they developed theories about how organisations learned and developed
the discrediting of the 'rabble hypothesis' theory--based on the assumption that individuals only pursue self-interest--led directly to the work of McGregor (Theory X and Theory Y Theory X and Theory Y are theories of human motivation created and developed by Douglas McGregor at the MIT Sloan School of Management in the 1960s that have been used in human resource management, organizational behavior, and organizational development. ) with its wider implications for leadership and organisation.
The conclusions drawn by Mayo from the Hawthorne studies established the beginnings of the importance of management style as a major contributor to industrial productivity, of interpersonal skills as being as important as monetary incentives or target-setting, and of a more humanistic hu·man·ist
1. A believer in the principles of humanism.
2. One who is concerned with the interests and welfare of humans.
a. A classical scholar.
b. A student of the liberal arts. approach as a means of satisfying the organisation's economic needs and human social skills.
Key works by Mayo
The editions cited here are those held in, and available for loan to members from, the Chartered Management Institute's Information Centre. These may not always be the first edition.
The human problems of an industrial civilization, 2nd edition
Boston, Mass: Harvard University, 1946
The social problems of an industrial civilization, London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1949