EDITORIAL FABLED LOGIC INTERNET TAX COULD KILL CALIFORNIA'S GOOSE THAT LAID GOLDEN EGGS.ONCE upon a time, the golden state of California had it all: a thriving economy, bountiful Bountiful, city (1990 pop. 36,659), Davis co., N central Utah; inc. 1892. It is a residential suburb N of Salt Lake City with some farming and floral nurseries; machinery and motor vehicles are produced. Bountiful was settled by Mormons in 1847. natural resources and rich intellectual capital - not to mention miles of stunning, smoke-free beaches and smog-free mountains. All of this was important to the state's health. But best of all was the state's booming technology industry, particularly its Internet businesses, which brought the state great wealth. Then, one day, some of the lords of California had a foolish idea: ``We will squeeze the Internet businesses and get all the gold now so that we can continue to spend the state's dollars recklessly for our own benefit and the benefit of our friends.'' But the squeeze on the Internet business was too hard, and it snapped the industry's neck, chased it away to other states and nations, as it did the film industry before that. Afterward, there was no more gold for California from that particular source, and it was bad. If this story sounds familiar, that's because it's adapted from Aesop's famous fable about how greed destroys: The Goose That Laid the Golden Egg. It's a story that California legislators would have been wise to consider before supporting the foolish idea of trying to get residents to pay sales tax sales tax, levy on the sale of goods or services, generally calculated as a percentage of the selling price, and sometimes called a purchase tax. It is usually collected in the form of an extra charge by the retailer, who remits the tax to the government. on Internet and out-of-state purchases. For starters, the tax is unenforceable Adj. 1. unenforceable - not enforceable; not capable of being brought about by compulsion; "an unenforceable law"; "unenforceable reforms" enforceable - capable of being enforced . It relies on taxpayers voluntarily reporting purchases on their annual state income tax return, and then shelling out for the sales tax they didn't pay throughout the year. That means keeping track of every book ordered online and every hooded hood·ed adj. 1. Covered with or having a hood. 2. Shaped like a hood, cowl, or similar covering. 3. Zoology a. Having coloration or a crest suggesting a hood. b. sweat shirt purchased while vacationing in Montana. Who has the time or the motivation to do that? Evidently, not many people, as only about 12,000 taxpayers - one of every 1,000 - fessed up to their purchases. The goal of the first year of pseudo-enforcement was to raise $13 million. But with two-thirds of this year's returns processed, only $766,000 were reported. That probably doesn't even cover the money spent on the salaries of those trying to enforce the law, or the time and cost of the legislation and printing new tax forms. Besides, there's no incentive. Californians are already heavily taxed on every dollar earned. Why would we go out of our way to cough up even more? The tax is also constitutionally suspect. The U.S. Constitution says interstate commerce interstate commerce In the U.S., any commercial transaction or traffic that crosses state boundaries or that involves more than one state. Government regulation of interstate commerce is founded on the commerce clause of the Constitution (Article I, section 8), which laws are set by the federal government, not by the state of California. This tax is just a bad idea all around. It's unenforceable, arguably ar·gu·a·ble adj. 1. Open to argument: an arguable question, still unresolved. 2. That can be argued plausibly; defensible in argument: three arguable points of law. unconstitutional and good for nothing more than turning most taxpaying Californians into criminals. If state lawmakers want to keep the state's lucrative Internet goose alive, they should consider making it more attractive to do business online, rather than less so. Otherwise, the current nearsighted near·sight·ed adj. Unable to see distant objects clearly; myopic. approach could eventually strangle Strangle An options strategy where the investor holds a position in both a call and put with different strike prices but with the same maturity and underlying asset. This option strategy is profitable only if there are large movements in the price of the underlying asset. the growing industry to death. |
|
||||||||||||||||

Printer friendly
Cite/link
Email
Feedback
Reader Opinion