Printer Friendly
The Free Library
14,582,462 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

Discovery channels: in the marketplace, truth is always a hot commodity.


The New Republic fires Associate Editor Stephen Glass
For the Scottish football (soccer) player, see Stephen Glass (footballer).


Stephen Glass (born 1972) was an American reporter for The New Republic who was fired for fabricating articles, quotes, sources and events.
 after discovering he invented sources and subjects for more than two dozen stories he wrote for the magazine. The Boston Globe dismisses columnist Patricia Smith after finding out she also created fictional characters to deliver polemical messages in her "reporting" about life on the streets. CNN CNN
 or Cable News Network

Subsidiary company of Turner Broadcasting Systems. It was created by Ted Turner in 1980 to present 24-hour live news broadcasts, using satellites to transmit reports from news bureaus around the world.
 and Time make a dramatic public apology and retraction In the law of Defamation, a formal recanting of the libelous or slanderous material.

Retraction is not a defense to defamation, but under certain circumstances, it is admissible in Mitigation of Damages. Cross-references

Libel and Slander.
 - and fire two producers - after jointly airing and publishing stories alleging that the U.S. military used nerve gas nerve gas, any of several poison gases intended for military use, e.g., tabun, sarin, soman, and VX. Nerve gases were first developed by Germany during World War II but were not used at that time.  on American deserters in Vietnam.

Prestige press outlets have taken some serious body blows over the past few months. And media critics have quickly fingered the cause of these missteps: capitalism - or more precisely, the lust to capture readers and viewers in a hypercompetitive marketplace.

In the Los Angeles Times Los Angeles Times

Morning daily newspaper. Established in 1881, it was purchased and incorporated in 1884 by Harrison Gray Otis (1837–1917) under The Times-Mirror Co. (the hyphen was later dropped from the name).
, former CBS (Cell Broadcast Service) See cell broadcast.  and NBC NBC
 in full National Broadcasting Co.

Major U.S. commercial broadcasting company. It was formed in 1926 by RCA Corp., General Electric Co. (GE), and Westinghouse and was the first U.S. company to operate a broadcast network.
 reporter Marvin Kalb, now a professor at Harvard's Kennedy School of Government, blames "profit-centered, business-oriented news" and the "24-hour-a-day news cycle with nonstop demands for 'profitable news.' "In Intellectualcapital.com, media critic Eric Alterman faults the "culture of celebrity worship" and "the notion that the actual information in any given story is less important than the entertainment package it helps create." Wired's Jon Katz complains that "the business of journalism has become dominated by large conglomerates whose only interest is profits, who have no ideology other than mass marketing."

Joseph Pulitzer and William Randolph Hearst must be cackling cack·le  
v. cack·led, cack·ling, cack·les

v.intr.
1. To make the shrill cry characteristic of a hen after laying an egg.

2. To laugh or talk in a shrill manner.

v.tr.
 from their graves. A century ago, the two icons of contemporary prestige journalism drove the nation into a frenzy - and a war with Spain - with their sensationally exaggerated accounts of Spanish oppression in Cuba. Their goal was to sell newspapers with what became known as yellow journalism. From the colonial pamphleteers who fomented revolution against the British to the frontier editors who would publish any slander to sell papers (as recounted in Mark Twain's hilarious early story "Journalism in Tennessee"), "newspapermen" and broadcasters have always sought bigger audiences and fatter profits by offering information and entertainment.

The current controversies are different in one important way: The competitive processes of today's marketplace led to the rapid exposure and resolution of these journalistic shenanigans shenanigans
Noun, pl

Informal

1. mischief or nonsense

2. trickery or deception [origin unknown]
. Rather than denigrate den·i·grate  
tr.v. den·i·grat·ed, den·i·grat·ing, den·i·grates
1. To attack the character or reputation of; speak ill of; defame.

2.
 capitalism and the search for profits, media critics should praise market processes for providing a public service. The desire to discover the truth, and to place reputation ahead of short-term notoriety, exposed all three frauds.

Glass's follies were made public by an editor for the online publication Forbes Digital Tool. Adam Penenberg covers technology companies, and when he read a story Glass wrote about young computer hackers working for high-tech firms, something seemed fishy fish·y  
adj. fish·i·er, fish·i·est
1. Resembling or suggestive of fish, as in taste or odor.

2. Cold or expressionless: a fishy stare.

3.
. Penenberg discovered that a company described in the article didn't exist - and neither did the hackers. Penenberg then approached TNR TNR The New Republic
TNR Trap-Neuter-Return (controlling feral cats)
TNR Times New Roman (font)
TNR Antananarivo, Madagascar - Ivato (Airport Code)
TNR Tonic Neck Reflex
 Editor Charles Lane with this information, and after conducting his own investigation, Lane gave Glass the heave-ho.

Patricia Smith's fabrications were discovered internally, but the Globe wasted little time getting rid of her in a very public way before she could further damage the paper's credibility - and its bottom line. And when outraged veteran groups and skeptical military analysts flooded CNN and Time with questions about their story on nerve gas attacks in Vietnam, CNN - a relative newcomer in the media business - feared that its reputation as a source of news might be irreparably damaged. It hired respected First Amendment lawyer Floyd Abrams to check out the criticisms. Abrams found the story shabbily reported and concluded it should never have been aired.

CNN's Ted Turner announced the creation of an ombusdman-like office that will vet future investigative stories before the network airs them. But the controversy continues, primarily because CNN didn't fire correspondent Peter Arnett, and media watchdogs are still hounding CNN.

Not so long ago, most people got pretty much all their news from the big three networks and their local daily newspaper. It was a great system for those fortunate enough to land the few available jobs. And many who work in today's prestige media prefer the old regime. Now, laments Kalb, NBC and its cable outlets MSNBC MSNBC Microsoft/National Broadcasting Company  and CNBC CNBC Center for the Neural Basis of Cognition (artificial intelligence)
CNBC Consumer News and Business Channel
CNBC Congress of National Black Churches, Inc.
 offer 27 hours of national news every day; most network affiliates add two to three additional hours of local news.

And that's just one media group: C-Span, CNN, Fox, PBS PBS
 in full Public Broadcasting Service

Private, nonprofit U.S. corporation of public television stations. PBS provides its member stations, which are supported by public funds and private contributions rather than by commercials, with educational, cultural,
, NPR NPR

In currencies, this is the abbreviation for the Nepal Rupee.

Notes:
The currency market, also known as the Foreign Exchange market, is the largest financial market in the world, with a daily average volume of over US $1 trillion.
, all-news radio channels, radio talk shows, and Web pages that link to wire services offer plenty more viewing and listening options. These additional outlets serve as feedback mechanisms, constantly vying to offer more information, a different take on a story, a new angle that can clarify a complicated issue. There are more opportunities for enterprising journalists to build reputations for themselves and their publishers.

A 24-hour market now serves news junkies, and it offers a new set of challenges for those who provide information to the public. There's more time to fill, which places a premium on providing material worth watching. Channel- (and Web-) surfing audiences are fickle; they can easily go elsewhere if they feel they're not being informed or entertained.

But these peripatetic viewers are also less likely to accept what they see without question, especially when hundreds of alternatives bid for their time and attention. And there's actually more pressure on reporters and editors to be careful in verifying stories before airing or publishing them: If a media outlet gets something wrong, there are countless competitors eager to point out mistakes before their news-hungry audiences.

If Kalb, Alterman, and Katz were truly public-spirited, they would celebrate the current competitive atmosphere: The "nonstop demand for profitable news" encourages correction of error and dissemination of truth. The quest to maintain credibility leads media outlets to investigate their own work. In the marketplace, reputation is one major factor that separates prestigious institutions from fly-by-night operators and other fast-buck artists. Competitive forces have broken up the near-monopoly powers the big media providers once enjoyed. As with the end of any monopoly, consumers - in this case, news lovers - are the ultimate victors.
COPYRIGHT 1998 Reason Foundation
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1998, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Henderson, Rick
Publication:Reason
Date:Oct 1, 1998
Words:986
Previous Article:The claims of nature: the "can gays change" debate is muddling the main issues.
Next Article:Does America hate its HMOs? (health maintenance organizations)(interview with American Enterprise Institute Fellow Karlyn...
Topics:



Related Articles
"How sick is the distribution channel?" (software industry reseller channel)
Glamorous Jewesses. (on Barbra Streisand and the signification of Jewesses in Hollywood motion pictures)
The plight of the Friends of Bill.(Bill Clinton apologists; Republicans who fear running against President Al Gore in 2000)(On The...
Letters.(Brief Article)
NEWS & NOTES : NBC CORNERS THE `TRUTH' AS IT ASSEMBLES PROGRAMMING.(L.A. LIFE)
Farm Journal Media's "AgDay" and "WeekEnd MarketPlace" join the early-morning lineup of the All News Channel, reaching more than 10 million DIRECTV...
U.S. cable nets keep strong overseas grip. (Int'l TV Channels).
A new job search.(Stateline)(Brief Article)
Hot Sand and Horny Toads.( Hot Sand and Horny Toads: Growing Up in California in the 1940s)(Brief article)(Book review)
American Hot Rod.(Brief article)(Book review)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles