Printer Friendly

Diagnosing sprinkler system problems

New ground has been broken in the diagnosis of sprinkler system problems, but this remains an area in need of attention. For the first time, the 2008 edition of NFPA NFPA National Fire Protection Association
NFPA National Food Processors Association
NFPA National Fluid Power Association
NFPA National Federation of Paralegal Associations (Edmonds, WA) 
 25, Inspection, Testing and Maintenance of Water-Based Pire Protection Systems, has introduced the concept of addressing system deficiencies not explained by normal wear and tear, but it has not yet fully addressed the need for periodic hazard evaluation.

NFPA 25 is used for purposes of system inspection, testing, and maintenance, defined as three separate functions:

"3.3.18 Inspection. A visual examination of a system or portion thereof to verify that it appears to be in operating condition and is free of physical damage."

"3.3.34 Testing. A procedure used to determine the status of a system as intended by conducting periodic physical checks on water-based fire protection systems such as waterflow tests, fire pump tests, alarm tests and trip tests of dry pipe, deluge Deluge (dĕl`yj), in the Bible, the overwhelming flood that covered the earth and destroyed every living thing except the family of Noah and the creatures in his ark. , or preaction valves. These tests follow up on the original acceptance test at intervals coming or happening with intervals between; now and then.

See also: Interval
 specified in the appropriate chapter of this standard."

"3.3.20 Maintenance. In waterbased fire protection systems, work performed to keep equipment operable operable /op·er·a·ble/ (op´er-ah-b'l) subject to being operated upon with a reasonable degree of safety; appropriate for surgical removal.

 or to make repairs."

Section 4.1.4 addresses corrections and repairs:

"4.1.4 Corrections and Repairs. The property owner or occupant shall promptly correct or repair deficiencies, damaged parts or impairments found while performing the inspection, test and maintenance requirements of this standard."

" Corrections and repairs shall be performed by qualified maintenance personnel or a qualified contractor."

A new annex section goes beyond the subject of repairs into the area of diagnosing potential problems:

"A. System deficiencies not explained by normal wear and tear, such as hydraulic shock, can often be indicators of system problems and should be investigated by a qualified person or engineer. Failure to address these issues could lead to catastrophic failure A catastrophic failure is a sudden and total failure of some system from which recovery is impossible. The affected system not only experiences destruction beyond any reasonable possibility of repair, but also frequently causes injury, death, or significant damage to other, often ."

The annex goes on to list symptoms of deficiencies not explained by normal wear and tear, including damaged pressure gauges pressure gauge

Instrument for measuring the condition of a fluid (liquid or gas) that is specified by the force the fluid would apply, when at rest, to a unit area, such as pounds per square inch (psi) or pascals (Pa).
, hangers hangers

used for hanging x-ray films to dry. There is a clip type, with a clip at each corner, and a channel type in which the film sits in channels in the sides of the frame.
, valves, wall penetrations, unexplained leakage, and unusual pump vibration or noises.

This section of the standard makes an important distinction: In the area of investigation, it calls for "a qualified person or engineer," which is different from "qualified maintenance personnel or a qualified contractor." In effect, the diagnosis of system deficiencies may require knowledge and experience beyond that of a competent sprinkler system inspector, involving product testing, statics statics, branch of mechanics concerned with the maintenance of equilibrium in bodies by the interaction of forces upon them (see force). It incorporates the study of the center of gravity (see center of mass) and the moment of inertia.  and dynamics, strength of materials strength of materials, measurement in engineering of the capacity of metal, wood, concrete, and other materials to withstand stress and strain. Stress is the internal force exerted by one part of an elastic body upon the adjoining part, and strain is the deformation , hydraulics hydraulics, branch of engineering concerned mainly with moving liquids. The term is applied commonly to the study of the mechanical properties of water, other liquids, and even gases when the effects of compressibility are small. , and interaction with other building systems.

The issue is not unlike the common confusion between a system inspection and a system hazard evaluation. The purpose of a system inspection, consistent with the above definition, is to ensure that the system equipment is in proper operating order. The inspection does not address design or installation issues that would ultimately predict the ability of the system to address adequately the fire hazard fire hazard fire n that's a fire hazard → das ist feuergefährlich

fire hazard n that's a fire hazard → comporta rischi in caso d'incendio 
 of the occupancy.

Consider, for example, the potential for obstructions to sprinklers. Section only requires that the inspector check for minimum clearance below sprinklers to stock and furnishings, with the annex noting that other obstruction rules "are impractical to enforce under this standard." NFPA 25 recognizes that other, specific obstruction rules, such as those for early suppression fast-response (ESFR ESFR Early Suppression Fast Response
ESFR East Side (mountain biking website) 
) sprinklers, have changed several times in the various editions of the installation standards. How would an inspector be expected to know all elements of the specific basis of design for a system?

Although NFPA 25 contains regular schedules for the inspection, testing, and maintenance of various system components, it contains no regular interval or trigger for a hazard evaluation comparing the potential fire severity to the system's capability. Where changes to the occupancy, fire hazard, water supply, storage commodity, storage arrangement, building modification, or some other condition that affects system installation criteria take place, the owner is obligated ob·li·gate  
tr.v. ob·li·gat·ed, ob·li·gat·ing, ob·li·gates
1. To bind, compel, or constrain by a social, legal, or moral tie. See Synonyms at force.

2. To cause to be grateful or indebted; oblige.
 under section 4.1.6 to take appropriate steps to evaluate system adequacy "such as contacting a qualified contractor, consultant or engineer...."

Unfortunately, subtle or gradual changes in the fire hazard of building contents or interior arrangements often take place undetected. As with unexplained system deficiencies, the type of person best able to evaluate system capability is rarely the same type of person who conducts system inspections, since the hazard evaluation requires a greater knowledge of applicable NFPA standards and other aspects of system design.

As the NFPA 25 Technical Committee prepares the next edition, it will receive a proposal that a hazard evaluation form be included parallel to the sample system inspection forms found in past editions. Even without a specific trigger or time interval, such a form would clarify the types of issues not addressed in a typical system inspection.
Copyright 2008 NFPA Journal
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright (c) Mochila, Inc.

 Reader Opinion




Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Russell P Fleming
Publication:NFPA Journal
Date:Sep 1, 2008
Previous Article:Smoke Detection Technology
Next Article:Fire Extension

Related Articles
Fires: minimizing the risks and damage.
FM Global Alerts Insureds To Problems With Sprinklers.
State hears PAV sprinkler appeal; Club resisting new regulations.

Terms of use | Copyright © 2014 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters