Printer Friendly
The Free Library
14,716,216 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

Devolution.


DINOSAURS, it seems, have changed more in the past twenty years than in the previous 200 million. First of all they are not, as you may have heard, extinct. Through a neat act of clerical redefinition, birds, once thought to be descended from dinosaurs, have now become dinosaurs. Then the reptile formerly known as Brontosaurus Brontosaurus: see Apatosaurus. , or Thundering Lizard, has been renamed Apatosaurus Apatosaurus (ăp'ətəsôr`əs, ā'păt'ə–), [Gr.,=deceptive lizard], quadruped saurischian dinosaur, estimated to be from 70 to 90 ft (21 to 27 m) in length and to weigh up to 30 tons (27 metric tons). , that is, Deceiving Lizard, a point upon which paleontologists insist with great solemnity, concealing the fact that the change is mostly one of labeling. Everything from the size to the speed and posture of these big chaps has been called into question, and the truculent truc·u·lent  
adj.
1. Disposed to fight; pugnacious.

2. Expressing bitter opposition; scathing: a truculent speech against the new government.

3.
 certitude cer·ti·tude  
n.
1. The state of being certain; complete assurance; confidence.

2. Sureness of occurrence or result; inevitability.

3.
 of yore has yielded to pandemic doubt.

The center of such revisionism is the American Museum of Natural History American Museum of Natural History, incorporated in New York City in 1869 to promote the study of natural science and related subjects. Buildings on its present site were opened in 1877. , which, amid much fanfare, has just reopened its Hall of Dinosaurs after many years of renovation. Given the $12 million that went into the restoration, one almost feels that the curators insisted on these changes largely in order to have something to show for the vast expense of time and money. The new section comprises two main halls, one for the Saurischians and the other for the Ornithischians, arranged according to the principles of cladistics cladistics (klədĭs`tĭks) or phylogenetic systematics (fī'lōjənĕt`ĭk) . This classification stresses shared characteristics such as grasping hands or backward-pointing pubis pubis /pu·bis/ (pu´bis) [L.] pubic bone.

pu·bis
n. pl. pu·bes
1. See pubic bone.

2. The hair of the pubic region just above the external genitals.
 bone, rather than chronology as in the past.

Unfortunately, it will be very difficult for anyone to see the present exhibition with real pleasure. The museum demonstrates the same questionable judgment that I remarked on in these pages several months ago apropos of the Smithsonian's new Museum of the American Indian: the spaces are cramped labyrinths abounding in verbiage, written and recorded, which thoroughly swamps the objects on display. There are more ramps and slopes and alcoves in the cluttered rooms than you will find on a miniature golf course.

But the real problem here is children. With all the fervor of Muslims at Ramadan pressing upon the altar of the Kaaba, they come by the busloads from their schools in the winter and their camps in the summer to look at the dinosaurs and the elephants and the big blue whale. And the museum is ready for them. Cutesy cute·sy  
adj. cute·si·er, cute·si·est Informal
Deliberately or affectedly cute; precious: a cutesy boutique for children's fashions.
 dinosaur footprints lead from everywhere in the museum to the new fourth-floor displays. Once you get there, you find yourself at the Dinostore, which purveys all the lemon- and grape-colored stuffed dinosaurs you will ever really need, not to mention socks, baseball caps, ties (for Dad), pencil sharpeners, games, and coloring books. Once you reach the actual display, you will find video games throughout posing as information centers -- imparting the message that science is fun.

Granted, the American Museum of Natural History has not yet sunk to the depths of the Franklin Institute in Philadelphia, which has become a cross between a theme park and a day-care center. But it is on its way. This is evidenced in the newly opened Hall of Human Life, whose candy-colored array of flashing lights has the appearance of a pinball machine at tilt, as well as a recent exhibit on spiders, which, with its big mockups of spiders and its goofy captions, could not have held the attention of anyone over 8 years old.

It was not always so. Once upon a time the American Museum of Natural History, like London's Natural History Museum, the Smithsonian, and the Franklin Institute, was an augustly Victorian structure whose wares were displayed in glass cases with very few distractions. Now this is no longer possible, the tendency in museology mu·se·ol·o·gy  
n.
The discipline of museum design, organization, and management.



muse·o·log
 being to show ever fewer objects with ever more commentary.

One had expected more from this renovation, especially since the Hall of Mammal Evolution, which was completed a year ago, was so sober and successful and, despite its glinty glint·y  
adj. glint·i·er, glint·i·est
1. Sparkling; glittery.

2. Cheap and flashy.
 postmodernity, perfectly matched to the Victorian architecture. The transformation of the corner turret into a silo of living light opening onto Central Park remains perhaps the most brilliant architectural coup de the`tre in many years. Unfortunately there is nothing of the sort about the new exhibitions, which have created an entangled en·tan·gle  
tr.v. en·tan·gled, en·tan·gling, en·tan·gles
1. To twist together or entwine into a confusing mass; snarl.

2. To complicate; confuse.

3. To involve in or as if in a tangle.
 chaos where formerly there was order.

On seeing them, one cannot help longing for what has been lost, for the museum of Teddy Roosevelt and Holden Caulfield, rather than the faintly vulgar spectacle that is gradually taking its place. As the American Museum of Natural History, now celebrating its 125th anniversary, prepares a massive expansion in the next millennium, it must take care to preserve, and where necessary to recreate, that older sobriety. It should have more temporary exhibitions, as art museums do, and it should hold them to as high a standard as does the Metropolitan Museum. Above all, it must resist the creeping contagion of infantilism infantilism /in·fan·ti·lism/ (in´fan-til-izm) (in-fan´til-izm) persistence of childhood characters into adult life, marked by mental retardation, underdevelopment of sex organs, and often dwarfism.  that has turned the Franklin Institute, once a venerable temple of science, into a pitiable pit·i·a·ble  
adj.
1. Arousing or deserving of pity or compassion; lamentable.

2. Arousing disdainful pity. See Synonyms at pathetic.



pit
, paltry waste of time.
COPYRIGHT 1995 National Review, Inc.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1995, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:American Museum of Natural History's Hall of Dinosaurs, New York, New York
Author:Gardner, James
Publication:National Review
Date:Sep 11, 1995
Words:805
Previous Article:The Net.
Next Article:Nightmare time. (Yugoslav civil war and international isolationism)(Column)
Topics:



Related Articles
Mistakes in museum mountings. (paleontology)
New dinosaur embryo rewrites history. (Flaming Cliffs dinosaurs found in 1923 belonged to Oviraptoridae family rather than Protoceratops family as...
Nesting dinosaur discovered in Mongolia. (fossil Oviraptor found in Gobi Desert indicates that dinosaurs may brooded like modern birds)(Science News...
Hints of a downy dinosaur in China.
Psst ... wanna buy a T. rex? Paleontologists fret about dinosaur sales.(Cover Story)
Feathered dinosaurs found in China. (Science News of the week)(Brief Article)
Getting under a dinosaur's skin.(Brief Article)
Feathery find: scientists unearth evidence that some dinosaurs sported feathers.(EARTH: FOSSILS)
Dinosaur neck size reaches new extreme.(PALEONTOLOGY)(Brief article)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles