Printer Friendly
The Free Library
14,709,470 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

Defense counsel: Waxman is Johnnie Cochran with a congressional staff and a political agenda.


IN August, staff from Rep. Dan Burton's House Government Reform and Oversight Committee informally interviewed David Wang, a 1996 donor to the Democratic National Committee. Wang voluntarily confessed that he wrote two $5,000 checks to the DNC DNC Democratic National Committee
DNC Democratic National Convention
DNC Do Not Call
DNC Delaware North Companies
DNC Domain Name Commissioner
DNC Direct Numerical Control
DNC Do Not Change
DNC Does Not Compute
DNC Digital Nautical Chart
 at the behest of John Huang A major figure in the 1996 United States campaign finance controversy, John Huang (Chinese: 黄建南) worked for Lippo Bank in California, Worthen Bank in Arkansas, and as deputy assistant secretary for international economic affairs in U.S.  and was reimbursed in cash the same day. But when Burton's staff decided to depose To make a deposition; to give evidence in the shape of a deposition; to make statements that are written down and sworn to; to give testimony that is reduced to writing by a duly qualified officer and sworn to by the deponent.  Wang -- i.e., to question him under oath in preparation for public testimony -- the committee's ranking minority member, Henry Waxman Henry Arnold Waxman (born September 12, 1939 in Los Angeles, California) is an American politician. He has represented California's At-large congressional district (map) in the U.S. House of Representatives since 1975.  (D., Calif.), balked balk  
v. balked, balk·ing, balks

v.intr.
1. To stop short and refuse to go on: The horse balked at the jump.

2.
. "There is no need to impose further burdens on [Wang]," Waxman wrote to Burton. In addition, Waxman publicly decried the fact that Wang had been interviewed without a lawyer present.

Since informal sessions like the Wang interview -- conducted not by Burton's GOP staff, but by non-partisan detailees from the Treasury Department -- are standard practice in any investigation, Waxman seemed extraordinary solicitous so·lic·i·tous  
adj.
1.
a. Anxious or concerned: a solicitous parent.

b. Expressing care or concern: made solicitous inquiries about our family.
 for Wang. But his attitude suddenly changed when Wang showed up to testify in October. Waxman sprang a sheaf of documents on him, including a letter he had gotten the night before from John Huang's lawyer asserting that Huang couldn't have been present at a meeting alleged by Wang. Waxman said Wang's testimony "appears to be a fix," and hammered him for alleged "immigration immigration, entrance of a person (an alien) into a new country for the purpose of establishing permanent residence. Motives for immigration, like those for migration generally, are often economic, although religious or political factors may be very important.  and tax fraud."

Waxman didn't explain what incentive Wang would have had to fabricate the Huang meeting -- or why DNC check-tracking records credit his donation to John Huang. But to try to clinch the case against David Wang, Waxman's staff called his father, James Wang (who was supposedly at the Huang - Wang meeting). The staff talked to James Wang, who barely knows English, without an attorney present and tried to get him to contradict his son, sending him a statement to sign attesting that his son was mistaken about the Huang meeting. When James Wang wouldn't sign it, Waxman lawyers signed their own statement alleging that he told them his son was wrong -- even though he denies saying any such thing.

The Waxman strategy seemed clear: 1) do anything to keep Wang from telling his story publicly, even if it means defending him more vigorously than his own attorney (who had no problem with the committee's initial interview with his client), 2) then bludgeon him when he shows up as a witness, even if it means adopting a tactic you have just been denouncing (talking to Noun 1. talking to - a lengthy rebuke; "a good lecture was my father's idea of discipline"; "the teacher gave him a talking to"
lecture, speech

rebuke, reprehension, reprimand, reproof, reproval - an act or expression of criticism and censure; "he had to
 a witness without an attorney). Henry Waxman is running a scandal defense at times more zealous than the White House; he's Johnnie Cochran Johnnie L. Cochran, Jr.[1] (October 2, 1937 – March 29, 2005) was an African American lawyer best known for his role in the legal defense during the O. J. Simpson murder case.  with a congressional staff and a political agenda. "What he has," says one GOP member of the Burton Committee, "is an unashamed un·a·shamed  
adj.
Feeling or showing no remorse, shame, or embarrassment:



una·sham
 intent to kill an honest investigation, to wreak havoc. It's worse than [Sen. John] Glenn -- by a lot."

Along with that intent, Waxman brings a set of political skills honed to razor sharpness during his days in the majority. Adept at playing the media, well staffed, and tenacious, Waxman is universally considered the model for effective congressional politics. And he is perhaps the congressional Democrat least fazed faze  
tr.v. fazed, faz·ing, faz·es
To disrupt the composure of; disconcert. See Synonyms at embarrass.



[Middle English fesen, to drive away, frighten
 by the GOP take-over of the House. Waxman lost his chairmanship of the Health and Environment Subcommittee of the Commerce Committee but became ranking minority member on the Burton Committee -- where he actually gained staff positions. In a sense, Waxman is the last congressional liberal left standing -- for the moment, smack in the way of a credible investigation of Clinton fundraising.

Waxman represents a Hollywood district
For other uses, see Hollywood (disambiguation)


The Hollywood District (originally Hollyrood, after the Scottish Holyrood) is a neighborhood of NE Portland, Oregon renamed for its historic 1920s era Hollywood Theatre.
 that is one of the most affluent and liberal areas in the nation. Waxman is short and pudgy, an unglamorous representative for his glitzy glitz   Informal
n.
Ostentatious showiness; flashiness: "a garish barrage of show-biz glitz" Peter G. Davis.

tr.v.
 constituents, but a perfect fit politically. He won election in 1974 and, together with fellow Rep. Howard Berman Howard Lawrence "Howie" Berman (born April 15 1941) has been a Democratic member of the United States House of Representatives since 1983, representing the 28th District of California (map). , forged a well-funded political machine that would have a powerful influence on California politics for two decades. In Washington, Waxman was the first to contribute heavily to fellow committee members in a campaign to win a chairmanship --nosing out a more senior Democrat for his subcommittee chairmanship as a result.

From his subcommittee, Waxman famously increased the scope of the Medicaid program in the dead of night, swelling the federal deficit almost single-handedly. The way he prevailed on this and other issues -- clean-air regulations, tobacco -- is a study in the effective use of power. "He will use everything at his disposal to kill you," says one Commerce staffer. His success was partly a matter, as one observer puts it, of "personal stamina"; he and his staff were always willing to be last to leave meetings, which in Washington is often the key to victory. And when he couldn't win immediately, he'd wait. "It's the Ho Chi Minh Ho Chi Minh (hô chē mĭn), 1890–1969, Vietnamese nationalist leader, president of North Vietnam (1954–69), and one of the most influential political leaders of the 20th cent. His given name was Nguyen That Thanh.  approach," says a Commerce staffer. "If [victory's] not in the first year, it's in the fifth."

WAXMAN matches his tenacity with an unfailing eye for media politics. "He's a master," says a former Commerce staffer, "at unveiling an issue and giving it national audience." Take tobacco. Waxman had no scruples about trotting out purloined documents to bolster his case. And when he held hearings on the issue in 1994, nothing was allowed to step on the story. Members typically defer to fellow members who want to testify at their hearings. Not Waxman --he shut out pro-tobacco then-Rep. Charlie Rose (D., N.C.). "He had the guts to tell this guy," says a GOP staffer, "'Hey, Charlie --sorry.' Guess whose story got in the papers the next day?"

In all this, Waxman is heavily dependent on staff, but that is not a weakness, because his staff is so sharp and committed. His chief of staff, Phil Schiliro, is a seasoned operative who ran for Congress twice himself. When Waxman lost his sub-committee chairmanship, his staff did not migrate to lobbying jobs, but to the federal bureaucracy and liberal advocacy groups. Waxman graduates include: Bill Corr, Donna Shalala's chief of staff at Health and Human Services Noun 1. Health and Human Services - the United States federal department that administers all federal programs dealing with health and welfare; created in 1979
Department of Health and Human Services, HHS
; William Schultz, deputy commissioner for policy at the Food and Drug Administration; Tim Westmoreland, counsel for the Koop - Kessler tobacco commission; and Greg Wetstone, legislative director at the Natural Resources Defense Council The Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) is a New York City-based, non-profit non-partisan international environmental advocacy group, with offices in Washington, D.C., San Francisco, Los Angeles, Chicago, and Beijing. Founded in 1970, NRDC today has 1. . "These are twenty-year [Waxman] veterans," says a GOP aide, "who are still doing Henry's bidding."

In some cases, Waxman uses the bureaucracy as a kind of way station for his aides. Phil Barnett worked for Waxman on clean-air issues, then went to the Food and Drug Administration when Waxman lost his chairmanship. After Waxman regained staff slots as ranking minority member, Barnett rejoined him as chief counsel. Schiliro and Barnett are the most aggressive staffers on Waxman's scandal team. Waxman seems to have concluded that a damaged White House can't help Democrats regain the House -- and himself possibly become chairman of the full Commerce Committee with its enormous resources. Hence his zeal in defending the White House.

His strategy can be called massive resistance. First, he complains about everything. Waxman has a larger percentage of the staff -- 25 per cent -- of the Government Reform and Oversight Committee than any other ranking minority member ever, but he incessantly carps about his lack of resources. Second, he resists all lines of inquiry. According to according to
prep.
1. As stated or indicated by; on the authority of: according to historians.

2. In keeping with: according to instructions.

3.
 committee sources, Charles Ruff
Chuck Ruff redirects here. For the rock drummer, see Chuck Ruff (musician).


Charles F.C. "Chuck" Ruff (1939-2000) was a prominent American lawyer based in Washington, D.C.
 and other White House lawyers have been more open to Burton inquiries regarding the coffee tapes and Webster Hubbell Webster Lee Hubbell (born 1949), known as Webster L. Hubbell and Webb Hubbell, was an Arkansas lawyer and politician. He was a lawyer in Pulaski County before serving as Mayor of Little Rock from 1979 until he resigned in 1981.  than Waxman's staff has. Third, he throws every possible obstacle in the way of getting witnesses. For a time, he was insisting that Burton staff read a disclaimer more detailed than the Miranda warning Miranda warning( Miranda rule, Miranda rights) n. the requirement set by the U. S. Supreme Court in Miranda v. Alabama (1966) that prior to the time of arrest and any interrogation of a person suspected of a crime, he/she must be told that he/she has: "the right to  to anyone interviewed by the committee. Fourth, he plays constantly to the media. In June, Burton's staff were engaged in confidential negotiations with Waxman over deposition authority. The day after Burton produced a draft proposal, it was leaked to Minority Leader Dick Gephardt's office and denounced in the press.

Waxman's behavior on the committee amounts to a litany of bad faith:

-- In June, according to a committee source, when Burton's staff planned a trip to Florida to interview a witness, Waxman's chief investigative counsel, Ken Ballen, wanted to be part of it. So a majority staff member, minority staff member, and detailee flew to Florida. Shortly thereafter Waxman wrote a letter blasting the trip as unnecessarily expensive -- precisely because so many staffers had been included.

-- In July, the attorney for Democratic fundraisers Gene and Nora Lum n. 1. A chimney.
2. A ventilating chimney over the shaft of a mine.
3. A woody valley; also, a deep pool.
 gave Burton and Waxman staff a hypothetical proffer To offer or tender, as, the production of a document and offer of the same in evidence.


proffer v. to offer evidence in a trial.
 -- a sketch of testimony that would be given in exchange for a grant of immunity -- on his clients' behalf. The attorney asked that it be kept confidential, and everyone agreed. But, according to a committee source, as soon as committee staff met with Justice Department lawyers, a Waxman lawyer appeared to try to disclose details --apparently in an effort to persuade Justice to object to a grant of immunity.

-- On July 9, according to a committee source, Burton staff told Ken Ballen that the committee would refrain from taking depositions from DNC officials Richard Sullivan For the author and academic, see Richard T. Sullivan.

Richard Joseph Sullivan (born 1964) is a judge of the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York. Nominated by President George W.
, Don Fowler, and two others because the Senate had already deposed them. Nonetheless, Waxman fired off a letter to Burton the next day -- all Waxman correspondence is for media consumption -- indicating his "strong opposition" to plans to depose Sullivan and Co.

In the fundraising investigations, the factor that the White House and DNC have benefited from most is the lack of cooperation of witnesses; so Waxman has set out to maximize it. The rough public handling of David Wang is a signal to others that going public can be painful. In the deposition of Manlin Foung -- used by her brother Charlie Trie as a conduit for illegal contributions -- Ken Ballen clearly tries to dissuade her from testifying. He tells her that Democrats "do not feel this deposition today is necessary." He pointedly warns her that Burton thinks her brother is part of a criminal conspiracy. Finally, he paints a frightening picture of a congressional hearing: "there will be a large room with many congressmen, over 44 congressmen sitting there. You will be at a table in front of them. There may be television cameras. There may be news reporters." And, he might have added, if you say something too damaging to the White House, Henry Waxman may do just about anything to discredit you.
COPYRIGHT 1997 National Review, Inc.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1997, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:House Government Reform and Oversight Committee member Rep Henry Waxman
Author:Lowry, Rich
Publication:National Review
Date:Nov 10, 1997
Words:1688
Previous Article:Right data.(wage data)(Column)(Brief Article)
Next Article:Power of attorney.(political attorney Bob Bauer)(Brief Article)
Topics:



Related Articles
The democrats' 'little big man'. (Henry Waxman)
A House divided. (futility of investigations by congressional committees)
The Speaker.(Speak of the House-elect Bob Livingston)
Dan Burton, Right Again - The congressman who does the job.(Burton leads investigation into questionable pardons granted by Pres Clinton)
WAXMAN TO TAKE OVER REFORM COMMITTEE.(News)
WAXMAN'S CLOUT COULD CHALLENGE BUSH.(News)
Election 2006: bigger changes at state level.(VIEW ON washington)
Contractors should get ready for scrutiny.(ETHICS CORNER)
WILSON TESTIFIES, BUT WAXMAN TAKES THE SPOTLIGHT.(News)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles