Printer Friendly
The Free Library
14,380,416 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

Debate smolders over cause of ice ages.


During the last 2 million years, Earth has endured more than 20 Ice ages of various lengths. The standard explanation for these periodic freezes involves rhythmic variations in the planet's orbit and tilt, but this theory has come under fire in recent years from researchers studying a Nevada cave called Devils Hole (SN: 10/10/92, p. 228). Now, a team of scientists contends that their findings have exorcised the specter of Devils Hole by confirming the orbital theory.

The debate centers on the timing of the last interglacial in·ter·gla·cial  
adj.
Occurring between glacial epochs.

n.
A comparatively short period of warmth during an overall period of glaciation.
 period, the short warm spell Warm Spell (1988-1994) was an American Eclipse Award winning thoroughbred racehorse, a Kentucky-bred son of Northern Baby, owned and trained by John K. Griggs and bred by Robert Kluener. He was ridden primarily by the owner/trainer's son, Kirk Griggs.  sandwiched between the last ice age and the next-to-last one. Dating of calcium carbonate calcium carbonate, CaCO3, white chemical compound that is the most common nonsiliceous mineral. It occurs in two crystal forms: calcite, which is hexagonal, and aragonite, which is rhombohedral.  layers in Devils Hole suggests that the last interglacial started more than 150,000 years ago--a time that doesn't fit the orbital hypothesis. Summer sunlight then was not strong enough to melt the giant ice caps and end the glacial epoch.

R. Lawrence Edwards of the University of Minnesota (body, education) University of Minnesota - The home of Gopher.

http://umn.edu/.

Address: Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA.
 in Minneapolis and his colleagues attacked the problem with a dramatically improved version of an old dating technique that relies on the radioactive decay radioactive decay
n.
1. Spontaneous disintegration of a radionuclide accompanied by the emission of ionizing radiation in the form of alpha or beta particles or gamma rays.

2. An instance of such disintegration.
 of uranium-235 to protactinium protactinium (prō'tăktĭn`ēəm), radioactive chemical element; symbol Pa; at. no. 91; at. wt. 231.0359; m.p. greater than 1,600°C;; b.p. 4,026°C;; sp. gr. 15.37 (calculated); valence +4, +5. 231. They rechecked the ages of previously dated coral from Barbados that grew during the last interglacial, when Earth was warm and sea levels were higher than they are today.

The new coral dates confirm that sea levels were high 126,000 to 121,000 years ago, when summer sunlight grew most intense in the far northern latitudes, the scientists report in the May 2 Science. These results, they argue, back up the orbital explanation of the ice ages.

That conclusion gets a cold reception from Isaac J. Winograd, a researcher at the U.S. Geological Survey in Reston, Va. Winograd lauds Lauds is one of the two "major hours" in the Roman Catholic Liturgy of the Hours. It is to be recited in the early morning hours, preferably near dawn. Structure of the hour  the protactinium, dating technique but objects that the new study reanalyzed coral samples already known to support the orbital hypothesis. To address the issue thoroughly, says Winograd, Edwards should redate other corals that show sea levels rising far earlier or later than orbital theory would predict.
COPYRIGHT 1997 Science Service, Inc.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1997, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:Earth Science; R. Lawrence Edwards used protactinium dating to support the orbital theory of ice age development
Author:Monastersky, Richard
Publication:Science News
Article Type:Brief Article
Date:May 24, 1997
Words:332
Previous Article:Vanished sea leaves climatic legacy. (French researchers used computer modeling to determine the influence of the ancient sea Paratethys on the...
Next Article:Deciphering the grapefruit juice effect. (a study of 10 men found that consumption of grapefruit juice increased the potency of drugs by suppressing...
Topics:



Related Articles
Ice age insights: samples of air from glacial times add pieces to the ice age puzzle.
Devil's Hole fires Ice Age debate.
Reading climate changes in an Ice Age map. (levels of atmospheric carbon dioxide)
Devils Hole heats up debate over ice ages. (results from alterations in Earth's orbit)(includes related material)
Coral's chilling tale; ancient reefs may resolve an ice-age paradox. (contradictory evidence about effect of ice age on low latitudes)
Staggering through the Ice Ages: what made the planet careen between climate extremes? (includes related article on stability of current climate)
New beat detected in the ice age rhythm.(research on climate shifts during last ice age)
Climate modelers: go talk to the trees. (model indicates that changes in plant communities were an important factor in stimulating an ice age)(Brief...
When glaciers covered the entire Earth.(geological evidence indicates that Earth has experienced at least two global ice ages)(Brief Article)
Frozen in time: concepts of 'global glaciation' from 1837 (die Eiszeit) to 1998 (the Snowball Earth).

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles