Printer Friendly
The Free Library
19,604,530 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

DREARY `8 1/2 WOMEN' MAKES EVEN SEX BORING.


Byline: Glenn Whipp Film Critic

Anyone who found ``Eyes Wide Shut'' to be a little too warm and erotic for their tastes would do well to check out Peter Greenaway's latest exercise in tedium, ``8 1/2 Women.'' A dry meditation on sexual fantasies, ego and, yes, Fellini, this movie is such a cold dish that it makes Kubrick's last movie look like a bawdy trip through Amsterdam's red-light district.

Greenaway's films have always been studies in structure, symbols and formalism, making up for what they lack in humor with an overabundance o·ver·a·bun·dance  
n.
A going or being beyond what is needed, desired, or appropriate; an excess: teenagers with an overabundance of energy.
 of elitist malarkey ma·lar·key also ma·lar·ky  
n. Slang
Exaggerated or foolish talk, usually intended to deceive: "snookered by a lot of malarkey" New Republic.
. Still, in the case of, say, ``The Cook, the Thief, His Wife and Her Lover,'' Greenaway's obsessions can be diverting and his visual presentation can be strikingly inventive. But there's little in ``8 1/2 Women'' that rises above the banal; Greenaway seems largely to be trying to see just how much time he can spend either talking about or showing male genitalia. (Answer: a lot.)

The movie follows a self-absorbed businessman, Philip Emmenthal (John Standing) and his equally shallow son, Storey (Matthew Delamere). When Philip's wife dies, Storey goads his father on a voyage of sexual self-discovery. This comes after Philip's rather strange way of coping with his grief (``You've never slept with a corpse, I take it?'' he asks Storey) and an episode of father-son incest, something that seems to fascinate Greenaway simply because there isn't a word in the English language for it.

After watching Fellini's ``8 1/2,'' the Emmenthals ponder the nature of cinema. ``Do all directors make films to satisfy their sexual fantasies?'' Philip asks. If you're Greenaway, it's a rhetorical question, and he soon has father and son collecting a mansion full of libidinous li·bid·i·nous
adj.
Having or exhibiting lustful desires; lascivious.
 playthings, women that run the gamut of sexual fantasy figures. There's a sexually talented, gold-hearted whore (Polly Walker), a nun (Toni Collette), a subservient housekeeper (Barbara Sarafian), a passive Japanese porcelain doll (Kirina Mano ma·no  
n. pl. ma·nos
A hand-held stone or roller for grinding corn or other grains on a metate.



[Spanish, hand, mano, from Latin manus, hand; see manner.]
) and an earth mother who grooves on being perpetually pregnant (Natacha Amal).

And lest Greenaway be accused of mellowing, he also includes a paraplegic paraplegic /para·ple·gic/ (-ple´jik)
1. pertaining to or of the nature of paraplegia.

2. an individual with paraplegia.
 (Amanda Plummer) who enjoys an intimate relationship with a pig and a mysterious legless legless
Adjective

1. without legs

2. Slang very drunk

Adj. 1. legless - not having legs; "a legless man in a wheelchair"
 woman, Giulietta (Manna Fujiwara, playing a character seemingly named after Fellini's wife, an odd homage indeed).

Philip muses that ``most films are about what people haven't got - sex and money - and we have them both,'' but it's obvious that this happiness will be short-lived and that the Emmenthals will receive their comeuppance come·up·pance  
n.
A punishment or retribution that one deserves; one's just deserts: "It's a chance to strike back at the critical brotherhood and give each his comeuppance for evaluative sins of the past" 
. But what passes for female empowerment in Greenaway's misogynistic mi·sog·y·nis·tic   also mi·sog·y·nous
adj.
Of or characterized by a hatred of women.

Adj. 1. misogynistic - hating women in particular
misogynous

ill-natured - having an irritable and unpleasant disposition
 world is really just male self-pity, dressed up in pseudo-intellectual claptrap. As the friendly prostitute says, ``Men love women, women love children, and children love hamsters.''

And if you find deep meaning in that, you certainly won't agree when Philip admits to Storey that ``all this narcissism is rather boring.'' But for Greenaway, it's less a self-conscious confession than a mission statement, as much a badge of honor as all the genitalia he keeps purposelessly pur·pose·less  
adj.
Lacking a purpose; meaningless or aimless.



purpose·less·ly adv.
 waving in the audience's face.

The facts

--The film: ``8 1/2 Women'' (R; strong sexuality, nudity, language).

--The stars: Polly Walker, Amanda Plummer, Toni Collette, Vivian Wu, John Standing, Matthew Delamere.

--Behind the scenes: Written and directed by Peter Greenaway. Released by Lions Gate Films.

--Running time: Two hours.

--Playing: Laemmle's Pasadena Playhouse 7; Laemmle's Sunset 5 in West Hollywood

--Our rating: One star.

CAPTION(S):

photo

Photo:

Polly Walker and Matthew Delamere are two of the participants in the debauchery Debauchery
See also Dissipation, Profligacy.

Debt (See BANKRUPTCY, POVERTY.)

Alexander VI

Borgia pope infamous for licentiousness and debauchery. [Ital. Hist.: Plumb, 219–220]

Bacchus

(Gk.
 of ``8 1/2 Women.''
COPYRIGHT 2000 Daily News
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2000, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:L.A. Life
Publication:Daily News (Los Angeles, CA)
Article Type:Movie Review
Date:May 26, 2000
Words:581
Previous Article:BRIEFLY $4,000 IN STOLEN ITEMS RECOVERED.
Next Article:NEW DOCUMENTARY GETTING RAVE NOTICES.
Topics:



Related Articles
The Closet (Le Placard).
NO ILLUMINATION IN 'LUMINARIAS'.
PRETTY ACTORS IN `NO LOOKING BACK' ARE PRETTY BORING.
PINKETT SMITH WILL `WOO' YOU WITH HER CHARM.
PHONE-SEX FILM 'GIRL 6' ULTIMATELY DOESN'T SATISFY.
`CITIZEN RUTH' EVENLY IRREVERENT ON ABORTION.
EARTHY `MICHAEL' CAN'T QUITE FLY : THE FACTS.
MACDOWELL CONSTRICTED BY FIRST-TIME WRITER.

Terms of use | Copyright © 2012 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles