Cytogenetic markers, DNA single-strand breaks, urinary metabolites, and DNA repair rates in styrene-exposed lamination workers.The effect of occupational exposure to styrene sty·rene n. A colorless oily liquid from which polystyrenes, plastics, and synthetic rubber are produced. Also called vinylbenzene. on frequencies of chromosomal aberrations and binucleated bi·nu·cle·ate also bi·nu·cle·at·ed or bi·nu·cle·ar adj. Having two nuclei. Adj. 1. binucleated - having two nuclei binuclear, binucleate cells with micronuclei and on single-strand break levels in peripheral blood lymphocytes Peripheral Blood Lymphocytes (PBL): These are the mature lymphocytes (small white immune cells) that are found circulating in the blood, as opposed to organs, such as the lymph nodes, spleen, thymus, liver or bone marrow. These cells consist of T cells, NK cells and B cells. was studied in 86 reinforced plastic workers and 42 control individuals (including 16 maintenance workers with intermittent, low-dose exposure). In these individuals, the irradiation-specific DNA repair rates and the repair rates of 8-oxoguanines were investigated. We assessed the exposure by measuring the concentrations of styrene in air and in blood and of mandelic acid man·del·ic acid n. An acid that has both antibacterial and bacteriostatic properties, used in treating urinary tract infections. mandelic acid a keto-acid used as a urinary antiseptic in nephritis, pyelitis and cystitis. , phenylglyoxylic acid, 4-vinyl phenol phenol (fē`nōl), C6H5OH, a colorless, crystalline solid that melts at about 41°C;, boils at 182°C;, and is soluble in ethanol and ether and somewhat soluble in water. conjugates and regioisomefic phenyl phenyl (fĕn`əl), C6H5, organic free radical or alkyl group derived from benzene by removing one hydrogen atom. hydroxyethyl mercapturic acids in urine. All these parameters correlated with one another. No dear relationship was found between the styrene exposure and the frequencies of chromosomal aberrations. Binucleated cells with micronuclei were moderately related to the parameters of styrene exposure. We found a negative correlation between all exposure parameters and single-strand breaks. The positive correlation between exposure parameters and DNA repair rates suggests that particular DNA repair pathways may be induced by styrene exposure. Key words: DNA repair rates, genotoxicity Genotoxic substances are a type of carcinogen, specifically those capable of causing genetic mutation and of contributing to the development of tumors. This includes both certain chemical compounds and certain types of radiation. , styrene exposure, urinary metabolites Metabolites Substances produced by metabolism or by a metabolic process. Mentioned in: Interactions . doi:10.1289/ehp.6849 available via http://dx.doi.org/[Online 12 February 2004] ********** Styrene is used widely in the production of plastics, synthetic rubber, and polyester resins and occurs as an environmental contaminant contaminant /con·tam·i·nant/ (kon-tam´in-int) something that causes contamination. contaminant something that causes contamination. , present in small amounts in food items, tobacco smoke, and engine exhausts. Occupational exposure in hand lamination lamination a laminar structure or arrangement. work in the reinforced plastic industry may entail a daily intake of gram quantities of styrene via inhalation [International Agency for Research on Cancer The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC, or CIRC in its French acronym) is an intergovernmental agency forming part of the World Health Organisation of the United Nations. Its main offices are in Lyon, France. (IARC) 2002]. Many genetic toxicology assays are positive for styrene [reviewed by World Health Organization (WHO) 2001]. IARC has classified styrene as a possible human carcinogen carcinogen: see cancer. carcinogen Agent that can cause cancer. Exposure to one or more carcinogens, including certain chemicals, radiation, and certain viruses, can initiate cancer under conditions not completely understood. (group 2B), with limited evidence for carcinogenicity carcinogenicity /car·ci·no·ge·nic·i·ty/ (kahr?si-no-je-nis´i-te) the ability or tendency to produce cancer. carcinogenicity the ability or tendency to produce cancer. in humans and in experimental animals, whereas its main intermediary metabolite metabolite, organic compound that is a starting material in, an intermediate in, or an end product of metabolism. Starting materials are substances, usually small and of simple structure, absorbed by the organism as food. , styrene-7,8-oxide (StO), has been classified as a probable human carcinogen (group ZA; IARC 1994, 2002). Styrene metabolism has recently been reviewed (Vodicka et al. 2002). StO, formed from styrene by cytochrome cytochrome (sī`təkrōm'), protein containing heme (see coenzyme) that participates in the phase of biochemical respiration called oxidative phosphorylation. P450 monooxygenases, is primarily detoxified by microsomal microsomal pertaining to or emanating from microsome. epoxide hydrolase to phenylethylene glycol glycol (glī`kōl), dihydric alcohol in which the two hydroxyl groups are bonded to different carbon atoms; the general formula for a glycol is (CH2)n(OH)2. , which is further metabolized to yield mandelic acid (MA) and phenylglyoxylic acid (PGA (1) (Professional Graphics Adapter) An early IBM PC display standard for 3D processing with 640x480x256 resolution. It was not widely used. (2) (Programmable Gate Array) See gate array and FPGA. ), the principal urinary metabolites. To a minor extent, StO is conjugated conjugated adj. Conjugate. estrogens, conjugated Warning - Hazardous drug! C.E.S. with glutathione glutathione: see coenzyme. by glutathione S-transferases (GSTs), resulting in subsequent formation of phenyl hydroxyethyl mercapturic acids (PHEMAs), excreted in urine. An alternative oxidation on the aromatic ring aromatic ring, n closed ring structure formed by six carbon atoms, with a single hydrogen atom attached to each one. Also called a phenyl ring or a benzene ring. leads to the formation of 3,4-arene oxide, which may contribute to the styrene genotoxicity (Pfaffli et al. 1981). This metabolic pathway can be monitored by measuring urinary 4-vinyl phenol conjugates (4-VPT; Manini et al. 2003). Styrene is known to induce DNA DNA: see nucleic acid. DNA or deoxyribonucleic acid One of two types of nucleic acid (the other is RNA); a complex organic compound found in all living cells and many viruses. It is the chemical substance of genes. single-strand breaks (SSBs) in human white blood cells White blood cells A group of several cell types that occur in the bloodstream and are essential for a properly functioning immune system. Mentioned in: Abscess Incision & Drainage, Bone Marrow Transplantation, Complement Deficiencies (Vodicka et al. 1999) as well as cytogenetic cytogenetic /cy·to·ge·net·ic/ (-je-net´ik) 1. pertaining to chromosomes. 2. pertaining to cytogenetics. cytogenetic pertaining to or originating from the origin and development of the cell. damage in peripheral blood lymphocytes of styrene-exposed workers (Artuso et al. 1995; Somorovska et al. 1999; Tates et al. 1994). A recent hypothesis has postulated that oxidative stress oxidative stress, n an imbalance of the prooxidant antioxidant ratio in which too few antioxidants are produced or ingested or too many oxidizing agents are produced. may arise as a result of imbalance between oxidants and antioxidants Antioxidants Substances that reduce the damage of the highly reactive free radicals that are the byproducts of the cells. Mentioned in: Aging, Nutritional Supplements antioxidants, n. and contributes to the genotoxic genotoxic /ge·no·tox·ic/ (je´no-tok?sik) damaging to DNA: pertaining to agents known to damage DNA, thereby causing mutations, which can result in cancer. ge·no·tox·ic adj. effects of styrene exposure (Marczynski et al. 2000). The discrepancies between an excessive, long-lasting occupational exposure to styrene and relatively low levels of measured biomarkers (Koskinen et al. 2001; Vodicka et al. 2003) and inconclusive outcomes from cancer epidemiology studies (Kogevinas et al. 1993) indicate that various mechanisms connected with styrene biotransformation biotransformation /bio·trans·for·ma·tion/ (-trans?for-ma´shun) the series of chemical alterations of a compound (e.g., a drug) occurring within the body, as by enzymatic activity. and DNA repair may be of importance. Recent studies have reported that GSTM GSTM Gatespace Telematics (supplier of systems and components for telematics) GSTM General System Test Module 1 genotype along with GSTT GSTT Generation Skipping Transfer Tax GSTT Geological Society of Trinidad & Tobago 1 genotype may affect the genotoxicity of styrene in human lymphocytes Lymphocytes Small white blood cells that bear the major responsibility for carrying out the activities of the immune system; they number about 1 trillion. in vitro in vitro /in vi·tro/ (in ve´tro) [L.] within a glass; observable in a test tube; in an artificial environment. in vi·tro adj. In an artificial environment outside a living organism. (Bernardini et al. 2002) and urinary excretion of PHEMAs in styrene-exposed workers (Haufroid et al. 2002). In addition, genetic polymorphisms of biotransformation enzymes have been suggested to modulate the genotoxicity in styrene-exposed workers (Vodicka et al. 2001), although no strict conclusions can yet be drawn. Thus far, little information is available on the possible effect of styrene exposure on DNA repair rates. An early study indicated that styrene exposure, both in vivo in vivo /in vi·vo/ (ve´vo) [L.] within the living body. in vi·vo adj. Within a living organism. in vivo adv. and in vitro, increased unscheduled DNA synthesis induced in human mononuclear leukocytes by N-acetoxy-2-acetylaminofluorene but not by ultraviolet radiation (Pero et al. 1982). The authors concluded that styrene exposure does not alter the efficiency of DNA repair synthesis but only the susceptibility of DNA toward damages from chemical mutagens that depend on cellular metabolism. However, preliminary studies using the comet assay have suggested that the capacity of lymphocytes to remove both [gamma]-ray-induced DNA damage and oxidative DNA damage is increased in styrene-exposed workers (Vodicka et al. 2003). In the present study, we examined the effect of occupational exposure to styrene on the frequency of chromosomal aberrations (CAs) and binucleated cells (BNs) with micronuclei (MN) and on the level of SSBs and SSB SSB Statistisk Sentralbyrå (Statistics Norway) SSB Super Smash Bros (video game) SSB Space Studies Board SSB Single Side Band SSB Single Stranded DNA-Binding Protein SSB Salomon Smith Barney endonuclease endonuclease /en·do·nu·cle·ase/ (-noo´kle-as) any nuclease specifically catalyzing the hydrolysis of interior bonds of ribonucleotide or deoxyribonucleotide chains. III (Endo III) sites in peripheral lymphocytes. An innovative aspect was an investigation of the irradiation-specific DNA repair rates and the repair rates of 8-oxoguanines. Whether the level of various biomarkers is modulated by polymorphisms in DNA repair genes as well as by individual DNA repair rates (particularly those related to styrene-induced DNA lesions) in styrene-exposed subjects has to be addressed in the future investigation. Materials and Methods Subjects. The styrene-exposed group consisted of 86 workers employed in three plants (designated A, B, and C) located in the same area. The control group consisted of 26 employees of the Regional Hygienic Station (external control; EC) and 16 maintenance workers from plant B (plant control; PC). The design of the study was approved by the local ethical committee, and all participants provided their informed consent. The sampling of biologic material was carried out according to the Declaration in Helsinki (World Medical Association Declaration of Helsinki For the political accords, see . . There is also another Declaration of Helsinki, dealing with the Information Society.[1] Introduction The Declaration of Helsinki,[2] was developed by the World Medical Association[3] 1964). The exposed and control workers had similar socioeconomic background; the exposed subjects were, in comparison with the controls, on average 8.7 years younger, included more men (71 vs. 52%) and smokers (51 vs. 19%), and had smoked about twice as many cigarettes during their lifetime (Table 1). These differences were taken into account in the statistical analyses. Styrene exposure in workplace air and in blood. The concentration of styrene in the workplace air was determined by personal dosimeters the day of the sampling (Vodicka et al. 1995). The determination of styrene concentration in blood has been described previously (Vodicka et al. 1995, 2001). Styrene-specific urinary metabolites. An aliquot aliquot (al-ee-kwoh) adj. a definite fractional share, usually applied when dividing and distributing a dead person's estate or trust assets. (See: share) of urine was collected at the end of shift concomitantly with other samplings and used for the determination of the styrene-specific urinary metabolites MA, PGA, 4-VPT, and regioisomeric PHEMAs. The methodologies have been described previously for MA and PGA (Symanski et al. 2001), for 4-VPT (Manini et al. 2002), and for the PHEMAs diastereomeric N-acetyl-S-(1-phenyl-2hydroxyethyl)-cysteine (M1RR), (M1RS), and N-acetyl- S-(2-phenyl-2-hydroxyethyl)-cysteine (M2) (Ghittori et al. 1997). Determination of SSBs and SSB Endo III sites. SSBs, reflecting DNA damage induced by alkylation alkylation /al·kyl·a·tion/ (al?ki-la´shun) the substitution of an alkyl group for an active hydrogen atom in an organic compound. al·kyl·a·tion n. , were detected by a modified single-cell gel electrophoresis (comet) assay (Collins et al. 1996). SSB Endo III sites, reflecting abasic sites and oxopyrimidines, were evaluated by a modified version of comet assay with Endo III treatment (Collins et al. 1996) and are expressed as net values after the subtraction of SSBs. Cytogenetic analyses. The techniques used for the determination of CA (Valjus et al. 1993) and MN (Migliore et al. 1999) have been described previously. One hundred metaphases per sample for CA and 1,000 BNs/sample for MN were scored from coded slides. DNA repair rates. Peripheral blood lymphocytes isolated using Ficol gradient were used to test individual DNA repair capacity as described previously (Alapetite et al. 1999; Vodicka et al. 2003). Briefly, cells embedded in agarose agarose more highly purified form of agar with similar uses to agar and widely used in the separation of nucleic acid fragments. on slides were irradiated with 5 gray (Gy) of [gamma]-rays (0.42 Gy/min) and either lysed immediately or incubated at 37[degrees]C for 40 min before the lysis lysis /ly·sis/ (li´sis) 1. destruction or decomposition, as of a cell or other substance, under influence of a specific agent. 2. mobilization of an organ by division of restraining adhesions. 3. . The DNA breaks induced by [gamma]-rays are repaired according to the individual repair capacity, and the results are expressed as amount of repaired SSBs. Simultaneously with the analysis in human lymphocytes, irradiation-induced SSBs and remaining SSBs in various intervals were assayed for in human fibroblasts Fibroblasts A type of cell found in connective tissue; produces collagen. Mentioned in: Skin Grafting . This test confirmed that SSB removal is measured and the time interval is appropriate (Figure 1). [FIGURE 1 OMITTED] In addition, the individual capacity of peripheral lymphocyte lymphocyte: see blood; immunity. lymphocyte Type of leukocyte fundamental to the immune system, regulating and participating in acquired immunity. Each has receptor molecules on its surface that bind to a specific antigen. extracts to repair 8-oxoguanine, known to be removed from DNA by a specific glycosylase (oxoguanine glycosylase; OGG1), was determined as previously described (Collins et al. 2001). Briefly, HeLa cells HeLa cells cells of the first continuously cultured carcinoma strain, descended from a human cervical carcinoma; used in the study of life processes, including viruses, at the cell level. were pretreated with the photosensitizer photosensitizer Oncology A substance that sensitizes an organism, cell, or tissue to light; an agent used in photodynamic therapy which, when absorbed by CA cells and exposed to light, is activated, killing cancer cells. See Photodynamic therapy. Ro 19-8022 (Hoffmann-La Roche, Basel, Switzerland), irradiated with a fluorescent lamp to induce 8-oxoguanine, incubated with cell extracts prepared from lymphocytes of each subject, and analyzed by the comet assay. The level of SSBs reflected the removal of 8-oxoguanine from HeLa cell He·La cell n. Any of the cells of the first continuously cultured human carcinoma strain, originally obtained from cancerous cervical tissue and maintained for use in studying cellular processes. DNA by the lymphocyte extract. Statistical analyses. Statistical calculations were performed using Statgraphics, version 7 (Manugistics, Inc., Cambridge, MA, USA). The data were not normally distributed, and nonparametric tests were used: Mann-Whitney U-test for testing significant differences between groups, Spearman spear·man n. A man, especially a soldier, armed with a spear. correlation analysis for estimation of the correlation between parameters, and the Kruskal-Wallis test for the associations between biomarkers. All analyses were performed with coded samples. Results Styrene exposure. The mean styrene concentration in the workplace air, determined by personal dosimeters in three plants, was 81.3 [+ or -] 56.3 mg/[m.sup.3]; the highest mean concentration was in plant A, followed by plant C and plant B (Table 1). Styrene concentration in blood was, on average, 0.56 [+ or -] 0.43 mg/L in the exposed group and 0.07 [+ or -] 0.06 mg/L in the controls (Table 1). In the control group, styrene concentrations in blood were exclusively recorded among the plant controls, suggesting that low-level, intermittent exposure to styrene might occur among the maintenance workers. Although these workers were not directly involved in the styrene processing (as declared also in questionnaires), the low-level styrene exposure was further supported by the levels of urinary metabolites. In exposed workers, the concentrations of styrene in the air were correlated with those in blood (R = 0.817, p < 0.001). Styrene-s1)ecific urinary metabolites. The styrene metabolites determined in the urine of laminators followed the levels shown by external exposure parameters (Table 1). The mean levels of MA, PGA, and 4-VPT in the laminators were more than 10 times higher than those of the plant controls. In the exposed workers, urinary concentrations of various PHEMAs were 1.8 [+ or -] 4.1 mg/g creatinine for M1RR and M1RS, and 1.4 [+ or -] 3.2 mg/g creatinine for M2. PHEMAs were not determined in the control groups. All urinary metabolites in all exposed individuals and in workers from each particular plant correlated strongly with each other as well as with the concentrations of styrene in the air and in blood (data not shown). Cytogenetic markers. CA frequencies are presented in Table 2. The highest mean CA frequency was in the EC group (3.2 [+ or -] 2.0), and the lowest was in the plant controls (1.7 + 0.9; 1) = 0.042). Workers from plant A, exposed to the highest styrene concentration (mean, 112 mg/m3), exhibited the second highest CA frequency (2.5 [+ or -] 1.6) but did not differ significantly from the other groups. Results on chromatid-type aberrations (with and without gaps) and on chromosome breaks followed the same pattern as the frequency of total aberrant cells (Table 2) and did not correlate with any marker of styrene exposure. CA frequencies correlated positively with age (R = 0.223, p = 0.014); this correlation was more pronounced for chromosometype CA (R = 0.228, p = 0.012). No influence of other confounders on CA frequencies was recorded. The highest mean BN MN frequency was recorded among the workers from plant A and the ECs, and the lowest was in plant controls (Table 2). An association between BN MN frequency and styrene exposure (1) = 0.001 for styrene in air and p = 0.001 for styrene in blood) was found. In addition, BN MN frequency correlated with MA, PGA, and 4-VPT (data not shown). Significandy elevated BN MN frequencies were found in individuals with a higher index for cumulative exposure (styrene concentration in air multiplied by duration of exposure) than in those with a lower index (17.6 + 7.2 vs. 13.9 [+ or -] 6.2,1) : 0.017; Figure 2). BN MN frequencies significantly increased with age (R = 0.231, 1) = 0.013) and were higher in women than in men (F = 25.7, p < 0.001). [FIGURE 2 OMITTED] SSBs in DNA and SSB Endo III sites. The lower mean level of SSBs was recorded in plant A in comparison with both plant and ECs (Table 2). In fact, SSBs negatively correlated with most markers of styrene exposure (R = -0.350, 1) = 0.007 for styrene in blood; R = -0.402, 1) = 0.01 for MA; R = -0.403, p = 0.001 for PGA; R: -0.375,1) = 0.003 for 4-VPT). Decrease of SSBs with increasing concentration of styrene in air is illustrated in Figure 3A. SSB levels were not affected by any confounder recorded. [FIGURE 3 OMITTED] The mean level of SSB Endo III sites were not significantly different among different groups of exposed subjects and in comparison with the control individuals (Table 2). The levels of SSB Endo III sites did not correlate with any of the exposure markers, including urinary metabolites. DNA repair rates. As shown in Figure 1, most SSBs induced by [gamma]-rays are rapidly removed from DNA with an approximate half-life of 15-20 min. There is still residual DNA damage, which may be unrepaired double-strand breaks (DSBs). Individual capacity to repair SSBs induced by [gamma]-rays was significantly lower in the ECs, compared with all exposed groups (1) = 0.023 vs. plant A, 1) = 0.016 vs. plant B, 1) = 0.001 vs. plant C; Table 2). Irradiation-specific DNA repair rates were associated with styrene concentration in air (Figure 3B), correlated significantly with styrene in blood (R = 0.308, p = 0.031), and showed a tendency to decrease with increasing age (R = -0.204,1) = 0.095). The capacity of lymphocytes to incise in·cise v. To cut into with a sharp instrument. 8-oxoguanine in the different groups is shown in Table 2. The only significant (> 2-fold) increase in the DNA repair was recorded among workers from plant A (p = 0.0006 vs. plant B, p = 0.0007 vs. plant C, p = 0.0003 vs. plant controls, p = 0.015 vs. ECs). Repair capacity to remove oxidative DNA damage increased with increasing styrene concentration in air (Figure 3C) and correlated significantly with styrene in blood (R = 0.371,1) = 0.004) and with urinary metabolites (R = 0.414, p = 0.002 for MA; R = 0.428, p = 0.001 for PGA; R= 0.336,1) = 0.010 for 4-VPT). Discussion In this study, we examined the levels of specific urinary metabolites and chromosome and DNA damage in relation to DNA repair rates in styrene-exposed workers. Exposure assessment. The strong correlations observed between measures of external and internal styrene exposure and styrene-specific urinary metabolites have been well documented (Vodicka et al. 1999). As an interesting new finding concerning the metabolites, the urinary excretion of both 4-vinyl phenol conjugates 4-vinyl phenol glucuronide and 4-vinyl phenol sulfate sulfate, chemical compound containing the sulfate (SO4) radical. Sulfates are salts or esters of sulfuric acid, H2SO4, formed by replacing one or both of the hydrogens with a metal (e.g., sodium) or a radical (e.g., ammonium or ethyl). was exposure dependent, indicating that 3,4-arene oxidation takes place in styrene metabolism in humans and may contribute to the genotoxic burden. Although this metabolic pathway has been previously postulated (Pfaffli et al. 1981), the biologic relevance of styrene-3,4-oxide, for example, in terms of DNA adduct formation has yet to be investigated. Exposure-dependent excretion of diastereomeric PHEMAs in workers provides only limited information, because conjugation conjugation, in genetics conjugation, in genetics: see recombination. conjugation, in grammar conjugation: see inflection. of StO with glutathione represents a minor metabolic pathway (< 1% of the total urinary metabolites), and is highly dependent on GSTM1 polymorphism polymorphism, of minerals, property of crystallizing in two or more distinct forms. Calcium carbonate is dimorphous (two forms), crystallizing as calcite or aragonite. Titanium dioxide is trimorphous; its three forms are brookite, anatase (or octahedrite), and rutile. . GSTM1-positive individuals have been shown to excrete excrete /ex·crete/ (eks-kret´) to throw off or eliminate by a normal discharge, such as waste matter. ex·crete v. To eliminate waste material from the body. five to six times more PHEMA PHEMA Poly 2-Hydroxyethylmethacrylate than do GSTM1-negative subjects (De Palma Palma or Palma de Mallorca (päl`mä thā mälyôr`kä), city (1990 pop. 325,120), capital of Majorca island and of Baleares prov., Spain, on the Bay of Palma. et al. 2001). Cytogenetic markers. In contrast to previous findings (Artuso et al. 1995; Somorovska et al. 1999), we did not observe any effect of styrene exposure on CA frequencies; nor were chromatid-type aberrations, previously shown to be indicative of styrene treatment (Jantunen et al. 1986), increased in the exposed subjects. The BN MN frequencies were associated with the concentrations of styrene in the air and in blood and of urinary metabolites and with cumulative exposure index, suggesting an effect of the occupational exposure on MN formation, after adjustment for known confounders (age and sex). However, the differences in the mean BN MN frequency between the exposed group and ECs were negligible, whereas the plant control group showed the lowest BN MN frequency. Remarkably, a higher BN MN frequency in the EC group may be due to the known confounders affecting this end point: age and sex (Fenech 1998); indeed, the EC group consisted mainly of women with higher mean age. Similar considerations may be plausible for frequencies of CAs. SSBs and SSB Endo III sites. SSBs in DNA were significantly lower in exposed workers than in those unexposed and correlated inversely with parameters of internal exposure. This is in striking contrast to previous studies (Vodicka et al. 1999), where an exposure-related increase in SSBs was found and SSBs correlated significantly with [O.sub.6]-styrene--guanine DNA adducts (Vodicka et al. 1995) and CA (Somorovska et al. 1999). This discrepancy may be caused by differences among the populations examined: The previous consisted of individuals exposed for 14 years on average, whereas workers in the present study were exposed to styrene for less than 4 years. On the other hand, in the present study the relatively lower SSB levels in exposed workers were associated with more efficient DNA repair capacities, whereas in previous reports DNA repair rates were not addressed. SSB Endo III sites, reflecting either abasic sites or oxopyrimidines, were almost identical in both the exposed and control groups, but in contrast to our previous study (Somorovska et al. 1999), we recorded this type of DNA damage at clearly distinguishable levels. Because oxidative DNA damage may arise because of various intrinsic and extrinsic factors and SSB Endo III sites represent a nonspecific nonspecific /non·spe·cif·ic/ (non?spi-sif´ik) 1. not due to any single known cause. 2. not directed against a particular agent, but rather having a general effect. nonspecific 1. marker, it is difficult to pinpoint the origin of this DNA damage in the present population. The role of oxidative stress related to styrene exposure may be a contributing factor, as indicated by increased levels of 8-hydroxyguanine DNA adducts among workers exposed to styrene (Marczynski et al. 2000). DNA repair rates. To screen individual DNA repair rates, we employed a modified comet assay on irradiated human lymphocytes. The comet assay is a useful tool for the DNA damage and repair assessment (Dikomey et al. 2000; Popanda et al. 2003), but its version based on alkaline denaturation denaturation, term used to describe the loss of native, higher-order structure of protein molecules in solution. Most globular proteins exhibit complicated three-dimensional folding described as secondary, tertiary, and quarternary structures. does not allow discrimination of simultaneously induced SSBs and DSBs. Irradiation-induced ([gamma]-rays) DNA damage consists of mainly SSBs (90%), whereas DSBs account for 10% (Sakai and Okada 1984). Because most of the DNA damage induced by irradiation is repaired very quickly, this repair pathway may be attributable to base excision repair Base excision repair (BER) is a cellular mechanism that can repair damaged DNA during DNA replication. Repairing DNA sequence errors is necessary so that mutations are not induced during replication. . In fact, the irradiation-related DSBs are repaired with half-life of more than 2 hr (Dikomey and Franzke 1986) via nonhomologous recombination recombination, process of "shuffling" of genes by which new combinations can be generated. In recombination through sexual reproduction, the offspring's complete set of genes differs from that of either parent, being rather a combination of genes from both parents. repair (Natarajan 2002). We investigated individual capacities to repair SSBs induced by irradiation. On the other hand, SSBs were also analyzed as an indicator of DNA damage without any information on their specificity and origin. Despite the limitations in specificity, the association between the actual levels of SSBs and the capacities of their repair is important. Capacity to repair irradiation-specific DNA damage was significantly higher in exposed workers than in unexposed or moderately exposed subjects. The apparent increase in DNA repair rates related to styrene exposure may reflect effective activation of the DNA repair machinery. It remains to be resolved whether DNA repair rates are truly induced, whether a threshold exists in this induction, and whether long-term exposure could exhaust the induction. An increased capacity of lymphocytes to incise 8-oxoguanine was recorded among highly exposed workers. Significant association between both internal and external exposure parameters and repair capacity to remove oxidative DNA damage suggests a possible role of oxidative stress in styrene-related genotoxicity, as previously postulated. However, until we address combinations of various exposure parameters and multiple markers of early effect, interpretations should be cautious, and the complexity of the biologic system has to be considered in order to prevent simple mechanistic extrapolation (mathematics, algorithm) extrapolation - A mathematical procedure which estimates values of a function for certain desired inputs given values for known inputs. If the desired input is outside the range of the known values this is called extrapolation, if it is inside then . In styrene-exposed workers, genotoxic effects may depend on the extent of exposure, duration of exposure, and individual susceptibility in several biotransformation and DNA repair genes, as well as adaptation processes. As suggested by the present pilot study, the role of individual DNA repair rates deserves further investigation. This study was supported by grants EU QLK4-CT-1999-01368, GACR GACR Gyrate Atrophy of Choroid and Retina 310/01/0802, GACR 310/03/0437, and AVOZ5039906. The authors declare they have no competing financial interests. Received 10 November 2003; accepted 12 February 2004. REFERENCES Alapetite C, Thirion P, De La Rochefordiere A, Cosset cos·set tr.v. cos·set·ed, cos·set·ing, cos·sets To pamper. n. A pet, especially a pet lamb. [Possibly from Anglo-Norman coscet, pet lamb JM, Moustacchi E. 1999. Analysis by alkaline comet assay of cancer patients with severe reactions to radiotherapy: defective rejoining of radioinduced DNA strand breaks in lymphocytes of breast cancer patients. Int J Cancer 83:83-90. Artuso M, Angotzi G, Bonassi S, Bonatti S, De Ferrari M, Gargano D, et al. 1995. Cytogenetic biomonitoring of styrene-exposed plastic boat builders. Arch Environ Contam Toxicol 29:270-274. Bernardini S, Hirvonen A, Jarventaus H, Norppa H. 2002. Influence of GSTM1 and GSTT1 genotypes on sister chromatid exchange Sister chromatid exchange is the exchange of genetic material between two identical sister chromatids. It was firstly discovered by using giemsa staining method on one chromatid belonging to the sister chromatid complex before anaphase in mitosis. induction by styrene in cultured human lymphocytes. Carcinogenesis car·ci·no·gen·e·sis n. The production of cancer. carcinogenesis production of cancer. biological carcinogenesis viruses and some parasites are capable of initiating neoplasia. 23:893-897. Collins AR, Dusinska M, Gedik C, Stetina R. 1996. Oxidative damage to DNA: do we have a reliable biomarker? Environ Health Perspect 104:465-469. Collins AR, Dusinska M, Horvathova E, Munro E, Savio M, Stetina R. 2001. Inter-individual differences in repair of DNA base oxidation measured in vitro with the comet assay. Mutagenesis mutagenesis /mu·ta·gen·e·sis/ (mu?tah-jen´e-sis) 1. the production of change. 2. the induction of genetic mutation. mu·ta·gen·e·sis n. pl. 10:297-301. De Palma G, Manini P, Mozzoni P, Andreoli R, Bergamaschi E, Cavazzini S, et al. 2001. Polymorphism of xenobiotic-metabolizing enzymes and excretion of styrene-specific mercapturic acids. Chem Res Toxicol 14:1393-1400. Dikomey E, Brammer I, Johansen J, Bentzen SM, Overgaard J. 2000. Relationship between DNA double-strand breaks, cell killing, and fibrosis studied in confluent con·flu·ent adj. 1. Flowing together; blended into one. 2. Merging or running together so as to form a mass, as sores in a rash. skin fibroblasts derived from breast cancer patients. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol 46:481-490. Dikomey ER, Franzke J. 1986. Three classes of DNA strand breaks induced by X-irradiation and internal B-rays. Int J Radiat Biol 50:893-908. Fenech M. 1998. Important variables that influence base-line micronucleus micronucleus /mi·cro·nu·cle·us/ (-noo´kle-us) 1. in ciliate protozoa, the smaller of two types of nucleus in each cell, which functions in sexual reproduction; cf. macronucleus. 2. a small nucleus. frequency in cytokinesis-blocked lymphocytes-a biomarker for DNA damage in human populations. Mutat Res 404:155-165. Ghittori S, Maestri L, Imbriani M, Capodaglio E, Cavalleri A. 1997. Urinary excretion of specific mercapturic acids in workers exposed to styrene. Am J Ind Med 31:636-644. Haufroid V, Jakubowski M, Janasik B, Ligocka D, Buchet JP, Bergamaschi E, et al. 2002. Interest in genotyping and phenotyping of drug-metabolizing enzymes for the interpretation of biological monitoring of exposure to styrene. Pharmacogenetics Pharmacogenetics Definition Pharmacogenetics is the study of how the actions of and reactions to drugs vary with the patient's genes. Description 12:091-702. IARC. 1994. Styrene. IARC Monogr Eval Carcinog Risks Hum 60:233-346. IARC. 2002. Some Traditional Herbal Medicines, Some Mycotoxins, Naphthalene naphthalene (năf`thəlēn'), colorless, crystalline, solid aromatic hydrocarbon with a pungent odor. It melts at 80°C;, boils at 218°C;, and sublimes upon heating. , and Styrene. IARC Monogr Eval Carcinog Risks Hum 82. Jantunen K, Maki-Paakkanen J, Norppa H. 1986. Induction of chromosome aberrations by styrene and vinyl acetate in cultured human lymphocytes: dependence on erythrocytes Erythrocytes Red blood cells. Mentioned in: Bartonellosis erythrocytes (ē·rithˑ·rō·sīts), n.pl red blood cells. . Mutat Res 159:109-116. Kogevinas M, Ferro G, Saracci R, Andersen A, Biocca M, Coggon D, et al. 1993. Cancer mortality in an international cohort of workers exposed to styrene. IARC Sci Publ 127:289-300. Koskinen M, Vodicka P, Hemminki K. 2001. Identification of 1-adenine DNA adducts in workers occupationally exposed to styrene. J Occup Environ Med 43:694-700. Manini P, Andreoli R, Poli D, De Palma G, Mutti A, Niessen WMA (Windows Media Audio) An audio compression method from Microsoft. Known originally as MSAudio, this proprietary format competes with the MP3 and AAC methods. WMA encodes rapidly and is known to be especially effective at low bit rates. . 2002. Liquid chromatography/electrospray tandem mass spectrometry Tandem mass spectrometry, also known as MS/MS, involves multiple steps of mass spectrometry selection, with some form of fragmentation occurring in between the stages. characterization of styrene metabolism in rat and in man. Rapid Commun Mass Spectrom 10:2239-2248. Manini P, Buzio L, Andreoli R, Goldoni M, Bergamaschi E, Jakubowski M, et al. 2003. Assessment of biotransformation of the arene moiety moiety: see clan. of styrene in volunteers and occupationally exposed workers. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 189:160-169. Marczynski B, Peel M, Baur X. 2000. New aspects in genotoxic risk assessment of styrene exposure-a working hypothesis. Med Hypotheses 54:819-625. Migliore L, Botto N, Scarpato R, Petrozzi L, Cipriani G, Bonuccelli U. 1999. Preferential occurence of chromosome 21 malsegregation in peripheral blood lymphocytes of Alzheimer patients. Cytogenet Cell Genet genet: see civet. 87:41-46. Natarajan AT. 2002. Chromosome aberrations: past, present and future. Murat Res 504:3-16. Pero RW, Bryngelsson T, Hogstedt B, Akesson B. 1982. Occupational and in vitro exposure to styrene assessed by unscheduled DNA synthesis in resting human lymphocytes. Carcinogenesis 3:681-685. Pfaffli P, Hesso A, Vainio H, Hyvonen M. 1981. 4-Vinylphenol excretion suggestive of suggestive of Decision making adjective Referring to a pattern by LM or imaging, that the interpreter associates with a particular–usually malignant lesion. See Aunt Millie approach, Defensive medicine. arene oxide formation in workers occupationally exposed to styrene. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 60:85-90. Popanda O, Ebbeler R, Twardella D, Helmbold I, Gotzes F, Schmezer P, et al. 2003. Radiation-induced DNA damage and repair in lymphocytes from breast cancer patients and their correlation with acute skin reactions to radiotherapy. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 55:1216-1225. Sakai K, Okada S. 1984. Radiation-induced DNA damage and cellular lethality in cultured mammalian cells. Radiat Res 98:479-490. Somorovska M, Jahnova E, Tulinska J, Zamecnikova M, Sarmanova J, Terenova A, et al. 1999. Biomonitoring of occupational exposure to styrene in a plastic lamination plant. Mutat Res 428:255-269. Symanski E, Bergamaschi E, Mutti A. 2001. Inter- and intra-individual sources of variation in levels of urinary styrene metabolites. Int Arch Occup Environ Health 74:336-344. Tates AD, Grummt T, Van Damm FJ, De Zwart F, Kasper FJ, Rothe R, et al. 1994. Measurement of frequencies of HPRT HPRT Hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyl transferase, see there mutants, chromosomal aberrations, micronuclei, sister-chromatid exchanges and cells with high frequencies of SCEs in styrene/dichloromethane-exposed workers. Mutat Res 313:249-262. Valjus J, Norppa H, Jarventaus H, Sorsa M, Nykyri E, Salomaa S, et al. 1993. Analysis of chromosomal aberrations, sister chromatid exchanges and micronuclei among power linesmen with long-term exposure to 50-Hz electric and magnetic fields magnetic fields, n.pl the spaces in which magnetic forces are detectable; created by magnetostrictive ultrasonic scalers to cause the tips of instruments such as ultrasonic scalers to vibrate. . Radiat Environ Biophys 32:325-336. Vodicka P, Bastlova T, Vodickova L, Peterkova K, Lambert B, Hemminki K. 1995. Biomarkers of styrene exposure in lamination workers: levels of [O.sup.6]-guanine DNA adducts, DNA strand breaks and mutant frequencies in the hypoxanthine hypoxanthine /hy·po·xan·thine/ (-zan´then) a purine base formed as an intermediate in the degradation of purines and purine nucleosides to uric acid and in the salvage of free purines. Complexed with ribose it is inosine. guanine guanine (gwä`nēn), organic base of the purine family. It was reported (1846) to be in the guano of birds; later (1879–84) it was established as one of the major constituents of nucleic acids. phosphoribosyltransferase gene in T-lymphocytes. Carcinogenesis 10:1473-1481. Vodicka P, Koskinen M, Arand M, Oesch F, Hemminki K. 2002. Spectrum of styrene-induced DNA adducts: the relationship to other biomarkers and prospects to human biomonitoring. Mutat Res 511:239-254. Vodicka P, Koskinen M, Stetina R, Soucek P, Vodickova L, Matousu Z, et al. 2003. The role of various biomarkers in the evaluation of styrene genotoxicity. Cancer Detect Prey 27:275-284. Vodicka P, Soucek P, Tates AD, Dusinska M, Sarmanova J, Zamecnikova M, et al. 2001. Association between genetic polymorphism and biomarkers in styrene-exposed workers. Mutat Res 482:91-105. Vodicka P, Tvrdik T, Osterman-Golkar S, Vodickova L, Peterkova K, Soucek P, et al. 1999. An evaluation of styrene genotoxicity using several biomarkers in a 3-year follow-up study of hand-lamination workers. Mutat Res 445:205-224. WHO. 2001. Styrene. In: Air Quality Guidelines for Europe, 2000; Full Background Material to WHO Regional Publications. European Series, No. 91. 2nd ed. Copenhagen:World Health Organization Regional Office for Europe, 1-31. World Medical Association Declaration of Helsinki. 1964. Ethical Principles for Medical Research involving Human Subjects. World Medical Association Declaration of Helsinki. Helsinki, Finland:18th World Medical Association General Assembly. Pavel Vodicka, (1) Jarno Tuimala, (2) Rudoff Stetina, (3) Rajiv Kumar, (4,5) Paola Manini, (6) Alessio Naccarati, (1,7) Luciano Maestri, (8) Ludmila Vodickova, (9) Miroslava Kuricova, (1) Hilkka Jarventaus, (2) Zuzana Majvaldova, (10) Ari Hirvonen, (2) Marcello Imbriani, (8) Antonio Mutti, (6) Lucia Migliore, (7) Hannu Norppa, (2) and Kari Hemminki (4,5) (1) Institute of Experimental Medicine, Academy of Science of the Czech Republic, Prague, Czech Republic; (2) Laboratory of Molecular and Cellular Toxicology, Finnish Institute of Occupational Health, Helsinki, Finland; (3) Purkynje Military Medical Academy, Hradec Kralove, Czech Republic; (4) Department of Bioscience at Novum, Karolinska Institute, Huddinge, Sweden; (5) German Cancer Institute, Heidelberg, Germany; (6) Laboratory of Industrial Toxicology, University of Parma History The school was founded during XI century [1]as a center for study of the general liberal arts curriculum of the medieval period. The faculties of law and medicine were added in thirteenth century. , Parma, Italy; (7) Department of Human and Environmental Health, University of Pisa The University of Pisa (Italian Università di Pisa) is one of the most renowned Italian universities. It is located in Pisa, Tuscany. It was formally founded on the September 3, 1343 by an edict of Pope Clement VI, although there had been lectures on law in Pisa since the , Pisa, Italy; (8) Fondazione S. Maugeri and University of Pavia History The University of Pavia is one of the oldest universities in Europe. An edict issued by King Lotarius quotes a higher education institution in Pavia as already established 825 A.D. , Pavia, Italy; (9) National Institute of Public Health, Prague, Czech Republic; (10) Regional Hygiene Station, Usti/Orlici, Czech Republic Address correspondence to P. Vodicka, Department of Genetic and Molecular Toxicology, Institute of Experimental Medicine, Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic The Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic Czech: Akademie věd České republiky, abbr. AV ČR , Videnska 1083, 142 20 Prague 4, Czech Republic. Telephone: 420-2-41062694. Fax: 420-2-41062782. E-mail: pvodicka@biomed.cas.cz
Table 1. Characteristics of the studied population and indicators of
exposure to styrene.
All exposed Plant A
Characteristics (n = 86) (n = 35)
Age [years (mean 36.5 [+ or -] 12.0 36.8 [+ or -] 12.6
[+ or -] SD)]
Sex (F/M) 25/61 15/20
Smoking habit 44 S/42 NS 15 S/20 NS
Lifetime no. of 80,711 [+ or -] 76,52 59,853 [+ or -] 64,80
cigarettes (mean
[+ or -] SD)
Years of employment 4.0 [+ or -] 4.1 3.4 [+ or -] 5.3
(mean [+ or -] SD)
Workplace styrene 81.3 [+ or -] 56.3 112.4 [+ or -] 57.5
exposure [mg/[m.sup.3] (n = 73) (n = 29)
(mean [+ or -] SD)]
Styrene levels 0.56 [+ or -] 0.43 0.71 [+ or -] 0.47
in blood [mg/L (n = 78) (n = 34)
(mean [+ or -] SD)]
MA + PGA levels 496.9 [+ or -] 402.2 797.5 [+ or -] 418.9
[mg/gcreatinine (n = 80) (n = 33)
(mean [+ or -] SD)]
4-VPT levels 5.64 [+ or -] 4.82 7.82 [+ or -] 5.70
[mg/gcreatinine (n = 80) (n = 33)
(mean [+ or -] SD)]
PHEMA levels [mg/g
creatinine
(mean [+ or -] SD)]
M1 (RR + RS) 1.75 [+ or -] 4.11 2.09 [+ or -] 3.05
M2 1.37 [+ or -] 3.22 1.46 [+ or -] 1.78
(n = 76) (n = 30)
Plant B Plant C
Characteristics (n = 31) (n = 20)
Age [years (mean 38.0 [+ or -] 12.6 33.7 [+ or -] 9.5
[+ or -] SD)]
Sex (F/M) 0/31 10/10
Smoking habit 16 S/15 NS 13 S/7 NS
Lifetime no. of 114,850 [+ or -] 96,23 62,761 [+ or -] 45,42
cigarettes (mean
[+ or -] SD)
Years of employment 5.6 [+ or -] 3.1 2.5 [+ or -] 1.9
(mean [+ or -] SD)
Workplace styrene 47.1 [+ or -] 41.9 82.4 [+ or -] 43.9
exposure [mg/[m.sup.3] (n = 27) (n-17)
(mean [+ or -] SD)]
Styrene levels 0.40 [+ or -] 0.31 0.50 [+ or -] 0.44
in blood [mg/L (n = 27) (n = 17)
(mean [+ or -] SD)]
MA + PGA levels 269.9 [+ or -] 180.0 307.8 [+ or -] 271.9
[mg/gcreatinine (n = 31) (n = 16)
(mean [+ or -] SD)]
4-VPT levels 3.38 [+ or -] 2.23 5.63 [+ or -] 4.71
[mg/gcreatinine (n = 31) (n = 16)
(mean [+ or -] SD)]
PHEMA levels [mg/g
creatinine
(mean [+ or -] SD)]
M1 (RR + RS) 0.40 [+ or -] 0.64 3.65 [+ or -] 6.61
M2 0.33 [+ or -] 0.40 3.14 [+ or -] 6.32
(n = 30) (n = 16)
Plant controls External controls
Characteristics (n = 16) (n = 26)
Age [years (mean 48.5 [+ or -] 7.6 42.8 [+ or -] 8.2
[+ or -] SD)]
Sex (F/M) 0/16 20/6
Smoking habit 2 S/14 NS 6 S/20 NS
Lifetime no. of 127,750 [+ or -] 5,16 85,600 [+ or -] 62,59
cigarettes (mean
[+ or -] SD)
Years of employment ND ND
(mean [+ or -] SD)
Workplace styrene ND ND
exposure [mg/[m.sup.3]
(mean [+ or -] SD)]
Styrene levels 0.07 [+ or -] 0.06 ND
in blood [mg/L (n = 10)
(mean [+ or -] SD)]
MA + PGA levels 42.1 +15.5 ND
[mg/gcreatinine (n = 14)
(mean [+ or -] SD)]
4-VPT levels 0.39 [+ or -] 0.39 ND
[mg/gcreatinine (n = 14)
(mean [+ or -] SD)]
PHEMA levels [mg/g
creatinine
(mean [+ or -] SD)]
M1 (RR + RS) ND ND
M2 ND ND
Abbreviations: F, female; M, male; ND, not determined;
NS, nonsmokers; S, smokers.
Table 2. Mean values ([+ or -] SD) for various parameters of
genotoxicity and repair rates of irradiation-specific and
oxidative DNA damage in styrene-exposed workers and controls.
Parameters All exposed Plant A
Total CA without gaps (%) 2.3 [+ or -] 1.6 2.5 [+ or -] 1.6
CA chromatid-type, 1.5 [+ or -] 1.3 1.6 [+ or -] 1.4
without gaps (%)
CA chromatid-type, 2.0 [+ or -] 1.5 2.0 [+ or -] 1.4
with gaps (%)
CA chromosome breaks (%) 0.2 [+ or -] 0.4 0.2 [+ or -] 0.4
BN MN (%) 15.1 [+ or -] 6.7 17.9 [+ or -] 8.1 *
SSBs(SSB/[10.sup.9] Da) 0.29 [+ or -] 0.21 0.16 [+ or -] 0.12 **
SSB Endo III sites 0.12 [+ or -] 0.14 0.08 [+ or -] 0.10
(SSB/[10.sup.9] Da)
Irradiation-specific 1.08 [+ or -] 0.47 0.94 [+ or -] 0.32
DNA repair rates
(SSB/[10.sup.9] Da)
8-Oxoquanine repair 1.17 [+ or -] 1.04 1.88 [+ or -] 1.19 (##)
rates (SSB/[10.sup.9] Da)
Parameters Plant B Plant C
Total CA without gaps (%) 2.3 [+ or -] 1 .6 2.0 [+ or -] 1.4
CA chromatid-type, 1.4 [+ or -] 1.4 1.5 [+ or -] 0.9
without gaps (%)
CA chromatid-type, 2.3 [+ or -] 1.9 1.8 [+ or -] 1.0
with gaps (%)
CA chromosome breaks (%) 0.2 [+ or -] 0.4 0.1 [+ or -] 0.4
BN MN (%) 13.4 [+ or -] 4.3 12.5 [+ or -] 4.7
SSBs(SSB/[10.sup.9] Da) 0.44 [+ or -] 0.22 0.31 [+ or -] 0.19
SSB Endo III sites 0.10 [+ or -] 0.14 0.24 [+ or -] 0.19
(SSB/[10.sup.9] Da)
Irradiation-specific 0.96 [+ or -] 0.44 1.63 [+ or -] 0.41 (#)
DNA repair rates
(SSB/[10.sup.9] Da)
8-Oxoquanine repair 0.66 [+ or -] 0.48 0.56 [+ or -] 0.27
rates (SSB/[10.sup.9] Da)
Parameters Plant controls External controls
Total CA without gaps (%) 1.7 [+ or -] 0.9 3.2 [+ or -] 2.0
CA chromatid-type, 1.2 [+ or -] 0.8 1.8 [+ or -] 1.7
without gaps (%)
CA chromatid-type, 1.7 [+ or -] 1.3 2.5 [+ or -] 1.9
with gaps (%)
CA chromosome breaks (%) 0.2 [+ or -] 0.4 0.4 [+ or -] 0.6
BN MN (%) 11.6 [+ or -] 4.9 15.6 [+ or -] 6.9
SSBs(SSB/[10.sup.9] Da) 0.57 [+ or -] 0.26 0.53 [+ or -] 0.26
SSB Endo III sites 0.16 [+ or -] 0.24 0.14 [+ or -] 0.38
(SSB/[10.sup.9] Da)
Irradiation-specific 0.81 [+ or -] 0.25 0.55 [+ or -] 0.64
DNA repair rates
(SSB/[10.sup.9] Da)
8-Oxoquanine repair 0.54 [+ or -] 0.47 0.90 [+ or -] 0.44
rates (SSB/[10.sup.9] Da)
* Statistically different compared with plant C (p = 0.004) and
plant controls (p = 0.002). ** Statistically different (p < 0.001)
compared with plant B, plant controls, and ECs. (#) Statistically
different (p = 0.001) compared with ECs. (##) Statistically
different (p < 0.001) compared with plant controls and plants
Band C.
|
|
||||||||||||||||||

Printer friendly
Cite/link
Email
Feedback
Reader Opinion