Printer Friendly
The Free Library
22,728,043 articles and books

Consumers, states challenge federal ban on drug imports.

In the midst Adv. 1. in the midst - the middle or central part or point; "in the midst of the forest"; "could he walk out in the midst of his piece?"
 of an election-year maelstrom Maelstrom, whirlpool, Norway: see Moskenstraumen.  over high prescription drug prescription drug Prescription medication Pharmacology An FDA-approved drug which must, by federal law or regulation, be dispensed only pursuant to a prescription–eg, finished dose form and active ingredients subject to the provisos of the Federal Food, Drug,  prices, aim elderly Chicago-area couple has sued the FDA FDA
Food and Drug Administration

FDA, See Food and Drug Administration.

FDA, the abbreviation for the Food and Drug Administration.
 and the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Noun 1. Department of Health and Human Services - the United States federal department that administers all federal programs dealing with health and welfare; created in 1979
Health and Human Services, HHS
 (HHS HHS Department of Health and Human Services. ) to permit the legalized import of cheaper prescription drugs from Canada. (Andrews v. Dep't of Health & Human Servs., No. 1:04CV00307 (D.D.C. filed Feb. 26, 2004).) The couple's counsel have proposed class certification for the suit.

Ray and Gaylee Andrews are at the forefront of widespread concern over U.S. prescription drug prices. Both 74 years old and on Medicare, the Andrewses take brand name medications--some manufactured domestically--for ailments common in elderly people, including arthritis, asthma, and diabetes. Their monthly drug bill is about $800. That cost, Gaylee said, has forced both of them to take jobs; they are also selling their home of 32 years to make ends meet. The Andrewses said that buying the same drugs from Canadian pharmacies via the Internet or mail order could save them as much as $350 a month (Canada has drug price controls that the United States United States, officially United States of America, republic (2005 est. pop. 295,734,000), 3,539,227 sq mi (9,166,598 sq km), North America. The United States is the world's third largest country in population and the fourth largest country in area.  does not).

The only hitch: Such drug purchases are currently illegal. The federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act The United States Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (abbreviated as FFDCA, FDCA, or FD&C), is a set of laws passed by Congress in 1938 giving authority to the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to oversee the safety of food, drugs, and cosmetics.  prohibits the importation of drugs that have not received FDA approval, even if the only difference between an approved drug In the United States, the FDA approves drugs. Before a drug can be prescribed, it must undergo an extensive FDA approval process. This process involves first testing the drug on animals or in medical labs.  and an unapproved un·ap·proved  
Not approved or sanctioned: an unapproved vaccine; an unapproved protest march. 
 one is a matter of packaging. Also, to ensure that all drugs are made and handled according to according to
1. As stated or indicated by; on the authority of: according to historians.

2. In keeping with: according to instructions.

 FDA specifications, only a drug's manufacturer is permitted to import or reimport re·im·port  
tr.v. re·im·port·ed, re·im·port·ing, re·im·ports
To bring back into a country (goods made from its exported raw materials).

 prescription drugs into the United States. Several bills pending in Congress at press time would allow individuals to import drugs themselves.

The recently passed Medicare Prescription Drug Improvement and Modernization Act (MMA (Microcomputer Managers Association, Inc.) A membership organization with chapters throughout the U.S. that was devoted to educating personnel responsible for personal computers. It disbanded in 1996.

Mma - A fast Mathematica-like system, in Allegro CL by R. Fateman, 1991.
), while prohibiting the U.S. government from negotiating with pharmaceutical companies for better Medicare drug prices, gives the HHS secretary the power to approve imports of cheaper drugs from Canada. Since the statute's passage in 2003, however, the secretary has refused to act on that power.

Indeed, in April, the Illinois governor and attorney general filed a petition with the FDA, demanding a response within six months to the governor's proposed plan to import drugs from Canada for Illinois citizens. The governor, who has spoken in favor of the Andrewses' lawsuit, created the project to save the state millions in prescription drug costs. So far, however, the FDA has not responded, although an agency task force the MMA called for expects to issue a report by the end of the year on the safety of drug imports.

In the meantime Adv. 1. in the meantime - during the intervening time; "meanwhile I will not think about the problem"; "meantime he was attentive to his other interests"; "in the meantime the police were notified"
meantime, meanwhile
, illegality has not stopped some states and municipalities, including Minnesota and New Hampshire New Hampshire, one of the New England states of the NE United States. It is bordered by Massachusetts (S), Vermont, with the Connecticut R. forming the boundary (W), the Canadian province of Quebec (NW), and Maine and a short strip of the Atlantic Ocean (E). . Both states run Web sites, for instance, with information on purchasing lower-priced prescription drugs from Canada and links to online Canadian pharmacies.

Thus far, breaking the law has brought only limited ramifications ramifications nplAuswirkungen pl . The FDA sued to shut down Rx Depot, a U.S.-based online drug provider. (United States v. Rx Depot, 290 F. Supp. 2d 1238 (N.D. Okla. 2003).) In separate actions, the FDA has also conducted several "blitz" examinations of packages sent via the U.S. Postal Service The U.S. Postal Service (USPS) processes and delivers mail to individuals and businesses within the United States. The service seeks to improve its performance through the development of efficient mail-handling systems and operates its own planning and engineering programs.  and believed to contain unapproved and imported drugs.

Perhaps because of such relatively lax enforcement, illegal imports are a booming, if somewhat covert, business: IMS Health IMS Health (NYSE: RX) is an international consulting and data services company that supplies the pharmaceutical industry with sales data and consulting services. IMS Health was founded in 1954 by Bill Frohlich and David Dubow. , a company that analyzes time pharmaceutical industry, estimates that last year approximately $216 billion was spent in the United States on prescription drugs. Stephen Schondelmeyer, director of the University of Minnesota's PRIME Institute, which studies pharmaceutical policy issues, believes about $2 billion of that was spent on illegal imports. And William Vaughn, government affairs director of Families USA Families USA is an American non-profit consumer health-care advocacy organization. It was founded by attorney Ron Pollack, its executive director.

Pollack was Dean of Antioch School of Law, and argued cases involving food aid for low-income Americans before the Supreme Court.
, a health-care advocacy group based in Washington, D.C., estimated that about half of those imports came from Canada, either by mail or with returning U.S. visitors.

At press time, the FDA had been granted an extension, until mid-May, to respond to the Andrewses' lawsuit. The agency emphasizes that current laws protect U.S. consumers from counterfeit and dangerous drugs that are illegally imported.

"It is hard to overcome the argument that the overriding purpose of the FDA is to protect the public health," admitted George Bellas, one of the Andrewses' lawyers. "The FDA is entrusted with the enforcement of the statutes, and any violation is presumed to cause public harm."

Thus, the Andrewses have taken a novel stance. "Our tack in this lawsuit," said Bellas, "is to look at the issue from an individual, consumer-rights perspective. The whole statutory Damework violates consumers' constitutional rights."

The lawsuit alleges that current law violates

* the Fifth Amendment's Due Process Clause, which protects citizens' privacy rights to make personal medical decisions

* the right to equal protection incorporated into the Fifth Amendment, by allowing selective enforcement of the law so that residents near Canada may cross the border and buy drugs without much threat of punishment, but mail-order sales are shut down

* substantive due process The substantive limitations placed on the content or subject matter of state and federal laws by the Due Process Clauses of the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments to the U.S. Constitution.  rights under the Due Process Clause, by preventing the importation of prescription drugs from Canada that are chemically identical to drugs sold in the United States and thus defeating "the historically rooted and traditional right to direct one's own medical treatment"

* the Presentment Clause in Article 1, [section] 7, by letting the HHS secretary modify a federal statute and allow drug imports without presentment to the president or congressional approval

* the Vesting Clause in Article 1, [section] 1, by giving the HHS secretary the power to determine when legislation allowing importation will take effect.

For the FDA and others who oppose importation, however, the satiety satiety

being in a state of satiation; in experimental animals used with reference to eating and drinking.

satiety center
located in the ventromedial hypothalamic nucleus.
 of imported drugs remains key. Even though there have been no reports of harm from illegally imported drugs, the FDA would not necessarily receive such reports, said agency spokesman Jason Brodsky. "Patients aren't typically inclined to tell their doctor that they purchased their drug from an illegal source."

As noted by Jeffrey Axelrad, an attorney and adjunct professor at George Washington University George Washington University, at Washington, D.C.; coeducational; chartered 1821 as Columbian College (one of the first nonsectarian colleges), opened 1822, became a university in 1873, renamed 1904.  School of Law in Washington, D.C., illegal prescription drug imports also raise significant liability issues.

"Because even safe and efficacious drugs can have effects that are untoward and, for a tiny proportion of users, even catastrophic, the potential for litigation An action brought in court to enforce a particular right. The act or process of bringing a lawsuit in and of itself; a judicial contest; any dispute.

When a person begins a civil lawsuit, the person enters into a process called litigation.
 is very real," he wrote in a Legal Times opinion article.

"For states and municipalities, (liability for] injuries due to the inherent risks in drugs would be added to liability for purchasing stale, counterfeit, or ineffective medications." A single liability, judgment, he wrote, could wipe out ally savings from such imports. (Jeffrey Axelrad, Watch Out for Canadian Drugs!, LEGAL TIMES, Mar. 1, 2004, at 52.)

Paying the price

Americans pay the highest prices in the world for prescription drugs, but the reasons for that vary, depending on who's talking.

"Basically, what we're importing from Canada is the backbone of the Canadian politicians," said Families USA's Vaughn. "They have taken the tough steps to negotiate with powerful lobbies to get a better price."

Although increases in U.S. prescription drug spending consistently outpace inflation, pharmaceutical companies say the spending funds important research. However, the nine companies that made the top 50 drugs used by seniors in 2001 spent that year on average only 11 percent of their revenues on research, compared to 27 percent on marketing, advertising, and administration, according to a Families USA report. (Profiting from Pain: Where Prescription Drug Dollars Go (July 2002).)

Drug costs are at issue in several lawsuits. In Massachusetts, a federal court judge allowed a suit against pharmacy benefits managers (PBMs) to proceed. (In re Pharm. Indus. Average Wholesale Price Litig., MDL MDL - (Originally "Muddle"). C. Reeve, Carl Hewitt and Gerald Sussman, Dynamic Modeling Group, MIT ca. 1971. Intended as a successor to Lisp, and a possible base for Planner-70. Basically LISP 1.5 with data types and arrays. . No. 1456, Civ. A. No. 01-12257-PBS, 2004 WL 345847 (D. Mass. Feb. 24, 2004).) In the suit, consumer groups allege that PBMs--which negotiate drug prices for health plans--and drug manufacturers inflate the average wholesale price of drugs and give discounts to pharmacies and doctors without passing on those savings to consumers.

The District of Columbia District of Columbia, federal district (2000 pop. 572,059, a 5.7% decrease in population since the 1990 census), 69 sq mi (179 sq km), on the east bank of the Potomac River, coextensive with the city of Washington, D.C. (the capital of the United States).  Circuit rejected a pharmaceutical-industry challenge to the use of "preferred drug" lists in Michigan. (Pharm. Research & Mfrs. of Am. v. Thompson, 362 F.3d 817 (D.C. Cir. 2004).) Several of the state's health programs use these lists to steer qualifying residents toward lower-priced drugs. The state programs (which were approved by HHS--the reason the HHS secretary is named in the suit) require that drug makers give rebates; without a rebate, a drug would not be automatically covered under the state plans and would probably be used less.

Rebates also figured in a recent settlement by the nation's largest PBM PBM - play by mail. See play by electronic mail. , Medco Health Solutions Medco Health Solutions, Inc. (NYSE: MHS) is a leading pharmacy benefit manager (PBM) company based in Franklin Lakes, New Jersey. The current chairman is David Snow. The company formed in August 2003 as a spinoff from Merck & Co.. . (U.S.A v. Merck Medco Managed Care, Civil Action 00-737 (E.D. Pa. Apr. 26, 2004).) The company will pay 20 states for damages, restitution, and tees in a case alleging that it encouraged switching patients to drugs with higher manufacturer rebates and then pocketed the rebates without passing along the savings to consumers.

Generic drugs have been cited as a solution to high U.S. prices. In congressional testimony in March, for instance, FDA Commissioner Mark McClellan noted that U.S. generics are generally cheaper than those abroad. He said consumers could reap savings by using more generics and that those savings would eventually "reduce the inequities in new drug prices across countries."

For the Andrewses and others like them, however, generics are not the answer, said their lawyer, Bellas. He noted that there are no generics for most of the medications the Andrewses take, and one generic Gaylee tried caused complications that forced her back to the brand-name drug.

The PRIME Institute's Schondelmeyer thinks raising generics as the answer is a distraction. "People aren't going to Canada to buy generic drugs," he said. "They are going to buy brand-name drugs that aren't generically available. To say that generics are the solution is to tell a person who needs a drug that's under patent today just to wait six years and then buy it generically."

The safety question

Proponents of drug importation claim that Canada's regulations for drugs are similar to, and as good as, those in this country. A Congressional Research Service The Congressional Research Service (CRS) is a branch of the Library of Congress that provides objective, nonpartisan research, analysis, and information to assist Congress in its legislative, oversight, and representative functions. U.S.  memorandum last year concluded that there are essentially no differences between FDA standards and those used in Canada.

The FDA's Brodsky, however, said Canada's system for regulating prescription drugs, "like ours, is not designed to ensure the safety of exports to other countries," a statement affirmed by Health Canada, the Canadian agency that develops and administers that country's health policies.

To prevent safety problems with imported drugs, advocates have called for more regulations. A bill the House of Representatives passed by a large margin in July 2003, tot instance, called for imports of FDA-approved drugs from FDA-approved facilities in other countries, as well as counterfeit-resistant packaging on all imported drugs. But implementing such a system "would be very expensive," Axelrad said. "You'd have to set lip a whole new regulatory regime to do that, and who's going to pay for it?"

Schondelmeyer, however, believes that the benefits of such a regime would outweigh any costs. "I think the cost will be far less than the cost to American consumers overpaying for their prescriptions in the current U.S. marketplace. That isn't economically efficient," he said.

Last year, in an attempt to stem the tide Stem The Tide

An attempt to stop a prevailing trend. Sometimes referred to as "stop the bleeding."

If a stock is continually falling, stemming the tide would be an attempt to halt the free fall and change its direction.
See also: Reversal, Trend
 of illegally imported drugs from Canada, several major U.S. pharmaceutical companies began to limit supplies to that country. Minnesota's attorney general sued to force one of them, GlaxoSmithKline, to turn over documents related to its Canadian sales as part of an investigation into whether the supply limits are retaliatory. Arguments were heard last fall; at press time, a judgment had yet to be reached. (in re GlaxoSmithKline, PLC, No. CIV. MC03-015992 (Minn., Hennepin County Dist. Ct. filed Sept. 30, 2003).)

For Schondelmeyer, the current situation inevitably pits consumers like the Andrewses against drug makers.

"What we have here are consumers trying to express price sensitivity. They're saying, 'I am concerned about the cost of my medicine, and if it means going to Canada, and there's a reasonable chance that it's the same quality and safety, I'm willing to go to Canada.' They're voting with their fleet. That's the way the American market works. But here we have an industry under the banner of free markets saying, 'Don't do that.' It's a bit ironic."
COPYRIGHT 2004 American Association for Justice
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2004, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion




Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Jablow, Valerie
Date:Jun 1, 2004
Previous Article:Family, friends, and ATLA.
Next Article:Won't get fooled again: overcrowding at concerts causes injury and death - despite industry denials. Don't be fooled: crowd crush cases turn on...

Related Articles
Supplements supply dietary danger, as FDA looks on.
Red-yeast product is no drug, court says.
Canadian drugs: panacea or problem?
Canadian internet pharmacies have strict standards, U.S. auditors reports.
Crossing borders: importing prescription drugs, illegally or legally, into the United States isn't expected to have a significant short-term impact...
CA concerned about importing price controls of drugs.
Tribal help with drug costs.
Fighting to end the 'ban litigation' crisis: powerful wrongdoers are trying to deny people an essential constitutional right: access to the courts....

Terms of use | Copyright © 2014 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters