Conseco Sends Letter to Investors About Analyst Report.Business Editors INDIANAPOLIS--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Jan. 7, 2002 The attached letter from Conseco, Inc. (NYSE NYSE See: New York Stock Exchange :CNC (Computerized Numerical Control) See numerical control. CNC - Collaborative Networked Communication ) Executive Vice President of Corporate Affairs, Mark Lubbers, was sent to Conseco investors this afternoon via e-mail, fax, etc. January 7, 2002 Dear Conseco Investor: When Gary Wendt recruited me to the Conseco turnaround 17 months ago, he didn't sugar-coat the task ahead. At the time, this company had $2 billion in bank debt coming due and no apparent way to pay it. And if it could negotiate that "boulder," as he called it, there were half a dozen other boulders waiting to be moved. Beyond the immediate boulders was the tough job of changing Conseco from an acquisition engine into a company producing shareholder value through operations. He knew there would be bumps in the road, and that an open channel to investors and our other outside audiences would be important to our success. Like the others Gary recruited to this adventure, I enjoy a challenge. But I never imagined having to write a letter like this. On Saturday morning, I was quoted in the New York New York, state, United States New York, Middle Atlantic state of the United States. It is bordered by Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and the Atlantic Ocean (E), New Jersey and Pennsylvania (S), Lakes Erie and Ontario and the Canadian province of Times calling SalomonSmithBarney's January 3 "research" report absurd. I called it that because the report contains misleading information and bad analysis. The core of the January 3rd SSB SSB Statistisk Sentralbyrå (Statistics Norway) SSB Super Smash Bros (video game) SSB Space Studies Board SSB Single Side Band SSB Single Stranded DNA-Binding Protein SSB Salomon Smith Barney report takes the loan losses projected by Greenpoint on its exit from the MH business and projects them onto Conseco. The report states: "Tied to its exit from MH loan financing, GPT GPT glutamic-pyruvic transaminase; see alanine transaminase. GPT abbr. glutamic-pyruvic transaminase GPT glutamic-pyruvic transaminase. essentially doubled loan loss assumptions, and we anticipate, based on its own loan pool performance, that CNC may face similar action." The report proceeds to justify this statement NOT by an analysis of loan pool performance, as promised. Rather, in an official-looking table on page 3 of the report, the report takes Conseco public data, ASSUMES the projected cumulative loss rate projected by Greenpoint to calculate its write-off, and PLUGS the difference as something called "projected additional future losses based on GPT". Then, the assumed cumulative loss, borrowed from the GPT announcement, is draped drape v. draped, drap·ing, drapes v.tr. 1. To cover, dress, or hang with or as if with cloth in loose folds: draped the coffin with a flag; a robe that draped her figure. in a new title: "SalomonSmithBarney Revised Projection of Lifetime MH Losses." This so-called analysis is used to assert that it "would imply" future charges or loan losses of between $2.2 and $3.5 billion for Conseco. What is wrong with this "analysis"? It is 100% based on the Greenpoint data and assumptions. Two data points drive the cumulative loan loss projection announced by Greenpoint: (1) default rates and (2) severity rates. For the SSB analysis to hold water, Conseco's experience would have to mirror the Greenpoint experience and projections. Does it? NO Will it? NO. Is there any basis for an analyst's claiming that it does or it will? No, none whatsoever. In fact, there is basis for an opposite conclusion. In one of its several demonstrably de·mon·stra·ble adj. 1. Capable of being demonstrated or proved: demonstrable truths. 2. Obvious or apparent: demonstrable lies. misleading statements the report says: "Greenpoint is considered to have been a much more disciplined and prudent lender than Conseco Finance." Based on what? I should think that people reading SalomonSmithBarney research would prefer data. Not to pick on Greenpoint, a well-run and successful company, but the loan performance data clearly shows that Conseco Finance is the better performing MH lender. In data compiled by Lehman Bros BROS Brothers BROS Benefits and Retirement Operations Section (King County, Washington) BROS Barnes and Richmond Operatic Society (London, UK) . and available on its website, you can see that for securitization Securitization The process of creating a financial instrument by combining other financial assets and then marketing them to investors. Notes: Mortgage backed securities are a perfect example of securitization. May also be spelled as "securitisation. pools since 1999, Conseco has lower average monthly losses and lower cumulative losses. See attached. Worse, SSB's analysis is based on Greenpoint's projected severity rate of 80.2% -- which means that GPT plans on getting less than 20 cents on the dollar for its repossessed MH units. Is that or will that be Conseco's severity rate? NO. Should an objective analyst know why this is an inappropriate basis for making projections about Conseco? Absolutely. We have talked many times in the last year about how critical it is to our operations to avoid wholesale disposition of repo Repo An agreement in which one party sells a security to another party and agrees to repurchase it on a specified date for a specified price. See: Repurchase agreement. repo See repurchase agreement (RP). units. Throughout this bad cycle in the MH business, our severity rates for on-balance-sheet receivables have remained at approximately 48%.(1) In a business that plans on between 1 in 4 and 1 in 5 loans defaulting, the recovery rates on repossessed collateral is a crucial financial metric. And this is where being No. 1 in the industry really matters - as we've said many times before. At September 30, Greenpoint's severity rate was 65%, 35% higher than our on-balance-sheet severity rate and 20% higher than our average of all MH repo disposition. And as Greenpoint noted in its announcement last week, its 80% severity rate is predicated on its exiting the market. Conseco is not exiting this business segment. There is no disgrace in Greenpoint's exiting. Its presentation last week shows pretty conclusively that it generates higher returns for shareholders by getting out. As Gary Wendt has told you before, he made the same decision at GE Capital, where, as we all know, market leadership was prized above all things as a critical element of financial success - just as it is in the MH lending business, where Conseco Finance is No. 1. The positive variance between Greenpoint and Conseco Finance on loan performance is almost exclusively owing to owing to prep. Because of; on account of: I couldn't attend, owing to illness. owing to prep → debido a, por causa de Conseco Finance's strategic advantage in the market. Yet, the SSB report gives it not a pause. It passes completely over the data and extrapolates an unsupportable opposite conclusion, namely, that whatever befell Greenpoint will befall be·fall v. be·fell , be·fall·en , be·fall·ing, be·falls v.intr. To come to pass; happen. v.tr. To happen to. See Synonyms at happen. Conseco. Extrapolating a conclusion about Conseco's ongoing business from the economics of Greenpoint's exit is inappropriate. And for an analyst to ignore completely the several reasons why a Greenpoint exit is beneficial to Conseco Finance is inexplicable in·ex·pli·ca·ble adj. Difficult or impossible to explain or account for. in·ex pli·ca·bil .In short, the "analysis" that is the core of the SSB report is the fabrication fabrication (fab´rikā´sh n the construction or making of a restoration. of a circumstance that does not and will not exist. I am obliged o·blige v. o·bliged, o·blig·ing, o·blig·es v.tr. 1. To constrain by physical, legal, social, or moral means. 2. to note a few other errors in the SSB report. Perhaps the most egregious e·gre·gious adj. Conspicuously bad or offensive. See Synonyms at flagrant. [From Latin is the comment that: "on a liquidation The collection of assets belonging to a debtor to be applied to the discharge of his or her outstanding debts. A type of proceeding pursuant to federal Bankruptcy basis ... policyholders should be reasonably well protected by various state guaranty As a verb, to agree to be responsible for the payment of another's debt or the performance of another's duty, liability, or obligation if that person does not perform as he or she is legally obligated to do; to assume the responsibility of a guarantor; to warrant. funds." The misinformation mis·in·form tr.v. mis·in·formed, mis·in·form·ing, mis·in·forms To provide with incorrect information. mis that this sentence implies is simply irresponsible. The analyst knows well that Conseco's insurance policyholders are backed by $25 billion of assets that are held on the books of our insurance subsidiaries, and that our risk-based-capital (RBC RBC red blood cell. RBC or rbc abbr. red blood cell RBC, n See red blood cell count. RBC red blood cells; red blood (cell) count (see blood count). ) ratios are well in excess of prescribed levels. We have worked diligently to maintain the confidence of insurance regulators around the country, and the claims paying ability of this company is not in doubt. The SSB report makes several references to the performance of our MH securitization pools. We went into great detail on this subject at the November 15th investor briefing in New York (which Mr. Devine chose not to attend). I won't repeat those arguments explaining why the SSB views on recent portfolio performance are wrong. By the way, none of this note should be construed to say that performance in the MH sector is by any means rosy. It is not. We are in a very difficult economy that will continue to put pressure on earnings in the Finance company. Obviously, the accounting for the 4th quarter is not complete, but due in large part to increasing provision for losses, we expect to fall short of our previous guidance of 72 cents per share Cents per share The amount of a mutual fund's dividend or capital gains distributions that a shareholder will receive for each share owned. for 2001. This will come as no surprise given the similar recent announcements by many in the banking and lending business. The weight of the unemployment and business slowdown hit hard in November and December. On two other 4th quarter issues raised in the SSB report, we can report that there will be no I/O (Input/Output) The transfer of data between the CPU and a peripheral device. Every transfer is an output from one device and an input to another. See PC input/output. I/O - Input/Output impairment charge in the 4th quarter - in other words Adv. 1. in other words - otherwise stated; "in other words, we are broke" put differently , performance was within the more conservative model put in place last quarter for the old gain-on-sale pools. Second, the SSB report erroneously reports that guarantees on securitizations are funded by and backed by an LOC An Loc (Vietnamese: An Lộc) is a small town in southern Vietnam, located approximately 90 km north of Saigon (Ho Chi Minh City) with a population of 15,000. The town became famous during the Vietnam War, as the location of a major battle in 1972. . That is not correct. Also incorrect, the report twice compares Conseco Finance's home equity lending to Providian, in one instance as follows: "Our rating and estimate changes reflect ... continuing problems in the home equity segment that have plagued rival Providian Financial." Not only is Providian not "a rival," they don't even do home equity lending! Providian exited this market and sold its home equity portfolio in early 2000. The other comparison that the report makes with our home equity lending business is with "Bank of America's now-discontinued Money Store operations." First, it must be noted that The Money Store was never owned by Bank of America
Bank of America (NYSE: BAC TYO: 8648 ) is the largest commercial bank in the United States in terms of deposits, and the largest company of its kind in the world. -- yet another error. It was owned by First Union. Although in this case it is at least true that The Money Store did home equity lending, the comparability stops there. The Money Store served a much riskier credit profile. Its distribution channel was direct response to television ads. Conseco Finance's home equity business is done through branch offices around the country. If Mr. Devine truly wants to present comparable home equity lending data, we suggest that he take a look at our competitor CitiFinancial - SSB's sister company at CitiGroup. The CitiFinancial website description practically mirrors Conseco Finance's: CitiFinancial provides community-based lending services through a strong branch network system. Decisions are made locally by CitiFinancial team members who live and work in the locations they serve. This on-the-ground, face-to-face customer interaction gives us a unique competitive advantage, allowing us to best determine each client's needs. Our consumer loan services include real estate-secured loans, unsecured and partially secured personal loans, and loans to finance consumer goods consumer goods Any tangible commodity purchased by households to satisfy their wants and needs. Consumer goods may be durable or nondurable. Durable goods (e.g., autos, furniture, and appliances) have a significant life span, often defined as three years or more, and . Our team at Conseco Finance says that CitiFinancial may generate better earnings than we do based on its lower cost of capital, but that we may have the better loan performance in a head-to-head comparison. Since SSB has unique access to the data, they perhaps could make a comparison. Is this report just sloppy work? Or is it an intentional effort to color the public perception of Conseco. I will leave that for you to judge. The purpose of this note is to communicate to all investors and potential investors in our company that Mr. Devine's work contains errors. There are several other reputable analysts who cover our company. If you read their work in combination, you will get a more accurate view of Conseco. We are a company now in the 19th month of a difficult turnaround, made even more difficult by the current economy. Our original turnaround objectives hit rough sailing in the 2nd quarter of 2001 when, as we now know, but didn't know then, the economy entered a mild recession. Compounded by 9-11, this economic backdrop has hindered our plan. Despite the setback, we continue to execute. We said we would make all our debt payments in 2001, and we did - six months early. We said we would reduce the company's debt by more than $3 billion by the end of 2003, and $2.2 billion has already been eliminated. We plan to survive. And we plan to thrive. We will do so with the support of investors, regulators, and customers who have the good sense - the common sense - to pay attention to the facts. Sincerely, R. Mark Lubbers EVP EVP Executive Vice President EVP EGR (Exhaust Gas Recirculation) Valve Position Sensor EVP Electronic Voice Phenomenon EVP Europäische Volkspartei (Germany) EVP Employee Value Proposition , Corporate Affairs Note on forward-looking statements forward-looking statement A projected financial statement based on management expectations. A forward-looking statement involves risks with regard to the accuracy of assumptions underlying the projections. : All statements, trend analyses and other information contained in this release and elsewhere (such as in filings by Conseco with the Securities and Exchange Commission, press releases, presentations by Conseco or its management or oral statements) relative to markets for Conseco's products and trends in Conseco's operations or financial results, as well as other statements including words such as "anticipate," "believe," "plan," "estimate," "expect," "projected," "intend," "should," "could," "goal," "target," "on track," "comfortable with," "optimistic op·ti·mist n. 1. One who usually expects a favorable outcome. 2. A believer in philosophical optimism. op " and other similar expressions, constitute forward-looking statements under the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act The Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995 (PSLRA) implemented several significant substantive changes affecting certain cases brought under the federal securities laws, including changes related to pleading, discovery, liability, class representation and awards fees and of 1995. These forward-looking statements are subject to known and unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors which may cause actual results to be materially different from those contemplated by the forward-looking statements. Such factors include, among other things: (1) general economic conditions and other factors, including prevailing interest rate levels, stock and credit market performance and health care inflation, which may affect (among other things) Conseco's ability to sell its products, its ability to make loans and access capital resources and the costs associated therewith there·with adv. 1. With that, this, or it. 2. In addition to that. 3. Archaic Immediately thereafter. Adv. 1. , the market value of Conseco's investments, the lapse rate lapse rate n. The rate of decrease of atmospheric temperature with increase in altitude. lapse rate The rate of change of any meteorological phenomenon, especially atmospheric temperature with altitude. and profitability of policies, and the level of defaults and prepayments Prepayments Payments made in excess of scheduled mortgage principal repayments. of loans made by Conseco; (2) Conseco's ability to achieve anticipated synergies and levels of operational efficiencies; (3) customer response to new products, distribution channels and marketing initiatives; (4) mortality, morbidity, usage of health care services and other factors which may affect the profitability of Conseco's insurance products; (5) performance of our investments; (6) changes in the Federal income tax laws and regulations which may affect the relative tax advantages of some of Conseco's products; (7) increasing competition in the sale of insurance and annuities and in the finance business; (8) regulatory changes or actions, including those relating to relating to relate prep → concernant relating to relate prep → bezüglich +gen, mit Bezug auf +acc regulation of financial services The examples and perspective in this article or section may not represent a worldwide view of the subject. Please [ improve this article] or discuss the issue on the talk page. affecting (among other things) bank sales and underwriting of insurance products, regulation of the sale, underwriting and pricing of products, and health care regulation affecting health insurance products; (9) the outcome of Conseco's efforts to sell assets and reduce, refinance Refinance 1. When a business or person revises their payment schedule for repaying debt. 2. Replacing an older loan with a new loan offering better terms. Notes: When a business refinances they typically extend the maturity date. or modify indebtedness and the availability and cost of capital in connection with this process; (10) actions by rating agencies and the effects of past or future actions by these agencies on Conseco's business; and (11) the risk factors or uncertainties listed from time to time in Conseco's filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission. (1) SSB estimates our 9/30 severity at 46% on page 3 of the report. There was no need to estimate. At the investor briefing on November 15, we covered this in detail for both I/O and on-balance-sheet assets. And in our 3Q earnings release, we said that the average recovery rate at 9/30 was 45%, which means that the average severity was 55%.
Manufactured Housing Summary Statistics
Monthly
Net Loss Cumulative
Issues Orig Pool Amt Factor (3-mo avg) Losses
--------- ------------- ------- ---- ----
CFC 2001-3 600,000,000 0.97698 0.00% 0.00%
CFC 2001-2 500,000,000 0.95814 0.09% 0.02%
CFC 2001-1 600,000,000 0.93323 0.41% 0.12%
CFC 2000-6 445,500,000 0.92796 1.04% 0.36%
CFC 2000-5 742,500,000 0.89433 1.19% 0.54%
CFC 2000-4 1,243,750,000 0.89394 2.05% 1.23%
CFC 2000-3 980,000,000 0.87103 1.78% 0.96%
CFC 2000-2 738,750,000 0.88403 1.90% 1.18%
CFC 2000-1 886,500,000 0.85244 2.60% 1.99%
CFC 1999-6 985,000,000 0.85173 3.10% 2.37%
GTFC 1999-5 2,000,000,000 0.82221 3.31% 2.97%
GTFC 1999-4 1,000,000,000 0.81806 2.84% 2.72%
GTFC 1999-3 800,000,000 0.80764 2.45% 2.58%
GTFC 1999-2 1,100,000,000 0.78240 2.56% 2.85%
GTFC 1999-1 700,000,000 0.78409 2.31% 3.00%
GP 2000-7 260,000,000 0.90497 1.99% 0.82%
GP 2000-6 190,000,000 0.91211 1.96% 0.82%
GP 2000-5 375,000,000 0.87801 3.21% 2.01%
GP 2000-4 305,000,000 0.88901 3.32% 2.04%
GP 2000-3 I 438,509,311 0.83545 4.56% 2.04%
GP 2000-3 II 280,656,917 0.85572 4.28% 1.17%
GP 2000-2 250,096,268 0.78388 7.40% 5.50%
GP 2000-1 340,000,000 0.83605 5.37% 5.46%
GP 1999-6 140,000,000 0.73066 10.55% 7.12%
GP 1999-5 540,000,000 0.79434 7.52% 7.71%
GP 1999-4 99,985,071 0.67899 7.18% 8.11%
GP 1999-3 810,097,658 0.76289 6.34% 8.50%
GP 1999-2 189,637,432 0.65635 6.02% 8.70%
GP 1999-1 631,659,215 0.76028 4.69% 8.12%
(source: Lehman Brothers Website)
|
|
||||||||||||||||

pli·ca·bil
Printer friendly
Cite/link
Email
Feedback
Reader Opinion